Cancian v. Hannabass and Rowe, Inc et al
Filing
26
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 12/11/2018. (aab)
I TH E U N I
N
TED STATE S D I
STRICT COU RT
FO R TH E W E STERN D ISTRICT O F W RGI I
N A
RO AN O U D I SI N
W O
rlFRK' oyFl t.s. sm K URT
S
cE J Dl
ATROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED
pE 11 2 1
: ' 22
JUL 0. DL CLERK
EX
BK
ALLE SAN D RO CAN CI ,
AN
4
DP
C
Pl nt f y
ai i f
Ci lActon N o.7: cv- 283
vi
i
18- 00
V.
II N ABASS AN D ROW E ,LTD .
-AN
,
and
LI D SAY M I ELLE STI SON ,
N
CH
N
D ef
endant
s.
By: M i
chae F.U t
l
bansd
l
Cli fU. Diti t udge
le S. src l
M E M O RAN D U M O PI I N
N O
Thi m att com esbef et c ton D e enda Hanna s & Rowe, d.s
s tr
or he our
f
nt
ba s
Lt '
rT nna s' a dDee a tLidsyMihel Sd o sts on)M o nst Dimis
Ha bas' n fnd n n a c l ns n' f Hns ' do o s s,
)
e
f
lot Sld on O c obe 16,2018.ECF N o.17- 9ECF N o.18 1. andf Ales ndr Ca i n
l h e
t r
1
- Pli f l a o nc a
rTli ip? rT nca ' fe t oii l o
antf o f in' l d he rgna c mpbi ilt ss ionl ne2 , 01 . No.
ca
)l
ntt hi ut u 0 2 8*
ECF
1.Pl i ffl t a e
anéf led he m nded com pli a
ant gzns D e e
t f ndant on O c obe 2,201 ECF N o.
s
t z
8.
16.l r s
n e pons t D ef ndant ' otonst dir s , andf Ales ndr Ca i n fld a
eo
e
s m i o snis Pli f l a o nc a le
m e or ndum i opposéon on Oct r30,2018.
m a
n
i
obe
ECF N o. Fort z as sa ed
23.
he e ons t t
beow,t c tnow D E N I S D ef nda s m odons
l
he our
E
e nt '
.
Tlsc s a e fo alg dc pyi ti tng me tPlidf i ayhoo rph rwho
l ae ds s r m l e o rgh nfi e n. an fs
i
e
tg a e
z g se e aphot t ph wih t Unie St t CopydghtO f e on M a 5,2017.Ca in
e i tr d
og a
t he t d a es
hc
y
nca
posed hi c rght phot a on t w e iew wm soopx. on M a c 17,2012.
t
s opy i ed
ogr ph
he bst
com
th
Pli ifalgest c i wasi tnged whe D ef nda sfc ed and pose t phot
antf le he opyrght
nf i
n
e nt Topi
t d he
o
on Ha a s ' omme ca we ie'T n ora ut v mbe 2 2 5'ECF No.1 , 1 .
nn ba s c
r il bsty r
'o
bo No e r 3, 01 .
:
6! 1
H anna s i acor aton f m e undert lw sofVigi a he
ba s s
por i or d
he a
r ni, adqua t r i
r e ed n
Ro nok , r i aa s caiigi c rr par ECF No. 6 T . tns wa t es l o r
a e Vigni nd pe il n n a e i.
z
1 , 2 S i on s h oe wne
a me rofSi o Commu c d LLC rf i o Commu c do ' aVigm'
nd mbe tns n
nia ons
st n
ns
nia ns), rt a
'
l t dl bit c mpa y ECF No. 6 !1 . n in c tc e S i on t o g c unslo
i e i ly o n .
mi a i
1 , 2 Ca ca on a td tns hr u h o e n
Fe ua y 6,201 r ques bot t tStns r m ove t phot i m e a ey a t t
br r
7, e dng h ha i on e
he
o m dit l nd ha
Ca in r eve c pe a
nca ec i om ns éon f t i rngem e .
or he nfi
nt ECF N o.18- Thephot w a r m ove
5.
o se
d
29 da lt r ECF N o.1 1,2.
ys a e .
