Tower v. New River Valley Regional Jail

Filing 6

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Glen E. Conrad on 5/11/2018. (slt)

I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STR I T C O UR T
C
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
R O A N O K E D I SI N
W O
TA YL O R N A TH AM EL TO W ER ,

CLERK' OFFI U. DI O UR'
S
CE B. SX
I
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

MA II2 1
t
98

CA SE N O .7: V001
18C
78

î . LEX CLPRK
D
:

.

CLERK

Pl nt f ,
ai i f
M EM O R AN DU M O PI
NION

NEW RW ER VALLEY REGI
ONAL
JA I
L,

By: H on.G l n E .C o
e
nrad
Se or U ni e St e D i t i tJudge
ni
t d at s s r c

D efendant
.

Ta orNahale To r aVigilai t pr e di pr K , ied t sci lr g s a ton
yl
t ril we , r ri nma e oc e ng o f l hi vi i ht c i
.

u d r4 U. C.j1 8 a an tt Ne Ri rValy Re in lJ i (t ej i'. To ralg s
n e 2 S.
9 3 g is he w ve l
e go a al Gh a1) we le e
t
'
t t he i no beng s
ha
s t i hown t 1b t s r s t r l e t hi G - p C' a i r c vi no
he a e t e uls ' atd o s ll
e
le
' nd s e ei ng

te t n ' ei b igd ne g iva c f r a d I u p o e s'a d h i s b e tt K nlla d
rame t h s en e id re n e o ms n f e r c s' n e s u j c o K e n
,
d
;
c
un s l t s me t i t ep o e tv c so y(TC' u i wh r h i h u e , e h sc oc f r
u ua pmih n' n h r tcie u t d ç ' nt e e e s o s d p r i h ie o
'
)
3
s ey r s . c omp1 2- ,ECF N o.
af t ea ons1

A s r i f Tow e s ks m one m' da ag . Af e
ele ,
r ee
t y m es
tx

r vi of t co pl nt t c t c l s t t Towe ' cvi aci mus be s ma iy
e ew
he m ai , he our onc ude ha
rs i l ton
t
um rl

ds se wi u p eudc .
imis d t t rj ie
ho
Und r4 U. C.j 1 9 ec () t ec u t y ds s a y j 1 8 a to l t r s e t o
e 2 S.
9 7 ()1, h o r ma imis n 9 3 cin i h e p c t
wi
prs n c tons...i t cour i s tsid t t a ton i fi ous malci ,( jfist
io ondii
f he t s aife hat he ci s rvol , i ous or al o
sae a cli upo whih r le c n be g a ed.' A ç rvol us'c am i one t t Gl ks aï
tt
am
n
c ei f a
r nt '
G i o ' li s
f
ha çac r

ag a l ba i ete i 1w o i fc ' Netkev.W i ims 4 0 U. 31 ,3 5 3 7 ( 98 )
r u b e ss i r n a r n a t' i
h
z
l a , 9 S. 9 2 , 2 1 9
l
(ntr etngGrvol 'i f me vesonof28U. C.j1 5( )
i epr i û i ous'n or r ri
f
S.
91 d).
Seci 1 3 pe t a a i ve pa t t fl aci laci p a i tape s n f a tons
ton 98 nnis n ggre d ry o ie vi to gans
r o or c i
t ke t de col of sa e 1 w t tvi a e hi c tm to lr ght Se Coope v.She ha 735
a n m r or t t a ha ol t d s ons i i na i s. e
r
e n,
1 SPecii aly, Toweralegest he ca onl l
fc l
l
hat
n y eave hi PC cel f one hourperday,has lmie
s
l or
i td
acces t a t e
s o el phone a no ac s t a t e si a has not been out i f r ea i even once
nd
ces o elvi on, nd
sde or ecr ton
snceD ec ber6,2017.He alo alegest ot PC i a eshavem or prviegest n hehas
i
em
s l
hat her nm t
e il
ha
.

F.d 1 3 1 8 (t Ci. 3 . Th o l e tt ta To rn me a a d fn a tt hi j 1 8
3 5 , 5 4h r 201 ) e ny n iy h t we n s s ee d n o s 9 3

camsi t ej i is l.Rhej i, we r i n tat ro ' u j c t s t n e j1 3.M c y
li s h altef n alho ve, s o t s n's b e t o uiu d r 98
pe
co
v Ch spe k Cor Ce tr 7 8F. u p. 9 8 -4( D. . 9 2 .
. e a a e r. n e, 8 S p 8 0, 93 9 E. Va 1 9 )
Be us To ' c antprs nt no l albassfracam acina eunde j1983
ca e wers ompli e e s eg
i o li to bl
r
a ns t onl de e nthe ha nn e t c u' wilsl rl dim is t s a ton wihout
gai t he y f nda
s m d, he ot t l lmma iy s s hi c i
t

p eudc un e j1 9 e c( )a fio o .Ana p o raeo d rwi e trti da .
rj ie d r 9 7 ()1 s rv lus
p r p it r e l n e h s y
l
ENTER;Thi ll
s

da ofM a 201
y
y, 8.

Se orUnie Stt Diti tJ
ni
td aes src udge