Campbell v. Brown

Filing 20

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Jackson L. Kiser on 5/28/2019. (slt)

CLERK' OFFI u. . :m COUX
S
CE s Dl
,
'T DM vttE,
A
VA
FI
LED

I TH E U NI
N
TED STA TES DI
STR I CO UR T
CT

FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A

MA 23 2 1
t
99

ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON

BqlYuL% j
YkcjDec M
2 A CLER
:=
HF
DEPUW

J ES W .CAM PBELL,SR .
AM
,
Pe ii r,
t tone

CA SE N O .7: 8CV 00
1
277.

V.

M EM O M ND U M O PI I N
N O

TAM M Y BR O W N ,

By: H o Jac on L .K i e
n. ks
sr
Se or U nied St e D i t i Judge
ni
t
at s s r ct
R espondent
.

Pe ii r J m e W .Ca
ttone , n s
mpbel,Sr,aVigi ai t pr edi :r K ,tld t s a ton
l .
r ni nma e oce ng o
ie hi ci
.

a apeii f rawrtofha asc pusunde 28U. C.j2254.Reponde ha sld amoin
s tton o
i
be or
r
S.
s
nt s e
to

t ds s, ungt a t ep tto s o db ds se wih u p eu c be a et ecamsae
o imis rg i h t h eiin h ul e imis d to t rj die c us h li r
u e h u td. S e 28 U. C.j2 5 ( ) Afe rv e o t e p tto a d sae c u tr c r s
n x a se e
S.
2 4 b . tr e iw f h eiin n tt o r e o d
a ia e o lne, c l t tt m o i n t dimism us bede ed.
val bl n i l oncude ha he to o s s
t
ni

Ca
mpbe li deai d purua t t fnalo de s of t Cic t Cour of Amhe s Count
l s t ne
s n o i
r r
he r ui
t
rt
y

e trd o Aug t2 ,2 5 ( s No CR1 01 21 - 0 a d No e e 9 20 5 ( s No
n ee n
us 6 01 Ca e . 5 5 3 0 ) n
v mb r , 1 Ca e .
CR1 01 3 7 0 ) Boh o t e ec n cin ao e o to te smes to crl tn e ,b ta
5 5 0 - 0 . t f h s o vito s r s u f h n e f icl a c s u t
ms
Ca
mpbelsr ques,t cr ui c ts ve e t c r s a he wa co c e i t s pa a e
l' e t he ic t our e r d he ha ge nd
s nvit d'n wo e r t
ti l.
ras

I Ca eNo.
n s
CR1501521 00, ferabe hti , m pbe l sc c e o ma a t i
3- a t
nc ralCa
l wa onvit d'f nuf curng
me ha
t mphen i and s nt nc t 25ye r i ionm e , t 1 yea ss pe
tm ne
e e ed o
a s' mprs
nt wih 4 r us nded.TheCour
t
ofAppe l ofVigi a r ve s d t sconviton,a t Co monwe t a pe e The Supr m e
as
r ni e r e hi
c i nd he m
a1h p ald.
e

Co r o Vignarves dtej g n o tec ur o a pe l,en ttdtecrutc u tso d r
u t f r ii e re h ud me t f h o t f p as ri sae h ic i o r' r e
o c n ito ,a d e tr d fn l ud me tfrt e Co n at o De e e 1 2 1 . Se
f o vcin n nee ia j g n o h mmo we 1 n c mb r 4, 0 7 e
h

