Hawks v. NRVRJ et al
Filing
7
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 5/30/2018. (slt)
.,
.
'
X
eœ î soF l e: 01 - ,
q
xf tep
*
-
.A p l kV
kT -vl A
k
gjan
t
t.
I Tu, vxl yo STATESol l c' cocR'
x
: ':
r
sw r
r
MA 3p 2 1
Y
23
FO R TI W ESTER N D I
IE
STR I T O F V I G I A J L,
C
R NI
u
R O AN O K E D I SI N
W O
B '
Y:
.
D
E
FRI M O NR O E H A W K S,
EL
Pl nt f ,
ai if
'
M EM ORANDUM OPI OX
NI
N R VR J,e al,
t .
D ef
endants
.
'
E
C i lA c i N o.7: c 00232
vi ton
18- v-
V.
,
.
By: H on. ks n L.K i e
Jac o
sr
Se orUnie St e Dit i tJndge
ni
t d at s s r c
Fre M onr Ha ,aVigilai a epr e ngpr K ,fl d aci ltght co pl nt
il
oe wks
r ri nm t oce di
o
ie
vi i ' m ai
s
ptr ua t 42 U .S. j1 3. Pli tf s i al lssf trde e nt t N e Ri rVa ly
l s nt o
C. 98 1 a n if pecfc ly it ol f nda s:he w ve le
Re ina J i (t
go l al E
NRVRJ'; u tn e d n Gr g r W i tn; . le; nd$ 1NRVRJ
' S pei tn e t e o y nso Dr Milr a W 1
)
Emply e . Th smatri beo emef rs re n , u s a t o28U. C.j1 5 Afe
o e s' i te s fr
'
o ce nig p ru n t
S.
91 A. tr
rv e n t c mplit Id s s t ec mpan wih u p eu ief rf iigt saeacam,
e iwig he o an , imis h o lit t o t rj d c o aln o tt li
de t m oton f a TRO,a g a tPl ntf lavet n nd.
ny he i or
nd r n ai if e
o me
The c pl i pr e s e g c a m s Cl i one ale st tnon- f
om a nt es nt i ht l i . a m
l ge ha
de enda N RV RJ s a f
nt
tf
ij r shi b a dn p s no a dp n ma e tc ls b tnc st li f o .Cli t alg s
nu e m y d ig oio us n h r c uia u sa e o ls o d am wp le e
t a Dr M ilrij r dlm b pr srbn G eo in 'whihc n an a i r de tta i
h t . l nu e l y e ci ig t lx c m, c o t is n nge in h t s
e
i
sl
'
docz e edi Pl ntY sffee ye m edialhit y a a a lr e Cl m tle compl i
lm nt n ai i i t n- ar
c sor s n le g n. ai lr e
ans
a o thea ia iiyo t ej i' a mi itaierme yfr .Cli f lralg st t o b u t valblt f h als d nsrtv e d o ms am pz le e ha n n
d fn a t
ee d n NRVRJsafij r dh m b u i e e sv fr ea plcngim i s g e ainf r
tf n u e i y sng xc sie o c nd a i l n e r g to o
i
t npt red y .Cli fv alg st a hef esp i a di ij r dbe a eG dc l. .
we t h e a s am e l e h t e l an n s nu e c us l ia .
e
me
r f s st g a t(i a c s t awh ec ara r q ie t e t ( rc nswihDia ii e
e u e o rn hml c e s o
e lh i s e ur d md r he Ame ia t s blt s
i
Acj' Cli sxalg st a h i ij r db t epo rwae q l ya t eNRVRJ Cli s v n
t. am i l e h t e s nu e y h o tr uai t h
'
e
t
. am e e
c pl i a utt w a f i s r d a t a a e s nii e Cl i e g alege t the i
om a ns bo he y ood s e ve nd r ys r a t z d. a m i ht l s ha
s
1W iht co pl nt Plitf fldaç eio fri daeijmcierle ' lc Ic ns u a a
t he m ai , anif ie t tt n o mme it nt t eit'wl h o t e s
p i
v
i
r
moinfratmp rr r srii o d rCTRO'.
