Kidd; Jr v. Berryhill
Filing
15
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Glen E. Conrad on 8/29/2018. (ck)
CL S OFFI U.S. ST
ERK'
CE
ATROANO DI . COUR7
KE,
VA
FI
LED
At J( 2 j
: ! gg
I THE U NI
N
TED STATES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN D I
STRI O F VI NI
CT
RGI A
ROA N OKE DI I ON
V SI
JU
BK
c.
L.
sy
RU SSELL EARL K I D,. ,
D T
R.
Pl i if
a ntf ,
Ci lAc i n N o. 1
vi to
7: 8CV 00
007
M EM O R AND UM O PI ION
N
N AN CY A.BERRYHI Actng
LL, i
Com m i si ofSoci Securt
s oner
al
iy,
By: o G l n E.
H n. e Conr
ad
Se orUnie St t Di ti tJ e
ni
t d a es src udg
D ef
endant
.
Pli ifha Gldt sa tonc lngi t Gnalde iin oft Co ison rofSo a
antf s e hi ç i hale ng he
cso
he mm s i e
cil
Se urt de n pl i if scl m f ape i d ofdiabiiy a di a lt i u a e be ft un r
c iy nyi g a ntf ' ai or r o
s lt nd s biiy ns r nc ne is de
t SocalSe uiyAc,a a de 42 U. C.jj41 ()a 423. J iditonoft sc r i
he i c rt t s men d,
S.
6i nd
urs ci
hi ou t s
etbls dpurua t 42U. C. 405g) Thi c tsrviw i lmiedt adeemi to a t
sa ihe s nto
S. j ( . s our' e e s i t o tr nain s o
whe he t r i s t ntal e d nc t s ppor t Co m is on r s c ncl i t tpl i if
t r he e s ubsa i vi e e o u
t he m s i e ' o us on ha a ntf
f ie t m e t t r quie e s f r e ttem e t t be ft und r t A c . l s h s t nta
a l d o e he e r m nt o n il n o ne is e he t f uc ubsa i l
e de e e ss t fnalde son oft e Co m i s o r m us b a fnne La sv.Ce e e z
vi nc xit , he i
cii
h
m s i ne
te f
d. w
l br z e,
368 F. 6 (t Ci.1 6) .ttd brel s tnta e de e ha be n dei d a s h
2d 40 4h r 96 . sae ify, ubsa il vi nc s e tne s uc
r l va e de e c i rng t r c d a a whol ,a m i t be f nd a qua e t s ppor a
e e nt vi nc , onsde i he e or s
e s gh
ou de t o u
t
c l i b ara o bl mi Rihads v. r e , U. 389, (971.
oncuson y e s na e nd. c r on Peals 402 S. 401 1 )
The pl ntf , Rus l Ea K i J , was bor on Januar 1 1964. H e evenm aly
ai if
sel rl dd, r.
n
y 4,
l
c ee hi hi shoole ain a d o ye rofc lgecous s ( . . Mr Ki ha
ompltd s gh c
duc to n ne a ole
re . Tr 204)
. dd s
be ne o di t pata adititma ge f vai rsa an c ais ( .40, 21 .
e mplye n he s s src na r or rous etur t h n . Tr 204, 4)
Hels woredo argulra s t ne ba i i Fe uayof201 ( . 3, ) 0nAugus
at k n e a nd usai d ss n br r
2. Tr 21 255.
t
1 201 M r Ki Gl d a a i a i f ape i d ofdia lt an dia lt i ur nc be ft .
9, 3, , dd e n pplc ton or r o
s biiy d s biiy ns a e ne is
I flng hi c r e c a m ,M r Ki ale d t a he be m e di a e f r a lf r s ofs s a i l
n ii
s u r nt l i
. dd l ge h t
ca
s bl d o l o m
ub t nta
ganf e oyme ton Ve nlr 1 201 duet b c p oblms mus l/ r e da ge a t ii,
i ul mpl n
b a y , 2,
o a k r e , ce ne v ma , rhrts
a d c r ncp i. ( .2 3 . Mr Kid n w manan ta h h srman d ds be t te
n ho i an Tr 0 )
. d o
itis h t e a e ie ia ld o h
pr s nttm e The r c d r ve st tM r Ki m e t i ur s us r q r men soft Ac a
ee i .
e or e al ha . dd t he ns ed Gt e uie t
he t t
alrlva tmesc vee b t fna d ii oft Co sine . Se ee r l 42U. C.jj
lee nti o rd y he i l ecson he mmiso r e nealv
S.
