Cancian v. Hannabass and Rowe, Inc et al

Filing 26

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 12/11/2018. (aab)

I TH E U N I
N
TED STATE S D I
STRICT COU RT
FO R TH E W E STERN D ISTRICT O F W RGI I
N A
RO AN O U D I SI N
W O

rlFRK' oyFl t.s. sm K URT
S
cE J Dl
ATROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

pE 11 2 1
: ' 22
JUL 0. DL CLERK
EX
BK

ALLE SAN D RO CAN CI ,
AN

4
DP

C

Pl nt f y
ai i f

Ci lActon N o.7: cv- 283
vi
i
18- 00
V.

II N ABASS AN D ROW E ,LTD .
-AN
,
and

LI D SAY M I ELLE STI SON ,
N
CH
N
D ef
endant
s.

By: M i
chae F.U t
l
bansd
l

Cli fU. Diti t udge
le S. src l
M E M O RAN D U M O PI I N
N O
Thi m att com esbef et c ton D e enda Hanna s & Rowe, d.s
s tr
or he our
f
nt
ba s
Lt '

rT nna s' a dDee a tLidsyMihel Sd o sts on)M o nst Dimis
Ha bas' n fnd n n a c l ns n' f Hns ' do o s s,
)
e
f
lot Sld on O c obe 16,2018.ECF N o.17- 9ECF N o.18 1. andf Ales ndr Ca i n
l h e
t r
1
- Pli f l a o nc a

rTli ip? rT nca ' fe t oii l o
antf o f in' l d he rgna c mpbi ilt ss ionl ne2 , 01 . No.
ca
)l
ntt hi ut u 0 2 8*
ECF
1.Pl i ffl t a e
anéf led he m nded com pli a
ant gzns D e e
t f ndant on O c obe 2,201 ECF N o.
s
t z
8.
16.l r s
n e pons t D ef ndant ' otonst dir s , andf Ales ndr Ca i n fld a
eo
e
s m i o snis Pli f l a o nc a le
m e or ndum i opposéon on Oct r30,2018.
m a
n
i
obe
ECF N o. Fort z as sa ed
23.
he e ons t t
beow,t c tnow D E N I S D ef nda s m odons
l
he our
E
e nt '
.

Tlsc s a e fo alg dc pyi ti tng me tPlidf i ayhoo rph rwho
l ae ds s r m l e o rgh nfi e n. an fs
i
e
tg a e
z g se e aphot t ph wih t Unie St t CopydghtO f e on M a 5,2017.Ca in
e i tr d
og a
t he t d a es
hc
y
nca
posed hi c rght phot a on t w e iew wm soopx. on M a c 17,2012.
t
s opy i ed
ogr ph
he bst
com
th

Pli ifalgest c i wasi tnged whe D ef nda sfc ed and pose t phot
antf le he opyrght
nf i
n
e nt Topi
t d he
o

on Ha a s ' omme ca we ie'T n ora ut v mbe 2 2 5'ECF No.1 , 1 .
nn ba s c
r il bsty r
'o
bo No e r 3, 01 .
:
6! 1
H anna s i acor aton f m e undert lw sofVigi a he
ba s s
por i or d
he a
r ni, adqua t r i
r e ed n

Ro nok , r i aa s caiigi c rr par ECF No. 6 T . tns wa t es l o r
a e Vigni nd pe il n n a e i.
z
1 , 2 S i on s h oe wne

a me rofSi o Commu c d LLC rf i o Commu c do ' aVigm'
nd mbe tns n
nia ons
st n
ns
nia ns), rt a
'
l t dl bit c mpa y ECF No. 6 !1 . n in c tc e S i on t o g c unslo
i e i ly o n .
mi a i
1 , 2 Ca ca on a td tns hr u h o e n
Fe ua y 6,201 r ques bot t tStns r m ove t phot i m e a ey a t t
br r
7, e dng h ha i on e
he
o m dit l nd ha
Ca in r eve c pe a
nca ec i om ns éon f t i rngem e .
or he nfi
nt ECF N o.18- Thephot w a r m ove
5.
o se
d
29 da lt r ECF N o.1 1,2.
ys a e .
7II
.

