Ernest DeWayne Jones v. Robert K. Wong

Filing 110

ORDER AMENDING BRIEFING SCHEDULE AND SETTING HEARING ON CLAIM 27 by Judge Cormac J. Carney: Accordingly, the briefing schedule on Claim 27 is hereby amended as follows: 3. The hearing on Claim 27 is scheduled for August 4, 2014 at 11 a.m. (see document for complete details) (Attachments: # 1 Supplement) (mu)

Download PDF
Death Sentences in California, 1978 – 1997 1 Between 1978 and 1997, 591 death judgments were imposed by the State of California. This chart describes the current case status of the 496 individuals sentenced in that time period whose death sentences have not been overturned by the California Supreme Court (unless subsequently reinstated) and whose postconviction proceedings have not been stayed to determine their mental competency to face the death penalty. Of these 496 individuals, 13 were executed by the State (Red), 18 had relief denied by the federal courts but have had their executions stayed (Pink), 37 had their death sentences vacated by the federal courts and are no longer on Death Row (Blue), 80 died on Death Row from causes other than execution by the State of California (Orange), 167 are currently having their habeas petitions evaluated by federal district courts (Green) or the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals (Purple), and 181 are still having their appeals reviewed by the California Supreme Court, either on direct or collateral review (Yellow). The chart is current through April 2014. 2 Name Lavell Frierson Doug Stankewitz Ronald Bell Robert Harris Earl Jackson Keith Williams David Murtishaw Robert Massie Richard Chase Stevie Fields David Ghent Richard Montiel James Anderson Steven Ainsworth Richard Phillips Alejandro Ruiz David Moore Marvin Walker Date Sentenced 8/14/1978 10/12/1978 3/2/1979 3/9/1979 Federal Case Number 92-06251 DDP 91-00616 AWI 99-20615 RMW 90-00380 E 3/19/1979 95-03286 ER 4/13/1979 89-00160 REC 4/27/1979 5/25/1979 6/8/1979 8/29/1979 10/30/1979 11/20/1979 11/30/1979 1/30/1980 2/20/1980 2/21/1980 4/30/1980 9/8/1980 Federal Judicial District Central Eastern Northern Southern Date Federal Habeas Proceedings Initiated 3 10/19/1992 11/15/1991 4/12/1991 3/26/1990 Current Case Status Relief Granted (2007) Relief Granted (2012) CD Cal Petition Pending Executed (1992) Years Since Sentenced --35 -- Central Eastern 5/17/1995 Relief Granted (2008) / Resentenced to Death (2010) 2/22/1989 Executed (1996) 35 -- 91-00508 OWW 99-02861 CAL Eastern Northern 92-00465 AHM 90-02763 RMW 96-05412 LJO 03-07948 JLS 90-00329 LKK 92-05167 AWI 89-04126 FMC Central Northern Eastern Central Eastern Eastern Central 94-01997 PJH Northern 9/10/1991 Relief Granted (2001) / Resentenced to Death / Deceased (2011) 6/14/1999 Executed (2001) Deceased (1980) 1/23/1992 Relief Denied (2007) / Execution Stayed 9/26/1990 Relief Granted (2002) 4/22/1996 ED Cal Petition Pending 11/4/2003 CD Cal Petition Pending 3/16/1990 Relief Granted (2001) 3/4/1992 Relief Granted (2012) 7/11/1989 Deceased (2007) Deceased (1980) 6/7/1994 ND Cal Petition Pending ---35 -35 35 ----34 1 Darrell Rich Jerry Bunyard Bernard Hamilton Lawrence Bittaker Harvey Heishman Eric Kimble Stanley Williams Robert McLain Joe Johnson Anthony Bean Stephen Anderson Oscar Gates Michael Burgener Ronald Hawkins Billy Ray Hamilton John Davenport Russell Coleman Edgar Hendricks Gary Guzman Fernando Caro Bluford Hayes Jr. Phillip Lucero Richard Hovey Carlos Avena Albert Brown Willie Branner Rondald Sanders William Payton William Bonin Benjamin Silva Darnell Lucky Richard Boyde 1/23/1981 2/2/1981 3/2/1981 3/22/1981 3/30/1981 4/6/1981 4/15/1981 5/12/1981 5/28/1981 7/20/1981 7/24/1981 8/7/1981 9/4/1981 9/20/1981 10/16/1981 11/4/1981 11/20/1981 12/4/1981 12/22/1981 1/5/1982 1/22/1982 1/26/1982 2/10/1982 2/12/1982 2/22/1982 2/26/1982 3/3/1982 3/5/1982 3/12/1982 3/15/1982 4/7/1982 4/20/1982 89-00823 EJG Eastern 92-00474 B 91-01643 TJH 90-01815 VRW 90-04826 SVW 89-00327 SVW 89-03061 JGD Southern Central Northern Central Central Central 90-00648 WBS 92-00488 JGD 88-02779 WHA 10-03399 GHK Eastern Central Northern Central 89-03758 THE 96-06883 DSF 89-01906 RMW 89-02901 EFL Northern Central Northern Northern 93-04159 JW 92-00603 DFL 01-02823 VAP 89-01430 MHP 96-08034 GHK 94-08150 ABC 90-03219 DLJ 92-05471 LJO 94-04779 R 91-00693 ER 90-03311 DT 91-00583 TJH 91-02522 GPS Northern Eastern Central Northern Central Central Northern Eastern Central Central Central Central Central 6/12/1989 Executed (2000) State Proceedings Pending 3/31/1992 Relief Granted (1994) / Resentenced to Death (1996) 3/27/1991 CD Cal Petition Pending 6/26/1990 Relief Denied (2010) / Execution Stayed 9/7/1990 CD Cal Petition Pending 1/18/1989 Executed (2006) 5/18/1989 