Dalton v. Berryhill

Filing 18

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/30/2018. (ck)

CLERK' OFFI L.S. Sq.
S
CE J
A7 ROAN Di -CCUF
I G
OKE,
VA
FI
LED

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN D I
STRI O F V I I A
CT
RG NI
R OAN OI D I SI
CE VI ON

0I 2 2
J
BK

c,
D

us cu
x
ç.

TRW I S. LTON ,
TY DA

Ci lAci N o.7: 7CV0051
vi ton
1
9
Pl i if
antf,
M EM O M N DU M O PI I N
N O

NANCY A.BERRYHI Aci
LL, tng
Com m i sone o Soc a Sec u t
s i r f i l t i y,

By:
Hon. e E.Corr d
Gln
ta
Se o Unie Stt sDititJ
ni r t d a e src udge

De enda .
f nt
Pl i ifha ll d t sa ton c lngi t fna de ii oft Comm isone ofSoc a
antf s ie hi c i hale ng he i l c son he
si r
il
Se urt de ng pl n ifs cli s f dia e cll s i tr nc be f and s e nt l
c iy nyi
aitf
am or s bl d lid' nsla e neks
uppl me a

s cliyi o b neist e t S ca S c rt Ac, sa nd d 4 U. C. j4 2 d a d4 ,
e t t nc me e ft md r he o il e u i ta me e , 2 S. j 0 ( ) n 23
r
y
a d 4 U.. j 1 1 e s q,rs ci ey. J rs ito o ti c u ti pzs n t 4 U. C.
n 2 SC. 38 t e . epe tv l u idcin f h s o r s l ua t o 2 S.
r
j40 ()a d4 U.. j 1 8 ()3 . Asrfe tdb t me rn aa ag me ts b te b
5g n 2 SC. 3 3c ()
elce y he mo a d nd r u n u mitd y
t pa tes t is s now bef e t c ta e whehe t Comm isone ' fnalde ii i
he ri , he s ue
or he our r
t r he
s i rs
c son s
s
uppo td by s t nta e de e,o whehe t r i Egood c us 't ne es ia er m a ngt
re
ubsa il vi nc r
t r he e s ç
a e' o c st t e ndi he

c s t t eCo s in rf rf rhe c n ieain. Se 4 U. C. 40 ()
a e o h mmiso e o u t r o sd rto
e 2 S. j 5 g .
The pl i i f Tr niy S.D a t w as bor on N ove be 7,1
a ntf , i t
lon,
n
m r
990, M r D a t e nm aly
. lon ve
l

g a u td fo h g sho lwih a mo iid dpo a t a eo 1 . ( .8 ) He h sn
r d ae r m ih c o t
dfe ilmaot he g f 9 Tr 20 .
a o

hso yo pa t ee a twok. ( . 6 68 .
itr f s rlv n r Tr 3 , )
On Se e be 13, 201 M r Dalon fl d a i a i f di a ed chid' i tr nc
pt m r
3, . t ie pplc tons or s bl
l s ns la e
be ft a s e e a s c ui y i om e be is I f lng hi c r e c a m s M r Dalon
ne is nd uppl m nt l e t t nc
neft . n ii
s u r nt l i , . t

al ge t the be n dia e f r a1f ms of s t ntalganf e pl e on M a c 1
le d ha
c me s bld o 1 or
ubsa i i ul m oym nt
r h 8,

2 2 d t a h a tc n iin a d p o lmswih hi rg tlp. ( .2 ) M. Datn n w
01 , ue o e r o dto n r be
t s i h l Tr 46 . r l o
i
. o
mai ai t theha r ma ne dia e t t pr e tm e.
nt ns ha
s e i d s bl d o he es nt i
M r Dat sa plc tonswe ede e upon i ta c i r ton a r onsde a i
. lon' p i ai
r ni d
niil onsde a i nd ec i r ton. He
t n r ue t d a r c i d a deno hea i a r vi w be or a Admi sr tve La J
he eq se nd e e ve
vo rng nd e e
f e n
nita i
w udge
.
I an o ni da e Nove be 23,2016 t La J
n
pi on t d
m r
, he w udge alo dee ne a tr a yi t
s tnni d, fe ppl ng he