7II
.
Rul 1 $()ofteFe ea RulsofCiiPz e tr pe- t apat t mo f
e 29 6 h d rl e
vl oc dze t s ty o ve ot
mi
dir s a ofacom pli f f iur t sa e a cnm upon wlih r i c n begr nt d.To
sni s l
ant or al e o t t li
ac elef a
a e
s vveamoéo t ds s u e Rul 1 $()t pli ifmus pla s ûce fcsTo
uri
n o imis nd r e 29 6,he antf t e d uf int at f
t
r ie arghtt r lefa
as i o ei bovet s c a i lve ' a fsa ea c m t t le t ti pl usbl
he pe ultve e l' nd ft t bi o ei f ha s a i e
o isfc . Bel lCo . Two , 5 U. 5 4 5 55 0( 0 )A panif
n t a e' lAt.
'
v. mbl 5 0 S. 4 , 55 7 20 7. litf
e tbihe (ail a iiif' ypla igfat l ontntt talwstec r t dtw t
sa ls s f ca plusbl b e dn r cua c e ha lo h ou t o a he
f
t
f
r s bl i e e e t t def nda i la e f t mi c
ea ona e nf r nc hat he e nt s ibl or he s onductalge ' As t tv.
le d. hc of
'
I a, 5 U. 6 2 6 (00 )l r l ona1 $()modo t c u tmus a c p al
qb l5 6 S. 6 , 78 2 9.n ui
ng
24 6
n,he o r t ce t l
we lpl de alga i i t com pli a t a dr w alr s
l- ea d le tons n he
nnt s rue nd a l ea onabl f tzli e e si
e acaa nf r nce n
t l htmos fvo a et t pli if I rav. td S ae , 2 F.d 4 2 4 4 ( h Ci.
he i
g
t a r bl o he antf. ba r Unie tts 1 0 3 7 , 7 4t r
1 9 ) Ho ve,Tth e d i r ctl oft ee nt ofac us ofa éo s re b
9 7 . we r fl r a ba e e ias he lme s
g
a e c n, uppo t d y
me econcus ysatm e s do nots hc 'L - ,556U. a 6 s eW a M or Do s
r
l or t e nt,
uf e. qbal
'
S. t 789 e
e
2
LLC v. at6 0F.d35 , 6 (f Ci. 1 )( dn tec r ( e no a cptlg l
Cozr, 8 3 9 3 5 4. r20 2 holig h ou tf d t ce e a
h
ne
concusonsc
l i
ouched asf ct orunwa t nt d i e ence ,unz s bl c usons ot
a s
r a e nf r s
ea ona e oncl i ,
apl ns'( en lq tdonmak omitd.
z me t' i r a uoa
) nt
rs te )
1 1.
1
D e e nt H anna s a Séns ha bot f d m odonst dim i s Thes
f nda s
ba s nd
on ve h ze
o s s.
e
m oéonsV I beaddr s d i t n.Ast alged ac
I
es e n ur
he le
donsofStns Com m uniadonsgi
i on
c
ve
rs t t ss t Sdns sm odon wilbe e mi d f t
ie o hi ui,
on'
l
xa ne us.
A.
I he m odon,Stns a gt t ts ca
n r
i on r z ha he nnotbehed i vi ly la e f a
es
l ndi dual ibl or céons
pe f m ed by Stns Com m unia
r or
i on
c éonsbe us Stns Com m uniaéonsi a LLC.
ca e i on
c
sn
An
LLC,otLi ie Libiiy Com pa ,i al ga endt s pa a e fom ism e be sorowne s
m t d a lt
ny s e l
y e tt r t m r
r.