Rul 1 $()ofteFe ea RulsofCiiPz e tr pe- t apat t mo f
e 29 6 h d rl e
vl oc dze t s ty o ve ot
mi
dir s a ofacom pli f f iur t sa e a cnm upon wlih r i c n begr nt d.To
sni s l
ant or al e o t t li
ac elef a
a e

s vveamoéo t ds s u e Rul 1 $()t pli ifmus pla s ûce fcsTo
uri
n o imis nd r e 29 6,he antf t e d uf int at f
t
r ie arghtt r lefa
as i o ei bovet s c a i lve ' a fsa ea c m t t le t ti pl usbl
he pe ultve e l' nd ft t bi o ei f ha s a i e

o isfc . Bel lCo . Two , 5 U. 5 4 5 55 0( 0 )A panif
n t a e' lAt.
'
v. mbl 5 0 S. 4 , 55 7 20 7. litf
e tbihe (ail a iiif' ypla igfat l ontntt talwstec r t dtw t
sa ls s f ca plusbl b e dn r cua c e ha lo h ou t o a he
f
t
f
r s bl i e e e t t def nda i la e f t mi c
ea ona e nf r nc hat he e nt s ibl or he s onductalge ' As t tv.
le d. hc of
'

I a, 5 U. 6 2 6 (00 )l r l ona1 $()modo t c u tmus a c p al
qb l5 6 S. 6 , 78 2 9.n ui
ng
24 6
n,he o r t ce t l
we lpl de alga i i t com pli a t a dr w alr s
l- ea d le tons n he
nnt s rue nd a l ea onabl f tzli e e si
e acaa nf r nce n

t l htmos fvo a et t pli if I rav. td S ae , 2 F.d 4 2 4 4 ( h Ci.
he i
g
t a r bl o he antf. ba r Unie tts 1 0 3 7 , 7 4t r
1 9 ) Ho ve,Tth e d i r ctl oft ee nt ofac us ofa éo s re b
9 7 . we r fl r a ba e e ias he lme s
g
a e c n, uppo t d y
me econcus ysatm e s do nots hc 'L - ,556U. a 6 s eW a M or Do s
r
l or t e nt,
uf e. qbal
'
S. t 789 e
e
2

LLC v. at6 0F.d35 , 6 (f Ci. 1 )( dn tec r ( e no a cptlg l
Cozr, 8 3 9 3 5 4. r20 2 holig h ou tf d t ce e a
h
ne
concusonsc
l i
ouched asf ct orunwa t nt d i e ence ,unz s bl c usons ot
a s
r a e nf r s
ea ona e oncl i ,

apl ns'( en lq tdonmak omitd.
z me t' i r a uoa
) nt
rs te )
1 1.
1

D e e nt H anna s a Séns ha bot f d m odonst dim i s Thes
f nda s
ba s nd
on ve h ze
o s s.
e
m oéonsV I beaddr s d i t n.Ast alged ac
I
es e n ur
he le
donsofStns Com m uniadonsgi
i on
c
ve
rs t t ss t Sdns sm odon wilbe e mi d f t
ie o hi ui,
on'
l
xa ne us.
A.
I he m odon,Stns a gt t ts ca
n r
i on r z ha he nnotbehed i vi ly la e f a
es
l ndi dual ibl or céons
pe f m ed by Stns Com m unia
r or
i on
c éonsbe us Stns Com m uniaéonsi a LLC.
ca e i on
c
sn
An

LLC,otLi ie Libiiy Com pa ,i al ga endt s pa a e fom ism e be sorowne s
m t d a lt
ny s e l
y e tt r t m r
r.

Re r I ve % e s LLC v. r 2 7Va 31 , 2 6 3S. 2d 8 5 8 7 (0 ) An LLC
mo a n s nt,
Or, 7 . 6 3 2, 7 E. 4 , 4 2 09 .
t s edsism e be sfom pe s lla lt f t ac
hus hil t m r r
r ona i biiy or he éonsoft e y I Pli fs
he ndt . d. andf'

c li alg st tSt o i font a sv rl l bef a ydie tc yiht
ompant l e ha i n s j i l nd e eal i l or n rc op rg
e
ns
y
ya
i rng me c mmitd b S i o Commu c é sLLC. ECF No. 6 $ 2 Pli fas
nfi e nt o te y tns n
nia on
'
'
1 , 0. andf lo
al st Stns i f ca i l la e'f t ac
lege hat i on s f rousy ibl ' oz he donsofStns Com m uniaéons I
vi
i on
c
. d.
Pl i ifdi not howe ,na e Stns Com m uni éonsa a def nda i t sc e,a
antf d ,
ver m
i on
ca
s
e nt n hi as nd

i t ad na e Sdns i he i vi lc pa iy,s e ng t hol he pe s ly la e See
nse
m d
on n r ndi dua a c t e ki o d t t onal ibl .
ECF N o.1
6.