41 ia 4 a.
6() nd 23()
M r K i s a i a i n was d ni u n i talc i e a i a r c i r ton. H e
. dd' pplc to
e ed po nii ons d r ton nd e ons de a i
te r q se a rc ve aJqn he rnga rviw beor a Admi srtveLa J e.
h n e uetd nd e ei d - ovo ai nd e e f e n
nitai w udg
l a o ni da e Fe u r 21 201 t La J ge a s d t r i d, fe a yi t fve s e
n n pi on t d br a y , 7, he w ud l o e e m ne a t r ppl ng he - t p
s qu nta e uain prc s t tMr Ki i n dia e * Se 20C. R.j404.5 The
e e il val to o es,ha . dd s ot s bld. e
F.
1 20.
La J e f und t tM r K i s f e sf om as ve e i pa r e ti t f m ofde ne a i dic
w udg o
ha . dd u f r r
e r m im n n he or
ge r tve s
di e s b t ts h i r e td s n m ee o e lt r quie e t o a ls e i r e t
s a e, ut ha uc mpaim n oe ot t r qua he e r m n s f it d mpaim n .
Tr 1 - . TheLa J et a ssedMr Ki sr i lfncinalcpa iya f lws
. 920)
w udg hen se s
. dd' esdua u to a ct s olo :
A fe c r f c s de a i of t e tr r c d,t unde sgne
t r a e ul on i r ton
he n ie e or he
ri d
Gnds t t t cl m ant has t r dual f tonal capaciy t
ha he ai
he esi
unc i
t o
pef m lgh wokasde d i 20C. R.()40 1 74)e e
ror i t r
Gne n
F. j 4.56 b xc pt
t cl m ant can f equenty cr
he ai
r
l ouch, kneel and bal
,
ance but onl
y
occasonaly cr l soop,and clm b r ps,sais l
i l aw , t
i am
t r , adder ,r ,
s opes
and s f ds. The cl m ant s d avoi a1 w or ar
caf ol
ai
houl
d l
k ound
vi a i ns a ha r s s h a o n m a hi r a unpr t c e
br to nd za d , uc s pe
c ne y nd
o e td
hei s.
ght
( .20 . Gi n s a r i lf tona c pa iy,a atrc ie ig t tmo fo a
Tr ) ve uch esdua unci l a ct nd fe onsd rn esi ny rm
voc tonal x r , heLa J
a i e pe tt
w udgede e m i d t tM r K i r t i s f i nt unc i lc pa iyt
t r ne ha . dd e ans ufk e f tona a c t o
rmr t hi patrlva wor asadititma ge. ( . . I teat n tve t La J e
e n o s s ee nt k
src na r Tr23) n h lerai ,he w udg
* T epo esrq rsteLa J d et c n ie,i sq n e wh te acama t ()i e g g d i
h rc s eui h w u g o o sd r n eue c, eh r li n: 1 s n a e n
e
s btnil an u a t i ;2 h sasveei ar n;3 h sa i ar n ta met o e u l terq rme t
u sa t g ifl ci t () a e r mp ime t() a n mp ime th t es r q as h eui ns
a
vy
e
o altdi ar n;4 c nrtl t hs atee a t r ; n ()f o, eh r ec np r m oh r r i te
f i e mp ime t() a eu. o ip s rlv n wok a d 5 in twh te h a el te wok n h
s
n
br
n to a e o o . 2 C. R.j4 4 1 2 . I a d cso c n b r a h d a a y se i t e s q e ta e au to
ain l c n my 0 F.
0 .5 0 f e iin a e e c e t n t p n h e u n il v lai n
pr es,f tere uain i unne esay. I
oc s urh val to s
c sr d.
2
f d t ti e n i M r K i i dia e f rpa tr e twor he r t nst e c pact t pe f r
oun ha f ve f . dd s s bl d o s elvan
k, e ai h a iy o r o m
ot rw o k r e e s i i s gni a num be i t e na i le ono y. A c o di y,t La
he r ol s xitng n i t nt
k
r n h tona c m
c r ngl he w
Judge concl
uded t M r. i i notdiabl and t the i notentted t aperod ofdi lt or
hat K dd s
s ed,
ha
s
il o
i
sabiiy
d sbly is rn eb n t . S e2 C. R. 4 4 1 2 ( ( ) Th La J d eso iinwa
ia it n u a c e eis e 0 F. j 0 .5 0 9-g . e w u g ' pno s
i
a op e ast fnal cso oft Co ison rbyt SocalSe u iyAdmi srton' Ap as
d t d he i de iin he mm s i e
he i c rt
nitai s pe l
Coun l Ha ng e us e a la l bl a i sr tve r m e e , r K i d ha no a al d t
ci. vi xha t d 1 vaia e dm nit a i e di s M . d s w ppe e o
t scourt
hi
.
