Brown v. Quintana

Filing 9

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 12/12/2017. (slt)

CLERK' oFFl u. Djm couRT
:
cq s, s
.
AT nANvI E,
Lk vA
FI
UED

I TH E UN I D STATE S D I
N
TE
STR I C O U R T
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STR I O F V I G I A
CT
R NI
R O A N O K E DI I O N
V SI

BE2 12 2 1
C?
u

C. DLEM CL RK
D

B: W
Y

CH R I
STO PH E R LA M O N TE BR O W N

DE I CL R
PU Y E
,

Pe i i r,
t tone

Ci lA c i n N o.7: c 00451
vi t o
17- vM EM O M ND U M O PI O N
M

F.QUI
NTANA,

By:

Re ponde .
s
nt

H on.Jackson L.K i
ser
Se or U ni e St t D i t i tJudge
ni
t d a es s r c

Chrs ophe La ont Br n,a f de a i a e pr e ng pr K ,fl d a pe ii f a
i t r m e ow
e r l nm t oc edi
o
ie
tton or
.

wrtofha sc puspl s ntt 28U. C.j2241.Peii rha be nc ce i t M i e
i
bea or
z ua o
r
S.
ttone d e onvitd n he ddl
D it i tofLoui i f c pi i t pos e s wih t i e t dit i e c i pos e s ng a
s rc
sana or ons r ng o s s t he nt nt o s rbut oca ne, s s i
tr a m i f r he a e ofa d ug t a f c ng c i e a pos e s ng a ûr a a a c
i e r n u t r nc
r r f i ki rm , nd s s i
e nn s onvi t d f on.
c e el

Uni dSae v. o , . :3 1 6 S SCR- ( . La J n 4, 1 ) Pei o rag e
t tts Br wn No 3 1 - 4 - DD- 1 M D. . u e 20 4 . tt ne r u s
e
i
t thi i a c r to i unc tt tonalbec us he i ac u ly i
ha s nc r e a i n s ons iu i
a e
s t a l nnoce oft s c i e , he
nt he e rm s t
e de e w asi uf i i ntt s t n t m ,a he ha i f e tve c
vi nc
ns f c e o us ai he nd
d ne f c i ouns l Pe ii ri pr s nty
e . ttone s e e l

c i d a ac r to lf iiy wihi t sditi t andt sma tri be or m ef pr lmi r
onfne t orec ina ac lt t n hi src ,
hi te s f e
or e i na y

rviw p rua t oRuls1b > d4o teRulsGo r ig j2 5 Ca e . Afe r ve ng
e e us n t e () n fh
e venn 2 4 s s1 tr e iwi
Pe ii rss isons 1co l t tPe ii rf ist de o tae a e ilm e t r le
ttone ' ubm s i , ncude ha ttone a l o m nsr t n ntte nt o e if

v aj2 41 a dld s s t p tto wih u p eu ie
i 2 , n imis he ei n t o t rj dc .
i
A dititco tmayno e eti aj2241peiin atmptngt i ldaeac cin
src ur
t ntran
tto te i o nvai t onvito

u ls amoinpu s a t oj2 5i Sn d q aeo i efciet t s t elg lt o gn
n e s to ru n t 25 s t a e u t r n fe tv o et h e ai f a
i
y
i t ')d tnin. 2 U. C. 2 5 ( S i v. e se 4 U. 3 2 3 ( 9 7 .
nmaes ee to ' 8 S. j 2 5 $; wan Pr sly, 30 S. 7 , 81 1 7 )
'
pr e a i di ntt j2255r le,s h a t saut oflmiainsort r eagans
oc durl mpe me o
eif uc s he tt e i tto
he ul i t

s e svepeii , no rnde j2255r viw tna quae' çnefe tve. l r Vil
ucc s i ttons does t e r
e e t de t'or ' fci ' n e a,
i
i
'
l l 1b p r t ac u toa pl teRulsfrj2 5 Cae t aj2 41h b a p tto , n Rue4p r t a
Rue () emi o r t p y h e o 2 4 ss o 2 a e s ei n a d l emi
s
i
s
c 't dim isahabe peii when ipl nl a ar t tapeiineri no en ildt r le.
our o s s
t
as tton
t ai y ppe s ha
tto s t tte o eif

.

