Tilley v. Patrick County Jail et al

Filing 21

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 2/21/2019. (slt)

CLERK' OFFI U. DlK COURT
8
CE S. *
ATDANVI E,
LL VA
FIED
L

F 2 l2 1
EB
29
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN D I
STW CT O F W R G I
NIA
R O A N O K E D I SI N
W O
GM W W AYNE TI
LLEY, ,
JR.
Pl ntf ,
ai i f

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

y.

PATRI CTY. L,e aI,
CK
JM
t .
D ef
endant
s.

J A C D DLE C RK
ULI
M

s xss
z DEP jw

CiiAc inNo 7: 8c 0 0 3
vl to . 1 -v- 0 7
M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI
'
By:Hon.JactonL. s r
ls
Kie
Se i rUn id St tsDit itJ e
n o ie a e src udg

Ga y W a Tily,J . a Vigi a i ae pr ee ng pr K ,fl d a c vi rght a ton
r
yne le r,
r ni nm t oc di
o
ie
i l i s ci
.

ptrua t 42 U. C.j 1983 a i tt e dee nt:Palc Count J i,Parc Cot y
zs nt o
S.
gans hr e fnda s ti k
y al tik mt
She ifsOfi e,a She f Da Smih.
rf
fc nd ni f n
t
1 Backgro
.
und

Plitf alg st a t ed fn a t ( )a miitr d te wr ngme iain a d lf hm
an if l e h t h e e d n s 1 d nsee h o
e
d c to n e t i
u atn e f rt reh u so M a 1 ,2 7 a d ( )h wa n taf r e ap o rk s rde.
n te d d o l ç o r n y 9 01 ; n 2 e s o fo d d r pe o he it
l
De e d n stlda 1 b ()mo int ds s, anifrs nd d a Dee a t rpl dt t
fn a t ie 2( )6 to o imis Pli t epo e , nd fnd ns e i o he
f
e
d,
l a
rs o s ,mn n i i matr rp fr ds sto A fer r vi w i t recor I w il gr nt
e p n e kig h s te i e o ipo iin. t e e ng he
D e e n s m oton t di m i s
f nda t ' i o s s .
I.
I

St
andar ofR e e
ds
vi w

A. 1 b)6 M o in t Dimis
2( ( ) to o s s
De e nt a guet tt c
f nda s r ha he ompl i f ist sa eac am upon whih r i m a begr n e
ant al o t t l i
c elef y
a td

pu s n t Fe e a Ru eo Ci l o e u e 1 ()6 .
rua t o d r l l f viPr c d r 2b ()
A c
ompl i nee o y c a n : s t pl n sae e of t c am s
ant d nl onti < hoz ai t tm nt he l i howi t tt
a
ng ha he

p e d ri e tte t rle . Fe R. v P. ()2 .W he e l tngaRu e1 ( )6 moint
la e s n ild o eif' d. Ci . 8 a( )
'
n vauai
l 2 b ( ) to o
dimis f rf iur t sa e a cai ,a c tmus a e astu a1 welpl ade al gai . See
s s o al e o tt l m
our
t cc pt r e l l- e d le tons

Vi l S. v. rme o e S i pngCo.7 8 F.d 5 ,5 9 (t Ci. 1 ) s eas E ik o v.
t s A. P i r s h p i
o
, 0 3 27 3 4 h r 20 3 , e lo rc s n
.

Pa d , 51U. 8 , 4( 0 7 .d h l ac mp an atc e b aRu e1 b ()moint ds s
r us 5 S. 9 9 2 0 ) t ie o lit ta k d y l 2( )6 to o imis
W
doe no nee de al d f t la lga i , a pli ifs oblgai n t pr de t gr t
s t d t ie acua le tons
antf'
i to o ovi he o mds o li
f zs
e ilm e tt r le r quie m o e t n lbel a co l i ,a a f r ac r iai n oft
ntte n o ei f e r s r ha a s nd ncusons nd o mul i ectto
he
e e t o aoa eofa ton wilnotdo. Be lAt. Co p. Two l 5 0U. 5 4 5 5(0 7 .
l men s f us
ci
l
' l l r v. mbv, 5 S. 4 , 5 2 0 )
'

