Williams v. Jones

Filing 28

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 5/7/2018. (slt)

rLERKS OFFI U..DI COUR'
CE S ST.
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FIED
L

MAt 28 2 1
28
I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI T C O UR T
C
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI GI A
CT
R NI
ROANOK E DI SI
VI ON

ANTONI SHEPPARD W I AM S,
O
LLI

JULK . UD I
CLE
BY:
. n
-c E

Ci lAc i n No.7: c 00475
vi to
17- v-

Pl ntf
ai if,

M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI
GALE JONES,
D ef
endant
.

By: H oh.M iha F.Ur
c el
bahs
ki
Chi fU ni e St e D i t i tJudge
e
t d at s s r c

Ant ni She r W iln s aVigi ai t pr e ng pr K ,
o o ppa d lim , r ni nma e oce di
o comm e e t sa ton
nc d hi c i

pzs a t o4 U. C. 1 8 .Plitf n me GaeJ n s whoi t eClsiiain S p r io f r
l u n t 2 S. j 9 3 an if n s l o e ,
r
s h a sfc to u e vs r o
t eVign aDe a t n o Co rcin (S
h r ii p rme t f re to s I
VDOC' , st es l d fn a tl Plitf alg st t
' a h oe e e d n
)
an if l e ha
e
Dee a t r ee h sta se t Re On o SaeP io (' P' a r tlain frc mme ig
fnd n o d r d i r n fr o d in tt rs n $
ROS ' s eaito o o ncn
)
acv l cin a ans safa S s x1 S aeP io (su sx1' .De e d n fldamo inf r
ii a to g i t tf t use 1 tt rs n t se 15 f n a t ie
ç
)
to o

s mmayj g n , n t tmef rPlitf t r s n e pr d madngt i ma tr ief r
u r ud me t a d he i o an if o epo d x ie , l h s te rp o
diposto Afe r vi wi t r c d,t c tg ant Def nda ' m o i n f rs
s ii n. tr e e ng he e or he our r s e nts to o umm a y
r

j d me tb c u ePlitf f ie t e h us a albl a miitaierme is
u g n e a s anif ald o x a t v ia e d nsrtv e de .
1
.

OnAp i 1 , 01 ,hel si to a ClsiiainAuhoiy((CA' a S se 1
rl 1 2 7 t n tt in l a sfc to t rt & ' t u sx 1
u
I )
rc
e omm e
ndedt tPli tY ss c iy s or bei r as dt Le l5 i pa'duet hi sgnii a
ha a n i
e urt c e nc e e o ve n l
t
o s i fc nt
prs n dicplna y c c i .TheI r o mende t tPl i ifbeta f redt Re Oni
io s i i r onvitons
CA ec m
d ha antf
r nse r o d on,

S s e 1S aeP io (t se 1) o W alnsRig S aePrs n(K RSP'.OnAp i 2 , 01 ,
u s x tt rs n f sx ,, r l
su
,
e d e tt io I
W
'
)
rl 0 2 7
D ef nda a oved t I ' r c m e ton t tPl i if s s c iy s or be i r s d,buts
e nt ppr
he CA S e om nda i ha a ntf e urt e e nc ea e
he
di notde e m i t whi h pr s Pl i i fs d bet a f r ed.
d
t r ne o
c i on a ntf houl
r ns e r

1J
sdentted n he ompli a GaiJ .
ant s l ones
ones wasm i i ii i t c

A boutam ont l t r o M a 1 a 24,201 s a f a Sus e 1 a l dl a s uled
h a e n y 9 nd
7, t f t s x 1 lege y s a t

Pl i if Pl n ifc
antf . aitf ommenc d acvi a ton a
e i l c i boutt al ge as a tilt U nied St t D i ti t
he le d s ul r he t
a es s rc
.

