Perfect 10 Inc v. Google Inc et al

Filing 600

SUPPLEMENT to EX PARTE APPLICATION to Compel re: Perfect 10, Inc.: Defendant Google Inc.'s Joinder in Defendants Amazon.com, Inc. and Alexa Internet's Ex Parte Application for an Order Compelling Perfect 10, Inc. to Affix Production Numbers to its Product #596 Google Inc.'s Supplemental Memorandum in Support of its Joinder in Defendants Amazon.com, Inc. and Alexa Internet's Ex Parte Application and Response to Perfect 10, Inc.'s Opposition Thereto filed by Counter Claimant Google Inc, Defendant Google Inc. (Attachments: #1 Supplemental Declaration of Thomas Nolan in Support Thereof, and Exhibits Thereto)(Herrick, Rachel)

Perfect 10 Inc v. Google Inc et al

Doc. 600 Att. 1

2 3 4 S 6 7 S

QUINN EMANUEL URQUHART OLIVER & HEDGES, LLP Michael T. Zeller Bar o. 196417} michaelzeller @ qumnemanuel.com 865 South Figueroa Street, 10th Floor Los Angeles , California 90017-2543 Telephone : [phone] Facsimile : 213 443-3100 Charles K. erhoeven (Bar No . 170151 } charlesverhoeven @ uinnemanuel.com 50 California Street, 2nd Floor San Francisco California 94111 Rachel Herrick Kassabian (Bar No. 191060} rachelkassabian quinnemanueI.com 555 Twin Dolphin rive , Suite 560 Redwood Shores, Califarnia 94065

9 Attorneys for Defendant GOGGLE TNC. 10 11 12 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA CASE NO. CV 04-9484 AT IM (SHz^) [Consolidated with Case No. CV 054753 AHM {SHx}] SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF THOMAS NOLAN IN SUPPORT OF GOGGLE INC.'S SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF YTS JOINDER IN DEFENDANTS AMAZON.COM, INC. AND ALEXA INTERNET' S EX PARTS APPLICATION AND RESPONSE TO PERFECT 10'5 OPPOSITION THERETO Hon. Stephen r. Hillman Date: November 3, 2009 Time: 10:00 A.M. Crtrm.: 5 50 Discovery Cut-off: None Set Pre-trial (.:onference: None Set Trial Date: None Set

13 PERFECT 10, INC., a California corporation, 14 Plaintiff, 15
vs.

16

GOGGLE INC. a corporation; and DOES 1 throug^ 100, inclusive, 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 vs. PERFECT 10, INC., a California corporation, Plaintiff, Defendants.

AND COUNTERCLAIM

24 AMAZON.COM, INC., a corporation; A9.COM, INC. a corporation; and 25 DOES 1 through 100, inclusive, 26 27 28
O 1980 .5 ] 32013186237.2

Defendants.

SUPPLEMENTAI. NOLAN DECLARATION IN SUPPORT QI~ GOOGLE'S JOINDER IN EX PARTS APPLICATION

Dockets.Justia.com

1 21

I, Thomas Nolan, declare as follows: 1. I am a member ofthe bar ofthe State of California and an associate

3 ^ with Quinn Emanuel Urquhart Oliver & Hedges , LLP, counsel for Defendant 4 Google Inc. in this action. I make this declaration of my personal and firsthand 5 knowledge and, if called and sworn as a witness, I could and would competently 6 ^ testify thereto. 7 2. I submit this declaration in support of Defendant Google Inc.'s

8 Supplemental Memorandum in Support of its Joinder in Defendants Amazon.com, 9 Inc. and Alexa Internet's Ex Pate Application and Response to Perfect 10's 10 Opposition Thereto (filed concurrently herewith}. 11 3. On October 22, 2009 Perfect 10 produced a hard drive to Google. I

12 ^ have personally reviewed the hard drive. The October 22, 2009 hard drive includes 13 folders titled "usenet" and "google." These folders contain thousands of f les. In 14 my review of the contents of these folders, I saw no subfolder or file name labeled 1S, with any clear reference to the Court's Order dated October 6, 2009. One of the 16^ documents contained on this hard drive is file titled "U.S. Copyright Office 17'^ Service Provider Agents.pdf' that is located in the "whois" folder, is 1,429 pages 18'. long, includes a URL from the website www.cop^ght.gov, is titled "Directory of 19' Service Provider Agents for Notification of Claims of Infringement," and contains 20I 25 pages of what appear to be electronic scans of hard copy documents. One of the 21 folders on this hard drive is titled "articles after production" and contains news

22 articles and similar documents. In reviewing the hard drive produced by Perfect 10 23 on October 22, 2009 (and previous hard drives produced by Perfect 10 in this 24i matter), I have observed that many of the produced files were not text-searchable. 25 For example, many of the copyright registration certificates and contracts that 26, Perfect 10 has produced were not in text-searchable format. 27 4. Attached hereto as Exhlblt A Is a true and correct copy of an electronic

28 file I created using the program Snagit 9. The f le is a screenshot of the properties
01980.5132013188237.2 ^..

