Smith v. Rose et al

Filing 15

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Glen E. Conrad on 1/22/2018. (slt)

CLERK' bFFI U.S. ST. COtR7
:
CE
DI , J
ATG NOKE,
VA
FI
LED

I TIE UM TED STATESDI
N I
STRI COUAT
CT
FOR TI E W XSTERN DI
I
STRI OF W RGI A
CT
NI
R OA NO K E D I SI N
W O

J 22 2 1
AN
28
J
UL

BY;

u LEy cuuqx

DEPU

A NDR EW ALLA N SM ITH ,

caeko 7:7 0 9
s . 1 cv0 4 3
Pl ntf ,
ai if
M EM O RAND UM O PINION

LT.BEVERLY ROSE, &
M

By: Hon.G l E.Conr
en
ad
Se o Unie S aesDititJ e
nir t d t t
src udg

Dee nts.
fnda t)
Pl i tf Andr w A la Sm ih,a V igi a i a e pr e di pr K ,h Gl d t s c vi
a n if
e
ln
t
r ni nm t oc e ng o
as e hi i l

rght aton und r42 U. C.j1 3. He ale sta t SoutwetVigi a Regina J l
i s ci
e
S.
98
lge h t he
h s r ni
o l ai

Auh iy fcly i Ha i Vigi a CEhej i',unlwf l basi ts fom rc i ng fee
tort a ii n ys, r ni t al) a uly r nmae r e evi r
t
'
r i o publc tons Af e r viw o t r c d,t c r c l s t tt lw s tm us be
elgi us
i a i . t r e e f he e or he ou t onc ude ha he a ui
t

)
di m i ed asm oot
s ss
.

Th j rs ito o fd rl o rsi l tdt l ec s so c n rv ris U.. n t at
e u idcin f e ea c u t s i e o i a e r o to ese . S Co s. r.
mi
v
11 j 1 I d velpme soc u durngteco s ofac s whihrnd rt c tuna et g a t
1, . f e o nt, c r i h ure
a e c e e he our bl o r n
a pa t t e r lef r que t d, t cl i s mus be di m i s d a m o . Bl nc a v.A le n *
r y h e i e s e he a m
t
s s e s ot
a ik
l Rhe y
,

Ludl Cop.77F. 6 69899( Ci.1 96) A prs ne' rl s fom apatculrprs
um
, 3d 90, - 3d r 9 . io rs eeae r
ri a ion

mooshi cli f ij tvea de a aoyr ifwihrs c t hi i ac rtont r See
t s ams or nunci nd clrtr ele t e pe to s nc reai hee.
I uma v.Ozmit 50 F.d 281 28 87 ( h Ci.200 ;Wila v.Grfi 95 F. 8
nc a
n, 7 3
, 6- 4t r 7) lims
ifn. 2 2d 20,
823(t Ci.991.
4h r1 )

Asrle i t slws t Smih se o y ij nci a /rde aaor rle die tng
eif n hi a ui, t e ks nl nu tve ndo clrt y eif rci

j io fcast a n terg lto srg r igic migr l iu p b iain .Heh sn t id
al f il o me d h e uain e adn n o n ei o s u lcto s
g
a oie
f
t c tho vert thewasrla e fom t j li lt Dec mber201 Ass c hi cli
he our, we ,ha
ee s d r he ai n ae e
7. u h, s ams

se ngc ng t c ii a tejiaenow moo.Fort tra o tec ur mus dimishi
e ki ha e o ondtons t h al r
t
ha e s n,h o t t s s s

c s wiho peu c .Anap op it ode wilis t sd y.
ae t ut rj die
pr rae r r l sue hi a
The Clr i die td l s n c e o t i me a du o ni a a c
e k s r ce o e d opis f hs mor n m pi on nd c ompa yi
n ng
or t pl ntf
der o ai if

ENTER:Thi SAJ d y o J n a y
s . ' a f aur

a 8
, cl .

4

.

-

Sen orUnie St t Diti tJ e
i
t d aes src udg