Cariou v. Prince

Filing 92

JOINT APPENDIX, Vol. 2, on behalf of Appellant Lawrence Gagosian, Gagosian Gallery, Inc. and Richard Prince, FILED. Service date 10/26/2011 by email, CM/ECF. [430293] [11-1197]--[Edited 10/27/2011 by HT]

A-336

•

•

•

A-337

•

•

r--

"'"
V)

o
o

U

A-338

•

00
~

If)

o
o
U

A-339

•

. ------__~.I--------_.,---------,.-------~.-~

-..

•

•

.

-----

A-340

•

•

o

lI"l
lI"l

o

o

U

•

.----.----

A-341

•

II"l
II"l

o

o

U

A-342

•

. -~-.

•

.----- • .
-----

•

N
V)
V)

o

o
U

•

.

. ---~-

A-343

•

M

<n
<n

o
o
U

A-344

•

•

•

•

•

•

-.:t

l/")
l/")

o

o
U

A-345

•

•

<n
<n
<n

o
o
U

A-346

•

•

.

'.""

,

- - .~ ~",--

.. ";~";~.i~- , -- ~-.; -:

- =-z ~'

=-c

.. ~

ID
V)
V)

o
o

U

A-347

•

•

r-IF)
IF)

o
o
U

A-348

•

•

00

'"
VI
o

o
U

A-349

•

•

A-350

•

~----Ia-

______.I____--

•

.

A-351

•

A-352

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

A-353

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

A-354

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

-

A-355

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

A-356

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

Deponent

•

NE- ~ \

D'J;~~Ptr&

.._
.......

A-357

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-33

',

Filed 05/1 8/10 Page 2 ,~rr1-'f-;
i

",'

Jt~jVctC.-

!

:~I
The Pitch
Charles Company, his wife, son and daughter arrive at the St. Barts airport,
late afternoon two days before Xmas, he's meeting up with his brother and
sister-in-law..• staying on the island for a couple ofweeks ••. v3.cation .•.
As he's landing, he sees out the window a lot of people running
around ... general commotion.
As the plane, taxis up to the gate he asks the pilot what's going on .•.
As the Company family disembarks the plane, there's more pandemonium ...
People grabbing, shouting,. some hysterical ... if s a tiny airport, but there's an
'overload of people waiting to get thru customs and many people literally
"cryingn. ~. they're "crying" because'there are no planes going out .•. no

'.-:.",~.---, ""'-'~~~~~~1~~o~i&~~~~~7w~~~:'~':~~~!~'''': :'''~''''

' ' ' ". '"

~
'.~

~
,
............

,

".,

~

,:t
: .:.~-:.:..:..~:.... ~

..'....: ...'" ........

There are no returning flights because these cities and many other major
"areas" in the continental U.S. and Western and Eastern Europe have just
been obliterated by nuclear attack.
his family are infonned of this fact and seemed to
Charles Company
melt into the tarmac under 88 degree temps .•. holding their bags, their
backpacks ... what will come to be as all their worldly possessions.
They hook up with Charles's brother, who will:&l1 them in with a bit more
detail of the events "round" the world. "What are we suppose to do?" is
Charles's wife's first question ...
"There's nowhere to go", is the first answer.
A good part of the world, "most" of the world, has been nuked and they are
here on a tiny French island in the middle of nowhere ... which in a year's
time will become part On the Beach, part Lord ofthe Flies.

and

Background: Charles is 55, has no military background, is pretty much out
of shape ... makes his living as an architect.
To make this pitch even shorter I'm going to cut to a year later.•.
People on the island have broken up into "tribes" ... most of the houses have
been ransacked and all of the hotels occupied.
Charles Company is now Charlie Company. He has been exercising. Res
also learned to load a weapon, field dress a wound, cook without a fire. His
daughter is the # 1 scavenger...
He, his wife, son and daughter, brother and sister-in-law, (along with 'SeVeral
followers) have taken over the Eden Rock Hotel. It's headquarters.

CONFIDENTIAL '- PR00079

~

J
~

i

A-358

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-33

Filed 05/18/10 Page 3 of 3

Stockpiled. A Mini-Mart. As best a fortress as can be under the
circumstances. Everything is rationed, everything is ''used'' ...
Next:
Charles's son is standing lookout. Thru his telescope out in the ocean he
sees what appears to be a periscope... he sounds the alarm ...
The movie is called, Eden Rock...

••

•• , . . . .

~•••••••••••••••••••••

- . - . - •••••••••

~ •••• ~ . . . . . . . _ . . . . . . . . ." . ; . " ' •• , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . :

••

~ •••••_ • • _ •• :

•••• , • • • • • , : • • • • • • , - . . . :

~

. :••••••• • • • : . : • • : ••• : . : .

: ••••••• _ : • • • : • • • • • : . :• • : •• ; ••• : . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . d

••••••••••••••

"

···········--·1
!

CONFIDENTIAL - PR00080

A-359

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-34

Filed 05/18/10 Page 2 of 3
TIoesRy, 0cIaI00r 11, 2008

~7

PM

, SoII!ject: III:: -no. PIIdo"
0.: 1Uesdav. 0a0IMIr
fnono: I.auIse Her! <loWe@p&os!an._

7. 200B ""'I"'"

To'8Msy8ls()One~~Io.com>

Dear BebiyThanks so much for all this.
I definitely want to talk to Richard, but let me get started. Would be great If we can schedule something in on Thursday, then
I can get dOfle by the end of lhe week.

r.egards and see you SOOn!

louise
Louilic Neri
Gagosian Gallery
555 West 24th Street,
NcwYork NY 10011

[e-mail]
..... .general: ...+ 1.2.12. l.H. 1 lJ.l ......
direct: .. + ....... -- -4212079.. -. - .
1 646 .... ..--- -.... " - ' ....
...
~- -~--

fill

.~

~~

~

Think be!ore )'0=.1 print

From: betsy biscone [mallto:bbisoJne@prince-stud"ro.com}
Sent: Tuesday, October 07,2008 4\:29 PM
To: Betsy BIsmne; louise Neri

Cc Melissa UJzarov
,SUbject: Re: "The PitCh"

Dear Louise,
I hope this finds you well. Per Richard's request, please find attached The Pitch, which was displayed on the wall at
the Eden Rock Hotel in Saint Barth for last December 2007, Eden Rock Show. Also, you" fmd below additional
writing Richard did this past Spring '08.
I understand you would like to talk with him at some pOint. Tell me know what you are thinking so I can schedule
something In.
00 let me know if there is any question or if I can be of further assistance,
All best,

Betsy Biscone
Prince Studio Manager
R'vllle, NY 12147
T: 518.797.5279
F: 518.797.9875

-- Additional Eden Rock/Pitch Materia' written HARCH 2008 -

More on Eden Rock
1. Rastas and Reggae ... they escape from one of the Cruise ships, (they were the band aboard the ship) three days
the bombs went off. They go to the Hotel Manapany. Six band members, two roadies and a manager.

aft~

2. The Backpackers ... these are college kids, use to spring breaks, know nothing of responsibility or the real wond.
h901of2

CONFIDENTIAL - PR00075

A-360

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-34

Filed 05/18/10 Page 3 of 3

• They gather first In bars then take over a small hotel just above Shell Beach. They keep partying, drinking,
smoking ••. they are the first to ·go native· .•• the first to smear ·war paint· on their bodies••• they're a\so the first to
get wiped o u t . . . . '
. '
3. The Amazons ... Four Lesbians who escape a second Cruise ship, who bring along part of the aew and take over
the Guanahani Hotel. These are large well built women along the lines of Shena Queen of the Jungle, Wonder·
Woman. cat Woman. think Raquel Welch meets Unda Hamilton In the Terminator. Their outfits, hair and make-up
remind us of Road Warriors....
4. The Ultimate Ones. .. this tribe Is made up of rich, affluent, masters of the universe... these are guys who own the
huge private boats parked In Gustavla••• they have the loyalty of their crews, they have their own weapons and in
the beginning access to food and water. They quickly make.deals with the local St. Bart police force. Thev stay on
their boats at first but then take over the III de France hotel... these guys are use to privilege and shaping the
future ... theY don't take ·no" for
answer. .. they believe they "own- the Island and everyone Is their subject...
several come to be assaSSinated. h~ld hostage, and hanged upside-down ... in an opening scene one of them is
plttured burled up to his head In the sand at Saline Beach wfth the tide coming In ...

a"

These are the four main tribes along with Charlie Company•••

..........Cbarlie.COmpany..represents.."famlly· .

. . .......... .... . . , .......... .

. :. :~~~~ :~~d,~!l.C1.e. ~p~~nts·tI1e: djsenfra~c/:Iised~ . . ..
......Backpackers·.represent'!'altemative!··
..................................................... .
Amazons represent "sex·
Ultimate Ones represent ·power"
Richard PrInce
------ End of Forwarded Message

"-2012

CONFIDENTIAL - PR00076

A-361
Uagoslan Vallery - eXhlbItlon - Klcnara t'nnce - l'lOVemOer () - Ut;;\,;t;;LL1UCl t.v, t.vvo

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-35
MEl( II

~.

'I

~I;:

F"

~ U5 v

Filed 05/18/10 Page 2 of 4

!

GAGOSIAN GALLERY

RICHARD PRINCE

HOI.[

CANA.l lONE
HOVEMIER. - D£C£MBlER 10,

I

s~s Wul .2..,th S~r":(:{
HeW' '((:11'11', KY LOCi!.l

~.'.

