Apple, Inc. v. Motorola, Inc. et al

Filing 107

Declaration of Winslow B. Taub filed by Plaintiffs Apple, Inc., Next Softward, Inc. re: 90 Motion Requesting Claims Construction by Plaintiffs. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. A, '486 Inf. Chart, # 2 Ex. B, '354 file history excerpt, # 3 Ex. C, '354 file history excerpt, # 4 Ex. D, Spielman report excerpts, # 5 Ex. E, '983 file history excerpts, # 6 Ex. F, '983 file history excerpts, # 7 Ex. G, '337 Inf. Chart, # 8 Ex. H, '002 Inf. Chart, # 9 Ex. I, '002 file history excerpt, # 10 Ex. J, '002 file history excerpt, # 11 Ex. K, '002 file history excerpt, # 12 Ex. L, dictionary definitions, # 13 Ex. N, JPS63-167588 cert. trans., # 14 Ex. O, appl. 08/050952 file history excerpt, # 15 Ex. P, invalidity conten. excerpt, # 16 Ex. Q, 6,371,977, # 17 Ex. R, 5,474,831) (Haslam, Robert) Modified on 7/18/2011 (llj).

Download PDF
EXHIBIT B Docket OTLC Docket No. Serial 09/287172 2672 Examiner Filed 1999 April For MENU STATE 3048.7037 P-0 10.60 Art Unit Group No. M. Luu SYSTEM AMENDV1ENT Honorable Commissioner of and Trademarks Patents D.C. Washington 20231 Sir In IN Examiners to the response Office action of 24 2001 April amend please the as follows. application THE CLAIMS awclms Please NEW method among propagating method operating change objects to comprising on source for receiving information with status The associated using method 26 130_I 26130 The with further receiver associated the connection event notification in the changes representing connection object method object information for system for the objects information representing the of notification receiving connection using in the change representing the receiver to object interest an method connection whether operating notification comprising of notifying method type the step of event the on c1aim method information the the using registered operating the of registered the to represent NEW events of of operating information b.1 information event computer-implemented objects steps notification corresponds u. NEW follows object object source responsive to the object and notifying method the behalf an creating in the as object registering change of in and an interest source 85 to for operating plurality creating receiver 57 behalf of wherein the further associated only receiver the connection the object the object step object if event object. connection activated wherein to the connection is the object comprtsing in the step claim corresponding by invoking connection is associated of to configure the status or inactivated. connection object information method is the operating of .DOC vi 354FH199 WI-App1e0004464 eriaINo 09/287172 ci secifled SQ the invoking NEW The each of from connection connection thti by different DocicetNo of claim plurality type the connection object The operating method the notification to corresponding in the connection method operating notification method object information 3048-7037 type object wherein to corresponds niethod uniqueconnection of another to corresponding method object the notification type plurality 5l NEW c.l .1 of claim$fbrther connection invoking informationin the connection object NEW The operating object method in the The c.1 NEW of connection connection with comprising of step the the the connection receiver object of step for using responsible the connection with associated graphic operating method connection in the of the receiver the step of operating method .85 data further method to read data comprising for using responsible or thodify claim object object further method to create connection invoking claimS object object The c.1 .1 method operating invoking in the information modi to object further method the for using object 33 NEW information connection claim object comprising responsible aname asociated modify of connection 1.1 invoking information to metljod with associated the step of the for using responsible the connectioh with associated comprising the the receiver object connection receiver object the of 46n NEW tP\ The 1.2 information of connection invoking in the connection object The operating method ft claim comprising step for using responsible an undo execute to further method object function the connection with associated the receiver objegt pq NEW c.1.2 information connection in the of connection invoking claim$ to object further method object execute comprising redo the step for using responsible function the of connection with associated the receiver object %1 NEW method among propagating method operating for operating comprising change objects to in and interest source the an creating in the for receiving receiver associated connection event connection object method object infonnation for system for the objects information representing the of notification receiving connection using change representing the receiver notification information corresponds information to to the using 26130 an in the of steps of notification changes representing in thesource object object to the responsive object source notifying method events object registering change the event computer-implemented objects behalf on creating receiver of plurality enable an interest connection the notifying vl __ object registered of the using registered information event the on by invoking connection behalf of the in the connection the object receiver object associated only if object object the event and to configure sttus step __ __ 354FH200 WI-App1e0004465 