Snider v. Commissioner

Filing 29

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 09/09/2019. (aab)

CL X S OFFS U. DI .COURT
EF
CE S. ST
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI ED
L

I TH E U N I
N
TED STATE S D I RI CO U RT
ST CT
FO R TH E W E STERN D I M CT O F W RG I M
ST
N
R OAN O U D I SION
W

sEP 29 2 1
22
JUL C UDL CLERK
EX
BY;

D=

J E S. or
AMI f

L

SAM TT S. deceas
EL y
ed,
Ci lActon N o.7:8- 00
vi
i
1 CV- 294

Pl nt f
ai i f

AN D RRW SAU L,Com m i i
ss onetof
Soci Securt
al
ip

By: M i
chaelF.U r
bansd
l

Chi fUnie S a esDi ti t udge
e
t d tt
s rc J
D ef
endant

M EM ORAN D U M O PI I N
N O

Tli s ils urt dia lt a a wasr f r ed t t H onot bl Robe tS.Bal
ls oca ec iy s biiy ppe l
e e r o he
a e
r
lou,

UitdSttsMa itae ud e p s a tt 28U. C. 6 q 17) ftp o e fnci sof
e ae gsrtl g , utu n o
S. j 36 $() ,o r posd i l
ng
f c a ar c mme ddiposdon. ma itaej g fldar po ta r c
a t nd e o nde s i The gsrt ud e l
e e r nd e omme a
nd don

(
R&R)o un 1 , 01 ,e o n ngt tt pan fsmodo f smmayjdg n be
nl e 4 2 9 tc mme di ha he lidf'
n or u r u me t
de e t Commiso rs modo f s
nid, he
sine'
n or ummay jd me be ga td a d te
r u g nt
rne , n h
Co sine' s ld cso beafr d Pliéf S mu lS rSo l)ha fldo e do
mmiso rs na e iin fime . an f a e . < mue' s le bjc ns
'
t t r ta t sm a t ri now rpe f t c tsconsde a l
o he epor nd hi te s
i or he our'
i r éon.

1 S a r ofRe e ofM a sr t J
. t nda d
viw
gita e udgeDe ii
c son

The o e to rq ie ntstf rh i Rue 7 $)oft Fe ea Rte ofCi l
bjcin e urme e o f n l 2
.
he d rl z s
l
vi
Pr e u e i d sg d t f ti jt atnto o 1 h t e d sdc c ' a t ec ur of
oc d r z s e ine o f ang he te in f 3 h it t out nd l o t
t
0t
t
a

1S mu l e o J n r 3 , 01 a lswiel mi S.wa s bs ue a pbidf. No. 5 Toa i
a e did n a uay 0 2 9 nd l f,n e , s u dttd s n fECF 2 . vod
i

c uson,t pli ifwtlsilber e r t as<Sa ue.'
onf i he nntf ' tl
l
efr ed o < m 1'
2f ihi 14 da aferbeng s ve wih acopyoft r omm e d diposton,apary m a s vea fl
w tn
ys t i er 'd t
he ec
nde s ii
t y ez nd te

s cscwrte obedo t t prpoe f l sa rc mme a ns'Fe . Ci P. 2 .
pei itn jc ns o he o sd mrng nd eo nd do . d R. v. 7 $)
'
i
'

a asu n onl t eis st trmani ds t atrt maitaej g ha ma e
ppel po y hos sue ha e i n ipu e fe he gstt ud e s d
hndn a rc mme éo . Uni dSae v. d et, 78F.d61 ,6 (t Ci. 0 )
igs nd e o nda ns' t tts Mi te 4 3 6 21 4h r2 07
' e
(iigTho sv. n,4 4U..1 0 1 - (9 5) An o e dn pat mus d s T t
ctn
ma Ar 7 S 4 , 47 48 1 8 ). bjc g ry t o o f h
wi
s f int s c fct s a r s bl t a e t t diti courtof t t ue gr
ufk e pe iiiy o s ea ona y o l t he stct
he r
ound f t
or he

o e to 'I . t6 .
bjcin- d a 22
'
To c cu ot r s wo d dee tt pu e ofr q ii g o e do . e
on lde he wie ul f a he mos e urn bjc ns W
w oul be pe r t apa t t a
d
rniéng
r y o ppea a i s t twasbe or t m a sr e
l ny s ue ha
f e he gitat

j g , e ade soft naur a s o ofobeéo ma t t ma itae
ud e rg r ls he t e nd c pe
jc ns de o he gstt
j g 'rpo tEihe t dstc c tr wo l t nha t tviw e r is i
ud es e z. t r he itit ozt ud he ve o e e vey sue n
te maitaej g ' p o e E ng a tc
h gsrt ud es r posd ndi s nd e omme a onso c ursof
nd d
ro t
a a s woul be r quied t z vi w i s s t t t diti t c t ne r
ppe l
d
e r o e e s ue ha he src out ve

c nsde e I et rc s ,jdiilz s ur e wo l bewa t d a t e cit t
o i r d. n ihe ae u ca e o c s u d
se nd h l dc
s
c u ts efci ne s bae o hep fo ma itae jdg s woz b
o t' fe t s sd n l r m
ve
gsrt u e
tl e
d
t dev ned.
m tni
I
d