Re r I ve % e s LLC v. r 2 7Va 31 , 2 6 3S. 2d 8 5 8 7 (0 ) An LLC
mo a n s nt,
Or, 7 . 6 3 2, 7 E. 4 , 4 2 09 .
t s edsism e be sfom pe s lla lt f t ac
hus hil t m r r
r ona i biiy or he éonsoft e y I Pli fs
he ndt . d. andf'
c li alg st tSt o i font a sv rl l bef a ydie tc yiht
ompant l e ha i n s j i l nd e eal i l or n rc op rg
e
ns
y
ya
i rng me c mmitd b S i o Commu c é sLLC. ECF No. 6 $ 2 Pli fas
nfi e nt o te y tns n
nia on
'
'
1 , 0. andf lo
al st Stns i f ca i l la e'f t ac
lege hat i on s f rousy ibl ' oz he donsofStns Com m uniaéons I
vi
i on
c
. d.
Pl i ifdi not howe ,na e Stns Com m uni éonsa a def nda i t sc e,a
antf d ,
ver m
i on
ca
s
e nt n hi as nd
i t ad na e Sdns i he i vi lc pa iy,s e ng t hol he pe s ly la e See
nse
m d
on n r ndi dua a c t e ki o d t t onal ibl .
ECF N o.1
6.
O nl af w f c u s ena i pe- i apli ft bypa st sled an LLC ofe sand
y e a t al c ros t t andf o
m
s he lil
fr
hod t eme e soft a LLC pe s nal l be S eI r W hi , 1 B. 8 0 8 ( nk .
l h mb r h t
ro l i l. e n e t 4 2 R. 6 , 65 Ba r
ya
e
W . Va 2 09 (tén t l t dcru tnc sj éfi t ep e cn o a LLC vel.
D. . 0 ) sa g he i e ic msa e us yng h ir ig f n
mi
i
)
Fis,am e be orof e ofa LLC m a be pur ue i vi ly f a
rt
m r
ûc r n
y
s d ndi dual or cdonst ke by t
a n
he
LLC whe acour de i t fpi cet ve l' l A c tm a pir e t veli t e
n
t c des o f er he i.' d. our y e c he i n ht e
i tnc s 1 f n t unt of n e e ta o rhi i s h t a t s paa epe s aie
nsa e : ) f
whe he iy i tr s nd wne s p s uc h t he e r t ron l s
d
oft e ( a d t i ii uasn lng re ita t a he et t ts p r tn s woud
h LLQ n he ndv d l o o e x s nd o d r o ha e a ae e s l
woka i éci 2 wheet i iiu ls g t beh l l beatmptdt u et LLC
z n t e' ) t he ndvd a ou ht o ed i l te e o s he
jus '
a
velt e deapes a o ia n, me t afa do ci , ommia i dc , rg i
i o va
ron l bl do pe mae ru r rme c
g
tn t
jus e o an
a a v ntg ;a 3 wheeteLLC'i blyt stsyaj g nta nns ii t rs tof
n d a a e nd ) r h
S na it o aif ud me g i tts he eul
i
dei rt u ra iaia n.d.q odn O' z av. e u eCrdtCo .24 Va 1 1
l ae ndec ptl do l (u g Ha z Ex c dv e i
be
z
6 . 1,
1 5 43 S. 2 3 8 3 0(9 ); nav. 1 Fze s n,nc. 6Va 49 , 0 ,5 7SE.
1 , 1 E.d 1 , 2 1 93)Da 3 3 emao l .26 . 1 5 2 8 . 2d
5 , 5 (0 3 .
48 5 4 2 0 )
Pl i ifha pl no f ct i c i t ta oft a
antf s ed
a s ndiatng ha ny he bove a
ppEes I t d, andf
. nsea Pli f
s a est tSéns Com m uniaéonsno l re ss i e Stns Com m uni éonswas
t t ha
on
c
onge xit- nde d, i on
ca
c nc ne f rno pa me offe o a uay31 20 7 ECF No. 6 ! 3 ECF No. - .
a e d o n- y nt e s nl n r , 1 .
