National Products, Inc. v. Arkon Resources, Inc.

Filing 155

ORDER ON DEPOSITION OBJECTIONS by Hon. James P. Donohue. (TF)

Download PDF
1 2 3 4 5 6 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT WESTERN DISTRICT OF WASHINGTON AT SEATTLE 7 8 NATIONAL PRODUCTS, INC., 9 Plaintiff, 10 ORDER ON DEPOSITION OBJECTIONS v. 11 12 Case No. C15-1553-JPD ARKON RESOURCES, INC., Defendant. 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 For the benefit of the parties, the Court ORDERS as follows: 1. Deposition of Aaron Roth. Objection Location Sustained Overruled Page 18, Lines 17-25 X Page 19, Lines 1-6 X Page 20, Lines 5-6 X Page 21, Line 2 X Page 21, Lines 21-24 X Page 22, Lines 1-2 X 25 Page 47, Lines 5-9 X 26 Page 48, Lines 19-25 X ORDER PAGE - 1 1 Objection Location 2 Page 49, Lines 1-2 X 3 Page 50, Lines 8-13 X 4 Page 57, Lines 19-20 X Page 58, Lines 12-22 X Page 66, Lines 2-8 X Page 68, Lines 11-14 X Page 69, Lines 21-23 X Page 73, Lines 21-25 X 11 Page 74, Lines 1-14 X 12 Page 79, Lines 21-25 X 5 6 7 8 9 10 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 Sustained Overruled Page 80, Line 1 Page 81, Lines 23-25 X Page 82, Lines 1-2 Page 83, Lines 10-22 X Page 91, Lines 23-25 X Page 92, Lines 1-25 Page 93, Lines 2-12 X Page 97, Lines 9-11 X 2. Deposition of Paul Brassard. 22 23 Objection Location Sustained Overruled Page 18, Line 6-13 X 25 Page 18, Lines 14-25 X 26 Page 19, Lines 1-5 X 24 ORDER PAGE - 2 1 Objection Location 2 Page 19, Lines 7-12 X 3 Page 19, Lines 13-21 X 4 Page 23, Lines 1-21 X Page 24, Lines 3-14 X Page 29, Lines 5-14 X Page 32, Lines 22-23 X Page 33, Line 25 X Page 34, Lines 1-2 X 11 Page 39, Lines 18-25 X 12 Page 40, Lines 1-12 X 13 Page 41, Lines 12-22 X 14 Page 43, Lines 6-8 15 Page 43, Lines 19-25 X Page 44, Lines 1-14 X 5 6 7 8 9 10 16 17 18 19 20 Sustained Overruled X Page 47, Lines 3-13 X Page 47, Lines 18-25 X Page 48, Lines 1-5 X Page 51, Lines 10-18 X Page 60, Lines 2-16 X 23 Page 72, Lines 9-25 X 24 Page 73, Lines 1-25 X 25 Page 74, Lines 1-25 X 21 22 26 ORDER PAGE - 3 1 Objection Location 2 Page 92, Lines 10-16 X 3 Page 92, Lines 19-25 X 4 Page 93, Lines 1-4 X Page 93, Lines 6-17 X 5 6 7 8 Sustained Page 93, Lines 18-25 X Page 94, Lines 1-6 Overruled X Page 95, Lines 4-10 X Page 95, Lines 16-20 X 11 Page 104, Lines 13-25 X 12 Page 105, Lines 1-20 X 13 Page 113, Line 25 X 14 Page 114, Lines 1-11 X 15 Page 114, Lines 13-25 X Page 115, Lines 1-3 X Page 115, Lines 4-18 X Page 115, Lines 20-25 X Page 116, Lines 1-5 X Page 116, Lines 18-24 X Page 121, Lines 21-25 X 23 Page 122, Lines 2-5 X 24 Page 122, Lines 24-25 X 25 Page 123, Lines 1-3 X 9 10 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 26 ORDER PAGE - 4 1 Objection Location 2 Page 124, Lines 22-25 X 3 Page 125, Lines 1-12 X 4 Page 127, Lines 21-25 X Page 128, Lines 1-11 X Page 128, Lines 22-25 X Page 129, Lines 1-4 X Page 129, Lines 11-16 X Page 131, Lines 4-20 X 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Page 