fvese s q nta e l ton pr e s t tMr Dalon i no dia e See 20 C. R.jj
i -tp e ue il vauai oc s , ha . t s t s bld.
F.
w udg ound t tM r Dat s f r fo s ve a s ve e
ha
40 1 20 a 41 920. The La J e f
4. 5
nd 6. 1
lon ufe s r m e r l e r
.
i pa r e s i l ng t t tl pos ao tc t a r quii s e pl c m e , s a us pos o n
m i m nt , nc udi ç a ts
s
t r i e r e rng t nt a e nt t t
t pe

r d to itr a fx to l f t rg t i a d()la nn d sb l y'b t h th s i i n s
e ucin ne n li ain o lhe ih hp, n a e r ig ia ii y u t a te e mpanne t
t '
do not et i vi ly o i c
, iher ndi dual r n ombi to m e tormedialy e lt r quie nt o alse
nai n, e
c l qua he e r me s f it d

i ar n .Tr 3 - 1 . Th La J d et e a s se M r Datn' rsd a f to l a ct
mp ime t( . 0 3 ) e w u g h n se s d . l s e iu luncina c pa iy
o
asf l s
olow '
.

Afe c r f l c i r to of t e ie r or t t r i ne
tr a e u onsde ai n
he ntr ec d, he mde sg d
fnds t t t ca ma has t r sdual f nci na c pa iy t
i
ha he li nt
he e i
u to l a ct o
pe f
ronn a r nge of s de a y wor as de i
a
e nt r
k
fned i 20 C. R.
n
F.

4 4.5 7 a a d 41 .6 ( i t t t e cama t i a l t
0 1 6 4) n 69 7 $, n ha h li n s be o
fe nty lf a c r y 1 pot ,oc aso ly lf a c
r que l it nd a r 0 mds c i nal it nd any 20
pot ,a stf r sx hotr a sa wa k f f tr hotr i a
mds nd i o i
ls nd t nd/ l or o l ls n n
ei thour pe i
gh rod. I a ton, t ca ma c n ne r c i
n ddii
he li nt a
ve lmb
l dde s r s ors afol ,c oc sonal c i r mpsorsar ,
a r , ope , c f ds an ca i ly lmb n
t is
knee,or c a ,ca fe nty soop o c ouc a s d a d
l
r wl n r que l t
r r h, nd houl voi
co e r td e lr t ha r .
nc ntae xposze o za ds

1A cai f rdia ed c l s i ur e be isdsanayz t rt s m e tve-t p s nta pr es
l m o s bl hid' ns anc nett s
i
l ed mde he a i se eque il oc s
us t deemi dia lt f rpu pos ofdia lt i tr nc be isand s pplme als urt i ome a t
ed o tr ne s biiy o r es
s biiy nsla e nett
u e nt ec iy nc , nd he

cama tmutas ha eadsbit ta b g n b fr (e r ah da e2 . Hik v. l m No. 1 -v-0 8
li n s lo v ia ly h t e a eoe h ) e c e g 21 c s Covi
i
'
7:2c 0 61 ,
201 U. DitLEXI 2 2 4 a * n2( . Va Fe 2 , 01 )(i to so te ) Th po esrq ie t La
4 S. s. S 2 7 , t 4 . W D. . b. 0 2 4 ct in mitd . e rc s e urshe w
a
J g t c n ie,i s q n e wh te acama t ()i e g g d i sbsa t lg i u a t iy ()h sasv r
ud e o o sd r n e ue c , eh r li n: 1 s n a e n u tni anfl ci t; 2 a e ee
a
v
i ar n;3 h sa i ime th t eso e uasterq ie nso alse i ar n ;4 c nrt ' t hi
mp ime t () a n mpar n ta me t r q l h e urme t f itd mp ime t () a etn ö s
u
p s rlv n wok a d () i n t wh te h c n pef r oh r wok i te n to a e o o
at ee a t r; n 5 f o, eh r e a rom te r n h ain l c n my. 2 C. R.
0 F.
j 4 41 2 a d 41 .20 I a d cso cn b ra h d a a y se i tesq e ta e au to p o e s frh r
j 0 .5 0 n 69 . f e iin a e e c e t n tp n h e u nil v lain r c s, u te
e uai i ur e s ay. 1
val ton s m ce s r d.

