Hurst v. Berryhill

Filing 17

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Glen E. Conrad on 11/20/2018. (aab)

CLERK' OFFI U.S.DI COURT
S
CE
SX
ATROANOKE,VA

I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COU RT
CT

FI
LED

FOR THEWES
TERN DITRI OFVI NI
S CT
RGI A

N 2g 2 j
gy
gj

ROAN OU DI I ON
V SI
W I AM DA VI H URST,
LLI
D

J LI
A
BY:

Ci lA c i N o. 7:
vi ton
17CV 00473

(
)

CL
ERK

Pl ntf ,
ai if
M EM O R AND UM O PG ION

NAN CY A .
BERRYH I A c i
LL, tng
Com m is one ofSoc a Se urt
si r
i l c iy,

cuE

By: o G l n E. r d
H n. e Con a
Se o Unie S a e Dit i tJ ge
ni r t d t t s s rc ud

Def
endant
.

Pl n ifh fl d t s a ton c le ng t e fn de i i n oft Co m is on rofSo a
ai tf as ie hi c i ha l ngi h i al c s o
he m s i e
ci l

Se u iyde n pli irscli f ape i ofdia lt a dia lt i ur nc be it u r
c rt nyig antf am or rod
s biiy nd s biiy ns a e ne s nde

t SocalS u iyAc,a a n d,42U. C.jj41 i a d423. J rs cin oft sc ur i
he i ec rt t s me de
S.
6() n
uidito
hi o ts
e tbls d purua t 42 U. C.j 40 g . Asrfe td b t me a a agume t
sa ihe
s nt o
S.
5()
elce y he mornda nd r n
s bm it d by t pa te ,t i s s now be o e t e co ta e whe he t Com m i s o r s f n
u te
he r i s he s ue
f r h ur r
t r he
s i ne ' i al
de i i i s
c s on s uppore b s t nta e d nc o whe he t r i t
t d y ubsa i l vi e e, r
t r he e s G
good c us 't ne s ia e
a e' o ce st t

rma n t c s t t Commisone f frh rc ieain. Se 42U. C.j405g)
e ndig he a e o he
si r or u te onsd rto
e
S.
(.
The pl ntf ,W ila D a d H u s ,w asbor o Fe ua y 26, 1
ai if li m vi r t
n n br r
974. He c pl t d hi
om e e s

hi s ho e cai a e nt l grd td fom c lg ( .39 . M r Hurtha be n
gh c ol du ton nd ve ualy a uae r ole e. Tr )
. s s e
e pl d a a hos t cl a r s c iy gua d, nd c t a He wor d f a c nt a tc e ni
m oye s
pial e ne , e urt
r a usodi n.
ke or o r c l a ng

s r c fr patof201 a d 201 wih t assa c ofaj c ac ( .1 200,278 .
evie o r
5 n
6 t he sitn e
ob o h. Tr 7,
)
H owe r t A d i sr tve La J dge de e m i d t a s h e pl m e di no r ac t l vel
ve , he m ni ta i
w u
t r ne h t uc m oy nt d t e h he e

o s tni gai ula tviy. ( .1 )
f ubsa tal nf ci t Tr 7 .
On Se e be 26,201 M r Hur t fl d a ap i a i f a pe i o di a lt a
pt m r
3, . s ie n plc ton or
rod f s biiy nd
dia lt i ur nc be ft . I flng hi c r e c a m , M r H ur t a l ge t t he be a e
s biiy ns a e ne is n i
s u r nt l i
. s le d ha
cm
diabl f al f ' sofsubs antalgai ulem pl enton Sept ber19,2013, t As r s
s ed or l ol
m
t i
nf
oym
em
due o pe ger'

s r ,atntond fcihypea tviydior r(
yndome te i ei t rci t s de ADHD)a i omni. ( . . Mr Hu s
, nd ns a Tr205) . rt
now m ai a ns t the ha r m a ne dia ed t t pr s n tm e The r c d r ve l t t M r
nt i ha
s e i d s bl o he e e t i .
e or e a s ha
.
H ur tm e t i ur d s a us r quie e t o t e A c a a lr e n tm es c r d b t tna
s t he ns e t t e r m n s f h
t t l elva t i
ove e y he i l

