Williams v. Jones

Filing 14

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 11/30/2017. (slt)

CLERK' OFFI 'U.S. ST.
S
CH
OI COUR'
I
ATROANOKE,
VA
FI
LPD

N2V 32 2 1
27
,CL
FNTHEWEEETDET ITOFVIOURT BvwEU CEK
I T UNTT RN ISDI RI C NI J:DPUD LyER
ORHE ISDSATS RCT CTRGI A ULK C
S
.

R OANOKE DI SION
VI
ANTONI SH EPPARD W I AM S,
O
LLI
Pl ntf ,
ai if

C i lA c i N o.7: c 00475
vi t on
17- v-

V.

M EM O M ND U M O PI O N
NI

GAI JONES,
L
D e endant
f
.

By:

H on. ihae F.Ur
M c l
bansd
l
C hi fU nied St e D i t c Judg
e
t
at s s ri t
e

Ant o She r W iln ,aVigi a i a epr e ngpr K , m me e t sa ton
oni
ppa d li ms
r ni nnit oce di
o co
nc d hi ci

purua t 42U. C.j 1 3.Pl ntf name c rctonalofiilGalJ sa t s e
s nt o
S. 98 ai if
s ore i
fca i one s he ol

d fnd n .Plitf alg sta J n sS e lg ne(ijmyta frrg t yv oae DOC ree a t anif le e h t o e t gi e t sc
n
rnse i h b i ltd
e
'

e r pr n ta f ri aeslkem egoho ene ye r by ta f rmet Re Oni Prs
nty ogr m r ns e nm t i
m
xt a , r ns e
o d on ion
N

h

t tdon' g no r - nty pr r m f m e' Pli tf f el hes ul ha be n ta f r e t a
ha
t ot e e r og n or .' a n if e s ho d ve e r ns e r d o
dif e prs n t tha ar - ntypr r m .Pli ifalof ulsJ sbe aus Pli ifs
fer nt i o ha s e e r og n
antf s a t one c e antf

cel t a Re Oni Stt Prs n t oode g s nos ' Pli ifwa sda sf bei a .
lmae t d on ae io l
bl d hij e. antf nt mage or ng t
'
Re Oni St t Prs n be we n Augus a No mbe 201
d on a e io t e
t nd ve r 7.
Thec t us dimisa aci n orcli sl dby a i aei t c tde e re t t
our m t s s n to
am e
n nm t f he our t nnits ha
t a ton orcli i fi ousorf l t sa eacli onwhi h r le m a begr nt d.Se 28
he c i
am s rvol
ais o t t
am
c e if y
a e
e

U. C. j 1 5 e( ) 1 5 b () 4 U.. j 1 9 ec .Thetrtsa d r icud scams
S. j 91 ()2 , 91 A()1 ; 2 SC. 9 7 ()
ss tn a d n l e li
bas d upon ta i s a y m e ils lgal he y, t l i sofi rnge
e
ln ndiput bl rte s e t or ' t am
'c
nfi mentofal ga i e es
e l ntr t

whih clary doe note s ' cli swhe et S ac t c e i nsa ec e ry ba el s'
c e l
s
xit'or am
r he t tz ont nto r l a l s es .'
f al

Netkev. iln , U. 31 3 ( ) Thes c sa r i t fmiirsa r f
iz W lims 490 S. 9, 27 1989 .
e ond tndad s he n la tndad or

amoint ds s u d rF d r l eo Ci l o e u e1 b () a c p i aplitf'
to o imis n e e ea Rul f viPr c d r 2()6 , c e tng anifs
f c ua alega i a t te. A c pl i ne ds G s t nd pl i s a e e o t c a m s i
a t l l tons s rz
om a nt e t hor a
a
a n t t m nt f he l i how ng

t tt plade i e ildt rle'a s fce çlj t algai ...oriearghtt
ha he è r s ntte o eif' nd ufiint tfacual le tons t as i o

r le a
ei f bovet s c ai lve .... BelAt. p . Two bl , 5 0U. 5 4, 5 ( 0 )
he pe ultve e l ' l l Co v. m y 5 S. 4 5 5 20 7
'

(ntr quottonmaksomitd) A pl nifsba i f rle Tequie moet nlbesa
i enal ai
r
te . aitf' ss or eif ç rs r ha a l nd
r
co l i .... 1 The e or ,apl ntf m us t le f t s fc e t sa ealt elme s
nc usons
' d. r f e
'
ai if t G lge ac s ufii nt o t t 1 he e nt
a
'
s
o gh )cam,1 Bas v E.. p n d Ne u s& Co.3 4F.d7 , 6 (t Ci. 0 )
f t e li '
I Du o t e mo r
, 2 3 61 7 5 4h r 20 3 .
.

