D.T. v NECA/IBEW Family Medical Care Plan et al

Filing 213

ORDER re Plaintiff's 204 Motion for Final Approval of Settlement Agreement, Award of Attorney Fees and Litigation Costs, and Incentive Award; and Motion for Extension of Deadline to Allow Processing and Payment of Late Filed and Emailed C laims and for Notice of Arbitration Process to Claimants. The Settlement Agreement is approved. Class counsel is awarded attorney fees and litigation costs. The Claims Processor is ordered to provide written notice regarding the arbitration pr ocess. Case contribution award of $25,000 to Plaintiff D.T., by and through his parents K.T. and W.T., as set forth in the Agreement is approved. Class counsel is ordered to submit a Final Report in accordance with the Agreement and this Order. The Court shall retain jurisdiction over this matter until the Settlement Amount is fully disbursed and an Order of Dismissal is entered. Signed by Judge James L. Robart. (LH) (cc: Judge Robart's chambers via ECF ad hoc)

Case 2:17-cv-00004-RAJ Document 213 Filed 10/08/21 Page 1 of 9

1
2
3
4
5
6

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
WESTERN DISTRICT OF WASHINGTON
AT SEATTLE

7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23

D.T., by and through his parents and
guardians, K.T. and W.T., individually, on
behalf of similarly situated individuals,
and on behalf of the NECA/IBEW Family
Medical Care Plan,
Plaintiff,
v.
NECA/IBEW FAMILY MEDICAL CARE
PLAN, THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF
THE NECA/IBEW FAMILY MEDICAL
CARE PLAN, SALVATORE J. CHILIA,
ROBERT P. KLEIN, DARRELL L.
MCCUBBINS, GEARY HIGGINS,
LAWRENCE J. MOTER, JR., KEVIN
TIGHE, JERRY SIMS, AND ANY OTHER
INDIVIDUAL MEMBER OF THE BOARD
OF TRUSTEES OF NECA/IBEW FAMILY
MEDICAL CARE PLAN,

NO. 2:17-cv-00004-RAJ
ORDER
(1) FINALLY APPROVING
SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT;
(2) APPROVING DISBURSEMENTS
PURSUANT TO THE SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENT; APPROVING
PAYMENT OF ATTORNEYS FEES,
LITIGATION COSTS AND CASE
CONTRIBUTION AWARD;
(3) ESTABLISHING A LATE CLAIM
DEADLINE DUE TO COVID-19;
(4) REQUIRING NOTICE OF THE
ARBITRATION PROCESS TO
CLAIMANTS; AND
(5) ORDERING FINAL REPORT ON
DISBURSEMENT OF QUALIFIED
SETTLEMENT FUND

Defendants.
I.

BACKGROUND

24

On February 2, 2021, this Court preliminarily approved the Settlement Agreement

25

in this matter and certified the Settlement Class. Dkt. No. 197. The Court directed the

26

Claims Processor to issue notice to the Settlement Class. Id., ¶4. Class Notices and Claim
ORDER FINALLY APPROVING SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENT, ETC. – 1
[Case No. 2:17-cv-00004-RAJ]

Case 2:17-cv-00004-RAJ Document 213 Filed 10/08/21 Page 2 of 9

1

Form Materials were mailed in accordance with the Class Notice procedures beginning

2

April 26, 2021. . Dkt. No. 199, ¶¶4-5 The Claims Processor updated Notice recipients’

3

addresses when the notices were returned and re-mailed the notices to all updated

4

addresses located. Fortunato Decl., ¶6.

5

Class counsel also established a settlement web page within 30 days of the date of

6

the February 12, 2021 Order that contained the Class Notice, the Claim Form Materials

7

and key filings in the litigation, including the Motion for Attorney Fees, Litigation Costs

8

and

9

http://www.symslaw.com/dtsettlement (last visited 9/27/21). Defendants provided

10

the required notice under the Class Action Fairness Act (“CAFA”). Hamburger Decl.,

11

Exh. 4.

Contribution

Award.

Hamburger

Decl.,

¶6;

see

12

The Order also provided that class members who wished to comment on or object

13

to the proposed Agreement were required to do so by September 24, 2021. Class

14

members were informed of their rights and of this deadline in the notices that were

15

mailed to them and via links on Class counsel’s website.

