Ernest DeWayne Jones v. Robert K. Wong

Filing 116

DECLARATION of Michael Laurence re Brief (non-motion non-appeal) 109 in Support of Claim 27 (Supplemental) filed by Petitioner Ernest DeWayne Jones. (Attachments: # 1 Appendix Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence)(Laurence, Michael)

1

7

Michael Laurence (Bar No. 121854)
Cliona Plunkett (Bar No. 256648)
HABEAS CORPUS RESOURCE CENTER
303 Second Street, Suite 400 South
San Francisco, California 94107
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: [phone]
E-mail:
[e-mail]
[e-mail]

8

Attorneys for Petitioner Ernest DeWayne Jones

2
3
4
5
6

9

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

10

FOR THE CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

11
12
13

ERNEST DEWAYNE JONES,
Petitioner,

16
17
18
19

DEATH PENALTY CASE

V.

14
15

Case No. CV-09-2158-CJC

KEVIN CHAPPELL, Warden of
California State Prison at San
Quentin,
Respondent.

CORRECTED DATA USED IN
DECLARATION OF MICHAEL
LAURENCE IN SUPPORT OF
PETITIONER’S OPENING BRIEF
ON CLAIM 27
Date:
July 16, 2014
Time:
9:00 a.m.
Courtroom: 9B

20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Corrected Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence
in Support Petitioner’s Opening Brief on Claim 27

Case No. CV-09-2158-CJC

1
2
3

Jones v. Chappell, Case No. CV-09-2158-CJC
Index of Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence in Support of
Petitioner’s Opening Brief on Claim 27

4

Data

Page

5 Paragraph 5

1

6 Paragraph 6

13

7 Paragraph 7

14

8 Paragraph 8.l

26

9 Paragraph 8.2

29

10 Paragraph 9.1

34

11 Paragraph 9.2

35

12 Paragraph 10

36

13 Paragraph 11.1

37

14 Paragraph 11.2

38

15 Paragraph 12

39

16 Paragraph 13.1

41

17 Paragraph 13.2

47

18 Paragraph 14

53

19 Paragraph 15

56

20 Paragraph 16.1

59

21 Paragraph 16.2

66

22 Paragraph 17

74

23
24
25
26
27
28
i
Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 5

Name
Robertson, Andrew Edward
Green, Charles Alan
Frierson, Lavell
Gzikowski, John
Thompson, Maurice Seton
Stankewitz, Douglas Ray
Velasquez, Nick Ramon
Bell, Ronald Lee
Harris, Robert Alton
Jackson, Earl Lloyd
Hogan, Carl David
Lanphear, Ronald Eugene
Williams, Keith Daniel
Murtishaw, David Leslie
Lee, Chol Soo
Massie, Robert Lee
Chadd, Billy Lee
Chase, Richard Trenton
Croy, Patrick Eugene
Easley, Elbert Lee
Fields, Stevie Lamar
Haskett, Randy
Mroczko, Richard John
Ghent, David Luther
Montiel, Richard Galvan
Anderson, James Phillip
Reno (aka Memro, Harold Ray)
Ramos, Marcelino
Ainsworth, Steven King
Frank, Theodore Francis
Phillips, Richard Louis Arnold
Ruiz, Alejandro Gilbert
Holt, Steven Vincent
Ledesma, Fermin Rodriguez
Arcega, Vincent M., Jr.
Turner, Richard Dean
Mattson, Michael Dee
Mozingo, Ronny William
Moore, David Lee
Alcala, Rodney James
Joseph, Mariney
Leach, Michael Todd

Date of death
judgment
5/31/1978
6/16/1978
8/14/1978
9/8/1978
9/29/1978
10/12/1978
1/31/1979
3/2/1979
3/6/1979
3/19/1979
4/2/1979
4/11/1979
4/13/1979
4/27/1979
5/24/1979
5/25/1979
6/6/1979
6/8/1979
8/2/1979
8/9/1979
8/21/1979
8/28/1979
9/13/1979
10/30/1979
11/20/1979
11/30/1979
1/22/1980
1/25/1980
1/30/1980
2/4/1980
2/20/1980
2/21/1980
3/14/1980
3/14/1980
3/31/1980
4/7/1980
4/10/1980
4/25/1980
4/30/1980
6/20/1980
7/8/1980
7/11/1980