( .3 ) Gie ti rsd a f n to a c pa iy a d atr c n i eig t e tsi n o a
Tr 2 . v n h s e iu l u cin l a ct, n fe o sd rn h e tmo y f
voc tona e r,t La J
a i l xpe t he w udgede e ne t tM r Dat n r t i s fc e f tonalc pa t
t nni d ha . lo e ans ufii nt unc i
a ciy
t pe f m ce ti t kil d,s nt r wor r e e si i sg sca numbe i t na i l
o ror
ra n ms le ede a y
k ols xitng n i ni nt
r n he tona

e o my ( . 6 . Ac o dn l t La J d ec ncu e t tM r Dat ni n tds be , nd
c no . Tr 3 ) c r igy,he w u g o ld d ha . lo s o ia ld a
t t he i not e il t be ft unde et r f de al pr r m . Se ge r ly 20 C. R.
ha
s
ntted o ne is
r ihe e r
og n
e ne al
F.

j 40 3 0 a( ) 40 1 2 () a d 41 .2 ( ) Th La J d eso i o wa a o t d a te
j 4.5 ()5 , 4.5 0g , n 69 0 g . e w u g ' pnin s d p e s h
fna de i in of t Comm isone by t SocalSe liy Admi sr ton' Appea s Cot i.
i l c so
he
si r
he
i
ctrt
nita i s
l
mcl
Ha ng e use a1 a ia e a i sr tve r m e es M r Dat n has now a
vi xha t d 1 va lbl dm nita i e di , . lo
ppeae t t s
ld o hi
court
.

W hie pli tf ma be dia e f r c ran f r of e oy e ,t c uca f c a
l a n if y
s bld o e ti o ms
mpl m nt he r il a m l
de e mi ton i whehe pl i if i dia e f r a 1f ms o s t nta ga nfl e oyme .
t r nai s
t r antf s s bld o 1 or
f ubsa il i il mpl
nt

Se 4 U. C.j 4 3 d ()a 1 8 ca . Thee a e f t ee n s o p o fwhih mus be
e 2 S. j 2 ()2 nd 3 2 ()
r r ot lme t f r o
r
c
t
c n ie e i ma n s c a a ayss Th s ee nsaes mmaie a f lo : 1 o j ci
o sd r d n kig u h n n l i. e e lme t r u rz d s olws ( ) be tve
me ia fcsa d ciia fn ig ;( )te o ii n a c n l in o te tngp sca s ( )
dc l a t n ln c l i dn s 2 h pn o s nd o cuso s f r ai hy iin ; 3

s be tvee i e c o p y ia ma fsain o i ar n s a d s rb dtr u hacama ts
u j ci v d n e f h sc l nie tto s f mp ime t, s e cie h o g li n '
tsi n a d( )t cama tse u ain, c to a hit r , e iu l kls a da e Vie v.
etmo y; n 4 he li n ' d c to vo ain l so y r sd a s i , n g . tk
l
Fic 4 F.d 1 5 ,1 5 - 0( t Ci.1 71 ; d m o dv. bio f 2 8 F. 8 0 8 (t
n h, 38 2 1 7 1 9 6 4h r 9 ) Un e o Ri c f, 9 2d 5 , 51 4 h
Ci.1 6 )
r 92.
On a a ,M r Dat n r ies s ve a a g e t ,i l ng t tt La J
ppe l . lo a s e r l r um n s ncudi ha he w udge e r d i
re n
de e ni hi r i ua fmc i lc pact a pr s nt d al ga l i ufi i nthypot tca t t
t nni ng s esd l t tona a iy nd e e e e ly ns fc e
he i l o he
voca i na e r . A fe r vi w i t r cor a c i rng t pa te a gum e s t c t
to l xpe t
tr e e ng he e d nd ons de i he ri s' r
nt , he our
f nds ç
i
s
good c e' t r m a t c e t t Com m i s o r f f r he de l e a
aus ' o e nd he as o he
s i ne or u t r ve opm nt nd

c i rton. See42U. C.j405g)
onsdeai
S.
( .

The a i sr tve r or r ve s t t M r Dat has a s c fc l r ng dia lt f
dm nitai ec d e al ha
. lon
pe ii en ni
s biiy or

whc h r c i ds e il d c t n sr ie i sho l ( . 2 , 21 8 7 8 5 . At tpt o
ih e e eve p ca e u ai e vc s n c o . Tr 8 0 8 , 2 , 6 ) se wo f
o
t esq e ta e lainpr c s,heLa J d ef t t a p an ifsla nngd sb l yç a s gj
h e u n il vau to o e s t w u g omd h t litf e r i ia ii ç u e s
t c
sgnii a f nc i lmia i 'and t r f e qua ii a a û e r ' me a i ime t r
i fc nt u tonal i t tons'
he e or
lfes s ç ve e' nt l mpar nt mde
s

t ea pl a er g lto . ( .3 ) Ad iin l a se t re o t e s q e ta p o e s t
h p i bl e u ains Tr 0 . dto al t tp h e f h e u n il r c s, he
c
y,
La J
w udge de e ne t tpli ifs me a i par ntr s t i G
t nni d ha antf
nt l m ime e uls n t
moder t d fkuli s'wih
ae il te ' t