O nl af w f c u s ena i pe- i apli ft bypa st sled an LLC ofe sand
y e a t al c ros t t andf o
m
s he lil
fr

hod t eme e soft a LLC pe s nal l be S eI r W hi , 1 B. 8 0 8 ( nk .
l h mb r h t
ro l i l. e n e t 4 2 R. 6 , 65 Ba r
ya
e
W . Va 2 09 (tén t l t dcru tnc sj éfi t ep e cn o a LLC vel.
D. . 0 ) sa g he i e ic msa e us yng h ir ig f n
mi
i
)

Fis,am e be orof e ofa LLC m a be pur ue i vi ly f a
rt
m r
ûc r n
y
s d ndi dual or cdonst ke by t
a n
he
LLC whe acour de i t fpi cet ve l' l A c tm a pir e t veli t e
n
t c des o f er he i.' d. our y e c he i n ht e

i tnc s 1 f n t unt of n e e ta o rhi i s h t a t s paa epe s aie
nsa e : ) f
whe he iy i tr s nd wne s p s uc h t he e r t ron l s
d
oft e ( a d t i ii uasn lng re ita t a he et t ts p r tn s woud
h LLQ n he ndv d l o o e x s nd o d r o ha e a ae e s l

woka i éci 2 wheet i iiu ls g t beh l l beatmptdt u et LLC
z n t e' ) t he ndvd a ou ht o ed i l te e o s he
jus '
a
velt e deapes a o ia n, me t afa do ci , ommia i dc , rg i
i o va
ron l bl do pe mae ru r rme c
g
tn t
jus e o an
a a v ntg ;a 3 wheeteLLC'i blyt stsyaj g nta nns ii t rs tof
n d a a e nd ) r h
S na it o aif ud me g i tts he eul
i
dei rt u ra iaia n.d.q odn O' z av. e u eCrdtCo .24 Va 1 1
l ae ndec ptl do l (u g Ha z Ex c dv e i
be
z
6 . 1,
1 5 43 S. 2 3 8 3 0(9 ); nav. 1 Fze s n,nc. 6Va 49 , 0 ,5 7SE.
1 , 1 E.d 1 , 2 1 93)Da 3 3 emao l .26 . 1 5 2 8 . 2d
5 , 5 (0 3 .
48 5 4 2 0 )
Pl i ifha pl no f ct i c i t ta oft a
antf s ed
a s ndiatng ha ny he bove a
ppEes I t d, andf
. nsea Pli f
s a est tSéns Com m uniaéonsno l re ss i e Stns Com m uni éonswas
t t ha
on
c
onge xit- nde d, i on
ca

c nc ne f rno pa me offe o a uay31 20 7 ECF No. 6 ! 3 ECF No. - .
a e d o n- y nt e s nl n r , 1 .
1,1;
23 1
Tli f ton isown,howe r doe notexpos Séns t pe s lla lt Vig' l '
ls ac
t
ve , s
e
on o r ona ibiiy. t m ' s
a

Li tdLibit Co nyAc (h Ac)sae t ti tee n ofa t éccnc l do of
mie a ly mpa
i
t te t tts ha,n h ve t uoma a el n
a
a LLC' e itnc ( u t ,f re a e afi et pa f e)
n
S xse e d e o o x mpl, al o y e s,
ur
f o m e be , m a ge , or ot r a nt of a lm ie Ia lt
f
N
m r
na r
he ge
i t d i biiy
c pany s l ha a pe s loblga
om
hal ve ny r ona
i éon f a la lée of
or ny ibii s
t l ied la lt com pa whet r s h la ldes a e i
he i t ibiiy
m
ny,
he uc ibii
ds n
c t c ,t q or ot r s s ey by r a on oft c
ont a t or
he wie, oll
es
he anceldon
la
of t lm ie la lt com pa s e senc pur uant t t s
he i t d i biiy
ny' xit e
s
o hi
sc
e don.'
'