Relief Granted (1998) State Proceedings Pending 5/18/1990 Relief Granted (1998) 1/24/1992 Executed (2002) 7/14/1988 ND Cal Petition Pending 5/6/2010 State Proceedings Pending Deceased (1983) 10/4/1989 Deceased (2007) 9/30/1996 State Proceedings Pending 6/2/1989 Relief Granted (2000) 8/7/1989 Relief Granted (1995) Deceased (1991) 11/23/1993 Relief Granted (2002) 4/14/1992 Relief Granted (2005) 3/27/2001 CD Cal Petition Pending 4/26/1989 Relief Granted (2006) 11/15/1996 Circuit Appeal Pending 12/5/1994 Relief Denied (2008) / Execution Stayed 11/9/1990 ND Cal Petition Pending 7/13/1992 ED Cal Petition Pending 7/18/1994 Relief Denied (2011) / Execution Stayed 2/7/1991 Executed (1996) 6/26/1990 Relief Granted (2005) 2/1/1991 CD Cal Petition Pending 5/9/1991 Relief Granted (2008) 2 -33 33 33 33 33 --33 --33 33 --33 -----32 -32 32 32 32 32 --32 -- Melvin Wade George Carpenter Gary Howard Richard Grant John Brown Manuel Babbitt Mose Willis Prentice Snow Adam Miranda James Karis James Karis Brett Pensinger Fernando Belmontes Bronte Wright Ronald Deere Joseph Poggi Clarence Allen Ricardo Sanders Craig Ross Steven Champion Michael Hamilton Maurice Keenan Ronald Fuller Denny Mickle Douglas Clark James Melton Michael Williams Jaturun Siripongs Malcolm Robbins Larry Roberts Larry Webster 5/21/1982 5/21/1982 5/27/1982 5/28/1982 6/15/1982 7/8/1982 7/26/1982 8/31/1982 9/17/1982 9/17/1982 9/17/1982 9/20/1982 10/6/1982 10/29/1982 11/10/1982 11/12/1982 11/22/1982 12/3/1982 12/10/1982 12/10/1982 12/17/1982 1/21/1983 2/3/1983 2/24/1983 3/16/1983 3/18/1983 4/1/1983 4/22/1983 5/12/1983 5/27/1983 6/9/1983 89-00173 R Central 88-07240 WJR 90-00779 JAM 90-02815 AHS 89-01407 WBS Central Eastern Central Eastern 12/8/1988 6/18/1990 6/1/1990 8/1/1989 89-07130 JLS 89-00527 LKK Central Eastern 12/11/1989 4/13/1989 92-01928 DSF Central 3/30/1992 89-00736 JAM 92-06918 AHM 92-01684 CAS Eastern Central Central 88-01123 FCD 96-07429 JFW 96-02720 SVW 96-02845 SVW 90-00363 OWW 89-02167 DLJ Eastern Central Central Central Eastern Northern 92-02951 THE 92-06567 PA 89-04182 RMT 90-01212 R 89-06530 WDK 91-04748 TJH 93-00254 TLN 93-00306 LKK Northern Central Central Southern Central Central Eastern Eastern Relief Granted (1994) Deceased (1984) Relief Granted (1996) Relief Granted (2010) CD Cal Petition Pending Executed (1999) Deceased (1988) State Proceedings Pending CD Cal Petition Pending Relief Granted (1998) / Resentenced to Death (2007) Deceased (2013) Circuit Appeal Pending 5/25/1989 Relief Denied (2010) / Execution Stayed 11/20/1992 Deceased (2000) 3/18/1992 Circuit Appeal Pending Deceased (1990) 8/31/1988 Executed (2006) 10/22/1996 Circuit Appeal Pending 4/16/1996 CD Cal Petition Pending 4/22/1996 State Proceedings Pending 6/12/1990 Relief Granted (2009) 6/22/1989 Relief Granted (2001) Deceased (1989) 7/30/1992 ND Cal Petition Pending 11/3/1992 CD Cal Petition Pending 7/13/1989 Relief Granted (2007) 8/31/1990 Relief Granted (1993) 11/9/1989 Executed (1999) 9/4/1991 CD Cal Petition Pending 2/18/1993 ED Cal Petition Pending 2/25/1993 ED Cal Petition Pending 3 ---32 --32 32 --32 32 -32 --32 32 32 ---31 31 ---31 31 31 Michael Morales Kevin Malone Gerald Gallego William Proctor George Marshall Martin Gonzalez Keith Adcox Francis Hernandez Albert Howard Douglas Mickey Alfred Dyer Demetrie Mayfield Constantino Carrera John Visciotti Donald Miller Robert Thompson David Mason Jackson Daniels Mark Reilly Andrew Robertson Donald Beardslee Michael Jennings Michael Hunter Charles Moore Michael Jackson Scott Pinholster Richard Ramirez Jesse Andrews Robert Diaz Stephan Mitcham Robert Bloom 6/14/1983 6/14/1983 6/21/1983 6/28/1983 6/28/1983 7/8/1983 7/11/1983 7/12/1983 8/3/1983 9/23/1983 9/26/1983 9/30/1983 91-00682 DT 96-04040 WJR 92-00653 SBA 96-01401 JAM 97-05493 AWI Central Central Northern Eastern Eastern 2/6/1991 6/7/1996 2/4/1992 7/31/1996 5/12/1997 92-05830 LJO 90-04638 RSWL 93-05726 LJO 93-00243 RMW 93-02823 VRW 94-06011 ER Eastern Central Eastern Northern Northern Central 12/1/1992 8/28/1990 10/25/1993 1/22/1993 7/29/1993 9/2/1994 10/7/1983 10/21/1983 11/10/1983 12/6/1983 1/27/1984 1/31/1984 2/1/1984 2/3/1984 3/13/1984 3/27/1984 3/28/1984 5/16/1984 5/21/1984 6/4/1984 6/4/1984 6/8/1984 6/15/1984 7/6/1984 7/23/1984 90-00478 AWI 97-04591 R 91-02652 NM 90-06605 CBM Eastern Central Central Central Eastern Central Central Central Northern Northern Northern Central Central Central Central Central Central Northern Central 7/31/1990 6/23/1997 5/16/1991 12/5/1990 92-04683 JSL 93-07055 JAK 90-04850 CBM 92-03990 SBA 89-01360 JW 90-03275 JW 91-05976 KN 91-04249 R 95-06240 GLT 07-08310 BRO 02-08969 R 93-06309 TJH 97-03825 LHK 90-02581 8/5/1992 11/22/1993 9/10/1990 10/1/1992 3/19/1989 11/13/1990 11/1/1991 8/8/1991 