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 1

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 5
Name
Turner, Melvin
Frierson, Lavell
Harris, Lee Edward
Walker, Marvin Pete, Jr.
Boyd, Juan Anthony
Guerra, Danny Montana
Griffin, Donald
McDonald, Eddie Bobby
Smallwood, Ronald Jerome
Garrison, Richard William
Rich, Darrell Keith
Bunyard, Jerry Thomas
Warren, Robert Gentry
Warren, Woodrow
Hamilton, Bernard Lee
Armendariz, Joseph Mario
Bittaker, Lawrence Sigmond
Heishman, Harvey Lee, III
Kimble, Eric B.
Balderas, David
Williams, Stanley
Myers, Venson Lane
Bigelow, Jerry Douglas
McLain, Robert Cruz
Whitt, Charles Edward
Chavez, Raymond Rudy
Johnson, Joe Edward
Rodriguez, Luis Valenzuela
Bean, Anthony Cornell
Anderson, Stephen Wayne
Gonzalez, Jesse Edward
Gates, Oscar
Hayes, John Westley
Hale, Brian Darle
Coleman, Calvin, Jr.
Louis, Vincent
Burgener, Michael Ray
Hawkins, Ronald Chester
Hamilton, Billy Ray
Stankewitz, Laird Gene
Davenport, John Galen
Ratliff, James Monroe
Silbertson, Steven Clark
Coleman, Russell

Date of death
judgment
8/20/1980
8/26/1980
8/27/1980
9/8/1980
10/22/1980
11/12/1980
11/26/1980
12/11/1980
1/9/1981
1/16/1981
1/23/1981
1/30/1981
2/5/1981
2/5/1981
3/2/1981
3/11/1981
3/24/1981
3/30/1981
4/1/1981
4/15/1981
4/15/1981
4/21/1981
5/8/1981
5/12/1981
5/26/1981
5/28/1981
5/28/1981
7/8/1981
7/20/1981
7/24/1981
7/28/1981
8/7/1981
8/20/1981
8/24/1981
8/27/1981
8/28/1981
9/11/1981
9/20/1981
10/16/1981
10/23/1981
11/4/1981
11/5/1981
11/18/1981
11/20/1981

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 2

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 5
Name
Fuentes, Jose Leon
Hendricks, Edgar Morris
Lanphear, Ronald Eugene
Guzman, Gary Lee
Caro, Fernando Eros
Hayes, Blufford, Jr.
Bloyd, Dale Michael
Lucero, Phillip Louis
Crandell, Kenneth
Hovey, Richard Adams
Avena, Carlos Jaime
Brown, Albert Greenwood, Jr.
Branner, Willie
Sanders, Ronald Lee
Payton, William Charles
Bonin, William George
Silva, Benjamin Wai
Marks, John
Milner, Lynn Bernard
Lucky, Darnell
Boyde, Richard
Williams, Kenneth Derrell
Wade, Melvin Meffery
Carpenter, George Allison
Howard, Gary Lee, Sr.
Grant, Richard Edward
Brown, John George
Babbitt, Manuel Pina
Jones, Troy Lee
Willis, Mose
Snow, Prentice Juan
Miranda, Adam
Karis, James Leslie
Pensinger, Brett Patrick
Belmontes, Fernando, Jr.
Wright, Bronte Lamont
Deere, Ronald Lee
Poggi, Joseph Carlos
Allen, Clarence Ray
Sanders, Ricardo Rene
Ross, Craig Anthony
Champion, Steve Allen
Hamilton, Michael Allen
Farmer, Lee Perry

Date of death
judgment
11/30/1981
12/4/1981
12/18/1981
12/22/1981
1/8/1982
1/22/1982
1/25/1982
1/26/1982
2/2/1982
2/10/1982
2/12/1982
2/25/1982
2/26/1982
3/3/1982
3/9/1982
3/12/1982
3/15/1982
3/31/1982
4/2/1982
4/7/1982
4/20/1982
5/14/1982
5/21/1982
5/21/1982
5/27/1982
5/28/1982
6/15/1982
7/8/1982
7/23/1982
7/26/1982
8/31/1982
9/17/1982
9/17/1982
9/20/1982
10/6/1982
10/29/1982
11/9/1982
11/12/1982
11/22/1982
12/3/1982
12/10/1982
12/10/1982
12/17/1982
1/17/1983