SerialNo 091287172 NEW method propagating among method operating for operating change objects to in and interest the an creating for receiving information to disable source in the the an source for receiving information invoking the each of object object to the responsive the by of behalf in the the invoking connection associated only object the receiver connection object if the event and object to configure object status event computer-implemented events notification in the changes representing system for the objects of steps of receiver object associated connection method object information for the representing notification receiving of information connection using in the source change representing object object responsive to the receiver an to of object registered interest information the using by on behalf with the invoking the connection associated registered being event of associated the if only object receiver notification object the event object type to corresponding method object by specified the corresponds connection source step connection event notification connection said of object notifying method the representing object creating change for the notification receiving connection in the event on information in and an registering f- behalf on the using ofobjects the comprising of registered for operating objectsinterest to system objects information for using change object interest plurality creating change information registered notifying method method rectiver method object representing connection the among an to the using operating connection object associated the receiver corresponds NEW receiver connection event notification information propagating in the object source notifying method of an notification changes represehting object source in the events 3048-7037 of steps behalf on registering change the comprising event computer-implemented ofobjects plurality creating receiver No Docket the connection connection notification method object information in the notification type object to the same single between two objects corresponding typplurality to the corresponding connection connection object method and notification transferring VQ NEW The c.1.i informjtion connection object The operating method c.1.1 invoking in the NEW c.1.I information method connection in the NEW information operating invoking The connection object operating method invoking in the connection connection connection object type information of claimbQfurther object to method modify of claim.Q object to name modify with comprising icon object to read method data responsible associated the associated of claim.ftirther comprising with of the connection step object of the connection with the step for using the step the receiver for using responsible graphic the for using associated further method comprising responsible the receiver object of the connection receiver object 26130vl 354F 201 WI-App1e0004466 SerialNo. /5. NEW.. The c.1.1 information method operating of connection ciaim method to create object or NEW 2t The includes object method operating textual descriptive NEW The c.1.2 wherein of claim connection connection object The operating method further method object in the information of with associated the data the connection the receiver with associated the object. receiver data. method operating invoking data modify 3048-7037 of step for using responsible iJ claim V. the comprising ifirther object connection invoking in the No Docket 09/287172 execute to undo an the comprising function of step for using responsible the connection with associated the receiver object. NEW c.1.2 information connection in the of claim$turther connection invoking method object to execute object the comprising for responsible function redo of step using the associated connection with the receiver object. NEW method propagating method operating b among for operating comprising on creating receiver to change source the an creating in the C2. 71 NEW status the The b.t step receiver information with change on registered method operating of object information for for the the representing notification receiving notifier in the source of object object connection wherein further notifyinjtep information the by invoking notifier object the receiver claim method event the of behalf of th with registered the by method operating notification comprising invoking the the connection The to the type the only resiionsive to the associated if the object event information object. the notifier comprising the is object associated with of step in the notifier object active of to configure the status or passive. corresponding step method the connection infonnation methdd notifier object to is the operating of method the to corresponding notification type in the notifier object. information of claim1iherein notifier object single J$ wherein claim notifier object operating same method the notification operating type method plurality further all comprising of transferring aAt NEW 26130 method object representing the further correspond connection abject associated make with PNBW system objects and operating the The cl specified in the 5/ NEW method receiver using to associated the interest information information p. an to of notification for receiving corresponds notification changes representing of steps connection event object source notifying method events object registering change the behalf event computer-implcmented objects in and an interest objects of plurality