Wilkerson v. Walrath et al
Filing
12
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Glen E. Conrad on 2/9/2018. (slt)
CL
ERK:OFFI U, . ST.
CQ : DI COUR'
ATROANOKE,
VA
FI ED
L
FEB 2! 2 1
22
IN TH E U NITED STATES' I
D STRICT CO UR T
FO R TH E W ESTER N DISTRICT O F W RG I I
N A
R OAN O K E D I SIO N
W
D ON TA Z LA TR AY M QLK ER SO N ,
JUL C.
DUD
BY:
7Y
,C P'
F h
f
CA SE N O .7:
17CV00562
Pl ntf ,
ai if
V.
M EM O R ANDU M O PI N
NIO
JOHN E.W M Z TH, K ,
M
c
By:Hon.GlnE.Conra
e
d
Se orU pie St e D it i tJudgq
ni
t d at s s r c
Defnda t)
e nts.
D on a La r y W ike s n,a V igi a i m a e pr c edi g pr K ,br ugh t s c vi rgh s
t z ta
l ro
r ni n t o e n o
o t hi i l i f
a to u d r4 U. C.j1 8 ,algn ta ofcasa Rie No t Co rcin lCe trh v
cin n e 2 S. 9 3 le ig h t fiil t v r ri re t a ne a e
l
o
unconstt i l r t i ed hi t noncont vi iaton f tve year a har her puni ent
iutonaly es rct
m o
act st i or i
s,
s
shm
t n t y ha i e on ot rsmial st td i t . Among ot rde nbsf rle,
ha he ve mposd
he i lry iuae nmaes
he ma or eif
W ikes nha move fratmporr r sr ni orgra aprlmi r ij to t rganhi
l ro s
d o e ay etai ng d nd ei nay nuncin o e i s
c t c vi ia i n prvie s whie t s l w s ti pe n A fe r vi w o t r c d,t c r
on a t st to i l ge
l hi a ui s ndi g. t r e e f he e or he ou t
c l st tt es m otonsm us be de e
onc ude ha h e i
t
ni d.
Thepa t se ng apr i nay ij tonmus ma ace rs ngRha hei lkel
ry e ki
elmi r nunci
t ke la howi t t s i y
t s cc e o t e m e is t a he i lke y t s f rir pa a e ha m i t a e e ofpr i i r
o u ed n h
rt , h t s i l o uf e r e r bl r n he bs nc
elm na y
rlef t tt balnc ofe testps i hi fvo,a t ta ij ton i i t publc
ei , ha he a e quii i n s a r nd ha n nunci s n he i
'
nt
i ees.1 W i er v NaurlRe .De.Councl I ,5 U. 7,20 ( ) The pa t s
ntr t'
ta s f
i. nc. 55 S.
2008 .
ry'
'
.
pl q ng mus s ts y a l ourf t r o t W i e sa r t wa r nts h r i f I a 20.
e di
t a if 1 f ac o s f he nt r t nda d o r a uc ele . d. t
TheEqua Pr e tonClus oft Foure nhAme me de lrsta tl oStt s l
l otci a e he te t
nd nt cae h t çnl ae hal
. . .
de yt a pes ...hee ual otci oft lws'U. Cons-a nd. V,j1 Thi
n o ny ron t q pr e ton he a - S. t, me XI
'
. s
1 W ikes alo r quet a tmporr r sr ni or r Te r r r tai ng or r a e is d onl
l ron s e ss e
ay etai ng de .
mpo a y esr ni
de s r s ue
y
rrl wh ntemo a tpo e ta h wil ufrij r i rl fi n tga tdb fr t8a v repat c udb
aey, e h v n rv s h t e ls fe nuy f ei s o rne eo e h d es r o l e
e
y
n t ida dh v o p ru i t rso d S eFe . Ci P. 5b .S c a o d r udo l ls u t s c tme
oie n a e p otnt o ep n . e d R. v. 6 () u h n r e wo l ny at ni uh i
f
y
l
a ah aig o apei n r ijn t nc ud b arn e . Asi i cerfo teo te ta Wi esn i n t
s e rn n rl ay nu ci o l e ra g d
mi
o
t s la r m h ust pt l ro s o
k
e tldt apei n r ij n t n tec u tid n b ssu o whc t ga t i atmp rr rsriigod r
nie o rl ay nu ci ,h o rfn s o mi p n ih o rn hm e o ay etann r e.