d ciinoft Co si e . Se ge e al 42U. C.j 41 i a d423()
e so he mmison r e n r ly
S. j 6() n
a.
M r H u s ' a i a i was de e u n i ta c nsde a i a r c i r ton. He
. r t s pplc ton
ni d po nii l o i r ton nd e ons de a i
t e r q s e a r c ved a de novo he rng a r vi w be o e a Adm i sr tve La J ge.
h n e ue t d nd e ei
a i nd e e
fr n
ni ta i
w ud
I an opi on dat N ovem ber2,2016,t Law J
n
ni
ed
he
udgeal det m i aferappl ng t tve- ep
so er ned, t
yi he i st
1

s que ile uai pr es t tMr Hu s i no dia e Se 20C. R.j40 1 20. The
e nta val ton oc s,ha . rt s t s bld. e
F.
4.5
La J e f d t tM r H urt s f r fom s ver s ve e i r e s i l ng A s r r s
w udg oun ha . s uf e s r e al e r mpaim nt , nc udi
pe ge '
s r e AD HD,he rng l s de es i n,a a e y,b t tt s i paim e t do no ,e t r
ynd om ,
a i os , pr s o nd nxi t ut ha he e m r n s
t ihe
i vi aly ori c bi ton,mee orm e c l e alt r quie e t o a lse i im e t
ndi du l
n om na i
t
di al qu he e r m n s f it d mpa r n .
y

( .1 8 . TheLa J dget nas se M rHurtsrsdu f ncinal a iya f l :
Tr 7-1 )
w u he ses d . s' e i al u to c pact s olows
Afe c r f co i e a i n o t e ie r c d,t unde s g d
tr a e ul ns d r to f he ntr e or he
r i ne
fnds t a t c a m a ha t r i l f tona ca ciy t
i
h t he l i nt s he esdua unc i l pa t o
pe f r a f lr nge of wor a a l e to l ve s bu w ih t
ro m
ul a
k t 1 xeri nal e l t t he
f l w i none ri l lm ia i ns: t c a m a t i a e t
olo ng
xe tona i t to
he l i n s bl o
und r ànd, e e b ra c r y ou s mpl i t u to i r pe ii
es
r m m e nd a r t i e ns r c i ns n e ttve
uns le wor He s d ha no i e ac i n w ih t ge r l
kil d
k.
houl ve
nt r to
t he ne a
publc and no m or t occasi i er i wih co- or and
i
e han
onal nt acton t w kers
s r ior . H e w o d be a e t r s
upe v s s
ul
bl o e pond a o i t l t
ppr pra e y o
s r i i n, c w o ke s a us l wor st tons H e s ul
upe v s o o- r r , nd ua
k iua i .
ho d
avoi f tpaced envionm ent lke t e on an ass bl lne. He
d as r
s i hos
em y i

s o l h v sai j bd te ta rmanfil c nsa ta da od
h ud a e ttc o uis h t e i ary o tn n v i
e
xpos et e s i y l ba kg oun noi e s h a he v ta fc
ur o xce svel oud c r d s uc s a y r f

a j c amme sc tu ton e ui nti t i dit wor
nd a kh
r/onsr ci q pme n he mme ae k
e r me .
nvion nt

1The pr ce sr quiest La J
o s e r he w udge t c i r i sq e c ,wh te a cama t ()i e g g d i
o onsde, n e u n e eh r li n: 1 s n a e n
sb tnil anu at t () a asv r i ar n;3 h sa i ar n ta met o e u l terq i me t
u sata g ifl ci y;2 h s e ee mp imet () a n mp imeth t es r q as h e ur ns
vi
e
o al tdi ar n;4 cnrtr t hs atee a t r; n ()in twh te h c np rom oh r r i te
f i e mp ime t() a eun o ip srlv n wok a d 5 f o, eh r e a efr te wok n h
s
n t n leo o 2 C.. j4 4.5 0 I ad cso cn b rah d a ay se i tesq e ta e lain
ai a cn my. 0 FR. 0 12 . f e iin a e ec e t n tp n h eu nil vau to
o
pr e s f rhe e l ton i un ce s r I
oc s , u t r va ua i s ne s a y. d.