W hie pl i tf m a be di a e f r c ra n f m s of e oymen , t c uc al f c ua
l a n if y
s bl d o e t i or
mpl
t he r i a t l
det nui i i w het pl ntf i di ed f al f
e naton s
her ai if s sabl or l onus of subsantalgai ul em pl ent
t i
nf
oym .
Se 42U. C. 423( () Theeaef elme so pr whihmus bec nsdee i ma ng
e
S. j d)2 . r r our e nt f oof c
t o i rd n ki
s c a a ayss Th s ee nsaes mmaie a fl ws ()ojcieme ia icsa d
u h n n l i. ee lme t r u r d s ol : 1 bet
z
o
v dcl- t n
a
ciia Gn ig ;()teo iin a dc n lso sQ te t gph sca s ( )s be tv e ie c
l c l dn s 2 h pno s n o cu in f rai y iin ; 3 u j cie v d n e
n
n
ofphysc ma fsai ofi ime s a desrbe tr h acama ' t tmony;a d ()
ial niettons mpar nt, s ci d houg li nts esi
n 4
t e cl i a t s e a i voc to hit y,r i ls ls a a . Vie v.Fi ch,438 F.
h a m n ' duc ton, a i nal sor esdua kil , nd ge
tk
n
2d
1 5 ,1 5 -0(t Ci. 9 1; d e o dv. bcf, 9 F.d8 0 8 (t Ci.1 6 )
1 7 196 4h r 1 7 )Un e o Riiof2 l 2 5 , 51 4h r 9 2.
A fe a r vi w of t r c r i t s c e t co t i c ta ne t c l t t t e
tr e e
he e o d n hi as , he ur s onsr i d o onc ude ha h
Comm is o r s fn d i i i s
s i ne ' i al ec s on s uppo t d by s bs a ta e d nc Th r o d r ve l t tM r
re
u t n i l vi e e. e ec r e a s ha .
K i d pr s n e t Ca ii Clni s Col ni Ave Fa iy Pr c i e i Se e be o 2011 wih
d e ç t d o rlop i c'
o al nue m l a tc n pt m r f
t
c pl i s o c oni ba pa n. M r K i d r l t d t pa n t a c pr s i fac r t the
om a nt f hr c ck i
. d e a e he i o om e s on r m e ha
suf er as a r ul ofa m ot vehi e acci
f ed
es t
or
cl
denti 2002,and he r t t t pai had been
n
epored hat he n
ma ge bl unit we kspro t t a nme t ( .31 ) Onph ia exa nai M r
na a e tl wo e ir o he ppoit n. Tr 8.
ysc l mi ton, .
K i diplyed t
dd s a
endem essi t ar oft l ers
n he ea he ow capul w hi w asslghty w or on t rght
a, ch
i l
se he i
sde ( .3 . Thee ni physcin,Dr W ila W hine as se pli ifwih ba k
i . Tr 20)
xami ng i a . lim
t y, se sd antf t c
pan,at a i c mprsi fa tr,a de neai j n die s oft t a i s ne. ( .
i horcc o e son rcue nd ge rtve oit sa e he horcc pi Tr
320 . Hea nitrdaDe - e r ij ci a dprsrbe Pe c c tf pan. ( .3 21.
)
dmi see
poM dolneton n ec i d r o e or i Tr 20- )
l N ovem ber of 2011, M r K i s
n
. dd ought t eat ent fom D r Curts B akhi, a pai
r m
r
.
i
t
n
m a ge e ts c a itw ho ha pr vi us' s e pl i ifi 200 . D r Bac tno e t tpl ntf
na m n pe i ls
d e o l e n a ntf n 2
y
. lhi t d ha ai if
ha $ hit y of-7 ve t b alb fa m r ' a t a hi t a i pai ha pr vi usy r s
s ç sor
a
1 r e r ody r c e, nd h t s hor c c n d e o l e pond
'
ed
welt ij ci t rpy. ( .278 . An e mi to o plitf' t r i s ne rve l
l o ne ton hea
Tr )
xa nain f anifs hoacc pi e aed
pa a re a tnde ne si t m i-hor ccr gin. Pl ntf di no ha a ym i i t ndene s
r ve tbr le r s n he d t a i e o
ai if d t ve n dlne e r s
a hi rn o moton wa ade uae,b hee bie pai u e e i ( .27 . Dr
nd s a ge f i
s q t ut xhi td n pon xtnson. Tr 9) .
