Wilcox v. Lyons et al

Filing 32

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 4/25/2018. (ck)

CL S OFFI U,S. SX COURT
ERK'
CE
DI
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

I TH E UN I
N
TED STAT ES D ISTRI CO U RT
CT
FO R TH E W E STE RN D I RI OF W R GI M
ST CT
N
ROAN O U D I SI N
W O

AFR 2 5 1
8
JUL c

BY;

, cj
Ex

,
,

, - - .
RK

CO LETTE M .W I
LCOX ,
Pl ntfy
ai if

Cas N o.7: 7- 000530
e
1 cv-

N ATI AN H .
I
LYON S, Q .p pky
ES ,. l

By:M i ha l Ur nsd
c e F. ba l
Cli fUnie St t sDit t udge
le
t d a e sdc J

D ef
endant
s.

>

M O M N D U M O PI I N
N O

Pli fCoet M . i o f dt se o me a éo p s a t 4 U.. j
anéf lte W l x ie hi mply nt c n uru nt o 2 SC.
c
1983,al i vi a
l ng oldonsofhe Equa Pt e éon rght unde t Foutee h Am endm e t
eg
z
l ot c
i s
t he
t nt
nt o

t Unied St e Consiudon.D ef nda sm ove t din isW icox' c m s The c t
he t at s
tt
e nt
d o s as l s bi .
our

hed ahe rngon defnda s moéonst dimisonM ach22,2018. f l ng da i
l
ai
e nt'
o s s
t
The olowi y,t

e e e a o d rdimisn wih p eudc Wic x' c/msa nn tCa r l u ya wela
ntr d n r e s sig t r j ie lo s li g i s rolCo nt s l s

he h lewoke vt me csm ( un 11 a ans d fnda t Naha H. o , q.
r os
r n ion nt li Co t 1) g i t ee ns t n Ly ns Es
a PhlpC. tee Es Th c ur ds se Wic ' sxdsrmi to ( ntI,
nd ii Sel, q. e o t imisd loxs e ici nain Cou )
l
ztl éo ( untI)a d prvainofl ryi eet( nt1 cnmswih utp eucc
eai n Co I nd e i to i t ntr s Cou / li to zj l e
a
be
i
a g vehe la t a nd Thesaelw b te ycnm a is de e a S e l ( u V)
nd a r e ve o me .
tt a atr ll gan t f nd nt t ee Co nt
savi d t m odon t dinas .
t ve he
o s is

W icox now m ovest am e he com pli a f r onsde adon oft cout '
l
o
nd r
ant nd oz ec i t
he
ts
ot rasr ga dsCountI ,a lg ng r t la
de
e t
1 le i e aidon.Shes eksl a t a end he c
e
e ve o m
r ompl ntt
ai o
a s r adci
s e t ldona algatonss
l le i
uppor he c lm f de i i oflbe t i e es, ch t
dng r l i or prvaton i ry nt z t whi he

c r ata ykz ntdi isMa c 2 o d t t r a s r h zbatr cnm, nd t r a s r he
ou t le d a e n t r h 3 r e , o e se t e te y li a o e set r

z t la
e aidon cnm wihq a e ng t r lva f tzlalgatons The pr
li t ut m ndi he e e nt acaa le i .
opos d am e
e
nded
com pli doe noti l a com f s x dic i i ton.
ant s
ncude li or e s rm na i
Asr gar t r t la
e ds he e ai don c m , icox as t c tt r onsde isM a c 23
bi W l
ks he our o ec i r t z h

txi a gui s hasalged acnm f r lefs fc e t s vi acha lngeput ua t
nlng, t ng he
le
li or ei ufii nt o ut ve
le
s nt o

Rul 1 $()o teFe rl e ofCiiPr c d e Wic post ti he bu d no
e 2q 6 f h dea Ruls vl o e ut. lox is h t r r e f
esabls ng aptm af i c e ofr t ladon a t ssa i notone ous a he ale don of
t ihi
i ace as
e ai
t hi t ge s
r , nd r lga

t por lpr m iy aone i e
em a ovi t l s nough t esabls aca a conne i bet n t pr e t
o t ih
uà l
cton wee he ot c ed
a t a t a z ee pl enta
céviy nd he dve s m oym
céon a t r or s a eava i c nm f z t ia
nd he ef e t t
ld l i oz e aidon.
The cour dia re sa a s h, l GR AN T i pa ta D EN Y i par W icox' m oéon
t s g e nd, s uc wil
n r nd
n
t l s
t a e a D EN Y he m odon f r c i t don.
o m nd nd
r
ot e oqsde a
1.