Va Cod An j1 .-05 . ( 1 ) Furh r teAc g sont prvd f p e l
. e n. 31 1 02 20 3. te,h t oe o o ie ot otnda
cni a si t e ntofc nc ldon,s yng
l m nt n he ve
a ela
ai

4

< he ca el
T
nc ladon of e se e of a lm ie la lt com pa
' t nc
xi
i t d ibiiy
ny
s l nott ke a y ori par a t m e a ia e t or a i t
hal
a wa
m i ny e dy valbl o
gans
t l ied la lt c pa or is m e be s or m a ge s f
he i t ibiiy om ny
m
t
m r
na r or
any rght or c nm exiéng,or a la lt i t ed,be or t
i
li
s
ny ibiiy ncur
f e he
ca el ton.
nc lai '
'

vA. eAn j1 1 1 05( 0 3 . nca ' ph o phwa alg dypose on
cod n. 3.- 05 . 2 1 ) Ca ins ot ra
s l e l td
e
H a ba s we iei N ove be of2015. utng t stm e Sdns Com m uni donswasa
nna s ' bst n
m t
D i hi i ,
on
ca
pr ry f m ed a ope adona LLC ofVigi i.Theca laéon oft tsat doe not
ope l or
nd
r
l
t la
a
ncel
ha t us s

e
xpos Sdns t pe s lla lt
e
on o r ona ibiipl

Plidf as asrsta S oni b hfoitya sveal l bl'a f ia l
an f lo set h t dns s ot j nl nd e rl i e' nd f cdousy
ya
v
la e'f t i rnge e ofStns Com m unia
ibl' or he nfi m nt
i on
c éons The Copy i Act a i e r ed
.
rght , s ntm et
by t c t,e endspe s lla lt f t ac
he ours xt
r ona ibiiy or he donsofc or éonsand LLCSunde
om a
r

c ranctumsa c s S e1 U.. A. 5 1(- )(0 2 rAn onewhovoae a o t
eti ic tn e. e 7 SC. j 0 a b 2 0 ) f y
ilts ny f he
e l i rght oft c rghtowne aspr de by s ctons106 t ough 122 ...i a
xcusve i s he opy i
r
ovi d
e i
hr
sn
i rnge oft copyrght....
nfi r he
i
The lga orbene ilowne ofa e usverghtunde a
e l
hca
r n xcl i i
t

c py ih i e te .. t i étzea a to f ra i tng me t.. .) Unves l t t r
o rg t s nd ld .o ns t n c in o n nfi e n .>; i ra Fu nia e
t
'

J tlI . Frnk l8 5F. u . d35 5 ( . N. 20 1,apd, 3 F. x2 7(t
n ' ncv. a e, 3 S pp 2 , 0 M D. C. 1 ) f 5 8 App' 6 4h
,
Ci. 1 )(
r 20 3 i i pe s a l blt o ac po aeof e f rc py ih i dng me b
mposng ron li ii n or z t hc r o o rg t nf e nt y
a y
t c r r d ll i a d s v r libit f rac mor t of e i t c tx ofc y ih
he o po a on . ont n e e a l l y o o ae hc r n he on e t op rg t
a i
i rnge e wille f het t of ie w a t dom i nti l nc i t c ot éon,a
nfi m nt l i f e he fc r s he
w
na nfue e n he om a
nd
1I hi m e o i opposdon t Sdns sm odo t dim i s Pli fpoi soutt tSi o Comm uniadonsha
n s m n
i
o
on'
n o s s , andf nt
ha tns n
c
d
a r a be n c nc led a t tm eher que t d Stns r m o t p og a f om H a ba s we ie a a t tm e
le dy e a e l t he i
e s e i on e ve he hot r ph r
nna s ' bst nd t he i
s di s 29 da sl er Pl i fa gu st sm a she pe s lyla e f he f im e t fe di l 't m ovet
he d o,
y at . andf z e hi ke r r onal ibl oz r a l o t xpe dousy e
f
he