Bac tpe f me a ne'e bl k ijci a -6- a T7- a prvie a prs rpi fr
lhi ror d l oc ne ton t 1 7 nd 8, nd o d d e citon o
v
Pec e. ( . )
roct Tr279 .
M r K i r t r d t Dr Ba t on De e be 1 2011 a r po t d t t he ha
. dd e u ne o . khi
c m r 2,
nd e r e ha
d
e p re c daç oie b erd cin o hsp i atrteJs ijcin' n wa G on b te.
x ein e E tc a l e u t f i an fe h at ne to ' a d s ç ig etr'
n
o
d
'
( . 81. DrBa ht d nsee a oh rn rebo kij cina disr ce pan ifortr
Tr2 ) . k ia miitrd n te ev lc n eto n n tu td lit t eun
f
frap sil rpetijcini t mo t s i n c say ( . 818 )
o o sbe e a ne to n wo nh ,f e e sr . Tr2 -3 .
Folo u noe fo DrBa ti c t t t rKi rt n dfrnev bl kij tons
lw-p ts rm . khi ndiae ha M . dd eure o re oc neci
a o m a el e r t t t e m ont i 201 and t fr tha fo 201 Durng t phys c l
ppr xi t y ve y wo o hr e
hs n
2
he is l f 3.
i he
ia
e m i tons M r K i dipl ye pa a r e r t nd m e s and oc a i naly r duc d r nge o
xa na i , . dd s a d r ve t b al e e s
c so l e e a
f
moi u
ton pon e t nson,bu hi de p t ndon r fe s w e e no m ala hi s ns ton w a i t c
xe i
t s e e
e l xe
r r
nd s e a i
s na t
biaealyi t u re temii . ( . 4, 7, 29 296, , 4142 .' . khinotd
ltr l n he ppe xr tes Tr28 28 290, 3, 301 3 - ) DrBa t e
on m uli e o ca i t a pl i tf h ex r e d a dsgnii a ' or G e t r t n 50% '
tpl c sons h t a n if ad pe i nce
si fc nt' G a e ha
gr
'
r du to of hi s
e c in
s ymptms f lwi t prvi ij tons a t tte pr srbe pan
o olo ng he e ous neci , nd ha h ec i d i
x
me c tonha prve t behepf . ( . 287, 293, 301.
diai d o n o
l ul Tr 284, 290, 296, )
4
I Nove r of 201 atr g ng wihou ijcin tea fr s vea monhs fr
n
mbe
3, fe oi
t t ne to h rpy o e rl t o
Gna i r s ,Mr Ki rpo td t thi s o ha e c ltd. ( .3 . Dr Bac t
ncal eaons . dd e re ha s ymptms d s aae Tr 43) . lhi
a nitrd anevebl k ij ci a lvesT7 9 T9- 0,a T1 1 Heas c ee a
dmi see
r oc ne ton t e l - , 1 nd 0- 1.
lo ompltd
r s d f nc i na c pa iy que tonn r ,on w hi h he opi d t tpl i if c oc a i naly lf
e i ual u to l a c t
s i aie
c
ne ha a ntf an c s o l i t
no m or t n t n poun , i f a oxi a e y t e hour i a e gh - urw or y, t nd orwal
e ha e
ds st or ppr m t l hr e
s n n i t ho
kda s a
k
f a o maeyt hour i a egh-ourwor y,a e gei onl lmie ra hi ( .
or pprxi tl wp s n n i th
kda nd nga n y i td e c ng. Tr
31 11. DrBa taloo nedt tpl nifwoul ne dt tkeoneort uns he ul bra
0- ) . khi s pi ha aitf
d e oa
wo c d ed e ks
durng a e ghtho wor a a t the w o d ne d t be a e t f om w or m or t n f
i n i - ur kd y, nd ha
ul e o
bs n r
k
e ha our
tme amo ha ar ulofhi ph'iali nnen. ( . 0- 1.
i s nt s es t s ysc mpai t Tr 31 1 )
.