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 3

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 5
Name
Keenan, Maurice J.
Fuller, Ronald Edward
Sixto, Felipe Evangelista
Neely, Charles Frederick
Clark, Douglas Daniel
Melton, James Andrew
Murtishaw, David Leslie
Williams, Michael Allen
Siripongs, Jaturun
Hitchings, Keith Sanford
Robbins, Malcolm Joseph
Bonillas, Louis Lujan
Edelbacher, Peter
Roberts, Larry H.
Webster, Larry Junior
Morales, Michael Angelo
Malone, Kelvin Shelby
Gallego, Gerald Armond
Marshall, George Edward
Proctor, William Arnold
Gonzalez, Martin G.
Adcox, Keith Edward
Hernandez, Francis Gerard
Howard, Albert Cecil
Odle, James Richard
Bonin, William George
Mickey, Douglas Scott
Dyer, Alfred R.
Mayfield, Demetrie Ladon
Carrera, Constantino
Visciotti, John Louis
Hendricks, Edgar Morris
Miller, Donald
Stankewitz, Douglas Ray
Morris, Oscar Lee
Thompson, Robert Jackson
Mason, David Edwin
Reilly, Mark Anthony
Hardy, James Edward
Robertson, Andrew Edward
Stanley, Gerald Frank
Beardslee, Donald Jay
Daniels, Jackson Chambers, Jr.
Jennings, Michael Wayne

Date of death
judgment
1/21/1983
2/3/1983
2/17/1983
3/11/1983
3/16/1983
3/18/1983
3/25/1983
4/1/1983
4/22/1983
5/6/1983
5/12/1983
5/20/1983
5/25/1983
5/27/1983
6/9/1983
6/14/1983
6/14/1983
6/21/1983
6/28/1983
6/28/1983
7/8/1983
7/11/1983
7/12/1983
8/3/1983
8/12/1983
8/26/1983
9/23/1983
9/26/1983
9/30/1983
10/14/1983
10/21/1983
11/8/1983
11/10/1983
11/18/1983
11/21/1983
12/6/1983
1/27/1984
2/1/1984
2/1/1984
2/3/1984
2/7/1984
3/13/1984
3/14/1984
3/27/1984

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 4

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 5
Name
Hunter, Michael Wayne
Moore, Charles Edward
Jackson, Michael Anthony
Pinholster, Scott Lynn
Andrews, Jesse James
Diaz, Robert Rubane
Harris, Von Maurice
Mitcham, Stephan Louis
Easley, Elbert Lee
Bloom, Robert Maurice
Kaurish, Jay Charles
Kirkpatrick, William, Jr.
Thompson, Thomas Martin
Marquez, Gonzalo Marquez
Allison, Watson
McDowell, Charles Edward
Lewis, Robert, Jr.
Carpenter, David Joseph
Lang, Kenneth Burton, Jr.
Boyer, Richard Delmer
Turner, Thaddaeus Louis
Clark, William John
Jones, Earl Preston
Douglas, Fred Berre
Weaver, Ward Francis, Jr.
Gordon, Patrick Bruce
Cooper, Kevin
Whitt, Charles Edward
Burton, Andre
Mincey, Bryan Joseph
Haskett, Randy
Holloway, Duane
Stansbury, Robert Edward
Ramirez, Richard Raymond
Cummings, Raynard Paul
Gay, Kenneth Earl
Horton, James Frank, II
Cox, Michael Anthony
Sheldon, Jeffrey Theodore
DeSantis, Stephen
Mattson, Michael Dee
Hawthorne, Anderson, Jr.
Anderson, Stephen Wayne
Mickle, Denny

Date of death
judgment
3/28/1984
5/16/1984
5/21/1984
6/4/1984
6/8/1984
6/15/1984
6/19/1984
7/6/1984
7/13/1984
7/23/1984
7/27/1984
8/14/1984
8/17/1984
9/24/1984
10/2/1984
10/23/1984
11/1/1984
11/20/1984
12/5/1984
12/14/1984
12/21/1984
2/1/1985
2/22/1985
4/5/1985
4/11/1985
5/3/1985
5/15/1985
5/23/1985
6/4/1985
6/14/1985
6/28/1985
7/8/1985
7/15/1985
8/8/1985
9/20/1985
9/20/1985
10/7/1985
11/26/1985
12/19/1985
2/3/1986
2/7/1986
2/18/1986
3/26/1986
4/17/1986

