Ruppert, Lawrence G. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Fund
Filing
572
JUDGMENT declaring that defendant Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan violated 29 U.S.C. § 1054(c)(3) by underpaying the lump sum retirement benefits of plaintiffs Lawrence G. Ruppert and Thomas A. Larson and all members of the certified subclasses identified in the July 2, 2012 order of this court. Plaintiffs are awarded $7,890,569.75 in additional plan benefits and $10,787,101.58 in prejudgment interest. (BBC/PAO) (arw)
<![CDATA[
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF WISCONSIN
LAWRENCEG.RUPPERT
and THOMASA. LARSON,
on behalf of themselves and on behalf
of all others similarly situated,
JUDGMENT IN A CIVIL CASE
Plaintiffs,
Case No. 08-cv-127-bbc
v.
ALLIANT ENERGY CASH
BALANCE PENSION PLAN,
Defendant.
This action came for consideration before the court with District Judge
Barbara B. Crabb presiding. The issues have been considered and a decision has been
rendered.
IT IS ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that judgment is entered declaring that
defendant Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan violated 29 U.S.C. ยง 1054(c)(3) by
underpaying the lump sum retirement benefits of plaintiffs Lawrence G. Ruppert and
Thomas A. Larson and all members of the certified subclasses identified in the July 2,
2012
order of this court. Plaintiffs are awarded $7,890,569.75 in additional plan benefits and
$10,787,101.58 in prejudgment interest, to be distributed to class members as set forth in
Attachment A to this judgment.
Approved as to form this
~1'~ay of August, 2012.
~a -<.,A..~ . , ~
c... L,(,..,
Barbara B. Crabb
District Judge
~~
Peter Oppeneer
Clerk of Court
Date
i
Attachment A
232.31
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
29,897.17
29,712.33
370.64
13,537.47
29,712.33
138.33
35,152.93
319.80
15,743.16
319.80
0.00
1,457.49
432.80
658.24
494.32
598.63
432.80
A
Class A
Class B
A
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
A
A
A
A
A
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
A
A
A
B
B
B
B
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
B
B
B
B
B
Ruppert, et al. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.O. Wis.)
PIN
0.00
0.00
Underpayment
due to PJI
9322
16,359.70
19,409.77
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
1763
2656
1483
15507
6,603.25
12,253.56
7,897.04
6,603.25
52,738.19
17,376.83
14,760.44
0.00
72,658.07
5,123.27
6,863.40
9623
19,919.88
5,480.09
26,701.25
6700
2842
7347
6,605.97
67,655.73
858.86
1,105.89
1,194.23
15,742.36
1,125.88
11227
699.91
24,117.23
40,954.48
7350
447.65
8,374.87
1546
7351
6595
1071
11169
9,559.60
5,255.48
19,382.27
12,119.42
26,896.70
5,787.73
24,514.10
27,013.26
9,379.46
4,997.81
7,514.43
532.25
6,966.47
14,954.50
14,893.84
22,300.43
1061
2472
1,968.66
2655
2695
12,920.97
12,380.30
23,045.63
1114
29,184.32
47,647.77
9436
16,804.02
12,718.63
24,602.14
30,966.23
2551
18,247.60
6214
1089
Page 1 of 39
Ruppert, et al. v. Affiant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:0B-cv-00127-bbc (W.D. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
Class A
Class B
10263
123.81
441.49
317.68
A
B
2587
1,188.12
11,371.90
10,183.78
A
9881
444.09
1,485.37
1,041.28
A
B
B
2178
14,121.23
24,371.98
10,250.75
A
B
10089
492.60
1,517.06
1,024.46
A
B
10950
193.08
638.32
445.24
A
B
1808
0.00
0.00
0.00
A
B
2307
13,668.71
28,608.93
14,940.22
A
B
0.00
14,573.98
14,573.98
A
B
1,127.54
2,809.90
1,682.36
A
B
1931
0.00
15,978.41
15,978.41
B
8112
0.00
8,231.54
8,231.54
B
1611
10117
2117
0.00
0.00
0.00
3856
42,664.42
69,667.54
27,003.12
B
A
B
B
7146
0.00
0.00
0.00
5692
923.05
1,613.82
690.77
A
B
9238
826.58
3,195.13
2,368.55
A
B
11116
359.21
827.93
468.72
A
B
2507
1,450.20
8,742.22
7,292.02
A
B
10090
880.10
2,356.74
1,476.64
A
B
1770
60,173.11
103,853.39
43,680.28
A
B
1366
31,235.88
50,028.89
18,793.01
A
B
7881
0.00
11,785.66
1053
4,231.97
19,863.92
11,785.66
15,631.95
A
B
2129
28,071.74
52,478.05
24,406.31
A
B
Page 2 of 39
B
Ruppert, et al. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.O. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
Class A
Class B
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
1743
16,939.73
32,585.45
15,645.72
A
3508
2,644.59
6,632.44
3,987.85
A
A
A
A
A
1861
0.00
4,347.97
4,347.97
2585
15,959.50
26,937.98
10,978.48
6484
0.00
1,399.77
1,399.77
2369
3,773.82
10,012.21
6,238.39
10003
1,756.13
4,554.39
2,798.26
A
10294
1,885.35
4,404.01
2,518.66
2232
5,798.76
10,999.19
5,200.43
5235
0.00
340.68
340.68
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
1899
962.92
1,839.41
876.49
2489
42,063.71
71,382.24
29,318.53
6906
3,906.86
6,404.30
2,497.44
1260
26,836.74
44,487.68
17,650.94
9690
62.41
263.04
200.63
9273
1,164.44
4,597.53
3,433.09
15479
311.94
728.01
416.07
1598
0.00
0.00
0.00
1289
26,783.78
51,873.02
25,089.24
1015
5,578.79
21,490.28
15,911.49
A
A
A
A
A
A
2816
36,888.34
63,665.96
26,777.62
A
1047
16,526.27
28,045.13
11,518.86
9493
72.69
182.62
109.93
9008
4,534.92
15,217.10
10,682.18
6492
945.09
1,701.21
756.12
Page 3 of 39
B
8
8
B
8
B
8
8
B
8
8
B
8
B
8
8
8
B
Ruppert, et al. v. Afliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.O. Wis.)