Purua t Rue5 $,hec u tla t epo e t zc nsd ta modf is
s nt o l 49 t o z as h w t o e o ie nd iy t
i e l ut y or t t tt s ve f we t al c m sf ta tm e bef e t e t ofa
nt roc or de s ha e ol e t han l bi f ny i
a
or he nty

j g nta j iaigalh c msa alt pade'ihta la ite . Fe R. v.
ud me dudc tn lte bi nd l he r s rg nd iblis' d. Ci P.
i '

5 $9 Ca eAs' v.
4q Am. no sn M

hr r I c, 2 F.d5 5 5 4 1 (t Ci. 0 3.
Fams n .3 6 3 0 , 1 - 5 4h t2 0 )

Ac o cngy Tg o
c rl l,f donsf rr c i z do of n e lc t yo d r a eno s jc t t e
i
ml
o e onsdea n i tro u or r e s t t ub e t o h

sdc sa ad a ia et mo sf zrc nsd réono af lud me . Am. no
t t tnd r s ppl bl o don o e o iea
c
f ma j g nt'
' Ca e
As' 3 6F.da 5 4 Atpantf' rq s,h c t wi rve ispto tl i l to
sn, 2 3 t 1 . li ifs e uttte ou t l e iw t ir' i n kh f
l
u ng
t a gum e s z ies
he r
nt he as .

I
1.
Pl i fpr s est the m tla i c lm al i ad r eac
anéf e um ha r a iton l i legng ve s don on a ountofhe
cc
r

c mpli ofdsrmi to i a to bl und tj1 8 a avoléonoft Eq l otc n
o ant ici nain s cina e e 9 3 s i a
he ua Pt e éo
Clus oft Foutee h Am endm e - butt tf c i f tfom c t an.W hie t Fourh
a e he
t nt
nt
ha a t s a r
e ti
l he
t

Cic tnHode v. t o Raeg 8 7F.d8 3, 2 (t Ci. 9 9, edsaee ly e
tuii l r Ciy f lih, 6 2 2 8 8 4h r 1 8 ) h l tt mpo e s
c l b i gFo te hAme me c aln e u e j1 8 t ds rmi t z e l y nt
oud rn ure nt
nd nt h l g s nd r 9 3 o ic i nao y mp o me
e
decsons r t rt r li e l i l on Til V I ,H ol rdoesnots k s c fc ly t
ii , a he han ey ng xcusvey
te I
de
pea pe ii al o
r a idon cnm s Te yeuslt r t Fourh Cic ta es ed r t la
etla
li . n
a e , he
t r ui ddt s e aiéon cnm si t
li n he

c n e tofj1 8 a sae Ed r v. ofGo ds r t ta2 zeo ge rc
o tx
9 3 nd tt d wa ds C#
l bo o ha : r z nei
pt
m t la i cnm ...sm pl doe noti plc t t Equa Pr e ton Clùs . 178 F. 231,
aiton li
i y s
m ia e he
l ot c i
a e'
?
3d

2 0(t Ci. 9 99 e as Matnv. f, 5 F.d2 9(t Ci. 01 )Soli pan fs
5 4h r 1 9 ) se lo ri Dufy 8 8 3 3 4h t2 7 dng lidf?
equa pz e ton cl m w a be tc t t rz asa r wor ng ofli Fis Am e e
l ot c i li
s s ha ac e i ed
e di
's t t
l
ndm nt
ê aiton c nm a i s h c r um s a es ge zcr t la cni sdo noti plcae t
et la i l i nd,n uc ic t nc , ne i e ai éon l m
m i t he

