Moore v. Southwest Regional Jail et al

Filing 9

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 4/16/18. (sas)

PdK'*$ oN j t.x;I . -il
.'
>
c J$ r rrlr

A
TO

I THE UNI STATESDI CT COURT
N
TED
STRI

:y jj 2 j
n
jg

FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRICT O F V I G I I
R N A

ROANOKE DI SI
VJ ON

KN
BUAq V
A

Flln
l

&

2

BM NDON EDW ARD M O ORE,
Pl ntf ,
ai i f

Ci lAc i n No.7: c 0009
vi to
18- v-

V.

By:

OE
ERK

D

M EM O M N D UM O PI I N
N O

SOUTHW EST REGI
ONAL JAI e a .
L, t l,
D efendant
s.

.

H on. ihaelF.Ur
M c
bans
ki
Chi U nied St es Di t ctJudge
ef t
at
s ri

Br
andon Edwa d M oor ,aVigi ai t pr ee ng pr K , ie a c
r
e
r ni nma e oc di
o fld ompl i pur ua
ant s nt
.

t 42U. C.j1983nami t So hwetRe ona J i a t Vigi aDe rme of
o
S.
ng he ut s gi l al nd he r ni pa t nt

Cor cins(VDOC' a d fn a t.Plitf c mp an i p r t a teVDOC h sn t od
re to ç
ç
' s ee d n s anif o lis n a th t h
)
a o tl
s ter s f e he our f r c e ni
s nt o
hi hi r e e dat 1 Thi ma t i be or t c t o s r e ngpur ua t 28U .S.
m s el as
e.
C.

j1 1 A.
95
Thec tmus dim ist c
our
t s s he ompli be us net rde e nti ame bl t s tvi
ant ca e ihe f nda s na e o ui a

j1 8 , n tu ,h c mp an fist saeacam u nwh c rle ma beg a td S e ec,
9 3 a d h s te o lit al o tt li po ih eif y rn e . e . ..
W il M ihia De to S aePoie 49 U. 5 , 0 71( 9 9 ; e t Ati s 48 U. 4 ,
l v. c c n p' f tt lc , 1 S. 8 7 - 1 8 ) W s v. k n , 7 S. 2
48( 9 8 ; r v l Re o 5 F. u p. d 3 7 3 0( D. . 9 9 (1 h Pit n Re in l
1 8 ) P e a v. n , 7 S p 2 0 , 1 E. Va 1 9 ) (Tq e el t go a
(
mo
J i i no aS e s n, a dt rf r n ta n bet s iu d r U. C. 1 8 .) afdL p r
al s t G ro ' n heeo e o me a l o ut n e 42 S. j 9 3', f q a t
p
'
'
a drv' L p r, 3F.d 8 ( t Ci. 0 0 , e o tdi f l-e tfr ta 20 0U. Ap .
n e d q a t20 3 21 4h r 2 0 ) rp re n ' ltx oma t 0 S. p
u
LEXI 4 5 a * , 0 W L 2 9 , t*1(Th c u t lop o ryd tnnie t a t
S 6 , t 3 20 0
05 1 a l e o r as rpel ee n d h the
1
P e mo tRe ina J i i n t ç ro a di t eeo en tn n bl t s i u d rj1 3g ' .
id n go l als o a pes n' n s h r fr o me a e o ut n e 98 .'
))
Tot e tn Plitf ma b a l t n meaç e s n' u j c t s t i j1 8 , an if
he x e t anif y e be o a
s ro 's b e t o uiv a 9 3 Plitf
p
i g a edt n da t fl am o i t a ndt co aitt tsa e acli upon whih r le
s r nt e ys o ie
ton o me he mpl n ha tt s am
c eif

'Asoft daeoft sOpi o ,t VDOC' publcwe
he t
hi
nin he
S i bpagenotst Pl ntf' e ctdr las daei
e hat ai ifs xpe e ee e t s
Augus 8 2018.
t,

m a begr nt d agans ape s n a tng t rcol ofsa elw . Se e:. Gor n v. e 574
y
a e
i t r o c i mde or t t a
es . , do Le ke,

F. 1 4 ,1 5 ( t Ci.1 7 ) P an ifma fn ip eea et tk lng rt ntnd yst
2d 1 7 1 2 4h r 9 8 . litf y i d t r frbl o a e o e ha e a o
c ul lgalr our s t nk a uthi a lga i ,a fl ane c
ons t e es ce , hi bo s le tons nd ie
w ompl i i ane a
ant n
w nd

spaaea to .I Plitf c o s sn t ofl t emoinwihntnd y ,h c s wil eco e
e ri ci n f an if h o e o t ie h to t i e a s t e a e l b l sd

wih u p eu ie a Plitf wo l n t p eu ie b c u eh i alwe t tl ac mplit
to t rj d c , nd an if ud o be rj d c d e a s e s lo d o se o an
i ane a ds p rt a to a t etmeo hi c ies b e t otea plc b elmiainsp ro .
n w n e a ae cin t h i f s hoc u j c t h p ia l i tto ei d
Se . ..Owe v. u e 48 U. 23 , 49 5 ( 9 9 ' . d j8. - 4 ( ; e as Ry n
e ec, ns Ok r , 8 S. 5 2 - 0 1 8 ) Va Co e 012 3 A) s e lo a
,
v Go z ls 1 3S. . 9 , 0 ( 01 )( oi d src c u tsds rto t ma a eiso
. n ae , 3 Ct 6 6 7 8 2 3 n tng itit o r' icein o n g t wn
doc t)
kes.
I Pli tf i t adnzhesa c est s k a ame e i t sc e, s ul kno
f a n if nse
s
nd hoos o ee n
ndm nt n hi as he ho d w

t a t ec u t yds s t a nd dc mp an wi p eu iea fio o o f rfiigt
h t h o r ma imis he me e o lit t rj dc s rv lus r o aln o
h
sa eac am u whih r i fma beg a e a a s s adsrke. Pli ifs ul unde sa
t t l i pon c ele y
r ntd nd s e s çti ' antf ho d
'
rt nd
t thei alowe onl t e S ti 'fo bot compl i si dititc t a a asi
ha
s l d y hr e l rkes' r m
s
h
ant n src ours nd ppe l n

c t ofa asbeor hei nol ral dt pr e L fr pa rswihoutprpa ng
ours ppe l f e s onge lowe o oce d q o ma upei t
e yi
t $400 flng f e a e ce t n c tons Cong e sc e t t sç hr e-ti s'nleasa
he
i e bs nt rai ondii .
r s r aed hi t e srke ' l n
t
e nom i i en i f pr s r t ls o a t nk'be or f lng a c pl i . Se ee. ,Roge s
co
c nc tve or i one s o tt p nd hi ' f e ii
om a nt e c.
r

v Blh No.10 c 1 , 0 U. Dit LEXI 91 46 a # , 0 7W L 4 01 7 a * ( .
. u m,
:7 v1 77 2 07 S. s.
S 6 ,t 2 2 0
4 8 , t 1 W D.
M ih. c.1 2007)
c De 3,
.

E E T i 1 dyo A r,08
NT R: hs * a f pi2 1.
l

,

f m 4 s '/.
wf' o ow
Chi fUnie Stt
e
td ae

2

ititJ
src udge

'
.
'