Campbell v. Ratledge

Filing 2

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 12/14/2017. (tvt)

CLERK' OFFI U. DI COURT
S
CE S. SX
AT Or.NOKE,
nI
t
VA
. r! .
!r
àp

DEC 1i 2 1
27
IN TI E U NITED STA TES D I
I
STR I C OU RT
CT
FO R TI W ESTERN D I
IE
STRICT O F VG GINIA
R OA N OK E DIW SION
JA M E S A NDR EW CAM PBELL ,
Pettoner,
ii

C.M TLED GE ,W ARD EN ,
Respondent
.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

J .w.- L
ULI '' 0
' '

cAs No. :7 0 ?0
E
7 1 CV0 5
M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI
By:Hon. enE.
Gl
Conr
ad
Se orUnie St e DititJudge
ni
td ats src

J mes Andr w Ca pbe l a i a e a t Unied St t s Pe t n i r i Le Cou y,
a
e
m l, n nm t t he
t
a e nie ta y n e
nt
V igi a f l d t s ac i pr s a a pe ii n f a w rt of ha s c pus un r 28 U . C.
r ni , iè hi ton, o e, s
tto or
i
bea or
de
S.

j22 Ca
41. mpbel alge t thes dber e e e b a ehi fd r ci na s ne e
l le s ha
houl
esntnc d, ec us s e eal rmi l e tnc
unde t Ca e rOf e rg d i i unlw f u rM a hi v. t d St t s U . ,1 S.
r he r e f nde ui elne s a ul nde
t s Unie a e ,
S. 36

Ct 2243 ( 6) J on v.Unie Stts U. ,1 S.Ct 25 ( 5) a Be klsv.
. ,201 , ohns
td ae , S. 35
. 51 201 , nd c e
S.
Unie Stt s U .
t d ae ,
-

-

,

1 S.Ct 886( 7 .Uponrviw o t rc d,hec tc nclde
37
. 201 )
e e f he e or t our o u s

ta Ca
h t mpbelha no c nia ecli frrlefund j22 i t sc q b hi pla ngi
l s og z bl am o ei
er 41 n hi our ut s e di s
a o i t l c ns r d a a m o i t vac t ,s ta i o c r e tt s nt nc unde 28 U . C.
ppr pr a e y o t ue s
ton o a e e s de r o r c he e e e
r
S.

j2255a ta fre t t s ne i c ur.
nd rnserd o he e tncng o t

Ca el' peii a c r rc dsa ia eo i i c t t taj y i t Unie
mpb ls tton nd ou t e or valbl nlne ndiae ha ur n he td
St t s D iti t Cou tf t M i e Dit i t o Fl r d f nd Ca pbe l gui y of di ti i
a e src
r or he ddl s rc f o i a ou
m l l
t
srbutng,
pos e s ng, a m a ac urng na c i s The Cour s nt nc d Ca pbe l t 3 m on hs i
s si
nd nuf t i
r otc .
t e e e
m l o 60
t n
prs on Co One w ih c ur e t t r s o 240 m o hs on Cou s Tw o a Th e The
ion
unt
, t onc r n e m f
nt
nt
nd r e.

j
udgme was atr d on a a,a Ca l' j2255 moi i t til c twa
nt
fsmé
ppe l nd mpbels
ton n he ra our s
uns c sf .Assae Campbel peii t sc tund rj2241f ha ea c pusrle
uc e sul
ttd,
lnow ttons hi our e
or b s or eif
un rt M a hi . oh on, nd Be kl s de i i ns s e n t be r s n e e Ca pbe lb i ve
de he t s . ns a
l
c e c s o , e ki g o' e e t nc d. m l ele s
t hi s ence i uncons i tonalbecause a prorconvi i f bater of a l e or ent
hat s ent
s
tm i
i
cton or t y
aw nf cem
kx

C RK

ofi e t tw a us d t e nc t s nt nc a l ge y no l rq ii s a a p e ca e o f ns
fc r ha s e o nha e he e e e le dl
onge ualfe s r di t f e e
undert Car Of endergui i
he eer f
delne.
A s such,Campbel' cl m chale
ls ai
lnges t l iy of hi f al s ence as i
he egalt
s eder ent
mposed.

Suc cl msmus nomal beriedona a ori aj2255moto i t sne i c t J
h ai
t r l as
y
ppe l n
in n he e tncng our. .
q

r J s 226F.d 3 ,3 ( h Ci.2000 . Ca l' j22 peiin rii s h cai i
e one ,
3 28 32 4t r
) mpbels 41 tto asng uc l ms s
ba r d u es i m e t t s rnge tsan r m a a e und rt I r J ne de i i 1 a 333r e nl s t e s he t i n t da d nd t d e he n e o s c s on. d. t

3 (i n t tc le t fdealc ci i b rd fom rviw un r j2241a e a
4 fndig ha halnge o e r onviton s are r e e de
bsnt
s
howi t tunde a pos- onvi ton c nge i t l w , ttone ' of e e c nduc i no l e
ng ha
r
tc c i ha
n he a pe ii r s f ns o
t s ong r

ci na) Be a e non oft de so on whih Ca el r is ha a efc on t
rmi l. c us
e he ciins
c mpb l ele d ny fe t he
ci naiy ofhi fdealofe e con t he c nno prc e wih hi cam unde j 2241
rmi lt
s e r fns
duc, a t o e d t s li
r
.
Theeoe,t c r wilde r ifunde j22 ,c nsreCa
rfr he ou t l ny ele
r 41 o tu mpbelss bmiso a aj2255
l' u s in s
m o i an t a f r i t t Unie St t s D it it Co t f r t M i e D iti t o Fl i a,
ton, d r ns e t o he
t d a e sr c ur o he ddl sr c f ord
Ta pa D i son,f f rhe pr e di s a w a r nt d. The Cl r i die t t s nd c e of
m
vi i or u t r oc e ng s r a e
e k s r c ed o e opi s
t s mem o a
hi
r ndum o ni a t e a o pa ng o de t Ca pbe l
pi on nd h cc m nyi r r o m l.
EN TER : Thi
s

day ofDecem ber 2017.
,

Se orU nie St t sD it itJ
ni
t d a e sr c udge

2