Eq a Pt tc on Clus , i ngEd r ) Dititc u t ha snc t l donEd t i
u l oe d
a e cé
wads. src o rs ve i e ei
e
wa ds n
hol ng t Fot h Cic tdoe notr c i egenercz t i t c nm sba ed on equa
di he ut t ui
s
e opaz
i e ala bn l i
s
l

p otci Se e .Phl sv. be 3 7F. u p. d 8 1 8 1( D. C. 0 5;oh o v.
r eton. e . , il Ma , 6 S p 2 6 , 7 M. N. 2 0 )J ns n
i
Sc t Cnt . c Bd, 2:2 v0 01 , 01 WL 4 8 5 , t*( D. . uy3 , 01 )
o t y S h. .No. 1 c 0 0 2 2
45 1 0 a W. Va J l 1 2 2
ga sJ) l ta c gt ha ef ndr tl éon cnmsa emo epr pel alg d u e t
me , .. nse d, ot s v ou eai
a
li t r o ry le e nd r he
cons uton' Fis Am e e pr e dons Se e. .W hiev.G ason Count Boar of
ét i s rt
ndm nt ot c
. e
t
t
y
d

Ed abn, 31 -v- 0 5 , .7WL 2 1 , t* ( D. C. a 1 , 01 )(e aido
uc t No. :6 c 0 5 2 20
1
20 34 a 3 W. N. J n. 8 2 7 z tl n
a

cam p o ryasze un tj1 8 a voluo ofFis Ame me trte t n
li z pel setd àe 9 3 s i a n
rt nd n, ah rha
Fot e nt Ame dme ) I o v. y r& C# Cou iBat r Ciy No. 1 - 7 1 8 ,
ute h
n nt;c x Ma o
ncl lmo e t, J0 1 - 3 4
i
2 7WL 5 0 7 ( Md. v. 9 2 7 (i ngEd r sa h dngr tl ùoncnm not
01
9 3 09 D. No 2 , 01 ) cd
wa d nd oli e ai
a li
v oa n o rg t e a pr tc in, ahe i fi ce ry e tbls d a a ts a n met iht
i léo f iht o qu l o e to zt z t fs la l sa ihe s frt med n rg
f

and asa sauty rghtunde Til V I ;butno ce ry e t bls d rghte s sunde t e a
tt o i
r te l
la l s a ihe i xit ' r he qu l

Jr/r/zca et befe fo z tl éo n W ic x a s tsno Fis Ame me cnm of
t:' ; lus o r e t m eai n.). lo s et
//
b
a
rt nd nt li
r t la
e aiéon he e.
t

The c ltnot st a las onect ui hasr ce c nge issa on t sis
olr
e hat t e t
ic t
e ndy ha d t tnce
hi s ue.
l Ve av.H e sea U ni Fr e Sc
n
m t d
on e hoolD iti ,t Se
srct he cond Ciczta
r li ckno ldged t
we
he
ff

c nsd r b ec nf so sur un n t v a it ofrtla n cnmsu e j1 37a d
o i e a l o u i n t o dig he ibl y eaido li nd r 98 : n
i

ca i t f e aitoh c m sal g ng a a r e a éon bec us ofa c pl i of
lrhed hat r t la i bi le i n dve s c
r
a e
om ant

d s tmia on a ea éo bl un rj1 8 7algngav oai oft eEq a Pr tci
ic i n é z c na e de 9 37 l i i lt
e
on h u l o e t
on
Clus . 01F.d 7 , 0 (d Ci. 1 ) TheS c nd Cic i r a o dt ta e o è '
a e 8 3 2 8 2 t 20 5 .
eo
t ut e s ne ha n mply rs
r tl t r a to i r s et a e l y espltcpa i i ad s rmi éo i ska n
eai o y c in n e pons o n mp o e ' tii ton n ici na n t t do
a
we
a pr eelngsc ttzed a i r isbl r as t te ta em pl e dif r l f
nd oc ci onsitt n mpe nas i e e on o r a n
oye f e enty or

pur esoft Equa Pz e
pos
he
l otcdon Clus J za 81 82.Thecour fut rr make t t
a e... t d
t t he e r d ha
r t la i i a f m ofdic i i don and,asi ha r
e aiton s or
s rm na
t s ecogr'e t ta equa pr ec i c m
uz d ha n
l ot ton bi

pa alesaTil V I c m , tf
r ll
te I bi i ound no good t s t de at fom t sprncpl f
ea on o vi e r hi i i e or
z t la
e aiéon com s w hen t t t la or a
li ,
he e ai t y cdon i t ken be us apli fc pli ofot
sa
ca e anéf om ans
oppos sdic i i
e s tm nadon.I a 8
d. t 2.
I i unce whe he t Fourh Cic twoul adoptt r s ng oft Se
t s lar
t r he
t r ui
d
he ea oni
he cond

