Waker et al v. Bankers Life Insurance Company et al

Filing 16

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Glen E. Conrad on 5/23/2018. (ck)

Download PDF
cœ M s OFFI t. . Ok GOUIT CE IB ST. R AT ROANOKE, VA FI LED MA 23 2 1 ï 28 I TI UNI N V TED STATES DI SO CT COURT FOR ' E W ESTERN DI 1 II STRI OF VI CT RGN A ROANOKE DI SI W ON JU BY: C. DL CLERK EM . EP ERK WI E J OR W AKEK i i dual a LLI UNI ndvi ly nd BARRARA KR E W AKEK bya O o nd ugh he Ato e i Fa t W ileJ orW a r r tm y n c li uni ke , Pll i , nntfs Ci lAc vi GonNo. 1 7:8CV0011 8 M EM /RANDIM OPN ON J M. BAxu lsL/E m s t u- cE co - BANKERSLP' Axo cAs T#co. E uv , Hon.Gln E.Con-d e Se orUnie Stt sDlti tJ ni td ae src udge c o sERvl Es. Lc. w c L J NNPER s E wEbB mo,n z ooE, wét a d o> De e a s f nd nt . l t s ac n hi fon,whih wa r mo d fo t CH ui Co tf t Ciy of Ror o , c s e ve rm he t ur or he t ke pll tfq W ile J orW a r a Ba ba a Kyl W a ras etc smK l r s e 1w a l ani li e ke nd r r e ke s r l l mde ut a gs ne Ba r Lle I r nc Co n Be e sLie a O at Co nke s f nmla e mpa y, r f nd mmlly mpO y,CN O Ser l s LLC, vce , J nnle Swe nbu g,a J hn Do The c s i pr s nty be om t c ur o t pli s e fr de r nd o e. a e s e e l f he o t n he ano ' motont r ms . n emoto i o e nd he o lwi l nhasbe nf lybre eda l Hpef c son. Fort f lo ng e ul if nd s orde i1 1 ra o ,h p an i ' io wi b d n e wl o t rj dc t rn wa. e snste litfs mo n l e e id t u p eu le o e e l l h Bae r kq ound The pl t i a e cile ofVlgi w who r sd l Roa ke The we e pr vi l antfs r tz ns r nl ele a no k y r e ousy i ur dl rl -e c r i lmnc polcesis d by M e poltn LieI ur nc Compa y ns e mde ong t = a e nsl e ii sue ko la f ns a e n CM e Lie' Mr. k rsMe Llepolyp o le u l tdlf* eb n Et. M rW a e' t f'. s Wa e ' t f lc r vd d nl e ie ) ml e e s . k rs poly pr vi d o r$25 000l be st . lc o de ve 0, n ne s ''i cou * 1dipe e wih orlv lw rt ' s ns t a e be us t f c and lga c e nt ca e he a l e l ontnfons a e a r dequady t pr s ntd i t matral bef et co tandor la e e e n he e i s or he ur a eumen woul notsgni ntyai t decsona pr s . t d i fca l d he ii l ox s Je frS d n m g arp e e tt eo Ba k r Liea dCau lyCo a y t a k r e e we e b , e rs nal f n es f n s at mp n i n es v % Liea dCn %t', aldtepan si Mac o 2 1 a da # sdte t a s ewo l s o f n =11 ' c le h lie n rh f 0 6 n d ie h m h t h ud o n y) beviii t i negh r d. Sheu ke i t y woul lket ds us i ur nc o rngss h stng her i bohoo d f he d i o lc s ns a e se i uc a l ng-m so t N c r i lmnc M r W a re pli d t tt e c upl O e d ha l ng-e r e a e nsl e. . ke x ane ha h o e a y d o t= mr ' mq a e butt tt pr mi ha be omes hi t thewoul beit r se i l m l a ut pr nc , ha