Simmons v. MRRJ et al

Filing 8

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 4/17/2018. (slt)

cu s of cE u s aam eour
ERK' Tl

A n N lL ,A
T A vêi V
FI*D
L

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTE RN DI
STRI O F V I GI I
CT
R N A
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON
CH R I O PH ER L.SI M O N S,
ST
M
Pl ntf ,
ai if
V.

M I R J,e a .
R
t l,
D ef
endant
s.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)

APZ !? 2 1
22
JUL
BY:

. D ,D pRK
J
.
C E

C i lA c i N o. 1 c 0007
vi t on
7: 8- v9
M EM O M N D UM O PI O N
NI
By:

H on.Jacks L . i e
on K s r
Se or U nie St e D i t c Judge
ni
t d at s s ri t

Chr s o rL.Si m ons a V igi a i a e pr ed tg pr K ,fl d a c pl i plr ua
i t phe
m
, r ni nm t oce il o
ie
om a nt z s nt
.

t 4 U. C. 1 8 na nga dee d n st M i deRi rRe in l al G
o 2 S. j 9 3 mi s fn a t he d l ve go a J i ($
MRRJ',
'
)
Supe i t ndentJ c Le a Core tona Ofi e Ca tr
rn e
a k e, pd r c i l fc r re .Thi m a tri be or m ef rs r e ng
s te s f e
o c e ni

purua t 28U. C.j 1 5A.
s nt o
S.
91
1mus dimist c antbe a et J i i no a na et s tvi j1 3a
t s s he ompli c us he als t me bl o ui a 98 nd
be a e Pl i iff ist s a e a cl i a i tLe o Ca t r Se W e tv. t ns 48 U . 42,
c us a ntf a l o t t
a m ga ns e r re . e s A ki , 7 S. 48

( 9 8 (e o n zngaj 1 8 cam mu talg t vo aino af d rlrg t yapes n a tn
1 8 ) rc g ii
9 3 li s le e he ilto f e ea ih b
ro ci g
u d rc o o saelw) Prva v. no 5 F. u p. d3 7, 0( D. . 9 9 (E h
n e olr f tt a ; e l Re , 7 S p 2 0 31 E. Va 1 9 ) çTj e
$
Pi dm on Reg o lJ i i nota S r on,' nd t r f e notn e bl t s tt de 42 U . C.
e
t i na a l s
s s ' a he e or
pe
m na e o ui m r
S.

j 1 8 .) a- dL p r a drv' L p r, 0 F.d8 (t Ci. 0 0 , e re i f l-e t
9 3', i' q a t n e d q a t2 3 3 21 4 h r 2 0 ) rpo td n ultx
' f
fr ta 2000U. App.LEXI 465,a * 2000W L 20591 a *1(ç- co tas pr ry
o ma t
S.
S
t 3,
, t ûlhe ur lo opel
de em i t tt Pi
t r ned ha he edmontRe ona J i i nota S r o al i t r f enota na et s t
gi l al s
pe s n' rd s he e or
me bl o ui

u e j1 8 (2'.
nd r 9 3 . 1
'
)
W hie Pl ntf i upse aboutCarer' aleged sngl sexualcom m ent,com m ent t
l ai if s
t
t s l
i e
s hat

ma co tt eve bala e o ha a s e d notrs t t lve ofa zi h Ame m e
y nsiut i bus r r s m nt o
i e o he e l n ght
nd nt

vi ain.SeeColi v.Cund 603F. 8 8 ( 0t Ci.1 ) ctdfvorbl j Moody
olto
lns
y,
2d 25, 27 1 h r 979 , ie a a y .
q

v Gr v , 8 F. 8 5(t Ci. 9 9 (a e (mp b ihe )(tt a ag n r l l t a veba
. o e 8 5 2d 6 4 h r 1 8 ) tbl) t u ls d sai s e e a nze h t r l
ng

a us o imae b g a d , t u mo e d e n tsaeac n tt to l li ; ors nv.
b e f n ts y u r s wi t r , o s o tt o siuina cam) M rio
ho
M a t , 5F. u p. 8 , 8 ( D. C. 9 0 (n ) Th Co siuin d e no G r tc
ri 75 S p 6 3 6 7 E. N. 1 9 ) s me. e n tt to o s t s oe t
n
p

a ans a1 nr so so o e sp a eo mi . Pitlvv W aih, 27F.d3 7( s Ci. 9 1 .
g i t 1itu in n n ' e c f nd' tse . rs 9 2 , 1t r 1 9 )
'
.