Thedsdc c r mus dee ieA no pa ypodonoft ma itaejdg 'rpo t
it t ou t t t= n
v n r
he gstt u es e r
a rc
nd e omme ain t whc apr pe obedon ha ben ma e T ' dsrc c r ma
nd to o ih o r jc
s e d .f he itit ou t y
l
a c patjcao mod f t er c mme e d s i ; e eveflt e e i e c ; r t r t e
c e t ee t r iy h e o nd d iposdon r c i l l r v d n e or eu n h
tn

matrt tema itaej g wihi tu tons'Fe R. v. 7 $() a c r 2 U.. j
te o h gsrt ud e t nsr ci . d. Ci P. 29 3; c o d 8 SC.
'
6 q 1.
36 $()
I,ho ve,apat Tma e g nea o c ncusr o e do t tdo no drc te
f we r ry f k s e rl r o l o y bjc ns ha
f
t ie t h
c 't t as cf er ri t ma itaejd ' pr s d S ng a r c mme ai y'
o't o pe ik ro n he gsrt u ges opo e ndi s nd e o nd tons'
'
'
X novo rviw i notr quied.Di r e o v.Coli No.5: c 00088ee s
e r
os r
v n,
13-vFDW DSC,2014

WL 1 6 0 , t* ( . . C. r 28 20 4 (uod Ho r Yel w Ca , nc v. td
6 98 6 a 1 W. N. Ap . , 1 ) q ng wad lo bs I . Unie
D
S ae ,9 7F. upp. 9 4 4 ( D. C.1 7 (uo Ominov. ohns 6 7F. 4 4
t ts 8 S 46 , 7 W. N. 99 ) q dng a J on, 8 2d 4, 7
(t Ci. 9 2 .f hec t wi no c nsd rt eob e d byt pan f ha a eme ey
4h r 1 8 1 f
T' ou' l t o i e hos jc ons he lidf t t r r l
t l
2

c ls r o atmptt obe tt t e ieyoft Re r, t tfc sn tec ur'
oncu o y r te
o jc o he ntrt he po twihou o u ig h o ts
a t néon on s chc e r st r i ' Ca e v.Comm ' ofSoc Sec,N o. 08c
te
pe i r or he en.' m r
r
. .
4: v69,
2009W L

9 4 1 , t* ( D. . a 6 2 09,afd, 7 F. x3 6(t Ci. 1 ) seMi et,
0 41 1 a 2 E. Va M y , 0 ) f' 3 3 App' 4 4h r20 09 e d te

4 8F.da 6 rf ci 6 9 1 d snotc ntna eafr ofg neaie o e do t
7 3 t 21 se t 36 $() oe
on
ou e nc o m e tl d bjc n o
z
c ve alsu sa d e sdb t ma itaejdg ;tc ntmpae ta apat o e do t a
o r lis e d r se y he gsrt u e i o e lts h t rfs bjc n o
ma itaej d esr po tbes cfca pa d uai e , st sam edie t t dititc u'
gsrt u g ' e r pe ii nd r c lrz d a he tt r cs he stc o l
t

t rve o l G oe mh softerp to j c e p o e Sndng o rc
o e iw ny t spo n h e or rpel d r posd i s r e omme do t
h
f
nda ns o
séJ' o.hco / ma e' . u h g ne a o e éo f v t s me e fc a af iuet o e t
ô
* b t n ' d.' S c e r l bjc ns f e he a
â
i . 't
r
ha
fet s al o bjc,
t

o a awave ofs h obe to 'Moo v.BWX Te h o 's 7 2F.S pp. 8 7 8
r s i t uc jcin.
' n
c nol e, 4
u 2d 2 , 29

( . Va 2 0, f', 98F. p' 2 (t Ci. 01 )S eas Ar , 4U. a 1 4rrl e
W D. . 01 )afd 4 Ap x 68 4h t2 2 . e lo n 47 S.t 5 flh
sa edoe no zqletejdg t rve a is eéqno oi n obeto aefld . .)
tmt s t e li h u e o e iw n su
t
v f o jcins t t . .'.
e
'
Re a hig agu n sr ie be o e t ma itae j g d snotc mpy wih t e
h s n r me t as d f t he gstt ud e oe
o l t h
.

rq ie n stf t i t Fe eaRulsof vl o e ur t fl s cf o e t .nd e ,
e urme t e orh n he d rl e CiiPr c d e o l pei bjci I e d
e
k
ons
o e do t tsmpyrieaeagu nt rie beoet ma itaejd aec i rdt
bjc ns ha i l etrt r me s asd f r he gsrt u ge r onsdee o
beg ne a o e d t t e ieyo t etpot a t c mme ai S eVe e v. tue
e tl bjc ons o he nt t f h e t nd e o nd t e n Ast ,
t
on.
5 F. up 2d8 , 4 - 5 ( D. . 0 )Ast ec r n e i y ç-y
39 S p. 41 8 4 4 W. Va 2 08. h ou t otd n -se :
Alowi a ltga t obt i de novo r viw of he e ie c e by m e ey
l ng ii nt o
nn
e e
r ntr as
rl

rf t ti a e tirbre a a obeéonf kls t ii l eee et t
eo mat n al if s n jc f e) he téa t ftnc o he
ng
e
ma
a
m ag sr e us l s The Sm c
itat ees .
donsoft diti c tar efe i l duplc t d
he srct our e f ctvey
ia e
a bot t m a st t a t diti c t pe f m i ntca t s .Thi
s h he gita e nd he srct our r or de i l a ks
s

du ia on ( tmea e f r wa tsjd ca r s ure r t rt n svigt m,
pl é ? i nd fo t se u iil e o c s ahe ha a n he
c
f
a d r nsc nta yt t pu pos soft M a itae Ac . Ho r ( S cyof
n u o rr o he r e he gsrt s t' wa d v. e '
'
He lh& Hl n S r sl 9 2 F.d (0 , E 5 9 (6. Ci.1 1j
at
l
ma e v . 3 2 5 5) I 0 (t1 t 99 ).
,
1