Co tf t Ea tr DititofVigi a i e ry J 201
ur or he se n src
r ni n a l une 7.
Pl i ifw a t a f r ed f o Sus e 1 t R OSP o A ugus 8,201 Pl i t f co m e e
a ntf s r hs e r r m
sx 1 o
n
t
7. a n if m nc d

t sa ton on Oc o r5,201 a Pl i iflf ROSP o Nove be 1 201 whe hewas
hi c i
t be
7, nd antf e t
n
m r 5, 7, n

ta f redt Suse lStt Prs (l sx1'.
r nser o s x ae ion t e 5)
sus
Pl i ifdi no fl ape tne r gulrg i va ea utt ee nt .I lt Aprl201
antf d t ie ri nt e a re nc bo hes ve s n ae i
7,
Pl i iffl d a i or a c pl i a
a ntf ie n nf m l om a nt boutbe ng t a f r e t Re Oni n. l e ry Se e be
i r ns e r d o d
o n a l pt m r

201 Pl i iffl d a i o ma c
7, antf ie n nf r l ompll r que tng ata f rt Sus e lorW RSP s t the
ant e si
r ns e o s x
o ha
c d pa tci t i r - ntypr r m mi .2
oul ri pa e n e e r og a ng
II.
A.

A pat i e tte t sl r j g n i tepla i g ,hed sl s dmaeil o fl,
iy s n ild o t
mma y ud me t f h e dn s t ico e tras n ie
a any a fda t s
nd
f vis how t tt r i no g nui diput a t a m a e i f c . Fe R. v.
ha he e s
e ne s e s o ny t ral a t d. Ci P.

56() M aei fcsaet ene esayt etbls t elme sofapa t sc us ofacin.
a . tral a t r hos c sr o sa ih he e nt
ry' a e to
Andes n v.Li rvLo l .477U. 242,248( 986) A ge nediput ofmae ilf t
ro
bet bby.nc,
S.
1 .
nui s e
tra ac
e ssi,i viw i a s i ee de a a lr as bl i er nce d a t r f o i alght
xit f n e ng dmi sbl vi nce nd 1 e ona e nf e s r wn he e r m n i
mos f vo a et t nont a r bl o he
movi pary,ar as fa ef tfnde c dr t n ave ditf t nonng t e ol bl ac-i r oul eur
r c or he

mova .J sThemovi pa t ha t bu de ofs ng- tha i, ntngoutt t ditit
nt #.
ng ry s he r n howi d t s poi i
t
o he src
c t t tt r i a a e e ofe de e t s
our - ha he e s n bs nc
vi nc o uppo tt no ovi pa t s c s ' Ce ot x Cop .
r he nm ng r y' a e.
' l e

v. tet47 U. 31 , 2 ( 98 ) I temo a tstsi st sbzd n te t en n mo n mus
Cart, 7 S. 7 3 5 1 6 . f h v n aife hi t e ,h n h o - va t t
r
s f t s cii f c st tde
et orh pe fc a t ha monsr t t e se eofa ge ne diput off tf til I a
ta e he xit nc
nui s e ac or ra . d. t
2Pl ntf' antci td goodtmer las daei Ocober2,201
ai ifs i pae
i ee e t s t
8.

2

3 2- .A p ryi e tte t s mmayj d me i t ea misbee ie ea awh l c udno
2 24
a t s nild o u r u g nt f h d si l vd nc s oe o l t
lad ar tona ti roff c t fnd i f voroft no mova . W ila v. ifn,95 F. 820,
e
a i l re
ato i n a
he nnt
li ms Grfi
2 2d

823(t Ci.1 ) C eeuns
4h r 991. ç r uppore s ulton ...snote
M
td pec ai
i
nough. de e tas
t f a ummay
p
r

j d me tmoin. En i v Na'As ' o Bus & Ed c Ra i snc, 3F.d5 , 2(t Ci.
u g n to ' ns . tl sn f . u . d o l .5 3 5 6 4h r
'

1 9 ) A p an ifc n o u ear s o et amo inf rs
9 5 . litf a n t s ep ns o to o umma yj d me tt a n o c re t
r u g n o me d r or c a
c mplitc alng db temo infrs mmayj g n .Cl a i e v. c vt, 5 F.d
o an h l e y h to o u r ud me t o nnc r M De it5 5 3
e
3 4 3 6( t Ci. 0 )
2 , 3 4h r 20 9 .
B.