he e umg d c o gh ha d n e e td n es ng bo po e tne c ts e g . M r W a as i c t dt theO dMswiewe ert d,1a t y lve os a s . kc lo ndia e ha f r eH t he i d aone a t tMswieh de ntm l , nd ha f ad me l Swe nbu g s ng t vil t pll lf'home on M ac 30,201 On t tda e de r - ed o st he sntfs rh 6. ha t , 's e n g a J Doe a u de t w de bur nd ohn , n nl nmu a n ofBa ke Lie a Cauat me wlh t ge t n a f nd s ly, t t he pll l . Duyng t me e g, t plhd ss pr vl V te don antfs l he e he a o ded t n pmen s e de i t i t vl ncng her e si xitngpolc e w1 M e Lle. Swe nbur a Doead s dt pll i t t nke sLlea li s 1 t f de g nd vie he nntfs ha Ba r f nd Cas t woul o f r le s me l mnc co r ge t tQzy ha t o M : Lie bu w1 M y d fe a nml e ve a ha d hr ugh t f , t 1 sgnGc n l r d edpr mi . Reyi on l ea en s r pr s ntfons t pli tf c nc ld i l a ty e uc e umg l ng g t ' e e e a , he antfs a e l t rM e Liepoldesa p c s d a l nmnc po iy 9o Ba ke sLlea On nt hei t f i nd ur ha e n nq e lc m n r f nd .=lly. I M a c of201 leVigi aSàt Polc I u o c Fr ud Uni c nt ce t pli t s n rh 7, r nl e ie ns r e a t o a td he a n x a a s d t m t tSwe n g wasun rl si ton f ga e ta ilga i l e nd dvle he ha de bur de nve tgai or uduln nd le l nsl mnc de l . AtO ttme M r W a re ml d le po iy doc n r c i d 9om Bn ke sLie mlngs l , . ke xs ne lc ume l e eve n r f a CaS I a dœ r ne 1a t i lrnc prduc h ha be ns dwasnotleprdud he nd UaT nd ml d the nsla e o t e d e ol o ha bee pr mie orquo e by lec d n o sd td ompan a iei age s Unlket co r gepr vl dby y nd r nt . l he ve a o de M e Lle Y epoiy a ld a pad frbyt Wa r i Msc l ()LI TED BENEFI t f, lc pple nd l o he kes n rh s a W T POLI whih onl gl s le W a r pr t ci o cae f 90 or l 0 da ba e on t i CY c y ve ke : o e ton r r or 8 ys s d her s lcim' Co l!4 , c e No 12 ee t ' mp . 0 Do k t . - . o 2 On Fe r a y 1 ,2018 t pl ' l sl d s ta l tBa r Liea Ca uat Be e s bur 8 , he mntfs e ul gsnq nke s f nd s ly, r Liel l eCo n CNO Se vie , f nsl mnc mpa y, r c s LLC,J nnle Swe e g, ndJ m Doei t Cic t e f r d nbur a ol n he r ui Co tf t Ciy ofRou oke algi âa a vi a ur or he t , le ng ud nd olGonsofl eVlgl s Cons e Pr t c n r nl A r o e uo Ac. Thepl l i l e t r c rc mpe aor dn ge i t mnou o $900000, tve t antfs e k o e ove o ns t y ms s n he nt f , punil d mn e i ie a o n o $ 0 ,0 ,te l d ms e l e Vlgna Co e j 5 .