3

V ç c ,539 F.Supp.2d a 8 A pli fwho r ie a eshi pt vi l- a s d az z e swil
.
a
t 46. andf
et r t s e ousy r ie gtm nt l
- ..
.

no begv n fhes c d b t a t a e( ls e s'i t a lsr -l dbze wi bete td
t ie f e on ie t he ppl he e k i nse d,l e fl if l r ae
t
'
i
e
l

a ag nea o e do wlihha tesmeefc a woudafi r t obetI
s e rl bjc n, lc s h a fet s l al e o jc. d.
u
I . udi i l v e ofSoca Se trt De e mi tons
1 J c a Re i w
i l cziy t r nai
I i nott pr nce ofa f de a cour t m a a i s t dve cia lt decsons
ts
he ovi
e rl
t o ke dm nita
ls biiy ii .

Rahe,udca rve ofdsblyc ssi l tdt dee- ni whehe s bsa ta e ie e
t rj iil e iw ia ii ae si e o tt ng t r u tnil vd nc
t
mi
mi
s
uppor st Com m isone ' concuson t tt pli ff ied t m e li bur ofpr ng
t he
s i rs
l i ha he andf al o et ls den
ovi

dsbit.Se Ha sv.S l n,9 7 F. 1 5 ,1 6 (t Ci.1 909se as La v.
ia ly e
i
ulva 0 2d 4 3 45 4h r 9 ) e lo ws
i
Cee e z , 8F.d6 0, 4 (t Ci.1 6 ) I s d ig,hec ur ma net rund ra ea
lbrz e 36 2 4 6 2 4h r 9 6.n o on t o t y ihe etk
X novo rviw oft Commisone ' decson nozr - i t e de eofr cot Huntr
e e
he
si rs ii
ewegh he vi nc
e d.
e

v.Sll n,99 F.d 31 3 ( h Ci.1 9 ) Evd nc i s tn lwhe c nsd tt t
llva 3 2 , 4 4t r 9 2 . ie e s ubsa da
i
n, o ieig he
n
r c d a awhol,i m i bede m ed a qua et s
e or s
e t ght
e
de t o uppor ac l i by ar s bl m i
t oncuson
ea ona e nd,
m char on v.Pe a e ,402 U . 389,401 (9 ) o whe i wo d b s hce tt r f s a
ds
rls
S.
1 71, r n t ul e uf in o e u e

Hie tdvediti ajr tilS t v.Chae,9 F.d 6 , 38(t Ci.1 9 ) S bsa l
rce r c n u y ra. mih
tr 9 3 35 6 4h t 9 6. u tnéa
e denc i nota fat orc i r bl a ountofe de y'Pi cev. nde wood,487 U.
vi
es
f ge
l
onsde a e m
vi nce' er
U
r
S.

55 5 5 ( 9 8 ,b i mo et n ame es i laa s me a ls t n ap e dea c .
2, 6 1 8 ) ut s t ha
r cnd l nd o wh t e s ha r pon r n e
Pe als 402 U . at401 La ,368 F. a 6 I t Comm i sone ' decson i s
r e,
S.
; ws
2d t 42. f he
s i zs ii s uppored
t

b s tnéa e i ç c ,tmus bea f me 4 U.. j4 5() Pe ae , 0 U. a 4 .
y ubsa l v d n e i t fi d. 2 SC. 0 g ; r ls 4 2 S. t 01
r

4

1 1 Pl i psObj c i 3
1 . andf
e tons

S mue o e t t ttef l sbyt ma itaejd e ()ta t ATJsas sme
n l bjcs o h' mcng he gsrt u g :1 h the ,' ses nt
e
i
ofS mue' r sdu lf nc lc pa iy I FCIi s p td b s bsa ile i e e ()t t
n l e i a u dona a ct 1
s
l s u pore y u tnta v d nc ; 2 ha
t AT c nsde e a ga pr pe weg tt Sa e' s bjc ve c mpli t;a ()t t
he J o i r d nd ve o r ih o mu ls u e d o an s nd 3 ha
ne e de e s nit t t Appe s Counci di notwa r ntr m a of hi ca e The
w vi nc ubl ted o he
al
l d
r a e nd
s s.