The notificatioƆ operating type method information between of claim further two objects. comprising the step of vi 354FH202 WI-App1e0004467 SerialNo.09/287172 61.1 information notifier object The 1.1 information operating to create method notifier object or method to read data for using responsible data modifS the associated with comprising of claimXfurther notifier object invoking in the method notifier object invoking in the KNEW No Docket the for using responsible with associated the connection the receiver step the receiver 3048-7037 object of connection object ct3 ST1 NEW The operating method of The operating method of claimjf The operating method of claim$wherein the event has the creating step is the creating step is an assQciated type attribute NEW IC notifier NEW .0 source wherein initiated by the initiated by the object 7wherein claim object REMARKS STATUS OF THE CLAIMS Claims 27 to 56 remain in the new and case 57 claims to II Claims 27 to which was not skilled in the relevant added are to the case THE EXAMINERS REJECTION OF THE CLAIMS matter 85 56 are rejected described art that of the claimed The the full The the Applicant of disclosure Al claims specifically Rejection Examiner are at the time as firstparagraph such way the application as to containing reasonably was filed subject convey had one to posession invention THE APPLICANTS IlL in specification inventors thp 112 under 35 u.s.c in the not RESPONSE respectfully the of claims 48 has shown rejected in the that requests inventionin the to the Examiner specification of the withdraw application this rejection in view of as filed 56 claims 48 specification to 56 on or the the basis figures that the Regarding following claim 48 limitations the in Examiner asks What is consumer What is supplier object What is channel object object 354FH203 WI-App1e0004468 SerialNo 09/287172 Where channel 48 of the of event information to Applicant event computer-implemented events the interest event with registered reads by the on registered follows as notification in changes representing for propagating system the objects method the operating of consumer object in and an associated connection information method object the representing for of notification receiving object supplier connection the of object an to corresponds Claim 48 here which repeats interest registering consumer notification 3048-7037 object objects steps objects the notifying for receiving on behalf of creating consumer the if for operating plurality comprising change the response method among only show it method object consumer the does drawings associated object behalf In in the the invoking No Docket creating an the supplier event notifying the consumer receiving notification with channel object supplier object responsive to the the associated object object and for information to corresponds The an event with the on registered will point Applicant of the object registered interest in the change representing behalf where out by invoking channel these of only object the consumer elements method event Information the If in change object may be found in the Applicants specifiiation The ii 24 framework notification 28 page line 15 to is page The consumer object The supplier object The channel object is disclosed 31 the receiver Ito page line Page at and line object line 26 page 23 lines 18 in Figure disclosed at 28 page lines 28-29 and 31 objects and connection object page 31 notifier object which objects and in turn have source object are is disclosed of at the at more interest with is disclose in events object each of Figure line 24-25 page 28 line 27 The notifier 28 both relate to the tchannel at on page information disclosed that the has generated information to 28 page which is contained within 29 object.. connection at disclosed connection line 18 They interest in association to 28 specialized particular object specification refers page disclosed object notifier consumer that the general source in the also in Figure signifying have objects This disclosed notifying line is objects Claim 48 objects The to 48 in Claith connection is about the in the specification connection object responsibility by the which receiver source of objects for one object the events for which at is page 30 or more The is receiver connection generated it line with registered by responsible 18 26130v1 354FH204 WI-App1e0004469 SirialNo. The on the of receiver from particular the The These different connection of classes The Examiner claims are not 27 claim has What is What is second What is the an for connection of behalf In response to change the Applicant comprising second information receiving the of and drawings are delivered to 18. Figure that the the event show it in limitatiotis following it interest second to show an first associated object the notification to corresponds of behalf in and notiiing for receiving information on creating objects first change does method object repeats on Claim 27 here which the steps behalf events reads event computer-implemented in and an first interest an of object the with registered registered representing follows as notification system in the changes for the objects of of object connection information object method receiving information with first associated for representing notification the of object the an connection event in the change representing connection second object object responsive to the objection and the notifying for the basis does of.obj cots plurality creating