2

( .20 . Gi n s h arsd f ci lc pa t a d atrc i rng t tsi
Tr ) ve uc e iual un tona a ciy, n fe onsdei he etmony ofa
vocatonalexpe ,t Law J
i
rt he
udge det m i t M r.H urs i unabl t perot any of hi past
er ned hat
ts
eo f m
s

r e ntwor ( .24) Ho ve,t La J
elva
k. Tr . we r he w udge f nd t tMr Hurtrt nss fce t
ou ha . s eai uf in
f tona c pa iy t pe f r ot r w or r e e s i i sgni a n be i t na i l
unc i l a c t o r o m he
k ol s xitng n i t nt um r n he tona
k

e onomy. ( . ) Ac or ngl t La J co ude t tMr Hurti no dia e a
c
Tr 25. c di y, he w udge ncl d ha . s s t sbld, nd
t t he i no e tte t a pe i d of dia lt or dia lt i u a e be ft . Se 20 C. R.
ha
s t n il d o
ro
s biiy
s biiy ns r nc ne is
e
F.

j40 1 20() TheLa J ge' o ni wa a optda t Gna de sono t Commisone
4.5 g .
w ud s pi on s d e s he l cii f he
si r
by t Soc al Se urt A d i sr to s Appea s Counc l H a ng e ha t d al a iabl
he
i
c iy m nita i n'
l
i.
vi x us e l va l e
adm i s r i r edi M r Hur thasnow appeal t t scour.
nitatve em es, . s
ed o hi
t

W hie pl i tf m a be dia ed f c rai f m s o e pl e t t c uc a f c u
l a n if y
s bl or e t n or
f m oym n , he r i l a t al
de e m i ton i whe he pl i if i dia e f a lf
t r na i s
t r a ntf s s bl d or 1 onns o s t nta ga n ule pl e t
f ubs a i l i f m oym n .

Se 42U. C. 4 d ( . Theeaefuree nt ofprofwhihmus bec psdee i ma ng
e
S. j 23()2)
r r o lme s o
c
t o i rd n ki
s h a a l i. Thes elme sae s
uc n nayss
e e nt r ummaie asf l :( )obe tve me c f csa
rz d olows 1 j ci
dial at nd
ci c fndi ;()t o ninsa c ncl i ofte tngphyscins ()s beci e d nc
lniali ngs 2 he pi o nd o usons rai
i a ; 3 u j tve vie e
o ph ia ma fsai o i ime t,a de cie t o acama ' tsi ny;a (
f ysc l niettons f mpar ns s s rb d hrugh li nts etmo nd 4)
t cama ' e uc to voc tona hit r r sdua s ls a a . Viek v.Fic 438 F.
he li nts d a in, ai l so y, e i l kil, nd ge
t
n h,
2d

1 57,11 60( hCi.19 ) Und r
1
59- 4t r 71; e woodv. biof, F. 8 8 ( hCi.1 2)
Ri c f298 2d 50, 51 4t r 96 .
On a pe ,M r H urtr ie s ve a a gum e s i l ng t tt La J ge i pr pe l
p al . s a s s e r l r
nt , nc udi ha he w ud m o ry
a s s e t o ni e d nce a d e r d i de e m i ng hi r sdua f tona c pa t Afe
s e s d he pi on vi e
n r e n t r ni
s e i l unc i l a ciy. tr

r viwi t r c r a co i rng t pa te 'a gu nt,t c tfnd fg
e e ng he e o d nd nsde i he ris r me s he our
s <ood c us ' t
a e' o
r m a t c s t t Com m i sone f rf t rde l pm e a c i e a i n. Se 42 U . C.
e nd he a e o he
s i r o urhe ve o nt nd ons d r to
e
S.

j405g .
()
Th m e c l r c r e t bls s t t M r H urt s f r f om a c bi ton of s ve e
e di a e o d s a ihe ha
.
s ufe s r
om na i
e r
none r i nali r e s I Se e be of 201 D r Ge g W a r a phys c a w ih N e
xe to
mpaim nt . n pt m r
2, . or e gne ,
i in t w