ç o c nrto ,pesse c o p c . ( .31. Alh ug t e La J g dd n ticu e a y
s n e tain ritn e r a e' Tr ) t o h h w ud e i o n l d n
c
'
r titonsr lt d t pli tf sl n n ng dia lt i hi r i ua fl tona c ciy a s s m e t
esrc i e ae o a n if e r i
s biiy n s esd l lnc i l apa t s e s n

o t ei ta h p t tc lp e e tdt t ev c to a e p r ( . 2 6 ) tevo ain le p r
r h ni l y oheia rs n e o h o ai n l x e t Tr 3 , 8 , h c to a x e t
i
v lmtrl a d dal tto t S ns ild' r ( . 8 (I hn teh poh tc l s fn s
o t aiy d e i ain o G k l 'wo k. Tr 6 ) t t ik h y t eia bet r me
mi
u
e
(
t s de a y wor
he e nt r
k,obvi l uns le Furhe ,I s es we l atpr uci n- nt d
ousy, kild.
t r ugg t
ook
od to ode e

wo k' . Th vo ain le pett e ie tfe sv r lun k le ,sde tr j bst a c u d be
r .) e c to a x r h n d n iid e ea s ild e na y o h t o l
'
p ro me b a idv d a wih t lmiain d s rb d b t e La J d e ( .68. I
e fr d y n n ii u l t he i tto s e cie y h w u g . Tr ) n
pa tculr t voc tona e r t sii d t tt d e i loc upai na ba e'wo d i l t
ri a , he a i l xpe t e tfe ha he t sdua c to l s ' ul ncude he
r

j b o a smblr b g e/mfe,a di s e trt se . ( . 8-9 . Th La J d eulmaey
o s f se e , a g rs fr n n p co /e tr Tr 6 -6 ) e w u g t tl
i
r l do t et si n o tev aina e p r i d tr nigt a çh r aej bsi sg i a t
ei n h e tmo y f h oc to l x e tn eemi n h t ç ee r o n in fc n
e
t
n mb r i tenain l c n myt a tecama tc np ro m. ( . 6 .
u es n h to a e o o h t h li n a e fr ' Tr 3 )
'
I t c tsvi w,t difc t wih t La J
n he our' e he fi uly t he w udge' e l ton ofpl i ifsm e al
s vaua i
antf
nt
i ime i t f d. Fis ,heLa J
mpa r nt s wo-ol
rtt
w udge' o ni n a a st c r ea e a a lt t pe f m
s pi o ppe r o o r lt n biiy o ror
s m pl t ks w ih t abiiy t m a nt i c e r ton,pe s s e ,a pa . On pa 8 ofhi
i e as
t he lt o i a n onc nta i
r i t nce nd ce
ge
s

decson,t La J
ii he w udgesl rl sa e a f l :
lmma iy tt s s olows
Ast r i no al ga i ore de ofa pr blm swih s i l
he e s
le ton
vi nce
ny o e
t oc a
i e a ton,het r i d fndst tt cli ntha no difc t
nt r c i t mde sgne i ha he a ma
s
fi uly
m ant i ng s i l f to ng. Ho ve ,t unde sgne fnds
i ani oc a unci ni
we r he
ri d i
t t t m e a i nne c us mode ae difc te i
ha he
nt l mpai nt a es
rt
fi ulis n
4

m ant i ng c
i ani
once r ton, pe sse , or pa e.
nta i
r it nce
c

Thus t
, he

t e sg e fn s ta rsrcins i s d b Eh ) lanng
md ri n d id h t etito mpo e y t e e r i
d s biiy a e lm ied t i biiy t pe f m wor t t i no
i a lt r i t o na lt o ror
k ha s t
uns led i naur .
kil n t e

( . 5 . Th c u t g e swih tep an ift a t eLa J d esc ncus r a ay i c n lcs
Tr 3 ) e o r a re t h litf h t h w u g ' o l oy n lss o fit
wih t decson oft UniedSt t sCo to Appe l f t Fo ut Cic ti M as i v. vi
t he ii
he t
a e ur f
a s or he t ' r ui n
h
c o Col n,