Cicztt Ve aa f ar tl d cnm b o g pu s n t j1 8 a t Eq l
rtii g nd i eai on li ê u ht rua t o 9 3 nd he ua
z
nd
a
Pr ec
ot éon Clus i vi bl .Thecout ne notr ac t is howe t asW icox ha
a es a e
t ed
e h hat s ue,
ve ,
l
s

f ld t sa e aprm a f c eca e f r t la i unde t Til V I fa e k,e n as lm i
aie o t t
i a i s ot e ai ton
r he te I r m wor ve sl ng
ii a
t s pphc bl he e
a e t.

4

1 1.
1

Toetbihaprmafcec s ofrtl to Wic mus s w:i fha gh j
sa ls
i a i ae eai in, lox t ho ( ç t s e
a
)t

e g g di p oe tda t ty @ rha (e e l e)toka ves 'cina ans t z,
n a e n t tce ci y ' f t h t mpoy t o d tea to g i thel'
vi
t
'
a dti Tha acuslea ns i e se be ent p otce ad t a t a v re
n ii f t a a rldo hp xitd > e he r etd c viy nd he d es
)t

e ly n a d t. Fo trv. v. Ma lndE. hoe 7 7F.d2 3 25 ( hCi.
mpo me t c viy' se Uni of
'
a - S r, 8 3 4 , 0 4i t
,

'

.

.

'

'

20 5 . c t h l t tWic x fi dt s dsyt t r c us do ee nta g vehe
1 ) The ou t ed ha lo al o a f he hid a a n lme nd a z
e
la t a>e l he modon f z onsdé a
e ve o nd. n r
or ed i t don,W ic ague s nee nota nd,a
lox r s he d
me s
he a lga ast t m por lpr m iyi a one s fcentt s a eaprm a f c ec e f
r le éon o e
a oxi t s l
ufi i o t t
i a i as oz
r t la
e aidon.

W icox' alga i pli y s f t fr ta s c
l s le tons anl adsy he ls nd e ond ee e sofa r aiton c m .
lm nt
et la i bi
She algess e ge i pr ec e a t by com pli ng aboutt ale d dic i i don
le
he nga d n ot t d cdviy
nni
he lge s rm na

a hos ewor e t e a t s s f r adve s .m pl e a éon a ar s t
nd dl
k nvionm nt nd.hat he uf e ed
r ee oym nt c
s e ul.
A m .Com pl,ECF N o. 1 a ! ( 2 9 Asz g t t ec us li , lo f eish a l
.
26 , t ( 9 , 4. e ads l a a l Wic x f l e vi
j
l
nk
re
y
,

-

o tmporl o i t - t t -nd-- l mo h tmes n be we n he No mbe 3 ,
n e a pr xmif7 he vo a ahaf nt i pa t e r ve r 0
2015pr e e a éviy'nd he Febrz r 1 2016 t t i
ot ct d c t a
r
ta y 7,
evn nadon. ot t Rec i r ECF
M .o
onsde ,
N o.25,a 4t 5.

f he c est ta ce m e et m por lpz m iybe we a e pl rsknowl dge of
f
x' as ha c pt t e
a oxi t t en n m oye '
e
pr ec e a i t a a a r e e pl e a
ot t d ctviy nd n dve s m oym nt cdon a s fce e denceofca a iy t
s uf int vi
us lt o
esa ih aprrm f ce c e unior l hol t tt t m pot lpr m iy m us be f r
t bls
ir a i as
f nay d ha he e
a oxi t
t ve y

co ej'Clt C . c Ditv. e d n 5 2U. 26 , 7 (00 )(iainso te ) O e
l s g' ak
'
S h. s. Br e e , 3 S. 8 2 3 2 1 ctto mitd .
t ei no rbrghtt m por llne, c e1w f om t Four h Cic ts
her s r i e
a i ' as a t
'
he
t t ui uggesst tt a a
t ha wo- nd- hafm ont be we n t pr e ed ac t and t a r ea bn i t l t esa ih
l
hs t e he ot ct
éviy
he dve s ct s oo ong o t bls