1 5F.d 1 9 ,1 9 n. (t Ci. 9 7 .Th UntdS ae Co t fAp e l f rt eFo rh
1 3 1 2 1 4 5 4h r 1 9 ) e ie tts ur o p as o h u t
Cic i h sf u dta j2 5 i ia e u t a die fciet ts t lg l yo ac n ito
rut a o n h t 2 5 s n d q ae n n fe tv o e the e ai f o v cin
t
onl whe a prs rs ts sat ee pa tsa r
y
n
ione a ife hr - r t nda d:

( )g tt etme o c n ito s tld lw o ti cru to t e S p e Co r
1 Aq h i f o v ci n et a f h s ic i r h u rme u t
e
etbihe t elg lt o tec n cin ( )s bsq e tt t prs n rsdrc
sa ls d h e aiy f h o vito ; 2 u e u n o he io e ' ie t
a p a a d frt j2 5 mo in t e s b tn ie 1w c n e s h t a t
p e l n s 25
to , h u sa tv a ha g d uc h t he
c
onduc ofwhi h t prs rwa c ce i de med nott be c i na ;a
t
c he ionr s onvi td s e
o
rmi l nd

()tep io e c n ts tsy teg tk e n p o iin o j22 5be a s t
3 h rs n r a no aif h ae e pig r vso s f 5 c u e he
ne r ei noto ofc tt i ll w.
w ul s
ne onsiutona a

l r J n s 2 6F.d3 , 3 - 4(t Ci. 0 0 .
n e o e , 2 3 28 3 3 3 4h r 2 0 )
Peiin rma n tc le eh sc n cin vi j2 41 Pei o e fist e p anho a
tto e y o halng i o vito s a 2 . tt n r al o x li w
i
c ng i s t ntve l w m a i l ga t c pie t pos e sw ih t i e t di t t
ha e n ubs a i a
de t e l o ons r o s s t he nt nt o sdbu e

c i pos e safr ar i f t r nceofa d ug ta fc ng c i e orpos e afr r a a
ocane, s s ie m n urhe a
r r f iki rm ,
s s ien m s

c ce fl Thefc t tane j2255moi wo dbetmebardorc i rd
onvitd eon.
a t ha w
ton ul i
re
onsdee
s c svedoesno ma j2255rviw ti deq t'o ti fe tve. Ac or ngy, ttone
uc esi
t ke
e e çna uae' r lnef ci ' c di l Peii r
'
fist mee t l r J ssa r t s w t tj2255i i q t ori fci t ts t
al o t he n e one tnda d o ho ha
s nade uae nefe tve o e the
l lt ofhi c cins hi camsc l bea e s dunde j2241, ndt peii mus be
egaiy s onvito , s li amot ddrs e
r
a he tton t
dim is d wiho prl die.2
s s e t ut e' c
u

ENTER:Th s s hd yo De e e , 2017.
i T a f c mb r

Se rUnied St t D i ti tJ
n'
t
a es sr c udge

21d ciet c ntu peio e ' j2 41p tt na aj2 5 moin.Fis aj2 5 moinmu t efldwi
e l o o sr e tin rs 2 eii s 2 5 to rt
n
t
o
2 5 to s b ie t
h
tec u't ti sdt s ne c .28U. C. 2 5 ( S c n , eio e ara ytldaj2 5 moint
h o l ha mpo e he e tn e
t
S. j 2 5$. e o d P tt n r le d ie
i
2 5 to o

c leg hscn it n.Co sqe t Ptto e mutrc iepefln atoiainfo teapo raecu'
haln e i o vci s neu nl ei nr s eev r-i j uhrzto rm h p rpit ol
o
y, i
i
t
o a pe lt 5l as c esv j2 5 moin.2 U. C. 2 5 ($. Peio e h sn td mo tae ta ac u t f
f p as o e u c sie 2 5 to 8 S. j 2 5 1
tln r a o e nsrtd h t o r o
t
a e l h sa t rz dh m t s b t s c n o s c e sv j2 5mo i n a d ta fn' gac e ry s c e sv
pp a s a uho ie i o u mi a e o d r u c s i e 25 to , n rnse i
n la l u c s ie
j2 5 moint tesne cngc ut o sn t'rhe teitrsso j sieo j iil c n my
2 5 to o h e tn i o r d e o f t r h neet f utc rudca e o o .
u
2