Log Cabin Republicans v. United States of America et al

Filing 179

NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION IN LIMINE to Exclude Certain of Plaintiff's Proposed Exhibits filed by Defendants Donald H Rumsfeld, United States of America. Motion set for hearing on 6/28/2010 at 02:30 PM before Judge Virginia A. Phillips. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Table of Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Exhibit List, #2 Proposed Order)(Parker, Ryan)

Log Cabin Republicans v. United States of America et al

Doc. 179 Att. 1

DEFENDANT'S OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT LIST Exhibit No. Description Objections

1 10 U.S.C. § 654 (1993) Nathaniel Frank Expert Report (Jan. 18, 2 2010) 3 S. Rep. No. 103-112- National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 1994 "Report of the Board Appointed to Prepare and Submit Recommendations to the Secretary of the Navy for the Revision of Policies, Procedures and Directives Dealing with Homosexuals 25 December 1956-15 March 1957)" (the "Crittenden Report") (DoD LA 7-10 49668-49741) Theodore Sarbin and Kenneth Karols, Defense Personnel Security Research and Education Center, "Nonconforming Sexual Orientations and Military Suitability" (OSD P&R 7328-7376) U.S. Gen. Accounting Office, Report to Congressional Requesters, "Defense Force Management: DOD's Policy on Homosexuality" (June 1992) U.S. Gen. Accounting Office, Report to the Hon. John W. Warner, U.S. Senate, "Homosexuals in the Military: Policies and Practices of Foreign Countries" (June 1993) RAND National Defense Research Institute, "Sexual Orientation and U.S. Military Personnel Policy: Options and Assessment" (1993) U.S. Gov. Accountability Office, Report to Congressional Requesters, "Military Personnel Financial Costs and Loss of Critical Skills Due to DOD's Homosexual 1
Dockets.Justia.com

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

4

5

6

Relevance

7

8

9

Relevance

Conduct Policy Cannot be Completely Estimated" (Feb. 2005) Blue Ribbon Commission Members Report, "Financial Analysis of 'Don't Ask, Don't Tell': How Much Does the Gay Ban Cost?" (Feb. 2006) Sam Rodgers, "Opinions of Military Personnel on Sexual Minorities in the Military" (Zogby International, Dec. 2006) Aaron Belkin et al., "How to End 'Don't Ask, Don't Tell:' A Roadmap of Political, Legal, Regulatory, and Organizational Steps to Equal Treatment" (Palm Center, May 2009) Aaron Belkin and Melissa Levitt, "Homosexuality and the Israel Defense Forces: Did Lifting the Gay Ban Undermine Military Performance?," Vol. 27 No. 4 Armed Forces & Society 541 (2001) Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

10 11

12

13

14 Inadvertently Skipped Nathaniel Frank, "Gays and Lesbians at War: Military Service in Iraq and Afghanistan Under 'Don't Ask, Don't Tell'" (Center for the Study of Sexual Minorities in the Military, University of California, Santa Barbara, Sept. 15 15, 2004) Nathaniel Frank, "The Road to Gays in the Military Runs through Iowa," Huffington Post, available at http://www.huffingtonpost.com/nathanielfrank/the-road-to-gays-in-the16 m_b_183492.html (Apr. 6, 2009) Nathaniel Frank, "Refuting the Latest Arguments Against Gay Troops," Huffington Post, available at http://www.huffingtonpost.com/nathanielfrank/refuting-the-latest17 argum_b_327553.html (Oct. 20, 2009) 2

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay ; Foundation; Authentication

Nathaniel Frank et al., "'The Importance of Objective Analysis' on Gays in the Military: A Response to Elaine Donnelly's Constructing the Co-Ed Military" (15 Duke J. 18 Gender L. & Pol'y 419, 2008) 19 Not used Nathaniel Frank, Unfriendly Fire 113-136 20 (New York, St. Martin's Press 2009) Nathaniel Frank, "Gay Troops and the Trouble with Polls," Huffington Post, available at http://www.huffingtonpost.com/nathanielfrank/gay-troops-and-the21 troubl_b_460291.html (Feb. 12, 2010) Nathaniel Frank, "Gays in Foreign Militaries 2010: A Global Primer" (Palm Center, Feb. 22 2010) 23 Rob MacCoun Expert Report (Jan. 19, 2010) 24 Inadvertently Skipped Leonard Wong et al., "Why They Fight: Combat Motivation in the Iraq War" (US Army College, Strategic Studies Institute, 25 July 2003) Robert MacCoun et al., "Does Social Cohesion Determine Motivation in Combat? An Old Question Answered," Vol. 32 No. 4 26 Armed Forces & Society 646 (July 2006) Robert MacCoun, "Sexual Orientation and Military Cohesion: A Critical Review of the Evidence," in Out in Force: Sexual Orientation and the Military (University of 27 Chicago Press, 1996) 3

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Incomplete (part of Ex. 300)

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation

28 Inadvertently Skipped 29 Elizabeth Hillman Expert Report (Jan. 18, 2010) Elizabeth Hillman, "Guarding Women: Abu Ghraib and Military Sexual Culture" in One of the Guys: Women as Aggressors and Torturers 111-123 (Seal Press, 2007). Servicemembers Legal Defense Network, "Conduct Unbecoming: 10th Annual Report on Don't Ask, Don't Tell" (2004) Bonnie Moradi and Laura Miller, Attitudes of Iraq and Afghanistan War Veterans toward Gay and Lesbian Service Members (Armed Forces and Society, Oct. 29, 2009). Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay

30 31

32

33 Aaron Belkin Expert Report (Jan. 15, 2010) Aaron Belkin and Geoffrey Bateman, "Does the Gay Ban Preserve Soldiers' Privacy?" in Don't Ask, Don't Tell Debating the Gay Ban in the Military (Lynne Rienner Publishers, 34 2003) Aaron Belkin and Melissa S. Embser-Herbert, "A Modest Proposal: Privacy as a Flawed Rationale for the Exclusion of Gays and Lesbians from the U.S. Military," Vol. 27 No. 35 2 International Security 178 (2002) Log Cabin Republicans' Internal Survey of 36 Members (LCR 1-17) (Feb. 22, 2010) 37 Not used 38 Declaration of John Doe (June 11, 2007) 39 Inadvertently Skipped 4

Hearsay

Letter from John Alexander Nicholson (SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER) 40 (Feb. 10, 2002) Letter from John Alexander Nicholson (SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER) 41 (Feb. 8, 2002) 42 Not used