Co si ne r s nde t a t ma itaej g c te ty f un t ts tn le i e c
mmiso r e po d h t he gsrt ud e o r cl o d ha ubsa éa v d n e
s ppo td t ATJsc ncuso .
u ze he ,' o l i ns
A.Phys calRFC As s e
i
ses m nt

Thept s f a s s i ac qm a ' IFC i s f ' i SSR 96- 7 1 W L 374184
oce s or s e sng l i nts L s et oth n
t
81, 996

( S. ) Thelln s t o i r lva pa t hef l wig:
S. A.. nl g es ut n ee nt r t ol n
i
o
TheRFC m us fr ti
t ls dendf t i vi lsf tona lm iadonsorr sdc i
y he ndi dua' unc i l i t
e t tons
a as es li or he woz t lt d a ldes on a f nc
nd s s as
r
k- ea e bii
' don- f don ba i,
u
by- unc
ss

icudngt fnc i paa rphs() () a ()of20CFR 40 .5 a
n l i he u éons n rg a b,c, nd d
41 45 nd
416. O nl a t r t m a t I be e e s i t t soft e ona
945. y fe hat y he IFC
xpz s ed n e'
m
he xeo
l
lve sofwor s
e l
k, edent r ,lght m edbp ,he vy,a ve y he vy.
ay i ,
m a nd r a

1 a * .Ph ia a iiissto i 20 C. R.40 .5 5@)a 41 9 $)i ld st g,
d. t 1 ysc l blte e ut n
F. 41 4
nd 6.45 ncu e idn
sa ng, waki lfi c r i pus ng, plli z c ng, ha i soopi a
t nli
l ng, itng, aryng,
hi
plng, ea hi
ndlng, t ng, nd

cou hng Me a a ite sto ti sbpat()oft rg ldon i lde u esa cig,
r c i . ntl blis e u n u t c
i
he e ua
ncu nd rtnl
n
r m e be i and c t yng outi tuc
e m rng,
ar i
nsr dons z pondi a opra ey t s r ii co, es
ng ppr i t l o upe v son,

wor r,a wok p e s e i awo kst g Ote a iée stou i s pat()oft
kes nd r z surs n
r edn . h t bl s e t n ub r d he
i
r gu a
e l éon i l t e a f c ed by sdn i
nc ude hos f e t
l mpnime s or e lps i plt
r nt
pie y, m iment of vii
son,
hen i orot r s ns ,ozi par e swlih i pos e t
tng
he e es m im nt lc m
e nvionm e a r s dc
nt l e t dons
.

3D eaie f t a
t ld acs boutSamue' i pn- e sa m edia a pr dur llit y c bef
ls m i nt nd
c l nd oce a lsor an oundizt r por
t he e t

a rc
nd eomme a n( No 26 a i t al nsrdv ta ci ( No.)a wi no berpetd
nd do ECF . ) nd n he c ita e rnsrptECF 8 nd l t e ae
mi
l
he e.
r

5

TheFozt Cic tma ce ri Mo oev. vn 8 6F. 1 (t Ci. 01 )t t
trh rui de la t nr Coli, 2 3d 76 4h r2 6,ha
l
t Tfs es m e m us ft ti ndf t i vi ls f dona lm ia
he fa s s nt
t ls de y he ndi dua' unc
l i t éons orr ti
esrcdonsand
aj es li orhe wor r a e a ldeson af ton- - unc
s s as
r k-elt d bii
unc i by f don bass i l lng t f dons
i, ncuci he unc
'

l tdi t er gta ns'Monr , 26F.da 1 7 1 (i gMa cov. li 7 0F.d 6 2
i e n h e z do .
s
l
'
oe 8 3 t 8 - 88 cén si Covn, 8 3 3 ,

6 6( h Ci. 1 )(uo gS R 9 -P, 1Fe Re a 3 ,7 ). yatrs hafnc
3 4t r20 5 q dn S 68 6 d. g. t 44 5)Onl fe uc u donb -u c n a lssma a AT e pr s IFC f tt o t e e to llv l ofwot .'
y f n do nay i y n J x e s L ' f e' f he x rina e es
V ms
k'
'

Mo oe 8 6F. a 1 9(uo S R 9 -1, 1Fe . g. t3 ,75.
nr , 2 3d t 7 q dng S 687 6 d Re a 44 )
Expr s i IF' bef e a l i t cnm ants lm ia
e sng L C
or nayz ng he li
' i t éons fa don by R nc
nc
don

c e tst d n e t tft a u iao g 1 o ro l tdonso r sdc nst twoud
r ae he a g r ha rhe djd c t t wi1 vel ok i a
f
l
mi
r e t do ha
l
nar w t r n r a tpe ofwo k a i ii a ma bea l t d ' i aa 1 7 (uo
to he a g s nd y s
r n ndvdu l y be o o.' d t 8 q dng
'
Ma co,78 F.d a 6 6 a S R 9 - p,61 Fe g a 3 ,7 ) I a i n,t AT '
s i 0 3 t 3 nd S 6 8
d.Re . t 44 6 . n dddo he ,s
J
as es m e m us i l anatadve dic son ofhow t e dences
s s nt t ncude
r
s us i
he vi
uppor se h c uson,
t ac oncl i
c tng m edi lf t a nonm e ca e de ,a ff us buid a ac ur ea l ca brdge
ii
ca ac s nd
di l vi nce nd f t l n c at nd ogi l i
m

fo t e i nc t h sc ncuso ' I a 1 9( u gClfo dv. fl22 F.d 8 3 8 2
r m he v de e o i o l i n.' d. t 8 q odn if r A e, 7 3 6 , 7
'

(t Ci. 0 0)4
7h t 2 0 ).
I t sc s,t AT frtf nd t a S mue ha t e s v r i ime s o ac l
n hi a e he J ts ou h t a l d h e e e mpnt nt f loho
a e and s a t - t hi atht a t f l t hi a s tl r nec oss She t dic s
bus
t tz pos p t opls y ot ef p va cza
s
r i.
hen s us ed