St t d dif r nty,t s vi a m o i t dim is & c
a e f e e l o m ve
ton o s s , ; ompl i mus c an s t intf dua
a
ant
t ont i ufk e a l
m a tr a e e ast u t sae a ca m t r le t ti pl usbl on isf ce. As r tv.I ba,
te , cc pt d r e, o t t li o e if ha s a i e t a ' hc of q l
'

5 6U. 6 2 6 8( 0 9 .
5 S. 6 , 7 2 0 )
A co tnee no d ce t l lc i i nsdr wn fom t f c s'o ta e a m z
ur
d t t pt he ega oncuso
ac
a r he a t' r lcc pt s e
unwa r nt i er nc ,unr as bl c l i ns o a gum e s' E.Sho e M lt . I .v.JD .
r a ed nf e es
e ona e oncuso , r r
nt.'
r ts. nc
.

Aso s Lt . s i 21 F.d 1 5 1 0 (t Ci. 0 0 .G cu lalg to mu tb e o g t
s c . d P'hp, 3 3 7 , 8 4h r 2 0 ) Ta ta le ains s e n u h o
r ie arghtt r i a
as i o elef bovet s c a i lve y Twombl 550 U. a 555, t a 1a l a i
he pe ultve e l'
'
y,
S. t
wih l leg tons
it c
n he ompl i t ken a t u a alr a o bl i e e e d a i t pl n ifsf vo ,Chao v.
ant a
s r e nd l e s na e nf r nc s r wn n he aitf ' a r

Rie elW o d .I . 41 F.d 3 2 3 6 ( t Ci.2 0 ) Rue 1 ( )6 d e i trq ie
v nd l o s nc, 5 3 4 , 4 4h r 0 5 . l 2 b ( ) o s i e u r
no
he g e f c ea ngofs c fc , onl e
i ht ned a tpl di
pe iis but y noughf t t saeac am t r le t t splusbl
acs o t t l i o ei f ha i a i e
on is f c ' Twombl 550 U . a 570. M a ng t pl usbiiy de e nai n i & ç e t a e.
'
y,
S. t
ki he a i lt t nni to s ( ont xt
a

s ct ts t a rq ie t er ve ng c u tt d a o isj d ca e p re c ml c mmo
pe i ak h t e ur s h e iwi o r o rw n t u iil x ein e d o n
k
s ns . D ba ,556U . a 679.
e e'
'
l
S. t

B. Pr S Pla ng
o
e di s
Thepli ifi pr ee ngpr K a t , ntte t albe a c t c i of hepladi
antf s oc di o nd, hus e il d o i r l onsnzton t e ng.
.

Se .e a. Erc on,551 U . at90- H o e r ç i i e r q rng ge ous co t c i n of
e . , i ks
S.
95. w ve , ç nc pl s e uii
pr
ner
nsnz t o
pr # c pl i sar not... ihou lm is ' Be ude t Civ ofH n pt 775 F. 1
o . om a nt e
q
w t t i t .' a t v. t
m on,
2d 274,1
278

(t Ci.1 8 ) Th Fo rhCic ih se pan dt tCh u !po# lt nsc n o, fc us,
4h r 9 5. e u t rut a x lie ha ç o gl r - ii t n n to o re
t
q ga
bee c e t fn el ga i s wiht c a iya pr ii i aly e de i t wor oft e
xpe t d o r m e l s ues t he l rt nd ecson de l vi nt n he k hos

tane i lw, i rc nd src c u t ber q rdt c n t eu a d cd is sn v rfil
ri d n a net a itit o rs e uie o o jl p nd e ie sue e e ary
he
r
pr e e t t m . l a 1
es nt d o he ' d. t 276;s eKa de o v. nke sen, N o. Ci 9440,201 W L 3359473
'
e l r n Fi lt i
08 v
0
,