9/19/1995 12/26/2007 11/21/2002 10/19/1993 8/10/1994 5/22/1990 4 Relief Denied (2005) / Execution Stayed Executed by Missouri (1999) Deceased (2002) ED Cal Petition Pending Deceased (2001) Deceased (1990) State Proceedings Pending Circuit Appeal Pending Deceased (2009) Relief Denied (2010) / Execution Stayed Relief Granted (1998) Relief Granted (2001) 31 --31 --31 31 -31 --- Relief Denied (2012) / Execution Stayed Circuit Appeal Pending Deceased (2005) Deceased (2006) Executed (1993) Relief Granted (2006) / Resentenced to Death (2010) CD Cal Petition Pending Deceased (1998) Executed (2005) Relief Granted (2003) Relief Granted (2001) Relief Granted (1997) / Resentenced to Death (1998) Relief Granted (2001) / Resentenced to Death (2002) Relief Denied (2011) / Execution Stayed Deceased (2013) Circuit Appeal Pending Deceased (2010) ND Cal Petition Pending Relief Granted (1997) / Resentenced to Death (2001) 31 31 ---30 30 ----30 30 30 -30 -30 30 Robert Bloom Jay Kaurish William Kirkpatrick Thomas Thompson Watson Allison Charles McDowell Robert Lewis Kenneth Lang Richard Boyer Thaddaeus Turner William Clark Earl Jones Ward Weaver Fred Douglas Patrick Gordon Kevin Cooper Charles Whitt Andre Burton Brian Mincey Randy Haskett Duane Holloway Robert Stansbury Richard Ramierz Raynard Cummings Kenneth Gay Michael Cox Jeffrey Sheldon Stephen DeSantis Michael Mattson Tiequon Cox Henry Duncan Ronald McPeters 7/23/1984 7/27/1984 8/14/1984 8/17/1984 10/2/1984 10/23/1984 11/1/1984 12/5/1984 12/14/1984 12/21/1984 2/1/1985 2/22/1985 4/4/1985 4/5/1985 5/3/1985 5/15/1985 5/23/1985 6/4/1985 6/14/1985 6/28/1985 7/8/1985 7/15/1985 8/8/1985 9/20/1985 9/20/1985 11/26/1985 12/19/1985 2/3/1986 2/7/1986 4/30/1986 5/5/1986 5/7/1986 92-01623 DT 96-00351 WDK 89-03630 DT 92-06404 CAS 90-04009 MRP Central Central Central Central Central 3/16/1992 1/18/1996 6/15/1989 10/26/1992 7/30/1990 91-04061 MMM 06-07584 GAF 91-00153 LJO 95-00334 DOC 94-00816 TJH 02-05583 AWI 91-03055 RSWL 91-00882 LKK 92-00427 H 94-07960 WJR 91-01652 AHM 93-02554 PSG 92-06192 GAF 05-02089 KJM 95-08532 WMB 91-03802 CBM 95-07118 CBM 01-05368 GAF 04-00065 MCE 96-05545 TJH 93-01083 FCD 91-05453 FMC 92-03370 CBM 92-01403 AHS 95-05108 LJO Central Central Eastern Central Central Eastern Central Eastern Southern Central Central Central Central Eastern Central Central Central Central Eastern Central Eastern Central Central Central Eastern 7/29/1991 11/29/2006 4/1/1991 1/18/1995 2/7/1994 5/17/2002 6/6/1991 7/5/1991 3/24/1992 11/23/1994 3/27/1991 5/3/1993 10/15/1992 10/19/2005 12/11/1995 7/15/1998 10/20/1995 6/18/2001 1/5/2004 8/13/1996 7/1/1993 10/8/1991 6/4/1992 3/4/1992 2/13/1995 5 State Proceedings Pending Deceased (1992) Circuit Appeal Pending Executed (1998) Relief Granted (2010) Relief Granted (1998) / Resentenced to Death (1999) State Proceedings Pending CD Cal Petition Pending Circuit Appeal Pending Relief Granted (2009) Relief Granted (2006) Deceased (2006) ED Cal Petition Pending Relief Granted (2003) ED Cal Petition Pending Relief Denied (2009) / Execution Stayed Deceased (2004) Circuit Appeal Pending CD Cal Petition Pending Relief Granted (2009) ED Cal Petition Pending Deceased (2003) Relief Granted (2009) Circuit Appeal Pending State Proceedings Pending ED Cal Petition Pending CD Cal Petition Pending Deceased (2002) Deceased (2009) Relief Denied (2011) / Execution Stayed Relief Granted (2008) ED Cal Petition Pending 30 -30 --30 30 30 30 ---29 -29 29 -29 29 -29 --29 29 29 29 --28 -28 Chay'im BenSholom Freddie Taylor Ralph Thomas Curtis Price Barry Williams Anthony Sully Troy Ashmus Mauricio Silva Royal Hayes Rodney Alcala Antonio Espinoza Wilbur Jennings Robert Danielson Thomas Edwards 5/9/1986 5/30/1986 6/4/1986 7/10/1986 7/11/1986 7/15/1986 7/25/1986 8/1/1986 8/8/1986 8/20/1986 9/17/1986 11/12/1986 11/13/1986 12/11/1986 93-05531 AWI 92-01627 EMC 93-00616 MHP 93-00277 PJH 00-10637 DOC 92-00829 WHA 93-00594 THE Eastern Northern Northern Northern Central Northern Northern 8/10/1993 4/30/1992 2/18/1993 1/25/1993 10/4/2000 2/21/1992 2/17/1993 01-03926 MHP 94-1424 SVW 94-01665 LKK 91-00684 AWI 95-02378 SI 93-07151 CJC Northern Central Eastern Eastern Northern Central 10/18/2001 3/4/1994 10/13/1994 12/16/1991 7/8/1994 11/26/1993 Anderson Hawthorne Theodore Frank Teofilio Medina Christopher Day David Breaux Conrad Zapien Richard Benson Robert Nicolaus Alfred Sandoval Steven Livaditis 12/19/1986 2/23/1987 2/25/1987 3/3/1987 3/12/1987 3/23/1987 4/30/1987 6/23/1987 6/30/1987 7/8/1987 92-00488 JGD 91-06287 AHS 94-01892 RSWL Central Central Central 93-00570 JAM 94-01455 WDK 94-05363 AHM 95-02335 MMC 94-08206 R 96-02833 SVW Eastern Central Central Northern Central Central 11/13/1995 CD Cal Petition Pending 11/18/1991 Deceased (2001) 