S mu l me ia hso ya lngh a d s mmrie lss bjc c mpli s icuci t
n e' dcl itr t e t n u
s
z d l u eéve o ant,n l l he
i
ng
tsi y hega a t he rng R. 3 5 . AT c ncud d t tSa e ha t eRFC t
et
mon
ve t he ai . 5 - 8 The J o l e ha mu l d h
o

4I Clfo d 22 F.d a 8 2 t c u tobst d ta ii n e ug f ra AT t saei ac ncu o y
n if r , 7 3 t 7 , he o r eve h tt s ot no h o n J o tt n o ls r
ma
nnert acnmantst tm onyr ga ci lmiatonspl d on li dal a teswa uns
hat li ' esi
e rlng i t i
ace
ls iy cdvii s upport by t
ed he

me ia e e c . t r a AT mu ta d uaef o lgt t r a o frli de in'a R t a
dc l dd n e Rahe, n J s r c lt t me e ii e e s n o l dso ' nd bu' n
,
s
ma
s
l
d
a um t a l c brdge fom t e de t li c uson.'
cc e nd ogial i r he vi nce o ts oncl i '

6

do s de ay wor wih t addi lr ti
e nt t
k t he
dona esrcdonsofs a ng a waki f at a oft
t ndi nd l ng or ot l wo
hour i an eghthourwor y wih ea h sa ng i e a l dng up t one ha fhoura a
sn
i kda t c t ndi ntrv l as
o
- l
t

tm e a waki up t ffee m i e a a tm e oc sona balncng,soopi c ouc ng,
i nd l ng
o it n nut s t i ; ca i l a i t ng, r hi
c a i kne lng,and clmbi butne r on ldde s r s or s f ol ;he coul do no
r wlng, e i
i ng,
ve
a r , ope , ca f ds
d

pus ng ozp'li w11 t l e e t m i s w oul nee t a d c entat d e
hi
xlng t1 he ow r xte de ;
.
d d o voi onc t e xpos e t
ur o
t m pe a at e t m esofcol a he t we es ,hlm i t a vi a i ,and woul r t
e z t e xte
d nd a , m s l diy, nd bt tons
d equie
aca f a buléon. 53.
ne or m a
R.

Th AT ' d cson i lde a deald sx r ofS mue' me ia r c r ,t
e ,S e ii ncu d
J
tie l
mma y a l d c l e o ds he
s

me clopni ,a hi h a tsi y Th maitaejdg c l e t tt AT '
dia i ons nd s e dng etmon . e gsrt u e oncud d ha he Js
opi on i l d t pa r dve i s son z t d by SSR 96- and cont i d s f ent
ni ncude he r a
cus i equie
8P
ane ufki

i o ma in t alw me ni fz rviw. c ur wa no lf t gu s a utho t AI
nf r to o l
o
a ng t e e The o t s t et o e s bo w he J
l
r c d he c l i be us s a qua ey e nne t .
ea he r oncusons ca e he de t l xpli d hem

S mue agzst tt AI di notb id t to ia b i g 'r q ie b Mon o a
a l r t ha he J d
e
u l he f gc l rd e' e ut d y t e nd
l
Cl f d Ho ve ,a rv e of t AT dee i do s ws t t s di e p e he
i or . we r e iw
f
he J t= na n ho ha he d x l
r
c usons Fote m pl s poi e outt talhough Sa ue t tfed t thewasuna e
oncl i .
xa e, he nt d
ha t
m l esii ha
bl

t wak bec us ofs ve eli pan,he as t s i d t thecoul wak t lngt ofa f bal
o l
a e e r zp i
lo e dfe ha
d l he e h
oot l
Eel wihout soppi t z t a t the c d do c e M ound t hous wih f e nt
d t
t ng o es, nd ha
oul
hor s
he
e t r que
br aks Folowi hi l tt a hi a t opl sy,Sa ue wa de c i asdoi welwih onl
e . l ng s ef ot l p rhr a t m l s s rbed
ng l t
y
lt r li ii pa n a mi m a pan wih r nge ofm odon.Fi m ont afe hi suge y
a e a nc son i nd ni l i t a
ve
hs tr p t r ,
Sa uel sdicha ge fom physca t r py f f ii t a a f a
m
wa s r d r
i l he a or alng o ppe r or ppoi m e sbuti w a
nt nt
t s

not t thi s r ngt pan lves gat a f dona peror anceha ali oved.R.54.
ed ha s te h, i e l, i, nd unc
l f m
d l mpr

Th AT d s u s d a iina me c l t c t wlih s we l t e i nc
e J ic s e ddto l dia e o ds tc ho d i l vde e
te
m us ul ke e a a
c os l t l bnor ai s a a s i c t t t m os ofSa ue' pr e s we e t
m lde nd lo ndia ed ha
t
m ls obl m
r he

r ul ofac
es t loholi oxia
nt c don a a e. er por e usng a biyc e f t a por a
nd bus H e t d i
c l or r ns t don a a
nd
ps hi t t he s w e our ge li t r t n t wot W he Sa ue was not c lm i
yc a ds
a nc a d lm o e at o
k.
n m l
onsz ng

acohol he r pored f ei be trbutha s e l thi pai a we
l
, e t e lng te
d om ef p n nd akne s
s.