4
M r Ki rtr d t Dr Ba tfra he neveblck ij ci i Fe u r of201
. dd eune o . khi o not r r o n eton n br ay
4,
whih rpore yprvieda$5 rd to ofhi s t f t monhs' ( .3 351.
c e tdl o d
$0% e ucin
s ympoms or wo t . Tr 46, )
'
Afe t ep i d àre t ga u l rtr , p anif e ev da oh r e v bo kij cino M a
trh an s td o r d al eun' litf rc ie n te n r e lc ne t n y
j
y
'
o
1 201 ( .351. Exa n ton noe fom Dr Ba trve t tpli if c ntnue t
9, 4. Tr )
miai
ts r
. khi e al ha antf o i d o
rc ve ijci t rpy e l t ort eemo hs a t therpore e re i postve
e ei ne ton hea ve' wo hr
y
nt , nd ha e td xpeincng ii
rs t fo t c s oftet nt ( .35 377, 387, 3 402, 2,41 )
euls rm he oure rame . Tr 4, 382, 392, 97, 41 5 .
Th rc di c t t tM rKidrc i dhi ls nev bl kij cino De mbe 1
e e or ndiaes ha . d e eve s at re oc ne to n ce r 8,
201 ( .377 . 0n Ma 1 201 ,plitf a s dDr Ba tt thewa ( ngfil wel
5. Tr )
y 2, 6 anif dvie . khi ha
sC
doi ary l
wih(he prs n rgi nofme c tons'a t thewa tdt E dof'o ij ci frt
t t ) e e t e me
diai ' nd ha
ne o t f n ne tons o he
hol
tmebeig. ( .369 . Li wie,on J y 1 201 pli ifrpore t thi E dba k pai
i
n Tr ) ke s
ul 4, 6, antf e td ha s G
mi c n
c tnued t bef ry wel c ntole 'a t thewa tdt G dof onpr e r f rg
oni gl o ail l o r ld' nd ha
ne o G
hol f
oc dues or iht
no ' ( .36 . Thesmewa juei t fl o 201 DrBac tnoe t tMr Ki spai
w. Tr 4)
'
a
s r n he al f 6. . lhi td ha . dd' n
w asGade el addr s w iht useofPer
t quat y
es ed t he
cocetand ldocai 'and t pl ntf
i
ne'
hat ai ifdeni havi
ed
ng
a sdeefcsfom t me c ton. ( . ,43 .
ny i fe t r he diai Tr 359 4)
On Sept m ber 1 2016,Dr.Bakhi complt anot physi as sm entofpl ntf
e
2,
t
e ed
her
cal ses
ai ifs
a lt t pe f r wor - elt d t ks D r Ba hi opi d t tpl i if c n ne r lf a muc a
biiy o r o m
k r a e as . . k t ne ha a ntf a ve it s
h s
t n po
e unds t the c n stf at t loft hour i a ei hthou w o kda a t the c n s a
, ha
a i or o a
wo
s n n g - r r y, nd ha
a t nd
orwak f at o t hour ilanei thourwor a ( .431 . Dr Ba tf t ro ne
l or oul f wo s f
ghkd y. Tr ) . khi urhe pi d
t tpli ifwoul ne dt t keu c duldbr a e r ffe n mi t sa t thi i r nt
ha antf
d e o a ns he e e ks ve y te nu e nd ha s mpaime
wo dlkel c us hi t bea e fom wor mor t nf tme amont ( . - )
ul i y a e m o bsnt r
k e ha our i s
h. Tr 43132 .
A t t a i sr tve he i g he d o N o m b r 29 201 , M r K i t s i d t t he
he dm nita i
arn
l n ve e , 6
. dd e tfe ha
so dwor ngd t choni pana t tt panha prgrsi l wos ne ( . - )
tppe
ki ue o r c i nd ha he i d o e svey re d. Tr 4142 .
Pl i ifesi a e t th c n w a k abl k on ago d y b f e hi ba k be nst s s a t t
a ntf tm t d ha e a
l
oc
od a e or s c gi o pa m nd ha
hec nc mf tbl lfnomoet ntvepo . ( . - . MrKi f t rtsi dt the
a o ora y it
r ha i unds Tr 4546)
. dd urhe etfe ha
(ael la s t hous 'ot rt n t go t t goc r sor o t do tr ( .47,58 .
t r y e velq he
r
e' he ha o o he r ey t e r he co . Tr
)
Pl i ifa s t s i d,
a ntf lo e tse howe r t the o nsa c bi a ho a a ha fa y t theoc asona l
ve , ha
w
a n n ur nd
l wa ha
c i ly
vi is a t t he ha drve t M yrl Be c Sou h Ca olna t vi i hi gilr e on on
st , nd ha
d i n o
te a h, t
r i o s t s r f ind
e
oc asondurngt prvi ye r ( .5 56 .