T~llU.~'U..UJ1 f~1 ,Zl~.~~J.!OGJ1
lhlt-s,;~

"', "

Richard Prince

ZOOI

II)·G

GAry Inf'onniltlo1'l

tr!ro

""-

Gallery Hap

PRESS RELEASE

VI EVI

lilEW WORK
VIEW CATALOG

ART2ST INFO

Rit:harc Prince
Caflai ZOI"l~

VIEW

"The sOOry WBS baSiCilHy .bout a guy who lands in St Barth,
gets off the plane, Is immediatefy t(t/d mat: there"s been a

fludear holocaust in the rest of tfle world,. and he looks at
his tamOy 3nd says 'We can't go back.·..

-Rlchi!lrd P(lnce

Gagosian Gallery is pleased to announce "CIInal Zone,· an
exhibition of new paintings by Richard Prince.

following his burtesque dialogues with the art of Oe

"oaRing, Picasso, and Naughty Nurse pulp fictiOn. Prince has
turned to hIS own biographic.a' R)ots for Im.plriltion. The

Panama canal Zone, "hen! he was born. was, until 1979. a
politiCiJI exdave of the U.s., part-c:clonlal company endave

and part.. $OCIallst government. purportedly dominated by
yirulent separatist racism. In hili characteristic manner,
Prtnce hilS tnlInsformed the former realitV of his birthplace

into a fictive space: -canal Zone" proYides an anarchic
tropical scenarlc In whim extreme emanations of the (white
American male) lei - fteshy female pin-ups, Rastafarians

with massive dreadlOCks, electric gultaB. and vime black
bodies - run riot.

~de

from thefr "'storyboard'" loolcs and their ability to

absorb information based on Prince1s original ·pltdl,· what is
evidentfy new In these paintings Is the way they are,
literally, ·put togetner.-Ilke provisioflil magazine lay-outs.

http://www.gagosian.comlexhibitionsI2008-11-08_richard-prince!

12/8/2008

C00008

A-362

Some Images. scanned from originals. are printed directly

onto the base canvas; others are adragged on,· using a
primitive wlt.Jge technique whereby printed figures are
roughly Ctlt out, then the backs of those figures painted and

Pilsted dilectlv onto the base canvas; with a squeegee so
that the eJCces:s paillt squirtS' out on and around ttle image.
On top of this are vlolently suggestive swtpes and drips of

livid ""lnt and scribbles of oil·stick crayon which, together
with the comic. abstract sign·features that mask eac.h
figure's filce, add to the powerful push·pult between degree
and effect. This has become a completely ne'N way ror
..PriA~ ..,o.J"I)~k~ iI. p~I~!~g~ .~~.e_~ !!!l!.~ ~r..~.~~~,~~~.~. ~,P o~

the $lIrtace is Incidental to the- process.

Thomas More's Utopia of 1518 desO'ibed a fictional Island in
the AtlantiC Ocean that possessed iI seemingly perrect 50do·
political-legal system. Since then, the term has been used

both for intentional communities attempting to create ideal
~

.

societies and Ideals that are impossible to achieve. Prince's
island and its IJnfettered imaginings that vadRate betweel1
humorous delinquency and Si!!Idei2ln e)(ce5S, is a rather more
carnivale5Que response to the original concept. "Canal
Zone; this orgiastic. post-nuclear. new order for ci'Vllization

as we onCe knew It, takes its: place among other great
modern 'llisions

Heart

or the apocalypse., from Joseph Conrad's

ofoar~l1ess

and Pablo PlcaUQ's Gllernica, to The

BI!21tles' "Heller Skener" and Michel Houllebecq's proQhetic
Platform.

Richard Prlnc.e was born in 1949 in the Panama Canal
Zone and lives aod works in upstate Ne.w York. His work has
been the subjl!Ct of major exhibitions, including the Whitney

!

i
.j

Museum of American Art. New York; the San Frandsco
Mus~m

of Modern Art; Museum Boijmans van Beuning!!n,

Rotterdam: Museum fOr Gegenwartskunst. Basel;
Kunstmuseum Wolfsburg; Serpentine Gallery! london

j
1
'f

!
,

(2008). A retrospective survey opened at the Solomon Fl.
Guggenheim Museum in ZOO 7 and traveled to The: Walker
Art Center. Minneapolis in 2008.

For more Information, please contact Melissa Passman at

212.7'11.1111 or

mRa.s.S:01_an@~.99.s.i.~!L~Jn.

:1
~

:1

1
i
·1

httn·llwww.I1Hl1l1sian.com/exhibitionsf2008-11-08 richard-prince/

12/8/2008

C00009

A-363

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-35

GAGOSIAN

Filed 05/18/10 Page 4 of 4

GALLERY

RICHARD PRINCE

MUIt,

ARTIST BIOGRAPHV
ARTIST eXHIBITIONS

Richard Prine!)

puaLlCATlONS

N:lY tt • Oce 20: 2000

l4111

st .....

VIEW

~tl:SI!.:I

(Glr11r1'Htrij.

1~93

~....aa~l'Irr;~

e ""

~·]Ja

!ndl\!.J. (20.l

JC.

P.:chard prince

13.7 ~ .... l

EoltiCtI

C"r'ad Zooe

PJchard Prince was born in 1949 In the Panama Canal Zone
Bnd liwes and works in upstate New York. Mining images
rrom mass media, advertiSing and entertainment since the

late seventies, Prince has redefined the concepts of
Iluthorship, ownership. and aura. Applying his

understanding af the complex transactions of representation
to the maldng of art. he evolv@d

il

unique signatur-e IiU!!d

with echoes of other Signatures yet that is unquestionably

his own. An avid collector ilnd percePtIve ehronidec- of
AmeriCan subcultures and vernaculars and their role io tht!!
construction of American

identity~

he has probed the depths

or radsm, seJdsm, and psychosis In mainstream humor; the
mythical status of cowboys~ b(kers~ ct.Istomlzed cars, and
celebrities; and most recently I the push-pull allure of pulp
fiction and soft pom, predudng such ynlikely Icons a~ the

highlv coveted Nurse paintings.

(

http://www.gagosian.comlartistslrichard-prmce/

12/8/2008
C00010

A-364

•

•

•

•

•

•

@

m
CONFIDENT r'L

•

•

•

I

GG0076

-

I

A-365

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

GG0077

•

A-366

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

ill CONFlDENTIAL
GG007S

•

A-367

•

•

•

•

•®

•

•

•

GG0079

•

A-368

•

•

•

•

•

•

1D CONFIDENT:

•

i\

•

L
GG0080

•

A-369

Case 1:08-cv-11327 -DAB Document 54-37

From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:

Filed 05/18/10 Page 2 of 2

Alison McDonald
Thursday, October 2,20085:22 PM
Darlina Goldak <[e-mail]>
FW: images for Interview

---'---'

---.--~-----

From: Melissa lazarov
Sent: Thursday, October 02, 2008 4:56 PM
To: Alison McDonald; Nicole Heck
Subject: FW: images for Interview

see below - I need to send some jpegs to glenn. please attach for me. Melissa

From: betsy biscone [mailto:[e-mail]]
Sent: Thursday, October 02,20084:52 PM
To: Melissa lazarov
Cc: Glenn O'Brien
Subject: Re: images for Interview

Dear Melissa,
Per Glenn's O'Brien's request below, would you kindly have your team send him a small selection of high Res Rasta
works. Please include James Brown Disco Ball, Meditation & a few others to chose from.
Many thanks in advance.
bets
On 10/2/084:14 PM, "Glenn O'Brien" <[e-mail]> wrote:

Hi Betsy,
Richard said you could hook us up with images for his interview. I love the rasta work and would like to run several big
pages. We are on a tight deadline. What's the next step?
Glenn

~

..

GGP001421

CONFIDENTIAL

A-370

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-38
From:
Sent:
To:

Subject:

Filed 05/18/10 Page 2 of 2

Darlina Goldak
Thursday, September25, 2008 11:46 AM
Nicole Heck <[e-mail]>
Richard Prince painting layouts - notes from mlaz

MlazlLG notes on Prince:
-They would like the blue Rastaman (image attached) on the cover. They like the textured, burlap surface that is on the back of the
dummies. Please try the blue Rasta man on this surface for the cover. She seemed indiii"erent about if the textured surface is also on
the back when 1 asked.
-They would like the book larger, both horizontally and vertically. If the book needs to be male veltical because the blue Rasta image
is vertical, that is. fme. I asked her if she had a book in mind to compare for size, but she could not corne up with an example.
.They like the hinding with the spine sandwiched hy the fmnt and hack cover.
·Please include "Essay" or "Text by lames Frey' in the title page. They want the book to come up if you Google James Frey.
-Please include source material in the book. They want you to "get into his head" and see how he got to where he is and see where he
is going_ (I'm looking into this)
.They want a more interesting, non-traditional way to present the text in the book. Alison e".-plained this to Ivoryesterday.
Note, Richard Prince will be sending us more studio photos soon.

GGP002332

CONFIDENTIAL

A-371

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

A-372

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

•

RICHARD PRINCE
November 8-December 20, 2008
Opening reception Saturday, November 8, 6-8pm
Gagosian Gallery
555 West 24th St, New York 10011
T 212.741.1111
www.gagoslan.com

~G>ornmIT~

~c COtJ~l-O
Deponent _ __
i""[ \:t((/="J ..l:l:.b..
f1..
Date _
_ Rptr
WWW~

GGPOD140A

•

A-373

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-40

From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:

Filed 05/18/10 Page 2 of 5

Andie Trainer <[e-mail]>
Friday, December 5, 20082:16 PM
Jessica Arisohn <[e-mail]>
Ryan from Rare Posters

Hi Jessy.
Ryan from Rare Posters came by today and picked up two boxes, or 100, Richard Prince invites. You can now
deduct the $100 from his account.
Best.
Andie

Andie Trainer
Gagosian Gallery
555 W. 24th Street
New York, NY 10011
212.741.1111
[e-mail]

.CONFIDENTIAL

GGP004297

A-374

Case 1:08-cv-11327 -DAB Document 54-40

From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:

Filed 05/18/10 Page 3 of 5

Jessica Arisohn
Wednesday, November 19, 20083:00 PM
Alison McDonald <[e-mail]>; Nicole Heck <[e-mail]>;
Darlina Goldak <[e-mail]>
FW: Ryan from Rare Posters

Ryan Dowler wants Prince Canal Zone - Andie says we have three extra bQxes left. Don't know if we should give i1 to him
though 8S he has acted a bit shady in the past ·but otherwise they will be tossed. What do you think?