3/25/1994 Circuit Appeal Pending Deceased (1994) 4/6/1993 ED Cal Petition Pending 3/7/1994 Circuit Appeal Pending 8/8/1994 Circuit Appeal Pending 9/17/1992 Deceased (2003) 12/7/1994 Relief Granted (2001) 4/22/1996 CD Cal Petition Pending 28 -27 -27 27 27 --27 Harold Memro (Reno) George Wharton Robert Garceau Willie Johnson Timothy Pride 7/17/1987 7/22/1987 7/30/1987 8/5/1987 8/6/1987 96-02768 CBM 92-03469 CJC 95-05363 OWW 98-04043 SI 93-00926 GEB Central Central Eastern Northern Eastern 4/18/1996 6/9/1992 5/12/1995 10/21/1998 6/9/1993 27 27 -27 -- 6 Relief Granted (2012) ND Cal Petition Pending Relief Granted (2013) ND Cal Petition Pending CD Cal Petition Pending Relief Denied (2013) / Execution Stayed ND Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending Relief Denied (2011) / Execution Stayed Relief Granted (2003) / Resentenced to Death (2010) ED Cal Petition Pending Deceased (2014) Deceased (1995) Relief Denied (2009) / Deceased (2009) State Proceedings Pending Circuit Appeal Pending Deceased (2004) ND Cal Petition Pending Deceased (1994) -28 -28 28 28 28 28 28 28 28 ---- Bruce Morris Jeffrey Wash Donrell Thomas Mitchell Sims Martin Kipp Paul Tuilaepa Fred Freeman Kenneth Clair Keith Fudge Richard Clark Michael Wader Michael Hill William Noguera Horace Kelly Laverne Johnson Lance Osband Marcelino Ramos David Rogers 8/27/1987 9/1/1987 9/10/1987 9/11/1987 9/18/1987 9/25/1987 10/7/1987 12/4/1987 12/11/1987 12/18/1987 1/5/1988 1/21/1988 1/29/1988 3/24/1988 4/1/1988 4/8/1988 4/27/1988 5/2/1988 Dennis Brewer (Mayfield) Bill Bradford Curtis Fauber David Raley Theodore Wrest William Hart Armenia Cudjo Joselito Cinco David Carpenter Richard Samayoa Guy Rowland Gary Hines Tracy Cain 5/4/1988 5/11/1988 5/16/1988 5/17/1988 5/18/1988 5/27/1988 5/31/1988 6/10/1988 6/27/1988 6/28/1988 6/29/1988 7/8/1988 7/12/1988 92-00483 EJH 95-01133 CAL Eastern Northern 3/27/1992 Relief Granted (2007) 4/3/1995 Deceased (1996) Deceased (1992) 8/8/1995 Relief Denied (2006) / Execution Stayed 5/10/1999 CD Cal Petition Pending 7/13/1995 State Proceedings Pending 9/22/1995 Deceased (2009) 2/26/1993 Circuit Appeal Pending 8/11/1995 CD Cal Petition Pending 8/5/1994 Circuit Appeal Pending 8/9/1996 Deceased (1997) 2/24/1994 ND Cal Petition Pending 9/23/1994 CD Cal Petition Pending 4/6/1998 CD Cal Petition Pending 1/26/1995 ND Cal Petition Pending 1/30/1997 ED Cal Petition Pending 3/20/1988 Deceased (2007) State Proceedings Pending ---27 27 27 -27 27 27 -26 26 26 26 26 -26 95-05267 GHK 99-04973 ABC 95-04619 DDP 99-20614 JW 93-01133 CAS 95-05369 RGK 97-20618 WHA 96-05482 HLH 94-00641 CW 94-06417 CAS 98-02722 TJH 95-00305 THE 97-00152 KJM 98-02037 AHS Central Central Central Northern Central Central Northern Central Northern Central Central Northern Eastern Central 97-03742 FMO 98-05799 RSWL 95-06601 GW 93-02071 JW 95-00214 DDP 05-03633 MMM 99-08089 JFW Central Central Central Northern Central Central Central 5/19/1997 7/20/1998 10/3/1995 6/1/1993 1/11/1995 5/16/2005 8/9/1999 Northern Southern Northern Eastern Central 10/6/2000 10/16/2000 8/26/1994 5/1/1998 4/11/1996 26 -26 26 26 26 --26 26 26 26 26 00-03706 MMC 00-02118 W 94-03037 WHA 98-00784 TLN 96-2584 ABC 7 CD Cal Petition Pending Deceased (2008) CD Cal Petition Pending Relief Denied (2007) / Execution Stayed CD Cal Petition Pending CD Cal Petition Pending Relief Granted (2013) Deceased (1988) ND Cal Petition Pending Relief Denied (2012) / Execution Stayed Circuit Appeal Pending ED Cal Petition Pending Circuit Appeal Pending Dennis Webb William Dennis Jerry Frye Daniel Jenkins Charles Riel Richard Turner Jose Rodrigues Sammy Marshall Teddy Sanchez Aurthur Halvorsen Rodney Berryman Max Barnett Manuel Mendoza Herbert Coddington Reynaldo Ayala Lester Ochoa Drax Quartermain Rodney Beeler James Scott Jeffrey Kolmetz Steven Crittenden Jack Farnam Albert Cunningham Louis Craine George Smithey David Welch Ronald Seaton James Blair Cynthia Coffman Robert Fairbank Manuel Alvarez 8/15/1988 9/6/1988 9/12/1988 10/6/1988 10/14/1988 10/19/1988 10/21/1988 10/27/1988 10/31/1988 11/18/1988 11/28/1988 11/30/1988 1/6/1989 97-00956 VAP 98-021027 99-00628 LKK 07-01918 JGB 01-00507 LKK 09-07449 BRO 96-01831 CW Central Northern Eastern Central Eastern Central Northern 2/13/1997 10/9/1998 3/29/1999 3/22/2007 3/14/2001 10/14/2009 5/17/1996 CD Cal Petition Pending ND Cal Petition Pending ED Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending ED Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending ND Cal Petition Pending Deceased (1997) ED Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending Circuit Appeal Pending State Proceedings Pending CD Cal Petition Pending 26 26 26 26 26 26 26 -26 26 26 26 25 97-06134 AWI Eastern 11/20/1997 95-05309 AWI 