Mlsna, Mark v. Union Pacific Railroad

Filing 252

ORDER : IT IS ORDERED that the parties' request for rulings on objections to certain designations is GRANTED, and the objections are sustained in part and overruled in part. Signed by District Judge William M. Conley on 6/25/2021. (voc)

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF WISCONSIN
MARK MLSNA,
Plaintiff,

ORDER

v.
18-cv-37-wmc
UNION PACIFIC RAILROAD COMPANY,
Defendant.

Before the court is the parties’ request for ruling on objections to certain deposition
designations as to Garry Gordon.
Page and Line
Designations

Objections

Court Ruling

5:11-17

Counter
Designations

Court Ruling

8:4-15

5:24–6:1
9:20–14:25
18:7-10,

17:14-18
STRIKE 18:7-10;

18:22-19:5

STRIKE 23:2-16;

19:21:20:14

otherwise
OVERRULED

23:2-25:25

25:8-25; R, F,
403

STRIKE ALL

20:15-21:11
21:12-23:1
26:11-27:6
28:3-6

28:10-29:4
29:9-32:12

29:5-8
30:23-31:14: R,
F, 403

OVERRULED

1

32:17-25

STRIKE

Page and Line
Designations

Objections

Court Ruling

Counter
Designations

Court Ruling

31:18-25: R,
403
38:12-39:3
42:9-42:21

38:2-11
R, F, 403

OVERRULED

41:3-14
41:25-42:8
42:22-24

42:25-43:23

43:19-23: R, F

OVERRULED

44:6-46:10

45:12-23: R, F,
H

43:24-44:5

STRIKE 43:2425

OVERRULED

47:8-25

STRIKE ALL

45:24-46:10: R,
F, H
46:21-47:7

H, F

SUSTAIN
OBJECTION

48:1-8
49:19-24; 50:2-5;
50:18-20; 51:1-2

52:18-54:20

53:16-54:20: R,
F, H

OVERRULED

55:4-25

58:24-59:8

H, F

OVERRULED

58:7-23
59:9-60:19
60:23-25; 61:9-25
62:1-6

64:3-65:18

R, 403, F;
Vague as to
“tweaked it or

STRIKE 64:18-19;
STRIKE 65:14;
otherwise
OVERRULED

reprogrammed
it” at
64:14-16

2

STRIKE 59:960:7; STRIKE
60:23-25

Page and Line
Designations

Objections

Court Ruling

Counter
Designations

STRIKE 69:17 &
72:21-73:80;
otherwise
OVERRULED

Court Ruling

74:2-77:6

65:7-18 – R, F,
403, H
69:10-73:22

69:10-20: F,
403
69:25-70:10: R,
F, 403
70:13-73:2: R,
403, F, H
73:9-22: R, 403,
F

77:10-79:20

77:10-79:20 –
beyond the
scope/improper
additional cross

STRIKE 77:10-20;
STRIKE 79:1-15;
otherwise
OVERRULED

examination
77:21-78:12 –
R, F
78:13-79:20:
R,403,F

Accordingly, IT IS ORDERED that the parties’ request for rulings on objections to certain
designations is GRANTED, and the objections are sustained in part and overruled in part as
provided above.
Entered this 25th day of June, 2021.
BY THE COURT:
/s/
WILLIAM M. CONLEY
District Judge

3