7 0F.d6 2( t Ci. 01 ) I M aco t eFo rhCic i e pan dta Chea i t t pel m
8 3 3 4h r2 5 . n s i,h u t rut x lie h t c bl y o rbr
t
i
smp et s sdfesfo tea l yt sa o t s ' n ta G o ry telte l tto wo l
i l a k ifr r m h bit o ty n a k'a d h t t ql h atr i ain u d
i
g l
mi
a ountf a cai ntslmia i i c e r ton,pe sse e,orpa ' M a c o,78 F. a
cc
or l ma ' i t ton n onc ntai
r it nc
ce.
'
si
0 3d t
638. Thus m e e y lm ii a cam a t t kild wor wihouta f t r e a ton,i
, r l i tng li nt o ms le
k, t
ny urhe xpl na i s

i s f in u d r M a co S e ia (peh p te ALJ c n e p an Nh h a co' r d rt
n u ûce t n e s i . e l G r a s h
i
a x li v y 4 s i s no eae
lmia i i c e r ton, r it nc o pa e a se t e doe no ta lt i o alm iai n i
i t ton n onc nta i pe sse e, r c t tp hr e s t r nsa e nt i t to n
M as i sr sdua fmc i
co' e i l t tonalc pact ....Butbe us t ALJ her ga no e a ton,a
a iy
ca e he
e ve
xplna i

rma di i od r' .
e n s n r e .)
'
Forsmia r as ,t cour i as una e t c ude t tt La J
i l r e ons he
t s lo bl o oncl ha he w udge pr s nt d a
ee e
l ga l s fc e t hypot tc l t t vocai na e l W hie t Law J
e ly ufi i n
hei a o he
to l xpet
l he
udge ado e t
pt d he
vocai na e r' o ni n t tpl i ifca pe f pr uci n- re e w o k asa as e e ,
to l xpe ts pi o ha antf n ronn od to o int d r
n s mbl r
s f r o i pe t r t voc tona e r wasnota ke t c i rt sgnik a eofm ode a e
mf e , r ns c o , he ai l xpe t
s d o onsde he i t nc
rt

l tto si c n e tai n p ritnc ,o pa e i t ep ro ma c o s c j bs a1o whih
i ain n o c n rto , esse e r c n h e fr n e f u h o , 1 f c
mi
woul s e i yr quie a tnda et t s Ne rhees , heLaw J
d e m ngl e r te nc o a k. ve t l s t
udger le ont t tmony
ei d he esi

o tev c to le p r i d tnnn n t tt r aej b e itn i sg iia tn mb r i t
f h o aina x e t n ee ii g ha hee r o s x sig n infc n u es n he
nai nale no y whi h M r Dalon ca pe f m .
to
co m
c
. t
n ror

I W ake v.Bo n,8 9 F. 4 ( t Ci.1 8 ) t e Fo rh Cic i c mme td a
n lr
we 8 2d 7 4h r 9 9 , h u t rut o n e s
f l s
olow :

Thepur eofbrngi i avoc tona e r i t as itt ALJi
pos
i ng n
a i l xpe t s o ss he
n
de e mi ng whehe t r i wor ava lbl i t nai na
t r ni
t r he e s
k
ia e n he to l
e
cono ywhi ht spa tc a c aman c n pe f m. I or rf a
m
c hi riulr l i t a ror
n de or
voc tonale r' opi o t be r lva t or hel u ,i m us be
ai
xpe ts ni n o
ee n
pf l t
t
bas upon ac i r ton ofa1ot re de i t r co d, i
ed
onsde a i
1 he vi nce n he e r and t
m us be i r pons t pr pe hypot tca q s i nsw hi h f il s t
t n es
eo o r
he i l ue t o
c a ry e
outalofca ma ' i panne s
l
li nts m i nt .

