Muhammad v. Fleming et al

Filing 30

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 9/25/2018. (tvt)

cteRl' OFFI U. ,Dl IOURT '
ts
CE s sr.
AT DANVI VA .
LLE,
FIED
L

sEP 25 2 1
28
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
FO R THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI
CT
RGI A
NI
R O AN O K E DI I O N
V SI

MALCOLM M VHAM M iD,
Pl ntf
ai if,
V.

L.J.FLEM I
NG,e al,
t .
D ef
endant
s.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

J W C D DL C RK
UL .
c
EPUW CL
E

C i lA ct on N o.7:
vi
i
17-cv00481

M EM OR AND U M O PI I N
N O
By:

H on. ls L .K i e
Jac t on
sr
Se or U nied St e D i t i tJudge
ni
t
at s s r c

M a c m M uha a aVigni prs 'a fe
l ol
mm d, r i a ione nd r quen fl ri t sc t c me d t s
r
t ie n hi our, om nce hi

a to p oî p ru n t 4 U. C.j1 8 a d â2 0 c - , ts q, b u h se p re c sa
cin r q u s a t o 2 S.
9 3 n 0 0 c 1 e e .a o t i x e in e t
W ale R i St t Pr s 1pr vi l or r Pl i ift fl a s c
l ns dge a e i on. e ous y de ed a ntf o ie e ond n e d c pl i
m nde om a nt

t td e n t n l eamij i e cam o d fn n .S e e2, d. Ci . 20 a( ) 21
ha o s o i cud
so n d li r ee da t e s ..Fe R. v P. ()2 , .
,
His nv No we tF n S. .nc, 3 F.d61 , 8( t Ci. 01.Plitf fldt en w
n o . r s i . C.l .2 9 3 1 61 4h r 20 ) an if ie h e
p e dng a dDe e d n sfldamoint ds s o t srk mij ie camsa dd f n a t.
la i , n fn a t ie
to o imis r o tie son d li n e e d n s
De e nt a gue i t i m o i n t tPl i iff ie t compl wih t prorOr ra
f nda s r
n her to ha antf al d o
y t he i
de nd
t Fe r lRul s a t y a k m e t di m i s a 1butone c ai a utPl ntf sr i i us d e i
he de a
e , nd he s
o s s l
l m bo
ai i f elg o i t n
O c o r201 Pl i i fa gue i r s
t be
5. a ntf r s n e pons t ta 1cl i s a de e nt i t ne pl ad ng
e ha 1 a m nd f nda s n he w e i

c e n t s me s i ofalege y r t it yta a tonsa haveco m o que to ofl w
onc r he a eres
l dl eala or r ns c i
nd
m n si ns a
and f c sr s tng f o Pl ntf s e r i e ofa Fis A m e
a t e uli r m ai if xe c s
rt
ndm e r ght
nt i .

De e nt 'm o i n t dim isort srkemus bede e Booke v.Sout Ca olna
f nda s to o s s
o ti
t
ni d.
r
h r i

De a t n o Co r ci n , 5 F.d 5 3, 45( t Ci. 01 ) h l i 2 7t a, i c 2 0
p rme t f re to s 8 5 3 3 5 4h r 2 7 , ed n 01 h t sn e 01 ,
pri
soner i t s cicui have had a cl l es abls Fi s Am endm entr ghtt fl a wri en
s n hi r t
eary- t i hed r t
i o ie
tt

pr s p g i va e w ihouts f rng r t i t o A tl a to t
i o r e nc t
uf e i e ala i n.
e s ne mpubls c r ui c to ri has
i hed i c t our pilon

r m a d ac s unde Booke ,fndi af r lc ebe a e aprs rm a a û r l
e nde
ae
r
r i ng ede a as c us
ione de & ba
ve

co a nt' o sa fa t n s ehi adve s t t prs rha ne lt r Se e. ,Pa t
mpli 't t f nd he om t ng
r e o he ione ppe d a e . es g. ton

v. mbl, 7F. p' 2 , 7 ( t Ci. 01 )
Ki e 71 Ap x 71 2 2 4h r 2 8 .
Al os ffy ye r e rir t Supr m eCour r c ni e t tlc t a ei1eq ppe t
m t i' a s a le ,he
t
e
t e og z d ha iours r l ui d o
de w ih t i r as ngl ur ntpr e s ofpr s a i s r ton a r f m .' Pr t i rv.
al t he nc e i y ge
obl m
i on dm ni ta i nd e or ' oc m e

M a t e , 6U. 3 6 4 5( 9 4 .TheCo r e pli d:
ri z 41 S. 9 , 0 1 7 )
n
u t x ane
( dea co tja e ...i1s t t a ta t fontlne a nces fr t
Fe rl urs z
1 uied o c s he r -i ge i o he
c i r to a r ol i n of t i i t va i t of pr s r c pl i s
ons de a i n nd es uto
he nfnie re y
i one om a nt .