From: Andie Trainer

Sent: Wednesday, November 19, 2008 10:16 AM
To: Jessica Arisohn
Subject: Ryan from Rare Posters
Hi Jessy,
Ryan from Rare Posters emailed me expressing interest in scoopiog up any extra Prince invites we might have. We did
get quite a few (we started with seven boxes, three remain} ... but somehow it doesn't seem right for him to be SELLING
our invitations. Thought I'd run it by y.ou for a second opinion before I got back to him. Let me know your thoughts.
Thanks,
Andie

Andie Trainer
Gagosian GaUel")'
555 W. 24th Street
New Yurk,NY 10011
211..741.1111

&tr:[e-mail]

GGP0030G1:

CONFIDENTIAL

., . :GG002763

A-375

Case 1:08-cv-11327 -DAB Document 54-40

From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:

Filed 05/18/10 Page 4 of 5

Nicole Heck
Wednesday, November 19, 2008 3:08 PM
Alison McDonald <[e-mail]>
Jessica Arisohn <[e-mail]>; Darlina Goldak <[e-mail]>
RE: Ryan from Rare Posters

Shouldn't we get a percentage ofthe sale if he is selling something we paid to produce?

From: Jessica Arisohn

Sent: Wednesday, November 19,20083:00 PM
To: Anson McDonald; Nicole Heck; Darlina Goldak
Subject: FW: Ryan from Rare Posters
Ryan Dowler wants Prince Canal Zone - Andie says we have three extra boxes left. Don't know if we should give it to him
though as he has acted a bit shady in the past but otherwise they will be tossed. What do you think?

From: Andie Trainer

Sent: Wednesday, November 19, 2008 10:16 AM

To: Jessica Arisohn
Subject: Ryan from Rare Posters
Hi Jessy,
Ryan from Rare Posters emailed me expressing interest in scooping up any extra Prince invites we might hav.e .. We did
get quite a few (we started with seven boxes, three remain) ... but somehow it doesn't seem right for him to. be· SELLING
our invitations. Thought I'd run it by you for a second opinion before I got back to him. Let me know your thoughts...
Thanks,
Andie

Andie Trainer
Gagosian Gallery
555 W. 24th Street
New York, NY 10011
212.741.1111
atrainer@gagosian.c:om

GGP003062

CONFIDENTIAL

. ;:.;, ,GG002764

A-376

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-40

From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:

Filed 05/18/10 Page 5 of 5

Alison McDonald
Wednesday, November 19, 2008 3:16PM
Nicole Heck <[e-mail]>
Jessica Arisohn <[e-mail]>; Darlina Goldak <[e-mail]>
RE: Ryan from Rare Posters

We should sell them to him.

From: Nicole Heck

Sent: Wednesday, November 19, 20083:08 PM
To: Alison McDonald
Cc: Jessica Arisohn; Darlina Goldak
Subject: RE: Ryan from Rare Posters
Shouldn't we get a percentage of the sale if he is selling something we paid to produce?

From: Jessica Arisohn

Sent: Wednesday, November 19, 200S 3:00 PM
To: Alison McDonald; Nicole Heck; Darlina Goldak
Subject: FW: Ryan from Rare Posters
Ryan Dowler wants Prince Canal Zone - Andie says we have three extra boxes left. Don't know if we should give it to him
though as he has acted a bit shady in the past but otherwise they wiD be tossed. What do you think?

From: Andie Trainer

Sent: Wednesday, November 19, 200810:16 AM
To: Jessica Arisohn
Subject: Ryan from Rare Posters
Hi Jessy,
. Ryan from Rare Posters emailed me expressing interest in scooping up any extra Prince invites we might have. We did
get quite a few (we started with seven boxes, three remain) ... but somehow it doesn't seem right for him to be SELLING
our invitations. Thought I'd run it by you for a second opinion before I got back to him. Let me know your thought$.
Thanks,
Andie

Andie Trainer
Gagosian Gallery
555 W. 24th Street
. New York,NY 10011
212.741.1111
[e-mail]

GGP0030S3

CONFIDENTIAL

··.GG002766·

A-377

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-41

Filed 05/18/10 Page 2 of 2

LARRY GAGOSIAN
IS PLEASED TO INVITE

TO A DINNER GIVEN ON SATURDAY. 8 NOVEMBER 2008. AT 8:30 PM
IN HONOR OF

RICHARD PRINCE

PRIVATE ROOF CLUB
GRAMERCY PARK HOTEL
2 LEXINGTON AVENUE. NY

RSVP KAREN HO
KAREN@GAGOSIAN,COM

212.741.1"-'-

GGP001696A

A-378

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-42

From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:

Tom Duncan <[e-mail]>
Saturday, September 6,200810:03 AM
Anita Foden <[e-mail]>
RE: Prince works received today

Filed 05/18/10 Page 2 of 3

--~~

;\iji~ •
,![.I.~Spt,~

.L ...·.·~:~

Anita,
RPS51D and RPSSll DO NOT match what we have received. Cookie Crumbles is the work with seven figures,
Untitled (Rastas) (though on the back it is Untitled (Rasta)) is the work with four figures. All else matcheshowever, the list they provided does not have the Specially Round Midnight diptych on it, even though it is
indeed here at 555.

All works were photographed yesterday EXCEPT the ~~cted

Redacted
Thanks!
THOMAS DUNCAN
GAGOSIAN GALLERY
555 WEST 24TH STREET
NEW YORK NY lOOn
TEL: [phone]
FAX: [phone]
From: Anita Foden
Sent: Friday, September 05,2008 3:24 PM
To: Tom Duncan
Subject: FW: Prince works received today

Anita Foden
Gagosian Gallery
980 Madison Avenue
New York, NY 10021
Tel [phone]
Fax [phone]
an [e-mail]
From: ebrown [mailto:ebrown@prince-studio,comJ

Sent: Friday, September 05, 2008 3:19 PM
To: Anita Foden
Subject: Re: Prince works received today
Anita,
Attached is a list of the works you received from the LI Studio. Can you please double check that RPS510 and
511 match what you have received - please check the title on back of painting - Richard couldn't remember
which was which.

GGP004072

CONFIDENTIAL

GG010033

A-379

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-42

Filed 05/18/10 Page 3 of 3

From: Anita Faden
Sent: Friday, September 05, 2008 3:24 PM
To: Tom Duncan
Subject: FW: Prince works received today

Anita Foden
Gagosian Gallery
980 Madison Avenue
New York, NY 10021
Tel [phone]
Fax [phone]
[e-mail]
From: ebrown (mailto:[e-mail]]
Sent: Friday, September 05,2008 3:19 PM
To: Anita Foden
Subject: Re: Prince works received today
Anita,
Attached is a list of the works you received from the U Studio. Can you please double check that RPS510 and 511 match
what you have received 0 please check the title on back of painting - Richard couldnCt remember which was which.
Thanks for all and let me know if you need anything else.
All best,
Eric

Eric Brown
Prince Studio
T: 518. 797. 5279

C: 347. 423. 7530
F: 518. 797.9875

On 9/5/08 2:13 PM, "Anita Faden" <[e-mail]>wrote:
Hi Eric,
Hope you are well and enjoying this last bit of summer.
We received the 15 Prince works today =:J can you please forward me a list so we can match.the RPS numbers for our
records?
Best regards,
Anita Foden

Anita Foden
Gagosian Gallery
980 Madison Avenue
New York, NY 10021

GGP004075

CONFIDENTIAL

GG010036

A-380

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-43

From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:

Filed 05/18/10 Page 2 of 7

Karen Ho <[e-mail]>
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 12:5 I PM
Vanessa Riding <[e-mail]>; Rysia Murphy <[e-mail]>
FW:

One more for Victoria's list.
----Original Mes~age---­

From: Victoria Gelfand
Sent: Tuesday, October 28, 2008 12:50 PM
To: KarenHo
Subject: Re:

I need to add Redacted

I

to list

---- Original Message -----

From: Karen Ho
To: Victoria Gelfand
Sent: Tue Oct 28 16:45:03 2008
Subject: RE:

j

Hi Victoria,

As per LO, he needs to approve everyo~ we are inviting to the Prince dinner. I have sent it on to Vanessa and Rysia and they wililel
me know as soon as he gives the okay.
Sorry for the delay. I will email you as soon as I know.

----Original Message---From: Victoria Gelfand
Sent: Tuesday, October 28, 2008 12:40 PM
To: KarenHo
Subject:

Dear Karen
PIs email me prirlce dinner invite. Have you invited all the people val sent you from my side? .
Hciw are we doing with numbers? Could I add a couple more? Will it be separate tables?
Thanks

GGP003313

CONFIDENTIAL

A-381

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-43

From:

Sent:
To:
Subject:

Karen Ho <[e-mail]>
Tuesday, October 28, 2008 2:24 PM
Vanessa Riding <[e-mail]>; Rysia Murphy
<[e-mail]>
Prince invites

Candy would like to inviteRedacted
and Redacted
they will come. Please have LG approve.