c ustonbytmpoa pt i t aone S eI v. msed, 2 F.d1 , 5 n. ( h
a ai
e tl oxmiy l . e Gn Ru fl 3 8 3 45 1 1 5 4t
Ci. 0 )twomonhsa t weksçufiint lngs a t we k n sg i nt t
t2 03 t
t nd wo e f fce l o o s o à e ini l he
s
y
ka y
i e e eo c us to bewe n t t e nt? Ho nev. z ikFe e & Sl r n, 5
nfr nc f a a in t e he wo ve s); r Re nc dd z i ma 1 4
ve

F. x3 , 6 ( . Ci. 0 )socigdstc c r ddno eri g a i s mmay
App' 61 3 4 4t t2 05 ll itit ou t i t r n tnt u r
h
n
ng
j g ntnd fnd ntsfvo o rtl éo c m, spanuf' o ye i nc ofc u a n
ud me i ee a ' a r n eai n bi a li fs nl yde e a sdo
a
wa t ts ewa ftdt monhsatrdsrnia nc lit cén 1 1$9seas
s ha h s te wo t fe ician do ompnn, i g 11 e lo
1
:
. I

'

.

'

Pe v. os48 F. p' 6 7, 4 (t Ci. 1 )Sodngtremo hlps tol g
r Ka , 9 Ap x 3 6 3 4h r20 2 li h e nt a e o on
t etblhc usdon, t ut t)Pac l Lo 'HomeCts,nc, 9 F. x2 9
o sa i a a wiho mo e; sua v. wes
s
t.I .1 3 App' 2 ,
23 (t Ci. 0 6 (h e t furmo hspaa nbewentr naina dcnme
3 4h t2 0 ) tr e o o
nt e réo t e emi to n li d
pr tce a t iyt lngt e tbih ac uslc ne éo b t mpo a p o i t aone;
o e t d ci t oo o o sa ls a a on c n y e r l r xmi l )
v
y

W i o v Ci ofGat rb . ,1 F. p 3 4 ,4 50 . d 20 5 q ps ofmo et n
ln .
s
ihesur 21 Su p. d 78 8 M . 1 ) a e
r ha
t eem ont t l ape i t esa ih aça a r l tons p on tm por pr m iy
hr
hs po ong
zod o tbls
us l e ai hi
e
al oxi t

aon )g.Fo trv. v. Md.78 F.d2 3 2 7( . Ci. 01 )(o li sof
l e; - se Uni of , 7 3 4 , 4 4t r 2 5 c mpant
f
h
dsrmiai o mo hpro t trni éo s hce t cet aj yq e d tg r i
ici n t ne nt ir o er na n uf int o rae ur u s on e adng
on
c us éo p o ofp i fcec s ll n i v. yo dEntranme Co.8 0 F. u 2
a a n r ng zma a i a ei e kns Ga lt e ti nt , 4 S pp. d
8 3 8 ( Md. 0 2 (wo da s n bewe n op ii a tvt a s pe i n wa f r
7 , 81 D. 2 1 ) t - y pa t e poston c iiy nd us nso s f y
ve
cos 'a s âce tt saeac nz b ec u ai n clml
l e' nd uf in o tt og ia l a s to li .
W icox ct ss ve a ca esfom t Fotr h Ciczti s
l
ie e t l s r he zt t ti n uppor ofherposton t tt
t
ii ha he
t a a ha fm ont dm elps i s fcentt esa ih a c us llnk and s a ea ptm a f i
woc nd- - l
h
a e s ufii o t bls
a a i
tt
i ace
c e ofr t ladon.SeeM ot t Rec i r ECF N o. a 4- Two oft s ca èsdo not
as
e ai
.o
onsde ,
25, t 5.
he e s

hep t pli f I Pe e v. c owelCounl Boar ofEduca
l he andf. n nly M D
l
d
éon,8 F. 646,656
76 3d