PIN
7136
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
0.00
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
1,977.04
Class A
1,977.04
Class B
B
10144
0.00
2,790.15
2,790.15
1344
33,213.99
62,550.08
29,336.09
A
B
B
1457
5,140.64
21,813.87
16,673.23
A
B
9176
1,528.56
4,347.59
2,819.03
A
B
8,509.34
379.81
3,198.80
A
B
144.50
A
B
A
1068
5,310.54
9696
235.31
10181
463.98
1,598.21
1,134.23
2541
0.00
19,293.04
19,293.04
B
B
1337
19,309.45
48,693.37
29,383.92
A
B
10118
1,527.09
3,539.45
2,012.36
A
B
10497
431.90
1,090.50
658.60
A
B
2197
792.26
41,487.68
40,695.42
A
B
2352
29,568.96
47,009.17
17,440.21
A
B
1322
0.00
38,975.88
38,975.88
A
B
1766
5,751.94
21,329.94
15,578.00
A
B
8133
4,465.79
7,099.78
2,633.99
A
B
9209
1,656.18
2,633.02
976.84
A
B
9958
5967
0.00
1,080.82
1,668.70
8,486.07
1,668.70
7,405.25
A
B
B
7159
4,323.45
7,005.45
2,682.00
A
B
1492
3,582.60
10,698.00
7,115.40
A
B
1034
20,310.66
35,054.38
14,743.72
A
B
7113
0.00
176.58
176.58
A
B
2216
11,998.62
22,920.25
10,921.63
A
B
Page 4 of 39
Ruppert, et al. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.D. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
Class A
Class B
11059
378.64
909.78
531.14
A
B
9073
987.84
1,619.31
631.47
A
B
1562
32,297.56
69,856.25
37,558.69
A
B
9698
615.79
1,001.65
385.86
A
B
7888
372.09
710.78
338.69
A
B
1128
24,727.72
42,677.83
17,950.11
A
B
2461
48,370.64
83,483.38
35,112.74
A
B
1160
2,274.03
10,748.77
8,474.74
A
B
11141
0.00
375.49
375.49
6211
22,590.47
38,336.09
15,745.62
A
B
B
6,968.32
A
B
6822
2,636.37
9,604.69
2347
8,721.62
16,543.33
7,821.71
A
B
9439
191.97
309.86
117.89
B
6184
1,290.13
2,201.30
911.17
A
A
9367
536.42
852.81
316.39
A
B
1094
9,309.33
32,108.66
22,799.33
A
B
5761
0.00
3,305.44
3,305.44
A
B
143.40
356.95
213.55
A
B
1,358.39
2,317.77
959.38
A
B
11042
7941
B
9504
155.43
327.45
172.02
A
B
9607
2,671.35
9,789.36
7,118.01
A
B
1980
4,953.06
8,602.21
3,649.15
A
B
11085
404.38
1,016.80
612.42
A
10404
480.67
1,131.45
650.78
A
B
B
0.00
29,934.44
29,934.44
A
B
2441
Page 5 of 39
Ruppert, et a/. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.O. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
2594
0.00
8,121.86
8,121.86
1859
12,211.02
23,325.99
11,114.97
8143
888.41
2,982.17
2,093.76
11178
454.03
1,098.58
644.55
9883
Class A
A
A
A
A
Class B
B
B
B
B
222.24
680.81
458.57
A
B
1,476.67
3,453.34
1,976.67
B
9959
1,397.46
3,543.98
2,146.52
A
A
1426
15,075.63
25,583.39
10,507.76
A
B
A
A
B
10202
2350
0.00
4,823.37
4,823.37
1045
24,392.39
39,830.80
15,438.41
B
B
9121
1,315.34
2,156.17
840.83
A
B
1105
60,344.26
100,073.39
39,729.13
A
B
2646
23,607.51
71,481.05
47,873.54
A
B
10091
1,274.22
4,110.68
2,836.46
A
B
A
10953
141.78
439.17
297.39
1400
4,951.28
27,467.95
22,516.67
B
B
8151
539.49
891.22
351.73
7119
0.00
10,249.40
10,249.40
2009
0.00
10,512.35
10,512.35
2325
0.00
57,345.58
57,345.58
A
B
1031
7,725.03
14,756.67
7,031.64
A
B
9644
389.98
1,643.21
1,253.23
A
B
A
B
B
B
9740
188.43
653.29
464.86
A
B
7082
1,166.97
1,991.16
824.19
A
B
9839
60.28
508.98
448.70
A
B
Page 6 of 39
Ruppert, et al. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.D. Wis.)
PIN
1146
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
16,454.59
62,177.94
45,723.35
2502
0.00
7,647.36
7,647.36
10350
305.85
952.57
646.72
Class A
Class B
A
A
A
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
10072
1,698.80
4,216.70
2,517.90
A
1881
10,193.84
17,393.40
7,199.56
1505
8,210.99
61,859.23
53,648.24
A
A
9037
220.44
370.20
149.76
A
9323
20.43
730.69
710.26
2632
10,126.94
19,208.96
9,082.02
A
A
9608
1,639.72
3,705.13
2,065.41
A
9212
366.05
1,061.13
695.08
A
9653
3,167.71
8,071.83
4,904.12
15438
276.89
643.91
367.02
A
A
1667
0.00
20,377.65
20,377.65
9556
243.79
814.85
571.06
A
9160
55.86
290.03
234.17
A
10258
72.31
256.49
184.18
A
15523
0.00
118.53
118.53
5266
0.00
14,151.19
14,151.19
2150
32,954.97
58,009.91
25,054.94
A
2056
0.00
7,164.02
7,164.02
2205
0.00
81,953.99
81,953.99
1023
29,753.59
50,767.52
21,013.93
A
A
A
11121
124.32
333.39
209.07
A
2085
6,957.12
23,435.79
16,478.67
A
Page 7 of 39
Ruppert, et a/. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.O. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
1701
31,118.61
51,606.31
20,487.70
2047
28,511.58
49,208.43
20,696.85
3066
287.20
548.62
261.42
10182
1,850.95
4,654.86
2,803.91
1869
0.00
3,821.91
3,821.91
1234
0.00
38,377.21
38,377.21
9259
342.62
561.64
219.02
6176
9,057.08
15,834.96
6,777.88
3834
21,347.13
34,993.20
13,646.07
2737
1,056.88
9,082.68
8,025.80
1879
5,478.72
15,165.77
9,687.05
2578
15,387.08
40,047.07
24,659.99
2597
14,897.76
40,716.24
25,818.48
6868
543.36
1,015.77
472.41
8159
1,996.91
4,820.72
2,823.81
15439
255.95
592.99
337.04
1818
0.00
29,376.98
29,376.98
10954
133.01
427.69
294.68
2665
10,535.54
38,588.52
28,052.98
2011
0.00
0.00
5,464.34
16,820.18
Class B
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
B
0.00
2567
Class A
11,355.84
8113
1,325.34
4,360.58
3,035.24
7373
0.00
708.05
708.05
1174
9,382.63
17,540.14
8,157.51
1603
46,832.57
79,475.01
32,642.44
Page 8 of 39
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
A
A
A
A
B
B
B
B
Ruppert, et al. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.D. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
2633
21,589.03
36,636.65
1576
77,984.81
128,828.86
10367
466.12
1,274.17
2253
0.00
9,066.73
15,047.62
50,844.05
808.05
9,066.73
Class A
Class B
A
B
A
B
A
B
B
2253
0.00
12,088.97
12,088.97
B
2253
0.00
9,066.73
9,066.73
B
1937
21,380.03
53,852.46
32,472.43
A
B
1261
27,005.84
67,367.55
40,361.71
B
1090
21,461.50
37,040.62
15,579.12
1485
0.00
0.00
0.00
A
A
A
10010
1,930.07
4,423.23
2,493.16
A
B
557.30
1,742.38
1,185.08
A
B
A
A
B
A
B
9702
7099
188.43
644.76
456.33
1447
4,427.15
8,397.50
3,970.35
9245
0.00
2,931.87
65,366.37
105,506.81
40,140.44
B
B
B
2,931.87
1647
B
11097
415.66
966.48
550.82
A
2535
39,022.62
74,542.59
35,519.97
A
7973
1,076.07
1,807.10
731.03
A
B
B
B
2522
0.00
0.00
0.00
A
B
8135
791.34
1,297.20
505.86
A
9246
1,360.59
4,801.47
3,440.88
A
B
B
B
B
1908
9,857.67
18,564.41
8,706.74
A
B
1870
0.00
11,227.06
11,227.06
1248
18,591.57
39,668.62
21,077.05
A
Page 9 of 39
Ruppert, et al. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.O. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
Class A
Class B
2497
11,749.07
19,642.51
7,893.44
A
B
7086
2,206.91
3,659.88
1,452.97
A
B
2310
5,810.07
10,861.50
5,051.43
A
B
1939
4,229.87
51,133.61
46,903.74
A
B
4795
172.39
324.65
152.26
A
B
2316
56,319.92
97,203.13
40,883.21
A
B
11203
170.23
398.35
228.12
A
B
B
B
B
B
B
7312
62.44
104.86
42.42
A
1873
33,830.85
55,457.09
21,626.24
A
8095
1,296.63
5,188.59
3,891.96
A
2091
0.00
0.00
0.00
A
2406
149.56
5,649.15
5,499.59
A
9298
0.00
11,970.28
11,970.28
9530
0.00
4,889.04
4,889.04
11086
314.21
744.88
430.67
B
B
A
B
9422
213.44
845.48
632.04
A
B
2582
32,659.32
56,367.06
23,707.74
A
B
2027
0.00
25,743.15
25,743.15
9764
2,996.17
7,392.57
4,396.40
B
A
B
3979
0.00
8,053.53
8,053.53
9299
1,230.38
4,031.81
2,801.43
A
B
7190
784.47
1,422.81
638.34
A
B
9010
798.83
3,660.58
2,861.75
A
B
8114
6,514.18
15,118.86
8,604.68
A
B
9656
0.00
3,418.25
3,418.25
Page 10 of 39
B
B
Ruppert, et a/. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.D. Wis.)
