Rosario v. Breckon

Filing 27

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Glen E. Conrad on 9/11/2019. (slt)

ULERTS OFFI U..DI O UFI
CE S 8%
ATRoa oc ,
vA

FL J
IE;

I TH E UN I D STA TES D I
N
TE
STR I CO UR T
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STR I O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
R O A N O K E D I SI
W ON

SEF 11 2 1
29
JULK

DUD

uBK
-

ua o
vj'

R AM O N R O SA RI ,
O

IC RK

.' K
,
ck

CA SE N O .7:
18CV 00255

Pe i i r,
t tone
V.

M EM O R AND U M O PI O N
NI

M .BRECKON,

By: Gl n E.Conr
e
ad
Seni U nied St D i t ctJudge
or
t
ates s ri

R e ponde .
s
nt

Rn o Ros do,a f de ali aepr e ng pr K ,fld t spe ii n f rawrtofha as
m n
a
e r nm t oc edi
o
ie hi tto o
i
be
.

c r u u d r2 U. C.â2 41 Reyng o Untd S ae v.W h ee ,8 6 F.d 41 (t Ci.
o p s n e 8 S.
2 . li n ie tts
e lr 8 3 5 4 h r
2 8, U. C. 2 5 4 a dBu r g v. ie S ae ,5 1U. 2 4 ( 1 ) Ro ai s e st
01 ) 28 S. j 2 5 $, n ra e Untd tt s 7 S. 0 20 4 , s ro e k o
i i et s nt nc i
nvaldat he e e e mpos o hi byt Unie St t sDititCotr f t M i eDiti t
ed n mf he t d a e src tt or he ddl src

o Flrd i Se tmb ro 1 9 , s No 9 - 0 -rOr- 2 ( ) o rv e o ter c r ,
f oi a n p e e f 9 8 Ca e . 8 1 0c - 12 c S1 .Up n e iw f h e o d
t c tco l
he our ncudest tt r s
ha he e ponde ' m o i t dim ist pe ii mus be g a e
nts ton o s s he tton
t ' nt d.
r

1.

On M ac 21 1 8 e r e c me ia e vc s (EM S' pes nn lr s o d d t a
rh , 99 , meg n y dc lsr ie : ' ro e e p n e o
G
)
pos i eo r ea ar i nc i Ora
sbl ve dos t esde e n l ndo, ordmlW he EM S a ve , t y e ot t r d J m es
Fl i
n
ni d he nc m e e n
Ros nbll ,a l ye - d m a e who wass f rng fom r s r t r f iur a a a
e lm
7- arol l ,
ufe i r e pia o y al e nd n ppre dnl
nt g
o r e.Hi m o he wa ad i se i CPR.EM S a nit r oxyge a N a c adr t t
ve dos
s t r s m nit rng
dmi se ed
n nd r an, ug ha
c mtr c s a opit ove dos a ta pore hi t a hos t l The e,he r ceved f t r
ot e a t n a e r e, nd r ns td m o
pia .
r
e i
urhe
te t nta wa a itd t t i e i ca e Ini i c iialco to To co og t tng
r a me nd s dm te o he nt nsve r l t n rtc
ndii n. xi l y esi

1 Thef csandpr dur lhit y, whih aenotdiput ar tke 9om t paris s
at
oce a sor
c r
s ed, e a n
he te ' ubmisons i l ng
s i , ncudi
t copisofdocl nt fo Ros s ci na pr ee ngsa t hed t t mo i t dimis a c tr or
he
e
lme s r m
mio' rmi l oc di tac
o he ton o s s nd our ec ds
a lbl onlne
vaia e i .

r v ae t ep e e e o heon hy r c lrd a ma i a i Ro e bu ss se He as
e e ld h r snc f r i d o ho i e nd r u na n s n lm' y tm.
j
lo
r poredha ng i se alohol a i sn i sand a tbitc .Hi te tngphyscanuli ael
e t vi nge td c , nthit m ne
ni ois s r ai
i i tm t y
dignos d Ros nbll a ha ng s f r a he oi o r e. He r mai d i i e i c e f
a
e
e lm s vi ufe ed
r n ve dos
e ne n ntnsve ar or
t da .
wo ys
The i si tng ag nt l n n d f o Ros nbll t the ha ptr ha e t he oi he
nve tga i
e ere rm
e tm ha
d lc s d he r n
i se fom Ka l Va ue on M a ch 20,1
nge td r
ros zq z
r
998. The a ntt i e vi wed Va quez who
ge hen nt r e
z
,
ad itd pr di t he oi t Ros nbl afe pur ha i i f o Ros ro.
m te ovi ng he r n o
e um tr c sng t ' m
r
ai