to o e o ay etanng r e
'
)
b igij rdb c M n me ti s g e ainf rt n pt r eh t sad ybe a eo hi me ia
en nu e y o e n n e r g to o we t h e ol a c us f s d c l
r
c ndii .2
o ton
1mus dim isa aci n orc am fl dby a i a ei 1dee net tt a ton or
t s s ny to
l i ie
n nm t f tnni ha he c i
c am i f vol orf l t sa eac am on whih r le ma begrnt d. Se 28 U. C.
l i s zi ous ais o t t l i
c ei f y
a e
e
S.
j 1 5 e( ) 1 1 A( )1 ; 2U. C. 1 9 ec .Th frtsa d r i cud scamsb s d
j 91 ()2 , 9 5 b () 4 S. j 9 7 () e ls tn a d n l e li a e
u G l i s abl m eil sl lt or 't l i sofi rnge e ofal gali e e twlih
pon t ' ndiput y ztes ega he y,' G am
al
c
nfi m nt
e nt r s lc
cea l doe no e s , o cai whe et çf c ta c e i a e cea l ba ees . Neizkev.
l ry s t xit' r l ms
'
r he ça tz l ontntons r l ry s l s'
' t
W iln , 9 U. 31 , 2 ( 9 9 .Thes c ndsa d r i t efmiirsa d r f ramo int
lims 4 0 S. 9 3 7 1 8 )
e o tn ad s h n la tn ad o
to o
ds s t e Fe rlRul o Cii P o e u e 1 ( )6 , c e tn teplitY sf cua
imis md r dea e f v l r c d r 2 b ( ) a c p ig h ani a t l
al ga i ast e. A c
le tons ru
ompli nee & s t ndpli sa e toft c am s wi t tt
ant ds ç hor a
a
a n t t men
he l i ho ng ha he
pla e i e tte t rle a ds fkin çfa ta alg to . .or ieadg t or l fa o e
e d r s n ild o eif' n u f e tç j cu l le ains . t as
l
h t ei b v
e
t es e ultv lve . .' Bel l Co . Two l 5 0U.. 4 , 5 ( 0 7 ( tm a
h p c aie e l . . l At. p v. mby, 5 S 5 4 5 5 2 0 ) i e l
'
n
q tto mak o te ) plitY sb ssf rr l fRe uie mo et a lb l a d
uoain r s mitd .A an i a i o ei rq r s r h n a es n
e
c l i ns.... I The e or t pl i ifm us t l f c ss t i ntt sa ea 1t
oncuso
' d. r f e, he antf
'
t & ege a t ufk e o t t l he
al
'
s
ee n so ( )cam .3 B a sv. ..
lme t f t li ' s E I DupontdeNem our & Co., 3 4F.d76 , 6 (t Ci.
he
2 3 1 7 5 4h T
20 3 .
0)
2Pli ifas notst alhough hei i e e td i purui i t f t eanaddii cl m a t
antf lo e hat t ,
s ntr se n s ng n he uur
tonal ai bout he
de a off andas i dit he i notpr r d t puruet tcai no
nil ood
pecsc e , s
epa e o s ha l m w.
3D ee mi ng whehe ac
tr ni
t r ompl l saesaplusbl cai f r le i Rac e -pect t k t tr quie
aht tt
a i e l m or eif s ontxts ik as ha e r s
terve n c m't da o i j iile p re c a dc mmo sns. As co v Ib l5 6U. 6 2 6 87
h e iwig o to rw n t udca x ein e n o n e e' h r h .q a, 5 S. 6 , 7 -9
s
'
( 0 ) Th s ac u t ceni ac mplitu d rRue1 ( 6 c nie tf pe dng t taen te t ldt a
20 9 . u , o r sre ng o an n e l 21 ) a d n i la l sha r o nie o n
9(
y
t
as to o tuhbe a ete c n ito nomo et% lbesa c ncu in .J Alh u hIl eal c ntu
sumpin f rt cus h y o ss f
r h a l nd o lso s . to g i r l o sr e
T.