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Nathaniel Frank, Unfriendly Fire 191-192 (St. Foundation; Incomplete (part of 300) 43 Martin's Press 2009) Yusef Najafi, "Servicemembers' Milestone, Largest Organization of Gay Veterans Opens DC headquarters" Metroweekly, available at Relevance; Hearsay; http://metroweekly.com/news/?ak=4369 (July Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation 44 2, 2009) Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; 45 Alan Okros Expert Report Foundation; Authentication 46 Inadvertently Skipped 47 Inadvertently Skipped 48 Inadvertently Skipped 49 Inadvertently Skipped Melissa Sheridan Embser-Herbert Expert 50 Report (Jan. 15, 2010) Melissa Sheridan Embser-Herbert Curriculum 51 Vitae Melissa Sheridan Embser-Herbert, Excerpt from "Feminism, Militarism, and Attitudes Toward the Role of Women in the Military," 52 Vol. 14 Issue 2, Feminist Issues 25 (1994) 5 Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation

53 54

55

56

Melissa Sheridan Embser-Herbertt, Excerpt from Camouflage Isn't Only for Combat (New York University Press, 1998) Melissa Sheridan Embser-Herbert, "A Missing Link" in In the Company of Men (Northeastern University Press, 2005) Melissa Sheridan Embser-Herbert, "Frederick the Great or Frederick's of Hollywood? The Accomplishment of Gender Among Women in the Military" in Everyday Inequalities, (Blackwell Publishing Ltd. 1998) Melissa Sheridan Embser-Herbert, "Gays and Lesbians in the Military" in U.S. Military's 'Don't Ask, Don't Tell' Policy: A Reference Handbook, (Praeger Sec. Int'l., 2007)

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation

57 Not used Lawrence Korb et al., "Ending 'Don't Ask, Don't Tell:' Practical Steps to Repeal the Ban on Openly Gay Men and Women in the U.S. Military" (Center for American Progress, 58 June 1, 2009) 59 60 Lawrence Korb Expert Report (LCR 152171) Servicemembers Legal Defense Network, Excerpt from "About 'Don't Ask, Don't Tell,'" available at http://www.sldn.org Defense Manpower Data Center, "Separations Due to Homosexual Conduct" (Report Prepared for Under Secretary of Defense for Plans, May 12, 2009) (DMDC 225-257) Lawrence Korb, "Evolving Perspectives on the Military Policy on Homosexuals: A Personal Note in Gays and Lesbians in the Military: Issues, Concerns, and Contrasts (Aldine Transaction, 1994)

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

61

Relevance; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

62

6

Memorandum from Craig Alderman to Director DOD Personnel Security Research and Educational Center regarding PERS-TR98-002, "Nonconforming Sexual Orientations and Military Suitability" (Jan 18, 1989) (DoD Relevance; Foundation 63 LA 2-6 42416-42417) Palm Center, excerpt from "Attitudes of Iraq and Afghanistan War Veterans Toward Gay and Lesbian Service Members" available at Relevance; Hearsay; 64 http://www.palmcenter.org/) (Oct. 29, 2009) Foundation; Authentication Notice of 30(b)(6) deposition (Retained) 65 (Dec. 21, 2009) Memorandum from David Chu to the Secretaries of the Military Departments regarding Directive Type (DTM) 08-018 66 "Enlistment Waivers" (June 27, 2008) Michael Boucai, "Balancing Your Strengths Against Your Felonies: Considerations for Military Recruitment of Ex-offenders," 61 U. Miami L. Rev. 997 (2007) (available at 67 http://www.palmcenter.org) 68 Not Used Gwyn Harries-Jenkins, excerpt from "Comparative International Military Personnel Policies" (U.S. Army Research 69 Institute, May 1993) (ARI 60756-60779) Franklin Pinch, "Perspectives on Organizational Change in the Canadian Forces" (U.S. Army Research Institute, 70 January 1994) (ARI 60206-60272) Memorandum from Paul Gade to Bob Wisher regarding Review of Sr. Pinch's Report Entitled Perspectives on Organizational Change in the Canadian Forces (June 28, 71 1993) (ARI 60755) Email communications between Franklin Pinch and Paul Gade regarding gays in 72 Canadian military (Nov. 1, 2000) (ARI 7 Relevance

Relevance Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication; Incomplete Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

Relevance Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

62002-62004) Paul Gade et al., "Social Science Research on Homosexuals in the Military" in Gays and Lesbians in the Military: Issues, Concerns, and Contrasts (Sandra Stanley and Wilbur Scott, eds., Aldine Transaction, 1994) Paul Gade, U.S. Army Research Institute, slides regarding Research Findings and Issues Concerning Homosexuals in Military Service (ARI 61994-62001) Paul Gade, "The Integration of Homosexuals in the U.S. Military" (Nov. 18, 1992) (ARI 60533-60534) Dep't of the Army, "Future organizational change US Army (Focus Army) Chronology of Policy Events/Activities" (July 30, 1993) (ARI 62125-62128) Aaron Belkin and R.L. Evans, "The Effects of Including Gay and Lesbian Soldiers in the British Armed Forces Appraising the Evidence" (Palm Center, Nov. 2000) (LCR 4706-4775) Aaron Belkin and Melissa Levitt, "Homosexuality and the Israel Defense Forces: Did Lifting the Gay Ban Undermine Military Performance?," Vol. 27 No. 4 Armed Forces & Society 541 (2001) Aaron Belkin and Jason McNichol, "The Effects of Including Gay and Lesbian Soldiers in the Australian Defence Forces Appraising the Evidence" (Palm Center, Sept. 19, 2000) (LCR 4666-4705) Aaron Belkin and Jason McNichol, "Effects of the 1992 Lifting of Restrictions on Gay and Lesbian Service in the Canadian Forces: Appraising the Evidence" (Palm Center, Apr. 2000)

73

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay

74 75

Relevance Relevance Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

76

77

78

79

80

8

Aaron Belkin, "Don't Ask, Don't Tell: Is the Gay Ban Based on Military Necessity?" 81 (Palm Center, 2003) (LCR 3367-3378)

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

82 Not used Ministry of Defence, Memorandum attaching 2002 "Tri-Service Review of the Armed Forces' Policy on Homosexuality and Code of Relevance; Hearsay; Social Conduct" (British Ministry of Defence, Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication 83 May 18, 2007) 84 Not used Defendants' Objections and Responses to Plaintiff's First Set of Requests for Admission 85 (Jan. 28, 2010) Relevance Defense Manpower Data Center, Chart titled "Homosexual Separations by Service and Reason, DoD Official Numbers FY 97- FY 86 08" (DMDC 250-253) Relevance; Foundation Dep't of the Army, Excerpt from Future Organizational Change - U.S. Army, Focus Army Task Force Documentation Book Relevance; Hearsay; 87 (1993) (ARI 62124) Foundation; Incomplete 88 Not used Memorandum regarding Gays and Lesbians at War: Military Service in Iraq and Afghanistan Under "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" (redacted) 89 (OSD P&R Plans 58910-58911) Relevance; Foundation Bonnie Moradi and Laura Miller, "Attitudes of Iraq and Afghanistan War Veterans toward Gay and Lesbian Service Members" (Armed Forces and Society, Oct. 29, 2009) (DMDC 90 11-22) Duplicate of Ex. No. 32 91 Not used FORSCOM Regulation 500-3-3 (July 15, 92 1999) 9