Hoi nsHe t ae da nosd pli ifwih ADHD a i o a ( .311. Hepr srbe
rzo
alhc r, ig e antf t
nd nsmni. Tr )
eci d
ta odo a a i pr s an ,w hi h pl n ifc i d t t k a t tm e oft e ad i sr tv
r z ne, n ntde e s t
c ai tf ontnue o a e t he i
h m nita i e

he rng. ( . 311. OnNo mbe 1 201 M rHurt ee tdt DrAlnKaz aci ca
ai Tr46, )
ve r 2, 3, . spr sne o . a t, lni l
ps hol s,f a ne ops hol c le l to ( .3 ) Dr Kaz who ha prviusy
yc ogit or ur yc ogia vauain. Tr 21. . t,
d eo l
e l t d pl i ifi 2001 no e t tpl ntf ha : l s a ng hit y ofs i la xit t t
va ua e antf n
, t d ha ai if s : ong t ndi
a
sor
oc a n e y ha
ha be n co plca e by i t r it nt e s es o poo l m od a e a r a r duc d s i
s e m i td
n e m te pi od f ry
ul t d nge nd e e oc al

j d me t' ( .3 1 . Dr Kaz as n td t a plitf e hbt K lsi ma ie tto s'o
u g n ' Tr 2 ) . t lo oe h t anif x ii ç a sc nf sain ' f
sc
a ts s c r m di o de orA s r e ' s o e, uc asçs i la k a dne s de r a e i i t
u i m pe t u s r r
pe g r s yndr m s h toc a w w r s , c e s d ns gh
a a non- r l l ar ng diab lt ' and t t o he Ec m plc tng f t r ' i l de E ie ong
nd
ve ba e ni
s iiy,
'
ha t r l o i a i ac o s' nc u l f l
l
d pr s i r duc d sr s t e a e a f a s ab t hi a lt t mai u i i pe ntlvi '
e e son, e e te s ol r nc nd e r ou s biiy o
n n nde nde i ng.
'

( . ) Baedonci c i e ve ,hi rviw ofe si rc ds a t rs t ofasre
Tr 321. s
lnialntr iws s e e
xitng e or , nd he euls
eis
ofque ton ie a t t , . t di gnos d pl ntf w ih a im s c r di o de , s r er s
s i na r s nd ess Dr Ka z a
e ai if t uts pe t um s r r A pe g '

s r ,a viua i ime t a rgh font pait deiis ( .327 . Mor rc nt
yndome
s l mpar n, nd i t r o- real fct. Tr )
e ee
t e t e tr c dsf om N e Horz H e t ca e a s r te tdi g esofA s r r s s r e
r a m n e or r
w
i ons alh r l o el c a nos
pe ge ' ynd om

an de r sin,a wela modeaehe rngl si b he r. ( .38 400 404, 40 .
d p eso s l s
rt ai os n ot as Tr 9, , 405, 7)
The r c d c nt nss ve a o ni ns r ga d ng t i pa to M r H u s ' i im e t o
e or o ai e r l pi o e r i he m c f . r ts mpa r n s n
hi a lt t w o k. Att c l i oft i ta ne o yc ogi a e l ton, r Ka znot d
s biiy o r
he onc uson he nii l ur ps hol c l va ua i D . t e
t a M r Hur tE
h t . s G d be w e ls r e by a a i a i n f r So a Se urt be ft ,' t a he
woul
l evd
n pplc to o ci l c iy ne i s' but h t

rmane ho u ta pli ifsEa quiiin o be ft oft s tpe ( d pr t be a
e i d pefl h t antf çc sto f neis hi y woul) ove o
tmporr arnge nt'snc e o ntwoul beEhehe lhis ofalposi li -' ( .
e ay ra me ,' i e mplyme
d t
t at e t l sbiies' Tr
t
3 . Dr Kazrco nde ta plitf Cniit c ntc wiht De rme ofAgi a
26) . t e mme d h t anif s tae o a t t he pat nt
i
ng nd

