Ballance v. Zanin et al

Filing 3

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/23/2017. (tvt)

CLERKS OFFI U. DI
CE S. ST.
65 ROANOKE,
VA
:) ;D
1.
.jJ

I TH E U NI
N
TED STATE S D I
STR I CO U R T
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN D I
STR I O F W R G I I
CT
N A
R O AN O K E DI I O N
V SI
K EV I BA LLA N CE ,
N

C21 2i 2 1
27
J
ULI .
BY:

CA SE N O .7:
17CV 00468

Pl ntf
ai if,
V.

M EM O M NDUM OPI ON
NI

FRANK J ZANI c & ,
.
N,
,

By: Gln E.Conr
e
ad
U ni e St e Di t i tJudge
t d at s s r c

De e
f ndants.
t)
Pl ntf,a Vigi a i ae pr e ng pr K ,fl d a ci ldght c
ai if
r ni nm t oc edi
o
ie
vi
s ompli ,ptr ua t
a nt ls nt o
.

4 U. C.j1 8 ,algn vilto o hi c nsi in lzg t. Be a s c u trc r ss o
2 S.
9 3 le ig oains f s o tmto a i h s c u e o r e o d h w
t tpanifh sh d a la tt ep irc s sds se f ro o t ea o e sae r a o s he
ha litf a a t e s ve ro a e imis d o ne f h b v -ttd e s n ,
mus prpa t f 1 $400. i flng cossunls he s
t e y he u 1
00 n ii
t e s howsi i ntda e ofs ro physc l
mm ne ng r e i us
ia

h r S e28U. C.j 1 5 g . Plitf h sas sae hsitn in t p y t e efln c ss
a m. e
S.
91 ( ) an if a lo ttd i ne to o a h s iig o t.
Ac or ngl by or re e ed Oc o r5,201 t cot' dieced hi t pa t $400. slng
c di y,
de nt r
t be
7, he ut r t m o y he
00 i
c t wihi f ree da
oss t n ou t n ys. The o dernotfed pli ift tf iur t c
r
ii
antf ha a l e o ompl woul r ul i
y
d es t n

d s sa o t a to wih u p eudc . Thetmealte f rp y n o t efe h sp se ,
imisl f he cin t o t rj ie
i l td o a me t f h e s a a s d
o
a pl i ifhasnotf wa de t spa e t t c torm o d f a to ltmet do s
nd antf
or r d hi ym nt o he our
ve or ddii na i o
o.

Th r f r, o t ra o sae ,hec u t ld s s t a to wih u p eu ie S e
e eo e f r he e s ns ttd t o r wil imis he cin t o t rj dc . e
I . t9 (tt p oK ltg n sa es be tt tmerq ie n sa drs c f rc u t r esa d
d a 6 sai r iia t r u j c o i e urme t n epe t o o r o d r n
ng
d s sa wi o tp eu iei a a prpraes n to frno c mpin e; r lvv J h s
imis l t u rj d c s n p o it a cin o n-o la c l Domel . o n h
M mwil S lsCo p, 7 F. 3 9 3 - ( dCi. 98 )(e o niigad src c u t ys
le ae r .6 7 2d 3 , 4041 3 r 1 2 rc g zn itit o r ma ua
s n ed s s a a to pls a t oFe . Ci P. ( ).An a p o raeo d rwi e tr h s
po t imis n cin t u n t d R. v. 41b )
r
p r p it r e l ne t i
l
da
y.
Pl ntf i ad s d t t i he i e t pr ee wih t s aci n,he m us peii t
ai if s vie ha f
nt nds o oc d t hi to
t tton he
c twihi 30 oft e r oft s o de f a r i t tm e of t s ac i Any moton f
our t n
he nty
hi r r or ensae nt hi ton.
i or

r nsae e s ul pr des c fc e a to f hi f ilr t r s nd i atmel f s on t
ei t tm nt ho d ovi pe ii xplnai n or s alze o e po n i y a hi o

t c tsor rofOc o r5,201
he our' de
t be
7.
TheClr i die t d t s nd ac oft sor rt t pl i if
ek s rce o e
opy hi de o he antf.
EN TER :

Thi &S 4 d yo oco r 2017.
a f tbe
s
,

Z

Unied St sDititJ
t
at
src udge