Ward v. Cisco Systems, Inc. et al

Filing 25

RESPONSE in Opposition re 24 MOTION for Leave to Supplement the Record Regarding It's Pending Motion to Dismiss for Improper Venue, or in the Alternative, Motion to Transfer Venue filed by John Ward, Jr. (Attachments: # 1 Ex. 1, # 2 Ex. 2, # 3 Ex. 3, # 4 Ex. 4, # 5 Ex. 5, # 6 Ex. 6)(Patton, Nicholas)

1of Page 3 LawBlog-wsJ.com:RevealedPatentBlogger,andEmployel,suedfolDefamation

WAIJ, TIIE SIRNTUOUNNAL
Todal/t NMp.p.r

Mc LtR.menber

l4gln I

ilultmodh & onlln. Exlr..

Sowi@ Pa8 Cusbmer SetMy Hom | cltssri{ed'

O Blossedch, of dd business lhcbusinesslaw onlawand WSJ.@b THIIBLIE < EaslculollBeblrilg Bjdl!- SpiEt '1_ Prcviols I SIEALL PIS]S FNOM M & c h11,2008,4150 Pn

!,rqULBLlq

> I Next- Gl9trbefraudcldiclcllilcu84

PatentBlogger,and Employer,Suedfor Revealed Defamation
hr'\t .olea4u? Bobb M e tho , awrt ai"ca ftod Sanr'aa'is thtsuplak an the PatentTroll Trcclet soAo o pa'v'! alonA

w i d . l y - ( ! d tatentTIqLlTtslllr blog Theblogfollots pbten15 elcly lo sucfor Iniiingcmenl s a r d l oholding $e blog can be radonly by itvitcd mcnbcrs )

a 16rmo n. se p!!qd on RickFrenkel, laryer ed lhe hi ol r o r rl P l n e a l i o n c s @ q h o o u l e dm s . l l sf t cs u t h o r n l o

l *ith ci,m, Md day, rrcnkcr hisenProyer, sqe srsppcd adefmatiorvrsr rhc ncxr botn
I l r n el u i i . r r r e s u i r r r e m m c a t ' o n r t t o B p o ; r sRc lte n q h t h h e ! l l c s c d

wsrc?,YtLii*iAll^1

riii"ri'rii.'i"iL*i.*;'";i;h,qorq6ra*\eb.rohnn\wdaandIric,Edda.'#krsb-d'odd sherhs ci)(o 1hcpoi quesriomd smcdemdo"-' ,sod a l i i ' - ' i " , '.],i.*ii.i rs'r "e",n'r i.
$ iih L a m p .dd $ i l h t hdttet e o |patnrnlmgl Fenkclconduded'rh$h\etuothsm D r e d rhee d ' oi a a p a r e n l l i m g | i e n k d c o n c | U d e d c6es 'n.theban e x m D l col lhe abusren.lurcofliligaungpatent ;;;d;

i*i fo*.;icii.i

or pose ludscape E.sr!6 T'Fd3:e r'r", rcr @dtrie loi pasr onrt'cpatenr thc witch hosrd th.ndoivmou'tros ' c@Bic.

Wardorrernal lilcd a dcfmdion rurl 16l Not cmbet. !'^dvo{rn'l A m r d i n E lo ncss rcnons, b

; i " i , i u ii lip"ii.;;e.;'

wtrd dmcndcd surt Alb the u henFrcnkelAclled hrsrdcntirv. d.IMatlon McM$ hrlc thc \ u r l aslinslFrcnlclMd Cbtu on Mech J sllcerng

ij;i*'I'"