I sl t ATJ ds us e alt e d nc a lngh beo e c ncud n t a t RFC
n l he
m,
ic s d l he vi e e t e t f t o l i g h t he
wa s
s uppor e by t l i di lr cor Sa ue' cour e oft e t ent li dai ac tes
td
he ong m na e d, m ls
s
r a m , ls l dvii
y

i l igwor a d i s t o e d me ia t ie e a t o i o e i nc . s t
ncudn
k c vde ,he bjc ve dc l vd nc , nd he pnin vde e Thu ,he
c ut O dst a t AT pr vde afo ia b ig ' f rhe c ncuso r g r ng S mu ls
o t
h t he J o i d f gc l rd e' o r o l i ns e a di a e'
l
RFC. AL as c nd td t f nc n- y f n do a ay i c l d f ri t r gua ns
The J lo o uce he u éo b -u c n n lss al o n he e ldo
e
whe s dic s how l hec d wak,st a sand, nd hi ot re o ona lm ia
n he s us ed
ong
oul l i, nd t a
s he xe
l i t dons
.

Ac o dngy ti c ur at e wih t ma itae j g ' c ncuso t t t AT '
c r i l, hs o t ge s t he gsrt ud es o l in ha he ,S
J
deemi do ofS mu l R-Cwa sppo tdbys bsa il vd n e S mue'o e do t
tr na n a e' F s u re
s
u tnta e ie c . a ls bjc ns o
t sf di a e OVE RRU LED .
hi m ng t

B. ubj tv Co a nt
S eci e mpl i s

S mu las agt st tt AT meey s
a e lo r z ha he J rl ummaie hssbjc ve c ant a
e
tz d i u e d ompli s nd
concuded t t t alga
l
ha he le dons we e not f l s
r
ul uppored wihout pr di t r quied
y
t
t
ovi ng he e t

e plna n ofho s arve a he c cu i s Th ma ita ej d f und t a t AT
x a do
w he ri d t r on lson . e g st t u ge o
h t he J
i ude a de aie des rpéon ofSa uels m edi lhit y a ong wih li own alga
ncl d
t ld
ci
m '
ca sor l
t ls
le dons
bef e fnci t thi al ga
or i lng ha s le donswe e note ey conss e wi. t m e c le de e a
r
ne l
it nt t he di a vi nc nd
h

ot re de ei t t c d. re a e t AT f undt tS mue' s bjc vec mpbi s
he vi nc n he e or Fo x mpl,he J o ha n l u e d o
s
nt
w e e not 6A1 s
r
1 uppor e by t r t of doc or who te e hi ,i a i s u e ofhi
y
td
he epor s
t s
z at d m m g ng t dis
s
8

hi a t sat a nc physcans I a don,li r pol s ofli da' ac de we e not
p, nd he t e ge y
ii . n ddi
ls e '
t
ls ty dvi s t
l
c i t wih et rhi cnm ed physc lozm e a i pat e s
onssent t ihe s li
ia
nt l m im nt.

I hs o e do ,S mue ag e t tt AI e a e i s c ai a ma
n i bjc ns a l tu s ha he , ng g d n peulton nd de
J
gene ai d s a e ent t thi al dons a e notentt l conssentwih ot r e nc i
r lze t t m s ha s lega
r
iey
it
t he dde e n

t rc da t thema itaej g fi dt T c no e g t e ie c pontdt byt
he eor nd ha t gstt ud e al o f k wld e he vd n e i e o he
e a
AT d s no ds r ve p an fs pan alga ns' Ho v r S mue do s no s cf
J oe t ip o lidf' i l do . we e , a l e t pe iy
e
'

e a e ofs c ai o g n rl e sae nt t wlc he o e t,wlih ma si
x mpls peulton r e eai d ttme s o z h
z
i
bjcs lc ke t
i si et a drs t o e do
mpo sbl o d e s he bjc n.
Mo e ve ,t st ed yo t AT t ma f n soff c a t r s v c lcsi
r o r i i h ut f he J o ke i g a t nd o e ole onfit n
ndi
t e i e e 1 g-,9 7F.d a 1 5 .l t AI ctd s bsa da e i e ei s pot ofhe
he v d nc . â lq 0 2 t 4 6 f he J ie u t n l v d nc n up t
y
r

d tr nai t tSa l u e d c mpli swee no u te b t rc d,s e
eemi ton ha mue' bjc ve o ant r ts ppo td y he eor h
ss
c
ommitdnoerr S eBiho v. mm' ofSo . c,5 3F. x. , (t Ci. 0 4
te
ro . e s
Co r
c Se. 8 App' 65 68 4h r 2 1 )
(i ig AT ' deemi don s ppo td by s tnda e i e e whee s e ctd s chc
fndn .S tr na
J
u ze
ubsa l v d nc
r h ie pe i
c z dit r t si ya d e i e ei a lzngcnma tsc e blt)
onta co y e t
mon n v d nc n nay i li n ' r dii y .
i
Alo w11r gad t t eagu nt ha t e i e c ct db t e AT d snotds r ve
s , :1 e r o h z me t t he v d n e ie y h J oe
.
ip o
Sn ue ' alga
m ls le dons t r e of t r viwi cour i lm ied t det = i ng w het r
, he ol
he e e ng
ts i t o
e ni
he

s bsa da e i e e s ppo t t AT ' dee mia n.Thec ur ma no t weg t
u t n l v d nc u rs he .s tt n do
J
o t y t e ih he
e i e c a i n a l e t o d t r ne whehe t e i e e po ntd t by t AT
v d n e nd s ot t i ryt ee mi
b
t r he v d nc i e o he J
dipr v sS mue' s bjc vealg to . e H a sv. ul n, 0 F.d 1 3 1 6 (t Ci.
s o e n l u e é l ai ns S e
s
e
S lva 9 7 2 45 , 45 4 h t
i