- 0 ,a d n gs n u t f 7 00 0 rbe n g s md r r ii d 912 4 n r as na e a m e sf e a c t. e o bl e y' , e s nd oss OnMa c 2 , 01 , n esLlea dCaU I a dCNO S r ie , (olc v l te rh 0 2 8 Bs k r f n S aT n e vc s LLC c l f ey,h e K e vn Dee d ns'rmo e t c s * tl c u t nteb so dv mlyl rs it mz I R mo ig fn n t' e v d he a e h s o r o h %i f le t u idci ) o n t no le ofr mo ,t Re he tc e val he movig De e n s l c td t tSwe nbœg ha c e e t n f nda t ndia ba de d ons ntd o i mo . TheRe ô ng De e n si- he a s re t tBa r LieI m a eCompa y i a e val m vi fnda t r s e td ha nke s f ns nc n s noml pa œ whos co e i nn e s r f r r mo l a t talpe eshad a e d t a nnl r e ns nt s nec s ay o e va , nd ba l gr e o nons to t tde e nt Se Hn to dFieI . v. de vil M utI . .73 F. 25 ui f u f nda . e rfr r ns Co. Ha ys le .ns Co. 6 3d 5, 2 7(t Ci. 01 )CNO n l at saee cp e 9o ter q ie n ta a1 ee dmtj l i 5 4h r2 3 mla p ri r x e td m h é u me th t 1d fn s q on n e o c n e t ormo a t fd rl o r.) r o s n t e v l o e ea c u t' '. OnAprl1 201 t W a r mo t r ms hec t saec t heba i hn he i 1, 8,he ke s ved o e ndt %e o tt our ont ssl tt Re vn Dee d n s fild t p o etect e s o teJ h Do d fn n t n , sar s l mo ig fn a t Gale ) o rv h iz n ïp fh o n e ee d n a d a e ut i , ti c u t aksdv rl J ds ito ' P1' Br l S p o M o t Re nd2 Do k t 1 . h s o r lc iest u dcim' . .n u p. f t o mn , c e No. 1 y s l t l m oi q t W a r e ulzet a J hnDo i alge t ba wor d o ofan o c i n ber to he ke s mpl l h t o e s le d o ye ke ut m en Roa oke Vigi w a t tds ve y * 1 lkey e ïbls 1a he i a ciie o Vlgi a Se n , t ni nd ba co r 1 i l s lh t s tz n f r nl. e Co l ! 1 (l h Do wa a e o ea e to Bn k r Lie wh as s l ls rn e t mp . ( 0 $o n e s n mplye/g n f n es f o lo od n u a c o i i viual outofhi oo c l a e a 511 Bena d Dr,Suie 305 Roa ke, r nl 2401 i ndi d s s e oc t d t 5 r r . t , no Vlgi à 8n 2Ac di t t notc ofr val Be er Liea Cuualy i anl oi cor r oon ba edi cor ng o he it emo , s f nd t s O s po a s n Chcl ,ln i; Swie, ia nda almi dEaii cmyn wh s me esaeno ct o ij oIl osCNO e csLLC s nl in i t blt o ay é e mb r r tii f i e y xns a dS d n u gi ac* no hda a V Noieo Re v l !9-1 Doc No 1 n we e b r s i f in . tc f mo a ! 2, kd . . Vigl Ba sLieI lmnc:Co ny i aNorh Car i c porhon baq i Dur m, o i Cr lna r ma; nker f nsl mpa s t olna or a ed n hs N r i; 3 2 63. I rs n e t e Re vn Dee d n sag e t tte n tc o rmo a e tblh s 01 . n epo s, h mo lg fn n t ru ha h oie f e v l sa l e s c omplt dve st o ct ns p a o t H o na e e i r ly f iY hi m ng he wny med pa te a pr m ry dlr gcdst ris nd o l se he c l hi oft J Do de e n . hlons p he ohn e f nda t Di e s o s us i n l or e f a a to t be r mo d âom s e c t f de a c ,ie a ton mus be n d r or n ci n o e ve kt oM o e r l oM ci t o ei fwhc teds c c u t o teUntd Sae ha eo iia j ds iE n' 28U. C.j n % ih h id t o rs f h ie tts v rgn l u dc o . o ' S. 1 41a . Th b r e o d mo s fn j rx it n rss w11 te p ris s e i g rmo a. 4 () e u d n f e n lnl g u ldcl et t1 h ate e kn e v l o M uc h yv. l ba Ora l Ch mq Co. F.d 1 8 1 ( t Ci.1 9 ) I a a ylme la e CoA l a n c e . .29 3 4 , 51 4h r 9 4 . f t n l b fx f l u m e th a p asta t ec u t a k sb e tmatr u ldcln t ec u t s eo ma J d n p e r h t h o r lc s u j c te J rs lto , h o r mu t rma dt c s . 