( hCi. 01 ) t eFou t Ciczth l fstncngaon , no e g ( p otce s e c )
4t r 2 7 , h
rh rti ed f la l l e k wld e of r e t d p e h
g i
6

eg tt nnemo hspro go a ve s a do li no T r co e 'a wa t o d sa t t ie
ih o i
nt i t t d t e c n s t vey l s y' nd s o itnt o as
an i et nc ofc a
nf e e
aus don.
Anot tc e ct d by W ic Ptc v.Thom s , i a f iut -ohe as ie
lox, i e
on s al e t

hie c e. r ,t Fourh Ciczthed pl i ifha e t bls d aprm a f i c e of
r as The e he
t t ti l antf d s a ihe
i ace às
,

'

r t la
e aidon be us ar as
ca e e onabl tiroff tc d concude t def nda kne phi f
e te
ac oul
l
hat e nt w
néf

had e ge i pz e t ac t a deci d t hiehi a t & s a l bl opporaniy.
nga d n ot c ed éviy nd lne o t m t he t vaia e
tz t

3 0F.d 2 9 21 (t Ci. 0 4 . ihe oft e ec s si o po n .
8 3 0 , 3 4 h t 2 0 ) Net t h s a e s n i t
W i oxz l sp i rl onW iimsv. z r nis 8 1F.d 45 (t Ci. 9 9 a
l ei rmai
c
e
y
la
l
Cebe o c , 7 2 2 4 h r 1 8 ) nd

1 r v. n fl, 28F.d 1 ( hCi. 0 3,7 t of c aefc l ds gus be
Q, Rl ed 3 3 45 4t r 2 0 ) 10h whih z a mal idn iha l.
1
ms
y
I W ila s t c uthed t tpli fhad fs ds id t l sone ousbut n ofm aki a
n lim , he ot
l ha a néf
da fe he es
r
de
ng

prm af i c s ofc us ly 'butuli a ey det t i d t e denc di nots
i ace a e a ai '
tm t l e m ne he vi e d
uppor t
t he
i e encet tt pr
nfr
ha he obabl f f ' m oéve be nd W ilam s dic r wa r aiéon.1
e f or:
but
hi
li ' s ha ge s et la
d.
a 457,459. ila sfl d adic i i ton com pli on N ove be 4.Shewa pl c on
t
W lim .te
s rm na i
ant
m r
s a ed

p o d o a uay6 bu he s r iorwa no a r oft d srmi do c t a t
r ba on nl n r , t r upe vs
s t wa e he ic i na n hage t he
tm ehem a t decson.L .a 454.By t tm e s wa t r i e on Fe ' r 22,he
i
de hat ii ds t
he i he s e m nat d
bt y
ua
r
s r i or we ea e oft dic i i éon c r Alhough i i uncea whe W ilam s
upe v s s r wat
he s rm na
ha ge. t
ts l t
n li '

s r or be m e a e oft dic i i don c pl i ,t tm es bet n t
upe ds s ca wat
he s rm na
om ant he i pan wee he
pt ec e a i t a t a r e a éon wass e r a ound sxw e ks l st n t
ot t d ctviy nd he dve s c
om whe e t
i e - es ha he
tvo a ahafm ont a i s i t i tntc e
v nd
l
hs t s ue n he nsa as .

Thepli fi I ng,a t a he f t D e t e ofD ef ns D e ndentSchool,
andf n û
e c r or he pntm nt
e e pe
s
wa f t m ont a t wee afe hi s rozwasnot e t tI ng ha fld a
s red wo
hs nd wo
ks t z s upe i
o d ha o
d te n
.

EEO com pli .
ant The Fourh Cicztsa ed i a f not t tt sl ngt oftm e T s
t r li t t n oot e ha hi e h i f
i
s fce l l s ast we ke sg hca l t i e e e ofc us don be we n t t o
ufi inty ong o o a n i ni nty he nf r nc
a a
t e he v

e nt.'328 F. a 151 n. N e rhees ,t cout w e on t hol t l ng ha m a
ve s'
3d t
5. ve t l s he
t nt o d hat vi
d de
outaptm af i c e oft ai don.
i ace as
etla
The c ute aned:
ot xpli
Ye ,i t c e oft spa éctlr e pl e sm a i t s
t n he ont xt hi t za m oym nt i ton, hi
l h of tm e does not unde c t i er
engt
i
'
r ut he nf ence of c a
aus éon
enough t z nde I ng' ptm a f c e com uns c s u .H e e
o e r fi s i a i li
uc es f l t ,

N n s s pei rj c mmit d t o ong rviws of I g'
g' u ro s o te o ng i e e
in s
pe f - a e t s tt e oft a ade i s hoolye rast
r ol nc hat e he nd he c nnc c
m
a
he
nat a decson poi , t m a ng hkel t t a dichat ,
ar l ii
nt hus ki
y ha ny s ge
lwfz orunlwfz,woul c eatt tm e
a t
l
a t
l
d om
hat i .