99-02416 JAM 03-06194 SJO Eastern Eastern Central 4/27/1995 12/8/1999 8/29/2003 1/20/1989 2/9/1989 3/20/1989 4/10/1989 5/5/1989 5/18/1989 5/18/1989 6/12/1989 6/15/1989 6/16/1989 6/27/1989 7/18/1989 7/25/1989 7/27/1989 8/9/1989 8/31/1989 9/5/1989 9/14/1989 01-01290 KJM 01-00741 BTM 99-11129 DSF Eastern Southern Central 7/3/2001 ED Cal Petition Pending 4/27/2001 Circuit Appeal Pending 10/22/1999 CD Cal Petition Pending Deceased (2005) 1/29/1996 CD Cal Petition Pending 2/10/2003 CD Cal Petition Pending Deceased (1996) 10/26/1995 Circuit Appeal Pending 2/15/2006 State Proceedings Pending 9/13/2002 Relief Denied (2013) / Execution Stayed Deceased (1989) Deceased (2010) 2/28/2000 State Proceedings Pending 11/12/2004 CD Cal Petition Pending 7/20/2006 CD Cal Petition Pending 11/15/2006 CD Cal Petition Pending 3/16/1998 Relief Denied (2011) / Execution Stayed 10/8/1997 ED Cal Petition Pending 25 25 25 -25 25 -25 25 25 --25 25 25 25 25 25 96-00606 GW 03-00978 ODW Central Central 95-01957 KJM 06-00917 SJO 02-07170 GHK Eastern Central Central 00-20242 RMW 04-09339 FMO 06-04550 VAP 06-07304 ABC 98-01027 CRB 97-01895 GEB Northern Central Central Central Northern Eastern 8 David Lucas David Rundle Robert Maury Terry Bemore Stanley Davis Randy Kraft Hector Ayala Jeffrey Hawkins Dean Carter Jon Dunkle Alfredo Padilla Fermin Ledesma Pedro Arias Dennis Lawley Larry Davis Jr. Mario Gray Mark Schmeck Tracey Carter Christopher Tobin Richard Letner Jerry Bailey John Holt 9/19/1989 9/21/1989 10/27/1989 11/2/1989 11/15/1989 11/29/1989 11/30/1989 1/31/1990 2/6/1990 2/7/1990 2/7/1990 2/7/1990 2/22/1990 2/26/1990 3/8/1990 3/14/1990 4/5/1990 4/20/1990 4/24/1990 4/24/1990 5/16/1990 5/30/1990 Maureen McDermott Mark Bradford Steven Catlin Ralph Yeoman Raymond Steele Jarvis Masters Kurt Michaels Roland Comtois Joseph Muselwhite 6/8/1990 7/3/1990 7/6/1990 7/10/1990 7/24/1990 7/30/1990 7/31/1990 7/31/1990 9/25/1990 08-01879 TLN 12-01043 WBS 08-00311 LAB Eastern Eastern Southern 8/13/2008 4/19/2012 2/15/2008 01-04623 AG 01-01322 IEG 96-01155 TLN 06-04532 RGK 06-04115 PJH 01-06305 LJO 07-02130 PJH 99-00627 WBS 08-01425 LJO 96-002443 DT 07-05935 DSF 13-05415 RS 04-06524 DDP Central Southern Eastern Central Northern Eastern Northern Eastern Eastern Central Central Northern Central 5/23/2001 7/20/2001 6/19/1996 7/20/2006 6/30/2006 10/4/2001 4/17/2007 3/29/1999 9/23/2008 4/5/1996 9/12/2007 11/21/2013 8/6/2004 97-06210 AWI Eastern 12/15/1997 04-00457 DOC 97-06221 TJH 07-01466 LJO Central Central Eastern 03-00143 GEB Eastern 04-00122 JAH Southern 01-01443 LKK Eastern State Proceedings Pending ED Cal Petition Pending ED Cal Petition Pending Circuit Appeal Pending State Proceedings Pending CD Cal Petition Pending Circuit Appeal Pending ED Cal Petition Pending Circuit Appeal Pending ND Cal Petition Pending Deceased (2008) State Proceedings Pending ED Cal Petition Pending Deceased (2012) Relief Denied (2004) / Deceased (2005) Deceased (2013) ND Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending Deceased (1998) State Proceedings Pending 1/26/2004 CD Cal Petition Pending 8/19/1997 CD Cal Petition Pending 10/5/2007 ED Cal Petition Pending Deceased (2014) 1/24/2003 ED Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending 1/16/2004 SD Cal Petition Pending Deceased (1994) 7/26/2001 Deceased (2010) 9 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 24 24 24 -24 24 ---24 24 24 24 -24 24 24 24 -24 24 24 --- Kristin Hughes Evan Nakahara Isaac Gutierrez Jr. Paul Brown Milton Lewis Ramon Salcido Raymond Gurule Carmen Ward James Majors Christopher Box Paul Bolin Raymond Lewis Tauro Waidla Richard Moon Robert McDonald Ronald Jones John Sapp Paul Watson Curtis Ervin Clifford Bolden Jesse Gonzalez Martin Navarette Anthony Townsel James O'Malley Michael Slaughter Michael Jones Dellano Cleveland Deondre Staten Richard Farley Chauncey Veasley Robert Taylor Edward Bridges 10/2/1990 11/6/1990 11/14/1990 11/16/1990 12/6/1990 12/17/1990 12/19/1990 1/28/1991 2/4/1991 2/22/1991 2/25/1991 3/6/1991 3/8/1991 5/19/1991 5/31/1991 6/4/1991 6/21/1991 6/27/1991 6/28/1991 7/19/1991 7/28/1991 8/14/1991 9/13/1991 11/21/1991 11/27/1991 12/13/1991 12/19/1991 1/16/1992 1/17/1992 1/21/1992 1/30/1992 2/20/1992 03-02666 JSW 05-04604 DDP 05-03706 DOC Northern Central Central 02-00013 TLN 09-00586 MMC Eastern Northern 06-02009 PA 99-00493 MCE 04-00619 AJB 99-05279 LJO 03-06775 LJO 01-00650 AG 08-08327 JAK Central Eastern Southern Eastern Eastern Central Central 98-10318 JLS 04-04163 JSW Central Northern 00-01228 CW 09-02365 PJH 95-02345 JVS 11-07066 VAP Northern Northern Central Central 05-00922 AWI 04-02748 ODW 05-03822 SVW 01-09178 MWF Eastern Central Central Central 05-03822 SVW 07-06602 FMO Central Central 6/6/2003 ND Cal