GGP003316

Filed 05/18/10 Page 3 of 7

Both are LA-based so she thinks it is unlikely that

CONFIDENTIAL

A-382

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-43

From:

Sent:
To:
Subject:

Vanessa Riding
Thursday, October 30,200& 10:19 AM
Rysia Murphy <!)'[e-mail]>; Karen Ho <[e-mail]>
RE: VG Richard Prince invitees

----Original Message----

From: Rysia MllIJlhy
S~I:

Tuesday, O(;lober 28, 2008 10:51 AM

To: Vanessa Riding
Subject FW: VG Richard Prince invitees

-----Original Message----From: Rysia MllIJlhy
Sent: Tuesday, October 28, 2008 10:50 AM

To: Vanessa Riding
SUbject VO Richard Prince invitees
This list is fine. I took off the names that LG said no to.

Redacted

GGP003322

Filed 05/18/10 Page 4 of 7

CONFIDENTIAL

A-383

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-43

From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:

Filed 05/18/10 Page 5 of 7

Karen Ho <[e-mail]>
Tuesday, November 4,20083:50 PM
Rysia Murphy <[e-mail]>; Vanessa Riding <[e-mail]>

FW: For LG to check for Prince opening and dinner

These people were on theRed~a~ed
I committee for Prince. I have deleted names of people we have already invited.
Please ask LG if he would like any of these people invited.

From: Louise Neri

Sent: Tuesdav, November 04, 2008 3:46 PM
To: Karen Ho
Subject: For -LG to check for Prince opening and dinner
Hi KarenObviously many of these people are already on our invitation list. I have deleted
Guggneheim's original list.
Richard Prince: Redacted

Redacted

GGP003355

CONFIDENTIAL

Redact

and

Redact from the

A-384

Case 1:08-cv-11327 -DAB Document 54-43

From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Attach:

« ... »

Filed 05/18/10 Page 6 of 7

Rysia Murphy
Wednesday. November 5, 2008 10:22 AM

Olivia Byron <[e-mail]>
Prince Dinner Invite

RP.pdf

Olivia,

Attached is the invite. Please just make sure it is not sent to anyone that has not been approved by LG as he his being very

strict about this dinner.
Let me know if you need anything else~
Rysia

GGP003375

CONFIDENTIAL

A-385

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-43

From:
Sent:
To:
Subject:
Attach:

. I

Filed 05/18/10 Page 7 of 7

Rysia Murphy
Saturday, November 8,2008 12:25 PM
Victoria Gelfand <[e-mail]>
FW: Prince dinner list
Prince dinner.doc

Victoria,
Attached is the most up to date dinner list. As you know LG has been super intense about whose invited etc. so
please don't show the list to anyone etc. And of course, if you have any additions they have to be cleared by LG.
Let Karen or me know if you have any questions I
Also, there are some new changes that haven't been added to the attached list but it's pretty close 10 correct.
ThanKs,
Rysia

GGP003498

CONFIDENTIAL

A-386

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-44

From:
Sent:
To:

Cc:
Subject:

Filed 05/18/10 Page 2 of 2

Meredith Dunn <[e-mail]>
Thursday, October 23, 200B 10:29 AM
Sam Orlofsky <[e-mail]>; Rebecca Sternthal <[e-mail]>;
Stefan Ratibor <[e-mail]>; Valentina Castellani
<[e-mail]>; Victoria Gelfand <victoria@gagosiancom>; John
Richardson <[e-mail]>; Deborah McLeod
<[e-mail]>; Candy Coleman <[e-mail]>; Lauren
McCaffrey <[e-mail]>; Domenica Stagno <[e-mail]>;
Andrea Crane <[e-mail]>; Karen Ho <[e-mail]>; Melissa
Lazarov <[e-mail]>; Ealan Wingate <[e-mail]>
Vanessa Riding <[e-mail]>; Rysia Murphy <[e-mail]>
Prince in Chelsea

LaITY would like the opening and dinnel' to be "kick ass' so please invite celebritiesimomalgugglwhitIley curators and other clients
who will BUY his work. However, do not invite someone unless you confirm this with Vanessa, Ryscha, or Karen.
Vanessa has the list of people from Lany so far so feel free to touch base with her.
Many thanks,
Meredith
DETAlLSOpening is all Saturday November 8th at 24th St.
Dinner to follow at
Gramercy Pari< Hotel
Sent via BlackBerry by AT&T

GGP003205

CONFIDENTIAL

A-387

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-45

From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:

Filed 05/18/10 Page 2 of 2

Vanessa Riding
Thursday, October 23,20082:29 PM
Barbara Wilhelm Dwek <[e-mail]>
Karen Ho <[e-mail]>

RE: prince dinner

Before Larry approves this list he would like to know if you have sold any art to these people. If so, he· would like
to see proof.

From: Melissa i.azarov
Sent: Thursday, October 23, 2008 1:53 PM
To: IQlren Ho
Cc: Vanessa Riding; Rysia Murphy
Subject: Rf: prince dinner
will you run these names by Ig for approval

From: Karen Ho
Sent: Thursday, October 23, 2008 1:51 PM
To: Melissa Lazarov
Subject: FW: prince dinner
These are the people Barbara wants to invite to the dinner alter receiving LG's email. Yes or no?

From: Barbara Wilhelm Dwek
Sent: Thursday, October 23,2008 1:50 PM
To: Karen Ho
Subject: prince dinner

Redacted
BARBARA WILHELM DWEK
Gagosian Gallery

555 West 24 Street
New York, New York, 10011

tel [phone]
falC [phone]
ce II +1 917 257 91.33

.~.
GGP003694

CONFIDENTIAL

A-388

Case 1 :08-cv-11327~DAB Document 54-46

Filed 05/18/10

Richard Ponce
November 8, 2008
Gramercy Park Hotel
l.ASTNAME
Abramovlch and Dasha Zhukova
Ames
Anderson
Andich
Arabov
Armstroll2
Amault
Arslanian and Cecile
Ash /lnd Peter Ezersky'
Atencio Demirdjian
Aven
Avini
Balbakov
.Baron ................ - .... . ...... ,

TITLE

Mr.
Mr.

.. ,
'.~

..........
~-

..

~

.. ...

~-.~,.: ~

"'-'---

M£'.

Mt. and Mrs.
Mt.and Mrs.

Mr. and Mrs.
Mr. and Mrs.

Mr.

Mr. and Mrs.

""

FIRSTNAME
Roman
Ann and Steven
Pamela
Lidia
Jacob and Angela
Richard
Bernard
Ara
Lorinda
Tiqul
Peter
Andy
Maria
... .. ·Fablen .. · .. .. -.

... · Basilico._~_."_. __........_.... _ _ "....... ".......".... "'".''''''"'' Stefano" .....
.
.......... .......

Bauer and ]emilab Afshar
Baybakovand Lena
Belchanskaya
Bell
Berger
Berggruen
Bernardi
Beyer
Biesenbach
Biscone and Rob Currie
Black
Blair
Blavatnik
Bono and All Hewson
Bowes
Brant
Breus
Broad
Brown and NicolaI Ouroussoff
Brown and John Melick
Bullock
Bundchen and Tom Brady
Bush
Bush
Busson
BurJ!ess
Bushnell
Butler and David Schafer
Butler
Calicchio
Carmignac
Carter
Carter and Beyonce Knowles
Casdin
Castellani
Catone
Chatila
Chebotarev

"~

OIl!g

Marianna
William and Maria
Karen and Martin
Nicolas
David
Michele
Kiauz;
Betsy
Leon
Dike
Len
Frances
Peter
Shalva
Eli

Cealy
Eric
Janna
Gisele
Barbara
Lauren
Arid
Rupert
Candace
Cornelia
Gerry
Denise LeFrak
Edouard
Sean
Alex
Valentina
Gabriel
Abdallah
Leeza

NUMBER

LN

RP
LG
VG
LG
RP
LG
ML
VG
VG

2

2
2
1

GG
VG

. ...

1
1

.. · .. , ..... . ....
l.G/SQ.····· .. · .····_M.·M"·······M.. "_......
2
ML·
2
LG

.. . ·RP

....-,.. ... ,,.... ,...... ,.- ......-..-.

Sasha

Graydon

STAFF
LG

_

VG
LG/RP
LN

LG

0
0

CC
LN

RP

2

LG

RP
LG
LG
RV
LG
YG
LG
LG/RP

RP

2
2
0
2

LN

LG
LG/ND
LG/ND
YG
LG

LG
RD

0

YG

LN
VG
LG
LG
VG
GG
VG
VG
GG

0

1
1
0

CONFIDENTIAL - PR00045

A-389

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-46

Filed 05/18/10 Page 3 of 8

Richard Prince

November 8, 2008
Gramercy Park Hotel
TITLE

FIRSTNAME
LASTNAME
Shalva
Chiltirinsky
'.
Helena
Christiansen
Pietro
CicoMani
Ella
Cisneros
Coca Moroder
Boria
Cohen
Adam
Lvor
Cohen and \Nest
Cohen
PIDDa
Mr. and Mrs. Cohen
Steven
Mr.
Bob
Colacello
Candv
Coleman
Dan
Colen
Sofia
COD.OOIa
. . PhiliDDe ." . .....
... ... " .................. ...Co.steletos........... . ....... ... . ..... ...
... " ..
...........
.....
Craiijl········ ", ...............
'Aiidrea:' ..
..................... " .•..... .. _ .. ·Ci"iiz.. · .. ·······. , .. ·..·.. ···,.. ···'''··.. ··· .. ···· ............ .'._." .. .... -._--,'- 'Penelo'pe' ..... ......
....
~

~

"

'

Currin and Ms. RacheJ Feinstein
Dafoe
DalrvrnDle
David
de Kooninlt
Ms.
De Niro and Grace Hightower
DeSalvo
Mr. and Mrs. Dean
Mr.
Del Rosclo
Dellal
Dellal
Mr. and Mrs. Delsener
. DemarcheJier
Mr.
Dent-Brocklehurst and Duncan Ward
Denuccio
DeDD and Vanessa Paradis
DICanrio and Ruest
Di Fabio
D'Ofa2io
Dornnin
Dourdan
Downey Jr.
Mr.