c i
i he e ous a. Tr 4- )
W hen M r K i com pl edt adul f i r ti N ovemberof2013,he i ca ed t
. dd
et he
t uncton epor n
ndi t hat
he i c pa eofpe f r i lgh ho ecl a ng a pr pa i m e l , ha het ke c r ofhi pe s
s a bl
r o m ng i t us e ni nd e rng a s t t a à a e
s t,
a ta hego outi onadai ba i. ( . -4) Pli ifas rpo tdt thego t t
nd h t
es sde
l ss Tr2212 . antf lo e re ha
y
es o he
sor o awe kl ba i a t thei a et drvea goo alne. ( . 24)
t e n e y ss nd ha s bl o i nd ut o
Tr 2 .
A fe c i rng a1 o t e de e ofr c d, he La J
t r onsde i l f he vi nc
e or t
w udge de e m i d t tM r K i s
t r ne ha . dd'
ph i alpr bl m sa e no s s ve e ast pr ve pe f m a e o lgh e f m s o wor a tviy.
ysc
o e
r to e r
o e nt ror nc f i t r or f k c i t
I m aki t s det m i i t Law J
n
ng hi er naton, he
udge f
ound t M r K i s alega i of di i
hat . dd' l tons
sablng
ph i al i ia i nsa enote tr l c ns s e tw ih t m e c le de e a d o he e de e i t e
ysc lm t to r
n ie y o it n t he di a vi nc n t r vi nc n h
r o d, ncl ng pl n ifsown s a e e sr ga di hi da l a tvii sa hi t i o oft w n.
ec r i udi ai tf
t t m nt e r ng s iy c i te nd s rps ut o
6
( . 3) TheLa J ef t e
Tr 2 .
w udg urher mphasz dt t . ddç notg neal r c i dtetpeof
ie ha Mr Ki '
has e rly e eve h y
medialr ame o woul e c f at a l dia edi vi ua , a t tt te t ntheha
c te t nt ne
d xpe t or otly s bl ndi d l' nd ha he r ame
'
s
r c i d ha be n r utne a orc ns r a i i na r a ge r ly s c s uli c t oli hi
e e ve s e o i nd/ o e v tve n m e nd ne a l uc es f n on r lng s
s o .( . .
ymptms Tr23)
TheLa J dge a s d clne t a c pt r Bac t so ni nsr ga di g pl i tf a lt t
w u
lo e i d o c e D . lhi' pi o e r n a n ifs biiy o
wor The La J
k.
w udgee pha i e t tt lm ia i not d b D r Ba tw e e i o it n w ih
m s z d ha he i t tons e y . khi r nc nss e t t
t m ediale de e a a w hol , i u ng t physc tndi doc e t d i Dr Ba t s
he
c vi nc s
e ncl di he
i al i ngs um n e n . khi'
te t n noe . ( .22) The La J
rame t ts Tr .
w udge obsr e ta whie pl nifdiplye G ltr
e v d h t l aitf s a d ' aeal
bi
pa a r e r l e r es wih adi i s d r e o m oto a d pai o ex e i a fe on,' s
r ve t b a t nde n s t
m nihe ang f i n n
n n t nson nd l xi 'hi
i e srmoo fn to wa itc 'Gh r wa n s itctn in'a dteewa G o o j cie
' n o i tr u cin s na t'G ee s o cai e so , n h r s t b etv
s
t
'
n
i cton o we kn s o gai a or lt ' ( .22) The La J e as notd t tDr
ndiai f a es r t bn maiy. Tr .
'
w udg lo e ha .
Ba ts m or r c nte m i to no e i ca e t tpl n if s pa n was a qu t l c t ole
khi'
e e e xa na i n t s ndi t ha ai tf
i
de a e y on r l d
wihhi me cn rgi no Pero e a ldoc nepac s ( . . TheLa J ef t r
t s diial e me f c c t nd i ai the . Tr 23)
w udg urhe
o ev t tpl nifha notf ndine sayt undegoij ci t rpyi o raye r a
bs red ha aitf d ou t ces r o r n eton hea n ve a , nd
t tt r w a no i c to t the r q r d s r r oro he mor a e sve f m s o tea m e
ha he e s ndi a i n ha
e uie u ge y
t r e ggr s i or f r t nt
f hi musul keltli r nt ( . .
or s c os ea mpaime . Tr 22)
The La J
w udgeuli a e y a s gne gr a e w ei htt t o ni nsofD r Luc Vi a Dr
tm t l s i d e t r g o he pi o
.
nh nd .
