Northwest Territorial Mint LLC v. Hangzhou Cool Eagle Hardware Manufacturing Co., Ltd et al

Filing 24

ORDER granting pltf's 19 Motion for Default Judgment and Permanent Injunction by Judge Robert S. Lasnik.(RS)

1
2
3
4

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
WESTERN DISTRICT OF WASHINGTON
AT SEATTLE

5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12

_______________________________________
)
)
NORTHWEST TERRITORIAL MINT, INC., )
)
Plaintiff,
)
v.
)
)
HANGZHOU COOL EAGLE HARDWARE )
MANUFACTURING CO., LTD., et al.,
)
)
Defendants.
)
_______________________________________)

No. C11-0694RSL
DEFAULT JUDGMENT AND
PERMANENT INJUNCTION

13

This matter comes before the Court on “Plaintiff’s Motion for Entry of Default
14

Judgment” against defendant Hangzhou Cool Eagle Hardware Manufacturing Co., Ltd., d/b/a
15

Cool Eagle Mint, d/b/a Chinese Seller, d/b/a Cool Eagle Mint Co. Ltd., d/b/a Cool Eagle
16

Hardware Manufacturing Co. Ltd. Hangzhou (collectively, “Cool Eagle”).
17

Having reviewed the materials submitted and the remainder of the record,1 the

18

Court finds and orders as follows:
19

a.

Cool Eagle has failed to appear in this action and has failed to answer NW

20

Territorial Mint’s complaint (Dkt. # 1). Thus, each averment of the complaint is deemed
21

admitted.
22

b.

Based on the allegations of the complaint, the Court has jurisdiction over the

23

parties and the subject matter in this case. Venue in this district is proper.
24
25
1

26

This matter can be decided on the papers submitted. Plaintiff’s request for oral argument is
DENIED.
DEFAULT JUDGMENT AND
PERMANENT INJUNCTION

c.

1

Cool Eagle offers for sale on its website (www.cooleaglemint.com) coins that

2

appear to be identical or substantially similar to coins depicted on NW Territorial Mint’s website

3

(www.nwtmint.com). NW Territorial Mint owns copyrights in the original designs of its coins

4

and the photographs of the designs depicted on its website. Cool Eagle admitted in writing that

5

it has copied NW Territorial Mint’s original coin designs and infringed NW Territorial Mint’s

6

intellectual property rights.

7

d.

NW Territorial Mint has established its copyright infringement claim.

8

e.

NW Territorial Mint would suffer irreparable harm if a permanent injunction is not

9

entered because Cool Eagle’s copyright infringement jeopardizes NW Territorial Mint’s

10

competitive position by threatening the loss of prospective customers, goodwill, and reputation.

11

Moreover, NW Territorial Mint and Cool Eagle compete for the same customers in the same

12

markets. By gaining a free ride on NW Territorial Mint’s investment in creating its works, Cool

13

Eagle gains an unfair advantage in the marketplace that cannot fully be remedied with an award

14

of damages.
f.

15

The balance of equities tips sharply in NW Territorial Mint’s favor. Cool Eagle

16

admits it copied NW Territorial Mint’s designs. It promised to stop doing so, but continues to

17

copy and sell NW Territorial Mint’s designs to customers within NW Territorial Mint’s market.

18

The only injury Cool Eagle will suffer if permanent injunctive relief is granted is the loss of

19

market share and profits to which it is not, in equity or at law, entitled.
g.

20

Finally, the issuance of a permanent injunction is in the public interest because the

21

United States public has an interest in enforcing United States copyrights. If a person were able

22

to gain a free ride on the investment a copyright holder made to create its works, the copyright

23

holder would lose the incentive to continue to make that investment, which would harm the

24

public.

25
26
DEFAULT JUDGMENT AND
PERMANENT INJUNCTION

-2-

Accordingly, IT IS ORDERED that default judgment and a permanent injunction

1
2

is hereby entered in NW Territorial Mint’s favor and against Cool Eagle.2
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that:

3
4

1.

Cool Eagle, and its affiliates, officers, agents, servants, employees, attorneys and

5

all other persons in active concert or participation with any of them, are permanently enjoined

6

and restrained from copying images or coin designs from NW Territorial Mint or any of its

7

websites.

8

2.

9

Cool Eagle, and its affiliates, officers, agents, servants, employees, attorneys and

all other person in active concert or participation with any of them (including but not limited to

10

the owners of the websites accessible at www.eBay.com, www.Amazon.com,

11

www.AliExpress.com, and www.AliBaba.com), are hereby permanently enjoined and restrained

12

from displaying, advertising, selling, offering for sale, or otherwise using in any way images or

13

coin designs that were copied from NW Territorial Mint or its website.

14

3.

Cool Eagle, and its affiliates, officers, agents, servants, employees, attorneys and

15

all other person in active concert or participation with any of them, are hereby permanently

16

enjoined and restrained from importing, delivering, shipping, or providing “challenge” or other

17

commemorative coins (i.e., coins that are not legal tender) to any person or entity located in the

18

United States or on a United States military base located anywhere in the world except pursuant

19

to the terms stated below in subparagraphs (a) - (c).

20

(a)

That before delivering, shipping, or providing coins described in paragraph

21

3 to any person or entity therein described, Cool Eagle must notify NW Territorial

22

Mint and provide a description of all such coins using the same descriptions and

23

photos (including .jpg files) used in its marketing of such coins. Notice shall be

24

provided by email to Joe Beitey at [e-mail] and Michael Atkins at

25
2

26

No other complaining party has appeared or shown that Cool Eagle has violated its intellectual
property rights. Plaintiff may not assert the rights of third parties or seek remedies on their behalf.
DEFAULT JUDGMENT AND
PERMANENT INJUNCTION

-3-

1

[e-mail] or such other persons and/or addresses as NW Territorial Mint

2

reasonably designates.

3

(b)

4

business day from the date of receipt of Cool Eagle’s notice to object to Cool

5

Eagle’s proposed delivery or shipment on the ground that the proposed delivery or

6

shipment contains coins that infringe NW Territorial Mint’s copyrights.

7

Objections shall be sent to Cool Eagle by email to Andy Sun at

8

[e-mail] and [e-mail] or such other

9

persons and/or address as Cool Eagle Mint reasonably designates.

That NW Territorial Mint shall have until 5 p.m. Pacific Time on the fifth

10

(c)

11

paragraph 3 to any person or entity therein described if it receives an objection in

12

the manner described in subparagraph (b) unless it first obtains an Order from this

13

Court determining that the proposed delivery or shipment does not contain coins

14

that infringe NW Territorial Mint’s copyrights.

15

4.

That Cool Eagle Mint shall not deliver, ship, or provide coins described in

This Court shall retain jurisdiction for purposes of enforcing this injunction.

16
17

Dated this 26th day of March, 2012.

A
Robert S. Lasnik

18
19

United States District Judge
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
DEFAULT JUDGMENT AND
PERMANENT INJUNCTION

-4-