a * n. ( D. Y.Aug 2 ,2 0 (plitf sc mp an b ln st t e e e yhngb tt e
t l 1 S. N.
. 4 01 ) t an if o lit eo g o h v r ti -u -h t
kic n snk s hooloft
t he i c
hought' Ef e c
. t ' ompl i i exte ey difc tt f l w bec us ofis
' -h
ant s r m l f iul o olo
a e t
e r m e l t a pur td f c ua de al The f c u l ale tons a e ofen r peii ,
xte
eng h nd
pore a t l t i.
a t a l ga i
r t e ttve

ic nsse t a dc nrd de byd c e t r frnc di t c mpan ' .
n o itn , n o ta i d o mn n s eee e n he o lit'
)
C.4 U. . j1 8
2 SC. 9 3
ç'o saeadam unde j1983,aplitf mus alget vi ain ofarg s urdby
ç- tt
l
i
r
anif t le he olto
iht ec e
t Consiuton a lws oft Unied St t ,ard m us s
he
tt i nd a
he t
aes l
t how t tt a lge de i ton wa
ha he le d prva i
s

c mmitdb ape s na t u d rc lro saelm ' W e t At , 7U. 4 4 ( 9 8 .
o te y ro ci n e oo f tt a ' s v. l 48 S. 2, 8 1 8 )
ng
dns
Not bl a pl i ifm us s fc e l al ge a de e ntspe s
a y, antf
t ufi i nty le
f nda ' ronalac orom ison l di t a
t
s i ea ng o
de i ton o a f de a rght Se Fi he v.W a h.M e r Ar a Tr nstA ut r ,690 F. 11
prva i f e r l i . e s r
s
t o. e a i
ho .
2d 33,

1 4 43( t Ci. 9 2 , b o ae o oh rg omd b Ct . f v ri ev. c aug i 5 0U.
1 2- 4h r 1 8 ) a r g t d n t e rt s v y o Rie sd M ta hl 0 S.
n,
4 ( 9 ) Ne lg n d prv to saeno a to a l u d rj1 8 .Se s ..Da il v. iln ,
4 1 91 . gi e t e iain r t ci n be n e 9 3 e eg, n es W l ms
i

47 U. 3 7 3 0( 9 6 ;P n v. se , 2F.d7 ,7 (t Ci.1 9 ) Dee d n sa g et t
4 S. 2 , 3 1 8 ) i k Letr 5 3 3 7 4 h r 9 5 . fn a t r u ha
t compl ntf ist sa e acli upon whih r le m a be gr nt d ptr ua t Fede a Rul of
he
ai al o tt
am
c ei f y
a e ts nt o
rl e

Cii P o e u e1 ( )6 .
vl r c d r 2 b ( )
11
1.

D i us i
sc s on

A . Pa r c Count Ja land Pa r c C ount She f O f i e
t ik
y i
t ik
y
rirs f c

Att t e hol net rt Parc Co mt J i nort Pa rck Comt She ifsOfi e a e
he hr s d, ihe he tik t y a l
he ti
t y rf
tc r

enii t tma bes ml rj1 3.See e. ,M cco v.Che a keCor Ct.788F.Supp.
ttes ha y ued de 98
s :.
y
s pea
r. r,

8 0 8 4 ( D. .1 9 )( se t gt tp io sa j isa eç r n mso tesaef rElv n h
9 , 9 E. Va 9 2 a s ri ha rs n nd al r i e r f h tt o e e t
n
a
Ame ntpur e and t no t s unde j1 ';s e as Rute v.Town of
ndme
pos s
hus t perons' r 983' e lo ldce
)

Ch t n No 4:0 0 0 4,2 0 W L 4 6 91 ,a *1 ( . Va No 5 2 0 (() i
ah m, . 1 CV0 0 5 01
5 9 3 t W D. . v. , 01 ) ç 1t s
t
i sil t s alc l lc d p rme t(nd rj1 3 i Vigni b c u e a amatro lw,
mpo sb e o ue o a poie e a t n u e 98 j n r i a e a s , s te f a

t eei n e t yt to n b s d.) T f r, wil rn t moint ds s a t a1 li
h r s o ni ha a e ue ' .Theeo e I l g a the to o imis s o l cams
t
'
a ns t s de e nt .
gai t he e f nda s
B. She ifD an Sm i h
rf
t

