Draper v. Skaff

Filing 3

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 4/17/2018. (ck)

a wwœ=ov j u.. x uv
. . & s ast
ATi M ONBUR V
GR
q A
FlNn
l

I TH E UN I
N
TED STATE S D I
STRICT COU RT
FO R TH E W E STERN D I
STRICT O F W RG I I
N A
R OAN OK E D I SION
W

tr 1ï l 1'
'f
l
r>
;Y:

I . DLE CL .
A
X E

!

r ,K

CED RICK EU R O N D M PER ,
Pl ntf
ai ify

Cas N o.7: v001
e
18c
59

By: M i
chaelF.U i
bansd
l
W CT O R S.SK AFF,1
II

Chi fUnie S a e Diti t udge
e
t d t t s stc J

D ef ndant
e
.

M E M O RAN D U M O PI I N
N O

Pr ee ng pc . ,pli ifCe i k Eut D z pe f d t i t ntc pli ,
oc di
q K antf drc
on a r ûe he ns a om ant
-

se igla et p o e dL f t a a ei p r u ntt 2 U. C. 1 1 ()1. a rs
e kn e v o r c e q o' u rs u s a o 8 S. j 9 5a () Dr pe'
m
com pli na esone def nda ,aRoa
ant m
e nt
nokelwye ,and alge br ac ofor lc r ct
a r
le s e h
a onta .

Fe rlc rsaec rso l t dj idc a t c ur ha a i e e de
dea ou t r ou t f i e urs iéon, nd he o t s n nd p n nt
mi
obi éo t e auaes s o eiss bjc matzj idci n o racnm. e Ar u h v.
i n o v l t ua nt t u e t te uts ito ve li S e ba
ga
Y&H Co .5 U. 5 0 51 ( 0 ) s eas 2 U.. j1 1 ()2 ( (it tc ut ha
, 46 S. 0 , 4 20 69 e lo 8 SC. 9 5 e()B) d sdc ot s ve
a dut t s t e i ta flngsa dit s a c pl i fl d L f m a a e i a a tm ei
y o c e n niil li nd snis om ant ie q oz
u rs t ny i f

t ec utd tzni st tt a to fist sa eaclm up whihr l fc n b g a e )
l ot: ee r ne ha he ci n al o tt li on c ei a e r ntd .
a
e

He e Dr pe sae t ec u tha fde a q sin jrs it pu s ntt 4 U. C. 6 0 .
r , a r tts h o r s e r l ue to t idci rua o 1 S. j 5 3
z
on
Butt saat gove ni gove nm e c t c sha no be zng on t ssa elw br a of
hat t tze
r ng
r nt ont a t s
ai
hi t t a
e ch

c nta tc m. us t ec u td snot vejrs iton o e tlsm atzund r2 U. C.
o r c bi Th , h o r oe
ha u idci v r i
i te e 8 S. j

1 3 . zi t r dve st jrsl to un z28U. C. 1 2 a lo h pade a a t be
3 1 No s he e i ziy u ici in de
c
S. j 33 , s n t r s ppe t o
ctz ofVigi aa t a ounti contove s i ls t n $75000. i doe notha
iiens
r ni nd he m
n
t ry s e s ha
, As t s
ve

s jc matrj iditon o rt sa ton t 'c ur mus cs s t c mpli i is
ub e t te uts ci ve hi ci , he o t t l mis he o ant n t
i

1

'

e ie y. ba
ntr t Ar ugh,546 U . a 51
S. t 4.

Ac di y,D z pe ' a ia i t pr e L f ' a a e i wilbe GR AN TE D
cor ngl
a zs pplc ton o oc ed q ot
m
u rs l
a t sm a trwilbeD ISM ISSE D and STR I EN fom t a i doc toft cour.
nd hi te l
CK
r
he ctve ke
he
t

An a oprat O z rwilbeent r d.
ppr i e de l
ee

Enee : o (, - /T v ' o f
tzd
1z Z'

/ / . WV C*
+
W
Y

M i elF. ban
cha
Ur

Che Unie Sa e Ditit ud
if td tts src l ge

2

X