A g a djlyo t Unt dS ae DititCo r f rteM i l Ditito Flrd rtln d
rn t f he ie tts src u to h dde src f o ia el e
r
r
a s pe s di i cm e ,c r ng Ros ro wih c pii t pos e s he o n wih i e t
u r e ng ndi t nt ha gi
a i t ons rng o
ss r i
t ntnt o

d srb t,nvo ain o 2 U. C.j8 6.Ro ai v. l e S ae , 9 - 30 ( . F ..On
itiue i ilto f 8 S. 4
s ro Urtd tts No. 9 6 4 M D. 1)
i
J 1 1998, a i plade guit t t c x ,ptr ua t awrte pl a e me .
une 7,
Ros ro e d ly o he ha ge ts nt o
itn ea gr e nt

Thep ee tnc iv si ainrpo t & R' r ctdt eo fn ec n u ts mmaie h r
r sn e e n e tg to e r (
TS ' e ie h fe s o d c u rz d ee
)
a r c me d t tRos ro s ld be hed a c mt bl f 2. gr m s of he oi a t
nd e om nde ha
a i hotl
l c ot a e or 6 a
r n nd he
diti i n ofhe oi t tc us d Ros nbl ' ne rf t o dos . Se Re M o .Dim .Ex.4,
srbuto
r n ha a e
e um s a -aal ver e e n. t s

ECFNo 1 Ass c t PS f u dt a t e 2 U. C. 8 ( )1( , e a s ted sdb to
. 4. u h,he R o n h tmd r 8 S. j 41b ( )C)b c u e h it ui n

r s le i G eiusb dl ij r , Ro ai wa s be t oama d tr mi mu s n e c o 20
e utd n ç ro o i nu y' s ro s u j c t
s
y
'
n ao y ni m e tn e f
y a si p io a d ama i m o lf .Un e j2 .()2 o t U. Se tn i Guieie
e r n rs n n
xmu f ie d r D11a( ) f he S. ne cng d l s
n

M a u l CUS P' b c u e t e o fn e rs le i s ro b dl ij r ,te P a sg e
n a G SI I e a s h fe s e utd n eius o iy nu y h SR s in d
,
Ros o' Ba eOfe eLe la 38.W ih at e poi r duc i f a ce a eofr s nsbiiy,
mi s s f ns ve t
t hr e- nt e ton or c pt nc
e po i lt
hi Tot lOf e e Le lw asc c a e a 35.The PSR al o c c a e t tRos r o,a a 21, d
s a f ns ve
al ul t d t
s al ul t d ha
a i t ge ha

aCrm i lHit y Ca e y VI Thus hi m a t y s ntncnggu dei r ngewa 29 t 365
i na sor t gor .
, s nda or e e i
i lne a
s 2 o

mo t ( 4y as 4mo t s t 3 y a s 5mo t s.
nhs 2 e r, n h ,o 0 e r , nh )

Att s nt ncng he rng on Se e be 11,1 ,t gove nm e moved f t s nt nc
he e e i
ai
ptm r
998 he
r nt
or he e e e
e nc m e souti d i t PSR. Ros nbl ' teai physca t tfe t tRos nbll '
nha e nt
lne n he
e um s r tng
i in esii d ha
e lm s
co to on M a c 21,1
ndii n
rh
998,pr e e a s rousrs o l soflf wihoutte t e ,ba e on
es nt d e i
ik f os
ie t
r am nt s d
r po t t twhe EM S a ve hehad nopulea wasnotbr t
e rs ha
n
ni d,
s nd
eaMng,a on hi c to upo
nd
s ondii n n
a va a t hos t . M ot Dim .Ex.2,a 1 ECF No.11- The doc o a s t si d t t
ni l t he pial
. s
t 0,
2.
t r lo e tse ha
alhough Ros nbll ha i t d a c
t
e tm d ngese
ombi ton ofs aln ount ofot r s tnce ,wihout
na i
m l m
s
he ubsa s t