1,1;
23 1
Tli f ton isown,howe r doe notexpos Séns t pe s lla lt Vig' l '
ls ac
t
ve , s
e
on o r ona ibiiy. t m ' s
a
Li tdLibit Co nyAc (h Ac)sae t ti tee n ofa t éccnc l do of
mie a ly mpa
i
t te t tts ha,n h ve t uoma a el n
a
a LLC' e itnc ( u t ,f re a e afi et pa f e)
n
S xse e d e o o x mpl, al o y e s,
ur
f o m e be , m a ge , or ot r a nt of a lm ie Ia lt
f
N
m r
na r
he ge
i t d i biiy
c pany s l ha a pe s loblga
om
hal ve ny r ona
i éon f a la lée of
or ny ibii s
t l ied la lt com pa whet r s h la ldes a e i
he i t ibiiy
m
ny,
he uc ibii
ds n
c t c ,t q or ot r s s ey by r a on oft c
ont a t or
he wie, oll
es
he anceldon
la
of t lm ie la lt com pa s e senc pur uant t t s
he i t d i biiy
ny' xit e
s
o hi
sc
e don.'
'
Va Cod An j1 .-05 . ( 1 ) Furh r teAc g sont prvd f p e l
. e n. 31 1 02 20 3. te,h t oe o o ie ot otnda
cni a si t e ntofc nc ldon,s yng
l m nt n he ve
a ela
ai
4
< he ca el
T
nc ladon of e se e of a lm ie la lt com pa
' t nc
xi
i t d ibiiy
ny
s l nott ke a y ori par a t m e a ia e t or a i t
hal
a wa
m i ny e dy valbl o
gans
t l ied la lt c pa or is m e be s or m a ge s f
he i t ibiiy om ny
m
t
m r
na r or
any rght or c nm exiéng,or a la lt i t ed,be or t
i
li
s
ny ibiiy ncur
f e he
ca el ton.
nc lai '
'
vA. eAn j1 1 1 05( 0 3 . nca ' ph o phwa alg dypose on
cod n. 3.- 05 . 2 1 ) Ca ins ot ra
s l e l td
e
H a ba s we iei N ove be of2015. utng t stm e Sdns Com m uni donswasa
nna s ' bst n
m t
D i hi i ,
on
ca
pr ry f m ed a ope adona LLC ofVigi i.Theca laéon oft tsat doe not
ope l or
nd
r
l
t la
a
ncel
ha t us s
e
xpos Sdns t pe s lla lt
e
on o r ona ibiipl
Plidf as asrsta S oni b hfoitya sveal l bl'a f ia l
an f lo set h t dns s ot j nl nd e rl i e' nd f cdousy
ya
v
la e'f t i rnge e ofStns Com m unia
ibl' or he nfi m nt
i on
c éons The Copy i Act a i e r ed
.
rght , s ntm et
by t c t,e endspe s lla lt f t ac
he ours xt
r ona ibiiy or he donsofc or éonsand LLCSunde
om a
r
c ranctumsa c s S e1 U.. A. 5 1(- )(0 2 rAn onewhovoae a o t
eti ic tn e. e 7 SC. j 0 a b 2 0 ) f y
ilts ny f he
e l i rght oft c rghtowne aspr de by s ctons106 t ough 122 ...i a
xcusve i s he opy i
r
ovi d
e i
hr
sn
i rnge oft copyrght....