b y
p oK c mplit, ie v Ken r 4 4U.. 9 5 021( 9 2 , d no a t sa i t' a v c t,u s ne
r o ans Han s . r e, 0 S 51 , 2 - 1 7 ) 1 o t c a n nmaes d o ae sa ro t
de l ng sa tor a co tt tona camsno cea l r s hlac
veopi ttz y nd nsiui l li
t
t l ry aied
ompli . Se Br kv.Ca r l,1 F. 241
ant e oc
r ol 07 3d ,
2 3(t Ci. 9 7 ( ti J, o l r ) Be u et Civo Ha tn, 7 F. 1 7 ,1 78(t Ci.1 5; e
4 4h r 1 9 ) Lut .c ncl i ; a d tv. t f mp o 7 5 2d 2 4 2 4h r 98 ) se
g,
r ng
as Go d nv. e e 5 4F.d1 47 1 51(t Ci.1 7 )(eo iigt tads c c u tsn te p ce t
lo r o Le k . 7 2 1 , 1 4h r 9 8 rc gnzn ha itit o r i o x e td o
m s t r eofadvoc t frapr K pli if.
s ume he ol
ae o o
antf)
2
To saeacam t e j 1 8 , p an if s alg Ghev oaino arg ts c r db
tt li md r 9 3 a litf mu t l e û i lto f i h e u e y
e t
t Co tt ton a lwsoft Unied St t ,a mus s t tt al ged de i ton wa
he nsiu i nd a
he t
aes nd
t how ha he le
prva i
s
c mmitdb apes na tn t e c l ro saelm ' W etv At i , 7U. 4 , 8( 9 8 .
o te y ro ci g md r oo f tt a ' s . kns 48 S. 2 4 1 8 )
Net rt NRVRJnorE INRVRJEmpl e 'i ana opraedee ntt aj198 acin.
ihe he
W I
oye s's ppr it fnda o
3 to
Se . ..W il M ih g n De to S aePoie 491U. 58 7 ( 9 9 ; co v Ch s pe k
e eR, l v. c ia p' f tt lc ,
S. , 0 1 8 ) Mc y . e a a e
Co r Ct 78 F. p 8 0, 9 -4 ( D. . r 1 ,1 9 )(e s n n al aeno a p o dae
r. n, 8 Su p. 9 8 3 9 E. Va Ap . 3 9 2 ra o i gj is r t p r p t
d fn a t t aj 1 8 a to ) Fe g s nv M o g n, 19 c 0 31 ,1 91U. Dit LEXI
ee d ns o
9 3 ci n ; r u o . r a No. :0 v 6 8 9
S. s.
S
8 9 , t* - ,1 91W L 1 5 5 , t* ( D. Y. t 2 ,1 91 ( o cu i gt a ag o p o
2 5 a 34 9
1 7 9 a 1 S. N. Jme 0 9 ) c n ld n h t r u f
pes nn l l eG le lye s'i no aG ro ' o p r o e o j1 8 ) M s , an ifd e
ro e,i i l mp o e , s t ç s n'f r u p s s f 9 3 . o Plitf o s
k a
'
pe
notale a ac ,o s i polc orc t pe s nal a ti a et Supe e
l ge ny t mi son, iy, usom r o ly trbut bl o
dnt ndent
W i tn, n la iiyt e j1 3ma n t p e iae o t te r o rs o d a s p ro .
nso a d ib l md r 98 y o be r dc td n he h o y f e p n e t u eir
t
Se . ..M o el De t fS c S r s, 36U.. 5 , 6 n., 919 ( 9 8 .
e eg, n lv. p' o o . e v .4
S 6 8 6 3 7 6 -4 1 7 )
Pli tf l ge t tDr M il rne i nty pr crbe ç eoxin ,' c c us d a
a n ifale s ha . le glge l es i d ç l c m 'whih a e n
M
al r cr a to Pl i ifalo al gest thi s nstviy t a i edinfi t bl c m 'i
le gi e c i n. antf s le ha s e ii t o n ngr e n : oxi n ' s
M
dool nt d i ffe n ye r wo t ofm e ca r or i Dr M ilrspos es i n. Tli c am of
me e n ite a s rh
di l ec ds n . le '
s so
zs l i
ne lg n ei is m ce t osaeacam t e j1 3.Fu temo e t ealg dfc ta Dr
gi e c s n u in t tt li md r 98
rh r r ,h l e a t h t .
