Estate of Ashley DiPiazza v. City of Madison et al

Filing 236

ORDER on Deposition Designations, Counter-Designations, and Objections as to Damages. Signed by District Judge William M. Conley on 7/12/2017. (kwf)

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF WISCONSIN
THE ESTATE OF ASHLEY DIPIAZZA,
Plaintiff,

ORDER

v.
16-cv-60-wmc

JUSTIN BAILEY, GARY PIHLAJA,
and CARY LEEREK,
Defendants.

On the parties’ deposition designations, counter-designations, and objections as to damages
(dkts. ## 198, 213, and 228), the court rules as follows. The court reserves as to portions of the
objections pending stipulation of the parties (and/or argument while the jury is deliberating as to
liability) on the scope of plaintiff’s damages claims.
Plaintiff’s
Design’ns

82:14-86:8

87:8-93:21

Defendants’
CounterDesign’ns

15:18-27:19
47:2-19
59:3-64:19
65:3-76:8;
76:9-77:24
77:25-79:21
80:19-24

Defendants’
Design’ns

Plaintiff’s
Objections

15:18-27:19
167:17168:8;
184:2-24
46:3-4
47:2-19
59:3-64:19
65:3-81:22

Defendants’
Objections

15:18-27:19
167:17168:8;
184:2-24

Plaintiff’s
CounterDesign’ns

Court Ruling

SUSTAIN
SUSTAIN

EXCLUDE
SUSTAIN
SUSTAIN
SUSTAIN
objections

82:14-84:10;
84:15-22

[no objection:
79:22-80:18;
80:25-81:22]
SUSTAIN
objection

88:4-90:9;
91:20-93:21

[no objection:
84:11-14;
84:23-86:8]
SUSTAIN
objections
[no

objection:

94:8-14
121:16125:12
157:2-10
161:5167:16

87:8-88:3;
90:10-91:19]
EXCLUDE

15:18-27:19
121:16125:12
157:2-10
161:5-162:17; 190:7-13
162:18163:20;
166:3-18;
167:3-16

RESERVE
SUSTAIN
SUSTAIN
objection and
EXCLUDE
counterdesignation
[no objection:
163:21-166:2;
166:19-167:2]
SUSTAIN
objection and
EXCLUDE
counterdesignation

172:8174:23

172:8-174:23

190:7-13

175:5176:5

175:5-176:5

190:7-13

178:19180:4
189:11190:6
203:3205:10

178:19-180:4

RESERVE

189:11-190:6

SUSTAIN

203:3-205:10

SUSTAIN

SUSTAIN
objection and
EXCLUDE
counterdesignation

Entered this 12th day of July, 2017.
BY THE COURT:
/s/
WILLIAM M. CONLEY
District Judge

2