Dunn

Eberle and Richard Pandiscio
Edlis & Ms. Gael Neeson
Mr.
Einarsson
Mr.
E1derfield
Evans
FakhoulY
Fa1ckenberg
Fertitta
Mr. and Mrs. Fertitta
Firyal
Princess
Fisch
Fischbach
Fischl and Apn1 Gornik
Florio

John
WUlem

Clarissa
Kristen
Lisa
Robert
Donna
Thompson
Nicola
AJex

Guv
Ron
Patrick
Mollie
Salvatore
lohnnv
Leonardo
Alberto
Sante
Vladislav

Can
Robert
Meredith
Todd
Stefan
GardarElne
John
Michael and Lise
Pierre
Harald
Frank

Lorenzo
Mark
Linda
Eric
Tom

NUMBER

STAFf'
VG
LG
VG
VG
VG
GG

1

RP

ML
LG/RP
LG

1

GG

1

SR
RP

O·

VG
CG·
Lt;
LG/RP
PMF
RP
NS

.'

0
2

0

LG

LG

1

LG

LG
LG

VG
VG
LG/RP
LG
LG
VG
LG
LG

2

2
2

AP

VG
LG
VG
CC
GG

1

LG

RP
VG
LG
LGIRP
LG
VG
LG
LG
VG
VG
LN
LG
VG

2
0

0

CONFIDENTIAL - PR00046

A-390

Case 1:08-cv-11321-DAB Document 54-46

Filed 05/18/10 Page 4 of 8

Richard Prince
November 8,2008
Gramercy Park Hotel
TITLE

Mr. and Mrs.

LASTNAME
Foster
Foster and Sandy Talt
Franchi
Francis
Franco and ~est
Franzen
Freedman
Fremont

Frev

FIRSTNAME
Carter
Hal
Pepi Marchetti
Mark
lames
lonathan
Denls
Vincent
James and Mava
Mikhail
Leonid
Glenn
Richard

Fridman
Friedland
Fuhrman
Furman
.. ........... ....... , ... .. Gagosian .. ....... .. ..... .. .... ... .... Lanv..... ..... . ....... ...
GaUa'gher and Edaar Clinic
Ellen
............. -......
.-'"
-Mf;;..· ...... ·····"'CalUpoli ..........-- .......-...
Frarik
Mr. and Mrs. Ganek
David
Ganek
ludie and Howard
GaribashYilf
lraldi
Garavan! and Giancarlo Giarnmetti
Valentino
Ramiro and Gabriela
Garza
Gaydamak
Katla
Victoria
Gelfand
AlisonM.
Gingeras and Piotr Uklanski
Ms.
Massimiliano
Gioni
Gluckman and Ms. Tiffany Bell
Richard
Mr.
Gal
Ishala
Good
John
Gonzalez
Manuel
Gordeev
Se~i
Gordon and Thurston Moore
Kim
Mr. and Ms.
Gottesman
Noam
Graff
Laurence
Grant
Hueh
Grazer
Brian
Greenbel'}t-Rohatyn.and Nicholas Rohatvn Jeanne
Grotiahn and Jennifer Guidi
Mark
Guod and Nr. Daniel Shapiro
Ms.
Ames
Halbreich
Kathy
Ms.
Hammerstein
Simon
Hanson
Dian
Harland
Chris
Harris
Naomi
Harris
Nicki
Hartnett
Josh
Hearst
Amanda
Hearst and lay Mdnerney
Anne
Mr_
Heller and guest
Sanford
Hilton
Nikki
Hilton
Paris
Hirst & Maia Nonnan
Damien
Hoffman
Hannah
Philip Seymour
Holfman and Mimi O'Donnell

STAFF
RD

NUMBER
1

MF
GG
GG
LG
LG
RP
LG

2
1
1

LG/RP
LG

5

0
2

VG
VG
VG
.GG......... Z. ... , ..
2.
BM.

'RP

LG/RP
LN
VG
LG
LG
VG
GG
LGiRP
VG
LG
VG
GG
LN
VG
RP
LG
VG
RP

2

LG/CC

0

RP

2
0

LG
LG
LG
VG

1
2
0
1

2

0

0
0

RP

1

VG
RP
LN

1

LG
MD/LG
MO/LG
LG
LG
LG

1
0

LG/RP
DS
LG

CONFIDENTIAL - PROOQ44

A-391

Case 1:08-cv-11327 -DAB Document 54-46

Filed 05/18/10 Page 5 of 8

Richard Prince
November 8, 2008
Gramercy Park Hotel

TITLE
Mr. and Mrs.

LASTNAME
Holm
Holzer
Mr. & Mrs.
Hopper
Hotimskv
Hurst
Hutton
lies
Iseman and SVitlana Nesterova.
Jacobs
Jagger and LWren SCOtt
Jimenez
Ioannou
Mr.
Johns
.. .... . .......... ... .Johanssen and·RyanReynDlds . ... . ......
.·Johnson· ...
-_ .....
...... .................
........ '.··"n ... ' .................
·101ieanCl-BradPitf
Kanders
Kelsey
Kledls
Koons and lustine Wheeler
KrakoR'

Mr. and Mrs.

Kravis

Kydd
LaSIY
Lauren
Lazarov
Lee
Lehmann
LePalre
Uchtensteln
Liebennan
Undell

Mrs.

Lis

Mr.

Loeb
Lo~heed and

. AjJgeiiiia·

Warren and Allison
Kristle

KaJlg
Karpldas

Mr.

FIRSTNAME
Stellan
jane
Dennis
Isabelle
Fern
Lauren
Chrissie
Fred
Marc
Mick
Carmen
Dakis
Jasper
. Scarlett·· , - , . ..... -,. Nadine .....

Aaron Fleischmann

Pauline
John
Anthony
Jeff
Reed
He'!!)l_
Johnnie Shand
David and Evelyn
Dylan
Melissa
Heidi
Rachel and lean-Pierre
Cecile
Dorothy
Les
John
HaTIY
Daniel
Lin

Lowman
..

Nate

~

Glenn
Phyllis
Sondra
Harry and Linda
IDle
Tobey
Maureen
Bob
Brice
Donald
Patricia
Steve and Ann
David
John
Paul

Mack
Mack
Macklowe
MacPherson
Maguire and len Meyer
Mahoney
Manoukain
Mr. and Mrs. Marden
Mr. and Mrs. Marron
Marshall
Martin
Mr.
Martinez
Mayer
Sir
McCartney

STAFF

LG/RP
AA
L<i
LN
LN

CC

NUMBER
2
2

0

LG
L<i
L<i/RP
L<i
LN

2

LN

LG
,-

... ·LG·

0

.... . ,.. .. ...

LG

1

LG
LGLSO
VG
RP
VG

1

RP/LG

LG/RP

2

VG
LG
RP
RP
LG/MD
GG
VG
LN
GG
LG
VG
VG
VG

0
0
0
2
4

2
1

2

LG
LN

2

LG/SR
LG
LN
LN
LG
RP

1
0

0
0

LG/RP
ML
LG
LG

0
0

LG

0

MD/LG
LG
LG
RP
RP

1

CONFIDENTIAL - PR00047

A-392

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-46

Filed 05/18/10 Page 6 of 8

Richard Prince
November 8. 2008
Gramercy Park Hotel

TITLE

Mr.

Mr. and Mrs.
Mr.

Mr.
..

~

LASTNAME
McEwen
McLaren and Yuung Kim
McWhinnie and Maria Beaulieu
Meier
Mellon and Christian Slater
Mendez
Meyer
Michaels
Minskolf
Moore
Monk
Morton
Moss
Muxrabi

--_....-.................... .... ...MllrakamL........."................."."................. .. ........ ~

Neri
Mr. & Mrs.
Newhouse, Jr.
Mr. and Mrs. Niarchos
Niarchos
O'Brien
Mr. & Mrs.
Obrist
Older
Olsen
Olsen
Orlofskv
Otto
Otto-Bernstein
Mr. and Mrs. Ovitt
Paltrow and Chris Martin
Mr.
Parr and Allison Sarofim
Mr.
Perelman
Peters
Petzel
Peyton
Peyton-Jones
Phelan
Ms.
Phillips and Mr. Leon Falk
Phillips and Josephine Mec::kseper
Picasso
Picasso and Gilles Bensimon
Mr.
Pig!Jzzi
Pilati
M. etMme.
Pinault
Pinchuk
Pissarro
Pivovarov
Poehler and Will Arnett
Polley
Portman
Ms.
Prather
Prince
ROIcbofsky
Rales

F1RSTNAME
Adam
Malcolm
lohn
Richard
Tamara

STAFF
LG

0

RP
LG

2

LG
VG
LG
16
VG
GG
LG
RP
LG/RP
.... .r<i\~s.4.i... ..........................___......... __". . "..... ,...t,~.,.,.,...c., "'__"
..
Louise
GG
S.!.
LG
Philip
LG.lRP
.
Stavros
LG
Glenn
RP
Hans-Ulrich
16
David
VG
Ashley
RP
LG/SR
Mary-Kate
GG
Sam
Karla
LN
K3tharin3
LN
RP
Michael
Gwyneth
LG
Stuart
I.G
RonaldO.
LG
VG
Tara
RP
Friedrich
Elizabeth
LGLRP
LG
Julia
VG
John
Usa
LG/RP
I.G
Richard
Oaude
LG
Diana
LG
LG.lRP
Jean
LN
Stefano
LGJRP
Francois
Victor and Elena
LG
VG
Joachim
VG
Slava
Ron
Loroe
Edward and lulie
Frank
Bob
Peter
Kate
Alberto

._-

1

LG

Bva

"-,

NUMBER

RP

Amy

2
2
1

..........

........... _
.........