method to in specific object for operating second in the interest asks notification onlkif the rcgistering change notifications more figures. representing associated first interest objects 47 on or the and drawings receiving object creating first an or notifier objects object specification the among method operating the object object information by invoking method to specifically specification in the on 27. one to from object with events the notifier classes associated in the method propagating how of association classes of object first object connection event 27 claims connection Where in Notifier notification corresponding connection in and 47 specification Examiner the is object to the based standard interest. objects. from notification is change interest express an for receiving object specialization to rejected in the What Where identified to to receiver invention for propagating have they instantiated the that the objects which objects connection disclosed is 27 claims receiver in notification dispatches allow This discloses mechanism 3048-7037 Claim 27 Regarding Regarding each have objects shown allows objects notifier objects object that receivers. Rejection of the The line provides their connection objects objects source 31 page that framework to connection receiver to that provide object. of connection list specific events. source objects. The changes to register objects line framework for classes provided is enable receiver about 30 page objects. notification register at notification between information interface Docketflo. specification concept receive 72 0912871 first notification corresponds to an object of registered interest the event by invoking with registered the connection the associated object on behaif of the first only object lithe event object. 26130v1 354FH205 WI-App1e0004470 SerialNo 09/287472 The No Docket will point Applicant where out these may be found elements in the 3048-7037 Applicants specification object first an thc at 30 page associated block function 32 line to 31 24 the is object contained line in and an second 28 31 notifier object objects in source have object This are to to 18 the 26 line The specification interface is receiver from particular list receiver the specific events source The receiver These different of Regarding Regarding drawings does objects connection classes it at that objects receivers allow This is the by of the 28 26 the 23 lines 11 information is page is at more or The object events 30 page with registered one for the 29 representing specification source of line notification object which receiver connection by generated allows which an from object of how in association Figure based on in and interest standard classes of events notifier classes to one or more the notifier objects an notifications with is Notifier the line in Figure change notification corresponding connection Page interest objects from method and invention to express have notification to the at line for propagating objects responsible object disclosed 31 for receiving object the is event information the If that the they instantiated specialization is page to receiver objects connection disclosed to discloses receiver in associated only object line 15 notification identified the object mechanism objects disatches for which.it objects first that provides each have 24-25 page 29 The responsibility receiver notifier objects object line by invoking their connection objects line cohnectlon behalf to source The connection the event the that provide object of connection the framework to register objects objects The changes for classes provided enable register about has -24 and page 28 ito page 31 lineS framework objects notification receiver disclosed 18 on line at receiving the connection about Figure with 11 28 generated of line 18 The connection page object to each of object 30 at information with lines page notification between information receive at action Information for Ito page line in Figure that in events registered 23 Page at connection registered page the notification 28 page disclosed method object disclose interest interest an page concept of 18 interest first notification corresponds of 31 28-29 and lines appropriate at connection object disclosed specialized the notifying for receiving the object first Figure that the more connection 31 lineS and in association at takes disclosed associated object ofparticular disclosed is method appropriate receiver object disclosed is general have turn the of page and line signifying which objects to connection within ito page object line 15 source is on behalf and page the 28 page at line interest to change is notification creating objects disclosed object method the object connection first receiver object 1880 page second the is interest are to in specific delivered to 18 Claim 30 claim show 30 the each of Examiner specifically notification type asks Where in the plurality corresponds specification to unique and connection 26130vl 354FH206 WI-App1e0004471 SerialNo. 09/287172 method object notification the from connection Applicant method operating each of different the method object corresponding No. 3048-7037 of to another the plurality response The 30. from different type In Docket the plurality type connection corresponds method object reads follows as 29 wherein of claim notification Claim 30 here which repeats to connection unique of to another corresponding the method object notification type plurality. The will point Applicant where out element this may be found in the Applicants specification. 