PIN
1060
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
20,348.17
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
Class A
Class 8
B
B
B
35,119.12
14,770.95
A
A
2133
0.00
27,206.41
27,206.41
4631
4,054.40
13,349.45
9,295.05
2630
18,358.99
29,863.03
11,504.04
A
2293
8,171.85
14,103.88
5,932.03
A
B
B
9458
0.00
2,747.07
2,747.07
6430
15,353.44
36,252.43
20,898.99
A
B
B
1097
47,438.91
81,875.30
34,436.39
A
B
B
B
B
B
B
7377
895.64
1,624.44
728.80
A
1765
11,553.92
20,200.32
8,646.40
A
6190
0.00
0.00
0.00
A
1393
15,142.26
24,535.58
9,393.32
A
9423
47.78
78.32
30.54
A
2194
10,143.05
17,033.74
6,890.69
A
1803
2,526.48
4,826.18
2,299.70
A
2500
8,318.21
14,116.03
5,797.82
A
1017
0.00
10,957.51
10,957.51
9484
361.44
590.20
228.76
A
B
B
B
B
B
B
1645
0.00
20,443.33
20,443.33
1155
0.00
8,631.20
8,631.20
A
B
1410
22,636.14
53,388.86
30,752.72
A
B
1037
0.00
0.00
0.00
A
B
10093
2,071.94
5,132.66
3,060.72
A
9162
63.18
103.57
40.39
A
B
B
4089
0.00
449.29
449.29
A
B
Page 11 of 39
Ruppert, et al. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.O. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
2845
24,892.78
40,179.04
15,286.26
1618
0.00
12,301.08
12,301.08
1148
44,907.96
77,993.74
33,085.78
2024
0.00
5,637.21
5,637.21
7380
4,526.59
7,363.03
2,836.44
2864
45,695.22
77,968.17
32,272.95
6927
631.81
1,154.63
522.82
1070
0.00
3,779.74
3,779.74
8078
3,287.41
5,368.07
2,080.66
9744
94.86
581.09
486.23
1055
4,784.77
7,999.35
3,214.58
2045
0.00
29,381.59
29,381.59
1353
8,233.69
14,048.86
5,815.17
2615
15,471.18
26,701.87
11,230.69
7129
3,102.75
5,187.29
2,084.54
10351
0.00
619.39
2130
77,959.20
32,269.24
2527
70,520.56
116,048.46
45,527.90
1190
39,116.51
66,024.61
26,908.10
2885
7,654.96
12,694.79
5,039.83
4702
3,291.11
6,981.30
3,690.19
Class B
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
B
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
B
619.39
45,689.96
Class A
1773
0.00
0.00
0.00
6333
7194
5,624.81
13,367.01
7,742.20
4,209.93
6,981.64
2,771.71
8116
1,454.15
2,411.53
957.38
Page 12 of 39
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
Ruppert, et al. v. A/liant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.O. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
Class A
Class B
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
1848
21,429.20
40,647.30
19,218.10
9507
1,760.95
4,548.98
2,788.03
11142
281.77
695.71
413.94
A
A
A
1390
0.00
8,861.68
8,861.68
A
2596
22,268.42
34,454.93
37,995.84
15,727.42
A
59,839.48
25,384.55
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
2109
46,989.42
77,027.22
30,037.80
6330
10,999.86
26,684.60
15,684.74
6756
557.21
1,026.03
468.82
2682
0.00
14,413.12
14,413.12
1969
29,656.76
48,803.09
19,146.33
1747
0.00
57,076.29
57,076.29
1846
16,654.90
31,591.32
14,936.42
6928
0.00
6,855.36
6,855.36
9928
168.11
622.99
454.88
1844
1685
0.00
0.00
19,920.60
19,920.60
83,458.68
83,458.68
2614
39,741.45
68,590.18
28,848.73
2382
2,076.65
3,709.92
1,633.27
A
A
A
7386
10,774.74
28,976.83
18,202.09
A
8146
1,001.18
2,519.36
1,518.18
1990
12,745.39
28,723.53
15,978.14
A
A
A
A
A
7390
836.28
2,635.28
1,799.00
A
1830
7201
3,294.52
5,686.05
2,391.53
2164
4,193.37
14,092.54
9,899.17
Page 13 of 39
Ruppert, et al. v. Affiant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.D. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
Class A
Class B
2114
28,097.74
45,341.06
17,243.32
A
B
5978
4,394.30
16,164.09
11,769.79
A
B
9451
880.38
1,415.52
535.14
B
2603
0.00
15,705.87
15,705.87
5975
9,142.83
25,850.70
16,707.87
2611
41,071.81
66,037.48
24,965.67
2086
8,455.51
22,599.01
14,143.50
A
A
A
A
A
7204
610.12
1,313.70
703.58
A
B
B
B
2073
19,499.32
32,599.65
13,100.33
1415
27,552.27
47,552.75
20,000.48
1927
25,567.59
43,377.60
17,810.01
A
A
A
9214
324.78
3,715.94
3,391.16
A
15511
0.00
228.37
228.37
11063
267.65
647.24
379.59
1173
29,858.60
50,670.13
20,811.53
10325
306.08
968.84
662.76
8079
313.89
532.67
218.78
2413
0.00
32,951.11
32,951.11
1750
7,128.68
13,425.05
6,296.37
2064
10,151.24
18,692.11
8,540.87
1571
1,586.86
18,867.74
2,076.54
4,611.53
2,534.99
10228
178.53
573.63
395.10
5853
0.00
8,537.57
1,099.82
2,583.80
1,483.98
A
A
A
A
8,537.57
10185
Page 14 of 39
B
B
B
B
B
B
A
A
A
17,280.88
9612
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
A
A
B
B
B
A
B
Ruppert, et al. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.D. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
Class A
Class B
2059
52,885.26
91,275.21
38,389.95
A
8
6055
445.59
851.18
405.59
A
B
4865
9,545.89
17,053.66
7,507.77
A
2215
4,110.97
9,591.54
5,480.57
A
8
8
2228
17,222.71
30,185.90
12,963.19
9974
424.93
1,710.74
1,285.81
B
A
8
2478
4,381.78
15,617.18
11,235.40
A
B
1059
5,029.49
15,090.67
10,061.18
A
0.00
1,089.44
1,089.44
6170
1,989.54
4,830.95
2,841.41
A
8
8
8
1548
20,014.84
37,692.85
17,678.01
A
B
1270
24,104.71