Ge God i w h r vi wed t r c d a t r ue t o t s a e a nc Bot ph i i ns
ne
w n, o e e
he e or t he eq s f he t t ge y.
h ys c a
o ne t tpl i tf i c pa e o m e tng t lfi r q r m e t f lg w or a t the c n
pi d ha a n if s a bl f e i he itng e uie n s or i ht k nd ha
a
stsa a / wakf a oxi t ysxhour i a eihthou wokda ( . 78,8 8 .
i, tnd, ndor l or ppr mael i
s n n g - r r y. Tr76- 7-9)
D r Godw i al f
.
n so ound t pl ntf has occasi pos ur lm iatons and t he s d avoi
hat ai if
onal t al i t i
hat houl
d
c nc ntae e po uet virtonso ha ads ( . - . Dr God nf t ro ne t tDr
o e rtd x s r o bai r z r . Tr 8889) . wi urhe pi d ha .
Ba t sa s s m e tofpl i tm swor r a e lm ia i w a i ons s e w ih t t t iy oft
khi' s e s n
an i
k-elt d i t tons s nc it nt t he o alt
he
e de eofrc d. ( . .
vi nc e or Tr 89)
On a alt t s c t M r Ki d,t o
ppe o hi our, . d hr ugh c ns l a gu t tt La J e e r d i
ou e , r es ha he w udg r e n
f ii t gi s g fc tw e g t Dr Ba t s o ni ns H a ng r vi wed t r c d i is
a lng o ve i nii an i ht o . khi' pi o . vi e e
he e or n t
entr y, however t cour concl
iet
, he
t
udes t t s antal evi
ha ubst i
dence suppors t Law J
t he
udge'
s
de i i A lho t o ni nsofat e tng s r a e g ne a l e tte t g e t rwei htund r
c s on. t ugh he pi o
r a i ou ce r e r ly n il d o r a e
g
e
t a nitai rgultonsa ia et pl ntf cai ,s 20C. R. 40 1 c( ,t
he dmi srtve e ai pplc bl o ai ifs l ms ee
F. j 4.527()2) he
c r b i ve t t i t i t n c s t La J
ou t ele s ha , n he ns a t a e, he w udgepr ry d t r i d t gi m or w e g t
ope l e e m ne o ve
e i ht o
o he m e c e d nc i udi t r pors f om D r V i a D r God i The La J dge
t r di al vi e e, ncl ng he e t r
. nh nd . w n.
w u
r a o bl c l ed t t t sa e a nc ph i i ns a s s m e of M r Ki s r sdua
e s na y onc ud ha he t t ge y ys c a ' s e s nt
. dd' e i l
f i c
unctonal apaciy i m or consit w ih t clni Gndi t cour e oft eat entpr ded,
t s e
s ent t he i cal
ngs, he
s
r m
ovi
a t e f c t a c ns r a i t e t e m e s r ha bee ge r ly s c s f i co r lng
nd h a t h t o e v tve r a m nt a u es ve n ne a l uc e s ul n ntoli
pl i ifs s p om s l s r ,t co tbe i ve t tt La J
a ntf ym t . n ho t he ur le s ha he w udge s d i i n t di c ntt
' ec s o o s ou he
opi onsof er by Dr.Bakhi,and t rel i t on t opi onsoft sat agenc physi ans,
ni
f ed
t
o y nsead
he ni
he t e
y
ci
i w el s
s l uppored by t r d. See. e. , apv. vi 66 F.
t
he ecor '
g.Sh r Col n. 0 App' 251 25 ( hCi. 6
x , 9 4t r201 )
(fimigt La J ' d tr nai ta t plitf me c te t n,whih i ud d
afr n he w udges eemi ton h t he anifs dialrame t c ncl e
ijcin ,pan me iain a d p ysc lt ea y,S s c n e v t e a d ta h rc u s o
ne to s i dc to , n h ia h rp d o sr ai , n h t e o re f
wa
v
te t nts ppore ac l i t ts la abl t mai anar i wor she e'; s p
rame u td oncuson ha he s e o nti outne k c dul' Biho
)
v.Comm' ofSoc Se , F. x65 66( hCi. 4)(fimi t La J ge' de iin
r
. c.583 App' , 4t r201 afr ng he w ud s cso
t rj c te o iin o a te t g p y iin t a wa Tn o sse twi te mi t mo eae
o ee t h pno f rai h sca h t s E c n itn t h l o d rt
n
i
h
d
dignosi fndi 'a (heco ev tvenaueo (hépli ifs te t n )
a tc ngs' nd < ns rai t r f t antf')rame f'.