16

The Order further scheduled a final settlement hearing, which was held on

17

October 8, 2021, to consider objections and comments by class members and to determine

18

whether the proposed Agreement is fair, reasonable, adequate and should be approved

19

by the Court.
II. FINDINGS

20
21

1.

The parties reached a Settlement Agreement providing prospective

22

coverage of medically necessary Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) therapy and

23

Neurodevelopmental Therapies (“NDT”) (speech, occupational and physical therapies)

24

to treat certain mental health conditions that Defendants considered to be

25

“Developmental Delays.” See Dkt. No. 194-1, ¶¶6.1-6.3.

26

ORDER FINALLY APPROVING SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENT, ETC. – 2
[Case No. 2:17-cv-00004-RAJ]

Case 2:17-cv-00004-RAJ Document 213 Filed 10/08/21 Page 3 of 9

2.

1

The Settlement Agreement also establishes a Settlement Amount in a

2

notational account of $1,700,000. Under the terms of the Agreement, this fund is to be

3

used to pay retrospective claims for unreimbursed ABA and NDT services to treat

4

qualifying mental health conditions during the class period as well as alternative health

5

insurance purchased by class members to mitigate their damages. Any funds remaining

6

in the Settlement Amount after these payments will be returned to Defendants.
3.

7

The Agreement provides that the Defendants’ Benefit Office acts as the

8

Claims Processor to receive and process claims.

9

arbitration process. See Settlement Agreement, § 8.3.6.
4.

10

The Agreement provides for an

The Court’s Order required the Claim Processor to mail court-approved

11

notices and claim forms, to class members by direct mail. The notices informed class

12

members that they had an opportunity to object or submit comments to the Court

13

regarding the proposed Agreement and that they must do so in writing by September 24,

14

2021.
5.

15
16

Consistent with the Order, Defendants provided notices and materials

required under the Class Action Fairness Act (“CAFA”), 28 U.S.C. § 1715(b).
6.

17

Class Notices were mailed to 1,890 participants and beneficiaries in the

18

Plan. The Claims Processor reports that it searched for updated addresses for notices

19

that were returned and resent the Class Notice to any updated addresses found. See

20

Fortunato Decl., ¶6.
7.

21
22

No class members objected to the Settlement Agreement.

No class

members submitted comments.
8.

23

A total of 129 claims were received by the Claims Processor by July 30,

24

2021.

25

Processor, is approximately $351,681.46. The Claims Processor anticipates authorizing a

26

The total value of these claims, before they are adjudicated by the Claims

total payment of $277,967.74.
ORDER FINALLY APPROVING SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENT, ETC. – 3
[Case No. 2:17-cv-00004-RAJ]

Case 2:17-cv-00004-RAJ Document 213 Filed 10/08/21 Page 4 of 9

9.

1

Of the 129 claims received, 18 of the claims were denied for at least some

2

portion of the claimed amount. Fortunato Decl. ¶12. See Hamburger Decl., ¶10, Exh. 5.

3

The Claims Processor and Defendants agree to provide notice of the arbitration process

4

to Claimants with denied claims. Hamburger Decl., Exh. 6.
10.

5

The Claims Processor and Defendants agree to include notice about the

6

arbitration process to Claimants whose claims have been approved and are receiving

7

reimbursement from Defendants.
III. CONCLUSIONS

8

11.

9

Rule 23(e) provides that “a class action shall not be dismissed or

10

compromised without the approval of the court….” Compromise and arbitration of

11

complex litigation is encouraged and favored by public policy. See Simula, Inc. v. Autoliv,

12

Inc., 175 F.3d 716, 719 (9th Cir. 1999).
12.

13

A presumption of fairness and adequacy attaches to a class action

14

settlement reached in arm’s-length negotiations by experienced class counsel after

15

meaningful discovery. See, e.g., Officers for Justice v. Civil Service Com., 688 F.2d 615, 625

16

(9th Cir. 1982); Pickett v. Holland Am. Line-Westours, Inc., 145 Wn.2d 178, 209, 35 P.3d 351

17

(2001).

18

13.

Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(e)(2) requires a reviewing court to find

19

that a settlement “is fair, reasonable, and adequate” before granting final approval of a

20

class settlement. The court must consider whether:

21
22

(A) the class representatives and class counsel have adequately
represented the class;

23

(B) the proposal was negotiated at arm’s length;

24

(C) the relief provided for the class is adequate, taking into account:

25

(i) the costs, risks, and delay of trial and appeal;

26

ORDER FINALLY APPROVING SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENT, ETC. – 4
[Case No. 2:17-cv-00004-RAJ]

Case 2:17-cv-00004-RAJ Document 213 Filed 10/08/21 Page 5 of 9

(ii) the effectiveness of any proposed method of distributing relief to
the class, including the method of processing class-member claims;

1
2

(iii) the terms of any proposed award of attorney’s fees, including
timing of payment;

3
4

(iv) any agreement required to be identified under Rule 23(e)(3), [which
requires the parties seeking approval to file a statement identifying any
agreement made in connection with the proposal]; and

5
6

(D) the proposal treats class members equitably relative to each other.

7
8
9

Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(e)(2).
14.

Based upon these factors, the Court finds that the Agreement is fair,

10

reasonable, and in the best interests of the class. The requirements of Fed. R. Civ. P.

11

23(e)(2) have been satisfied. With the amended notice requirements for class members

12

who submitted claims specified in this Order, due process requirements have also been

13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25

satisfied.
15.

Specifically, the Court concludes that the Agreement was the result of

arm’s-length bargaining. It was reached after sufficient discovery and other litigation
activity. Although the class had a strong likelihood of success, the key legal issues in the
case had not been adjudicated, such that there was risk in proceeding with the litigation.
A settlement in which class members will be able to continue to obtain coverage of
medically necessary ABA and NDT services in the future, and reimbursement for costs
incurred to obtain medically necessary ABA and NDT services in the past achieves the
goals of the litigation. There is no evidence of collusion between the parties, and the
agreement was reached in good faith.
16.

The class was provided with adequate notice, and due process has been

satisfied in connection with the distribution of the class notice. No objections to the
proposed Agreement were received by the Court or any of the parties.

26

ORDER FINALLY APPROVING SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENT, ETC. – 5
[Case No. 2:17-cv-00004-RAJ]

Case 2:17-cv-00004-RAJ Document 213 Filed 10/08/21 Page 6 of 9

1

17.

Adequate notice to class members about their eligibility for reimbursement

2

under the Settlement Agreement was achieved, and due process is met in the settlement

3

claims process with the above agreements.
IV. PAYMENTS TO CLASS MEMBERS

4
5

18.

Upon the occurrence of the conditions set forth in Section 2 of the

6

Settlement Agreement, the Court authorizes the payment of approved class member

7

claims. The Court authorizes the disbursement of these funds from the Settlement

8

Amount.
V. ATTORNEY FEES AND LITIGATION COSTS

9
10

19.

Class counsel are entitled to their actual lodestar (hours x rate) attorney

11

fees and litigation costs up to $850,000 under the terms of the Settlement Amount, subject

12

to Court approval. That approval is granted, and the Court awards $850,000 as attorney

13

fees to Class counsel to be paid by Defendants.

14
15
16

20.

No objections were received to Class counsel’s fee request or the request

for reimbursement of litigation costs.
21.

Upon the occurrence of the conditions set forth in Section 2 of the

17

Settlement Agreement, Defendants are ordered to pay the approved attorney fees and

18

litigation costs to class counsel.
VI. CASE CONTRIBUTION AWARD

19
20

22.

Upon the occurrence of the conditions set forth in Section 2 of the

21

Settlement Agreement, D.T. by and through his parents K.T. and W.T. are awarded a

22

case contribution award in the sum of $25,000 as described in the Settlement Agreement,

23

subject to the Court’s approval. That approval is granted and the Defendants are

24

ordered to pay the approved case contribution award to Plaintiff D.T. as required by the

25

Settlement Agreement.

26

23.

No objections were received to the request for case contribution awards.

ORDER FINALLY APPROVING SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENT, ETC. – 6
[Case No. 2:17-cv-00004-RAJ]

Case 2:17-cv-00004-RAJ Document 213 Filed 10/08/21 Page 7 of 9

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8

VII. AUTHORIZATION OF LATE-FILED AND EMAILED CLAIMS

24.

were properly and timely-filed but instead emailed to Class counsel who forwarded the
email to the Claims Processor and Defense counsel. The maximum value of the four
claims is under $10,000.

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18

25.