t heoi t eot rs t e c ne woul notha ca e r piaor f iur J at20.
he r n,hes he ubsanc s ombi d
d
ve us d es r t y al e. .
Z
Thedocora fr e t ti he o ni Ros nbl ç e inci ahe oi ove dos whe he
t fim d ha n r pi on, e um ç
was xpere ng
r n r e
n
c
nmet t hos t l' I a 21 22.
o he pia . d. t '
The cour a ce ed t PSR a a e t tt evi nce s
t c pt he
nd gr ed ha he de
uppore a ia i oft
td pplc ton
he

j8 ( )1( sa uo y e h n e n a d US j2 .()2 , a igt eba eo fns lve a
41b ( )C) tt tr n a c me t n SG D1 1a ( )plcn h s fe e e l t
38. The c tgr nt d Ros ro a t e poi r uci n f a ce a e of r s i lt a
our a e
ai
hr e- nt ed to or c ptnc
e ponsbiiy nd
s ntnc d hi t 292 m on hsi prs t bo tm oft gti lner nge Ros do i c r nty i
e e e m o
t n ion, he to
he zdei a .
a s ure l n

c so y a t eUntd S ae Pe ie tay i Le Comt ,Vigna Hi prj ce r la e d t i
u td t h ie tts ntnir n e t y r ii. s oe td ee s ae s
J l 1 , 0 4 Se h s/uy 5 2 2 . e lp :
/

.o g v imaeo /(e rhBOPRe itrNu e 2 0 6 01 )
b p.o /n tlc s ac
gse mb r 3 8 - 8 .

Ro ai a pe ld t j d me t ag i t tlse h n e sn e c wa s mu h g e tr
s ro p ae he u g n, r ung ha l n a c d e tn e s o c rae
i
t n t a t lof e es ntnc t tt dititc ts ul ha a i d a c e ra c ncng
ha he c ua f ns e e e ha he src our ho d ve pple
l a nd onvi i
e de e sa r i t d of a pr po r nce oft e de e sa r The El ve h Cic t
vi nc t nda d, nsea
e nde a
he vi nc t nda d.
e nt r ui

Co r o Ap e l afr dtej d me t Uni d S ae v. s o, 8 F.d 1 8( 1hCi.1 9 )
u t f p as fime h u g n . t tt s Ro mi 1 1 3 0 1 t r 9 9
e
(mpubls d) c r.de ed,528U. 978(
t
ihe , e t ni
S. Nov.1 1 .
, 999)
Ros ro fl d a moton t va a e s tasde,orcorec hi s ntnc pur ua t 28 U. C.
ai e
i o c t, e i
r t s e e e s nt o
S.

j2255i t Unie Sae DititCour f rMidl Ditito Flrda.Thec tdimis dli
n he td tts src
t o d e src f oi
our s se ls

m oton o De mbe 8, 2000, a tm e ba r d.
i
n
ce r
s i
re

Ros ro v. Urie Stt , N o.
ai
lt d a es

60 c 5 3 vORI2 ( . F . 0 0 , c d 31F. p' 9 8( 1hCi. 0 2 .
:0 v1 3 c
-2C M D. 1 2 0 ) a ,
Ap x 3 1 t r 2 0 )
W hieRos rowa co i da af r prs i So hCa olna, fldaj2241peii
l ai s nfne t edeal ion n ut r i he ie
tton
i t Unie St t s Ditit Co t f r t Ditit of Sout Ca olna. Ros o v. F. I
n he
td ae
src
ur o he src
h r i
mi
C..