40,299.10
16,194.39
A
7319
2,855.27
4,644.43
1,789.16
A
8
8
1084
26,804.42
45,735.46
18,931.04
A
B
1405
0.00
61,538.29
61,538.29
A
B
4169
16,394.08
30,445.87
14,051.79
A
B
7903
6,163.05
29,926.93
23,763.88
A
B
10987
10097
4,060.96
9,799.18
5,738.22
A
B
2039
14,274.01
23,971.07
9,697.06
A
2726
20,316.09
35,063.75
14,747.66
A
2163
19,881.37
32,970.76
13,089.39
A
B
B
B
B
B
1158
7,903.29
12,756.57
4,853.28
A
B
42,662.83
68,861.39
26,198.56
A
B
10326
0.00
3,492.29
3,492.29
2292
3,993.32
7,520.40
3,527.08
1512
Page 15 of 39
A
Ruppert, et at. v. Affiant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.O. Wis.)
PIN
9659
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
536.79
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
1,826.88
1,290.09
Class A
Class 8
A
A
A
A
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
9887
261.12
1,072.26
811.14
10988
1,527.41
3,573.66
2,046.25
335.99
0.00
1,175.78
839.79
1083
23,233.87
23,233.87
4316
3,242.61
6,194.17
2,951.56
A
4789
0.00
827.86
827.86
A
A
A
9888
7214
113.10
219.04
105.94
9122
700.44
1,195.14
494.70
9011
2,948.80
4,796.57
1,847.77
A
2072
2,406.36
4,397.60
1,991.24
5508
189.18
356.27
167.09
A
A
1783
2,244.58
4,347.15
2,102.57
A
7397
1,417.74
10,467.38
9,049.64
A
B
4939
6,610.08
37,029.95
30,419.87
A
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
1654
0.00
8,702.13
8,702.13
A
7400
2,720.18
4,547.69
1,827.51
A
2354
3,742.41
12,178.49
8,436.08
A
9330
215.65
860.65
645.00
A
9375
2,126.40
3,445.49
1,319.09
A
1222
0.00
14,056.77
14,056.77
A
1397
41,160.51
75,791.43
34,630.92
A
9109
327.72
547.89
220.17
A
2207
7,365.90
13,871.79
6,505.89
A
10405
58.53
220.13
161.60
A
Page 16 of 39
Ruppert, et a/. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.D. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJJ
10099
1,516.86
4,776.01
3,259.15
1549
7,980.41
13,470.10
5,489.69
1541
25,606.84
43,692.07
18,085.23
2260
0.00
7,157.35
7,157.35
9460
7,855.86
18,425.51
10,569.65
1877
2131
25,782.73
10,925.95
43,992.18
20,425.26
18,209.45
9,499.31
1641
14,609.19
26,099.21
11,490.02
9932
242.63
934.78
692.15
1966
42,460.06
73,282.25
30,822.19
5185
3,592.07
25,492.36
21,900.29
6450
0.00
580.29
580.29
10328
1,129.53
2,673.88
1,544.35
9142
375.40
1,620.70
1,245.30
2123
30,520.33
53,360.27
22,839.94
1784
17,362.87
28,572.30
11,209.43
7106
3,055.17
5,184.63
2,129.46
9660
5,485.10
12,733.76
7,248.66
1433
0.00
37,568.07
37,568.07
1738
23,050.28
39,116.39
16,066.11
2621
26,324.21
45,433.22
19,109.01
9148
4,147.96
10,045.82
5,897.86
7081
1,149.89
1,984.61
834.72
7220
2,358.03
4,069.75
1,711.72
9123
193.27
335.66
142.39
Page 17 of 39
Class A
Class B
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
Ruppert, et al. v. Affiant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.O. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJ\
Class A
Class B
9059
1,151.00
1,942.77
791.77
A
1268
1558
9,258.18
59,739.51
50,481.33
A
20,327.39
44,955.87
24,628.48
A
B
B
B
B
B
9616
1,348.72
3,268.85
1,920.13
A
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
4615
28,635.35
49,732.34
21,096.99
A
1264
34,451.08
62,484.62
28,033.54
A
11187
172.41
405.45
233.04
A
2063
4,844.83
15,841.09
10,996.26
A
2306
0.00
0.00
2700
0.00
19,682.95
0.00
19,682.95
A
2449
0.00
22,108.63
22,108.63
A
9472
0.00
4,949.90
4,949.90
2699
0.00
943.80
13,521.09
13,521.09
A
2,292.26
1,348.46
A
10991
9934
2,166.20
5,352.32
3,186.12
A
1399
55,680.55
95,541.49
39,860.94
A
1535
4,542.20
51,112.77
46,570.57
A
1718
0.00
23,644.92
23,644.92
1753
14,470.89
27,642.88
13,171.99
A
B
7408
4,999.29
8,131.93
3,132.64
A
1624
6,668.31
12,827.23
6,158.92
A
B
B
B
B
3506
0.00
9,509.38
9,509.38
A
B
7224
6,604.95
10,500.65
3,895.70
A
B
1319
10,670.95
35,301.16
24,630.21
A
2229
7,588.49
21,817.66
14,229.17
A
Page 18 of 39
Ruppert, et at. v. Affiant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (WO. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
10101
1809
7341
9851
7225
2887
7109
1154
11172
1762
6222
2513
1850
2446
2106
1162
1664
1417
5670
7322
1012
7229
11045
10011
114.15
15,214.64
4,466.73
126.00
3,647.45
320.95
0.00
33,752.71
610.04
17,938.39
3,142.74
4,924.61
4,722.97
17,038.37
0.00
0.00
1,718.92
7,110.17
8,466.22
202.06
27,672.89
3,951.73
236.63
51.73
222.55
28,147.54
7,126.52
588.75
6,125.35
613.09
756.98
57,915.81
1,409.48
40,157.14
10,292.21
20,470.84
8,631.18
56,296.04
0.00
34,920.55
4,863.82
12,993.76
15,124.84
342.90
47,760.92
6,304.85
553.53
462.17
7125
0.00
Underpayment
due to PJI
1,455.70
Page 19 of 39
108.40
12,932.90
2,659.79
462.75
2,477.90
292.14
756.98
24,163.10
799.44
22,218.75
7,149.47
15,546.23
3,908.21
39,257.67
0.00
34,920.55
3,144.90
5,883.59
6,658.62
140.84
20,088.03
2,353.12
316.90
410.44
1,455.70
Class A
Class 8
A
A
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
A
B
A
B
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
