Reid v. Warrener et al

Filing 52

ORDER: The Court's working drafts of preliminary instructions, final instructions, and verdict forms are attached. Please study them. Be prepared at the 12 May 2014 pretrial to approve, object, and suggest changes as needed. The Court continues to wrestle with the substantive due process issues. Signed by Judge D. P. Marshall Jr. on 5/9/2014. (Attachments: # 1 Preliminary Instructions, # 2 Jury Instructions, # 3 Verdict Forms)(jak)

VERDICT NO. 1
1.

On Andrew Reid’s deliberate indifference claim against Mark Warner,
as submitted in Instruction No. 8, we find for:

________ Andrew Reid

________ Mark Warner

If you found for Reid on Question 1, then answer Question 2. If you found
for Warner on Question 1, your deliberations on this claim are done. Do not
answer Question 2 or Question 3.

2.

We find Andrew Reid’s compensatory damages against Mark
Warner to be $ _________
(state the amount, or if you find that Reid’s damages have no monetary
value, put $1.00).

If you found for Reid on Question 1, and awarded Reid compensatory
damages on Question 2, then answer Question 3.
3.

We

assess

punitive

damages

against

Mark

Warner

of

$________________ (state the amount, or, if none, write the word
“none”).
_________________________
Foreperson
Court’s Draft Verdict Forms 9 May 2014

______________________
Date
Reid v. Warner et al.
5:12-cv-338-DPM

VERDICT NO. 2
1.

On Andrew Reid’s deliberate indifference claim against Crystal Woods,

as submitted in Instruction No. 8, we find for:

________ Andrew Reid

________ Crystal Woods

If you found for Reid on Question 1, then answer Question 2. If you found
for Woods on Question 1, your deliberations on this claim are done. Do not
answer Question 2 or Question 3.

2.

We find Andrew Reid’s compensatory damages against Crystal
Woods to be $ _________
(state the amount, or if you find that Reid’s damages have no monetary
value, put $1.00).

If you found for Reid on Question 1, and awarded Reid compensatory
damages on Question 2, then answer Question 3.
3.

We

assess

punitive

damages

against

Crystal

Wood

of

$________________ (state the amount, or, if none, write the word
“none”).
_________________________
Foreperson
Court’s Draft Verdict Forms 9 May 2014

______________________
Date
Reid v. Warner et al.
5:12-cv-338-DPM

VERDICT NO. 3
1.

On Andrew Reid’s deliberate indifference claim against Vernon

Robertson, as submitted in Instruction No. 8, we find for:

________ Andrew Reid

________ Vernon Robertson

If you found for Reid on Question 1, then answer Question 2. If you found
for Robertson on Question 1, your deliberations on this claim are done. Do
not answer Question 2 or Question 3.

2.

We find Andrew Reid’s compensatory damages against Vernon
Robertson to be $ _________
(state the amount, or if you find that Reid’s damages have no monetary
value, put $1.00).

If you found for Reid on Question 1, and awarded Reid compensatory
damages on Question 2, then answer Question 3.
3.

We

assess

punitive

damages

against

Vernon

Robertson

of

$________________ (state the amount, or, if none, write the word
“none”).
_________________________
Foreperson
Court’s Draft Verdict Forms 9 May 2014

______________________
Date
Reid v. Warner et al.
5:12-cv-338-DPM

VERDICT NO. 4
1.

On Andrew Reid’s substantive due process claim against Mark Warner,
as submitted in Instruction No. 9, we find for:

________ Andrew Reid

________ Mark Warner

If you found for Reid on Question 1, then answer Question 2. If you found
for Warner on Question 1, your deliberations on Warner are done. Do not
answer Question 2 or Question 3.

2.

We find Andrew Reid’s compensatory damages against Mark Warner
to be $ _________
(state the amount, or if you find that Reid’s damages have no monetary
value, put $1.00).

If you found for Reid on Question 1, and awarded Reid compensatory
damages on Question 2, then answer Question 3.
3.

We assess punitive damages against Mark Warner of
$________________ (state the amount, or, if none, write the word
“none”).

_________________________
Court’s Draft Verdict Forms 9 May 2014

______________________
Reid v. Warner et al.
5:12-cv-338-DPM

Foreperson

Date
VERDICT NO. 5

1.

On Andrew Reid’s substantive due process claim against Crystal
Woods, as submitted in Instruction No. 9, we find for:

________ Andrew Reid

________ Crystal Woods

If you found for Reid on Question 1, then answer Question 2. If you found
for Woods on Question 1, your deliberations on Woods are done. Do not
answer Question 2 or Question 3.

2.

We find Andrew Reid’s compensatory damages against Crystal Woods
to be $ _________
(state the amount, or if you find that Reid’s damages have no monetary
value, put $1.00).

If you found for Reid on Question 1, and awarded Reid compensatory
damages on Question 2, then answer Question 3.
3.

We assess punitive damages against Crystal Woods of
$________________ (state the amount, or, if none, write the word
“none”).

Court’s Draft Verdict Forms 9 May 2014

Reid v. Warner et al.
5:12-cv-338-DPM

_________________________
Foreperson

______________________
Date
VERDICT NO. 6

1.

On Andrew Reid’s substantive due process claim against Vernon
Robertson, as submitted in Instruction No. 9, we find for:

________ Andrew Reid

________ Vernon Robertson

If you found for Reid on Question 1, then answer Question 2. If you found
for Robertson on Question 1, your deliberations on Robertson are done. Do
not answer Question 2 or Question 3.
2.

We find Andrew Reid’s compensatory damages against Vernon
Robertson to be $ _________
(state the amount, or if you find that Reid’s damages have no monetary
value, put $1.00).

If you found for Reid on Question 1, and awarded Reid compensatory
damages on Question 2, then answer Question 3.
3.

We assess punitive damages against Vernon Robertson of
$________________ (state the amount, or, if none, write the word
“none”).

Court’s Draft Verdict Forms 9 May 2014

Reid v. Warner et al.
5:12-cv-338-DPM

_________________________

______________________

Foreperson

Date

Court’s Draft Verdict Forms 9 May 2014

Reid v. Warner et al.
5:12-cv-338-DPM