Thec mpliti d s se wi o t rj d c f rfiigt saeacam u o whc
o an s imisd t u p eu ie o al o tt li p n ih
h
n
r ifma beg a td, Pli ifi grnt lavet n ndwihi tn d ys je e. ,Goodev.
ele y r ne but antf s a ed e o me
t n e a . e. z.

Ce .Va. lAi Soc'.nc,807F. 61 623- ( hCi. ) s ealoRvanv.
nt ,Leaa d y l .
3d 9, 24 4t r 2015 ; e s
Gonzae ,568U. 5 74 ( 3)(ç edonotpr umet tdititc t nee uns i e
ls
S. 7, 201 ç
W
es ha src ours d oldtd

a viefo u o ho t ma a et erd c es' Animaeha n c n ttto a rg t ob
d c r m s n w o n g h i o k t.
). n t s o o siuin l ih t e
h u e i a yp riu a p io .Se s ..M e c u v. n , 2 U.. 5( 9 6 . Alo a
o s d n n a t lr rs n e eg, a h m Fa o 4 7 S 21 1 7 ) s , n
c
i t doe no ha aconsiu i lrg t bepl c i as cii s c iy cls ii to
nma e s t ve
tt tona i ht o
a ed n pe fc e urt a sfcai n,

c so ilca sfc to sd no ce t amao d su to i ap io e ' e vio me t a d
u t da lsiiain o t rae j r ir p in n rs n rs n r n n, n
Pl i iff ist de c i a a y c a sgnii a ha ds p i r l to t t or na y i i nt
antf al o s rbe n t pial nd i fc nt r hi n e ai n o he di r ncde s
'

0 p io l e S e e:,S n i v Co n r 51 U. 47 48 - 7( 9 5 .Plitf al t
f rs n i . e . .. a dn . n e , 5 S. 2, 6 8 1 9 ) aniff is o
f
esa ih J s c pa esa eofmi f a al ge f iur t pr e tPli iffom t
t bls one ' ul bl t t
nd or n le d a l e o ot c antf r he

c lmae Se . ..Fame v. ema , 1U. 8 5 8 3 3 ( 9 4 .Alh u hPlitf alg s
el t. e ec, r r Brr n 51 S. 2 , 3 - 4 1 9 ) t o g anif l e
e
t tJ
ha onesvi a e VDOC pr e zesby ta f r i hi t Re Oni St t Prs ac am t t
olt d
oc dlr
r nse rng m o d on a e ion, l i ha
prs ofi i sha notf l d t rown i pe
ioh fcal ve
olowe hei
nde ndep polcesorpr edur sa s doe not
t ii
oc e lo s

1Dee mi ng wheherac ai satsaplusbl cli f r ifi <ac e -pect ts t tr uie
tr ni
t
ompl nt t e
a i e am or ele s < ontxts ik a k ha eq r s

terve n c utoda o i j dca e pein ea dc mmo sn e' Asco v Ib l5 6U. 6 2 6 87
h e iwig o r t rw n t u iil x re c n o n e s . h rq .g a, 5 S. 6 , 7 -9
s'
'
( 0 ) Thu, c ut ce nn ac mpan u e Rue1 ()6 cnie tf pla ig ta aen te tldt a
20 9. sa o rsr e ig o lit nd r l 2b () a d niy e dn s h t r o nie o n
t
asumptonoftut bec us t y c itofno mor t n lbel a c usons 1 Alhought c tlber l
s
i
r h a e he onss
e ha a s nd oncl i . d. t
he our i aly
co t u nr . tc mpans Han sv Ken r 4 4U. 51, 202l( 9 2 ,hec utd e n tata a imaes
nsr es o z o lit, ie . r e, 0 S. 9 5 - 1 7 ) t o r o s o c s n n t'

advoc t,s as edev opi sat o ya consiutonalcl msnotce l r ie i aco ant Se Br k v.
ae u pont el ng t utr nd
tt i
ai
lary as d n mpli . e oc