e
M ilrco d ha dico r d t r e n doc e a
le ul ve s ve e he elva t um nt bouta a lr i notal s i intt
n le gen s
one ufk e o
pr e apl usbl Ei h Am e
es nt a i e ght
ndme c am ofde i r t i fe e . Se .e. , a e v.
nt l i
lbe a e ndif r nce e :.D ns r
Sa b ny 7 2F.d3 0 3 (t Ci. 01 )(e o lzn t a alblt o ar lv n
tns e ', 7 3 4 , 48 4h r 2 4 r c g ig he v ia ii f ee a t
y
d cl n t a wo l h v p e e tdt eij wa n t tda t wh t ra a ra t al
o l t h t u d a e rv ne h n my s o mae l o ehe n do cu l
me
y
a p e itdt ers o hn m)
p r cae h ik f r .
Ac o dn l , ds s tec mplitwi u p eu iefrfiigt saeacam a an t
c r ig y I imis h o an t t rj dc o al o tt li g is
ho
n
t c e de e nt and u whih r i fm a begr nt d.Relt dl t m o i n f raTRO i
he = nt f nda s
pon c ele y
a e
a e y, he to o
s
3
de e be aus Pli iff ist s tsy t notc r quie ntf aTRO a t e e ntt the
ni d c e antf al o aif he ie e r me or
nd he l me ha
i lkey t s e ont m ei soft dim is c
s i l o ucc ed he zt he s s ed ompl i . Se e. ,W i e v. t a Re .
ant e. g. nt r Na ur l s
De . t i. n .5 5U. 7, ( 0 )
f Comcl I c, 5 S. 20 20 8 .
Tot e tn P an ifma b a et saecamsa an taG ro ' u j c t j 1 8 ,
he x e t litf y e bl o tt li g i s G s n's b e t o 9 3
pe
Pl i ifi gr nt d t n dayst f l a m oton t n e t co pl ntt ts a esa c ai upo
a ntf s a e e
o ie
i o m nd he m ai ha t t
lm
n
wli h r i m a be F a e agans ape s aci unde col ofsa el' Se .e. ,Gor
lc elef y
nt d i t r on tng
r or tt a
w. e g. don,
574 F. a 115 Pl i ifm a fnd i pr e a et t kel rt n t n da t c ul l l
2d t 2. antf y i t ef r bl o a onge ha e ys o ons t ega
r s c ,t nk a
e our es hi bouthi alegai ,a fl ane c
s l tons nd ie
w ompl i i ane a s pa a ea ton.I
ant n
w nd e r t c i
f
Plitf c o e no t fl t emoinwihntnd ys t c s wil co e wi u p eudc ,
an if ho s s t o ie h to t i e a ,he a e lbe l s d t t rj ie
ho
a dPlitf wo dn t prj dc dbe a s h i al we t fl ac mp a h ane a d
n anif ul o be eu ie c u e e s lo d o e o lht & w n
spaaea to a t etmeo hsc ies b e tt t a p ia elmi to p ro .Se . ..
e rt cin t h i f i hoc u j c o he p lc bl i t ins e id e eg,
a
Owe v Ok e 48 U. 23 , 49 5 ( 9 9 ; . d j8012 3 A) s eas Ry nv.
ns . ur, 8 S. 5 2 - 0 1 8 ) Va Co e . - 4 ( ; e lo a
Go ae ,1 3S. . 9 , 08( 3 ( tngdsrc c u tsds rto t mmlg iso
nz ls 3 Ct 6 6 7 201 ) noi itit o r' icein o a e t wn
doc t)
kes.
I Pli tf nse ru he a c
f a n ifi t ad s s nd hoos st s e a a
e o e k n mendme i t sc e he s d kno
nt n hi as , houl
w
t a ac u t y ds s a n nd dc mpan wihp eu iea fi lu o frfiigt s e
h t o r ma imis n me e o lit t rj dc s rvoo s r o al o Gt
n
ac am upon whih r le m a be g ant a as e saR ti ' Pl i ifs td unde sa t t
li
c ei f y
r ed nd s s stke. antf hotl
'
rt nd ha
he i a l e onl t ee Gs rke ' 9om bot co pl i si di ti tco ut a a a s i c t of
s low d y hr
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?