93 DOD Instruction Number 1332.14 94 DOD Instruction Number 1332.30 Dep't of Defense, Deputy Secretary of 95 Defense Organizational Chart (2008) Dep't of Defense, Defense Agencies 96 Organizational Chart (2008) Chart titled "Days between deployment end date and separation date active duty 97 separations as of April 1, 2010 98 Not used 99 Not used Michael McDaniel, "Preservice Adjustment of Homosexual and Heterosexual Military Accessions: Implications for Security Clearance Suitability" Defense Personnel Security Research and Education Center, 100 (Jan. 1989) (DoD LA 2-6 42467-42496) Theodore Sarbin, "Homosexuality and Personnel Security" (Defense Personnel Security Research and Education Center, 101 Sept. 1991) (PERSEC 7818-7863) 102 Not used Defendants' Objections and Responses to Plaintiff's First Set of Requests for 103 Production of Documents (Jan. 12, 2010) Defendants' Objections and Responses to Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories (Feb. 104 22, 2010) Defendants' Objections and Response to Plaintiff's Second Set of Requests for 105 Admission (Feb. 22, 2010) 10 Relevance Relevance Relevance

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay

Relevance; Hearsay Relevance Relevance

Defendants' Objections and Responses to Plaintiff's Second Set of Requests for 106 Production of Documents (Mar. 4, 2010) Defendants' Objections and Responses to Plaintiff's Second Set of Interrogatories (Mar. 107 4, 2010) Defendants' Supplemental Responses to Plaintiff's First Set of Requests for 108 Admission (Mar. 26, 2010) Draft of Log Cabin Republicans' Bylaws (Jan. 109 2006) Log Cabin Republicans' Articles of 110 Incorporation Alex Nicholson Certificate of Release or 110A Discharge from Active Duty (Mar. 29, 2003) Stephen Jay Vossler's Certificate of Release or Discharge from Active Duty (June 26, 111 2006) Michael Almy's Certificate of Release or 112 Discharge from Active Duty (Jul. 21, 2006) Letter from Colonel Paul Trahan to all Reviewed Authorities regarding Major 113 Michael D. Almy (Feb. 12, 2006) Memorandum from Lt. Colonel Jeffrey B, Kromer to All Reviewing Authorities regarding Major Michael Almy (Feb. 13, 114 2006) Memorandum from Major Scott D. Weenum, Department of the Air Force, to All Reviewing Authorities regarding Major Mike 115 Almy (Feb. 10, 2006) 11

Relevance; Hearsay Relevance

Relevance

Relevance

Relevance

Relevance

Relevance

Relevance

Relevance

Memorandum for Record from Captain Stuart A. Williamson, Department of the Air Force, regarding Major Michael D. Almy (Jan. 25, 116 2006) Relevance Memorandum for Record from Captain Timothy Higgins, Department of the Air Force, regarding Major Almy (Feb. 13, 2006) Letter from Captain Hyral Walker, Jr., Dep't of the Air Force, regarding Major Michael D. Almy (Feb. 8, 2006) Memorandum for Record from Captain Quintin Tran, Dep't of the Air Force, to All Reviewing Authorities, regarding Major Michael D. Almy (Feb. 3, 2006) Memorandum for Record from First Lieutenant Rahsul Freeman, Department of the Air Force, to All Reviewing Authorities, regarding Major Michael D. Almy (Feb. 10, 2006) Memorandum for Record from First Lieutenant Bryan Zollinger, Dep't of the Air Force, to All Reviewing Authorities, regarding Major Michael D. Almy (Jan. 23, 2006)

117 118

Relevance Relevance

119

Relevance

120

Relevance

121

Relevance

Memorandum from Senior Master Sargeant Leslie D. McElya to 52FW/CC regarding 122 Major Mike Almy (Feb. 7, 2006) Memorandum from Master Sargeant David H. Hogden to All Reviewing Authorities 123 regarding Major Mike Almy (Jan. 30, 2006)

Relevance

Relevance

Memorandum from Sargeant Denise D. Hyre to All Reviewing Authorities regarding Major 124 Mike Almy (Feb. 13, 2006) Relevance Memorandum from Senior Sargeant Thomas Ray, Department of the Air Force, to All Reviewing Authorities regarding Major Mike 125 Almy (Feb. 8, 2006) Relevance 12

Letter from Craig Weatherwax to all 126 concerned regarding Major Michael Almy Letter from Paul Tripp to all concerned 127 regarding Major Michael Almy Letter from General Robert H. Foglesong to Major Mike Almy regarding 2004 USAFE Lieutenant General Leo Marquez 128 Communcations Electronics Award (2005) Letter from M. Sgt. Patrick Nutt to undisclosed recipient regarding S. Sgt. 129 Loverde (Apr. 29, 2009) 130 Not used Email from Anthony Loverde to Jon Welch 131 (Apr. 22, 2008) Letter from Anthony Loverde to undisclosed recipient admitting his sexual orientation 132 (Apr. 22, 2008) Email from M. Sgt. Robert Eslinger to Anthony Loverde regarding "calling all 133 supervisors" (Apr. 28, 2008) 134 135 136 137 138 Anthony Loverde's Certificate of Discharge from Active Duty Letter from M. Sgt. Robert Eslinger to undisclosed recipient regarding Anthony Loverde Letter from CM Sgt. Michael Yakowenko to undisclosed recipient regarding Anthony Loverde (June 2, 2009) Letter from SM Sgt. Richard Horn to undisclosed recipient regarding Anthony Loverde (Apr. 28, 2008) Statement of Service, BOI Record of Proceedings in the Case of Lt.Jg. Jenny L. Kopfstein, USNR (Mar. 20, 2002)

Relevance Relevance

Relevance Relevance

Relevance; Hearsay Relevance; Hearsay Relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance Relevance; Hearsay Relevance

Jenny L. Kopfstein Fitness Report and 139 Counseling Record 13

Memorandum for Record from Jenny Kopfstein to Commanding Officer, USS 140 Shiloh (Jul. 17, 2000) Jenny Kopfstein's Certificate of Release or 141 Discharge from Active Duty Joseph C. Rocha's voluntary statement 142 regarding sexual orientation (Sept. 19, 2007) Joseph C. Rocha's Evaluation Report and 143 Counseling Record (June 22, 2006) Joseph C. Rocha Evaluation Report and Counseling Record (with additional signature 144 from Lt. Castoire) (June 22, 2006) Joseph C. Rocha Evaluation Report and Counseling Record (with additional signatures from Lt. Castoire and Joseph 145 Rocha) (June 22, 2006) Memorandum from Commanding Officer, U.S. Naval Support Activity Bahrain to Superintendent of the U.S. Naval Academy 146 regarding Joseph Rocha (Jan. 23, 2006) Memorandum from Commanding Officer, U.S. Naval Support Activity Bahrain to Commander of Navy Installations Command 147 regarding Joseph Rocha (Apr. 12, 2007) Email from Joseph Rocha to undisclosed 148 recipient regarding harassment and abuse Memorandum from Commanding Officer, U.S. Naval Support Activity Bahrain to Commander, Navy Personnel Command 149 regarding Joseph Rocha Joseph Rocha's Certificate of Release or 150 Discharge from Active Duty Administrative Separation Proceeding Notice - Administrative Board Procedure for Joseph 151 Rocha 14