SUPPLEMENTAL NOLAN DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OP GOOGLE'S JOINDER IN EX PARTS APPLICATION

1 ^ of the "usenet" folder of Perfect 10's electronic document production of October 22, 2 2009, as viewed on my computer using Windows Explorer. 3
S. Attached hereto as Exhibit B is a true and correct copy of an electronic

4 file I created using the program Snagit 9. The file is a screenshot of the properties 5 of the "google" folder of Perfect 10's electronic document production of October 6 22, 2009, as viewed on my computer using Windows Explorer. 7 6. On November 25, 2008 Perfect 10 produced a hard drive to Google. I

8 have personally reviewed the hard drive. The hard drive contains a large number of 9I documents spread throughout 49 first-level folders and multiple subfolders. In my 10 review of the hard drive I located no folders of documents labeled "financial 11 documents," "damages documents," or with any sort of clear reference to any of

12 Google Inc.'s Requests for Production of Documents in this matter. 13 7. Attached hereto as Exhibit C is a true and correct copy of an electronic

14 file I created using the program Snagit 9. The file is a screenshot of the file 15 structure of Perfect 10's electronic document production of November 25, 2008, as 16 viewed on my computer using Windows Explorer. 17 $. Attached hereto as Exhibit D is a true and correct copy of an electronic

18 file I created using the program Snagit 9. The f le is a screenshot of the properties 19 of the "0 0 0 for next production" folder of Perfect 10's electronic document 20 production of November 25, 2008, as viewed on my computer using Windows 21 Explorer. 22 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of

23 America that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed November 6, 2009 at Los 24 Angeles, California. 25 26 27
28 ai9sos^s2ars^sa2s^.2
_ -_^SUPPLEMENTAL NOLAN DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OF GOOGLE'S 70INDER IN $X PARTE APPLICATION

Thomas Nolan

EXHIBIT A

^ ^:eSa C3 ^kaFs - ^ .,. ^ ... . _. _ ^ . _. ^^

._....°- j -. ^II^'i^^

._.

^q f s ^AJ ^_ J

.-'rte

_.

^iE^

^^iL

^='-'v -7firY^ ^

.....

E_..

^^+t^i^

... . ..

)^i[^^p _
1

_

__

_

-,
{

_._

.._

-

_

.

f^ '^^;

Bads
r^

' rte

se arch

Folders

^`,` ,

^.
^ Co
^.

^` ^ ^unazori

AUi_

'^ General

Secu

customize. ^ -----

arbd^s after production Ichau prod Curtis most offered at i^a^use
[^ ^ (^ DMCJ^ n^ i sc

^ .^^, ^ usenet

I^efFarts tantracts
f^gr^agle

Type : Location: Size: Size on disk : Carrtains: Created :
^.tribvtes:

Fife.Frlder E:'1 ^.GB ^4,87^,3^6 ,3^5bytes) ^4.^3 GB {^,8^^,4^,ia7^ bytes} ^7,3^4^ Flee. 21'a[ders t^^artda}7 , (7ctaber
^ Read -en ^ Hidden

Imo+^ie ttr authorizatians (^neu^^ releases and copyright f^rapidshare

l^us^net
^^t^Elvis ^z i bills far usenet

^'
p 1

, ^t^.^, 4:3^ :^^ Pfu1
-:^dv^need -. ,

^1^

Car^^el

..^^i^

1 abjects: selected

,,.;

My Computer

EXHIBIT PAGE

^ ^

EXHIBIT B

gamy u^^eber (Andre i=elix

^
I

j

ra j _v ;;
_ F'

.^, AC}L
Iartides after praduciion d^au prod
curds mast offered at frause (^ QMC,^. mist efforts contracts I^^oogle