I a 5 (iai n o te )
d. t 0 ctto s mitd .
l hi o ni n,t La J
n s pi o he w udge di notofe a s ct r tona e f omitng m ode a e
d
f r ny pe ik a i l or ti
rt

lm ia i i c e r ton,perit nc or pa f o t hypot tc lque ton on whi t
i ttons n onc ntai
sse e,
ce r m he
hei a
si
ch he
vocai na e r' opi onwa ba e Thec r i smpl una et co l t tt spa tc a
to l xpe ts ni
s s d.
ou t s i y bl o ncude ha hi riul r

hypot tc lque to whih wa de d of a m e a r src i ,was s fc e t a e tt
hei a
si n, c
s voi
ny nt l e titons
uf i nt o lr he
vocai na e r t t e se
to l xpe t o he xit nce of m ode a e lm iai ns i pl i ifs co e r ton,wor
r t i tto n antf
nc ntai
k
pe sse e a a t nc t t s The c tbeive t tco i r ton of s h lm i i
r it nc , nd tenda e o a k.
our le s ha nsde a i
uc i Gtons

wo l be i o tn i a s si a cama ts c p ct t p ro m te j bs ie tte b t
ud mp ra t n se sng li n ' a a iy o ef r h o d n i d y he
i
voc to le r. I e i r pons t addii na que tons t voc tona e r t tfedt t
ai na xpe t nde d,n es e o
to l si , he a i l xpe t esii ha

t o evey s mej bswo d n ln e b a ia ei t eh p t tc li dv d lwa d srce
hs r n o
ul o o g r e valbl f h y oheia n iiua s ita td
fo wo l gfra la t p r e to t ewo k a . ( . 0 .
r
'm r
dn o t e s 20 e c n f h r d y Tr 7 )
M or ve ,t Fourh Cic tha s cf ly he d t tç n ALJdoe no a 't Gora
eo r he
t r ui s pe ika l l ha ç
a
s t cc mt f
o
cai ts lmia i i c e r ton,pe sse , a pa by r srci t hypot tca
l man ' i t tons n onc nta i
r it nce nd ce
e ti tng he
he i l

q sint smp e r u iets so t ki e wo k.' M a co, 8 F.da 6 ( u tn W is h l
ueto o i l,o tn a k r ms l d r '
l
' s i 7 0 3 t 38 q o ig n c e

v Co 'o So . c, 31F.d 1 76 1 8 ( 1hCi. 01 :. Thec u t e o nie ta M a co
. mm r f c Se .6 3 7 , 1 0 1 t r 2 1
o r rc g z s h t s i
doe nots a f t pr
s
t nd or he opos to t tm oder t lm iatons i c
ii n ha
ae i t i
n once r ton,pe s s e ,orpac
nta i
r it nce
e

awa ta lt i oalmiai i acama ' rsdua fmci lc palt Rahe , si c td
l ys rnsae nt i tton n li nts e i l l tona a iy. t r a ndiae
a
bove t de ii n t r c e t La J
, he c so mde s or s he w udge' dut t e an how hi r sdualfmci na
s y o xpl i
s ei
t to l

c pa iy fnd ng a quaey a omtf a camaq ' wo k-eae lr iai . I t sc e t
a ct i i s de t l cc t or li ts r r ltd int tons n hi as , he
La J
w udged dno pr des h e a a n. Cons que l : r m a i i o d r' I
i t ovi uc xpl n io
e nty, ( e nd s n r e -' d.
a
Fo t r a ons sa ed, t c t f s G od c us ' t r m a t s c s t t
r he e s
tt
he our md G
go
a e' o e nd hi a e o he

Commisone f fl rde lpm e tan co i r ton.2 I t Co s i r i = a e t
s i r or ldhe veo n d nsde ai
f he mmisone s bl o

de i t c e i plitY sf voron t bass oft e si r c r t Co s ine wil
cde he as n nn i a
he i
he xitng e o dj he mmiso r l
$
c uc a s e ntla nitai he rng a whih boh sdeswilbe alo d t pr s n
ond t upplme a dmi srtve a i t c t i
l
l we o e e t
a to le de ean a gl nt An a o it o de ofr ma wilbee eedt sda
ddii na vi nc d r lme .
ppr prae r r e nd l
nt r hi y.
TheClr i die t dt s nd c ri dc e oft sme r ndlm o ni t a1c uns lo
ek s r ce o e e tfe opis bi mo a ' pi on o l o e f
rc r
e o d.

y f tbe, 8.
DATED; us- * da o oco r 201
Tl :4
-

Se o Unie St t sDi ti tJ
ni r t d a e s rc udge

2l lg cft c r' de so t r ma t c s t t Comm iso r t c r de i st ad e sM r
n iht he ou ts ciin o e nd he a e o he
sine, he ou t olne o drs .
Dat j rmqnngcamgofer .
lon s e ii ' i
l
ror
'

7