Venable v. Nunn et al

Filing 16

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 2/13/2018. (slt)

eLERI OFFI U.S, ST
O
CE
AT > NOK DI . COURT

I THE UM TED STATES DI
N
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DISTRI OF W RGI A
CT
NI
R O A NO K E DI SI N
W O
JO HNNY L.
VENABLE, 1 ,
11
Pl ntf,
ai if

E,
VA

FI
LED

FEB 12 2 1
22
J
BYu
@

Ci lAc i No.7: 7- vvi ton
1 c 00495

c . lr?. . . , ....
I . x
.
K '; ' e:. .,
. . . :
' ' y .. q
e
.

B:-- . c
r''.,
'p
.
'.

. .. ..

. .
-...

M EM ORANDUM OPI
NION
BRAD NUNN,e al
t ,

Dee nts.
fnda t)

By: M i hae F.
c l Urbans
ki
ChifUnie St t sDit i tJudge
e
td a e src

J hn yL. n b e 11pr c e igp oK,ie acvirg t c mplitp ru n t 4 U.. j
o n Ve a l, 1, o e dn r fld i l ih s o an , u s a t o 2 SC.
'

1
983,whiei a c r t d. By isOr re e ed Oc o r30, 7, heco ta s dpl i ift ta
l nc r e a e
t de nt r
t be
201 t
ur dvi e antf ha
t

f iur t updat am a lng add es afe ata f rorr l s 9om i r r ton wilr ul i dim is
al e o
e
ii
r s tr r ns e
eea e
nca ce a i
l es t n s s al
o t sa ton.
f hi c i
The c ur' m a lt pl i ifha be n r t ne a undei r bl ,a pli ifha notc a t d
o ts i o antf s e e ur d s
lve a e nd antf s
ont c e

t co tsnc De e r29,201 Pli iff ie t c
he ur i e c mbe
7. antf a ld o ompl wih t c tsOr rr uii pl i if
y t he our' de eq rng antf
t m ant i a a c aem a lng a es . The e o e t co tsndst tpli iff l t pr ec et s
o i an n c ur t ii ddr s
r f r , he ur
ha a ntf aied o os ut M

a to p ru n t Fe ea Rueo CiiPr c d e41b , no c mp yn wi t c u tsJ n ay 1 ,
cin, u s a t o d r l l f vl o e m () by t o l ig t he o r' a u r 2
h
2 8 Or e.Ac o d n l, ds s tea to wii u p eudc a dd n a1 e d n moinsa mo t
01 , d r c r i gy I imis h ci n t o t rj ie n e y l p n i g to s o
Se Balr v. rs n, 8 F.d 9 , 6( t Ci.1 8 )(ttn p o. ltg n saes b e t ot
e l d Ca lo 8 2 2 3 9 4h r 9 9 sai g r j i a t r u j c t i
a
. i
:
me
rq ie n sa rs e tf rc u t r r a d s sa i a a p o raes n to frno c mpin e ;
e ur me t nd e p c o o r o des nd imis l s n p r p it a cin o n-o la c )
Do el v. o n - a vleSae Co .6 7F.d3 9 3 041( dCi.1 8 )(e o nzn ad src
mll J h sM n il ls m , 7 2 3 , 4 - 3 r 9 2 r c g iig itit
y

c u t ys as o t d s s a a to pzs n t Fe R. v. 41b )
o r ma u p ne imis n cin l ua t o d. Ci P. ( ).
r
The Cl r i die t t s nd c e oft sM e or ndlm Opi o a t ac mpa ngOr r
e k s r ced o e opi s hi m a l
ni n nd he co nyi
de
t t pa te .
o he r i s

ENTER: l /3 dyo Fb zr,08
Tls
i
a f enay2 1.
k

jr
..

'

.
. .
..
q

..
@
.

.

.

..

'
,
..

*
..
.
.

:'j;:
:. .
2 .
;
.

,

ChifUnie St e Diti udge
e
td ats sr
7

$q. ' .
. 4'
.

).:,
'
k

. .. .,

'