1

2
0

1
1

1

2
1
1

0

2
2
0

.
1

as

Doug
Natalie
Marla
Richard
Howard and Cindy
Mitch and Emily

1
0

VG
LG
I.G

GG
RV

0

2

LG

2

CONFIDENTIAL - PR00048

A-393

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-46

Filed 05/18/10 Page 7 of 8

Richard Prince
November 8, 2008
Gramercy Park Hotel
TITLE
Mr.

Mr. and Mrs.

Mr. and Mrs.
Mr. and Mrs.

"

. Mr.
·Mr."""""·

""LOrd' ...

. . . .. "
~

Mr.

Mr.

Mr.

LASTNAME
Ratner
Rav
Reeves
Refltenbagh
Reuben
Reuben
Reyle and AureUa Sellin
Richardson
Richardson. len Brill: land Arty Nelson
'.
Rlru!:lo
RinJZier
Robins
Rose and Ms. Amanda Burden
. .... ,.
'Rosenand'Samantha'BoaTdman' .
..
..
Ross
Rothschild and MiraridiiBrooks
Rothschild
:
Rower
Rubell
Rubenstein and llIle5t
Rubin and Steohane Samuel
Ruscha
Ruth
Sachs
Sal!:ona
Saplrstein
Sarkozv
Saxe-Coburl!:
Scarpetta
Scheinfeld
Schiff
Schorr and Monica Condrea
Schwab
Schwartzman
Sednaoul
Seguin
Semel
Semerskv
Serra & Clara Weyergraf-Serra
Shalrazi
Shaye
Shields
Silver
Simon and lake Paltrow
Simunovic
Sinl1:h
Smith and Jerry SaJt%

Mr. and Mrs.

Soros

Ms.

Spector and Michael Gabellini
Stemtbal
Stoclonan
Sugimoto
Sussman

FIRSTNAME
Brett
Charles
Keanu
Marlies and Jacco
Simon
Lisa
Anselm
Andrew
Terry
Leonard
Michael
Crall!:
Charlie
'Abv' .......... .... ..

STAFF

NUMBER

LG
LG

C(/SR
ACrane

0

LG
LG
LG

1
1

LN

RP

3
0
0
0

LG

RP
VG
'

....

LG

.. 'LG/RP' .... ..........

Lvn'

!:.N'

lacob
Nathaniel
Sandy
Don and Mera
Inga
Robert
Ed and Danna
Andrew
Richard
Marina
Fred
Charlotte and Olivier

LG
LG
LG

Rosario
Lillv
lane
Lisa
Collier
Katie
Allan
Elisa
Laurence et Patrick
Terry and lane

Emie& Dorv
Richard
Tony
Robert and Eva
Brooke
loel
Tarvn
Nick
Ranbir
Roberta
Georges
Nancy
Rebecca
Jennifer
Hiroshi
Elizabeth

2

LN
VG
RP

2
2
0

CC
VG
LG·
LG
VG
LG

1
2
1

RP
LN
LN

VG
2

RP
RV

RV
LG

LGIRP
LG
LG
LG
RP

2
0
0
1

LG
LG
VG

LC
GG
VG

1

LG
LG
RP
GG
RP

0
2
1

ElW
LG

CONFIDENTIAL - PR00049

A-394

Richard Prince
November B. 2008
Gramercy Park Hotel
TITLE

LASTNAME
Tananbaum
Mr. and Mrs. Taschen
Mr.
Teller and Ms. Sadie Coles
Ms.
Temkin
Tennant
,
Tlnterow
,
Traisman
Ms.
TurlingtOn and Ed B~ms
TwombJy
Van De Mel Tcheng
VandeWeghe
. - ..... , ............... ...... "Vsl"shlnsky"
.. ...... ... - ........... ...
.
·Ms.····· ...... ,·· .. Vogel ......... . .... .. .... .... .....
.....
.. 'Vousden'
-Wllde·"-'··~-·-····· ...... _ .. __ ....... ..._._,_", __ .... ____ •__ .. .....
Wakefield
Watts and Live Schreiber
Wechsler
Weinberll
Mr
WeiDll:arten
Mr. and Mrs. Weinstein
Weiss
West
Westreich and Ethan Wamer
Williams
M. ...... ____ " ... , ._._. __ ___
~

.~_.'

~_._

Wingate

Ms.

Wintour
Wool and Charlene von Heyl
Young and Alexia Niedzielski
Young

MSo

Young
Zahm
Zellweger

Zits

K~.".

NUMBER
LG
RP
RP
1
LG
RP
LG
GalY
VG
Yurt
Chrtsty
LG
Soledad Alessandro
PMF
Helen
RP
0
Christophe and Anne-GaeDe RP
·Mikhail··· . ...... " ................... ·VG···· ..... .......... ...
. . . . . . ·LG
- ....
,Carol·
1
. Robin'
1
GG
....•.
··Garolyn··_····_······_······_····· _ _ - .,-bN...._ "- ..
......... ..•..
Neville
RP
0
Naomi
ACrane
2
Nick
LG
Adam
LG
Andrew
VG
Harvey
LG
LG
Jeffrey
Kanye
LG
0
AA
Thea
LG
Pharrell
2
GG
Balan and Melinda
LG
Anna
LG/RP
Christopher
SR
Aaron
'M
1
Michael
1
AA
Neda
RP
Olivier
LG
Renee
LG
2
Carmen
F1RSTNAME
Steven and Usa
Benedikt
furgen
Ann
Stella

STAFF

CONFIDENTIAL - PROOOSO

A-395

.... C~se 1:08-cv:11327-DAB

Document 54-47

Schnader

140 BR.OAD""""'!

:~.

'",

":;:.,:
..- ".~-:.'

.

:,:'

SUIT!' .1100

10005·1101
·2·12.97L·80·OO·: FAX 21'2.972,'8798
NEW YORK. Ny

·,: .. ·./:.,.:.,A:T.TOR.NEY S AT LAW

.....:

Filed 05/18/10 Page 2 of 3

schn'ader,c'om

Decem:ber 11,~008

',-

-.'-,'

",

"

~

.

"il~p~~ri~P.ip;ij#'L,..

. ,.. ..'

. ·'RET{jRN":}Ul~eEIP'.f.i.tEQUES'f'Ef}··

A:TllIfBYfiANjj'·filti.fvERY

. . .'Mf;.iri6hat,t'tPrill~.
. .::·A5r~ghtet·~~a:..

»t~~Z1601i
..;naC:~D

,., ..

':Reiis§ela:¢ryiHe;Ne~ York 12147
.~ '-

,:;

.

.

,

. .... ,_.:
'

-:;~..

"

.;;.

.

.':'~31r.fu[~tW~t:~hlbii~~~6hs

·~~<!tI~~~f~~?jf~~~iJldor

.

··]),efuaiid.toCeas·e aridDis~Ur:6IiiU~authbtit~d'tJse·.Exhlbitioi1 and'
.....
..
:'-'"
...... .........:: .
. ....
,

.. Re:'

~.

-.'

....

... :

-

'. 'Dislributiofiof Copy'nght~d·Wor.k··

.

'.

..-.

'.

"'OearSirs:

. "- . '-;""" -~.

:',:

..

,:

.

. . . . . . ~m~f~:~%~~;~n~;~~.~:~~~~~· .
•

• :",:.

."

,,<,

"

<.""'-,~,,,.

•

" _.. . " .
.... ",', ·.~.:i.·· .-.:.':- '~/.·" :'.;/;~': ~';'::';~.,~-' ~ ~::::: ,>
,
............ ..
·s;~j,:~::'~~-~.~~:~\tC;:ti·~:Tt.~~:;-~;~:·~~~:·i,; ~:',;~'~;rn:~~~'i~;;";"" .."''''/' . , "

, ••.•

~'.:.•,

!

.::

.

.,'

".~

:.,' , : : . ,

.

'<).:·X,-:",, . .

. • '. • ' - . '

,'

... ' .. : . ',.' .••.••

' . ' '.... ,.,. "

" . , ' ': I ' . : . .

.

•

. : .~, ..

~ :,

:,",-.:.:~:f~~i 'i!.b:"H,~.J:.sl ~·~~iIC:.;~~:tj.t(~~!L;".~:~~~i,~·Gj·~.~~,I~ .,.;.~~.~}L:~:~~~:~ ~.'~ j{~f~~~~~~:I:'~64~~I'
...

'''''''''.,'" •

.......•

-- .. -:

-.. _-.

C00013

A-396
: .•..... :

"':;:':-::. '-_.

":.

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-47

Filed 05/18/10 Page 3 of 3

S c h n ·ade r

.4.TTORNF.YS A1' LAW

,Wi·.·iU,thardpr;nce

,.:., .. ;.
... '
,':; .

;·.Gigo,siariC3~it~rY.· ,.. ..
lUZiOfi'iilieiilationlil PublicationS

;~~!~,~,~fll;' 7°98
.. ;':'.':':

::

...:.... ...,

..... ''J';, . .•'. :'~~~m~~1t~i~~t~jiy,'~detliaL~a~l(oft<>~t ..

"', ,'.. :' ~' ..... .' . "." '2:' I(emove atriUiiainnoiize<rrepf6a~ctionH)fMr.·Canolr's ~pyt1g'hta-d 'Wort<:
.
from Mr. Prince's artwork.
. . .
'

."

.•..:...

'.'~'.:4;·\,;~~~~~fJ~~f~~;ili~~~~~.~:~j~:~~~~~~~~G:w1.;ti~~~:o~(,·

".;':' ......

~~i~~t.A.j._I~~t
damages. ate '3.v&libie to ·oui";cl1ent.

.

VIe.r¢qti~~t:a· response from you or yourllttorneysnot ialertlUln 'Monday,

December'15 . . . ..
..
, ' .2008.···

i:

,
,

.

. .

:n;::u~

...: ·D#i.i~u~·Br.()dks

';.'

!