"

ofthc bvasrccmcnt pdticsi,:i:"":Hlmfiil-'y,*^''"v5. c6(o. ; n s r ; rcs.Inquestion.EsN w6d'snisscd p6iNovomber rhis **", ffi,j1",?.ii.c.."Jgi "*,
A|bndons6n1|mmedialeIyovsl|able|olconncnl.$hl|ewedEqu.sad$at$c

acarr sho r'* . i i i " i i i " i"*r.,, p",i"", hanor ve,,eumed

llf"g*;lllx'l5:1:fffl11*

s!)s: $orks. *hcre crr'erstirr s spotespeGon lrtsourdrikero ln3l]l;n'S,1:# L'1"" F A sforcBco, *^.^, pcsonalbloc n$
rcpre)enkd fradein $e employ@\ th0t u . d e A @ r e $e commena oNn ooi.ions md sevdtl of his @ndents ec not @nshtnt wiii Cb@t views we @;tinuo 10havchigh Gsard for thc judiciary of thc Edt n Disticl of l cxs

-a

r,,i: '" i" t'" i'i.e'iry irsjudEes. """nai"* "f Trackbact h[p:tloe.w! com,la$/2008/01'll/rc\caled-po'enl' UIU Pcrndidl fmdimrackb(v. _ ._ bloeseFMdamplo)eFsmd-roGde ABOUT THIS BLOG S a v e Shm Shft on FaebookI Drl icio.uq Digg lh' ' I Lmail lhr & I Pnnt

Read morr Libr!&DofaDalio!, Mqlia, I0le11!!tud8!op!rit

onmenls to la!!1ee@{sj.eam Repon ofrensive prodplly I saidqhenFenkelws 'ouled'$.1 hed bosued Comedt by I srid il FIRST Mach 13,2008a1 4j4 pq! hoq righl I wal

01 I I hc wal I sreer Joumal's as Blos focuqes la$ hd Ld bu\ies.. Md rhebuliesof la$. Dtr slale,n*c lerd $,,1i, Ml tr. Ds iorrcdThewdllSs(rJourul fromThcDealmagtine Beforc bo@ning r jormalisl, De worked s a litigator at . Ner Yort Iaw nm. The blog s fo$di.e qriter va PeierL.tltnd, who now @ves pdlatc cquily for fie Jormal. Th. Law Blog alsoincludescontributionsfron t ponrsed edilois.l l,beJoumaled Dow Jo.es NqswiEs. Hae a conienl or lip? Wde !o laqblog@!qi!o!0.

sho h thisllwsuit alouttryingto obt in redresfor someone sufieEdFal, wno soneooe sdidtl ngsSEARCg or daroge. is il a taclicro intinidaledd silen@ @tiomble LEGAI NOTICES d deplahrirjun,dnrlike'

one of _ herc? Meoh 13.2008al 4:57pn Complle ot more lhefollowinsfilds: conmnlbycone on, R61[- whals al stake Dato Rmge' we settie witt lradrrbmlrronnerJusti@? knowfte ihs why norhaleihepanies

http:/,6logs.wsj.com,4aw12008/03173hevealed-patent-blogger-and-employer-sued-for-defam..'11

PatentBlogger,andEmployer' Suedfor Defamation Law Btog - WSJ.com: Revealed
in equipnflt is .sily 6d quicklyavtitable TX' andonels lMyer is society\ gan 5:05Dm CodnentbyTe6 lraditionali(- March13'2008a1
Tbe defuEion rrlon i5 frivotous cmpd(s md fte p@Plethar *o' t to' rtrm

Page2 of 3

AlrDol6

I

Cargory: al caboorios
KWotd(t)