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 5

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 5
Name
Cox, Tiequon Aundray
Duncan, Henry Earl
McPeters, Ronald Avery
Marshall, Ryan Michael
Taylor, Freddie Lee
Kelly, Horace Edwards
Price, Curtis Floyd
Williams, Barry Glenn
Sully, Anthony John
Deere, Ronald Lee
Ashmus, Troy Adam
Silva, Mauricio Rodriguez
Hayes, Royal Kenneth
Alcala, Rodney James
Fierro, David Rey
Espinoza, Antonio
Thomas, Ralph International
Jennings, Wilbur
Danielson, Robert Wayne
Montiel, Richard Galvan
Edwards, Thomas Francis
Frank, Theodore Francis
Medina, Teofilo, Jr.
Day, Christopher Teddy
Breaux, David Anthony
Frierson, Lavell
Zapien, Conrad Jess
Benson, Richard Allen
Bacigalupo, Miguel Angel
Nicolaus, Robert Henry
Sandoval, Alfred Arthur
Livaditis, Steven
Reno (aka Memro, Harold Ray)
Wharton, George Herbert
Williams, Darren Charles
Garceau, Robert Frederick
Johnson, Willie Darnell
Pride, Timothy
Morris, Bruce Wayne
Wash, Jeffrey D.
Thomas, Donrell
Sims, Mitchell Carlton
Kipp, Martin James
Fuentes, Jose Leon

Date of death
judgment
4/30/1986
5/5/1986
5/7/1986
5/9/1986
5/30/1986
6/25/1986
7/10/1986
7/11/1986
7/15/1986
7/18/1986
7/29/1986
8/11/1986
8/18/1986
8/20/1986
8/22/1986
9/18/1986
9/25/1986
11/12/1986
11/13/1986
12/8/1986
12/11/1986
2/23/1987
2/26/1987
3/3/1987
3/12/1987
3/18/1987
3/23/1987
4/30/1987
6/12/1987
6/23/1987
6/30/1987
7/8/1987
7/17/1987
7/22/1987
7/23/1987
7/30/1987
8/5/1987
8/6/1987
8/27/1987
9/1/1987
9/10/1987
9/11/1987
9/18/1987
9/18/1987

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 6

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 5
Name
Tuilaepa, Paul Palalaua
Freeman, Fred Harlan
Lucas, Larry Douglas
Clair, Kenneth
Fudge, Keith Tyrone
Clark, Richard Dean
Wader, Michael Joseph
Hill, Michael
Noguera, William Adolf
Kelly, Horace Edwards
Johnson, Laverne
Osband, Lance Ian
Ramos, Marcelino
Rogers, David Keith
Mayfield, Dennis
Bradford, Bill
Fauber, Curtis Lynn
Raley, David Allen
Wrest, Theodore John
Cudjo, Armenia Levi, Jr.
Hart, Joseph William
Cinco, Joselito
Turner, Melvin
Samayoa, Richard Gonzales
Rowland, Guy Kevin
Hines, Gary Dale
Cain, Tracy Dearl
Wilson, Robert Paul
Carpenter, David Joseph
Webb, Dennis Duane
Dennis, William Michael
Frye, Jerry Grant
Hill, Shawn
Haley, Kevin Bernard
Jenkins, Daniel Steven
Riel, Charles Dell
Turner, Richard Dean
Marshall, Sammy
Rodriguez, Jose Arnaldo
Sanchez, Teddy Brian
Halvorsen, Arthur Hans
Berryman, Rodney, Sr.
Barnett, Lee Max
Mendoza, Manuel

Date of death
judgment
9/25/1987
10/7/1987
11/4/1987
12/4/1987
12/11/1987
12/18/1987
1/5/1988
1/21/1988
1/29/1988
3/24/1988
4/1/1988
4/8/1988
4/27/1988
5/2/1988
5/4/1988
5/11/1988
5/16/1988
5/17/1988
5/18/1988
5/27/1988
5/27/1988
6/10/1988
6/10/1988
6/28/1988
6/29/1988
7/8/1988
7/12/1988
7/14/1988
7/19/1988
8/15/1988
9/6/1988
9/12/1988
9/22/1988
10/3/1988
10/6/1988
10/14/1988
10/19/1988
10/27/1988
10/28/1988
10/31/1988
11/18/1988
11/28/1988
11/30/1988
1/6/1989