ifign wok'a rq ie b 1 U.. j5 2c (0 0. No 2 ,8Ev ni t c u t ce tdta rmo a
nrn ig ry s e uzd y 7 SC. 1 () 2 1 )ECF . 3 . e fhe o r a cpe h t e v l
'
wi i amo t ino e p cd u (n t r i n jcca c n e s o tl pon)Plidf cdn tpe dsc l bl
t n nh s t x el o s a d hee s o ul il o snus n is it, an fl o la u h i il
h
i
i
i
i
ai
i tea n e c mpan. e ECFNo 1 . e as S u r Ri I c v Do -, . V 0 -6 ( )2 1 WL
n h me d d o litS e
. 6 S e lo ae n n . . el No C 95 3 GMS 0 5
3 7 8 ,t* @ . lJn. 3 2 1 )Sodn ta d 6 igtet= ' x e d u'rq ie afc l n lssa dlc s
0 4 0 a 7 De.a 2 , 0 5 lig h t e nn h e f p dio s'e urs ama a ayi n ak
e
lgl rcd ntop o ieg ia c)Th c utcn o ifr bi fo me rn l fldi o oio t a
ea p ee e t rvd ud n e. e o z l n tne c ms r m mo a dl t t pp sd n o n
m e l
opposng pa t sm odo
i
ry'
n.

5

de e mi t polceswlih r s t d i t i rngem e . Br M usc I . I ' Am or
t r ned he ii
lc e ule n he nfi
nt' oad
'
i , nc v. ts
e

CIgsNo. :8 7 , 0 WL 1 8 0 8( D. .un 3 , 00 )(iigSalrMuscv.
-l , 30 CV5 0 20 9
I
8 6 3 M. PaJ e 0 2 9 ctn i
o
i
.

MZ Ka ofCon o d l .6 0 F. u 6 9 6 4 ( N. 1 8 ) Viai usl bit i t
i
c r . nc, 4 S pp. 2 , 3 D. H. 9 4 . c to i l y n he
a i
s m e cont xtwillewhe ea c por eof rpos es esbot t rghtand a lt t
a
e
li
t or at fce
s s
h he i
biiy o

s r i et i zng ng a dviy a a obvi a diec f a i li e e ti t e oied
upe v s he nfi i c t nd n
ous nd t t m nc a nt z s n he xpl t
copydght d m a e i l. N e s Saa l v.M or n sdeD e o m e aLLC,284 F.
e
t rasz lon lbes nc.
ni i
vel
nt
3d

5 , 1 (t Ci. 0 ) S eas Uni ra Fu ntr I en, 3 F. u 2 a 5 Sodn
05 5 3 4h r20 2. e lo vesl r iue ntr 8 5 S pp. d t 0 lig
t tt ofie ofaco eyhedc
ha he fc z
lsl l ompa yta wa t j g ntde o fra $ 1miin
n h t s he ud me btr o n 1 lo
l
a r f da a f t i rngem e ofa c rghthol rsf niur desgnswas
wa d or m ges or he nfi
nt
opy i
de ' ut t e i
vi a
c dousy la e f t com pa si rnge e bec us t of thad 10t t abiiy t
l ibl or he
ny' nfi m nt a e he hce
7 h he lt o
s rds t diti i oft f ni e a aEna ili e e ti e oi t
upe e he s rbuton he ut t nd
ur
nca nt t s n xpl dng he

c py ih e f ni ze .
o rg t d ur t t)
a
Pli fa lge i hi c pli ,fupon i or a a bei , t tSdns m e t
andf le s n s om ant f
nf m don nd lef' ha
'
on t he
crt ra f 10t f m sofla lt .The Twom bl - ba sa
ie i or 3 h or
ibiiy
1 1 t ndar doesnotba placi
d
r e lngs

bas upon i or a i and bei ,t
ed
nf m ton
lef hough s h pl alngsa econsde ed ft nuousatbes .
uc e fi r
i r fe
t'
'

Ra b v. we 9 0F. u 2 6 2 61 ( D. . 0 3 . p anéf ma do s i h o s e
u Bo n, 6 S pp. d 0 , 5 E. Va 2 1 )A li f y o f e r h
i i a poston ofunce t nt bec us t ne s a y e de ei c r l by t def ndant
sn
ii
rai y a e he ce s r vi nc s ont oled
he e
.