.. ~;

........" ,... .

. For SCHNADERHARR!SONSEGAL&;LEWIS LLP ,
.

,"':'

. ;."'

' .....'"..-... ~~..~.,~, ... -......?"........

'

..:

.-

..

...

.

'

.-"~,.,.,,"--<,,'-,, .... .;.,:»~- .........,.; •• ,";,. ""'~"'''''-'~''''''~'''~'~''''''''''''''--'''''''''

r~:

.

.. .. " _.. , ,. . .:' "h_'"
~'

.
'.'''~'

•.

.....
""'~""''''''''''''''''''''~'''''''

': .,'., _....".._, .•. ".M .;""""....._...
..
~",

"",~..--'

••. .........' ...
~..,_

~'_

..._
......

.-_~

• ._" .......

r.~, .~ : •.

"

"','

.".

.....

:

..

.-

,~

.............-. ..
"

ii'

~

..

":

e.

C00014

A-397

Case 1:08-cv-11327-DAB Document 54-48

Filed 05/18/10 Page 2 of 4

~GEOTEXT

'/___

Translations. Inc.

STATE OF NEW YORK
ss
COUNTY OF NEW YORK

CERTIFICATION

This is to certify that the attached translation is, to the best of my knowledge and belief, a true
and accurate translation from French into English of the attached page with Bates No.C00088.

~
Geotext Translations, Inc.

Sworn to and subscribed before me

--'-"~~_' 20~.

NOTARY PUBLIC-STATE OF NEW YORK
No. OlEV6201257
Qualified In Queens County
My Commission Expires February 17.2013

New York 259 West 30th Street. 17th Floor, New York. NY 10001. U.S.A. 1:eI212.631.7432 fax [phone]
S .. n Francisco 220 Montgomery Street. 3rd Floor, San Francisco. CA 94104. U.S.A. tel 410.576,9500 fax [phone]
London 107-111 Fleet Street. London EC4A 2AB. United Kingdom ~el +44.(0)20.7936.9002 fax +44.(0)20,7990.9909
Hong Kong 20th Floor, Central Tower, 28 Queen's Road, Central. Hang Kong tel [phone] fax [phone]
[e-mail] I www.geoleXt.com

A-398

Case 1:08-cv-11327 -DAB Document 54-48

Filed 05/18/10 Page 3 of 4

From: • Patrick Cariou" <[e-mail]>
Subject: Re: An exhibit in New York City
Date: August 28, 2008 11 :25:52 AM EDT
To: ·christiane celie" <[e-mail]>
Hello Christiane,
Thank you very much for your interest in my work.

Of course, I know all the people that you mentioned in your email.
I do not have a gallery, and I would be interested in an exhibit.
The book Surfer, which has been out of print for some time, is going to be republished this year.
I also have another book, on gypsies, that I just finished after ten [years) of work.
Perhaps that will interest you.
Best,
Patrick
CELL PHONE NO. IN PARIS 0033632417641

812812008 Christiane Celie <[e-mail]>
Hello Patrick,
My name is Christiane Celie. We have never met, but I am familiar with your photographs.
I have been living in New York City for 20 years, residing for some years in SI. Barth, where I started a
store, CALYPSO.
Then I met Antoine Verglas, who is a photographer-perhaps you know him.
We have 2 children ages 14 and 12 years old, and have been living together in New York City ever since.
I created Calypso in 1992 in St. Barth, and I sold it in 2007.
I decided to change hats and open a gallery in New York City.
The first show will be in November. You can look for it online at www.vincentfournier.com. He has an
exhibit right now at Acte 2 in Paris and [will have] one in Tokyo in October.

Would you be interested in discussing the possibility of an exhibit in New York City?
I also have a gallery that is opening in Gustavia, SI. Barth, and I am starting with a show of the work of
Tony C., who is an unknown for you.
Tony worked with Peter Beard for years. Peter showed him how to do his diaries,
and Tony makes prints from those diaries.
The theme is surfing, as he has almost 60 [prints of surfing], and in May, he was a longboard champion.
I also thought that I could do an exhibit showing Tony's work and some of your surfing photos as well.
Finally, I wanted to know if you would be interested or if you have an exclusive relationship with someone:

I also know Thierry Des Fontaines, who was your assistant for a short time.
He is living in Brazil now, but he has a website that you should look at.
It is devoted to sports.
Thierry was my boyfriend in NYC for a few years.
That's it!
If you can give me a telephone number, I would be pleased to give you a call.
Christiane

CiS)

IT EXHIBIT_1_
Deponent CELLE
Date 1126110 Rptr. [initials)
WWW.DEPOBOOK.COM

C00088

A-399

Case 1:08-cv-11327 -DAB Document 54-48

, - - . - - - - - - - - - - - - _...••-

..

Filed 05/18/10 Page 4 of 4

_ __...•.....
...

From: ·Patrfck Carlou' <p&[e-mail]>

una

SubJwI: RBI
expD B n)'l>
Dille: August 211. 2008 11:25:52 AM EDT
To: 'christiane cells" <chrlstianecelleOIlOI.COfl1>o
Bonjour; Clvfs1l8l'18

Motel beauaoup pour 1.lnld~ que III pIlIIe a mDn travail

ilion .Or Je connaiS tcus '" gens que tu 01\88 dllrnl ton rnal
Je nale pas de gaNeryet)e sera! in~_ par una GJCPD
La livID IIUI!W qui est 6pUlS!! depUis I.ngtomps va lire I9J11Jbll' cella anntIe

Ja aU1III1 un IlII!rv lIVre que·ju Wens de IInIr apr~ dlx d. travail su, I~ gftans

all peu\ etne I. Int'res••ra
tJe$I

pOlek
N' CELL IN PARIS 00381132417641

200818126 c:MsUane Cilia <e!JJ!sI!an.cal!l!@gDlcom'>

; :

i IxmjaUr PalIIcIc •

IIe sLb 0MsII_ c:elIa.noue

De 1lDU81O_lamals IIlRcontrn maIs ,. tannais 1$$ photos.
..
villa nyc ~ 20ana _lin aejGur dlt quelques _as 8 61 barIh ou;'111 commence 1Dl8 cia CALYPSO
ensulle I8fICCII1Ir8 Anldne Verglas qut _ phoIognlphv at que IU corInals peul atre
.
I now 2 al1liitU 14 8112 _ ell1IXI8 vlvans IIISIIIII!lIe II. nyc daprAa

Ie
I
I""

i

.,i.., caIPID en 1992 ~ st istt, 8\ ja I,a! wnclr 3J07
J I.af dedde era chilnger ~ at d,ouvrlr Unit 91larie ri nyc
.
lie pmmlar sIlIIW ....... denoYIIII1bre 1Ir peux f89M1at onlIne wwwy!nCllmtqymjarcom n a un& expo malrdenanll:hoz me 2 a par.;lot una a
: takya lit octdJfe
GIl

ClUe

1If1

!

!lII!lIIIs III intvressa de dIa:uIar

Im8

pasIIIbIIlre Cl,1IOCJIO a I1)IC

II..' IIIIIIII unG IJIIIIar)' qUi OIMII agustalla. eb8I1h &1 Ie commenca _

till sIII>W de tony DqUl 8111 Jnconnu pDUr Id

, Iony IlIraYillie - peter beard penedllnl dn - - pDterlll a mantra conmentlalre _
I et ICIny fall dt8 pIfnIs de aaalllarfes

dillies·
.
lie l/tIrIJe eetle 8UIf oar I e ~ 80 and mal .8.1111 c:h!lmpl0IT de ran" baarcI
",., pansa . . ., qua Ie PQUmIft faiN lII1a"l'lI en mCllllranlIGny at CBllaines de \EI8 photos de 81rf _ I .

.:.:;.

IB~n

Ie VDlfIalS savelr SItu aUIis ~

01/" III ;mQ URII 8lIdIA:IvIIu IMID quelqU,UR

i

I

Ie COIIIUlIflUS&llhleny des IunIaInee qu/I,a _bID pendant l1li pell! moment
, b vlliu bresil malntenlll1ll1 II un ale til Ct1IIIIlS I8QMIer
I ...eat COII8IICI8 auxspoll

I

j thlamy elBIt moo boytdend
I voila

!

!ctvIs1iWl8

:)."

':',

8

nyg pe/IIIanI qUIIlquallllMeae

slW pet.OC me dorIoer l1li numero de tel Ie

aer. RIYflI da Ie lelephansr

COOOB8

A-400

Case 1:08-cv-11327 -DAB Document 36

Filed 05/14/10 Page 1 of 3

Daniel J. Brooks
Eric A. Boden
SCHNADER HARRISON SEGAL & LEWIS LLP
140 Broadway, Suite 3100
New York, New York 10005-1101
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: [phone]

Attorneys for PlaintiffPatrick Cariou
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK

-------------------------------------------------------------x
PATRICK CARIOU,
Plaintiff,
08 Civ.11327 (DAB)
-againstRICHARD PRINCE, GAGOSIAN GALLERY,
INC., LAWRENCE GAGOSIAN and
RIZZOLI INTERNATIONAL
PUBLICATIONS, INC.,

DECLARATION OF
ERIC DOERINGER

Defendants.
--------------------------------------------------------------x

ERIC DOERINGER, under the penalty of perjury, states as follows:
1.

Since graduating from Brown University in 1996, I have pursued a living

as a visual artist. I submit this declaration, based upon personal knowledge, in support of the
motion of plaintiff Patrick Cariou for summary judgment against the defendants Richard Prince,
Gagosian Gallery, Inc. ("Gagosian Gallery"), and Lawrence Gagosian.
2.

Beginning in 2001, as part of my Bootleg project, I appropriated images

derived from the paintings of various contemporary artists, including John Currin, and
incorporated those images into new artworks, which I created.

A-401

Case 1:08-cv-11327 -DAB Document 36

3.