2 U.. 91 4 () e n he ae 8 SC. 4 7c . Asl c td a ndiae bove t Re vl De e a sr move t c s t t sc t u tt , he mo ng f nd nt e d he a e o hi our p= an o 28U. C.j 1 3 , h : n fd rlds tc n o lln j ds lt n o e cvla t n i S. 3 2 wMc +a 1 e ea ldc o eq rgn l u dcl v r ii cl s n o o whlht amol l c nkove s e e s$75,00 a t diput i bewe n cdze ofdlf r nt c he mt n o ry xc 0 nd he s e s t e i ns fe e sae . Se 28 U.. 9 1 3 a() S e t n 1 3 rqle c mpee dv ri a n te tts e SC. 3 2()1. f ci 3 2 e lg s o lt iest mo g h s o l y pa te ,me nl t cile hi ofe c pli t mus be d e e *o t cil ns l ofe c ris s ng he tz ns p ah ane t e r nt m he ta h p a h . d fn a t' Ho c n v V p aah a Po r Co. 7 9 F.d 1 3 1 0 (t Ci. 2 1 ) ee d n ' sb r . p lc in we . 3 3 6 , 7 4h r 0 4 . I rl l i dee ml ng whe r a cvi a ton i r mo bl o t ba o dve st mpo t y, n tr nl mt ie i l c l s e va e n he /s f l r iy J rs iu n $h ct e s po d fnhnss e u d rfcio sna ss al edse ad d' 2 u ldc o ,% e iz n hi f ee r t u d n e tt u me h lb ir g r e . 8 i l ' ' * @ @ 1 1b ()3 u sc j 44 ( )1. 3Sœton 1441wa a nded i 2011 SeeFede a Coud.J iditon a VenueCle c ton Ac of i s me n . rl q urs c i nd a ai t 2 1 Pu .L.No 1 2 6 ,1 5 S 7 8 ( 1 ) 'h r ie n ta c u t dRe ad te cty n hp o 01 , b . . 1 - 3 2 àt 5 20 1. f e murme t h t o rs lrg r h iie s i f dee d nss e u e fciiu n me wa p e o l f u di j1 41a. 'h ln a ewa o n l a d fn R t q d nd r tto s n s s rviusy o n n 4 () l e a gu g s dgial d M ' y t t sat/na pa toft J a I ovement andAcc s t J uc Actof1 Pu L.No.100- 1 o he t l s r he udcil mpr q e s o us e 988, b. 702, 02 Sa. 4 ( 9 8,ç o d rt clt't p tc o n migdcii sd fn a t meeyt d s ydvest tt46 2 1 8 ) <n r e o lrmll mcie f n n tt ee d ns rl o e ko i w ou ri y' Ho lv. mutCi .30F. u p.d1 4 1 7n3' D. m 2 0 ) wel Ci i t 3 S p 2 31, 31 . ( Al 0 4. y M. 4 Thec ur a e swiht o t gr e t heke movi De e nt t t hecla dune voc llngu eof ng f nda s ha t e re qui a a ag ' 9 1 41 4)i ds sf e h r . A$tl sa e o t p o e dn s te c u tl r q ie t 4 1)1 s im iv ee h s tg f he r c e ig , h o r s e ur d o dlr g r lectz nœ p oft J Doede e n ,e n i he ei r a o t be ivet thei a se ad iie he ohn f ndn t ve ft r s e s n o le ha s k dtz no Vigna4 SeeW alerv CS Trns hlc. 5 F.d 1 9 , 3 6n. 1( 1 Ci. 1 ) ie f r iiX a p n .6 0 3 3 2 1 9 1 1 1 r20 1 . (oig1a ie l elo d tn àeGcii. d fn s t wee ctznso te s me saea ie n tn t i lh o % t k t o ee d ns r i e f h a tt