Relevance; Hearsay Relevance Relevance Relevance

Relevance

Relevance

Relevance

Relevance Relevance; Hearsay

Relevance Relevance

Relevance

Dep't of Defense, "Fact Sheet: Homosexuals in the Armed Forces" (Jan 1981) (DoD LA 2152 6 040937) 153

154

155

156

157

Relevance; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Bčrubč, A. and D'Emilio, J., The Military and Hearsay within Hearsay; Lesbians During the McCarthy Years Foundation Memorandum from Robert L. Gilliat to Offices of the Judge Advocates General of the Army, Navy, and Air Force regarding Gays Veterans Association, Inc. v. Secretary of Defense Civ. No. 85-3193 filed October 4, 1985) (Oct. 15, 1985) (DoD LA 7-10 054873) Relevance; Foundation Murphy, L. R., Perverts by Official Order: The Campaign Against Homosexuals by the Relevance; Hearsay; United States Navy. (Harrington Park Press, Hearsay within Hearsay; 1988) Foundation Memorandum from Secretary of Defense Richard Cheney to the Secretary of the Army et al. regarding Delegation of Authority to Suspend Provisions of Law Relating to Promotion, Retirement or Separation of Army Personnel (Nov. 23, 1988) (DoD LA 7-10 051797) Relevance; Foundation Michael McDaniel, "Preservice Adjustment of Homosexual and Heterosexual Military Accessions: Implications for Security Clearance Suitability" (Defense Personnel Security Research and Education Center, Jan. 1989) (DOD LA 2-6 042467-042496) Duplicate of Ex. No. 100

158 Not used Memorandum from Craig Alderman, Jr., Deputy Undersecretary of Defense for Policy to Peter Nelson regarding PERSEREC Draft Report Nonconforming Sexual Orientations and Military Suitability (Feb. 10, 1989) 159 (DOD LA 2-6 042466) 15

Relevance; Foundation

Memorandum from Maynard Anderson, Ass't Deputy Undersecretary of Defense, to Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Security Policy regarding Congressional Briefings (Oct. 18, 1989) (DoD LA 2-6 042458160 042461) Michelle Benecke and Kristin Dodge, "Military Women in Nontraditional Job Fields: Causalities of the Armed Forces' War on Homosexuals," 13 Harvard Women's Law 161 Journal 215 (1990) Allen Berube, Coming Out Under Fire: The History of Gay Men and Women in World War Two (The Free Press, 1990) Dyer, K. (ed.), Gays in Uniform; The Pentagon's Secret Reports (Boston: Alyson Publications 1990) Mary Ann Humphrey, My Country, My Right to Serve: Experiences of Gay Men and Women in the Military, World War II to the Present (HarperCollins 1990) Memorandum from Richard Cheney to the Secretaries of the Military Departments regarding Delegation of Authority to Suspend Provisions of Law Relating to Promotion, Retirement or Separation (Aug. 27, 1990) (DoD LA 7-10 051795 - 051796)

Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation

162 163

164

165

Relevance; Foundation

Dep't of the Navy, Naval Message regarding Sexual Harassment (Oct. 1990) (DoD LA 7166 10 047077 ) Letter from William Woodruff, Chief U.S. Army Litigation Division, to Irene Robertson regarding audit of DoD policy on homosexuality (Feb. 27, 1991) (DoD LA 2-6 167 042135-42137) Randy Shilts, "Pentagon Memo Urged Reversing Ban on Gays in the Military Army 168 Says the Officer's Opinions is his Own," (San 16

Relevance; Foundation

Relevance; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation

Francisco Chronicle, June 25, 1991)

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Robert Maginnis, "A Contrary Agenda" (DoD Foundation ; 169 LA 7-10 47931-47944)(1991) Authentication Memorandum from James Schwenk to Irene Robertson attaching excerpts from Navy Women' Study Group "Update Report on the Progress of Women in the Navy" (Oct. 24, 170 1991) (DoD LA 7-10 50025-50035) Relevance; Foundation Robert L. Maginnis, "Homosexuality in the Army's Future?" (Approx. 1991) (DoD LA 7171 10 47903 ­ 47922) Lori Ramsey and Barbara Urynowicz et al., "Update of the U.S. Army Research Institute's Longitudinal Research Data Base of Enlisted Personnel" (U.S. Army Research 172 Institute, Aug. 1992) Memorandum from T.D. Keating to Robert Adams stating that discharged homosexuals should receive half separation pay (Nov. 8, 173 1992) (DoD LA 2-6 40010 ­ 40011) Charles Jackson, Executive Vice President Non Comissioned Officers Assoc., statement before Republican Study Committee on homosexuals in the Armed Forces (Dec. 9, 174 1992) (DoD LA 7-10 49304 ­ 49353) Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation

Relevance; Foundation

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation

17

Dep't of Defense, "Hypothetical Teaching Scenarios for Commanders and Personnel Involved in Recruiting, Accession Processing, Criminal Investigations, and Administrative Relevance; Foundation 175 Separations" (Navy 058969-058974) F. Pond, A Comparative Survey and Analysis of Military Policies with Regard to Service by Gay Persons, in Policy Concerning Homosexuality in the Armed Forces, (Senate Armed Services Committee Hearing, 103d 176 Cong., 2d Sess. Washington, D.C.) Randy Shilts, Conduct Unbecoming: Lesbians & Gays in the U.S. Military Vietnam to Persian Gulf (Fawcett Columbine, 1993) Marc Wolinsky and Kenneth Sherrill, Gays and the Military: Joseph Steffan versus the United States (Princeton University Press, 1993) David Burrelli, "Homosexuals and U.S. Military Personnel Policy" (Congressional Research Service, Jan. 14, 1993) (DoD LA 26 45928- 46002) Memorandum from former President of the United States, William Clinton, to Secretary of Defense regarding ending discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation in the armed forces (Jan. 29, 1993) (DoD LA 7-10 55847) Memorandum from Les Aspin to Secretaries of the Army, Navy, Air Force and Joint Chiefs of Staff regarding Adminstrative Separation Procedures (Feb. 3, 1993) (DoD 710 54450 -54451) Memorandum from Robert Alexander to Deputy Assistant Secretaries of Army, Navy, Air Force regarding Armed Forces Applicant Screening and Periodic Briefing on Military Justice- Policy Guidance (Feb. 3, 1993) (DoD LA 7-10 55844) 18 Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation

177

178

179

180

Relevance

181

Relevance; Foundation

182

Relevance; Foundation

183

184

185 186

187

188

189

190

Memorandum from Les Aspin to Secretaries of Army, Navy, Air Force and Joint Chief of Staff regarding Administrative Separation Procedures (Feb. 3, 1993) (DoD LA 7-10 55845 - 055846) Eugene Gomulka, Deputy Chaplain of U.S. Marine Corps, testimony on "Homosexuality and Military Service" to Congress (Mar. 1, 1993) (DoD LA 2-6 39913 ­ 39917) Letter from former President of the United States, William Clinton, to Admiral Jim Stockdale regarding ban on homosexuality in the military service (Mar. 4, 1993) (Navy 58991) National Association of Evangelicals Resolution (Mar. 9, 1993) (DoD LA 2-6 39911 ­ 39912) Chaplain James Hutchens' testimony regarding Homosexuals in the Military before United States House of Representatives Republican Study Committee (Mar. 24, 1993) (DoD LA 2-6 39890 ­ 39903) Chaplain Edgren testimony regarding Homosexuals in the Military before United States House of Representatives Republican Study Research Committee (Mar. 24, 1993) (DoD LA 2-6 39904- 39910) Chaplain James Shaw, Director of the Ministry to the Armed Forces, Lutheran Church statement regarding Homosexuals in the Military to United States House of Representatives Republican Study Research Committee (Mar. 24, 1993) (DoD LA 2-6 39921 ­ 39926) Chaplain Timothy Tatum testimony regarding Homosexuals in the Military to U.S. Congress (Mar. 24, 1993) (DoD LA 2-6 39927 ­ 39929)

Relevance; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication; Incomplete

Relevance; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

Incomplete (part of legislative history) Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication; Incomplete

Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication; Incomplete Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication; Incomplete

19

191

192

193

194

195

Memorandum from Edward Martin, Acting Assistant Secretary of Defense to Secretaries of the Military Depts. regarding Medical Implication of Homosexuals in the Military (Mar. 30, 1993) (PERSEC 8000 ­8001) Senate Armed Services Committee Hearing Transcript regarding "Topic: the role of Unit Cohesion...ban on homosexuals in military" (Mar. 31, 1993) (DoD LA 7-10 49032 ­ 49068) RAND National Defense Research Institute, "Homosexuals and U.S. military Personnel Policy: Policy Options and Assessment" (interim report, Apr. 6, 1993) Letter from Clinton Anderson, American Psychological Association to Les Aspin regarding request for a meeting related to the ban on homosexuals in the military (Apr. 8, 1993) (DoD LA 2-6 36593-36604) U.S. Senate Committee on Armed Services Hearing Transcript, "To Receive Testimony on the Military Policy Concerning the Service of Gay Men and Lesbians in the Armed Forces: the Experience in Foreign Countries" (Apr. 29, 1993) (DoD LA 2-6 44033-44209)

Relevance; Foundation

Incomplete (part of legislative history) Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation

Incomplete (part of legislative history)

196 Not used U.S. House of Representatives Committee on Armed Forces Hearing Transcript regarding policy implications of lifting the ban on homosexuals in the military (May 4, 1993) 197 (DoD LA 2-6 43653-44032) U.S. Senate Committee on Armed Services Hearing Transcript "Testimony from Current and Former Members of the Military Services of Gay Men and Lesbians in the Armed Forces" (May 11, 1993) (DoD LA 2-6 43411198 43652) 20

Incomplete (part of legislative history)

Incomplete (part of legislative history)

199

200

201

202 203

RAND National Defense Research Institute, "Homosexuals and U.S. military Personnel Policy : Policy Options and Assessment" (interim report, June 3, 1993) Memorandum from Attorney General Janet Reno to President Clinton regarding defensibility of the new policy on homosexual conduct in the military (June 19, 1993) (OSD OEPM 14872-14873) H.W. Frank, "Legal Issues Raised during Senate Committee on Armed Forces" (Military Working Group, draft issue paper, Apr. 15, 1993) Ben G. Miller, "Homosexuality is Incompatible with Military Service" (Military Working Group, draft issue paper, May 20, 1993) Military Working Group, "Draft Statement of Option #2" (Jul. 7, 1993) Memorandum from Les Aspin to Secretaries of the Army, Navy, Air Force and Joint Chiefs of Staff regarding Policy on Homosexual Conduct in the Armed Forces (Jul. 19, 1993) (PERSEC 7973 ­7979) Letter from Lee Aspin to Hon. Richard Shelby attaching Summary Report of the Military Working Group and RAND report "Sexual Orientation and U.S. Military Personnel Policy: Options and Assessments" (Aug. 26, 1993) (OSD P&R 7428-7454) Dep't of Defense, "DOD/GC Homosexual Conduct Implementation Memo and Service/GC Responses" (Dec. 9, 1993) (OSD OEPM 13347-13378) DoD Directive No. 1304.26 (Qualification Standards for Enlistment, Appointment and Induction, Dec. 21, 1993) (DoD Issuances WHS 58075-58084) 21

Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

Relevance (draft document); Foundation; FRE 403

Relevance; Foundation Relevance (draft document); Foundation; FRE 403

204

205

206

Relevance; Foundation

207

Memorandum from Edwin Dorn to Assistant Secretaries of Army, Navy, Airforce regarding Training Guidance for DoD Policy on Homosexual Conduct in the Armed Forces 208 (Dec. 21, 1993) (OSD OEPM 31205 ­ 31229) Relevance; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; M. Cammermeyer, Serving in Silence Foundation 209 (Viking, 1994) W. J. Scott and S.C. Stanley, Gays and Lesbians in the Military: Issues, Concerns, and Contrasts (Aldine de Bruyter, 1994) Dep't of Defense, "DOD Policy on Homosexual Conduct Training Plan" (U.S. Military Entrance Processing Command, 1994) (PERSEC 7912-7972) Philippe Manigart, "Comparative International Military Personnel Policies Homosexuals in Belgian Military" (U.S. Army Research Institute, Jan. 1994) (ARI 61001 ­ 61026) "Additional Q's & A's for Mr. Dorn's Deposition" (Feb. 11, 1994) (OSD OEPM 27530-27531) DoD Instruction 5505.8, "Investigations of Sexual Misconduct by the Defense Criminal Investigative Organizations and Other DoD Law Enforcement Organizations" (Feb. 28, 1994) (DoD LA 7-10 48964 ­ 48967) DoD Directive No. 1304.26, Change 1 (Update) Qualification Standards for Enlistment, Appointment and Induction (Mar. 4, 1994) (DoD LA 7-10 48889 ­ 48945) Memorandum from John Deutch to the Secretaries of the Military Departments, "Recoupment of Education Assistance Funds, Bonuses and Special Pay...Basis of Homosexual Conduct" (May 17, 1994) (OSD OEPM 30783 -30786) 22 Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation

210

211

Relevance; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

212 213

214

215

216

Relevance; Foundation

217

218

219

220

221

222

223

224

Canadian Forces, "Briefing Note for Director of Public Policy" (Aug. 25, 1995) C. Dixon Osburn, "A Policy in Desperate Search of a Rationale: The Military's Policy on Lesbians, Gays, and Bisexuals," 64 University of Missouri-Kansas City Law Review 199 (1995) Lois Shawver, "And the Flag Was Still There: Straight People, Gay People, and Sexuality in the U.S. Military" (Harrington Park Press, 1995) Servicemembers Legal Defense Network, "Conduct Unbecoming: The First Annual Report on "Don't Ask, Don't Tell, Don't Pursue, Don't Harass" (1995) (LCR 40134044) Letter from Senate Armed Services Committee to Judith Ann Miller regarding Able v. US (Jul. 13, 1995) (DoD LA 2-6 44344-44346) Memorandum from Harlan Wilder to all staff JAGs regarding clarification of policy on homosexual conduct in the armed forces (Aug. 29, 1995) (DoD LA 2-6 044347) Servicemembers Legal Defense Network, "Conduct Unbecoming: The Second Annual Report on "Don't Ask, Don't Tell, Don't Pursue, Don't Harass" (Feb. 1996) (LCR 4045-4080) J. Halley, "The Status/Conduct Distinction in the 1993 Revisions to Military Anti-Gay Policy," 3 GLQ: a Journal of Lesbian and Gay Studies 159 (1996)

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation

Relevance; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation

Relevance; Hearsay; Gregory Herek et al. Out in Force; Sexual Orientation in the U.S. Military (University of Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation 225 Chicago Press, 1996 )

23

C.A. Rimmerman (Ed.), Gay Rights, Military Wrongs: Political Perspectives on Lesbians Relevance; Hearsay; and Gays in the Military (Garland Publishing, Hearsay within Hearsay; 226 Inc., 1996) Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Leisa Meyer, Creating GI Jane (Columbia Foundation 227 University Press, 1996) Dep't of Defense, "Separations for Homosexual Conduct, Fiscal Year 1996" (OSD OEPM 008310) Ministry of Defence, Report of the Homosexuality Policy Assessment Team (London, British Ministry of Defence, Feb. 1996) Dep't of Defense, "Discharge/Separation of Officer Members by branch, sex, and reason for separation" (Feb. 21, 1996) (OSD OEPM 008312 ­ 8376) Gregory M. Herek, "Successful Integration of Stigmatized Minorities into the U.S. Army: an Overview of Research Relevant to Personnel Policies Concerning Sexual Orientation" (U.S. Army Research Institute, June 26, 1996) (ARI 059823 ­ ARI 059908) Memorandum from Harlan Wilder to AF/JAG regarding the Air Force Equal Opportunity Policy Memorandum (Oct. 4, 1996) (DoD LA 2-6 44348) Servicemembers Legal Defense Network, "Conduct Unbecoming: The Third Annual Report on "Don't Ask, Don't Tell, Don't Pursue, Don't Harass" (Feb. 1997) (LCR 4081-4120)

228

Relevance; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

229

230

Relevance; Foundation

231

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation

232

Relevance; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

233

Dep't of Defense, "Information Paper" (DOD Relevance; Hearsay; 234 LA 2-6 040517-040522) (1980-1997) Foundation Letter from Robert Tyrer to Chief of Staff attaching Dep't of Defense, "Policy Governing Service of Homosexuals in the 235 Military" (Jul. 21, 1997) (DoD LA 2-6 Relevance; Foundation 24

040746-50) Dep't of Defense, "Rebuttal Cases" (Aug. 27, 236 1997) (16 LC 057844-057848) Memorandum from D.A. Anderson to Brad Weigman regarding follow-up information for SLDN report allegations (Oct. 31, 1997) 237 (DoD LA 2-6 044704) Memorandum from Commandant, U.S. Coast Guard to Office of the Under Secretary of Defense (Nov. 17, 1997) (DoD LA 2-6 238 40484-40488)

Relevance; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay Foundation

Relevance; Foundation

239 Not used Servicemembers Legal Defense Network, "Conduct Unbecoming: The Fourth Annual Report on "Don't Ask, Don't Tell, Don't Pursue, Don't Harass" (1998) (LCR 4121240 4199) Rob MacCoun, "Biases in the interpretation and use of research results,"(49 Annual 241 Review of Psychology 259-287 1998) E. Kier, "Homosexuals in the U.S. Military: Open Integration and Combat Effectiveness" 23 International Security 5 (1998) Melissa Sheridan Embser-Herbert, "Camouflage Isn't Only for Combat: Gender, Sexuality, and Women in the Military," (New York University Press, 1998). Dep't of Defense, "Homosexual Conduct Policy Briefing" (Jan 7, 1998) (DoD LA 2-6 40780-40787) Memorandum from Paul Mayberry to Bernie Rostker regarding trends in Navy Separations due to Homosexual Conduct (Jan. 19, 1998) (DoD LA 2-6 40723-40730) 25

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Foundation; Authentication

242

243 244

245

Relevance; Foundation

Memorandum from Bernard Rostker to Assistant Secretary of Defense (Force Management Policy) regarding clarification of Homosexual Separation Data (Feb. 24, 246 1998) (DoD LA 2-6 40760-40771) Office of the Under Secretary of Defense (Personnel and Readiness), "Report to the Secretary of Defense regarding Effectiveness of the Application and Enforcement of the Department's Policy on Homosexual Conduct in the Military" (Apr. 1998) (DoD LA 2-6 247 036014-036031)

Relevance; Foundation

Relevance; Foundation

248 Not used Memorandum from the Assistant Secretary of Defense to the Secretary of the Army an Airforce regarding Compliance with DoD Recoupment Policy (Oct. 16, 1998) (OSD Relevance; Foundation 249 OEPM 30781 ­ 30795)

Memorandum and report from Harlan Wilder to ASD/FMP (Nov. 3, 1998) (DoD LA 2-6 250 40799-407803) Servicemembers Legal Defense Network, "Conduct Unbecoming: The Fifth Annual Report on "Don't Ask, Don't Tell, Don't Pursue, Don't Harass" (1999) (LCR 4200251 4284)

Relevance; Foundation

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

26

Dep't of Defense, untitled report regarding number of DADT separations (DoD LA 2-6 252 040080-040081)

Relevance; Foundation

Dep't of Defense, report regarding number of DADT separations from FY 1994 to FY 1998 253 (Jan. 1999) (DoD LA 2-6 041168-041169) Dep't of Defense, "Statement by Under Secretary of Defense for Personnel and Readiness Rudy de Leon," (Jan. 22, 1999) 254 (DoD LA 2-6 036129-36133)

Relevance; Foundation

Relevance; Foundation

Memorandum from John P. McLaurin to Acting Assistant Secretary of Defense (Force Management Policy) regarding Compliance with DoD Recoupment Policy(Mar. 10, 1999) Relevance; Foundation 255 (OSD OEPM 30796) Memorandum from Harlan Wilder to Commander Defense Finance and Accounting Service regarding Debt Cancellations Mr. Joshua Jones 443-92-1188 and Ms. Jincy Pace 458-41-9079 (Mar. 10, 1999) (OSD Relevance; Foundation 256 OEPM 30797 ­ 30800) Memorandum from P.A. Tracey to the Director of Defense Finance and Accounting Service (Mar 17, 1999) (OSD OEPM 025367257 025368) Relevance; Foundation