Re bii i Se vc sfr...a ssa ewihj e plrto i e ve ngs lsandapo sbl
ha lttve r ie o
sitnc t ob x oain,ntr iwi kil
si e
posii ofsuppored empl ent' ( . . 0nDe e r5, 3, antf rtr dt Dr
ton
t
oym .' Tr 326)
c mbe 201 pli if eune o .

c a ntf
e s r tai G
o s
Kaz f r a f lw- a nt nt duri whi h pl i if expr s ed f us r ton çdue t hi
t o
olo up ppoi me , ng
4

une o ntsaus' ( .3 ) Att tpoi ,Dr Kazo ne t tpli ifç ul bebe t
mplyme tt . Tr 28 . ha nt . t pi d ha antf ç d
'
wo
s
s r e by a l as s tt r dia lt s ppor f o Soc al Se urt gi n t hos of s i l
evd
t e t hor e m s biiy u
t rm
i
c iy ve he t
oc a ,

e to la ne o gnii dekishec tnu t diply. ( .3 ) Ho ve,heuge
moina nd urco tve f t
oni es o s a ' Tr 28. we r r d
'
M r Hur t G o c tnue t pur ue a poston of hi y s r t r r pe ii a s r s d
. s G on i
t
o s
ii
ghl t uc u ed, e ttve nd upe vie
e pl e twhe e he ca wor a a r d e pac a w ihou s ci la i e pe s lde a
m oym n
r
n k t e uc d e nd t t o a nd nt r r ona m nds

b i plc du hi ' ( . 28 .
eng a e pon m. Tr 3 )
'
The sat agency ps
te
ychol s s D r Jos Lei and D r Li D oughert com pl ed
ogit , . eph zer
. nda
y,
et

t f m sr ar ng pl i tf m e t lhe 1h: Ps hi ti Revi w Te hni e f m a d a M e a
wo or eg di a n ips n a a t a yc a rc
e
c qu or n
nt l
Re i ual
s d Func i lCa ciy As e s e f m . On t l te f
tona pa t s s m nt or
he a t r onu, t ps hol s snot d t t
bo h yc ogit e ha
M r Hu s ha m a ke orm o r t lm ia i i t c t go i s ofGs t i d c e r to a
. rt s r d
de a e i t tons n he a e r e
Eus a ne onc nta i n nd
pe s se e, çs i l i e a ton, a E da a i ' bu t the 4 ho d be a e t pe f r t e
r i t nc ' doc a nt r c i ' nd E pt ton, t ha
'
'
a
'
s ul
s
bl o r o m h

ba i me tlde ndsofsmpl a lw srs c mpeii wor on a s ti d bai. ( .
sc na ma
i e nd o te s o ttve k
usane ss' Tr
'
75
-77,88 . Lie Dr Kaz ho vest sae ag nc ps hol ssalo i ctd t t
-90) k . t, we r he tt e y yc ogit s ndiae ha
pl i if woul r quie a he g e d l ve of s r son a a r s t o hi i paim e s W he
a ntf
d e r
i ht ne e l upe vii s e ul f s m r nt .
n
asked t expl n,i naratve f m ,t r uli lm iatons i t ar ofs t ned concent aton
o
ai n r i or he es tng i t i n he ea usai
r i

a pe s s e c t y s a e a f l s
nd r it n e, he t t d s olow :

Th cama tc n c n e taea dp rita smpl j b isr cin
e li n a o c nrt n ess t i e o n tu t s
o
a d i s m a sm pl d cii ,s t n o di r r tne w ih
nd ute , ke i e e sons usai r na y ou i s t
occasi
onal e r s vior hel m ai ai us
xt a uoer s v
o,
nt n ual a endance
tt
r quie e s wor a oun o he s wih be ng und y dit a t d
e r m nt , k r d t r t out i
ul s r c e
by t m a m e tsm pl pr uc i r uie e t .
he nd e i e od ton eq r m n s