Petition Pending 6/24/2005 CD Cal Petition Pending 5/18/2005 Deceased (2008) Deceased (2004) 1/3/2002 ED Cal Petition Pending 2/9/2009 State Proceedings Pending Deceased (2007) State Proceedings Pending 3/12/1999 ED Cal Petition Pending 3/26/2004 State Proceedings Pending 3/11/1999 ED Cal Petition Pending 12/9/2003 ED Cal Petition Pending 1/22/2001 CD Cal Petition Pending 12/17/2008 State Proceedings Pending Deceased (1993) 12/28/1998 CD Cal Petition Pending 9/30/2004 State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending 4/10/2000 ND Cal Petition Pending 5/28/2009 State Proceedings Pending 4/12/1995 State Proceedings Pending 8/26/2011 State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending 7/18/2005 State Proceedings Pending 4/20/2004 CD Cal Petition Pending 5/24/2005 CD Cal Petition Pending 10/24/2001 CD Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending 4/12/2005 CD Cal Petition Pending 10/11/2007 CD Cal Petition Pending Deceased (2008) 10 24 24 --24 24 -23 23 23 23 23 23 23 -23 23 23 23 23 23 23 23 23 23 23 23 22 22 22 22 -- Ricky Earp Colin Dickey Billy Waldon Jose Casares Richard Viera Gregory Smith Franklin Lynch James Marlow Paul Watkins Thomas Walker Andrew Brown Alfredo Valdez Marchand Elliott Alfredo Prieto Jack Friend Maria Alfaro Stephen Cole Gregory Smith Rodney San Nicolas Jessie Ray Moffett James Tulk Dannie Hillhouse Alphonso Howard Rudolph Roybal David Williams Gerald Cruz James Beck Richard Tully Sergio Ochoa George Williams Ricardo Roldan William Ramos 2/21/1992 2/27/1992 2/28/1992 3/13/1992 3/30/1992 4/3/1992 4/28/1992 5/8/1992 5/11/1992 5/12/1992 5/21/1992 5/22/1992 6/3/1992 6/18/1992 6/19/1992 7/14/1992 7/16/1992 8/14/1992 8/31/1992 9/2/1992 10/9/1992 10/13/1992 10/20/1992 10/20/1992 10/20/1992 10/26/1992 10/27/1992 12/4/1992 12/10/1992 12/21/1992 12/29/1992 1/8/1993 00-06508 MMM 06-00357 AWI Central Eastern 05-01492 AWI 05-08017 DSF Eastern Central 05-06477 ABC Central 04-03931 AG 10-05252 BRO Central Central 05-07566 AG Central 07-07072 CJC 05-04971 DMG 04-03436 JSW 06-00942 LJO Central Central Northern Eastern 03-00142 MCE 08-06851 DDP 99-02152 JM 12-03975 AG Eastern Central Southern Central 02-07774 RSWL Central 09-06589 DOC 05-03752 SI Central Northern 6/19/2000 CD Cal Petition Pending 3/31/2006 ED Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending 11/22/2005 ED Cal Petition Pending 11/9/2005 State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending 8/31/2005 CD Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending Deceased (1997) 6/2/2004 CD Cal Petition Pending 7/16/2010 State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending 10/20/2005 State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending 10/30/2007 CD Cal Petition Pending 7/7/2005 CD Cal Petition Pending 8/19/2004 ND Cal Petition Pending 7/20/2006 ED Cal Petition Pending Deceased (1998) Deceased (2006) 1/24/2003 ED Cal Petition Pending 10/17/2008 CD Cal Petition Pending 10/5/1999 SD Cal Petition Pending 5/7/2012 State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending 10/4/2002 CD Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending 9/10/2009 CD Cal Petition Pending 9/16/2005 ND Cal Petition Pending 11 22 22 22 22 22 22 22 22 22 -22 22 22 22 22 22 22 22 22 --22 22 22 22 22 22 22 22 22 22 21 John Lewis Gregory Tate Joseph Danks Erik Chatman Maurice Boyette Omar Martinez Anthony Oliver Albert Lewis Latwon Weaver Warren Bland 3/3/1993 3/5/1993 4/2/1993 4/9/1993 5/7/1993 5/10/1993 5/21/1993 5/21/1993 5/28/1993 5/28/1993 Catherine Thompson Vincente Benavides Michael Combs Robert Curl Mark Crew Charles Stevens 6/10/1993 6/16/1993 6/21/1993 05-0 4777 ODW 7/15/1993 7/22/1993 12-04259 YGR 7/30/1993 09-00137 WHA Christian Monterroso Corvin Emdy Richard Dehoyos Cedric Harrison Enrique Zambrano Eric Houston Robert Smith James Heard Cleophus Prince Abelino Manriquez Herbert Koontz Eric Hinton Michael Huggins Jerry Kennedy 8/12/1993 8/19/1993 8/27/1993 8/30/1993 9/8/1993 9/20/1993 9/24/1993 9/28/1993 11/5/1993 11/16/1993 11/19/1993 12/10/1993 12/17/1993 12/20/1993 11-06395 JAK Central 11-00223 LJO 07-00640 WHA 13-04376 WHO 04-09090 PA 10-08404 ODW 11-00766 ODW 12-02140 MMA Eastern Northern Northern Central Central Central Southern Central Northern Northern 12-07888 DMG Central 09-05045 JW 09-04917 LHK 13-05609 WHA 11-03062 EJD Northern Northern Northern Northern 03-01613 FCD 10-06714 DMG 06-07254 YGR 13-02041 LKK Eastern Central Northern Eastern 8/3/2011 CD Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending 2/9/2011 State Proceedings Pending 1/31/2007 State Proceedings Pending 9/20/2013 ND Cal Petition Pending 11/3/2004 State Proceedings Pending 11/4/2010 CD Cal Petition Pending 1/26/2011 State Proceedings