Car l,17F.d2 , 4 (t Ci. 9 7 ( ti, .c n u i g ; a d t v Ci o Ha tn, 7 F.d 17 ,
rol.0 3 41 2 3 4h r 1 9 ) Lutg J, o c n n ) Beu et . t f mpo 7 5 2 2 4
v
1 78(t Ci.1 8 ) seas God nv Le k , 7 F.d l47 1 51(t Ci.1 7 )(e o nii ta adsrc
2 4h r 9 5 ; e lo r o . e e 5 4 2 1 , l 4h r 9 8 rc g zng h t itit
cou ti notexpe t t a s et er eofadv aef apr .K. ai i )
r s
ced o s um h ol
oc t or o pl ntf .
f

2

saeac nsiuin lcam.Se . ..Untd Sae v Ca e e , 40U. 7 , 5 - 5( 9 9 ;
tt o ttto a li
e ea, ie tts . c r s 4
S. 41 7 2 5 1 7 )
Ricov Cny. fFara , 0 F.d1 9 1 9(t Ci.1 9 )
c i . t o if x 9 7 2 à5 , 46 4h r 9 0 .
Pl i ifma fnd i pr e a et t kel ng rt n t n da t c ul l lr our es
antf y i t ef r bl o a o e ha e ys o bns t ega es e ,
t nk a uthi a l a i ,a fl anew co anti ane a s pra eaci l Pl i if
hi bo
s leg tons nd ie
mpli n
w nd e t ton. f antf

c o s sn tt fl t mo int a n wi i tnd y , litf wo dn t p eu ie
h o e o o ie he to o me d t n e a s P an if ul o be rj d c d
h
be a ehei fe t fl aco a nti ane a s pa a ea ton a t tm eofhi c ce
c us
s r e o ie mpli n
w nd e r t c i t he i
s hoi

s b e t ot a plc b el tto sp ro .Se . ..Owe v. u e 48 U. 2 5 2 9 5
u j c t he p ia l i ai n e id e e:, ns Ok r, 8 S. 3 , 4 - 0
mi
( 9 9 ; . d j8. - 4 ( .
1 8 ) Va Co e 012 3 A)
I Pl i ifi t d r hesa c
f antf nsea us
nd hoos st s k a a e
e o ee n m ndme i t sc s ,he s dkno
nt n hi a e
houl
w

t a t ec u t y ds s a a n e c mplitwi p eudc a fioo so f rfiigt
h t h o r mà imis n me d d o an t rj ie s rv lu r o aln o
h
Nt t acai upo whi r le m a begr nt d,whih c d c tt t açsrke. Pl i if
sae l m
n ch e if y
a e
c oul onsiu e lti ' antf
'

s d t rt nd t thei al we onl tle Ssrke 'fom bot c
houl mde sa ha
s lo d y lr e çti s' r
h ompl i si dititc t
ant n src ours

a da p asi c urso a p asb i eh i n l n e al we t p o e dL f r p u ei
n p e l n o t f p e l ebr e s o o g r lo d o r c e q o ma a p rs
wihoutpr pa ngt $400 flng f t'bs ntce t n c tons Co r s c eaed t sGhr e
t
e yi he
ii e a e rai ondii . ng e s r t hi ç e t
s rkes' u e a a e onom i i e i f pr s ne st t t a t rk' be o e pur ui a l w s t
ti 'r l s n c
c nc ntve or i o r o ç op nd hil ' f r
s
s ng a ui.
Se .e. , e sv. uhm ,N o.1: v11 2007 U . D i t LEXI 91
e M. Roc r Bl
07c 77,
S. s .
S 646,2007 W L 4401 a
87, t

*1( . M ih. c 1 , 0 .
W D. c De . 3 20 7

EN E T i CJ
T R: hs

dyoNoe e,07
a f vmbr21.
chi funie stt sDititJ e
e
t d a e src udg