( . 8 (mpha i a d)
Tr76, 9) e ss dde .
The r d al cont nsa r tfom Denni St
ecor so
ai
epor r
s ephens a vocatonaleval orwih t
on,
i
uat
t he

sae' Di sono Re biiai Se vc . ( .
tt s vii f ha lttve r ies Tr329-33 . Bae onM rHurtsGo rlwor
0) sd
. s' sveal k

pe f ma c i c nuncin wih hi lmie s cils lsan i ie j
ror n e, n o j to t s i td o a kil d mpard udgme t'Stph ns n
n ' e e o
e prse t beift tM rHurtwo dha difc t manani f ltmee oyme t ( .
x e sd he le ha . s ul ve fiuly iti ng ul-i mpl n. Tr

33 . Hefrhe o ne ta pli ifwoul ne dEsppore e oyme sr ies'i or rt
0)
u t r pi d h t antf
d e ûu td mpl nt e vc ' n de o

o anpattmewok. ( .3 .
bti r-i
r Tr 30)
The La J
w udge uli a e y c l ed t tM r H u s ' non- xe ton i pa r e sdo no
tm t l onc ud ha . r ts
e ri al m im nt
t
r de hi dia e f a lf r s o s bs a talg n u e pl
en r m s bl d or l o m f u t n i ai f l m oyme o ot r ie c rbut t a
nt r he w s onti e o n
ove a l dia lt l a s s i pl i tf ' r s d l f nc i nal c pa iy, t La J
r l s biiy. n s e sng a n if s e i ua u to
a c t he w udge ga
ve

Ei fc ntweg 't t opi o o t saea nc ps holgit. ( .22- ) TheLa
G gniia
s
iht' o he nins f he tt ge y yc o ss Tr 23 .
w
J ge a s ga R om e wei t't Dr K a z' opi o notng t ti E ppe r c i t ntwih t
ud lo ve s
gh ' o . t s ni n, i ha t E a s ons se
a
t he

cli n 'rsdu f tona c pa t ' ( . ) Li wie,heLa J ga ço wegh'
ama ts e i alunci l a ciy. Tr 23 . ke s t w udge ve l me i t'
'
s
t M r Se ns n' o nin. ( .24) AlhoughMr Stphe o di no bele t tplitf
o . tphr o s pi o Tr . t
. e nsn d t ive ha anif
c d s cc s f l m a n a n f ltm eempl e t t La J
oul u e s uly i t i ul-i
oym n , he w udgeno e t ts G le st t he
t d ha he < i ve ha t
be
r s rc i i t c ai a t s r sdua f nc i lc pa t w o d e bl hi t s t i f ltm e
e t itons n he l m n ' e i l u tona a ciy ul na e m o usa n ul i

wor ' ( . .
k- Tr24)
'
Upo r vi w oft e r c r t c t suna et c l t tt La J e' as es m en
ne e
h e o d, he our i
bl o onc ude ha he w udg s s s t

ofMr Hurtsrsd lf tona c pa iy ($ ' i sppore by s tnta e de e. I
. s' e iua unci l a ct RFC' s u td
)
ubsa il vi nc n
a s sng a c a m a ' RFC,t La J
s es i
l i nts
he w udge c i r G lt r l va e de e ' m e c l or
onsde s ' he e e nt vi nc ,' di a
al
o he wi e t d t r i e a c ai a ' ça lt t m e t t p i a ,m e a , s ns r a o he
t r s , o eem n
l m nt s E biiy o e he hys c l nt l e o y, nd t r

rquie nt ofwok. 20 C. R.j 40 1 45. The La J dge C t i l a nartve
e rme s
r'
'
F.
4.5
w u t
mus ncude
rai
dic son de c i ng ho t e de e s rse h c ncuson,cii s cfc me c lf cs
s us i
s rbi
w he vi nc uppo t ac o l i
tng pe ii dia a t