Iie ou v. l colrCo . 1 7F. u 3 45 , 6 ( D. . 01 )(i ngArsa
td n t Mud- o
, 4 S pp. d 2 45 E. Va 2 5 cd
it
Re o d , v. 3 6 4 F.d 1 0 1 0 (nd Ci. 01 )rf' Twombyplusb ly
c r s LLC Doe , 0 3 1 , 2 2
t 2 0 xhe
l a iii
t
sa r ...
t nda d doesnotpr ve apl i ff om pladi f ct ale d T
e nt anéf r
e ng a s lge upon i of
nf maéon a
nd
2Stns wa t owne a me be ofa LLC, aco or eof e , t lw pe ti ng t l biiyf m e bes
i on s he
r nd m r n
not m at Ec r but he a rnni o i l or m r
a t
ofa LLC ge r l m ir st tofc or dons Se e.. Re or I t e s 277Va. 3 6 S. 2d a 8
n
ne al r or ha
y
om a . e
m a nvesm nt ,
at 23, 73 E. t 48

(eemiigwhehe ma a eso LLCSo isme esfd cayd ée t o g e a n d no a ao o sc r rt
d tr nn
t r ngr f
we t mb z u ir u shru h x mia o f n lg u opoae
lw)Ri ov CS Aso its1II- 2 2Va4 , 6-5 , 4 SE.d2 6 2 1(o aigama ae of nLLC t a
a ;
. C s cae I JE, 6 . 8 5 7 5 7 . 2 1 , 2 c mp r
n
ngr a
o
c mort drco a po iigama a e o a I. tesmep oed n a dd d sa ac rt drco)
o ae ie tr nd rvdn
n g r f n JC h a r tc o s n u e s omo ae ietr.

beifwheet fcsaepe uirywi nt poseso a dc nto oftedee da '
l
e
r he at r c l l t he ssin n o rl h fn nt
a
hi
).
Ce t i y,i ot a z ga di who de e i d polc e , nfue d ope a
r anl nf - don e r ng
m
t = ne
ii s i l nce
r dons s r ied
, upe v s
a ées a pos es e hna ili e e t i s ik m aera satanow c nc d LLC
cdvi , nd s s d
nca nt t s s n peci
t il
a eze
w otl bei t c r oft m e be is l- i t sc e Sdns 3Stns ar
zd
n he ontol he m r te f n hi as ,
on. i on guesi
n

r pons t Ca i n wa pr ded i o= a
es
e hat nca
s ovi nf
don t tfdie l conta c sli alga
ha f z cty
t dit ns le dons
ba e upon i or a
sd
nf m don a bei .'
nd lef'ECF N o.18- ,4. t a i m a t ea enott
1 Be hat s t y, hes r
he

f t pl i t am e
ac s ed n he
nded c pli , c t c tm us as um e astuei tli on t s
om ant whih he our
t s
r n nlng hi

mod S eECF No 1 Thefcspld a es f e t mo t t ne tsa eo l ka n.
on. e
. 6. a t e r ufkint o ve o he x tg f i do
t
Sdns as a gue ,<I i a om a t ti or rf Stns t bevi dousy la e
on lo r s <t s xi dc ha n de or i on o
ca
l i bl

f t ac i ofSdns Com m uniatonsLLC,t LLC m us bena ed a a def nda .'
or he tons
on
c i
he
t
m
s
e nt'

ECF N o.18 1, O n t c r r pbi if r gulrybtng cni sa i tpa de on t
- 4.
he onta y, ntf s e a l i l m gans r s he
ba i ofvi adousla lt wihoutna i t die l la epa t asa def nda .Se e .
ss
c
ibiiy t
nnng he r cty ibl ry
e nt e . ,

J u nv. d rHe lh,nc,1 F. u 2 1 3( Md 2 009Gi Chi & Aso its
a do Ele at I . 25 S pp. d. 5 D. . 0 ) na n
s cae,
I c v Fis Uro Ba , 0VA.5 3, 3 S. 2d5 3( 0 ) S s agu sta s
n . . rt l n nk 26
i
3 5 7 E. 7 20 0. dn on t e h t ome
f c sm us be alge t tStns Com m uni a
at
t
le d ha i on
c éonse ge i s ea i bywhih
nga d n om cton
c
Séns ca be hed i vi lyla e ECF N o.18- 3 Att ss a i t pr edi
on n
l ndi dual ibl ,
1, -4. hi t ge n he oce ng,

t cour i notonl r quied t a s eal alga
he
ts
y e r o s um l le donsi t c pli ar t e,butt dr w
n he om a nt e ru
o a
a lr s bl i e e spos i e fom t com pli i t pli fsf vor SeeI ra,120
l ea ona e nf r nce
sbl r
he
ant n he andf' a .
ba r