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 7

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 5
Name
Coddington, Herbert James
Ayala, Ronaldo Medrano
Jones, Jeffrey Gerard
Kipp, Martin James
Ochoa, Lester Robert
Quartermain, Drax
Brown, Albert Greenwood, Jr.
Beeler, Rodney Gene
Kolmetz, Jeffrey Wayne
Scott, James Robert
Jackson, Noel
Massie, Robert Lee
Crittenden, Steven Edward
Farnam, Jack Gus
Cunningham, Albert
Seaton, Ronald Harold
Davenport, John Galen
Craine, Louis
Smithey, George Hatton
Welch, David Esco
Ray, Clarence, Jr.
Blair, James Nelson
Marlow, James Gregory
Fairbank, Robert Green
Alvarez, Manuel Machado
Lucas, David Allen
Rundle, David Allen
Lucero, Phillip Louis
Medina, Teofilo, Jr.
Coffman, Cynthia Lynn
Bemore, Terry Douglas
Maury, Robert Edward
Ramirez, Richard Munoz
Davis, Stanley Bernard
Kraft, Randy Steven
Ayala, Hector Juan
Carter, Dean Phillip
Hawkins, Jeffrey Jay
Dunkle, Jon Scott
Padilla, Alfredo Alvarado
Ledesma, Fermin Rodriguez
Arias, Pedro
Lawley, Dennis Harold
Davis, Larry David

Date of death
judgment
1/20/1989
2/9/1989
2/22/1989
2/24/1989
3/20/1989
4/10/1989
4/19/1989
5/5/1989
5/18/1989
5/18/1989
6/2/1989
6/8/1989
6/12/1989
6/15/1989
6/16/1989
6/16/1989
6/26/1989
6/27/1989
7/18/1989
7/25/1989
7/28/1989
8/9/1989
8/31/1989
9/1/1989
9/14/1989
9/19/1989
9/21/1989
10/5/1989
10/25/1989
10/30/1989
11/2/1989
11/3/1989
11/7/1989
11/14/1989
11/29/1989
11/30/1989
1/30/1990
1/31/1990
2/7/1990
2/7/1990
2/7/1990
2/22/1990
2/26/1990
3/8/1990

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 8

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 5
Name
Gray, Mario Lewis
Millwee, Donald Ray
Schmeck, Mark Lindsey
Carter, Tracey Lavell
Tobin, Christopher Allan
Letner, Richard Lacy
Sheldon, Jeffrey Theodore
Bailey, Jerry Kenneth
Holt, John Lee
McDermott, Maureen
Bradford, Mark Alan
Catlin, Steven David
Yeoman, Ralph Michael
Steele, Raymond Edward
Masters, Jarvis J.
Michaels, Kurt
Comtois, Roland Norman
Musselwhite, Joseph Timothy
Snow, Prentice Juan
Hughes, Kristin William
Nakahara, Evan Teek
Gutierrez, Isaac, Jr.
Brown, Paul Madison
Hovarter, Jackie Ray
Lewis, Milton Otis
Salcido, Ramon Bojorquez
Young, Robert
Gurule, Raymond Anthony
Ward, Carmen Lee
Majors, James David
Box, Christopher Clark
Bolin, Paul Clarence
Anderson, James Phillip
Lewis, Raymond Anthony
Waidla, Tauno
Lewis, Robert, Jr.
Hernandez, Jesus Cianez
Stewart, Richard Bert
Moon, Richard Russell
McDonald, Robert F.
Jones, Ronald Anthony
Ervin, Curtis Lee
Bolden, Clifford Stanley
Stanley, Darren Cornelius

Date of death
judgment
3/14/1990
3/21/1990
4/5/1990
4/20/1990
4/24/1990
4/24/1990
5/11/1990
5/16/1990
5/30/1990
6/8/1990
7/3/1990
7/6/1990
7/10/1990
7/24/1990
7/30/1990
7/31/1990
7/31/1990
9/25/1990
9/25/1990
10/2/1990
11/6/1990
11/14/1990
11/16/1990
11/30/1990
12/6/1990
12/17/1990
12/17/1990
12/19/1990
1/25/1991
2/4/1991
2/22/1991
2/25/1991
3/4/1991
3/7/1991
3/8/1991
3/20/1991
3/21/1991
4/26/1991
5/9/1991
5/31/1991
6/4/1991
6/28/1991
7/19/1991
7/29/1991