Pending 8/30/2012 SD Cal Petition Pending Deceased (2001) 21 21 21 21 21 21 21 21 21 -- State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending 6/30/2005 CD Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending 8/13/2012 ND Cal Petition Pending 1/12/2009 ND Cal Petition Pending 21 21 21 21 21 21 9/13/2012 CD Cal Petition Pending Deceased (1993) State Proceedings Pending 10/22/2009 Deceased (2009) 10/15/2009 ND Cal Petition Pending 12/4/2013 ND Cal Petition Pending 6/21/2011 ND Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending 7/31/2003 Deceased (2007) 9/9/2010 CD Cal Petition Pending 11/22/2006 State Proceedings Pending 10/1/2013 ED Cal Petition Pending 21 -21 -21 21 21 21 21 21 -21 21 21 12 Lanell Harris Steven Bell Robert Wilson Christopher Sattiewhite Tim Depriest Delaney Marks Brian Johnsen Milton Pollock James Robinson Jaime Hoyos Phillip Jablonski Walter Cook Tomas Cruz Joseph Cook Mary Samuels Shaun Burney Bryan Jones Ronnie Dement Robert Jurado Billy Riggs Carl Powell Celeste Carrington Steven Bonilla Anthony Bankston Edgardo SanchezFuentes Danny Horning Randall Wall Steven Homick Royal Clark Raymond Johns 1/12/1994 3/7/1994 4/8/1994 07-00519 MWF 4/25/1994 5/27/1994 6/3/1994 6/9/1994 6/10/1994 6/17/1994 7/11/1994 8/12/1994 9/2/1994 9/9/1994 9/16/1994 9/16/1994 9/16/1994 9/19/1994 9/26/1994 10/1/1994 10/28/1994 11/10/1994 11/23/1994 1/20/1995 1/20/1995 Central State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending 1/22/2007 CD Cal Petition Pending 20 20 20 State Proceedings Pending CD Cal Petition Pending ND Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending SD Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending ND Cal Petition Pending CD Cal Petition Pending CD Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending SD Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending ND Cal Petition Pending ND Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 19 19 State Proceedings Pending 7/21/2010 State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending 5/16/2012 State Proceedings Pending Deceased (2004) 19 19 19 19 19 -- 07-06025 JLS 11-02458 LHK Central Northern 9/17/2007 5/19/2011 05-01870 SI Northern 5/5/2005 09-00388 L 07-03302 SI Southern Northern 2/26/2009 6/22/2007 13-02792 JST 12-08142 CJC 10-03225 SJO 10-00546 RGK Northern Central Central Central 6/18/2013 9/20/2012 4/29/2010 1/26/2010 08-01400 JLS 09-04624 JAK Southern Central 7/31/2008 6/26/2009 10-04179 RS 08-00471 CW Northern Northern 9/16/2010 1/22/2008 1/20/1995 1/26/1995 10-01932 JAM 1/30/1995 1/31/1995 2/3/1995 12-00803 LJO 2/8/1995 Eastern Eastern 13 Keith Loker Johnny Avila Randy Garcia Hooman Panah Ernest Jones Glen Cornwell Mark Thornton Greg Demetrulias Kerry Dalton Regis Thomas Lester Virgil Johnaton George Christopher Geier Charles Rountree Christopher Lightsey Sergio Nelson Thomas Lenart John Beames Paul Hensley Loi Vo Stephen Hajek Donald Smith Leroy Wheeler Stanley Bryant William Suff William Suff Caroline Young Douglas Kelly Ernest Dykes Demetrius Howard John Cunningham 2/10/1995 3/21/1995 3/23/1995 3/26/1995 4/7/1995 4/21/1995 5/15/1995 5/22/1995 5/23/1995 6/15/1995 6/29/1995 7/17/1995 7/21/1995 8/11/1995 State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending Circuit Appeal Pending CD Cal Petition Pending ED Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending Circuit Appeal Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending 19 19 19 19 19 19 19 19 19 19 19 19 19 19 State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending 9/21/2005 State Proceedings Pending 8/9/2010 ED Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending Deceased (2005) State Proceedings Pending 9/7/2011 ND Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending 19 19 19 19 19 19 19 19 19 19 19 19 -19 19 19 18 11-01196 AWI Eastern 7/19/2011 05-07606 RGK 09-002158 CJC 06-00705 TLN Central Central Eastern 10/21/2005 3/27/2009 3/31/2006 07-01335 DOC Central 2/28/2007 10-04676 R Central 6/24/2010 8/15/1995 9/9/1995 10/6/1995 05-01912 MCE 10/11/1995 10-01429 AWI 10/13/1995 10/18/1995 10/18/1995 10/19/1995 10/19/1995 10/19/1995 10/26/1995 10/26/1995 10/27/1995 11/8/1995 11/30/1995 11-04454 SI 12/7/1995 1/12/1996 Eastern Eastern Northern 14 Alfredo Valencia Valamir Morelos Jerry Rodriguez Steven Brown Dexter Williams Richard Gamache Andre Alexander Frank Carter Robert Cowan Dennis Ervine Keith Taylor Eric Leonard Keith Doolin Daniel Whalen Edward Morgan Clifton Perry Raymond Butler Lamar Barnwell Freddie Fuiava Christopher Self Albert Jones John Riccardi Bob Williams Richard Davis Richard Leon Richard Parson Darrel Lomax Charles Case James Thompson Michael Elliot Christopher Spencer 1/23/1996 2/21/1996 2/21/1996 