1 9 )rf j i n wi n t pz vnc ofa rviwig c r t d tr ane t weg oft
9 0 g t s ot t he o i e
f
hi
e e n ou t o e en i he iht he

e ie c , ri it c tsf n éo t s t eisj g ntfrta oft S ceayi hs
vd n e no st he our' ' c n o ubsi t ud me o h t he e rtr f i
u
mt
d cso i s re bys tnda e i e e'
e ii n s uppo t d ubsa l v d nc .)
'
9

Rah r a l nga t AI ctst s tnéa e i nc -mo et a as i ab ls
t e , s o s he J ie o ubsa l vde e - t h n cne ut e s
t n a pr ponde a e-t det = i don m us be uphe d.Pea s v.Col n,810 F. 20
ha
e
t nc he e na
t
l
z on
vi
3d 4,

20 (t Ci. 1 ) S eas Cti v. tt 7 F.d5 5 5 9(t Ci. 9 )( tngta t
7 4h t20 5. e lo a Chae, 6 3 8 , 8 4. t 1 96 noi h the
h
de ii be o et ec k i not e h tt c ma i dia ld, ut t tt AI ' S ng
cson f t l outs wh t e he bi nts s b e b whehe he Js ndi
a

ofnocsbit i'u re b sbsa da e ie c )Fo v Be 1i, C8D-72 43 2 8
l a ly ss ppo td y u tn lvd n e; . r 31 No.
i i
1
1 -7 , 01
W L 3 0 3 a * ( Md 2 8 (i l ta whi e ie ectd by pnn fc ul be
7 78 7 t 5 D. . 01 ) f i h t l vd nc ie
ncng
e
lidf o d
c sr e a s ppo tf rpli fsve i ti i notc ur' z l t r weg e i e e; ak
on tu d s u r o andf' iwpo n ,t s
o ts o e o e ih v d nc ) Clr

v.Coli No.51 -v 0 1 7 2 4 W L 7 05 6 a * rlhe Co tc nn s bs tze is
vn,
:3 c - 0 5 , 01
0 36 t 1 f'
ut a ot u dat t

jd me tfrt toft Commison r e ni t Co r wo dh ved cde dfee l, o
u g n o ha he
si e, ve f he u t ul a e i d ifrnt s
y
l n a t e ATJSde ii ni s ppo dbys tnda e i e c .)Fo t s z a ons t c r
o g s h ,' cso s u ne
ubsa l v d n e' r he e e s , he ou t
'

OVERRULES S mu l o e do t tt ma itaejdg etdwhe hef u ta te
a e' bjc n ha he gsrt u e te
s
n o nd h t h
AT pr ry c i r d Sn e' c mp nnt of d sbl g pan a hi ot r s jc e
J opel onsde e mp ls o li s ia i i nd s he ub e dv
n
com pli s
ant .
C.N ew'Evi
dence

I Wiknsv S c De 'Helh a Hu nSev.9 3F.d 9 ,9 (t Ci.1 91,
n li . e '
t at nd ma r s, 5 2 3 6 4h t 9 )
t Fourh Cic the d t tf Appe l Counc l us consde e de s it w1. t
he
t t ui l ha f
The
as
im t
i r vi nce ubm ted t1 he
1

r q e tf rr ve i d cd n wh t tt g a r v e < t a ddona e i e ei ()ne
e u s o e iw n e ii g ehe o r nt e iw i he d i l v d nc s a w,
f

()maeila ()rltst t pei o o beo et daeo t AT 'd cso ' (uoi
b tra, nd c eae o he rod n r fr he t f he ,S e iin.'q tng
J
'
W iimsv.S l n,9 5 F. 21 ,2 6 (t Ci.1 9 ).l a i ,t r mus as be a
ln
l
ulva 0 2d 4 1 8 h r 9 0) n dddon hee t lo
i
t s bl pt biiyt tt a dona e de woul c nget out om eoft decson.
ea ona e oba tt ha he ddi l vi nce
d ha
he c
he ii

2 C. R. 4 4.70 S mu l ub lte ne e de et t eAppe l Co i, lc c nsse
0 F. j 0 9 . n e s n itd w vi nc o h
as unclwlih o itd

of2 pa e fo Ne Ho io He lh ae d t dJ l 1 , 1 t o g Fe t ay 1 , 1 ,
1 g s r m w rz ns at c r ae uy 9 20 7 ht u h b' r 4 20 8
u

a 1 pa fom Ca ii Clni Pan M ana m e ,da ed Fe a y 21,2018 t ough M a ch
nd 4 ges r
rlon i c i
ge nt t
bru r
hr
t