rhis alawver' mvbodrEspeciarrv wa;r i"ir'i-ri-ti Jiii" i"y -yn'i"c thev lbour @nresr' likearroll'r adollorcwids i'-i ir'-iJu. u*ir",j"L help? Need viw our "t-u( See'hTis - Meh 13, 2008 !!11!a! at Refom ConncnbyTort t
$is scrds for d dti-SLAPPholion _ Comot by AnotrynousMech I l, 2008.t 5:4!!E litigadoi is liiiSntion thnwb6don of ftivolous In ny opinion, D.tent a! C o . n n n r b y l r e * Mech13,2008 i14!r4 Jusr naksw Mr wdd th8tI m notontheJury' Connentby Mftill - Mech 13,2008at 6:21!!0 not the .nd Wheeis $c lawsuit *hy does lawblog ptovidca link lo it?Lsttn b@n riShtonthisonc Th6o *erc thedavs. *ould have Comenr byAnon- Mdch 13,2008al 7!ll Pm t0 thne oftntcRst$ thd. appNntly,lne FtT hadrcad th rcacrcd trcpon One hd had b.lor!theirclienl theT(lawvets sued dat o nrhein-lcmd indicskd thal s6nd'nq bu! either rcporlpovd In@rrct or the@unclctk Mccted $' inrmel s nor ile d o c k e r b i c ol thccvbalh'chqav tob.lrcv.everv$mgonthc funlrr,iol toLh.publishonrhe$.bcondusionsftal)ou\e a m d rstcn slep rcpotffe over@&lrvc um t do b6cd 'ir b o!i3ton e ! on0rtt intcmcltcpori Mostlib.l involves facts n or.vancscent .

@

$?G!s' lM4s Exad!55ru-S-ea6 L OilsLockjaldrstlrelr6 JMie Didon: 'W. AhoslplsE@$4cld 2. l.!.Morcds 3. Al{c!ai! V! Molbl-lhe l9lqDelooq4ic c.o4Ye4lian 'shadolv llqkql 4. nqEelinb D.soile 5. llo{rbe EichW!!!dla{e Uldq obm& \&ean the le!4p 6. fe!!oil: IEA l.ohs Towsrd PessirililE to Me'- Looki!$l a!a{Ei.,a 7.I& rUode!!.Fmql&lten Attemative 8. tjov- l!!i!!Jo w!!l 9. MqtplBd 10. &q[[i4qE!o4aOicj

' E-MA!I, SICN-UP plus La{ of Gc1 roundup lhedayrs Bloepos15, lhola&stlar noqs a lh. Chcck boxb.low to subscbe. Nwrled.r f l L s * Dlos sifilr-_'l fs-at an ConmenbyThonson - Mech 14,2008 JoL)? t glict E:M3il To v'ewall oi chege anyofyou em.il scttings, lo 1lt9 cln&t Sctup $ thlt lik B u t looks .lcrylhmg guyposrcds felutllv ldc b6cdor cv.rything on had lhe did I v. Rdd. ce dockct sho* !t that pla'nriffla$veB su.d I The RELAfED ARTICLES AND BLOCS O,Iioc,whichwouldn8nthev it fron hc Patenl ort nt oncdlv bcfor issued Lmdlvfitdr was mol!-rauldlcofid And it h alsotruclhatfie couridockcl thcn *ouldn\ hav;bgalsllndinE. clcrk shrch aPP@ntl) lhr coun onl) daJ. c h m g cronovt$c filinsdacb' onc d 'nMurare oTr{ER fac6 sav ofthosc werc wu,coM san anione $at anv lr,oosrRoM o u l t h a v edon..lhalenr ehich 8e for bcinSsued th. Fstofthcp6t, qhichw.r. hisopiiions, H . 3 rcally protecrcby lheFi6l Amcndne.t. d a4 Come.t byCul - Meh 14,2008.110.15 Al vs. butihis isfi E4ilrn DistriclofT.xs, T.sksn. DivisionNickhtlon h wdd islBo a dd Craven Johmv Fokom vag'stdr.Jud8e ud c l o ; r; Judse undcr defendant lhe Counlqouldnolsdl b berhe l d n i l i e p F s e n cmthar e Tourist Mech14,200E IIr2l3m C o n n o byOMional Texdksna