2/23/1996 2/28/1996 4/2/1996 4/23/1996 4/25/1996 5/8/1996 5/31/1996 6/5/1996 6/13/1996 6/18/1996 6/24/1996 7/19/1996 7/26/1996 7/29/1996 8/9/1996 8/19/1996 8/28/1996 9/20/1996 9/20/1996 9/20/1996 9/26/1996 10/1/1996 10/11/1996 10/16/1996 10/25/1996 10/26/1996 10/31/1996 Eastern 8/17/2012 11-07404 JAK Central 9/8/2011 09-01453 AWI Eastern 8/17/2009 11-01367 AWI Eastern 8/16/2011 12-10646 VAP Central 12/12/2013 09-01068 AWI 13-00408 EMC Eastern Northern 6/17/2009 1/29/2013 11-01746 JLS Central 2/28/2011 11/7/1996 15 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 -18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 -18 18 18 18 State Proceedings Pending 12-01344 LJO State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending ED Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending Deceased (2001) State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending CD Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending ND Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending Deceased (2011) State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending 18 Brandon Taylor George Contreras Dewayne Carey Michael Pearson Scott Collins Maurice Harris Richard Foster Michael Ihde Eric Bennet Herbert McClain Karl Holmes Lorenzo Newborn Stephen Redd Jeffery Mills Joseph Montes Johnny Mungia Johnathan D'Arcy Jimmy Palma Richard Valdez Daniel Silveria John Travis Robert Scully Ramon Rogers Lawrence Bergman Bobby Lopez Michael Martinez Carlos Hawthorne John Famalaro Michael Bramit Royce Scott John Abel Ronald Mendoza 11/13/1996 12/11/1996 12/16/1996 12/18/1996 12/19/1996 13-07334 JFW 12/20/1996 13-04026 PA 12/31/1996 1/3/1997 1/9/1997 1/21/1997 1/21/1997 1/21/1997 2/28/1997 3/10/1997 3/18/1997 4/7/1997 4/11/1997 6/11/1997 6/11/1997 6/13/1997 6/13/1997 6/13/1997 6/30/1997 7/8/1997 7/11/1997 8/29/1997 9/5/1997 9/5/1997 9/15/1997 9/17/1997 9/26/1997 10/27/1997 Central Central State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending 10/3/2013 CD Cal Petition Pending 6/5/2013 CD Cal Petition Pending State Proceedings Pending Deceased (2005) State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending Deceased (1997) State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending Deceased (2009) State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending 16 18 18 18 18 18 18 18 -17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 -17 17 17 17 17 -17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 Terrance Page Frank Becerra Sean Vines Herminio Serna James Trujeque Frank Abilez Gunner Lindberg Floyd Smith Bill Poyner Martin Mendoza William Clark 10/31/1997 10/31/1997 11/7/1997 11/21/1997 11/21/1997 12/4/1997 12/12/1997 09-05509 MWF 12/14/1997 12/16/1997 12/23/1997 12/29/1997 Central Deceased (2008) State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending Deceased (2012) 7/28/2009 State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending Deceased (1998) State Proceedings Pending State Proceedings Pending 1 The chart describes the case status of any individual sentenced in 1997 or earlier because all such individuals, unless deceased, executed, or granted a writ of habeas corpus, have spent at least 17 years on Death Row, the amount of time Justice Stevens posited might be constitutionally problematic in Lackey v. Texas, 514 U.S. 1045 (1995) (Stevens, J., respecting the denial of certiorari). In total, 366 of the 746 inmates currently on California’s Death Row were sentenced to death 17 or more years ago. For all but a small handful of those individuals sentenced to death after 1997, state proceedings are still ongoing, and none have completed the federal habeas process. 2 The chart was compiled using publicly available information from the court dockets of the four federal judicial districts in California, the public docket of the California Supreme Court, and the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation’s (“CDCR”) list of condemned inmates, which is available at http://www.cdcr.ca.gov/capital_punishment/docs/condemnedinmatelistsecure.pdf, and the CDCR’s list of condemned inmates who have died since 1978, which is available at http://www.cdcr.ca.gov/Capital_Punishment/docs/CONDEMNEDINMATESWHOHAVEDIEDSINCE1978.pdf. 3 Federal habeas proceedings are initiated when the petitioner seeks appointment of federal habeas counsel, not when the petitioner’s federal writ of habeas corpus is filed. Some individuals that have initiated federal habeas proceedings may still have state proceedings pending for exhaustion purposes. In such cases, the federal petition is effectively stayed while the state proceedings are completed. 17 -17 17 17 17 -17 17 -17 17

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?