Smith v. Clarke

Filing 2

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 7/18/2017. (tvt)

clE- s OFFIE u. . 3%
C s DI
ATROANQKQ,
VA
rl (D
' Lc

JUL 12 2 1
g?
I TH E U M TED STA TE S D I
N
STR I CO U R T
CT
FO R T H E W ESTERN D I
STR I T O F V I G I I
C
R N A
R O A N O K E D I SI N
W O
Lm

Y W A YN E SM I ,
TH

Pe ii ne ,
tto r
V.

H AROLD W .CLARK E,
R espondent
.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

JULI C
A
BY:
D

CASE NO.7:
17CV00335
M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
M

By Ho Gln E. nr d
: n. e Co a
Unie St esDititJudge
td at src

La r W a Smih,a Vigi a i t pr e ng pr K ,fld t saci n asa peii
ry yne
t
r ni nma e oce di
o
ie hi to
tton
.

f ram i o h be sc r sun e 28U. C.j2 4. Upo rv e o S t ss b sin, h
o
t f a a opu d r
S.
25
n e iw f mih' u miso t e
c ur c n ld st ti mus b s mmaiyd s se wih u p eu iea as c e sv p tto .
o t o cu e ha t t e u rl imis d t o t rj dc s u c si e ei n
i

S t c aln e t v ldt o h sc n i e n u d raJ ne20 1j d me to teLe
mi h le g s he ai i f i o fn me t n e u
h
y
1 u g n fh e
Cot y Cic t Co tunde whi h Sm ih wa c ced of s c
mt r ui ur
r c
t
s onvi t
e ond de e m tr r a r lt d
gr e zde nd ea e
o f ns sa s nt nce t a t a of53 ye r i prs Hi die ta al a s eq ntsa e
fe e nd e e d o ot l
a s n ion. s r c ppe s nd ubs ue tt
ha a c puspr ee ngswe et ucc s f .
be s or
oc di
r ms e s ul

l 201 Smihfld apeii frawrto ha sc pusunde 28U. C.j2254i t s
n 4, t ie
tton o
i f bea or
r
S.
n hi
co t c l ngi t s s m e c
ur , hale ng he e n
onvi t o . The co tr f r d t r s
c i ns
ur e er e he e ponde ' m oton t di m i s
nt s i o s s

t t Unie Stt M ag sr t J
o he t d a es
itae udge who is d a Re ta Re m me ton fnd ng t t
,
s ue
por nd co
ndai i i ha

Smih was note il t rle t r j2254. The c trviwe t Re ta Smih'
t
ntted o eif mde
our e e d he por nd t s

o j cin t rt a d is d a fna o d r a o tn t e Re r a t o n o o t e c u t
b e to s heeo n sue i l r e d p ig h po t s he piin f h o r,
gr ntng t m o i t di m i s a de ng ha a r le . Sm ih v. i . V i g zi D e tofC o r ,
a i he ton o s s , nd nyi
be s e i f
t D r . r ila p'
r.

No.7:4CV00686,201 W L 972742 ( . Va M a .4,201 ) ado i Smih v.Di.Viai a
1
6
W D. . r
6 , ptna t
re r ni

De to Co , . 1
p' f m No 7:4CV0 68 2 6W L 9 0 6 ( . Va 2 6 , p e l imis d 6 7 F.
0 6, 01
5 9 4 W D. . 01 ) a p a d s s e , 5
Ap x 1 7( t Ci. 01 )
p' 7 4h r 2 6 .

.

S t sg e a d d td hs c re t j2 5 pei o o J ne 2 ,2 7,a d te c u t
mi in d n ae i u rn 2 4 t in n u 2 01 n h o r
h
t
r c i d a doc t i on J y 1 201 Smih s ksha sr le ba e o t s alegai ns
e e ve nd keed t ul 7, 7.
t ee
bea e if s d n he e l to :

t e tilc u tg v c nsiuin l d f ciej r i t cins t e d fns r q e td b twa
h ra o r a e o ttto al ee tv u y nsnzto ; h ee e e u se u s
y

d ne tsig f rg n ho r sd eo t fr nm a d o S t sfr am ij r ;t c u t re
e id etn o u s t e i u n he ie r n n mi o e r nu y he o r er d
h'
i rf sngt a mi it e i e c ata s rp o v d oe d n et j r ve d d rn tila
n e u i o d t n o v d n e rn cit f i e vie c he u y iwe u ig ra; nd
ti co ms ' f itr t r s t s i s was de e ve pe f m a e. Sm ih ofe s no r s n
ral t els a lle o aie he e s ues
f di
ror nc
t fr
ea o

t thewasprve e fom r sng t ecli i hi prorj2254peii a t c tfnds
ha
e ntd r aii hes ams n s i
tton, nd he our
no s h r as The ef r ,t c tc ude t tSm ih' pe ii i a s ond or s e sve
uc e on.
r o e he our oncl s ha
t s tton s ec
ucc s i
One.

Pt s a tt 2 U. C.j 2 4 09,a fd rld src c u tma c n i r a s c n o
l u n o 8 S.
r
24
e e a itit o r y o sde e o d r
s e svej2254peii lkeSmih' c rnts s i onl i t peii rscurss cfc
ucc s i
tton,i
t s ure ubmison, y f he ttone e e pe i
c ri a i n fom t Unie Stt Cour ofAppe sf t Fo t Cic tt tt ca msi t
e tfc to r he t d a es
t
al or he urh r ui ha he li n he

peiin me tc ran c ei s tf rh i j2 4 ( )3 . Be a s S t d e no d mo srt t a
t o e e ti dtra e o t n 2 4 b ( ) c u e mi o s t e n tae h t
t
h

he hm o tie s c c rikain,t c u tmus ds s t e p tto wih utp eudc a
s b an d u h e t to he o r
f
t imis h eiin t o rj ie s
s e s ve.
ucc s i

The Cl r i die t d t s nd co e of t s m e o a lm opi on a ac ompa ng
ek s r ce o e
pis
hi
m r nd l
ni nd c
nyi
o de t Sm ih.
r ro
t

ENTER:Thi t
s

da ofJ y, 7.
y ul 201

U nie St t sD i t i tJ
t d a e sr c udge