Bemetv l , 9:6 0 3 ( S. )
l ts il No. 1 CV0 0 3 D. C..Hùa g e t a teFlrd dsrc c ur i r pel
e
r u d h t h o i a itit o t mp o ry
e
nhanc hi s e efom 24 mont t 24 ye s whe hewa ,i f t a t ly i e oft
ed s entnc '
r
hs o
ar , n
s n ac , c ual nnoc nt he

f t ne esay t s
acs c s r o uppor t te nc me i lghtofBtrage 1 4 S.Ct a 892 ( di t t
t ha nha e nt n i
lr , 3
.t
hol ng ha

d f n a t n n t a esn e c e h nc dt e 21U. C. 8 ( )1( wheet eus o ad u
e e d n c n o h v e tn e n a e md r
S. j 41b ( )C) r h e f r g

h d srb tdwa no t u-o 'c u eo t d ah o ij r ) eSo t Caoi adsrc c u t
e itiue s t û tf r' a s f he e t r nu y .Th u h r ln itit o r
b
dimi s d t pe ii upon fndi t tt Fourh Cic tha not a t ttm e, d t taf de a
s s e he tton
i ng ha he
t r ui d , t ha i hel ha e r l

d f n a t o l u eaj22 p tto t c alng t evai iyo l ssn e ea i o e Ro ai
ee d n c ud s
41 ei n o h l e h ldt fl e tnc s mp s d. s ro
i
e
i
v. C.. n etvi e No 9:6 0 3 , 01 W L 49 1 6 , 3( S. Au 1 20 6 .
F. I Be n ts l , . 1 CV0 0 3 2 6
l
5 1 3 * D. C. g. 0, 1 )
I t p e e t t inu e j2 41 Ro ai s e srle u d rW h ee,8 6F.d a 4 ,
n he rs n pei o nd r 2 , s ro e k eif n e e lr 8 3 t 23
t
i whih t Fourh Cic tr c ni d lm ie cic sa eswhe eaf de alde e
n c he
t r ui e og ze i t d r um t nc
r e r f ndan m a brng
t y i

aj2241cam c le nghi s ntnc asi e Rosroc ntndst lse nce s ntnc
li halngi s e e e mpos d. ai o e hata nha d e e e
i

i u c nsiui n lb c us h tsa tal ino e to t e o ed s /o y ij r e h nc me t
s n o t to a e a e e E cu l n c n f h v r o eb d n u y n a e n
t
i
y
s ntnc i lg of' r e.M e .
e e e n i ht Burac
m Supp. t 3,
Pe . ECF No.1 1 Ther s
-.
e ponde hasfl am o i
nt
ed
ton
t dim is a Ros ro hasr ponde m adngt m a trrpef diposton.
o s s , nd
ai
es
d, l he te i or s ii

1
l.

A prs rge r l mus fl amoi t rj2255t c ltrly atc t lgalt of
ione nealy t ie
ton mde
o olaeal ta k he e iy
hi dee inunde afdealc cinorsntnc 28U. C.j22554 .Da sv. t Stt ,
s tnto
r e r onvito
e e e.
S.
4, vi Unied aes

41 U. 3 3 3 3( 9 4 .A dsrc c t t n o e tran ap tto f rawrto h be sc r us
7 S. 3 , 4 1 7 )
itit ol c nn t ne ti eiin o
r
i f a a op

4

u e j2 41p t in c aln i afd r l o r j d me t n e samo inp rua tt 2 U. C.
nd r 2 ei o h le gng e e a c u tu g n u ls
t
to u s n o 8 S.
j2 5i Gn d q aeo ie fciet ts t elg l y o ( a imaes d tnin. 2 U..
25 s l a e u t r n fe tv o et h e ai f t t n t') ee to ' 8 SC.
i
t
h
'
j2 5$ (t s vn ca s ' ;Un td S ae v.Whe lr 8 6 F.d 41 , 3 (t Ci. 8 .
25 ( Ehe a igs lu e' ie tts
t
)
ee , 8 3 5 42 4 h r 201 )
G -j erme y afr e b j 2 5 i n trnd r di a e uaeo i efci me ey b c u e a
ll h e d fo d d y 2 5 s o e ee n d q t r n fe tve r l e a s n
li vi
ndi dualhas be n una e t obt i r le under t t pr son,or bec us a i vi
e
bl o an ei f
ha ovii
a e n ndi duali
s

p o e urlyba e fo fl aj2 5 mo in' n r Vil 1 5F.d 1 9 ,1 9 n. ( t Ci.
r c d al n'd r m ii
ng
2 5 to .
'I e a, 1 3 1 2 1 4 5 4h r
1 9 )2
9 7.
Th Untd Sae Co r o Ap e l f rt eFo rh Cic i ha c n l e t tj2 5 i
e ie tts u t f p as o h u t r ut s o cud d ha 2 5 s
i qua ea i fe vet t tt l ga iy ofa s n e e whe
nade t nd ne f di o es he e lt
e t nc
n:

( )a t e tme o s n e cng s tld 1w o ti cruto t e S p e Co r
1 t h i f e tn i , et a f h s ic i r h u rme u t
e
e tbls e t e lg lt o t e sn e c ;( )s bs q e tt te p io e ' dr c
sa ih d h e aiy f h e tn e 2 u e u n o h rs n rs ie t
a p a a dfrtj2 5 mo in t eao e nine stlds b tn ie1w c a e
p e l n is 2 5 to ,h f rme to d ete u sa tv a h ng d
a d wa d e d t a py rto ciey o c l tr lr ve ()t prs n ri
n s e me o p l er a tv l n ol ea e iw; 3 he io e s
a
u a l t me t h g tk e n p o so so j2 5 ( 2 frs c ndo s c e sve
n b e o e t e ae e pig r viin f 2 5 1 ) o e o r u c si
$(
mo in ; n ()d t t sr to ci c a e tesn e c n w p e e t a er r
to s a d 4 ue o hi er a tve h ng ,h e tn e o rs n s n ro
s tce l g a t bede m e af nda nt lde e t
ufi inty r ve o
e d u me a f c .
W heee ,88 F. a 429.I e l tngt s t tvel w i as vi ca ea l i,t cour
lr 6 3d t
n vaua i he ubsan i a n a ngs lus nays s he
t
mus E ook t t s t ntve 1w oft cic t whe e a de e n wa c c e ' Hn v.
tç
l
o he ubsn i a
he r ui
r
f nda t s onvit d.
' hn

M o ee ,9 F.d 2 5 3 0 01(t Ci. 01 )(p ynga ay i i I r J n s 2 6 F.d 3 ,
s ly 31 3 9 , 0 - 4 h r 2 9 a pli n lss n n e o e , 2 3 28
3 3 3 ( t Ci.2 0 )r g r ig j2 41c le et t elg ly o c n ito ) TheFlrd
3 - 4 4h r 0 0 e adn
2 halng o h e ai f o vcin .
t
o ia
ditit c twher Rosro was c ce i wihi t Elve h Cic t 28 U. C.j41.
src our
e ai
onvitd s t n he e nt rui.
S.

2 The c r has o te i ena quo ai ma ks atr tons a o ciai hee a t o hou t s
ou t
mitd ntr l t ton r , le ai , nd/r ttons r nd hr ug t hi
me a l o ni t e sot rwienotd.
mor ndlm pi on,mls he s e

Acc di l whiet co tmus a y t pr dtr lsa r i W he l r3i mus do s usng
or ngy, l he ur
t ppl he oce la t nda d n
ee, t t o i

Elve t Cic ts tntvelw.Ju
e nh rui ubsa i a -s
d
Ros ro hass wn unde t s co W heeerf t ,t ta trhi c ci n,t s tl d
ai
ho
r he e nd
l acor ha fe s onvito he e te
s tntve 1w r lt d t t tc c i c nge whe t Supr me Cour de i d Bur a I
ubsa i a ea e o ha onviton ha d
n he
e
t c de
r ge. n

Bu r g ,te Cout l t a t a py t sau o y sn e c ela c me tu d rj8 () 1( ,
ra e h t'hed h t o p l he ttt r e tn e r n e n n e 41b ( )C)
h
t go r me mus me ta G f ' c us ton t t by pr ng t tE f ' t d ug t tt
he ve n nt
t e t or' a a i es,
but
ovi ha G or' he r ha he
but

def nda diti e t ove dos vitm w o dno ha di d o s f r dbodiy ha m .571U .
e nt srbut d, he r e ci
ul t ve e r ufe e
l r
S.