Ruppert, et al. v. A/liant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.O. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
9734
3,385.19
8,137.96
4,752.77
2438
29,097.64
53,579.31
24,481.67
2714
18,022.28
30,583.86
12,561.58
10298
832.96
2,629.66
1,796.70
2696
54,279.16
93,680.96
39,401.80
2559
0.00
25,537.94
25,537.94
1086
0.00
0.00
Class A
Class B
A
A
A
A
A
A
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
0.00
9800
1,267.80
4,038.31
2,770.51
10204
1,351.29
3,472.89
2,121.60
2392
27,341.24
45,520.96
18,179.72
6907
2,895.51
4,691.70
1,796.19
7778
11,611.57
29,204.71
17,593.14
7914
2,797.48
4,773.24
1,975.76
10125
238.16
953.59
715.43
2734
46,267.84
74,104.80
27,836.96
5693
192.21
361.98
169.77
1831
7,126.86
22,920.43
15,793.57
1925
51,928.30
86,456.44
34,528.14
1049
52,249.83
85,319.74
33,069.91
2042
0.00
15,347.77
15,347.77
1216
8,844.87
17,130.15
8,285.28
11014
1,490.25
3,690.35
2,200.10
9377
1,778.91
5,718.16
3,939.25
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
2320
1,488.17
14,717.95
13,229.78
2505
3,347.93
10,261.65
6,913.72
Page 20 of 39
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
Ruppert, et a/. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.O. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
Class A
Class B
8162
2,787.15
4,622.14
1,834.99
A
B
1217
14,909.59
25,732.61
10,823.02
A
B
2298
0.00
12,158.33
12,158.33
A
B
7238
1,416.10
2,390.23
974.13
A
B
1947
21,053.30
35,197.65
14,144.35
A
B
1982
0.00
9,097.77
9,097.77
A
B
6764
15,132.36
24,424.90
9,292.54
A
B
A
B
9802
7.34
16.83
9.49
9078
0.00
11,436.11
11,436.11
11208
0.00
300.91
300.91
4784
0.00
1,244.24
1,244.24
A
B
B
B
9617
2,537.91
3,802.94
1,265.03
A
B
7120
0.00
308.53
308.53
A
B
2496
5,670.39
15,895.23
10,224.84
A
B
2728
0.00
60,423.52
60,423.52
B
1767
16,741.47
28,894.27
12,152.80
A
A
2029
0.00
16,253.56
16,253.56
B
B
2389
1,319.41
2,466.54
1,147.13
A
B
1305
52,471.95
90,561.88
38,089.93
A
B
10002
145.63
497.14
351.51
A
B
1005
12,153.95
45,727.14
33,573.19
A
B
2560
715.30
17,926.53
17,211.23
2738
19,005.41
31,275.26
12,269.85
A
B
1816
0.00
79,145.78
79,145.78
A
B
2450
2,066.86
3,567.21
1,500.35
A
B
Page 21 of 39
B
Ruppert, et al. v. Affiant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.O. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
Class A
Class B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
3363
1,807.54
3,119.65
1,312.11
A
1824
20,824.49
47,805.16
26,980.67
6870
19,863.85
32,436.06
12,572.21
9150
3,681.19
9,627.49
5,946.30
A
A
A
A
A
A
1713
13,128.91
24,543.53
11,414.62
9318
561.48
2,058.13
1,496.65
9126
4,720.32
12,636.25
7,915.93
1347
0.00
15,552.61
15,552.61
7416
8,438.14
13,939.59
5,501.45
A
10076
185.76
853.91
668.15
A
A
5986
3,782.49
6,453.93
2,671.44
10441
0.00
189.02
189.02
2230
5,024.89
7,988.65
2,963.76
A
9803
124.82
564.74
439.92
A
9379
704.94
2,999.57
2,294.63
1690
11,157.79
28,723.24
17,565.45
A
A
1720
19,766.05
44,892.80
25,126.75
A
7419
3,512.16
16,644.84
13,132.68
A
1785
0.00
13,951.16
13,951.16
2717
12,723.72
21,960.00
9,236.28
1577
0.00
23,125.87
23,125.87
1526
21,079.04
33,630.90
12,551.86
10299
A
A
0.00
1,638.07
1,638.07
2401
6,816.23
11,130.35
4,314.12
A
2643
12,132.68
32,531.40
20,398.72
A
Page 22 of 39
Ruppert, et al. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.D. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
Class A
Class B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
9976
66.52
280.77
214.25
A
5793
0.00
0.00
0.00
A
9535
2,435.16
6,326.34
3,891.18
A
2267
0.00
519.58
519.58
A
1077
0.00
10,387.07
10,387.07
A
10077
11,418.60
6,726.78
A
10014
4,691.82
761.81
2,726.10
1,964.29
A
10015
121.61
419.73
298.12
A
2066
6276
26,423.62
42,157.99
15,734.37
A
64.53
58.74
A
94,326.67
A
3,892.69
A
1760
0.00
123.27
94,326.67
1967
5,362.49
9,255.18
7329
327.67
550.27
222.60
A
9163
660.31
1,431.29
A
2177
4,325.21
2,091.60
8,145.43
3,820.22
A
2751
0.00
290.71
290.71
A
5406
848.48
1,620.80
772.32
A
1413
65,532.25
113,102.78
47,570.53
A
1563
24,198.66
50,844.29
26,645.63
A
9855
519.03
1,647.74
1,128.71
A
2746
0.00
567.00
567.00
A
9303
585.21
948.24
363.03
A
9333
1391
1,239.61
4,082.36
2,842.75
A
15,557.59
31,847.67
16,290.08
A
9304
246.33
2,946.18
2,699.85
A
Page 23 of 39
Ruppert, et al. v. Affiant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (WO. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
Class A
Class B
285.64
659.93
374.29
A
B
3,277.57
8,132.01
4,854.44
A
B
9895
0.00
2,488.02
2,488.02
10333
1,866.75
4,643.73
2,776.98
A
B
15514
9621
B
9622
0.00
7,147.24
7,147.24
1897
1309
0.00
46,668.19
46,668.19
A
B
5,889.71
11,406.79
5,517.08
294.25
777.71
483.46
1032
24,960.15
43,078.98
18,118.83
1853
27,307.66
1,234.37
11,129.14
9893
16,178.52
427.49
7427
4,108.01
15,396.65
11,288.64
1133
25,498.20
49,025.88
23,527.68
1994
0.00
0.00
0.00