Dee d n ag e i t emoinf rs mmayj d me tta Plitf f i dt e h us
fn a t r u s n h to o u r u g n h t an if al o x a t
e
a alb ea miitai rme isa rq ie b 4 U. C. 1 97 () Th e h usin
v ia l d n sr t e de s e u rd y 2 S. j 9 e a. e x a to
ve
rquieme i ma t ya ç pple t a1i t s t a prs n lf .' Po trv. se
e r nt s ndaor nd t is o 1 nmae uis bout io iegj' re Nusl,
a
534U. 516,5 532( 2) çpr pe e usi de ndsco inc wiha a nc s
S.
24, 200 . d o r xha ton ma
mpla e t n ge y'

d a l e a doh rciia p o e u a r ls' W o d o dv. o 5 8U. 8 , ( 00 ) W he a
e di s n t e rtc l r c d rl ue . o f r Ng , 4 S. 1 90 2 6 . n
n
'
prs pr desa a i sr tve g i va epr edur ,t i aemus fl agre nc r ii a
ion ovi
n dm nita i re nc oc e he nm t
t ie i va e asng
pa tc a c am a pur uei tuough a 1a iabl l ve sofa a t i ope l e
riul r l i nd s t l
1 val e e l
ppe l o i
pr ry xhaus.'I ;
t' d.

Dio v. g , 91F.d.8 , 091(t Ci. 0 2 .On ead fn a t r s n se d n eo a
x n Pa e 2 3 4 5 49 - 7h r 2 0 ) c e e d n p e e t vie c f
f iur t e us, hebut n o pr s fst t pl i ift s
a l e o xha t t
de f oof hit o he antf o how, apr ponde a e oft
by
e
r nc
h:
e de e, ha e usi oc ur e ora nita i r m e e we et vaia et oug no f ul of
vi nc t t xha ton c r d dmi sr tve e di s r ma lbl hr h
a t

t eplitf.S e e:.Tuc l Gr v r 6 0F.d 1 4 ,1 5 ( 0hCi. 1 ; o r v
h an if e s . , ke v. o e , 6 3 2 9 2 4 1 t r 201 ) M o e .
Be n te 51 F.d71 ,7 (t Ci. 0 ) S h na a miitai pr c s i s s e i eo
n et, 7 3 7 25 4 h r 20 8 . i e n d n sr t o e s s u cpt f
W
ve
bl
m uli e r as
tpl e onabl i e pr t tons Cong e shasde e ne t tt i a e s ul e ron t s de
e nt r e a i ,
rs
t nni d ha he nm t ho d r
he i

ofe usi ' Ros v.Blke 578U. ,1 S.Ct 185 185 ( )
xha ton.
' s a ,
S. 36
. 0, 9 2016 .

O P 866. ,C f nde G re nc Pr ed e ' pr de t ad i s r tve r m e e f
1 t e r i va e oc ur ,' ovi s he m ni t a i e di s or
of

i t st r s ve c
nma e o e ol ompl i s a a a nita i de ii ,a c le polc e a
ant, ppe l dmi sr tve csons nd hal nge ii s nd
pr edu e . A1 i s a e gre bl e e is a
oc r s 1 s ue! r iva e xc pt s ues boutpolce ,pr ed e ,a de sonsoft
i ig oc ur s nd cii
he
Vigi aPa ol Boa d;dicplna y hea i pe te a orpr edur le r s sa ea f de a
r ni r e r s i i r
rng nali s nd/ oc a ror ; t t nd e r l

c tde sons lws a r gul to ;a ot rm a tr be
our cii , a , nd e ai ns nd he te s yond t VDOC' c r . l aesa e
he
S ontol nm t r
oren edt t i t gre ncepr ed ewhe t y e t rt VDOC' c t a whe t y
i t o he nma e i va
oc ur
n he n e he
S usody nd
n he
m' t a f r ed t ot rVD OC f ciii .
e r ns e r o he
a ltes

Be or s itng a gre nc ,a i t mus m a agood-at e f tt i onnal
f e ubm ti
i va e n nma e t ke
f ih for o nf ly
r ol t i s by s ithg a i o m a c m pl i f r , whi h i a ia e i hous ng unis3
es ve he s ue
ubm ti n nf r l o a nt o m
c s va l bl n
i
t.