M o e v r tec p ct o ol ci na j sies tm t d a f il a d f l
r o e, h a a iy f t rmi l u tc yse o e l ary n ul
r
y
wih l gii ae c am swilbei par d by a bur ni i r as offi l
t e tm t l i
l m ie
geo ng nc e e rvo ous
prs rc
ione ompli s As o m e ns o a lvi tng t spr e ,THE CHI
ant .
ne a f le ai hi obl m
EF
J
USTI ha s
CE s ugge t d t t f de al a sa e 'ut ii e or t
se ha e r nd t t a hortes xpl e he
pos i lt ofi tt i i e na ad i sr tvepr e esf diposton of
sbiiy nsiutng ntr l m nitai
oc dur or s ii
i at grevances.
nm e i
I a 405 n.
d. t
9.
M or t n t nt yea s l t r G
e ha we y r a e , t
cong e se t d t Pr s Lii ton Re o m Ac of
r s nac e he i on tga i
fr
t

19 (
9 5 PLRA). .nt ewa o as aprs i p io e ltg to i t ef d rlc u t,. .
. i h ke f h r ie n rs n r i ai n n h e ea o rs . .
i
d sg e t b igti ltg to u d rc nr l'W o d o dv. o 5 8U. 8 , 4( 0 ) A
e i n d o rn h s iiain n e o to . o f r Nc , 4 S. 1 8 20 6 .
'
C e e pi ce ' t s a t m ptw a t r qui e prs r t e us a l bl a i s r tve
t nt r e ' of hi t e
c
s o e r i one s o xha t vaia e dm nit a i

r me i s 4 U. C. 1 9 ea .No a l, o rsha eh l ta p io e sdono h v alg l
e de . 2 S. j 9 7 () tby c u t v ed h t rs n r
t ae e a
e t lme tt tl a piitai erme is S e eg.Ad msv. c , 0F.d7 7 (t Ci.
ni e n o ie d n srtv e d e . e . . , n
t
Rie 4 3 2, 4 4 h r
1 )
994 .
To hol ot r i e w oul be t br ng vi t ly e r t popul r de i i by
d he w s
d
o i
rua l ve y m
a c s on
sa e a t swihi t s pe ofa c us ofa ton f r'e a iton. Thi woul
tt c or t n he co
a e
ci o r t la i
s
d
pos pa tc a pr e si t c e ofprs n a nita i Eve yac of
e ri ulr oblm n he ont xt
io dmi sr ton. r t
d s i i by p i on ofi a s i by de i ton ( e a i t v' i t s ns t t i
i c plne
rs
tci l s
f nii G t la or ' n he e e ha t
r
rs
e ponds diec l t prs r m i c nd t The pr pe t of e e s cl i s o
r ty o i one s o uc .
os c
ndl s a m f
r t la i on t pa t o i a e woul dinz pr s of i i s i t
e a i ton
he r f nm t s
d s pt i on f c al n he
di c r o t i m os bas c dute .
s ha ge f he r
t i
is

1 (mpha i a d)
d. e ss dde .
2

Eve i prs ne sdo notha af de a rg t t m ,apr c i lr s tofBooke i t t
n f io r
ve e r l i ht o he
a tca e ul
r s ha
a i sr i r m e esa em o eas i
dm nitatve e di r
r prngboa dt n ahlr ef rf de alltgai n.A sngl
r ha
zdl o e r ii to
i e
wrte orveba co pl i e ur sa las o a tona ecli f wha e rpe c i d
itn
r l m ant ns e t e t ne c i bl am or t ve r e ve
S e a i t y' e nt occ i t r tne da t da a i s r t o i i a pds To sa e a
t t la or ' ve s ur n he ou i
r
y o y dm ni ta i n ns de
on.
tt

cam, p an ifn e o y( mo srt moet a as e j si iiyt a ad f n a t sa td
li a litf e d nl C n tae r h n he r o sblt h t e e d n ha ce
de
u lwf l '' As c o tv.nbal 556 U S. 6 , 7 ( 0 ) Wheh rt ealg d (eait r 'a t
n a ul ' h r f I ,
y.
6 2 6 8 20 9 . te h le e t tlao y' c
r
.