27

Memorandum from Rudy De Leon to Secretaries of the Military Departments regarding Implementation of Recommendations to Homosexual Conduct Policy (Aug. 12, 1999) (DoD LA 2-6 035967258 035972) Sarah Lyall, "European Court Tells British to Let Gay Soldiers Serve," The New York Times, available at http://www.nytimes.com/1999/09/28/world/e uropean-court-tells-british-to-let-gay-soldiers259 serve.html (Sept. 29, 1999) Sig Christenson, "Gay separations down by half ," San Antonio Express News, Oct. 11, 260 1999 (DoD LA 2-6 036056-036058) Servicemembers Legal Defense Network, "Conduct Unbecoming: The Sixth Annual Report on "Don't Ask, Don't Tell, Don't Pursue, Don't Harass" (2000) (LCR 4285261 4371) Dep't of Defense, "Homosexuality and the Armed Forces ­ Commanding Officers Information Pack" (Jan. 2000) (OSD OEPM 262 30885­30893) Ministry of Defence, "A Review of the Armed Forces Policy on Homosexuality," 263 (London: British Ministry of Defense, 2000)

Relevance; Foundation

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

Relevance; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

Palm Center, "Report of the General/Flag 264 Officers' Study Group" (2008) Dep't of Defense, "Implementation of the DOD Homosexual Conduct Policy" (Jan 14, Relevance; Hearsay; 265 2000) (OSD OEPM 31413 ­ 31684) Foundation Dep't of Defense, "Evaluation Report: Military Environment with Respect to the Homosexual Conduct Policy" (Mar. 16, 2000) 266 (DoD LA 2-6 036334-82) Relevance; Foundation

28

267

268

269 270

Memorandum from Harlan Wilder to AF/SGJ (Mar. 20, 2000) (DoD LA 2-6 035829) Letter from Charles Moskos to Secretary Cohen regarding doctors, psychologists, and inspectors general "turning in" servicemembers who make private statements (Apr. 12, 2000) (OSD OEPM 026438) Dep't of the Army Inspector General, "DAIG Special Assessment/ Investigation of Allegations of Violations of the DOD Homosexual Conduct Policy at Fort Campbell" (Jul. 2000) (DOD LA 2-6 036135036332) Office of the Assistant Secretary of Defense, "DoD News Briefing" (Jul 21, 2000) (OSD OEPM 31015­ 31026)

Relevance; Foundation

Relevance; Foundation; Authentication

Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation

271 Not used Steven Lee Myers, "Military Reserves are Falling Short in Finding Recruits," New York 272 Times, Aug. 28, 2000 Servicemembers Legal Defense Network, "Conduct Unbecoming: The Seventh Annual Report on "Don't Ask, Don't Tell, Don't Pursue, Don't Harass" (2001) (LCR 4372273 4474) Gary Gates, "Lesbians and Gay Men in the U.S. Military: Estimates from Census 2000" 274 (LCR WI 1028-1050) Dep't of the Army, Army Publication 600-5, "Dignity and Respect, a Training Guide on 275 Homosexual Conduct Policy" (2001)

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation

Relevance; Foundation

Gail H. McGinn, "Homosexual Conduct Policy: Background & Current Issues" (Jul. 3, 2001) (OSD OEPM 31061 ­ 31074, 31188 ­ 276 311201) Relevance; Foundation

29

277

278

279

280 281

282

283

Servicemembers Legal Defense Network, "Conduct Unbecoming: The Eighth Annual Report on "Don't Ask, Don't Tell, Don't Pursue, Don't Harass" (2002) (LCR 44754531) Aaron Belkin and J. McNichol, "Pink and Blue: Outcomes Associated with the Integration of Open Gay and Lesbian Personnel in the San Diego Police Department," 5 Police Quarterly 63 (2002) Servicemembers Legal Defense Network, "Conduct Unbecoming: The Ninth Annual Report on "Don't Ask, Don't Tell, Don't Pursue, Don't Harass" (2003) (LCR 45324592) SLDN Human Rights Watch, "Uniform Discrimination: The DADT Policy of the U.S. Military" (Jan. 2003) (OSD OEPM 31318 ­ 31373) David R. Segal and Mady Wechsler Segal, America's Military Population (Population Bulletin, 57:4, Dec. 2004). Melissa Sheridan Embser-Herbert, "A Missing Link: Institutional Homophobia and Sexual Harassment in the U.S. Military" in In the Company of Men: Male Dominance and Sexual Harassment (2005) Elizabeth Hillman and Elizabeth Lutes, Defending America: Military Culture and the Cold War Court-Martial (Princeton University Press, 2005)

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Duplicate of Ex. 214

DoD Directive 5505.8 (Jan. 24, 2005) (DoD 284 Issuances WHS 058644-48) Memorandum from Gail McGinn to Under Secretary of Defense regarding DoD Response to GAO Draft Report "Financial Costs and Loss of Critical Skills Due to DOD's Homosexual Conduct Policy Cannot 285 be Completely Estimated"(P&R) (Feb. 4, 30

Relevance; Foundation

2005) (13 LC 057231-57232) Letter from David Chu to Derek Stewart regarding DoD response to Government Accountability Office, draft report "Financial Costs and Loss of Critical Skills Due to DOD's Homosexual Conduct Policy Cannot be Completely Estimated"(GAO) (Feb. 7, 286 2005) (13 LC 57225-57229)

Relevance; Foundation

Military Readiness Enhancement Act of 2005 287 (Mar. 2, 2005) (OSD OEPM 31402 ­ 31405)

Relevance

288 Not used Letter from Michael Dominguez to Senator Ron Wyden regarding response to letter to Secretary Rumsfield regarding DoD homosexual conduct policy in the military 289 (Sept. 21, 2006) (13 LC 57312-57313) Email from Franklin Pinch to Paul Gade regarding Gays in the Canadian Military 290 (Nov. 1, 2000) (AR 62002-62004)

Relevance; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Authentication

291 Not used Bradford Booth et al. "What We Know About Army Families: 2007 Update" (Caliber, 2007) Relevance; Hearsay; available at http://www.army.mil/fmwrc/documents/resea Hearsay within Hearsay; 292 rch/whatweknow2007.pdf] Foundation; Authentication

31

Rick Maze, "Rise in Moral Waivers Troubles Lawmaker," Army Times, Feb. 20, 2007, available at http://www.armytimes.com/news/2007/02/ap 293 WaivedRecruits070213/. 294 295 296 297 Alan Simpson, "Bigotry That Hurts Our Military", Washington Post, Mar. 14, 2007 Dep't of Defense, "Active Duty Separations By Service & ISC FY 2008" (DMDC 000034) Fred Kaplan, "Dumb and Dumber," Slate, Jan. 24, 2008, available at http://www.slate.com/id/2182752/ Foreign Policy Magazine, "The U.S. Military Index," 165 Foreign Policy 76 (March/April 2008) (LCR FP 220-222)