nfi r he
i
The lga orbene ilowne ofa e usverghtunde a
e l
hca
r n xcl i i
t
c py ih i e te .. t i étzea a to f ra i tng me t.. .) Unves l t t r
o rg t s nd ld .o ns t n c in o n nfi e n .>; i ra Fu nia e
t
'
J tlI . Frnk l8 5F. u . d35 5 ( . N. 20 1,apd, 3 F. x2 7(t
n ' ncv. a e, 3 S pp 2 , 0 M D. C. 1 ) f 5 8 App' 6 4h
,
Ci. 1 )(
r 20 3 i i pe s a l blt o ac po aeof e f rc py ih i dng me b
mposng ron li ii n or z t hc r o o rg t nf e nt y
a y
t c r r d ll i a d s v r libit f rac mor t of e i t c tx ofc y ih
he o po a on . ont n e e a l l y o o ae hc r n he on e t op rg t
a i
i rnge e wille f het t of ie w a t dom i nti l nc i t c ot éon,a
nfi m nt l i f e he fc r s he
w
na nfue e n he om a
nd
1I hi m e o i opposdon t Sdns sm odo t dim i s Pli fpoi soutt tSi o Comm uniadonsha
n s m n
i
o
on'
n o s s , andf nt
ha tns n
c
d
a r a be n c nc led a t tm eher que t d Stns r m o t p og a f om H a ba s we ie a a t tm e
le dy e a e l t he i
e s e i on e ve he hot r ph r
nna s ' bst nd t he i
s di s 29 da sl er Pl i fa gu st sm a she pe s lyla e f he f im e t fe di l 't m ovet
he d o,
y at . andf z e hi ke r r onal ibl oz r a l o t xpe dousy e
f
he
ifign wok'a rq ie b 1 U.. j5 2c (0 0. No 2 ,8Ev ni t c u t ce tdta rmo a
nrn ig ry s e uzd y 7 SC. 1 () 2 1 )ECF . 3 . e fhe o r a cpe h t e v l
'
wi i amo t ino e p cd u (n t r i n jcca c n e s o tl pon)Plidf cdn tpe dsc l bl
t n nh s t x el o s a d hee s o ul il o snus n is it, an fl o la u h i il
h
i
i
i
i
ai
i tea n e c mpan. e ECFNo 1 . e as S u r Ri I c v Do -, . V 0 -6 ( )2 1 WL
n h me d d o litS e
. 6 S e lo ae n n . . el No C 95 3 GMS 0 5
3 7 8 ,t* @ . lJn. 3 2 1 )Sodn ta d 6 igtet= ' x e d u'rq ie afc l n lssa dlc s
0 4 0 a 7 De.a 2 , 0 5 lig h t e nn h e f p dio s'e urs ama a ayi n ak
e
lgl rcd ntop o ieg ia c)Th c utcn o ifr bi fo me rn l fldi o oio t a
ea p ee e t rvd ud n e. e o z l n tne c ms r m mo a dl t t pp sd n o n
m e l
opposng pa t sm odo
i
ry'
n.
5
de e mi t polceswlih r s t d i t i rngem e . Br M usc I . I ' Am or
t r ned he ii
lc e ule n he nfi
nt' oad
'
i , nc v. ts
e
CIgsNo. :8 7 , 0 WL 1 8 0 8( D. .un 3 , 00 )(iigSalrMuscv.
-l , 30 CV5 0 20 9
I
8 6 3 M. PaJ e 0 2 9 ctn i
o
i
.
MZ Ka ofCon o d l .6 0 F. u 6 9 6 4 ( N. 1 8 ) Viai usl bit i t
i
c r . nc, 4 S pp. 2 , 3 D. H. 9 4 . c to i l y n he
a i
s m e cont xtwillewhe ea c por eof rpos es esbot t rghtand a lt t
a
e
li
t or at fce
s s
h he i
biiy o
s r i et i zng ng a dviy a a obvi a diec f a i li e e ti t e oied
upe v s he nfi i c t nd n
ous nd t t m nc a nt z s n he xpl t
copydght d m a e i l. N e s Saa l v.M or n sdeD e o m e aLLC,284 F.
e
t rasz lon lbes nc.
ni i
vel
nt
3d
5 , 1 (t Ci. 0 ) S eas Uni ra Fu ntr I en, 3 F. u 2 a 5 Sodn
05 5 3 4h r20 2. e lo vesl r iue ntr 8 5 S pp. d t 0 lig
t tt ofie ofaco eyhedc
ha he fc z
lsl l ompa yta wa t j g ntde o fra $ 1miin
n h t s he ud me btr o n 1 lo
l
a r f da a f t i rngem e ofa c rghthol rsf niur desgnswas
wa d or m ges or he nfi
nt
opy i
de ' ut t e i
vi a
c dousy la e f t com pa si rnge e bec us t of thad 10t t abiiy t
l ibl or he
ny' nfi m nt a e he hce
7 h he lt o
s rds t diti i oft f ni e a aEna ili e e ti e oi t
upe e he s rbuton he ut t nd
ur
nca nt t s n xpl dng he
c py ih e f ni ze .