28 Page with means the objects These of receivers. to page This Still performs the work ClaIm claim Regarding does drawings it an an operating source response notification the of to the 26130 that the method addition connection classes line page 24 the the dispatches This receiver. disclosed method particular with associated do to object function calls work. asks specifically an interest comprising on event the behalf listener to an of Where the event the with connection Claim objects steps in the and specification events the invoking of 37 here which the event event reads if the listener as object event object follows notification changes representing associated only object behalf system in the objects for the of of an event listener interest in and objects by on registered computer-implemented of plurality event object registered Applicantrepeats change in the discloses the notification object listener for operating creating change 18. In receiver to different object event registering the of receiver notification creating representing in Figure notification delivered object the among method disclosure are objects Connection object listener corresponds propagating 34 to Examiner the event method 37. notifications source clients. 37 event for receiving In 20 connection in the 37 connection information the notifier to specific the how to those show notiing method with method i.e. the method of notification providing notifications dispatch from notifications lines appropriate corresponding notifier classes and feature. 59 page the clients specialization this Regarding the of allow discloses to the of in conjunction is further notification describe lists dispatch objects line 34 to manage the provide objects. 24 lines to object an connection associated information object method for receiving an event source object the connection event source information representing change with in the connection event source object object responsive to object and vi 354FH207 WI-App1e0004472 Serial No DocketNo 09/287172 notifying method object event the for receiving event information listener an corresponds to will point out of the object notification Interest the event by invoking with registered connection the on behalf of registered 3048-7037 associated event the the if only object listener object The Applicant where may be found element this in the Applicants specification an event listener an event source object the is receiver disclosed object 28 page at 28-29 and lines 31 connection the notifying method for receiving information object event corresponds to in the that the connection object an specification object has responsibility the by information source the Figure for interest page at or of the on with events 31 receiver in by if the source listener object event object is 18 They in Figure disclose that the connection general have interest have more in events specialized of are object 29 associated signifying turn 24-25 line only event and which objects objects generated the line 28 page the object line 28 page at invoking of behalf notifier object connection particular interest to 18 The on the receiver specification concept receive of is receiver from particular receiver the receiver specific These different By the the claims of abov remarks Accordingly allow the each have allow claims This the the is Applicant pass to the believes all respectfully how to of an the requests object an issues the one to notifications classes of events notifier classes the Figure standard Notifier from with in and interest notification the based change interest corresponding connection of to express objects the notification is jnvention for propagating from with in association that the for receiving instantiated object at have they to receiver in association the case objects which objects specialization disclosed discloses receiver connection identified disclosed mechanism notification dispatches Applicant and line in notifier objects object objects receivers allows objects their connection objects that 31 that provides source tO The object objects ito page that provide connection connection classes been resolved of The objects events source line is This responsible framework to register of connection list register The for classes objects is it framework objects provided enable 30 page about changes notification interface at notification betwecn information for objects which by connection Ito page line more The the event the at disclosed object with registered 30 registered one of object disclosed object connection registered object which about each of is source the is the listener notification disclosed generated is object or more notifier objects interest are to in specific delivered to 18 raise by Examiners the Examiner have reconsideration issue 26130v1 354FH208 WI-App1e0004473 SerialNo 09/287172 The may be credit Assistant required DocketNo 11 Commissioner for the timely to any overpayment is hereby authorized consideration of Account No Deposit this to charge amendment 13-4503 any Order No MORGAN gistr 20 L.L.P Hod tion No -7887 26279 Telephone Facsimile ADDRESS Finnegan L.LP Morgan Eye or 3048-703 FINNEGAN 202-857-7929 1775 which 1.16 By fl ohn SENDERS fees submitted Respectfully Dated_____________ additional under 37 C.F.R 3048-7037 Street Washington N.W D.C Suite 400 20006 2613Ov 354FH209 WI-App1e0004474

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?