Filed 05/14/10 Page 2 of 3

I adapted and transformed the images which I appropriated from John

Currin, in the process creating new works of art that were mine. In doing so, it was my intention
to pay tribute to Mr. Cmrin and to his stature in the art world.
4.

The images I took from Mr. Cmrin's paintings were scanned from art

books or magazines, printed on a standard inkjet printer and then cut out by hand. To create the
Currin Bootlegs, I painted a background on a canvas, collaged the cutout print of the image onto
the canvas, and covered the entire canvas with a clear acrylic medium to create a brush stroke
texture simulating a hand-painted canvas. In doing so, I believed I was giving voice to a new
artistic expression, with a different feeling and message, and a new work of art, in a different
medium, that was uniquely mine. The use I made of Mr. Currin's imagery was within a long
tradition of appropriation art, in which Richard Prince figures prominently, which features the
artist's use of found objects and images created by others which are recontextualized into a new
work of art.
5.

On November 10,2005, I received, by registered mail, return receipt

requested, a letter from a law finn (Sidley Austin Brown & Wood LLP), stating that it
represented Gagosian Gallery which in turn represented John Currin. The letter demanded that I
immediately cease and desist from reproducing and selling unauthorized copies of Mr. Currin's
works and that I sign a copy of the letter in order "to warrant that you have, and will not at any
time in the future, distribute, prepare derivative works or reproduce copies of Mr. Currin's
works." The letter also warned me that the reproduction and sale of copies of Mr. Cmrin' s
paintings was a "willful violation of the Copyright Act, 17 U.S.C. §§ 101 et seq." I was
threatened with "an award of statutory damages of up to $150,000." The letter stressed that:
"Gagosian Gallery and Mr. Cmrin take violations of their rights very seriously and they intend to

2

A-402

Case 1:08-cv-11327 -DAB Document 36

Filed 05/14/10 Page 3 of 3

fully enforce their rights if you fail to comply with our demands." A copy of this letter is
attached hereto as Exhibit A.
6.

Feeling extremely intimidated, I wrote back immediately, noting that I

believed I was within my rights in creating artworks incorporating imagery derived from Mr.
Currin's paintings, but agreeing to stop selling the paintings. After expressing my admiration for
Mr. Currin, I did, however, ask for Mr. Currin's permission to reproduce images of my paintings
based upon his work in the documentation of my Bootleg project and to exhibit existing
paintings in non-commercial settings, for purely educational purposes and without offering the
paintings for sale. A copy of this letter is attached hereto as Exhibit B.
7.

On November 28, 2005, the Sidley firm replied, rejecting my request that I

be permitted to display my Currin works for non-commercial purposes, and reiterating that if I
reproduced and sold "copies of the works of John Currin and/or distribut[ed] derivative copies of
such works," I would be sued for copyright infringement. A copy of this letter is attached hereto
as Exhibit C.
8.

I complied with the Gagosian Gallery's threat and ceased displaying,

exhibiting and selling my Currin Bootlegs.
Pursuant to 28 U. s. C. § 1746, I declare under the penalty of perjury under the
laws of the United States of America that the foregoing is true and correct.
Executed on May 6, 2010, at Brooklyn, New York.

ERIC DOERINGER

3

A-403

Case 1:08-cv-11327 -DAB Document 36-2

Filed 05/14/10 Page 2 of 3

SiDLEY AUSTIN BROWN & WOOD
1':iI.JJn,jc

787

~

S~VENTt:I AVI,NUIl

NEW YORK, NItw YORK 10019
TiiLEPHONE .212 839 5300
FACSINlt;E1. 2.1,28395599'

lUf1lSSIl:LS

c·rUCI\G·Q

LU"
T-OS ,,r,t40:1!t..Ji:S
/IIlnv YOlK

www.sddl~,Gorn

SMANGJI....·

FOllNDED 1866

D ...
ot.LLAS

SINGAPOltX

MONa KON(;l

TOKYO

LI!>NtlOJ-f-

WASHIII'IGTON. D.C.

\1iI:ITiR'S . Ollfli·iCT Nt1.~IUR

WR1Tn'~ rH.lt.\IL ADI.lUS5
pt(lfi:!II,@~idlil'Y ,com

(212.) S39-73:S7

November 1O~ 2005
JYRegl$tcw~M3:tt,Re~n Reooipt Req.uested

Eric ·D.o.eritlger
S21 .Dean St.r #6
Btootdyn~ NY

11211-2134

Re:

J:Oh1lCpnin

Dear Mr. Doeringer:
W{f; rep.res.ent Gagos,ian GaUery which in tum represents the painter John emit.'!..
It has come: ti;)· the' attention orOagosian Gallery and Mr, Cu:rrinthatyou are reproducing and
seUingunanthorized copies of~. Currin's paintings including '~eUetiere" and "The Moved

Over Lady.n
The reproduooonand sale of copies of Mr. Currin'8 paintings constitutes a wiUful
violation of tbeOlpyrigttt. Act 17 U.S.C. §§ 101 et s.e.q. YOll should be aware that in sooh cases
the Act provides that the COpynghtowner rnaybe r;ntitled to an award ofstatutQrydamagesof
.up.:iQ $150,000.
w<;\~~,':w,~,_yd..~ 1hatyou immediately cease

and desist from reproducing. and seiling
't11Utlrthorlze<icopies QHhc'works'of Jtdm Gmrin: urcoon:ection-tlteretu-wc ask that-you 'sign and
return a copy of this letter by NQvem~er :'U, 20051 to walTant that you have} and will. n()t at allY
titn¢ in tbe future~ distrib.ut~ prepare derivative works or reproduce Copies QfMr. Currin's
works.
.

Gago$ian Gtkltery and, Mr. Currin take violations oftheir Fights very seriouSly and
they intend. to funyenforce their rights if you fail to comply with out demands.

A-404

o

Ct)

<D

C":)

en
«l
a..

o
.....

~

~

<D

"0

u:::
C\l

<b
Ct)
.....
.....
c::

Q}
<D

::J

E
E

g
g

o
o
III
III
I

«
«
o
o

('I)
C":)

I"I"C\J

I

.....
.......
..~
~

co
co

CD

.....
..-

en
en

co
B
()

SrDlBY AUSTIN B'HOWN &t WOOD
SIDtBY AUSTIN B'HOWN &t WOOD
Eric Doeringe-r
Eric Doeringe-r
November 10, .2005
November 10, .2005

Pa;ge 2
Page 2
~

lLLP'
lLtP·

tru.ly yours,
~~ ~~

,,':~.~~

~"""J'T
i-~. '.. 'Qren

NEW YOllK

~~

····· ...'
. '.
it . -J-----r.

".
. .. g................ _"L. .........1t..ii .~
.
"",,.t
•
.. ........
.•
N:OtmnglU this ~..mH~ 1...... 'cO'JlWn~ as a 'wmverof'. ,lDy n&.~ts orrem.edies
.
avai~abJe to 'Gagosian. Gallery and Mr. Curtin and they hereby expressly reserve their. rights ·~o
pursue any rigbtsor rettIlBdies availabile to·mem, under the law.

V ..._ ··~"~~;",,,c.·
~a" ~'1i1:

_~~~

A.~d"o· +
Agreed .to:. _~~~_______
·'r,..,.... ·· ,( ,
______

A-405

Case 1:08-cv-11327 -DAB Document 36-3

Filed 05/14/10 Page 2 of 2

A-406

B·EIJING

787 SIiVIi.NTH AVliNUIi

-'-,

Nnw YO[(K, NEW YORK 10019
Tm.Ef'HONE 212 839 5300
FACSIMILE 21.23395599

,

CHiQA:CO

Nf,W

YOR~

,AN I'R .... Ncrsco

w·.sldley.c:om

SHANGHA.I

FOUNDIlO 18'66

·DAUAS

SINGAPORE

Wl....

~eN£V:A

TOKYO

-'-'-

LONDON

W.'\:;IHNGTON, I}.C.

W'IHTIHt'S

w'tTnil'S l)%RECT N·U'l.tilllll:

(212) 33'9.1357

F.-~'A[!.. AI)M~I!S~

ptoten@s-ldlt'}'.cool.

Nov·ember 28. 2005
Regiite.-ed Mail, Retllrlll Reooi})t Requested
Bric Doeringer

521 Dean St., #6
Brooklyn, NY 11217-2134
lte:

lqlul Currin

Dear Mr. Doerin.ger:
1 write in response to. your letter in which you agreed that you would immediately
<:lease and desist from reproducing and seiling unauthorized: copies of the WQrks of John Currin
and frQm distributing derivative copies oi]l,ifr.Cumn's worb.· In return. fur this, Gagosi.a.n
Galleries agrees' not to bring' a copyright 4rliing~ment action. against you for the reproduction and'
sale ofsu.cbunauthQrized. works. fQI as long as you do no·' viotatetheterms· ofthis agreement To
the extent that you violate the tettns oftlUs agreement by reproducing and selling copies of the
works of John Currin and/()t distributing derivative copies ohuch wodes. Gagosian Galleries
shall have the right to temrlnate this agreement and may bring an action fur ~opyright
iJlQ.itt'~t'$~damages f'Or aU past infting:ements.

Aft-er duecons.i.deration. our client has reject your request tha.t you be permitted to
continue to reproduce images '4ofthe WQTks previously exeeu.ted for the. DOll-comlnercial
purposes of documenting my 'bootleg' painting project ... "

.>!(IUi;< ~I.5IDIIlI!()WJ""'WOOIl L1.J'6 .. U ••II1U!LI":UIl,.ftl' i'!d<TN~
Aumt-! ~PXl\"'N. " !<"(Qb ""II:ThlllRSIli~

1't:ACncfN(: \10: I\~A T!C(>Il\'l1'lf QI'I<I!R

srolEr