s t i plltldl no delo co eedi riybe a ej1 r uie t tSciiusynl dpate anl d t s y mplt vest c us 441 eq rs ha tto l me ris b dse ad df r e o e o dv riyl rs lio ) Kn s 'ub c S q k o s o F a. e lrg re o p ss f est u ld c n ; me v. t a k tp b u e f 1.LLC. o No.1:5-w 1 441 201 U. Dlt LEM S 8 1 c 3 , 6 S. s 6524,a * ( . W . . uy5 2 6 (o cu lg t 7 SD. Va J l , 01 ) c n ldn . t tG antf c mm l n dve st l l c ng be a e t J Do de e n sa e lkey W e t bs pli lfs l ' h t rly s a ki c us he ohn e f ndn t lr i l s Vignactz n . .(al u d r 2 U. C.j1 41b()'; n svv. a wo d Re l L. . r ii i e s . fis n e) 8 S. 4 ()1' Lld e Hlh o s at P. l ) y No 31 -v 0 4 7 2 1U..Dit LEM S 1 8 7 ,a * @ . Vm S p 2 ,2 1 )(mdn . :1c - 0 4 , 01 S s. 0 1 2 t 7 D. e t 2 0 1 f ig un rl l t pli l su ume t tt r weeml cln r aonst belvet taJ l Doe pesmnve he antt ntha hee r m e t e s o le ha om d fn s t sacuz no Vign a. Be a ec mpeedv ri e ita n h kn v nn d ee d n wa l e f r ll c us o lt iest xss mo gte o y me pe e , hec ur mus d ny t pe n moto S ul dic r c lr t pl itfk i ta s t o t t e he ndlg l n. ho d s ovq y on m he an lf' nlil beif r ga di t cile p oft J Doe d e nt t pli if m a r ue tla t le s e r ng he tz ne he ohn efnda he antfs y eq s e ve o a n terc mpan a d rn w t ermoln t rms . Se 2 U. C.j 1 4 () s eas me d h i o lit n e e h i t o e nd e 8 S. o 4 7 c; e lo Do b v J o No fl. . . 5 1F.S p 2 5 1 5 2 ( D. . 0 7 ( tn ta te b s . BC f rok Va hc. 2 u p. d 3 , 3 E. Va 2 0 ) noig h t h pli i c ul r ne Msmouon t r ms 1fa whe l be ome cla t tdve st l Y s antf o d e w o e nd s nd l n t c s e r ha r iy n a t ni lc ig' ci s a kn '. o l 4I agui t t con rr n r ng o ho ta y , teplie spkdyal rl o Jhnonv. nrlMoosCoo rto . h an nn l ey n o s Geea tr roain y 2 2F. u p. 7 , # ( D. 1 65,nwhc leds c c u fu diO ee s frarmo igd fn a t 4 S p 7 8 7 0 E. Va 9 ) l ih iG t o d o n t c so o c vn oo d n t s t tal hnDoeco- f nda waqanon-e denta hetmeoft i 'u oft ac ' Howo r o how hn o de e nt r si tt i he nel fon he iom' t ve , J onwa de dH bef eConv es a e t r lo lsntt odic c t dir > dtl cta ns of ohns s ci or s m nded he e va 'tlet r ct oneq o s e le ii Mp deonda ss unde icutousnn s. Thata ndme f ecos al r lnc on J on. f nt ued r i me me nt or l es l ela o ohns y 5 Cond:s o in Fo ter ao ssae y pan f' io t rmn wil d ne wi u p eu iet r h e s n ttd ie liffs mo n o e nd lbe e id t t rl dc o ho r ne t e wa The Cl k i dle td t s nd e pi s o t s me a m o o a t er s r ce o e o e f hi mor ndu pM n nd he a o n ng or rt a1c e ofr c r cc mpa yi de o l ouns l e o d. a f oA-so: sgmd d yo . r w 2 8 01 . S io Unt S e Did c J d e e r id ùts s t u g 6

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?