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 9

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 5
Name
Navarette, Martin Anthony
Bunyard, Jerry Thomas
Carter, Dean Phillip
Townsel, Anthony Letrice
Sapp, John
Morrison, Jesse
Dent, Omar, III
O'Malley, James Francis
Slaughter, Michael Corey
Sakarias, Peter
Watson, Paul Gregory
Jones, Michael Lamont
Cleveland, Dellano Leroy
Burgener, Michael Ray
Staten, Deondre Arthur
Farley, Richard Wade
Veasley, Chauncey Jamal
Taylor, Robert Clarence
Bridges, Edward Dean
Earp, Ricky Lee
Dickey, Colin Raker
Waldon, Billy Ray
Phillips, Richard Louis Arnold
Casares, Jose Lupercio
Vieira, Richard John
Smith, Gregory Scott
Lynch, Franklin
Marlow, James Gregory
Watkins, Paul Sodoa
Walker, Thomas Edwin
Brown, Andrew Lamont
Valdez, Alfredo Reyes
Elliott, Marchand
Prieto, Alfredo R.
Friend, Jack Wayne
Alfaro, Maria del Rosio
Cole, Stephen
Smith, Gregory Calvin
San Nicolas, Rodney Jesse
Moffett, Jessie Ray
Stitely, Richard
Solomon, Morris, Jr.
Griffin, Donald
Richardson, Charles Keith

Date of death
judgment
8/14/1991
9/9/1991
9/9/1991
9/13/1991
10/16/1991
10/30/1991
11/1/1991
11/21/1991
11/27/1991
12/5/1991
12/13/1991
12/13/1991
12/19/1991
1/3/1992
1/16/1992
1/17/1992
1/24/1992
1/30/1992
2/20/1992
2/21/1992
2/27/1992
2/28/1992
3/13/1992
3/13/1992
3/30/1992
4/3/1992
4/28/1992
5/8/1992
5/11/1992
5/12/1992
5/14/1992
5/22/1992
6/3/1992
6/18/1992
6/19/1992
7/14/1992
7/16/1992
8/14/1992
8/31/1992
9/2/1992
9/14/1992
9/16/1992
9/22/1992
10/7/1992

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 10

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 5
Name
Tulk, James David
Hillhouse, Dannie Ray
Howard, Alphonso
Cash, Randall Scott
Williams, David Earl
Roybal, Rudolph Jose
Boyer, Richard Delmer
Cruz, Gerald Dean
Beck, James David
Holloway, Duane
Johnson, Joe Edward
Tully, Richard Christopher
Ochoa, Sergio
Williams, George Brett
Roldan, Ricardo
Ramos, William James
Sturm, Gregory Allen
Lewis, John Irvin
Tate, Gregory O.
Danks, Joseph Martin
Chatman, Erik Sanford
Boyette, Maurice
Martinez, Omar Fuentes
Oliver, Anthony Cedric
Lewis, Albert
Wallace, Keone
Weaver, La Twon Regenial
Bland, Warren James
Benavides, Vicente Figueroa
Thompson, Catherine
Combs, Michael Stephen
Curl, Robert Zane
Crew, Mark Christopher
Stevens, Charles
Monterroso, Christian Antonio
DeHoyos, Richard Lucio
Harrison, Cedric Seth
Zambrano, Enrique
Emdy, Corvin Charles
Houston, Eric Christopher
Heard, James Matthew
Smith, Robert Lee
Prince, Cleophus, Jr.
Manriquez, Abelino

Date of death
judgment
10/9/1992
10/13/1992
10/20/1992
10/20/1992
10/20/1992
10/20/1992
10/23/1992
10/23/1992
10/23/1992
10/27/1992
10/28/1992
12/4/1992
12/10/1992
12/17/1992
12/29/1992
1/8/1993
2/26/1993
3/3/1993
3/5/1993
4/2/1993
4/9/1993
5/7/1993
5/10/1993
5/21/1993
5/21/1993
5/27/1993
5/28/1993
5/28/1993
6/16/1993
6/16/1993
6/21/1993
7/15/1993
7/22/1993
7/30/1993
8/12/1993
8/27/1993
8/30/1993
9/8/1993
9/9/1993
9/20/1993
9/28/1993
9/30/1993
11/5/1993
11/16/1993