<

Ve ba ha a s e a i et east a i a e e n t a e e tt ti c us sa i m a ef a or
r l r s m nt nd dl hr t o n nm t , ve o n xt n ha t a e n n t e r
e i la e y,do notco tt ea i son ofa i ntfe lbery i e e t Se Emmons
motona nxit
nsiut n nva i
ny de ii d i t nt r s . e

v. c u h i, 7 F.d3 , 5 (t Ci.1 8 )(ttn v r a tr asc usngf a f r
M La c ln 8 4 2 51 3 4 6h r 9 9 saig eb lh e t a i e r o
plitf slf aen ta i fig me to ac n ttto a rg t.Fu te mo e Plitf c n o
an if ie r o n n rn e n f o si in l ih) rh r r, an if n n t
u
r l on r ponde ts rort sa eacli a i tLe See e. , one lv.De tofSoc
ey
es
a upe i o tt
am ga ns e. . c.M
l
p'
.

S r s, 3 U. 6 8 6 3n., 919 ( 9 8 .
e v .4 6 S. 5 , 6 7 $ - 4 1 7 )
Tot e e Pl ntf ma bea et sat acai a na a( ron'ands j c t
he xtnt ai if y bl o t e l m nd me t s ' ub e t o
pe
s tvi j1 Pl ntf i gr ne tnda t fl amoi t a ndt c an t tsae a
ui a 983, ai if s a td e ys o ie
ton o me he omplit ha tts
c am upo whi h r le m a be g a e agans ape s a tng unde c orofsa el w. Se
li
n
c ei f y
r nt d i t r on c i
r ol
tt a
es

eg.Go d nv Le k , 7 F.d 1 4 ,1 5 (t Ci. 9 ) Plitf ma fndi p ee a et
. , r o . e e 5 4 2 1 7 1 2 4h r 1 78 . anif y i t rfrbl o
t l ng rt n t n da t c ul l ga r our s t nk a uthi al ga i ,a fl ane
ake o e ha e ys o ons t e l es ce , hi bo s le tons nd ie w
c pl i i a ne a s pa a e a to fPl i ifc
om a nt n
w nd e r t c i n.I a ntf hoos sno t f l t m oton w ihi t n
e t o ie he
i
tn e

d y ,h c s wil eco e wi o t rj d c , ndPlitf wo l no b p eudc dbe a ehe
a s t e a e l b ls d t u p eu ie a anif u d t e rj ie c us
h

i alwe t fl ac mp an i ane a dspaaea to a t etmeo h sc ies b e t ot e
s lo d o ie o lit n w n e rt cin t h i f i hoc u j c t h
a p ia l lmiain peid.S e ec, n v Ok r , 8 U. 2 5 2 9 5 ( 9 9 ; . d
p lc b e i tto s ro e . ..Owe s . u e 4 8 S. 3 , 4 - 0 1 8 ) Va Co e
j8012 3 A) s eas Rv nv. n ae , 3 S. . 9 , 0 ( 1 )(o igdsrc c u ts
. - 4 ( ; e lo a Go z ls 1 3 Ct 6 6 7 8 20 3 n tn itit o r'
dicei t ma geiso doc t)
s rton o na t wn kes.
l Pl i ifi t a r s a c
f a ntf ns e d u hes nd hoos s t s e a a e e i t sca e he s d know
e o e k n m ndm nt n hi s , houl

ta tec u t yds s t a nd dc mp an wihp eudc a fi lu o frfiigt
h t h o r ma imis he me e o lit t rj ie s rvoo s r o aln o
s a e a cl i u w hi h r le m a be g a e a a s s a ( ti ' Pl i i fs d unde sa
tt
a m pon
c e if y
r nt d nd s es i r ke. a ntf houl
s
'
r t nd

t the i al wed o y t eet ti s'fom bot c
ha
s lo
nl hr s rke ' r
s
h ompl i si dititc t a a a si
ant n src ours nd ppe l n

co t ofa al beor hei nol ralowe t pr e dL f mapa rswihoutpr pa ng
urs ppe s f e s onge l d o oc e q or
upei t
e yi
t $400 flng f e a e c ran c tons.Cong e scr a e t sC lr e-ti s' u ea a
he
ii e bs nt e ti ondii
r s e t d hi l le srke 'r l s n
t
ec
onom i i ntvef prs r t ( t a t nk'be or slng a c
c nce i or ione s o t op nd hi ' f e i
s
ompl i . See e. ,Roce s
ant
, c.
r

v. u m, .10 c 1 7 2 0 U. Dit LEXI 91 4 , t* 20 7W L 4 01 7 a * ( .
Bl h No :7 v1 7 , 0 7 S. s.
S 6 6 a 2, 0
4 8 , t 1 W D.
M ih. c.1 200 .
c De 3, 7)

h

Fx'yR: hsl =dyo- r,08
,r: ' i
r
a f i2 1.
Ap l
.

ej

,

' ..
e

.

r

N

e

e ' rU nie St t s D it i tJ
t d a e s r c udge