o o sin o c re i n t u lyd s ue a teveya to ds i ieb p io o fcasi b
r miso c u r d s o us al ip td s ' q r c f icpl y rs n fiil s y
g
n
d i ton çe ai t y'i t s ns t ti r s ndsdie tyt prs rm ico uc ' Adn s
efnii r t laor n he e e ha t e po
r c l o ione s nd t'
m ,
s
upur W ha i of e t r ol d i t i e be nd t a to o i s on,and a pl i i f( d
a.
t s t n m es ve s he nt nt hi he c r m s i
a ntf G
nee

o l p e e te ie efo whihajzymih rt r av r it nlsfvo . And ro v.
ny r s n vd nc r m c l
r g t eu n ed c i l a r'
i
' es n
Li ry Lobby.I , U. 242, (98 .Fr t r,Gce biiydee mi tons t
be t
nc.477 S. 257 1 6) om hee trdi lt tr nai ,hq

weg n o t e i e c , n t d a ngo lgtmaei frn e fo t fcsaejzy
ihig f he v d n e a d he rwi f e ii t n ee c s r m he a t r l
r
f ncins n t h s o aj d e' 1 . t 5
' to , o t o e f u g . d a 25 .
u
'
Ev ni, r u nd , v r oh rcam i mij ie a fi oo , anif spla e
e f ac e o e ey t e li s son d nd rv lus Plitf ha e d d
'

,
;
(

rt l to wihati h t rle . . se tda an tte )g ee d n s j ity, e e al , ri t 1
eai in t s g t o eif . a s re g i s h g d fn a tq on l sv rly o n he
a
r
E

atr tvewih rs c t o arsngouio t s metans to oc ure e,o s isof
lenai t epe t o r ii
f he a r acin, c r nc r ere

i
;

ta a tonsorocc rnce 'a wiht tonoflw orf tco
rnsci
ure s' nd t ç i
ques
a
ac mmont a1dee ntgj'Fe 6
o l fnda s.' d.
R.Ci P.20()2) Thead c fo Adn -t te ts h cai wih Eke iim,ls f rl
v.
a( .
vie r m
ms o r a uc l ms t s ptcs e t edea
s
c t e br lt m s vesi e r dici i r a tt tocclsi sa epe i tt tons' i of
ours m oi he el n ve y s plna y c ha lr n t t nal nsiu i '- s
'

1 >ofc s , c t a er r d t lbe al c t eaprso r' pr é c pl nt sop ng s to y
And
our e ours r equie o i r lyqonsru
i ne s o q om ai , t pi hor nl
.

o ie t yngcamsn v rt il'pe e td.Be u et . t o Ha tn 7 5F. 1 7 ,1 78(t Ci. 98 )
f d ni i li e e fary' rsne
f
f
a d tv Ci f mpo , 7 2d 2 4 2 4h r 1 5 .
'
v
I i amor m a gea ee r iew he aprs rspladi doesnotls e r t ealaor 'c m e ,ac,a
ts
e na bl xe cs
n ione ' e ng
it vey t t it y' om nt t nd
r
om ison i am i eby m i el fom ea d f rs r lyeasa i vi e r c r to lsa fra a
si n
nut
nut og r
ch ay o eve a r nd nvol ng ve y orecina tfe t
Prs .
ion
'

ltl i o t cus c t t ma no iteta a ves pes etveu e Fe ea Rul o Ci l
it mp rbea e ols y ta h t d re rp çi nd r d rl e f vi
e
r
Pr c d r 1 ( )6 o 5 () S eUntdS ae v. e od l c, 6 U. 6 4, 5 ( 9 2 (On
o e u e 2 b ( ) r 6 a . e i tts Dib l. n .j 9 S. 5 6 5 1 6 ) :
e
&
s mmayj g n t ei frnc st b d a fo tet eli fcsc n ane i s c
u r ud me t h n ee e o e rwn r m h md ryng a t o ti d n u h
mae il mus beviwe i t lghtmos fvorbl t t pa t o i t moton.
tras t e d n he i
t a a e o he ry pposng he i '
);

Ha s nv. ie Sae Po t l 1 .8 0F.d 1 49 1 5 (t Ci.1 8 )(( e laiga
ni o Untd tt s sa Se' , 4 2 1 , 1 2 4 h r 9 8 çn vau tn
v
I
cv l ih sc mpan f rfiu et saeacam t e Fe . Ci P. 2()6 , mu tb
ii rg t o lit o alr o tt li md r d R. v. 1 b ( ) we s e
e pe a l s i iousoft wr ngsalege W em us notdim i st co pl i unl s i a a s
s ci ly olc t
he o
l d.
t
s s he m a nt es t ppe r

t a c rant t tt pli tf woul notbee ild t r i ft ra lgalt or whih m i
o e ti y ha he a n if
d
ntte o ele mde ny e he y c ght

plusbl b s g e tdbytefcsalg d. (nena q o ainmak o te l.Ac od n l,
a i y e u g se
h a t le e ' itr l u tto r s mitd ) c r i gy I
'
do notfnd De e nt 'm oton t d s iso t srkepe s i ,a i mus bede e
i
f nda s
i o im s r o ti
r uasve nd t t
nid.
Ex TsR : Thi
s

.

9 54 dyo s pe e 2018.
% a f etmbr
,

e

N

$

e rU nie St esD i ti tJ
n'
t d at
s r c udge

4