(. ,lboaoyGndi )a no dc le de e(. ,d iya tviis o evai l' M a co
eg. a rtr
ngs nd nme ia vi nc eg- al ci te, bs r tons' si
v.Col n,780F. 632,636(t Ci.201 )( otng SSR 96 8 1 SS LEXI 5,61Fe
vi
3d
4h r 5 qu i
-p, 996 R
S
d.
Re 3 47 3 475 (uy 2,1 :. Addii ly,i te RFC as àme G ontit wih a
g. 4, 4, 4, J 1
996
tonal f h
ses nt ç lcs t n
c
o ni fo ame ca s c ,t ( w J ge mus e ai whyteo ni wasno a pt '
pi on rm
di l oure he La ud l t xpl n
h pi on
t do ed.
'
SSR 96- p,1 SSR LEXI 5,61 Fed. g.a 3 478. U li a el t La J
8 996
S
Re t 4,
tm t y, he w udge 6 us b h
< t 0t
m

i niye de et ts
de tf vi nc ha uppors( r c l i a <uida a c aea l c brdgefo
t hel oncuson nd b l n c urt nd ogial i r m

(hale d nc t ( r c cl i '' Woodsv.Ber hil 888F. 68 694 (t Ci.2018
t t vie e o he) on uson-'
ry l,
3d 6,
4h r
)
(mph i i o i nal(uotngM o oev. vi 8 F. 1 ,18 ( hCi. 6:. I t La
e ass n rgi ) q i
nr Col n, 26 3d 76 9 4t r201
fhe w
J
udge f is t a qua e y e ai h s r a he c l i ns r ga d ng t cl i a ' RFC,
a l o de t l xpl n ow he e c d onc us o e r i he a m nts

rma i a o it. Se Masi 780F. a 6 seas Mo oe,8 F. a 1 (:W )
e nd s pprprae e co.
3d t 36; e lo nr 26 3d t 88 ç e
(
h ve he d t tr m a m a b a pr pra e whe e a ALJ f l t a s s a c a m a ' c pa t t
à
l ha e nd y e p o i t
r n
ais o s e s l i nts a ciy o
perbr r e
l m elvantf i ,des t cont ar evi
unctons pie
r y dence i t r d,orwhereot i
n he ecor
her nadequaci i
es n

t ALJSa l i futaeme ni f lrviw.)(ntr quoai makso te .
he ' nayss rsrt a ng u e e ' i enal tton r mitd)
'
I t e c tsviw ,t difc t w ih t La J e' as e s e ofpl i tf RFC i
n h our' e he f uly t he w udg s s s m nt
a n ifs
s

t ts f ie t a qu t y add e st e de c idi tng t tM r Hurtwoul ne d s cil
ha he ald o de ael
r s he vi n e n cai ha . s
d e pe a
s r son ora s s a et s t i e pl m en . The r c r r ve l t tM r H ur tr quie t
upe vii
s it nc o us a n m oy t
e o d e a s ha . s e r d he

a ssa c o aj bc a ht o ti a dp rom h smo trc n p st nwi ac nrc ce nn
sitn e f o o c o ban n efr i s e e t o io t o ta t la ig
i
h
s r c , nda1oft o ni e de ei c t st ta tona s pe vii oras itncewoul be
e vie a
l he pi on vi nc ndia e ha ddii l u r son
ssa
d
ne s a y,et r i t f m oft c s ona e r s pe v s y he p' o < up r e e pl e t'
ce s r ihe n he or
c a i l xt a u r ior l ' r c po t d m oym n '
oc
s

sr c s ( .76,89,30 3 . Alhôug t La J eafr dSsgnikan wegh't t
evie . Tr
0, 26) t h he w udg fode li t t i t' o he
opi ons oft s e a nc physc a ,s f ie t e ai w h t RFC a s s e di not
ni
he àt ge y
i i ns he a l d o xpl n y he
s es m nt d

i l a ylmiai rfe tngt n dfre r s r iin. ( . -23) Nordi s e an
ncude n i tton elci he ee o xta upe vso Tr22 .
d he xpli
how t RFC as ess entwas(consit nt'w ih Dr K a z' r
he
s m
d
s e ' t . t s ecom m endaton t pl ntf pur ue a
i hat ai if s