General ._;^^Secu^'.
^- ^-- W `^ ^---^-----^goagle

T}fie: Location: Size: Size an disk: Contains: Created:

Rle Folder E:'^. x.43 Gg ^1^.1^^.3.i^,^-416yte^} 9.^5 GB {1^Y,15D.^55,S3S taytes^ ^,^^^ Files. 1,t}7^Folders 1^landa}^, October ^, ^^^, x:15:51 Pty

ma+^ie tv authorizations new releases and copyright rapidsllare
I^usenet (^ ^^E,ois

^x 1 bills far usenet

EXHIBIT B S PAGE

EXHIBIT C

-

^__^:-^

File

Edit

Vies^^

Favorites

Tools

Help : f^ Folders ^ !' . ,^;--

.'?^^= ^: g^ #-a
^ Go Siae ; Type File Folder File Folder

^adc - ^ `3 ^`'^ ^;:^
Aticiress ^ F:^ _ _ Name r = _ {[JO 0 0 for next production

.^ Search

Date T+1adified . _ .... ...^. ....A_t.r_butes ^:^..' .. t i ...._._: f 11f26f2t10$ 1 03 PM A
1112612008 i.03 PM 111261200$ 1:06 PT^I 11,PZ6f200S 1:D6 PT^1 11fZbf200$ 1:20 PM 11126 12008 1:20 PM 1112612008 1:20 PM 1112612008 1:20 PM 111261200$ 1;23 PNl 11126f2D0$ 1:23 PT·1 11('26(2008 1:23 FT^I A A A A A A '

^a9 pa^sn^ords (^adver^sers I(^agree:rnent5 ly^amazc^n ^aol articles I^bndyinmind reports (^celebs blagspot (^cellphone dayvnfoads Ij^chillingeffett^ (^ compliments
jconne+ctions

File Folder Fife Folder
File Folder

File Folder File Folder
File Folder File Folder File Folder

A
A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A

File Folder Fife Folder
FileFalder File Folder

5 f 7f 2049 3: 51 PM
llfZ6j200$ 1;73 PM 1112612008 2:16 PM

Icapyright (^Qed[t card processors
(defame

File Folder Fife Folder ^
File Folder File Folder File Folder File Folder File Folder

11f26f2A08 2:16 PM
5f7fZD09 3:51 PM 1112612008 2:16 PT^1 5f7f2D09 3:51 PM 1112612008 2:16 FM 11f261ZDD$ Z:16 PM 1112612008 2:54 PM

j{^disdairners ^displa^+ (^da^n^nloads
'y iglam0ur,com ^google

^hegre '^Holly^r^+aod requests i^image findtarget
Image recognition

File Folder
File Felder File Folder File Folder

11126f20D$ 2:54 PM
11{26f2D0$ 2:54 PM 1112612008 2:54 FM 111261200$ Z:5^4 PM

I^imagevertue l^msn nasty
not fair use

File Felder
File Folder

11120 f2D0$ 2:54 PM
51712009 3:51 PM

A
A A

File Folder
File Folder

11126120D$ 3:14 PM
1112ofZD08 3:14 FM

A
A

^nudecelebforum.rom i^pass^n^ords
phun, org

File Folder File Folder
File Folder

rapidshare 43D08 rapidshare 81608 nz
rapidshare connections

File Folder
File Folder File Folder

11f2612DD8 3: 14 PM 1112612005 3;14 PM 11 f 2612008 3:23 PM 1 i f 26 f 2DD8 3:23 PM
11126fZOD8 3:23 PM 11f26f2D08 3:23 PM

A
A

A
A A

ij^rapidshare dovanloaded .5D908 Ij;^rapidshare dav,^nloaded 61208 i^rapidshare daranlvaded 63008
}rapidshare markets

File Folder
File Folder File Folder File Folder

11126120D8 3:24 PM 11(2612008 3:24 PM
1112o1ZD08 3:25 PM 111261 2008 3:26 PM

A A
A A A A A A A A

rapidshare using gaogle links ^remaves entire cp site
]^jrights triofa6ans

File Folder
File Folder File Folder File Folder

11(2612008 3:26 FM
11 f 2612D08 3:26 Ph1 1112612005 3:26 PM 11/2612008 3: Z6 PM

,
f 1

ij^safe search ^snagit trademark i^ucgalleries fur[ breakdown by site i^ usenet i^^rehais I ^.._ ..: ^.^.:.^ .. ._.:_._ ii

File Folder File Folder File Folder
File Folder

1112612DD8 3:26 PM 5 f 7/2.009 3:51 PM
^J j^C{1^8 ^ 3;^6 PM ! 1 ^, 1 { .4^ 31 26 PM ^ 1 8 3:32 PM 8 '^·"^^ °r^^

A
A

File Folder File Folder

A a ^.-

^^ v

-^n r em.. ^. r",^^ s,r.. r._ ^_ ..i__

rn ..L..:., ^...: li^:..l. JG......,-.,r... nn ,t ra\

EXHIBIT D

r.