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
B
11132
806.88
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
7922
2,432.02
4,173.07
1,741.05
A
B
2634
31,305.50
54,030.48
22,724.98
A
B
2652
0.00
9,584.67
9,584.67
B
1106
0.00
0.00
0.00
B
2384
7,155.53
30,809.97
23,654.44
1996
0.00
0.00
0.00
1445
50,826.10
84,972.86
34,146.76
1829
0.00
67,459.67
67,459.67
A
B
B
A
A
B
B
9219
12,424.84
28,877.21
16,452.37
A
B
2517
1,107.74
2,116.05
1,008.31
A
B
2802
4,506.37
8,297.86
3,791.49
A
B
Page 24 of 39
Ruppert, et al. v. Affiant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.D. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
Class A
Class B
1715
1,793.61
3,700.40
1,906.79
A
B
11068
96.93
243.00
146.07
A
B
A
B
1625
0.00
16,687.01
16,687.01
2675
20,609.10
35,569.46
14,960.36
B
9490
974.36
1,578.79
604.43
A
B
2503
1,262.02
11,435.11
10,173.09
A
B
2409
0.00
13,370.07
13,370.07
A
B
5954
8,898.50
14,197.26
5,298.76
A
B
1707
596.14
24,941.42
24,345.28
9697
654.96
1,041.27
386.31
1657
0.00
22,725.92
22,725.92
11100
121.24
285.94
B
A
B
164.70
A
B
B
1799
0.00
18,490.95
18,490.95
A
B
1905
4,494.44
10,074.54
5,580.10
A
B
2053
31,325.78
54,065.48
22,739.70
A
B
7428
1,678.26
2,677.61
999.35
A
B
10244
958.22
2,296.72
1,338.50
A
B
7429
4,929.52
15,723.12
10,793.60
B
2094
0.00
0.00
0.00
2727
27,175.83
40,516.17
13,340.34
10105
132.58
541.70
409.12
10106
147.06
576.53
429.47
2240
5,804.36
10,607.41
4,803.05
A
A
A
A
A
A
2841
0.00
384.14
384.14
A
B
B
1,108.60
2,654.41
1,545.81
A
B
10223
Page 25 of 39
B
B
B
B
Ruppert, et a/. v. Affiant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.O. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJ\
Underpayment
due to PJI
Class A
Class B
6435
15,109.44
35,180.95
20,071.51
A
9220
10,284.47
23,673.40
13,388.93
A
B
B
7261
261.66
499.83
238.17
A
B
7262
2,947.95
4,832.42
1,884.47
A
B
2001
18,311.63
42,318.28
24,006.65
A
B
1805
10,046.99
18,782.11
8,735.12
A
B
2555
43,802.58
76,582.32
32,779.74
A
B
8148
899.29
1,468.47
569.18
A
B
9663
531.87
2,725.09
2,193.22
A
B
1993
38,777.42
68,259.05
29,481.63
A
B
5055
4,589.18
9,461.66
4,872.48
A
B
1458
24,470.07
42,233.14
17,763.07
A
B
9283
675.47
2,363.18
1,687.71
A
B
10207
56507
1,961.49
1,396.42
A
B
1974
14,262.93
22,675.42
8,412.49
A
B
1010
8,601.52
23,660.48
15,058.96
A
B
10208
498.08
1,232.80
734.72
A
B
2405
0.00
2,075.66
2,075.66
A
B
1374
7,039.53
12,962.33
5,922.80
A
B
1658
0.00
16,668.61
16,668.61
A
B
7431
0.00
8,843.89
8,843.89
11006
B
1,982.54
4,624.75
2,642.21
A
B
7432
477.19
911.55
434.36
A
B
1024
0.00
0.00
0.00
1972
0.00
12,996.01
12,996.01
Page 26 of 39
B
A
B
Ruppert, et al. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.O. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
9467
865.08
1704
10,556.03
20,022.87
9,466.84
1903
0.00
43,896.44
43,896.44
6792
0.00
1,934.81
6,161.15
2,058.45
4,312.28
9665
0.00
1,352.25
216.70
349.77
133.07
2398
5,560.62
20,957.22
15,396.60
9859
73.65
2070
7,339.74
349.55
18,720.73
275.90
11,380.99
A
A
A
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
1,352.25
9221
Class B
6,161.15
6,247.09
9278
2,923.53
Class A
2819
6,599.21
10,775.98
4,176.77
1115
22,717.08
36,809.35
14,092.27
7265
576.46
1,101.18
524.72
2173
40,670.98
70,194.46
29,523.48
2098
6,870.60
15,000.45
8,129.85
1452
22,472.18
38,784.97
16,312.79
10477
0.00
1,685.12
9,567.51
16,416.76
6,849.25
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
1,685.12
2488
A
7266
325.22
1,427.73
1,102.51
1408
43,560.86
79,607.00
36,046.14
8120
899.56
1,534.89
635.33
1573
2231
2,611.65
1,559.33
5,371.89
9,986.69
2,760.24
8,427.36
1524
0.00
20,591.83
20,591.83
10045
2,359.85
5,818.56
3,458.71
A
A
A
A
Page 27 of 39
A
B
Ruppert, et al. v. Affiant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.D. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
2160
42,299.88
73,005.80
30,705.92
2375
8,172.48
28,566.34
20,393.86
11147
9151
372.66
925.62
552.96
1,035.65
3,136.32
2,100.67
9099
2,422.28
8,150.22
5,727.94
2542
25,007.76
11,728.68
1792
13,279.08
7,506.67
26,577.37
19,070.70
9,355.10
2649
6,369.00
15,724.10
10418
1,201.57
3,231.23
2,029.66
6005
4,409.04
18,713.45
14,304.41
10188
2,579.35
5,849.81
3,270.46
9921
274.61
1,014.46
739.85
1729
0.00
16,421.69
16,421.69
2128
18,427.87
27,567.41
9,139.54
1527
0.00
52,658.18
52,658.18
9061
1,011.61
1,745.95
734.34
1892
23,341.60
41,087.71
17,746.11
9430
4,522.22
10,367.69
5,845.47
5878
1,069.60
1,815.11
745.51
7103
3,390.38
10,772.54
7,382.16
1895
130.23
2,191.27
2,580.01
4,427.00
1,846.99
6688
0.00
527.94
527.94
2146
24,177.29
62,222.98
38,045.69
2595
0.00
17,220.52
17,220.52
Class B
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
B
2,061.04
7272
Class A
Page 28 of 39
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
A
A
A
B
B
B
B
Ruppert, et a/. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.D. Wis.)