G ii ofs
ç ton uppo t d e pl
pos
re m oymen ' o a E ii o hi y sr c r r pe ii a s r i e
t' r E ton f ghl tu m ed, e ttve nd upe v s d
pos
e pl e whe e he c n w or a a r uc d pa e a wihou s ci la i e pe s alde a
m oym nt r
a
k t ed e c nd t t o a nd nt r r on
m nds

bengpl e upo hi ' ( . ) I t a e eo s he a to ,hec tsc nsri d
i ac d n m. Tr328 . n he bs nc f uc xplnains t ouri o tane
'
t c ncl t t r nd i w a r n e unde t pa tc a c r um sa es o t s c e Se
o o ude ha ema s r a t d
r he ri ul r ic t nc f hi as . e

Sa r v.Col n,No. 1 c 0 ,201 U. Dit LEXI 1 02,a * ( . Va.Se .
undes
vi
7:4-v-0096 5 S. s.
S 289 t 29 W D.
pt
25, 201 (E ve Sa ess i ec nne td c le s of he rng l s a i elcu
5) E n und r' ntro ce halnge
Gi
ai os nd ntle tal
de i i nc e , heA LJ s l pr vi f t re a a i on r m a a t w hy he di nota ce t
fc e i s t
ha l o de urhe xpl n ton
e nd s o
d
c pt he

me ia r c mme d f n o tmpoA yr q llg aJ b c a h o wh s c arc mme d fo
dc l e o n a o s f e r
e nrn o o c r y u h e o n a n
d e no n e t b i ld d i te RF '; se as .ea. Go d n v.Berh l No
o s t e d o e ncu e n h C.) e lo .. o ma
'
ry il .
.

21 -v 0 28 , 0 7U. DltLEM S9 8 , t* 9( . W ah J n 1 , 0 7 (e n lgf r
:6 c - 0 5 2 1 S. s
31 8 a 2 W D. s .u e 6 2 1 ) rma dn o
f e e pr e l swhe et La J gef ie t a r s ap iin' o nin 1a t cama
n r oc ng
r he w ud ald o dd e s hysca s pi o
t he li nt

ma n e Rx s p r in a d e c ma e n t s o œ k';Ra b v.Cov No
y e d e ka u e dsp n n o g me t o ty n ' b
)
lm. .
*

11 -v0 6 6 2 1 U. DitLEM S3 6 5 a * 9tmdn t a teLa J d eerdl fl n
:2 c - 2 6 , 0 4 S. s.
8 9 , t 5 f ig h t h w u g re n nl g
l
t K c oun f rDr Tef r Tylrs o nl' t t.
o a c t o , lo d- e ' pi ons hn

, .

Pll ifm a r quie s me i fa e r
antf y e r o nl l xta

sp r iln' rR x li wh lo eo M o sween t r dtd'.
u e vso 'o e pan y s p n r o ce ie '
)
For t r s ns sa e t co t snds R od c qs ' t r ma t c s t t
he ea o tt d, he ur
go
a e' o e nd he a e o he
.
Commlso r f f- he de elpme a c *d r io .2 I t Commlsone i ' bl t
s lne or i r v o nt nd ons e a n f he
i
. i r s mn e o
s

d c d t x c s i pl i i sf vo on t ba i oft e si r c d,t Co s ine w11
e l e bl a e n antm a r he ss he xitng e or he mmlso r 1
c nduc a s plme M a nla tve he rn a whlh b 1 sde w1lbe al
o
t up e n dml m i
n ig t c 0t1 i s l
lowed t pr s nt
o ee
a i na e de ea a gu nt An a opdaeor e ofr ma ' l bee t r dt sd y.
ddGo l vi nc nd r me .
ppr
t d r e ndwll n e e bl a
TheClr i diede o s ndc e' c pi so t sme a um opi ont a1co e of
ek s r dt e e led o e f hi mor nd
ni o 1 uns l
xc r
o d.

fxo mbe
oATBo:n i zz dayo ve r 2018
s M
.
,

Se o Ultd Stt sDid c J e
nir
e a e s t udg

2h llto tec ur' d cso t mms t c s t t Co sine,hec u t e l st a de s
i f h o ts e iin o nd :e ae o bo mmiso rt o r d oi o d r s
ne
M r Hur psr #ml ngcl- ofe .
s e nl mmq aor
8