t
I af m i t Com m i oner' fnaldeci on,t cour doesnotsugges t M r.Ki i
n fr ng he
ssi
si
si he
t
t hat
dd s
f ee ofa1 pai and dicom f . I
r
l n
s
ort ndeed,t m edi evi
he
cal dence confr st pl ntf s f rsf
im hat ai if uf e rom
8
'
amu c ls eea i nr n t ç qbee petdt r s l i s be i el td n . Ho v r
suo k ltl mp lme t l a
mt
x c# o eut n u jç v l a o s we e ,
ml
i ' . ' . * t . .. l î
'
. .'
.
.
. . @%
.
.
1 '
e
.
t r c dsmpl doe no hcud chlc lGndlg o o j ci tsr s l tn aec n itn w11
he e or i y s t l e l ia
n s r be t e t eut b t r o sse t t
ve
s
1
.
ttl d sb ig s mp t lg ,a dine d idc tsts pnnc ss mp o v esb..t
oal ia ln y tmnoo y n n ta n iae h t llt y tmq u j d o
y
e
r as na e me c l c
e o bl dia onko t o
l br ugh e y nial c ns r a te u e m e s : . l . us be
s e ly o e v ove r a nt a ur s t. t
m
'
rc g l. ts-t... ls fl; t .wokwi. u a ysbeE ec mpnnsd e n to iefe d ra
eo nmd. t.hen..bly o r t .t n ujc v o llt o s o ft lrn e
h . * .œ
',
t
.. .
ào
s
.
cll n dia e ,Se , r h.76 E. a 592. I a pe t ' e c ltt t.he La J
nmn t s bld. e C a
3d t
t p rs o . blr ha t
i
w udge
.
.
.
i
' (
.
;
'
l
.
.
'
a
.
1
..
:
.
.
.
.
' . . '..
:
'
*
*
*
g
.
. r
-
.
c n lee al fh me la e ie c , swel sal f h s be tv f cd s e sn bys p o td
o sd r d lo te z c l vd n e a la lo t e u l cie a tr ra o a l u p re
'
b terc r ,na j dc dn Mr Kid scnm f rb n ft. Th s tl c u t o cu e t n al
y h e o d i du ia g . d ' ll o e e s u ,l o r c n ld s h t l
e
'
f c t o t Commlsone ' Sns de ii n a es re b s tmia e nc
a es f he
s i rs l cso r uppo t y ubsl l dde e.
.. .
' ,
.
t ;1
.
l
. 1
-
. . .
.
.
,
::'
,
T
. .
4
.
'
..
.
'q '
':
.*
..
Asage r l l,her s uto o c Alt i hee d nc i ama trwihl t pr vi e
ne s nxe t e ol l n f on cq nt vle e s
te t n he o nc
'
zJ.
oft Commlso r e n i t c e mihtr s l t co lc sdx e e l Rlhrds v.
he
s ine , ve f he on
g e ove he nflt
r nty. c
on
-
:. !
â
.
*
'
t
Z'
p.
'*
P rls s pm Op e h i v Fic .4 5F.d3 6 (t Ci.1 7 ) Fo t er ao ssae , h
eae . u r p n em . n h 9 2 9 4h r 9 4 . r h e s n ttd t e
'.
q
z
.:
.
.. , .
' . . l:.
.
.
'
.
.
..
*'
*
. ' * .
,
.
.
.
'
c nd lndst Commlsone ' r s uton o t perl ntc nil t i',t r c di tzsc s t be
o
he
s l rs e ol i f he tne o cs n Xhe e or n ll a e o
q
' '
.
s ppo tdb s bsn ile d nc Ac or l y, heGns de iin oft Co sl ne mle be
u re y u fnta vie e. c dngl t
l cso ' he mmlso r l
'
n nne La v.Cee e z si a
m
d. ws zlbr z e. tpr l
.
. . ....
.
.
. . .t .
'.
. .
.
.
.
:
.
.
.
.
;
.$
TheClr dle tdt sndc rl dc piso tlsme rndl o nint a1c l e of
ekk' mce o e e tse o e f ll moa lm pl o o 1 omnl
'
rc r
e o d.
o s 'u zp dyoA ss21.
AT o: n a f uut 08
n
,
Se orUnled SatsDid c J ge
nl
t t e s t ud
9
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?