PIN
10962
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
1,152.76
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
2,733.16
1,580.40
Class A
Class B
A
B
9222
279.69
454.95
175.26
A
B
10166
844.89
2,635.77
1,790.88
A
A
10210
141.69
474.23
332.54
1906
8,615.73
20,298.33
11,682.60
1020
6,824.31
22,923.64
16,099.33
A
B
B
B
B
6500
0.00
1,195.09
1,195.09
A
B
A
B
7275
191.14
359.96
168.82
7130
3,542.06
11,518.66
7,976.60
A
B
B
B
9710
495.33
1,222.39
727.06
A
2087
2,668.17
4,460.74
1,792.57
9900
655.00
1,517.29
862.29
A
A
B
9069
293.48
492.86
199.38
A
B
2198
0.00
2,835.49
2,835.49
A
B
A
A
B
1934
10,820.40
25,475.20
14,654.80
9334
1,377.85
3,540.63
2,162.78
1789
10,871.54
20,767.26
9,895.72
A
B
2340
2,508.93
8,439.83
5,930.90
A
B
B
7338
343.02
585.28
242.26
A
1079
17,565.23
30,316.01
12,750.78
A
B
B
2563
9,058.19
15,633.62
6,575.43
A
B
1150
11,999.24
20,978.89
8,979.65
A
1117
23,817.30
37,999.70
14,182.40
A
B
B
9083
430.91
739.39
308.48
A
B
7442
576.06
1,029.13
453.07
A
B
Page 29 of 39
Ruppert, et a/. v. Affiant Energy Cash Balance Pens;on Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.O. Wis.)
PIN
1327
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
45,189.97
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
Class A
Class B
32,803.86
A
1352
29,626.25
51,132.25
21,506.00
9711
0.00
7,159.60
7,159.60
2055
27,750.19
49,202.00
21,451.81
1621
4,223.44
12,619.43
8,395.99
11188
217.44
546.88
329.44
A
A
A
1626
34,580.63
59,003.73
24,423.10
A
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
77,993.83
7278
438.39
783.18
344.79
A
7279
4,177.58
6,821.65
2,644.07
A
9860
590.15
1,577.52
987.37
A
9569
5,120.28
14,142.13
9,021.85
A
9594
1,913.26
3,088.16
1,174.90
A
9045
715.04
1,172.13
457.09
A
2683
9,318.84
17,159.36
7,840.52
A
9514
605.18
2,205.54
1,600.36
A
5912
8,750.64
15,991.70
7,241.06
A
1793
0.00
7,257.14
7,257.14
A
1207
3,157.31
5,449.23
2,291.92
A
B
2440
420.80
687.13
266.33
A
B
1963
23,014.44
38,649.32
15,634.88
A
8
2451
1,677.36
5,012.08
3,334.72
A
B
A
A
A
A
8
8
7282
248.61
468.19
219.58
7079
212.42
341.54
129.12
9515
230.33
1,415.78
1,185.45
1292
9,237.65
61,865.61
52,627.96
Page 30 of 39
B
B
Ruppert, et al. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.D. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
Class A
Class B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
11123
538.77
1,238.05
699.28
A
2709
35,176.84
60,021.03
24,844.19
2677
30,678.71
52,346.02
21,667.31
1692
15,668.69
27,042.75
11,374.06
A
A
A
2433
2,319.86
7,820.80
5,500.94
1579
59,706.54
112,442.04
52,735.50
2282
22,707.81
39,191.64
16,483.83
2093
3,437.63
5,465.20
2,027.57
1997
0.00
16,779.83
16,779.83
2358
12,671.58
20,611.80
7,940.22
2166
17,407.93
31,099.14
13,691.21
9062
859.98
1,444.21
584.23
A
A
A
A
1642
55,831.15
93,760.09
37,928.94
9336
335.86
542.11
206.25
1478
1,810.24
3,592.74
1,782.50
10131
0.00
1,259.22
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
8
8
1,259.22
1323
11,896.95
20,189.16
8,292.21
7933
7,749.85
12,852.15
5,102.30
1232
7,722.96
18,813.71
11,090.75
11151
182.86
466.02
283.16
1509
935.18
5,478.12
4,542.94
7093
1,577.19
2,585.40
1,008.21
1022
34,389.27
54,866.92
20,477.65
10965
749.44
2,010.69
1,261.25
A
A
A
2684
6,695.85
23,052.77
16,356.92
A
Page 31 of 39
8
B
B
B
B
B
B
A
A
B
B
B
8
8
B
Ruppert, et a/. v. Alfiant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.D. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
1797
2,343.10
7,727.19
5,384.09
9046
524.12
880.18
356.06
1471
31,714.96
60,583.21
28,868.25
9517
591.59
2,564.13
1,972.54
2447
2,059.73
6,725.43
4,665.70
9167
7122
1,476.79
2,356.17
879.38
4,424.86
10,772.56
6,347.70
10369
103.81
334.59
230.78
2030
54,625.91
94,279.42
39,653.51
1470
0.00
5,119.04
4,766.24
9,709.89
4,766.24
4,590.85
7452
3,530.92
6,094.05
2,563.13
8086
2,168.71
3,514.04
1,345.33
4327
6,570.28
11,339.71
4,769.43
7453
121.63
220.60
98.97
1183
2102
8,189.54
14,223.16
6,033.62
2410
0.00
7,504.29
7,504.29
1030
14,080.17
34,216.20
20,136.03
1021
21,800.18
35,323.66
1147
11,053.15
26,067.88
13,523.48
15,014.73
2290
0.00
15,914.10
Class A
Class 8
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
15,914.10
7298
341.65
582.95
241.30
2057
28,571.98
54,961.37
26,389.39
2645
95.43
24,062.91
23,967.48
0.00
10,766.51
10,766.51
A
A
1476
Page 32 of 39
A
Ruppert, et al. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.D. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
Class A
Class B
9807
5,173.11
12,659.64
7,486.53
A
B
1273
0.00
7,028.28
7,028.28
A
B
11027
70.18
148.26
78.08
A
B
7299
6,162.21
9,796.77
3,634.56
A
B
2666
8,830.37
15,438.59
6,608.22
A
B
7300
0.00
675.75
675.75
A
B
2659
5,168.20
8,770.45
3,602.25
A
2284
7,886.45
22,075.45
14,189.00
A
B
B
2246
13,200.45
24,677.27
11,476.82
A
B
1210
7,264.28
3,137.50
24,496.53
10,303.13
2268
16,495.33
28,469.46
11,974.13
A
A
A
B
2512
4,126.78
14,193.40
A
B
B
B
7126
2,441.91
8,648.40
6,206.49
6612
0.00
14,117.08
14,117.08
7937
4,823.58
16,966.39
12,142.81
A
B
4417
3,356.37
8,276.62
4,920.25
A
B
98.34
325.04
226.70
A
B
1,592.88
2,561.12
968.24
A
B
10287
9071
B
8152
852.96
1,387.44
534.48
A
B
1631
47,323.52
79,117.12
31,793.60
A
B
9761
1,171.93
4,284.59
3,112.66
A
B
6877
2037
3,890.03
6,713.84
2,823.81
A
61,111.49
105,472.95
44,361.46
A
1547
10,970.25
18,933.67
7,963.42
A
4980
3,071.17
11,822.34
8,751.17
A
B
B
B
B
Page 33 of 39
Ruppert, et a/. v. Attiant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.O. Wis.)