Forhi cai a i tShe ifDm1Sm ih,Tily a s rst tSm ih ne rr s nde t a
s l m gans
rf
t le s e t ha
t ve e po d o

gre nce H o ver Tily ha no c tmtonale ilm e t t gre
iva . we , le d
onsi i
ntte nt o he ivanc pr e sa c nnot
e oc s nd n

b i aj 1 3cam al gn t ed n a o t a ia l yo t eg iva c pr c s. Se Bo k r
rng
98 li l i g h e il f he valbii f h re n e o e s e é e
e
t

y. C. n'o Co , 5 F.d5 3 5 ( t Ci. 01 ) Ad msv. c , F.d 7 7 ( t Ci.
S. De t f m 8 5 3 3 , 41 4h r 2 7 ; n
Rie 40 3 2, 5 4h r
1 9 )( odngSheCo tmto ce tsn e t lme t o g iv nc pr c dze o a c s t a y
9 4 h li l
t nsi in rae o ni e n t re a e o e l s r c e s o n
t
r
s c p o e u ev ln aiye tbl h db asae'.Theeo e Iwi g a ttemo int ds s
u h r c d r ou trl sa i e y tt'
s
)
r f r, l rn h to o imis
l
ast Sm ih.
o
t l
C . Til y' R e po e
le s s ns

I Til y' r s
n le s e pons t t m oto t dim is ECF No.18 he a tm pt t fl t ee
e o he
in o s s,
,
te ed o ie hr
m otons Fis, movedt srkeDe e nt m o i t dimi s Howe r Iwil nyt moto
i . rt he
o ti
f nda s' ton o s s .
ve , l de he i n
bee us he d d nota s t ml vai g ounds Se ond,Tily m oved f l a t fl a a nded
a e
i
s e' y ld r
t
. c
le
or e ve o ie n me
c
ompl i wihou flng apr e n e d c m pl i .Lii a s e n t epr ee ng pr K ,
ant t t ii
opos d m nde o ant tg nt , ve hos oc di
o
m us s
t ubmi a pr e n
t
opos d mende c
d ompl nt t a d a om a i deza of t i moton.
ai o voi ut tc zi l
her
i

M ac n o i v.Du zn ki 1 5 F.S p 3 6 9,6 7 ( . Va 2 5 (Th Co r wilno
r a tn o
d is , 5
u p.d 1 3 W D. . 01 ) C e u t l t
G
s c a ewhe he ahy t tc n nde co aitwoul be f tl orwhe he t good ca e
pe ult
t r
po he ial me d mpl n
d
u ie,
t r he
us

sa adi me.) Theeo e Iwi d nyt moin.Thr , le a p a st rq e tal tone .
tnd r s t'. rf r , l e he to
'
l
id Ti y p e r o e u s tatr y
l
A s t a ton w ilbe di m i s d f f l e t s a e a c a m , he m o i n i m oot
he c i
l
s s e or aiur o t t l i t
to s
.

1To any ext Tily a guest tSm ih f l t pr ry s vi hi s di es t cl m m us f l
ent le r
ha
t aied o ope l uper se s ubor nat , he ai
t ai

b c us r s nd a s pe iri no a ton bl vi j 1 3.Se . g.l a , 6U. a 6 6.
e a e e po e t u ro s t c i a e a 98
e e. , qb l 55 S. t 7
4

1 .
5,

Fort f egoi r as ,Iwilg a tDe e n s moton t d s is a de Til y'
he or ng e ons
l r n f nda t ' i o im s nd ny le s
pe ngm o i ns
ndi
to .
The Clr i die t d t s nd a c py oft sm e or nd opi on a t ac ompa ng
ek s rce o e
o
hi m a um
ni nd he c
nyi
or rt t pari .
de o he tes

ENTEREDti l1 jyo F b lr,0 9
hs S a f enay 2 1 .
o
x

(
/

J

c'

td'.
)str,

%

EN I R U N I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J D GE
CT U

5