Cn belv. mmo we l 791S. 2 3 ( . p. 0 6 , e d 8 7 S. 2d7 5( . 01 )
mp l Co n at
h,
E.d 51 Va Ap 2 1 ) rv' 0 E. 3 Va 2 7 ,
c r. e i4 1 9S. . 21( 2 , 01 ) rh' d nid 1 9 S. . 24 ( b.1 , 9 .
e td n e , 3 Ct 4 Od. 9 2 8 , e z e e , 3 Ct 1 4 Fe 9 201 )
l Cas No.
n e
CR15 307- Ca
015
00, mpbe le e e aco
l nt r d
ndhi na pl a ofguit t pos es i
o l e
ly o s son

wi itn t d srb t meh mp tmiet n ig t o to o g ija p a o t ep era
t ne t o itiu e t n hea n t dn he u c me f hs p e l f h rtil
h
pe
moin . ( s ' Ex. a 3( No 1 -2. ecr ut o r s ne e Ca b l t 1 y a s
to s' Rep.s B, t ECF . 42 )Th ic ic u t e tnc d mp elo 1 e r
'
i prs n, onc r n wih hi ot rsa es ntnc TheCour ofAppe l ofVigi aa fr e t s
n i o c ur e t t s he tt e e e.
t
as
r ni fim d hi

cn cin Cn b lv. mmo we lt81 S. 2 6 3( . p. 01 ) Th Su e Co r
o vito . mp el Co n at 7 E.d 6 Va Ap 2 8. e prme ut
l
o Vigi ar f s d Cn pbe lss e nta
f r ni e u e m l' ubs que ppea i t tc ton Aprl29,201
l n ha our
i
9.

Ca l sgne a dae hi j225 peiin onJ 1 2018 r ii t s mecams
mpbel i d nd td s
4 tto
une 2, , asng he n li
f r r if t t li ator y pr e e i a at he sa e c ta la e bre . Att ttme,
o ele ha ls ' ne es nt d n n tac d, t t our ppe lt if
t
ha i
Ca
mpbe lspeii f rawrtofc ri a ir ga di Ca eNo.CR15015 3- wassilpe ng
l' tton o
i
e tor r e f ng s
21 00
tl ndi
i t Unie Stt sSu e Cou t a li a alr ga di Ca eNo.CR15
n he t d a e pr me
r, nd ts ppe e r ng s
01530 00 wassil
7tl
pe ng i t Supr m e Co tofVig ni Ac or ng y,i Oc obe 201 Re ponde m o d t
ndi n he
e
ur
r i a. c di l n t r 8, s
nt ve o

ds s Ca b l' peiin f rfiu et e h u tsaec u t e de ,wi u p eudc t hs
imis mp els t o o alr o x a s tt o r rme is t t rj ie o i
t
ho
a lt t r fl li c am si ane peii n a trhi a pe swer c
biiy o e ie ls l i n
w tto fe s p al
e ompl t Se Sl v onv. t
eed. e a t
Smih,

4 4U.. 3 5 ( 9 )
0 S 5 , 4 1 71.
Re or a ia eonlneno i c t t t a t t camsriedi t j2254peii
c ds valbl i w ndiae ha, s o he li as n he
tton,
a s ri c te r cai so y,Cn
s e tng our ror l m nl
mpbelhase us e hi sae c tr
l
xha t d s t t our emedisby pr s ntng
e
ee i
t c am st t Supr m e Co tof Vigi a. Se O ' lva v.Boe c l 526 U . 838,8
he l i o he
e
ur
r ni
e Suli n
r ke ,
S.
45

(9 9 .I a dto hsc rir p tto i n l n e p n i .Ac o dn l, c n l et t h
1 9 ) n d i n, i e tomi eiin s o o g r e dng c r i gy I o cud ha t e
i
m o i t dim ishi pe ii n f f iur t e us a ia e saecour r m e e m us bede e
ton o s s s tto or a l e o xha t val bl tt
t e di s t
nid.
Iwilgr ntRes
l a
ponde 30 da t r pond t Cn pbe ljcli s The Cl r i dieced t s nd
nt
ys o es
o m l' am .
ek s r t o e
c esoft sm e or ndlm o ni n and a co pa ng o de t t pa tes
opi
hi m a l pi o
c m nyi r r o he ri .

ENTEREDtiW 6dyoMa 2019.
hs
a f y
,

x

$

OR UN I
TED STATES D I
STRI J G E
CT UD