3''ecour not t tt Twombl- ba sa z silr q r t apli fwhe plalngf csba e on
Ih
t es ha he
1 1 tnda d tl e uies hat andf, n e ri a t s d
i or a a bei , le e gh l de li f ct t al w apl usb ei e e e ofla lt i t c e ofhi or
nf m don nd l a lge nou m ry ng a s o lo
ef
a i l nf r nc
ibiiy n he ont xt s

h rp riua c m. Co . .PCO
e at lr bi HTC
c
v I mGMB & Co KG, 7 F. u p 2 1 6 1 9( D. 2 0)(iigEx te
H
. 6 1 S p . d 4 , 4 D. C. 0 9 ct e n
n
Co . Wa- tSo e I c, 7 Fe 1 1 , 3 0( d. r2 0 )Pan f c mpan,tisrctl ft rq ie
v. l ' trs n .5 5 d. 3 2 1 3 Fe Ci. 0 9. lidf' o liti t eia o he e urd
Mat
s
z
ee nso ji a dsv rliblya dvczo sl blyfrc p r tnr gme , o sd n eo s coet
lme t font n e eal it n iaiu i it o o ykh ifi e ntc me a g rul ls o
a i
ai
n
y
m isng tkst e hol '' eco tho ds howe r t tt f ct pl d z ga Hi Stns sr e i Stns Comm lnia ns
s i li hr s d.Ih ur l ,
ve , ha he a s e e r ng i on' ol n i on
l c do

a dtec p r tnrn e nt l gd, e asx da tu a dwh nal esn beifrncsaed a , l ws
n h o ykh ifig me al e wh n sl s re n e lrao a l n ee e r rwn al
e
me
o
Plndft metti sa ad io l js.
a f o e hs tnd z,f ny u t
i
7

F.da 4 4r. . c nsr etefcsa drao bl i ee c sdei d g o te
3 t 7 f. we o tu h a t n es na e nftn e rve f m h
r
c mpli qi t l ht s fvo a l t t ep ant f7 Pli fscsmst a
o ant n he i mo t a r b e o h li i ). andf' li h t
g
f
t ef nda s .c ed and us Copyrght d Phot r ph' a t tfstns w a t
o e nt . . opi
ed
i e
og a ? nd ha f i on s he

do na i l nc i S i o Commu c tons LLC,a dee mi d a / dr ce t
mi nt nf e n tns n
ue
niai ,
nd tt ne nd or ie td he
polcest t1d t t i rnge e sc pli ofhe e n' l a t t cea i e e e t
ii ha e o he nfi m nt om ant
r i ' e ds o he l r nf r nc hat

S i o Commu c to c uj d t i tn e ntECF No. 6 !1 , 0 W hl t a nd d
tns n
nia ins a e he nfi g me .
1 , 1 2 . ie he me e
c pli pr desr l i y ltl de alt s
om qnt ovi eatvel ite t i o uppor t cnm si l d t r i wha i t r
t he li ncude he e n, t s he e

i s i e s r un t hu deofa1 $()mo frds sa. tns smoi t
s uf nt umo t he t l
ki
2q 6 don o imislSi on' ton o
dimi si t r ot DE N I .
s s s he ef e
ED
B.