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation

Gary Gates, Testimoney regarding Don't Ask Don't Tell Submitted to U.S. House of Representatives Armed Services Committee 298 (Jul. 18, 2008) (LCR WI 01025-27) Kyle Dropp and Jon Cohen, "Acceptance of Gay People in Military Grows Dramatically," The Washington Post, Jul. 19, 2008, available at http://www.washingtonpost.com/wpdyn/conte nt/article/2008/07/18/AR2008071802561.htm 299 l

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation

Nathaniel Frank, Unfriendly Fire (St. 300 Martin's Press, 2009) Margot Canaday, The Straight State: Sexuality and Citizenship in Twentieth Relevance; Hearsay; Century America (Princeton University Press, Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation 301 2009)

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation

32

Rachel Maddow, "The Rachel Maddow Show for Tuesday, May 19," available at http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/30869189/. 302 (May 21, 2009) Spencer Ackerman, "`Don't Ask, Don't Tell Repeal Preview?' Gates Opened CIA to Gays," Washington Independent, June 8, 2009, available at http://washingtonindependent.com/46071/dad 303 t-repeal-preview-gates-opened-cia-to-gays. General John M. Shalikashvili, "Gays in the Military: Let the Evidence Speak," The Washington Post, June 19, 2009, available at http://www.washingtonpost.com/wpdyn/content/article/2009/06/18/AR200906180 304 3497.html

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation

President Obama, Remarks at the LBGT Pride Month Reception (June 29, 2009) (LCR 305 3999-4002) Relevance President Obama, Remarks at the Human Rights Campaign Dinner (Oct. 11, 2009) 306 (LCR 3995-3998) Col. Om Prakash, "The Efficacy of `Don't Ask, Don't Tell,'" 55 Joint Force Quarterly 307 88 (2009) (LCR 4776-4782) Lawrence Kapp and Charles Henning, "Recruiting and Retention: An Overview of FY2008 and FY2009 Results for Active and Reserve Component Enlisted Personnel" (Congressional Research Service, Nov. 30, 308 2009) Dep't of Defense, report comparing homosexual conduct separation/recoupment 309 with weight control separation/recoupment 33

Relevance Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Foundation

(OSD OEPM 27009-27011) Interview by CNN with William Cohen (Jan. 310 30, 2010) Gary Gates, "Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Men and Women in the U.S. Military: Updated Estimates" (Williams Institute, Feb. 2010) (LCR WI 1013-1050) Transcript of Testimony regarding Department of Defense Authorization for Appropriations for Fiscal Year 2011, and to Receive Testimony Relating to the "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" Policy: Hearing Before the Sen. Armed Services Comm., 111th Cong., 2nd Sess. (Feb. 2, 2010) Peter Baker, "Powell Favors Repeal of `Don't Ask, Don't Tell,'" New York Times, Feb. 3, 2010 Julian Barnes, "Navy Moves to Allow Women on Submarines," Los Angeles Times, Feb. 24, 2010 Transcript of testimony given by Major Michael D. Almy to Senate Committee on Armed Services (Mar. 18, 2010) John McArdle, "Wesley Clark Backs Cunningham in North Carolina," (Roll Call, Mar. 29, 2010) Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

311

Relevance; Multiple Documents; Hearsay

312 313 314 315 316

Relevance Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation

Craig Whitlock, "A `Don't Ask, Don't Tell' Rules Complicate Survey of Troops on Policy 317 Change," (Washington Post, Mar. 31, 2010) Letter from American Bar Association President Carolyn Lamm to Senators Reid, McConnell, Levin, and McCain regarding support for repeal of 10 U.S.C. §654 (Apr. 318 26, 2010)

Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

34

319

320

321

322

Transcript of Testimony regarding Hearing to Receive Testimony Relating to the "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" Policy Before the Sen. Armed Services Comm., 111th Cong., 2nd Sess. (Mar. 18, 2010) Exhibits added to the record of the Hearing to Receive Testimony Relating to "Don't Ask, Don't Tell" Policy Before the Sen. Armed Serives. Comm., 111th Cong., 2nd Sess. (Mar. 18, 2010) President Obama, statement on votes to repeal "Don't Ask, Don't Tell," available at http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-pressoffice/statement-president-votes-repeal-don-task-don-t-tell) (May 27, 2010) Memorandum from John Hutson to the ViceChief of Naval Operations regarding Homosexual Conduct Policy (NAVY 058930-058931)

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

Relevance

Relevance; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

Personnel Security Research Center, table showing surveys of servicemembers on a 323 variety of topics (PERSEC 7945 ­ 7954) Information Paper by Jim Woodard to Secretary of Defense regarding Implementation and Status of DoD Policy on Homosexual Conduct (OSD OEPM 8383 ­ 324 8384)

Relevance; Foundation

Dep't of Defense, untitled "questions and 325 answers" (OSD OEPM 8390 ­ 8391) Memorandum from Rudy de Leon to the Secretaries of the Military Departments regarding the application and enforcement of the homosexual conduct policy (DoD LA 2-6 326 040075-040076) 35

Relevance; Foundation; Incomplete

Relevance; Foundation

Dep't of Defense, document titled "Questions for the record: Ms. Gorelick" (DoD LA 2-6 327 042624-28)

Relevance (draft of information in legislative history); Foundation; FRE 403 Relevance (draft of information in legislative history); Foundation; FRE 403

Dep't of Defense, "Proceedings Involving 328 Homosexuality" (OSD OEPM 053537)

Dep't of Defense, document regarding definition of homosexual statement (16 LC 329 57849-52)

Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

330 Not used

Dep't of Defense, "Anti-Harassment Action 331 Plan" (OSD OEPM 30852­ 30853) Government Accountability Office, Draft "Financial Costs and Loss of Critical Skills Due to DOD's Homosexual Conduct Policy Cannot be Completely Estimated" (OSD 332 OEPM 31406 ­31412)

Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation

Relevance; Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication

36

333 334 335

336

Palm Center, "Creators of Gay Ban Tell Author it was `Based on Nothing,'" available at http://www.palmcenter.org/press/dadt/release s/Creators+of+Military+Gay+Ban+Tell+Auth or+It+Was+%22Based+on+Nothing%22+. (Mar. 2, 2009) Dep't of Defense, "Policy Concerning Homosexuality in the Armed Forces" (DoD LA 7-10 48968 ­ 49031) Dep't of Defense, Department of Defense and Military Working Group Schematic Diagrams and Charts Interview by CNN with Chairman Di Paola "NATO Chairman Di Paola: Allowing Gay men and Lesbians to serve openly working out quite well" (Media Matters from America , Feb. 24 , 2010)

Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Foundation; Authentication Relevance; Foundation Relevance; Hearsay; Hearsay within Hearsay; Foundation

1001 Not used

37