1 ,2 8 TheAppe l Co ncld ci d t c i rt e e i e ebe a et AI d cde
3 01 .
as u i e l o onsde h v d nc c us he J e i d
ne
Sa uelsc m on Aprl28,2017 and t e de w a pr
m ' bi
i
he vi nce s oduc afe t tda e.
ed t r ha t

S mue agu dt t maitaej get ttee ie c wa ne maeila drlva t
a l r e o he gsrt ud ha h vd n e s w, tra, n ee n
t t is e t t r beoet AT Heag e ta teAI dso tdS mue'alg éons
o he su s ha wee f r he J. ru d h t h J ic une a ls l a
,
e
ofpan be us he wa noton c
i ca e
s
ondnue pai m edia i a t ne e de e conft
d n
c tons nd he w vi nc
imed
t t opi ds w e e not pr c i d f li bec us of hi pas s t nc a e i s s a
ha
oi
r
es zbe or nm
a e
s t ubs a e bus s ue nd
ps chi ti il s The e de e f t ts e t tSa ue c
y a rc lnes .
vi nc urhe how d ha m l ondnue t ha sgni antl t
d o ve i hc ef

hi pan a w ake wih a lm p a t thi hi r a e e .
p i nd l d t i fe s p epl c m nt

Thema itaej g f und t a t ne e i e edd no z lt t y pe o o
gsrt ud ç o
h t he w v d nc i t eae o hç dod n r

beo et daeofteAT ' d cso Thema itaej g as f ndt tt ne e de e
fr he t h ,S e iin.
J
gsrt ud e lo ou ha he w vi nc
wa not n c lc wil t e i e eara yc i r dbyt AT a d t wozdnot iey
s i onfit tl he v d nc le d onsdee
he J n hus tl lk l
ha c nge he de ii
ve ha d r c son.

l li obe tons Sa l as dt smeagu nt her ie t t ma itaej g .
n ls jci , mue r ie he a r me s as d o he gsr t ud e
Al g S mue agu st a t AT ds ou e lsalg t ofpan be a s hewa n
t h a l r e h t he J ic ntd z l a i
hou
i e ons
i cue
s ot
onc ue panme iainst t sno ac lt r ctéo of heAT ' r a onsTheAT
on% d i d c to ,ha i t omp ee e ia n t
J
,S e s .
J
f m d t t Sn ue ' us of a c
ot
ha m ls e
l ohol snc li s ge y a hi r quess f na codc pan
i e as ut r nd s e t or r
i
m edi don we e nots r e de e ofs ve epan s pt sbe a e he ha a l hit y
ca
r
tong vi nc
e r i ym om
c us
d ong s or

ofhe vyac ho u epro t t sm pt . AT as no e t tt o t op dcs r e n
a lo l s i r o he y oms The J lo t d ha he rh e i u g o
ha not f
d
ound a fgood r as 'f Sa uels pan a ha notpr s rbed addi
r
e on' or m ' i nd d
e ci
donalpan
i
m e ca
i dons or uea nt e pt f physc t r py wlih Sa uel di not ate I
tne xce or
ial he a , lc
m
d
tnd. n
a don,at
ddi
lhough he t tfe t tpnn lm ie hi a lt t conce r t he as t s d t t
esi d ha i i t d s biiy o
nta e, lo e dhe ha

h wac dtlvso e jy dra igboo , n c ltdcoswo da S o upu ze .
e the ee iin, no e e dn
ksa d ompee r s r nd ud k z ls
R.5657.

The f ctt ta doc orwho s w Sa ue a t rAprl28,2017 f
a ha
t
a
m l fe
i
ound t us ofopi d
he e
oi
m e c don c r i ca e be a e of Sa uels hit y of acohol a e w oul not ha
dia
ont andi t d c us
m ' sor
l
bus
d
ve

c n e t AT ' o to S mu lsac l m wa wel l ntdi terc r a wa
ha g d he ,S piin. a e' lohoi
J
l
s s ldocz e n h e o d nd s
- me
ac
once n f ot doc or who pz s rbe m e c t ns R.896.H e t cal wa pr c i d
r or her t s
e c i d dia b .
ypi ly s es rbe
non- codc pan r le r s h a Cee ex,i of a t m i
nar
i eive s uc s lbt bupz en, ce n nophe and a pii R.696,
n,
s tn.
895,896 730. m uel nt t not ng i et t r or ort ne e de e t ti lc e
,
Sa
poi s o hi n iher he ec d he w vi nc ha nciat s

i woud ha c ng d t AI ' d cson wih tg r t hi s be t alg t ofpan.
t l ve ha e he Js eii t e ad o s u jci l ai
,
ve e ons
i
Theço e li obe donso t sis aeOVERRULED.
rfr,l jc
s
n hi sue r
CO N CLU SI N
O

Fo t r ao sae ,t c ur f n ez i t ma itaej g 'c ncuso
r he e s ns ttd he o t mds o roz n he gsrt ud es o l in
t tt A1Jsd cso i s ppo tdbys bsa ile i e c . s c t ma itaej g '
ha he ,' e ii n s u re
u tnta v d n e As u h, he gst t ud es
r por a r com m enda wilbe a ed i isentr y
e t nd e
don l
dopt n t iet .
An a opra e Or rw.lbe e e ed.
ppr i t de i
l
ntr

Ete:& % OQ M 11
nr
ed j
r

M iha lF. ba l
c e Ur nsd

Che Uri d S ae Ditit u ge
if le tts src l d
t