The Court orders the Claims Processor to accept all late-filed or emailed

claims through September 30, 2021. The Claims Processor is ordered to adjudicate those
claims as if they were timely filed and received via U.S. mail.
VIII. NOTICE OF ARBITRATION PROCEDURE

26.

The Claims Processor is ordered to provide written notice about the

availability of the Settlement Agreement’s arbitration process to all class members who
submitted claims and that they must submit written notice of their intention to invoke
the arbitration process to both Defendants and Class counsel within thirty (30) days of
the date of the notice, via email and/or U.S. Mail.
27.

The Claims Processor and Class counsel shall reach agreement on a

reasonable manner for class members to access the arbitration process. If the Claims
Processor and Class counsel cannot reach agreement, then this issue shall be decided by
the arbitrator pursuant to the Settlement Agreement, ¶8.3.6.

19

IX. CLASS COUNSEL’S FINAL REPORT, DISMISSAL
AND REVERSION TO DEFENDANTS

20
21

Adjudication and payment of these four claims will not

prejudice any other Class member.

9
10

The Claims Processor rejected four claims because they were filed late, or

28.

Class counsel shall submit a final report to the Court regarding claims

22

processing and disbursement of funds from the Settlement Amount by no later than

23

30 days after the Claims Processor processes and pays all valid claims, including any late

24

filed or emailed Claims authorized for payment by the Court, and any claims ordered to

25

be paid as a result of the arbitration process. The Report shall detail the payment of

26

court-awarded attorney fees and litigation costs, case contribution award, payment of
ORDER FINALLY APPROVING SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENT, ETC. – 7
[Case No. 2:17-cv-00004-RAJ]

Case 2:17-cv-00004-RAJ Document 213 Filed 10/08/21 Page 8 of 9

1

claims, and the amount of funds anticipated to revert to Defendants, as well as any other

2

activities necessary to close the Settlement Amount. At the same time, Class counsel

3

shall file a proposed Order of Dismissal.

4

29.

All remaining funds, if any, in the Settlement Amount shall be returned to

5

Defendants within 60 days of the entry of the Order of Dismissal, and consistent with

6

the requirements of the Settlement Agreement.
X. ORDER

7
8

It is hereby ORDERED that:

9

1.

10
11
12
13

The Settlement Agreement is approved as fair, reasonable and adequate

under Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(e)(2), and its terms shall bind all class members.
2.

Class counsel is awarded attorney fees and litigation costs, as set forth

above. These amounts are ordered to be paid to Class counsel by Defendants.
3.

The Claims Processor is ordered to accept, adjudicate and pay all late-filed

14

claims and emailed claims received by September 30, 2021, as if the claims were timely

15

filed and received via U.S. Mail.

16

4.

The Claims Processor is ordered to provide written notice regarding the

17

arbitration process, consistent with this Order and the terms of the Settlement

18

Agreement, to all class members who submitted claims. The Claims Processor must

19

reach agreement with Class counsel on the manner in which class members may access

20

the arbitration process. If the Claims Processor and Class counsel are unable to reach

21

agreement on this issue, then the Arbitrator shall decide, pursuant to Section 8.3.6 of the

22

Settlement Agreement.

23

5.

The Claims Processor is ordered to make payments and distribute checks

24

to Class members and the named Plaintiff in accordance with the Agreement and this

25

Order, as approved by the Claims Processor or on appeal by the Arbitrator. These

26

amounts are authorized to be paid from the Settlement Amount.
ORDER FINALLY APPROVING SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENT, ETC. – 8
[Case No. 2:17-cv-00004-RAJ]

Case 2:17-cv-00004-RAJ Document 213 Filed 10/08/21 Page 9 of 9

1

6.

Case contribution award of $25,000 to Plaintiff D.T., by and through his

2

parents K.T. and W.T., as set forth in the Agreement is approved, and the Claims

3

Processor is ordered to distribute that sum from the Settlement Amount to the parents

4

of D.T.

5
6
7
8
9

7.

Class counsel is ordered to submit a Final Report in accordance with the

Agreement and this Order.
8.

The Court shall retain jurisdiction over this matter until the Settlement

Amount is fully disbursed and an Order of Dismissal is entered.
It is so ORDERED this 8th day of October, 2021.

10

A

11
12

JAMES L. ROBART
United States District Judge

13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26

ORDER FINALLY APPROVING SETTLEMENT
AGREEMENT, ETC. – 9
[Case No. 2:17-cv-00004-RAJ]