a 21 - 7 Th Co r as hedt a tb e a eteGe t rs t' n a c me tgnj8 ( )1( )
t 1 1 . e u t lo l h tl j c us h d ah euls e h n e n i 41b ()C)
l
i r as t milmum a m a mum s ntnc st whih Buragewase
nc e ed he zi
nd xi
e e e o c
r
xpos d,i i a ee e
e t s n lm nt

t t t s b te t t ejzya df u dbe o dar a o b ed u t' J a 21
ha mus be u mitd o h t n o n y n e s na l o b . . t 0.
r
'Z
Ros ro' j2241peii fis howe r bec us hec r ts a rquie unde t
ai s
tton al,
ve, a e amo how s e r d
r he
s c W he l rf c ort tt c ng m oughtby t Burage de i i a e t e e t a y
e ond
e e a t ha he ha es
he r
c son r i m d o ppl
de
r toa tvel on c l tr lr vi ' W he e ,886 F. a 429. On t c r r t El ve h
er ci y
olae a e em '
elr
3d t
he onta y, he e nt
Cic ta ot rc t wihi t tcr ui ha hel t tBuragedoe nota y r toaci l o
r ui nd he ours t n ha ic t ve d ha
r
s
ppl er tvey n

c laea rv e Her r v. a d n FCC Coe n, 9 F.Ap x 8 9 8 ( 1h Ci. 01 )
o ltrl e iw. re a W r e s
lma 5 6
p' 5 , 61 1 t r 2 5 ;
UntdS ae v. u le , 3:O OM CW EM T, 01 W L 6 5 6 4, t* ( D. a De .1
ie tts Bo rir No. I CR3 /
2 4
7 0 7 a 2 N. Fl. c ,

2 4 (iigo h rc s s;Al rzv. si s No CV21 - 7 , 01 W L 4 8 7 3 a *1( D.
01 ) ctn t e a e ) vae Ha t , .
nz
40 0 2 4
3 5 0 , t S.
Ga S p ., 01 )(iig Elve t Cic i' d cso d n i peiin rsa piainf rla t
. e ts 2 4 ct
n e nh ruts e iin e yng t o e ' p lc to o e ve o
t
fl s cond ors e sve 2255 moton bas on Burage i plcti whi h i t co l i t t
ie e
ucc s i
i
ed
r ,m ii n
c s he ncuson ha

Burag i notr r ctvel a ia e.TheFourhCicuiha as de i t hol t Bura
r e s etoa i y pplc bl)
t r t s lo clned o d hat rge

3 Thecou tnotst tt Elve h Cicui hase e sy hed t tçacha i c ea doesnotma a
r e ha he e nt r t
xpr s l l ha t nge n as lw
ke
moton t va t aprs rss ntnce&nade t ori f tvet t tt lgalt ofhi de e ton.'M cca ha v.
i o cae ione ' e e i quae nefeci o es he e iy
s t n i ''
rt n

Die tro Go d lI utissu o s. n .8 F.d 1 7 1 8 -6( 1hCi. 7 ( b n )(in 28U. C.
rco f o wilnd sre- nc atI c, 51 3 0 6, 0 58 1 t r201) 0 a c ct g
i
S.
52 5e) Th s Ro ai' Burc cam u e j2 41wo l bes u dyrj ce i ac u t ti ta crut
25 (). u , sros ra e li nd r 2
ud o n l ee td n o r wihn h t ic i.

i r toa tvey a iabl t ca e on c lt r r e .Se ,e. ,At nsv.O' i n,1 F. pp.
s e r ci l pplc e o s s ola e al eviw
e c. ki
Bre 48 Su

3 5 , 5 ( D. . . 01 )( e l i gt a pl Bu g rto cieya ctn o h rc s s,
d 47 5 2 N. W Va 2 5 d ci n o p y aa e er a tv l nd iig t e a e)
n

apd 6 F. p' 25 ( t Ci. 01 )(fimig Go t era o ssae b t d src c uf'.
f . 47 Ap x 4 4h r 2 6 afr n t r h e s n ttd y he itit o l l
f
Ba e on t s p e de ,t cou tco l
sd
hi r ce nt he r ncudest tRos do ha nots tsi t s cond W heee
ha
a
s
a ifed he e
lr
fco .
a tr