t
mi
o
pr vi i doe no a t ge he f bi s a e f o cl s iyi i i dua s r t r i E e
o son
s t lo t r or d t t s r m a s f ng nd vi l ; a he t G ps
ke
go r e ald i i nm a r f om te tn dif r n l pe s who a e i a 1r l va r pe t
ve nm nt ec s o ke s r r a i g f e e ty r ons
r n l e e nt es c s
alk ' Nodlng rv. hn,5 U. 1 1 ( 9 .
ie- r i e Ha 05 S. , 0 1 92)
'
gl s c edon a e ua pr e to cli apli ifmus frtde nsrt ta
to uc e
n q l otcin am, antf
t is mo tae h t
he hasbeen Sèat dif enty fom ot sw ih whom he i si iary siuat and
r ed f er l r
her t
s m l l t ed
t
hat t unequal t eat ent w as t r t of i entonal or pur
he
r m
he esul
nt i
posef
ul
dicrm i i Once t s s i i m ade, t court pr
s i naton.
hi how ng s
he
oceeds t det r i
o
e m ne
wh te t e ds ai i te t n c n b j siid u d rt e rq st lv lo
eh r h ip rt n rame t a e u t e n e h e uiie e e f
y
f
s utny.
cr i
'
Kerv.Mas lUni Bd.ofGo nz s 8 F. 62,82(t Ci.201 ( tngMoni o v.
r
rhal v.
ve or, 24 3d
4h r 6) quoi
sn
Gar ht 2 F. 6 ,65 ( hCi. ).
rag y, 39 3d 48 4 4t r 2001)
W ike s m a t c ncl or s a e e t t hi pd ly e e de ot r i a e '
l r on kes he o us y t t m nt ha s na t xc e d he nm t s
penali under si iar cicum s a . H i com pl nt and ot subm i si how ever f lt
tes
ml r
t nces
s
ai
her
s ons,
, ai o
s a e f s concer ng any partcul i t
t t act
ni
i ar ns ancesw hen ot i at r ved l erpenali aft
her nm es ecei ess
tes er
sm iardi plnar i r i or s
i l sci i y nf actons, how t ofi al i entonaly i pos a har herpenaly on
hat fci s nt i l m ed
s
t
W ike s t di c i i t a i t hi . Acc r ngl u r t a i a e sa r i W i e ,
l r on o s rm ha e ga ns m
o di y, nde he pplc bl t nda d n nt r
W ike s n ha no de onsr t d t the i lke y t s cc e o t m e isofhi e lpr e to
l r o s t m ta e ha
s i l o u e d n he rt
s qua ot c i n
c ai o t the i lke y t s f rt ir pa a eha m ofc tnu vi a i ofhi c ns iuto
l m r ha
s i l o uf e he r e r bl r
on i ed ol ton
s o tt i nal
rgh s i t a é e ofi e l ut y r le . Th r f e t co tco ude t tt r que t d
i t n he bs nc
ntroc or eif
e e or , he ur ncl s ha he e se
r lefi no wa r nt d a wilde W ike s ' m o i ns2 A n a pr i t or e wile e t s
e i s t r a e nd l ny l r on s to .
p opra e d r l nt r hi
N
day.
sx - : Thi
rsR. s
é% d yo bu r, 2018.
l a ryeray
Seni U nied St esD iti J
or t
at
srct udge
2 Be us W i s n i notr p e e t byc e i t sa ton, s pa aeor r t c ur w ilgrnthi
ca e l o s
ker
e r s ned ouns ln hi ci by e r t dk ,he o t l a m
t oppo tniyt fl a a e dc pl nt
he
ru t o ie n m nde om ai .
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?