l t is i noti o ma l r s ve t i ae mus fl ar ulrgre ncewihi t ry
f he s ue s
nf r ly e ol d, he nm t
t ie eg a i va
t n hit

c e arda fom t daeof,ordic r olt i i nte pti c raner lmsanc slke
alnd ys r he t
s ove y l he ncde xce n eti icl t e i
e sbe
vent yond t i ae' co r 14 I a i t hasbee ta f r e snc t occtr nceor
he nm t s nto . f n nma e
n r nse r d i e he tre
i i nt t i ae s d sils i t i or c
ncde j he nm t houl tl ubm t he nf mal ompli ta gre ncet t f ciiy whe e
a n nd i va
o he a lt
r
t i i ntoc lr e
he ncde
czr d.
l i unc r ve t t tPl i ifdi notfl a r gulrg iva ewihi t ry da oft
t s onto red ha antf d
ie e a re nc t n hit ys he
a lged r t laor ta f r Alho h Pl ntf di notbele heha a nitâi r m e e
le
e ai t y r ns e . t ug ai if d
ive
d dmi sr tve e di s
a l e be a e ofhi ta f r OP 866. s ilpr vi d a r m e A n ad i sr tve r m e
vaiabl c us
s r ns e ,
1 tl o de
e dy.
m nit a i e dy

pr s doesnotbe m eç va lbl 'whe a i t doe notco pl wih pr e a nles
oce s
co l
una ia e' n n nma e s
m y t oc dur l l .

W oo f r v Ng 5 U.. 1 9 ( 0 6 .A c u t yn te c eaf iu et e h u t valbe
d o d . o, 48 S 8 , 5 2 0 ) o r ma o x us al r o x a s a ia l
3An i aei no r r d, how e r t fl a i or a com plita uta algedi de ofs xuala e.
nm t s t equie
ve ,o ie n nf m l
an bo n le
nci nt e
bus
4Greva st ta ea e ed a it r ei upt t e l l ofr e . A w a de conducst frt
i nce ha r cc pt t nake ec ve o hr e eves eviw
r n
t he ls,
tle l'r viw.I t i ei uns tsid wiht Le 1deemi ton,t im' t m a a alt dee nai
savel ' e e f he nmat s aife t he vel tr nai he n ae y pp: he tnni ton
wihi fveda ofr ei t Le l1,whih i us lydoneby ar gi ombuds
t n i ys ec pt o ve 1 c s ual
e onal
man.Formos i ues Le 1 i
t ss , vel 1 s
t f ll ofr viw.Fort f w is a al et Le 11 t i t ma a alheLe l1 dee mi ton
he ma evel e e
he e sues ppe abl o vel 1, he nmae y ppe t
ve 1 tr na i
wihi fveda ofr ei t ade y die o o t Diecoroft VD OC.
t ni
ys ec pt o put r ctr r he r t
he

4

r m e es e n t t ke i o ac ountç pe i lcic s a es' os ,1 S.Ct a 1
e di , ve o a nt c
t c a r um t nc .
s
'R s 36
. t 856.

Ac r ngl Pl i iff ist c ry hi btr n t s w e usi occ e ort tr m e e we e
co di y, antf al o a r s lde o ho xha ton un'd ha e di s r

ma eu a ia l t r u hn fulo h so , n Dee d n i e tte t sl r j g n .
d n valbe h o g o a t f i wn a d fh a t s n i d o t
l
mmay ud me t
111.

Fo t f rg i r a o ,h c u t rn sDee a tsmo inf rs mmayj d me t
r he o e ong e s n te o r g a t fnd n ' to U u r u g n .

E E Ti V
NT R: hs

dyoMa,08
a f y21.

,
jp.
j;,
j
p

,
.
.

Chi fU ni
e

.

.,

.

4
1
j

.)
..
.,
r

St t sD i t i tJ
a e s rc udge
k: ., .
-z!; k
. ;@ :

,

y ra.
..