L I i cea i I ngt tt Fouth Cicztsdeemi tont tat a ahafmont
da t s l t n fi ha he
y t ti' tt nai ha wo-nd- - l
h
tm el ps ga rs t a s hc e i er nceofca a gi t f ct oft pa éc ar
i a e ve ie o uf i nt nf e
us éon ven he a s hat r ul
ca e whet t nat a de ii poi wa t end oft ac de i yea . r i no
s,
e he ur l cson nt s he
he a nlc r The e s

com prabl de ii poi i t i t ca e.
e c son nt n he nsant s
l s t t ca e1w ct d by W ic gi st cot tno r as t r onsde ispdor
n hor, he s a ie
lox ve he u:
e on o ec i r t
rui a t herr t la i clm . nsca edoesnotiw ol t ki off r c os ' èm e
lng s o
e aiton li Tli s
t ve he nd f y l e' i
ve
s n be we n pr e ed a dviyand ad r e ac
pa t e ot ct c t
ve s don t tgve rs t a i e e e of
ha i s ie o n nf r nc
c us éon a e t bls a prm a f i c e ofz a iton.Tl ca e whe eTe por l
a a
nd s a ihes i ace as
etla i fn s s
r tm
a
pr m iy bet n pr ec e a i t a algedl r t la or c
oxi t
wee ot t d ctviy nd le y e ait y onduc i r s i cour sm a
t s nisng,
t y
l t t i e e ng pe i f ot re de e ofz t la ol a m ysr Le de iv.E uant
ook o he nt rv ni
rod oz he vi nc
e ait y ni .' t r

I .47 F.d6 0 65 ( h Ci. 0 7. r i nos hztl tr a i alge i t
nc, 8 3 4 , 0 4t r2 0 ) Thee s uc eai o y nmus l d n he
a
e
i t ntc e.
nsa as The onl ot talgadon W icox a nc si s
y he le
l
dva e n uppor ofhe r t la
t
r e aiéon csm i
li s

t a c wot e sFet a o sd sa e t m sl sfo he i De e r2 5 S e Am .
h t o- k r ls ndl ne itnc d he eve r m r n c mbe 01 . e

Co .ECF No. 6 1 a 41 Asnet rFet no l e wa t dè ii ma e h r ,hi
mpl
,
2 -,t .
ihe ls r on s s he cson k t e e t s
alga i sm pl notpr dveofr ait yani us
le don s i y
oba
et la or m .

8

IT
AFort er as ,t cout wtlD EN Y W ic sm odon f r c i r don ofis
hes e ons he
t *
l
lox'
or e onsde a
t

prordim is lofhe r aiéon cli .
i s sa
z et la
am The c twilG RAN T i par W icox' m oton t
our t
n t l s i o
'

.

a e a diectt Clr t fl t pz
m nd nd r he e k o le he opos d a e d c pl i on t doc .
e m nde om ant he ket

H owe r bec us W ic ci nota e he c nm f r t la
ve , a e lox ld
m nd z l i or e aiéon,Countloft pr
he opos
ed

a nd dc mpli wil DI M I ED p s a t Rue1 $()oft Fe rl isof
me e o ant lbe S SS
uru nt o l 24 6 he dea Rue
Ci lPr e e,c it ntwih t cout' M a c 23, 8 mxi
vi oc duz onsse
t he
ts z h
201 lng.

An a opra e Or twilbe e e ed.
ppr i t de l
nt t

s s s o t z -as/:
xv u o, y
'
6
2
1
p
.
1
e... '' y .y .
qzrw .
. :
w .z
r
.z.
:
,

M iha lF.Uz ns '
c e
ba

ClifUntd7ttsVitit ud e
le ie ae jtc l g

9