_ ^,

E^^^; T >" °^

-. ^a^v Trite,

_ ...,. .
__ . ^ ^...

l_

i

4'r` '^ ^ ^^^^ I

i=iie ^

Eui^ Bade

i r^^^l^

weld,
i

^ ., ;-^ r ^ ,^ ,^ SeareFt

^^ Folders ^

I ^.

,.

^.,

^

^ ^ a : a..
_y Ga , . ^_ .

^^ 1^ s ^ddre^s tame ^-

..._.._

,....._ ...... _... ^w_._ !_._.:..._.__,_, ,

Size j Type File Folder File Folder

date Mr^difie^d ^^^,>rz0tl8 1:03 I
Y

t ^0 p f ] for next production } I,^a9 passFn^ards f^,advertisers Ll
1J'^^^iJ

^^f, ^^7i^f ^^.RJI',4r^lR^^^^^^i, .7-.:: ^ ^.., r,.,.`

fzE)a8 ^;06I ,^?J^08 1'; 20 I J2t708 i:^^ I ^Z008 ^.:z01 f ^t108 1; z0 I

^a^reyements s (am^zan ao] ar'^eles ,^ ^ bad^+inmind reports

..^rw_ ._._.. Genetaf . Becurrty

Cu^tomtze µ.M^mm^^^-^
IC

^ ^ E3 [ii for next production

,E (,cel^bs blagspat ^cellphane dv^r^n[aads ^cl^illir^geffe^ (-compliments
Canrl^CtianS

/z008 1;Z3 l

T}fie: Location: Bite: Bite an disk : Car^tains : Created : Attributes :

Fle Folder ^ F:\ ^ . ^2 GB i?.9^' 1,^1 t' , ^;a7 t7ytes^ 7.^5 GB (^.^.3 b}^es}

^zraos ^; zs ^zaQS ^; z3 I as ^; si I^r^ ^zQOS ^., z3 I
X2008 z; i6 I

I ^

cop^rigl^t crediit Lard processors ({defame

1,152 Rles , 3{^^ Fo[ders ^'fednesday , h^avember z'6, 2^[}8,12:54:3 Pf^1 ® sRead^^.l^
Hidden

Er f 2008 2; i6 f,:

^ ^disd^irriers 'E Idispl^^ I ^jdour+r^lodds I ^glam0ur.oam f (^j^aagle ^^hegre ^Holly^n^ood requests

^2oos 2;16 I
U9 3:.51 Pfd /zOQB 2;16 I ^zQQB 2;16 I J.^Q08 2;541 j20C38 2; 5^ 1 f 2(1[18 Z; 5^ I

1^^ranced

^,, ima^e findtarget ^
^Ima^e recognition

^zaos 2; 54 ^
f z408 2:54 I

°

imagevenue

}zoos z: 5^ i
0^ 3;51 Rr^i

i,^ msn
,,, ^^^nast"y not fair use

{zoos ^; i^ I
^z^oa x, 14 I
File Folder File Folder
File Folder File Folder File Folder 1.1Jz6JzOQE3 3;1^F { 11,^7^^2008 3;1^ I ^1J'26 (2008

^rsudecelebfarum.cam
l^ pass^n^ards

^phun.ary rapidshare X3008 rapidshare ^ 1608 na I,^rapidshare connections l^Jrapidshare do^n^nloaded 5008 ^rapidshare do^n^nioaded 61208 ^rapidsl^are dav.^nloaded 630()8
1^ r^nir^a^^rc MnrLnh

File Folder File Folder File Folder File F^ ^ ^^ ^
^i^a ^

i1^z6{zoos 3:23 1 3;z^ I ii fzs{zoos ^; z.^ ^i^z^^zoos ^; z^^ i
1126 f 2008 3; 2^4 I 11f26f2008

^;z^ I i1^z6^zoas ^; z5 I

1 oBjec>rs ;selected

'

^y ^.ompu^er