M or ve ,tBuraq ha notbe n he d t a y t t Se e ng Gui lne . Yot v.
eo r l r e s
e l o ppl o he nt nci
dei s'
'
mg

An o liNo CV OT8 I O CM C- J 2 9W L 40 41 3 a * ( S. J n. 3, 1 ) rpo t
tnel, .
I - OI P G, 01
4 1 , t 2 D. C. a 2 20 9 ,e r
a d rc mme d to a o td No CV 0:8 1 0 CM C,20 9 W L 31 23 8 ( S. J y 1 ,
n e o n ain d p e , .
1 - 01 1
6 9 D. C. ul 6
201 ) Sic Bu r g ,ma y c u t h v r a h dt ec n l so t a ish l ig a piso yt
9 . n e ra e n o rs a e e c e h o cu i n h t t o dn p le nl o
t sauoy de t e nc me tf
he tt tr ah nha e n ound i 21U. C.j8 a nott t c ola ye nc me s
n
S.
41 nd o he or lr nha e nt

f t i te S n e cn Gud ln s S e eg, d (iig Pee - ln v. Bre Ci lAcin
omd n h e tn i g ieie . e , ..i . ctn rz coo O' in, vi to

No. :4 1 , 1 W L 71 81 6 a * ( D. . . c 8 201 )( o dn t a Bt r g E o s
11 CV1 9 20 6
6 8 , t 6 N. W Va De . , 6 h l ig h t t a e ç e
r
d
no a y ...whee t dititc ta id a sntncngenha me ,nota f ngt rj
t ppl
r he src our pple e e i
nce nt
mdi mde

8 ( )1( '; wel Uni dS e , v l . 0 CV21 ( , 01 W L 5 9 6 a *
41b ()C)) Po l v. t its Cii No 3:9
'
e
41EBB) 2 4
0 27 2, t 1
( Co n. t 1 , 01 )(po l' r l n eo Bu rc i mipa e f rma y ra o s no t e
D. n Oc. 0 2 4 i wels ei c n ra e s s lc d o n e s n , t h
s
a
las of whih i t tt m ur r c os -e e e g de i i o y a s nt nci f c o ,not a
e t
c s ha he
de r sr f r nce ui lne s nl
e e ng a t r
n
elm e oft ofe e ofco c i a a s h,i nota f c e i a w a by Bur a a t
e nt he f ns
nviton nd, s uc s
fe t d n ny y
r ae, nd he

r l i n n u c d d e n trn e hi a tal in c n o tes ne c e h c me t' Th s
ue t n o n e o s o e d r m cu ly n o e t f h e tn e n mze n ). u ,

Ro a i' rla c o Bu r g t c alng t ea plc to o teb dl ij r g i eiei li c s
sro s ein e n ra e o h le e h p iain fh o iy n u y u d ln n l a e
s
i m i pl c d.
s s ae

Fort r as saed,t c tconcudest tRos ro c nnotm e tt W heee f t s
he e ons t t he our
l
ha
ai a
e he
lr acor

r q ie t pr c e u e j2 41 a t s vng ca s t h ve h s s ne c r vstd
e ur d o o e d nd r 2 nd he a i s lu e o a i e tn e e iie .
Ac r i y,t c twilg a tt m oto t dim is a dim is Ros ro' pe ii wiho
co d ngl he our l r n he
i n o s s nd s s
a i s tton t ut

p eu ie fr lc o j s ito W h ee ,8 6 F.d a 4 425 ( lig t t j2 5 i
rj dc o a k f mi dcin. e lr 8 3 t 2 - hodn ha 25 /) s
j ds ito a) Ana p o raeo d rwil n e t i d y.
u dcin l. p r p it r e l e tr h s a
TheCl r i die t dt s nd c esoft sm e o a l opi o a ac ompa ngor r
e k s r c e o e opi
hi m r ndlm ni n nd c
nyi
de
t peii ra t co elofr co df rt r ponde .
o ttone nd o uns
e r o he es
nt
sxe
rsR: Thi ' 1 da orse e be ,201
s1* y
pt m r
9.

Se o Unie Stt sDititJ
ni r t d a e src udge

8