o rg t d ur t t)
a
Pli fa lge i hi c pli ,fupon i or a a bei , t tSdns m e t
andf le s n s om ant f
nf m don nd lef' ha
'
on t he
crt ra f 10t f m sofla lt .The Twom bl - ba sa
ie i or 3 h or
ibiiy
1 1 t ndar doesnotba placi
d
r e lngs
bas upon i or a i and bei ,t
ed
nf m ton
lef hough s h pl alngsa econsde ed ft nuousatbes .
uc e fi r
i r fe
t'
'
Ra b v. we 9 0F. u 2 6 2 61 ( D. . 0 3 . p anéf ma do s i h o s e
u Bo n, 6 S pp. d 0 , 5 E. Va 2 1 )A li f y o f e r h
i i a poston ofunce t nt bec us t ne s a y e de ei c r l by t def ndant
sn
ii
rai y a e he ce s r vi nc s ont oled
he e
.
Iie ou v. l colrCo . 1 7F. u 3 45 , 6 ( D. . 01 )(i ngArsa
td n t Mud- o
, 4 S pp. d 2 45 E. Va 2 5 cd
it
Re o d , v. 3 6 4 F.d 1 0 1 0 (nd Ci. 01 )rf' Twombyplusb ly
c r s LLC Doe , 0 3 1 , 2 2
t 2 0 xhe
l a iii
t
sa r ...
t nda d doesnotpr ve apl i ff om pladi f ct ale d T
e nt anéf r
e ng a s lge upon i of
nf maéon a
nd
2Stns wa t owne a me be ofa LLC, aco or eof e , t lw pe ti ng t l biiyf m e bes
i on s he
r nd m r n
not m at Ec r but he a rnni o i l or m r
a t
ofa LLC ge r l m ir st tofc or dons Se e.. Re or I t e s 277Va. 3 6 S. 2d a 8
n
ne al r or ha
y
om a . e
m a nvesm nt ,
at 23, 73 E. t 48
(eemiigwhehe ma a eso LLCSo isme esfd cayd ée t o g e a n d no a ao o sc r rt
d tr nn
t r ngr f
we t mb z u ir u shru h x mia o f n lg u opoae
lw)Ri ov CS Aso its1II- 2 2Va4 , 6-5 , 4 SE.d2 6 2 1(o aigama ae of nLLC t a
a ;
. C s cae I JE, 6 . 8 5 7 5 7 . 2 1 , 2 c mp r
n
ngr a
o
c mort drco a po iigama a e o a I. tesmep oed n a dd d sa ac rt drco)
o ae ie tr nd rvdn
n g r f n JC h a r tc o s n u e s omo ae ietr.
beifwheet fcsaepe uirywi nt poseso a dc nto oftedee da '
l
e
r he at r c l l t he ssin n o rl h fn nt
a
hi
).
Ce t i y,i ot a z ga di who de e i d polc e , nfue d ope a
r anl nf - don e r ng
m
t = ne
ii s i l nce
r dons s r ied
, upe v s
a ées a pos es e hna ili e e t i s ik m aera satanow c nc d LLC
cdvi , nd s s d
nca nt t s s n peci
t il
a eze
w otl bei t c r oft m e be is l- i t sc e Sdns 3Stns ar
zd
n he ontol he m r te f n hi as ,
on. i on guesi
n
r pons t Ca i n wa pr ded i o= a
es
e hat nca
s ovi nf
don t tfdie l conta c sli alga
ha f z cty
t dit ns le dons
ba e upon i or a
sd
nf m don a bei .'
nd lef'ECF N o.18- ,4. t a i m a t ea enott
1 Be hat s t y, hes r
he
f t pl i t am e
ac s ed n he
nded c pli , c t c tm us as um e astuei tli on t s
om ant whih he our
t s
r n nlng hi
mod S eECF No 1 Thefcspld a es f e t mo t t ne tsa eo l ka n.
on. e
. 6. a t e r ufkint o ve o he x tg f i do
t
Sdns as a gue , z
f - ?=
z
?w?
d '
'
Mi
ch
.
.
F. ba ki
Ur ns
.
.
'
'
Um e S ae Ditit ud e
d tt s stc l g
9
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?