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 11

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 5
Name

Date of death
judgment

Koontz, Herbert Harris
Guerra, Jose Francisco
Hinton, Eric Lamont
Huggins, Michael James
Kennedy, Jerry Noble
Harris, Lanell Craig
Bell, Steven M.
Wilson, Robert Paul
Sattiewhite, Christopher James
DePriest, Timothy Lee
Marks, Delaney Geral
Death judgments imposed before
June 9, 1994
Death judgments imposed before
June 9, 1989
Source: Habeas Corpus Resource Center

11/19/1993
11/22/1993
12/10/1993
12/17/1993
12/20/1993
1/12/1994
3/4/1994
4/8/1994
4/25/1994
5/27/1994
6/3/1994
493
318

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 12

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 6

Fiscal
year end
6/30/1999
6/30/2000
6/30/2001
6/30/2002
6/30/2003
6/30/2004
6/30/2005
6/30/2006
6/30/2007
6/30/2008
6/30/2009
6/30/2010
6/30/2011
6/30/2012
6/30/2013
6/06/2014

Number of inmates needing
habeas counsel
160
215
220
260
248
263
266
271
279
284
303
315
324
332
341
352

Source: California Supreme Court Automatic
Appeals Monitor and Habeas Corpus Resource
Center

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 13

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 7

Name

Direct appeal case number

Direct appeal case status

Avila, Alejandro

S135855

Judgment pending

Avila, Joseph

S078664

Judgment entered

Bacon, Robert Allen

S079179

Judgment entered

Banks, Kelvyn Rondell

S080477

Judgment pending

Blacksher, Erven R.

S076582

Judgment entered

Boyce, Kevin Dewayn

S092240

Judgment pending

Brady, Roger Hoan

S078404

Judgment entered

Brasure, Spencer Rawlins

S072949

Judgment entered

Capistrano, John Leo

S067394

Judgment pending

Castaneda, Gabriel

S085348

Judgment entered

Chism, Calvin Dion

S101984

Judgment entered

D'Arcy, Jonathan Daniel

S060500

Judgment entered

Debose, Donald Ray

S080837

Judgment entered

Duenas, Enrique Parra

S077033

Certiorari pending

Enraca, Sonny

S080947

Judgment entered

Famalaro, John Joseph

S064306

Judgment entered

Foster, Richard Don

S058025

Judgment entered

Gamache, Richard Cameron

S052808

Judgment entered

Gonzales, Ivan Joe

S067353

Judgment entered

Gonzales, John Anthony

S075616

Judgment entered

Gonzales, Veronica Utilia

S072316

Judgment entered

Grimes, Gary Lee

S076339

Judgment pending

Gutierrez, Alfred Anthony

S073253

Judgment entered

Hartsch, Cisco James

S074804

Judgment entered

Hensley, Paul Loyde

S050102

Judgment pending

Homick, Steven

S044592

Judgment entered

Jackson, Jonathan Keith

S086269

Judgment entered

Jackson, Michael Anthony

S110206

Judgment entered

Jennings, Martin Carl

S081148

Judgment entered

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 14

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 7
Name

Direct appeal case number

Direct appeal case status

Jones, Albert

S056364

Judgment entered

Jones, Bryan Maurice

S042346

Judgment entered

Jones, William Alfred, Jr.

S076721

Judgment entered

Lewis, Michael Bernard

S069959

Judgment entered

Lindberg, Gunner Jay

S066527

Judgment entered

Linton, Daniel Andrew

S080054

Judgment entered

Livingston, David James

S090499

Judgment entered

Lopez, Juan Manuel

S073597

Certiorari pending

Loy, Eloy

S076175

Judgment entered

Maciel, Luis Pelon

S070536

Judgment entered

Manibusan, Joseph Kekoa

S094890

Judgment entered

Martinez, Tommy Jesse

S074624

Judgment entered

McCurdy, Gene Estel

S061026

Judgment pending

McDowell, Charles Edward

S085578

Judgment entered

McKinnon, Crandell

S077166

Judgment entered

McKinzie, Kenneth

S081918

Judgment entered

Mendoza, Martin

S067678

Judgment entered

Mendoza, Ronald Bruce

S065467

Judgment entered

Montes, Joseph Manuel

S059912

Judgment entered

Moore, Charles Edward

S075726

Judgment entered

Moore, Ronald Wayne

S081479

Judgment entered

Morgan, Edward Patrick

S055130

Judgment entered

Myles, John

S097189

Judgment entered

Nunez, Daniel

S091915

Judgment entered

Redd, Stephen Moreland

S059531

Judgment entered

Rogers, Glen

S080840

Judgment entered

Rogers, Ramon Jay

S064337

Judgment entered

Romero, Gerardo

S070686

Judgment entered

Rountree, Charles F.

