ABS Global, Inc. v. Inguran, LLC

Filing 639

ORDER on deposition designations as to Ian Biggs. Signed by District Judge William M. Conley on 8/3/2016. (KC)

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF WISCONSIN

ABS GLOBAL, INC.,

v.

Plaintiff/Counterclaim Defendant,

INGURAN, LLC,

ORDER
14-cv-503-wmc

Defendant/Counterclaimant/Third-Party Plaintiff,
and
XY, LLC,

Intervening Defendant/Counterclaimant/Third-Party Plaintiff,

v.
GENUS PLC,
Third-Party Defendant.

Having reviewed ST’s amended proponent deposition designations (dkt. #630),
the court makes the following rulings as to witness Ian Biggs. The approved designations
may be presented to the jury unless the witness is available to testify in person. ST shall
remove all objections and any other asides or discussions between counsel and/or with
the court reporter, even where not noted by the court in its rulings.

Ian Biggs

6:7-10

Statements of the
videographer are not
evidence (Sustained)

6:21-12:24

Statements of the
videographer are not
evidence [6:21-7:5]
(Sustained)
Identification of counsel is
not evidence [7:6-16]
(Sustained)

13:9-16:22
17:2-20:7

Improper comment on
testimony [10:3; 10:11]
(Sustained)
Question assumes fact not in
evidence [16:19-22]
(Sustained)
Question assumes fact not in
evidence [17:2-9] (Sustained)

20:10-14

Question is leading [20:5-7]
(Sustained)

20:17-21
20:24-21:7
21:12-20
(starting at “How

Question is leading [20:10;
20:12-14] (Sustained as to
20:10; overruled as to
20:12-14)

24:15-23
29:17-30:3
32:19-21
60:19-61:16

61:23-62:5
62:8-63:19

63:23-64:10
64:12-65:13

30:4-6; 30:9-22

402/403,602
801/082
Assumes facts
not in evidence
[62:2-5
(Overruled),
62:8-11
(Overruled)];
Assumes facts
not in evidence
[62:22-25
(Overruled);
63:16-19
(Overruled)]
402/403
602
701
Assumes facts
not in evidence
64:7-10
(Overruled);
64:12-65:2]
(Overruled);

would . . .”)
22:8-11
22:15-23:19
(starting at “Is
that amendment
. . .”)
24:7-14
24:24-28:13

Question is leading [20:17
(Overruled); 20:19-21
(Sustained)]

402/403
602 [65:8-13
(Overruled)]

Question is leading [20:24]
(Sustained)

Questions are leading [28:1113] (Sustained)

28:16-25

Questions are leading
(Sustained)

29:4-16

Questions are leading [29:4]
(Sustained)

32:22-35:2

35:5-36:22

37:13-38:14

3

38:17-39:11

Question is leading [38:17]
(Overruled)

39:14-41:22

42:18-43:18

44:24-46:3

46:19-48:14

50:9-21

50:24-51:4

4

51:9-13

Question is leading
(Overruled)

51:16-53:19

Question is leading [51:1620; 53:15-19] (Overruled)

53:22-56:6

Question is leading [53:2254:5] (Overruled)

58:13-59:12

5

60:5-9

Question mischaracterizes
ABS’s complaint (Sustained)

60:11-14

Question mischaracterizes
ABS’s complaint (Sustained)

65:17-24

Improper commentary on
testimony (Sustained)

Entered this 3rd of August, 2016.

BY THE COURT:
/s/
__________________________________
WILLIAM M. CONLEY
District Judge

6