Ferguson v. New River Valley Regional Jail

Filing 12

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 11/28/2017. (tvt)

eko l' op c:t â olw.edke
t: rl ? t
i

A D N IL ,A
T A VCiV

.

FI
LED

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
R O A NO K E DI SI N
VI O
AN TH O N Y S.FER G USO N ,
Pl ntf ,
ai if

Nû 28 2 7
#
2
JUL
BY;
D

D

EY CLERK

Ci lA c i N o.7: c 00460
vi ton
17- v-

M EM OR ANDUM OPI ON
M

NEW RI
VER VALLEY REGI
ONAL
JA I
L,
D ee
f ndant
.

By:

H on.Jac o L.K i e
ks h
sr
Se or U ni e St esD i t i tJudge
ni
t d at
src

A nt ny S. r us a V i g ni i a e pr e ng pr K ,fl d a c m pl i pur ua t
ho
Fe g on, r i a nm t oc edi
o
ie
o a nt s nt o

4 U. C. 1 3n mi t eNe Rie ValyRe i n l al ç al)a t s l d f n a t
2 S. j 98 a ng h w v r le g o a J i (ç i' s he oe e e d n .
J '
Thi matri beor mef s r ni purua t 28U. C.j1 5A.
s te s f e or cee ng s nt o
S. 91

Th J ii n tn n b et s t aj1 8 .Se W etv At is 4 7U. 4 , 8( 9 8
e al s o me a l o uivi 9 3 e s . kn , 8 S. 2 4 1 8 )
(e o n zn aj 1 8 cam mu talg t evo ain o afd r l ih byap ro a tngu d r
rc g iig
9 3 li s le e h ilto f e ea rg t
e s n ci n e
c lro saelw) Prv l Re , 7F. u p. d3 7 3 0( D. . 9 9 (g h Pid n
o o f tt a ; e a v. no 5 S p 2 0 , 1 E. Va 1 9 ) G T) e e mo t
t
Re ina J i i n taç e s n, a dt e eo en ta n b et s i u d r4 U. C. 1 8 .)
go l al s o ç r o ' n h r f r o me a l o ut n e 2 S. j 9 39,
p
'
'
afdL p r a rv' i pat20 F.d8 (t Ci. 0 0 ,e o tdi f l tx f r ta 2 0
f' q at nd e d q r, 3 3 21 4h r 2 0 ) rp re n ul e t o ma t 0 0
U. Ap LEXI 4 5 a * , 0 0W L 20 91 a * (& c u t loprpel d tnnie t t
S. p.
S 6 ,t 3 2 0
5 ,t 1 s
The o r as o ry ee n d ha
t Pi dmontRe onalJ i i nota d r o a i t r f r no n e bl t s tunde
he e
gi
als
pe s n' nd s he e o e t m na e o ui
r

j 1 8 .'.Ac o dn l Ids s t ec mplitwi o t rj d c f rfii t saeacam
9 3( '
q) c r igy, imis h o an t u p eu ie o al o tt li
h
ng
upon whi h r le m a be g a ed.Tot e e Pli ifma bea et nameaç r o '
c e if y
r nt
he xtnt antf y
bl o
t s n'
pe

s b e t os tvaj1 8 , an ifi g a tdtnd yst fl amoint a n tec mpan
u j c t ui i 9 3 Plitf s r ne e a o ie to o me d h o lit
t tsat acli upon whi h r le may begr nt d a i tape s aci unde c orofsa e
ha t es a m
c ei f
a e ga ns
r on tng
r ol
tt

lw.Se e. ,Gor v. e 574F. 11 11 2( h Ci.1 .
a
e. c. don Le ke,
2d 47, 5 4t r 978)

K

Pl i ifmay fnd i pr f r bl t t kel rt n tn da t c ul l ga r s m c s
antf
i t e e a e o a onge ha e ys o ons t e l e o e ,
t nk a uthi a lga i ,a fl ane c
hi bo s le tons nd ie
w ompl i i ane a s pa a ea ton.I Pli if
ant n
w nd e r t c i
f antf

c o s sno t fl t qmoinwihntn d y , anifwo l no b p eu ie b c u ehei
h o e t o ie h to t i e a s Plitf u d t e rj dc d e a s s
alwe t ûl ac mp an i ane a s paaea to a t etmeo hi c oc s b e t ot
lo d o e o lit n w nd e rt cin t h i f s h ie u j c t he
a plc b çl tto speid.S e ea, n v Ok te 4 8U.. 3 , 4 - 0( 9 9 ; . d
p ia l i ai n ro e . ..Owe s . t , 8 S 2 5 2 9 5 1 8 ) Va Co e
mi
r
j8012 ( .
. -43A)
l Pli ifi t a r hesa c
f antf nse d us
nd hoos t s ek ala e e i t sc e, s ul kno
es o e r m ndm nt n hi as he ho d w

t a tec u t yds s t n n e c mp an wi p eu iea fio o o f rfiigt
h t h o r ma imis he me d d o lit t rj dc s rv lus r o al o
h
n
sa eacli upon whih r le m a begr nt a a s saçsrke. Pl i ifs ul t r tnd
tt
am
c ei f y
a ed nd s es sti ' antf ho d mde sa
'
t thei alowe onl t e S ti s'fo bot co pl nt i dititc t a a
ha
s l d y hr e G rke ' r m
s
h m ai s n src ours nd ppea si
l n

c t o a asbeor hei lmiednol ral dt pr ee i f
ours f ppe l f e s i t
onge lowe o oc d q onnapa rswihou
unei t t
pr payi t $400 flng f e a e ce t n c tons ng es c ea e t sç lr e srkes'nze
e ng he
ii e bs nt rai ondii .Co r s r t d hi ç ze - ti ' l
t
a a ec
s n onomi i e i f prs r t ç t p a t nk'be or flng ac
c nc ntve or ione s o G o nd hi ' f e ii
s
ompli .Se se. ,
ant e g.
Roge sv.Bl , o.107c 77,
r
uhm N
: v11 2007 U. Dit LEXI 91
S. s.
S 646,2007 W L 4401 a *1
87, t

( . M ih. c 1 , 0 7 .
W D. c De . 3 2 0 )
ENTER :
Thi

= da ofN o mbe ,201
y
ve r
7.
-

W

Se i rUnie Stt sDititJ
o
t d a e src udge