PIN
1965
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
12,454.96
23,283.63
10422
52.90
180.71
127.81
2590
3,234.72
16,127.74
12,893.02
1749
11,482.20
47,074.56
35,592.36
1731
0.00
9,536.20
14,737.95
20,472.13
5,734.18
0.00
288.07
288.07
7457
2,986.99
5,068.93
2,081.94
Class 8
A
A
A
A
B
8
8
B
B
B
B
B
9,536.20
1009
6113
Class A
10,828.67
5690
0.00
353.60
353.60
5233
34,575.67
56,241.35
21,665.68
1732
7,461.57
39,830.59
32,369.02
7118
592.82
1,059.07
466.25
1495
0.00
16,917.41
16,917.41
2108
2,548.83
7,678.78
5,129.95
2546
10,112.94
16,907.17
6,794.23
10992
1,264.88
3,090.61
1,825.73
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
2431
0.00
0.00
0.00
9538
92.33
883.42
791.09
A
A
1326
62,874.48
102,668.93
39,794.45
1011
16,341.22
28,203.48
11,862.26
7092
2,853.40
4,713.74
1,860.34
2484
8,427.59
14,545.26
6,117.67
9597
624.26
2,133.61
1,509.35
6153
0.00
342.44
342.44
1052
0.00
8,998.33
8,998.33
Page 34 of 39
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
Ruppert, et al. v. Affiant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.O. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
2184
40,122.04
68,458.85
28,336.81
1902
110.43
12,500.48
9306
321.10
516.28
195.18
0.00
613.37
Class B
A
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
12,390.05
11154
Class A
613.37
A
1067
0.00
5,635.21
5,635.21
A
1067
16,291.02
6,819.03
A
6,207.41
A
976.06
A
6134
8,425.43
23,110.05
14,632.84
9566
575.74
1,551.80
2304
4,591.76
10,281.31
5,689.55
A
2364
6,638.68
21,968.64
15,329.96
A
2403
8,983.14
30,483.57
21,500.43
A
1013
27,925.79
48,197.41
20,271.62
A
2791
0.00
1,417.21
1,417.21
A
1885
4,366.16
12,908.03
8,541.87
A
1976
0.00
462.84
462.84
A
1288
24,578.21
41,275.44
16,697.23
A
2065
24,126.91
44,426.39
20,299.48
A
2732
14,379.97
21,768.90
A
2778
211.08
A
4989
238.98
10,995.04
36,148.87
450.06
18,976.45
7,981.41
A
7226
8,747.25
15,096.97
6,349.72
A
5529
1,805.20
12,623.37
10,818.17
A
5711
0.00
12,992.23
12,992.23
A
3236
41,324.50
79,492.25
38,167.75
A
9632
7,949.31
12,830.85
4,881.54
A
Page 35 of 39
Ruppert, et al. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.O. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
6290
15,146.49
31,741.30
16,594.81
8534
98,481.70
188,123.75
89,642.05
8261
0.00
2,425.48
2,425.48
2335
1,140.43
3,027.71
1,887.28
9468
0.00
44,754.54
44,754.54
7508
23,679.92
45,234.35
21,554.43
404
9,528.13
18,453.44
8,925.31
4295
0.00
8,003.25
8,003.25
2127
1,920.19
3,294.83
1,374.64
7558
673.10
1,267.61
594.51
948
1,642.00
121,742.04
120,100.04
5856
0.00
34,015.38
34,015.38
4892
13,444.32
24,569.35
11,125.03
96
41,328.67
77,260.90
35,932.23
3385
0.00
0.00
745.25
1,278.76
533.51
7267
21,964.62
42,539.60
20,574.98
Class B
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
0.00
4660
Class A
8270
52.38
331.60
279.22
8105
65,997.89
113,906.43
47,908.54
5370
5,146.44
9,761.86
4,615.42
9442
6,878.30
11,102.15
4,223.85
6094
0.00
67,365.88
67,365.88
838.21
3,759.24
2,921.03
5638
0.00
30,099.31
30,099.31
5577
279.65
447.90
168.25
61
Page 36 of 39
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
Ruppert, et a/. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.D. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
Class A
Class B
B
B
8690
18,456.44
35,008.51
16,552.07
A
6911
0.00
3,758.00
3,758.00
A
7934
3,398.47
5,831.39
2,432.92
A
896
10,219.65
18,535.59
8,315.94
A
3414
24,436.24
47,326.46
22,890.22
A
9249
0.00
62,878.70
62,878.70
A
4205
11,727.96
32,840.28
21,112.32
A
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
6081
453.61
726.52
272.91
A
B
B
B
B
B
8144
1,358.54
2,391.41
1,032.87
A
706
3,856.81
6,297.86
2,441.05
A
3220
1,029.53
10,602.09
9,572.56
A
9082
0.00
39,581.20
39,581.20
A
3991
3,724.28
6,511.35
2,787.07
A
1149
9,449.62
18,051.05
8,601.43
A
4885
738.33
58,355.69
57,617.36
A
6540
0.00
2,042.90
2,042.90
A
1683
11,424.29
39,906.72
28,482.43
A
5716
0.00
23,123.77
23,123.77
A
2416
8,686.84
16,710.10
8,023.26
A
9210
462.77
877.79
415.02
A
6785
0.00
13,812.96
13,812.96
A
4168
34,218.11
65,364.82
31,146.71
A
563
0.00
61,133.36
61,133.36
A
3868
15,856.43
29,861.54
14,005.11
A
9237
0.00
447.83
447.83
A
Page 37 of 39
B
B
B
B
B
Ruppert, et al. v. Alliant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (W.O. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
9977
0.00
10,433.38
10,433.38
8334
6,771.23
24,203.52
17,432.29
7140
27,371.94
50,021.92
22,649.98
1652
25,878.98
44,156.41
18,277.43
3727
625.19
2,784.27
2,159.08
28,231.84
54,677.53
26,445.69
0.00
10,333.24
10,333.24
361
6319
4420
0.00
5,557.29
5,557.29
5950
5,423.27
12,791.52
7,368.25
580
451.42
17,469.83
17,018.41
8519
1,084.76
3,638.49
2,553.73
5318
6,026.93
11,593.47
5,566.54
203
0.00
80,637.43
80,637.43
6880
0.00
58,845.02
58,845.02
8400
4,135.92
7,280.37
3,144.45
462
1,107.72
29,447.08
28,339.36
5689
459.76
827.59
367.83
2193
3,495.24
15,551.74
12,056.50
6539
41,471.74
73,001.80
31,530.06
5262
0.00
44,229.58
44,229.58
9999
35,455.93
65,287.22
29,831.29
9937
17,390.48
30,202.86
12,812.38
8888
10,914.22
28,758.18
17,843.96
7420
10,116.61
25,433.80
15,317.19
3678
0.00
19,306.91
19,306.91
Page 38 of 39
Class A
Class B
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
B
Ruppert. et al. v. Alfiant Energy Cash Balance Pension Plan,
3:08-cv-00127-bbc (WO. Wis.)
PIN
Remaining
Underpayment
with PJI
Remaining
underpayment
without PJI
Underpayment
due to PJI
6946
0.00
9,579.62
9,579.62
6551
0.00
12,064.72
12,064.72
318
7,909.19
15,002.30
7,093.11
7544
10,379.66
17,810.32
7,430.66
9578
4,746.63
9,003.49
4,256.86
4221
7,874.73
22,879.46
9809
16,745.37
26,820.19
15,004.73
10,074.82
Totals
7,890,569.75
18,677,671.33
10,787,101.58
Page 39 of 39
Class A
Class 8
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
8
8
8
8
8
8
862
956
B
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
