Smith et al v. Wilson et al
Filing
208
ORDER on Objections to Deposition Testimony of Dr. Kenneth Robbins. Signed by District Judge William M. Conley on 4/21/2011. (arw)
<![CDATA[
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF WISCONSIN
_____________________________________________________________________________
ANTHONY SMITH and
FLYING A.J.’S TOWING COMPANY,
(a Wisconsin limited liability company)
ORDER
Case No.: 10-CV-62
Plaintiffs,
v.
JOHN WILSON (in his official capacity as
Police Chief and in his individual capacity),
and
TOWN OF BELOIT, WISCONSIN
(a municipal corporation)
Defendants.
_____________________________________________________________________________
COURT’S RULINGS ON OBJECTIONS TO DEPOSITION
TESTIMONY OF DR. KENNETH ROBBINS
______________________________________________________________________________
Dr. Robbins will be testifying by means of videotaped deposition. The parties submitted
designations and counter-designations, a number of which contain objections. Accordingly, the
court rules as follows:
Defendants’
Designations
Page 3 & 4 (Introduction)
Page 4 lines 13 - 25
Page 5 lines 1 – 25
Page 6 lines 1 – 25
Page 7 lines 1 – 25
Page 8 lines 1 – 25
Plaintiffs’
Designations
Objections
1
Court’s Ruling
Page 9 lines 1 – 25
Page 10 lines 1 – 25
Page 11 lines 7 – 25
Page 12 lines 1 – 25
Page 13 lines 1 – 25
Page 14 lines 1 – 25
Page 15 lines 1 – 25
Page 16 lines 1 – 25
Page 17 lines 1 – 25
Page 18 lines 1 – 25
Page 19 lines 1 – 25
Page 20 lines 1 – 25
Page 21 lines 1 – 25
Page 22 lines 1 – 25
Page 23 lines 1- 14,
19 – 25
Page 24 lines 1 – 25
Page 25 lines 1 – 7
Page 26 lines 17 – 25
Page 11 lines 1 - 4
Page 12 lines 1-21
Objection Waived
Sustained as to Page
12 lines 22-25,
otherwise overruled.
Page 14 lines 1-6
Page 15 lines 1-25
Page 16 lines 1-25
Page 17 lines 4-25
Page 18 lines 2-25
Overruled
Overruled
Overruled
Overruled
Overruled
Page 20 lines 1-6, 2325
Page 21 lines 1-13
Page 22 lines 8-25
Page 23 lines 15 – 17
Overruled
Page 23 lines 1-7 and
21-25
Page 24 line 1-22
Page 25 lines 8 – 25
Page 26 lines 1 – 16
Page 27 lines 1 – 25
(except the following
sentence which appears on
lines 20-21: “He’s had
other lawsuits about this
issue”).
Page 28 lines 1 – 25
Page 27 lines 1-19,
22-25
Page 28 line 1-25
Page 29 lines 1 – 25
Page 30 lines 1 – 25
Page 31 lines 1 – 25
Page 29 lines 3-9
Page 30 lines 1-25
Page 31 lines 1-25
2
Overruled
Overruled
Sustained; exclude
Page 23 lines 8-20
Form objections were
waived
Overruled
Overruled
Overruled; but
excluding Page 26
lines 17-25 and Page
27 line 1 as
cumulative.
Sustained as to Page
27 lines 7-25 and
otherwise overruled.
Sustained as to Page
28 lines 1-3 and
otherwise overruled.
Overruled
Overruled
Sustained as to Page
31 lines 14-25 and
otherwise overruled.
Page 32 lines 1 – 25
Page 32 lines 1-25
Page 33 lines 1 – 25
Page 33 lines 1-25
Page 34 lines 1 – 25
Page 34 lines 1-25
Sustained as to Page
32 lines 1-25.
Sustained as to Page
33 lines 1-25.
Sustained as to Page
34 lines 1-25.
Page 35 lines 1 – 6
Page 35 lines 7-25
Page 36 line 1
Page 36 lines 5-17
Page 36 lines 2 – 4
Page 36 lines 20 – 25;
Page 37 lines 11 – 17
Overruled
Page 36 lines 11-17
excluded.
Page 37 lines 18-23
excluded.
Page 43 lines 18-19
Overruled
Page 46 lines 4 – 8
Overruled
Page 48 lines 15 – 17
n/a (neither party has
designated the
testimony subject to
the objection)
Page 52 lines 19 – 25;
Page 53 line 1
Page 53 lines 19, 20
Page 54 lines 4 – 5
Sustained; Page 52
lines 14-18 excluded.
Overruled
Overruled
Page 56 lines 21-25
Page 57 lines 1-22
Page 59 lines 9-15,
19-25
Overruled
Overruled
Page 59 lines 9-15,
19-25 excluded as
cumulative.
Page 60 lines 1-16 is
excluded as
cumulative.
Page 37 lines 18-23
Page 39 lines 4-9
Page 41 lines 2-7
Page 43 lines 11-25
Page 44 lines 1-25
Page 45 lines 1-25
Page 46 lines 1-3
Page 46 lines 24-25
Page 47 lines 1-3
Page 48 lines 21-25
Page 50 lines 14-25
Page 51 lines 1-25
Page 52 lines 1-18
Page 53 lines 14-25
Page 54 lines 1-25
Page 55 lines 1-25
Page 56 lines 1-3
Page 56 lines 21 – 25
Page 57 lines 1 – 22
Page 59 lines 9 – 15,
19 – 25
Page 60 lines 1 – 25
Page 61 lines 1 – 16
3
Page 66 lines 20 – 24
n/a
n/a
Page 74 lines 6 – 16
n/a
Page 77 lines 17 - 21
Page 64 lines 1925; Page 65 lines 125; Page 66 lines 112
n/a
n/a
Sustained; Page 62
lines 10-14 excluded.
Sustained; Page 64
lines 19-25, Page 65
lines 1-25, and Page
66 lines 1-12
excluded.
n/a
Page 70 lines 15 – 16
Page 71 lines 20 - 21
Page 62 lines 10-14
Page 61 lines 23 – 25
Page 62 lines 6 – 8
Page 62 lines 15 – 17
n/a
Page 65 lines 16 – 18
Page 67 lines 1-19
Page 69 lines 22-25
Page 70 lines 1-8
Page 74 lines 18-25
Page 75 lines 1-23
Page 76 lines 1-8
Page 76 lines 9 – 25
Page 77 lines 1 – 3
Page 77 lines 4-5
Entered this 21st day of April, 2011.
BY THE COURT:
/s/
________________________________________
WILLIAM M. CONLEY
District Judge
4
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