136, Lines 18-25 12 Sustained Page 138, Lines 16-24 13 3. Overruled X X Deposition of Steven Hull. 14 15 Objection Location Sustained Overruled 16 Page 15, Lines 23-25 X 17 Page 16, Lines 3-12 X 18 Page 17, Lines 1-25 X 19 Page 18, Lines 1-25 X 20 Page 19, Lines 1-15 X 21 Page 20, Lines 3-16 X Page 21, Lines 11-25 X Page 22, Lines 1-12 X Page 22, Lines 16-25 X Page 23, Lines 1-18 X 22 23 24 25 26 ORDER PAGE - 5 1 Objection Location 2 Page 24, Lines 4-25 X 3 Page 25, Lines 1-22 X 4 Page 28, Lines 22-25 X Page 29, Lines 1-5 X Page 30, Lines 20-25 X 5 6 7 8 9 Sustained Page 35, Lines 15-18 X Page 36, Lines 1-9 Overruled X Page 43, Lines 12-25 X 11 Page 44, Lines 1-25 X 12 Page 45, Lines 2-9 X 13 Page 57, Lines 2-7 X 14 Page 57, Lines 8-17 X 15 Page 59, Lines 20-25 X Page 60, Line 1 X Page 60, Lines 5-25 X Page 61, Lines 1-10 X Page 61, Lines 13-25 X Page 62, Lines 1-3 X Page 62, Lines 18-25 X 23 Page 63, Lines 1-4 X 24 Page 68, Lines 13-25 X 25 Page 69, Lines 1-12 X 10 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 26 ORDER PAGE - 6 1 Objection Location 2 Page 71, Lines 6-24 X 3 Page 72, Lines 2-18 X 4 Page 80, Lines 24-25 X Page 81, Lines 1-3 X Page 81, Lines 14-21 X 5 6 7 8 9 10 Sustained Page 85, Lines 6-10 X Page 85, Lines 16-25 X Page 86, Lines 1-2 Overruled X 11 Page 87, Lines 17-23 X 12 Page 88, Lines 4-16 X 13 Page 91, Lines 5-7 X 14 Page 91, Lines 13-19 X 15 Page 94, Lines 19-25 X Page 95, Lines 1-23 X Page 96, Lines 1-5 X 16 17 18 19 4. Deposition of Joseph Todrzak. 20 Objection Location 21 Page 24, Line 25 22 Page 25, Lines 1-12 23 Page 27, Lines 1-25 X 24 Page 28, Lines 1-19 X Page 29, Lines 4-25 X 25 26 ORDER PAGE - 7 Sustained Overruled X 1 Objection Location 2 Page 30, Lines 1-25 X 3 Page 31, Lines 1-25 X 4 Page 32, Lines 1-18 X Page 35, Lines 7-9 X 5 6 7 8 9 Page 41, Lines 2-4 Sustained X Page 44, Lines 1-8 Page 50, Lines 12-13 Overruled X X Page 65, Lines 15-23 X 11 Page 71, Lines 4-18 X 12 Page 83, Lines 9-13 X 13 Page 83, Line 25 X 14 Page 84, Lines 1-3 X 15 Page 86, Lines 11-25 X Page 87, Lines 1-24 X 10 16 17 Page 89, Lines 23-25 X Page 90, Lines 1-25 X Page 91, Lines 1-25 X Page 92, Lines 1-18 X Page 117, Lines 23-25 X 23 Page 118, Lines 1-9 X 24 Page 121, Lines 23-25 X 25 Page 122, Lines 1-25 X 18 19 20 21 22 26 ORDER PAGE - 8 1 Objection Location Sustained 2 Page 123, Lines 1-25 X 3 Page 124, Lines 1-7 X 4 Page 124, Lines 15-22 X Page 126, Lines 2-14 X Page 127, Lines 6-25 X Page 128, Lines 1-5 X 5 6 7 8 Overruled Page 142, Lines 17-19 X Page 143, Lines 4-10 X 11 Page 143, Lines 17-25 X 12 Page 152, Lines 24-25 X 13 Page 153, Lines 1-2 X 14 Page 157, Lines 8-14 X 15 Page 158, Lines 2-9 X Page 159, Lines 7-14 X 9 10 16 17 18 Attorney objections or questions will not be read without prior approval of the Court. 19 Dated this 30th day of November, 2017. A 20 21 JAMES P. DONOHUE Chief United States Magistrate Judge 22 23 24 25 26 ORDER PAGE - 9

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?