Pl i ifalgest tH anna s pa écpat d i t c pli ofi lnge ent
antf le ha
ba s r i e n he om aned- nfi m ,
as e tng,fBe nni on ora
s r i f gi ng
boutN ovem be 23,2015,D ef nda scopi d a posed
r
e nt
e nd t

Co rg e Phot rpht Ha na s' c
pyihtd
oga o n bass ommeca we ie'ECF No.1 , 1 Ha na s
ril bst.
'
6 !1 . n bas
a guest tCa i n kne t ti ha t n Tno ac wli h woul cons ut a
r
ha nca
w ha t d ake d
don nc
d
dt e n
i rnge enton li pi tr ' ECF N o.1 1,3. ssat d a
nfi m
ls ctze.
'
7- A t e bove howe ,t t u h orf liy
,
ver he r t
ast
oft si notye a is I de i ng t sm oton,t c tt ke alf ct al ge i t
hi s
t t s ue. n c di hi
i he ouz a s l a s le d n he

c mpli a tu . eI ra 1 0F.da 4 4r<. weac ptt welpe alg t ofte
o ant s r e Se bar, 2 3 t 7 . . c e he l ld l ai
e ons h
c mpli a tte .' . an falg st tbo. Dee da sc mmit d t c py ih
o ant s tz ..) Pli df l e ha f f n nt o te he o rg t
'
e
h
i znge e on N ove be 23,2015. tpr e ,t si s fc e .
nfi m nt
m r
A es nt hi s ufii nt4

4 ec u t oe ta i hsme rn l i o oio t timo o Plidfag e ta Ha n b s i sbett
Th o r n ts h t n i moa dl n pp sd n o hs d n, an f ru s h t n a ass u jc o
m
vi a i usla lt i t a ofdie ty l lt f rtlsi e ge e ,due t isbusne sr ldons p wih Se s
c zo ibiiy ns e d
t c l i iy o li nf m nt
abi
o t i s ea hi t
on
Com m,ni a .
l c dons ECF N o.2 9 0. tpr e ,t c tc z otr l o a c e outi ofwha i pr e i t
3, -1 A es nt he our am a e h ny ont nt sde
t s es nt n he
a
mende c m pli ,but l be i e e t d i ç pl i g whet rH n bas i (:ec l orvi a usy l l , t r
d o ant wil nt z se t x orn
z
he nna s s 1 ty
1
c do l i e whe he
ab
Slns n Co m x ia nsfl do d a a e pl e o a i pe ntco r c orofH a ba s a wha i s st s
i o m m c do lnc ne s n m oye r n nde nde nta t
nna . , nd t s ue hi

rie i tr o Sn igl blyfrc p r h 1fn e n a smmayjd me t
assn ems f dn i it o o yi t2z g me t t l r u g n.
ai
g i
l
8

H a ba sas a gue t i c nnotbe hel la e f t ac i ofa e iynot
nna s lo r s hat t a
d ibl or he tons n ntt

na da ad fnd nti t ssi ( t rfti t S ns n Co
me s ee a n hi uthee eerng o d o mmunc to ) ECF&o. 7
iains.
11,3.Agan,H a bas ca
i
nna s nnotsm pl pl d f ct t tc r di wha i pl i t n e
i y ea a s ha ont a ct t s ed n he m nded
c pli i or rt s ur dinas a oft ss t Such a gu e sa ebes br
om a nt n de o ec e s is l hi ui.
r m nt r
t oughti a
n

mod frsmmayj g n. e Mate sv. lr48 F.up z 6 5 66 O . C.
on o u r ud me tS e trs Ta o, 7 s p.d 6 , 9 S.
2 0 )(itn ihnga1 9 6 mo fom amoin frsmmayjdg nt (flhe
0 7 dsigus i
2 $() éon r
to o u r u me ) f '
r
d fnda t rle onyon t alg t c nti di t Co
e e nj eis l he l a bns o ane n he mpbi a abai f rli
e
nt s ss o ts

moé Acor n l,t c r a re wihTalrt tRul 1 9 6, ndn Rue5 ,
on. c digy he out g e s t yo ha e 2 $() a ot l 6
p o i e t a pr p it sa dad ofrviw wihr s e tt l sModo t Dimis'
r v d s he p o rae t n r e e t e p c o l
i
n o s s.
).
I
V.

Fort r s e es ed a
he ea ons xpr s bove D ef ndant 'm otonst dinls a eD E N I .
, e
s
i o s is r
ED
An a oprat O r rwilbee e e
ppt i e de l
nt z d.
.

., .

''
'

'

Eié:/, /
ned'', /-> z
f - ?=
z
?w?
d '

'

Mi
ch
.

.
F. ba ki
Ur ns
.
.

'
'

Um e S ae Ditit ud e
d tt s stc l g

9