Subscribe

hcadlines rcadfron iny\rh.re onthc l,o to ISS - subscdbe updaied RsS, clickhrt9. aboul . g@d, nem a v..v W e bFormore I at I rhinkrhebiCgdtf4@ we hav themorenl b, rveheveno we all goodlsld oopatents, corecl meif I u wronSHnco hav ptlcics ctc 6'!alv Bllg Firczili A MullaMBAPhD P,O.Box 60,K S a v e& Share
Digg - subnit this ited to be shdcd dd votedon by tho digg conmunily. For noc aboutdige, click b9{e. Dcl.i.io.B - nark m item s ! favorile 10ecess lator or shd w'tn click t h edel.icio.us @nnu.ity. For morcaboddel.ic'o.us, h9&. a Facebook- share i1m with usoBof Facebook, mlleclion of $h@1, company&d regionalsocial oetworks.Foi mo@aboul

by Commenl litozali A. MutlaMBA PhD- Meh 14,2008at I l:48 m deforoebutonebadlssuit @ still ruinyourlif Truthmly bea great conmentby Intceted sdd - Meh 14,2008at l:54 pm Yodaremissing *veryinponmt+f@t peopte one agai.st his lamuit brcuetu oldat p&li.!le patcnl RickFEnklwd in charg

P A S TPOSTS

7/6D008 http://blogs.wsj.com/law2008l13ll3kevealed-palent-blogger-and-employer-sued-for-defu\...

Patett Blogger,andErnployer,Suedfor Defamation Law Blog - WSJ.com: Revealod
pt'idifs .gEitrE md made scrious ftlsacqtsdions oompsy0fl1'purposely+ ys rtbn ro EMgD itrfD dtsbdhin ittredt&ly cofine _ .t uq by sBry itud M.r.h t?, ?,008 9::14 Mtrch 200E MTVTFSS |2

3 P a g e of3

145578e !0 M2 1l l! 1516

I t r l u w & n t [ E b . s . l ! d t h e r c o e t t r l r t i c l c . t w u , E ! ! 5 ! E Y o 4 ! . q ! t r j 1 i h e v . . . nr8l9-10212223

30 Hi:hcrf#Si':',,*1f-1s"blogginsrsf:Eulviindep@d'i(iqnvi'i"ia'o261l'Jl t ks 3piEn ym lrFEtrLl 'frf"" l,i iiiii'f;' lf f;,iiij21 i,,,2s lod
ft.d bib Y.e hstr't Cisoo ii* Aluc Diloma - Melh 20,2006!t 4ilz!!0 Conmdt by Ci!@'3

TOP LAW STORIES
Viamn Filnt Ovff us6 YouTub.. to ColGS.nl6 Suitoecr SElc. Botrl6 A.rior*3lors slodkol3 Anatcd

lju.t folmd6t vtb sltoitd l.! youdoudtoldPd.nt! .5 PDi nld for nE. Its b!I]6Mx@!rrE!cvq.!!ol thouglt I'd shsr.fib lit!. !!n vrih hor. $.t arcini.Fstcd

rr08!
s.d . rmc l, 2008tl 9ld4 crmncnt byJohn
Fmr fdrfr rrrclard' Brlim id PFedoi

Ndnc:

I

bm oilrm E|lrrktr, ll*

, Asd.b

d PHohn-,

(|lruE t iir..r, c4m o.r- ln Brh.., ad uin{l! D.omlltud*lnnm.rc6 2!0('0.{rd5

Nurlrr, hxh,

d4. rl P.ht oilL. rffi

crnhn

Comnu||l

@M

..

:l|l

LAW PAGE ) VISITWSJ.CoMS

U|Itst&!!

tl{MDblrl I EIJ! I U9EE

Subsib. lddr
Prlvd Policv

Trk .Tdr

Cd !.[ Ug

S.nic!: QdinrI Pd!r| EDdL&lu Curlon6r vlm lliEEdr coflrichtPolicyM6btlGIt
lto* Jms Abotrt

Ncq,s Llod.lng

hnp://blogs.wsj.con/1aw2008/03/1

gger-and-employer-sued-for-dofam... 762008