S048543

Judgment entered

Satele, William

S091915

Judgment entered

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 15

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 7
Name

Direct appeal case number

Direct appeal case status

Sattiewhite, Christopher James

S039894

Judgment pending

Scott, David Lynn

S068863

Judgment entered

Soliz, Michael

S075616

Judgment entered

Solomon, Morris, Jr.

S029011

Judgment entered

Souza, Matthew Aric

S076999

Judgment entered

Suff, William Lester

S049741

Rehearing pending

Taylor, Brandon Arnae

S062562

Judgment entered

Taylor, Keith Desmond

S054774

Judgment entered

Thomas, Correll Lamont

S082828

Judgment entered

Thomas, Keith Tyson

S067519

Judgment entered

Thomas, Regis Deon

S048337

Judgment entered

Trinh, Dung Dinh Anh

S115284

Judgment entered

Valdez, Richard

S062180

Judgment entered

Vines, Sean Venyette

S065720

Judgment entered

Whisenhunt, Michael McCrea

S056997

Judgment entered

Williams, Corey Leigh

S093756

Judgment entered

Williams, Robert Lee

S118629

Judgment entered

Adams, Marcus

S118045

Briefing complete

Amezcua, Oswaldo

S133660

Briefing complete

Armstrong, Jamelle Edward

S126560

Briefing complete

Becerra, Frank Kalil

S065573

Briefing complete

Brooks, Donald Lewis

S099274

Briefing complete

Buenrostro, Dora

S073823

Briefing complete

Burgener, Michael Ray

S179181

Briefing complete

Cage, Micky Ray

S120583

Briefing complete

Case, Charles Edward

S057156

Briefing complete

Charles, Edward, III

S076337

Briefing complete

Clark, William Clinton

S066940

Briefing complete

Cooper, Leon Chauncey

S099770

Briefing complete

Covarrubias, Daniel Sanchez

S075136

Briefing complete

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 16

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 7
Name

Direct appeal case number

Direct appeal case status

Daveggio, James Anthony

S110294

Briefing complete

Deen, Omar Richard

S092615

Briefing complete

Donaldson, Jasari Latiful

S128402

Briefing complete

Flores, Alfred, III

S116307

Briefing complete

Flores, Joseph

S133660

Briefing complete

Frederickson, Daniel Carl

S067392

Briefing complete

Govin, Pravin

S137290

Briefing complete

Govin, Virendra

S130524

Briefing complete

Hazlett, Larry Kusuth

S126387

Briefing complete

Henriquez, Christopher

S089311

Briefing complete

Holmes, Karl Darnell

S058734

Briefing complete

Jackson, Bailey

S139103

Briefing complete

Johnson, Cedric Jerome

S075727

Briefing complete

Kopatz, Kim Raymond

S097414

Briefing complete

Krebs, Rex Allan

S099439

Briefing complete

Landry, Daniel Gary

S100735

Briefing complete

McClain, Herbert Charles

S058734

Briefing complete

Mendez, Julian Alejandro

S129501

Briefing complete

Mendoza, Huber Joel

S143743

Briefing complete

Michaud, Michelle Lyn

S110294

Briefing complete

Mickel, Andrew Hampton

S133510

Briefing complete

Mora, Joseph Adam

S079925

Briefing complete

Nelson, Sergio Dujuan

S048763

Briefing complete

Newborn, Lorenzo

S058734

Briefing complete

Ng, Charles Chitat

S080276

Briefing complete

Nguyen, Lam Thanh

S076340

Briefing complete

Potts, Thomas

S072161

Briefing complete

Powell, Troy Lincoln

S137730

Briefing complete

Rangel, Ruben

S079925

Briefing complete

Reed, Ennis

S082776

Briefing complete

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 17

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 7
Name

Direct appeal case number

Direct appeal case status

Rhoades, Robert Boyd

S082101

Briefing complete

Salazar, Magdaleno

S077524

Briefing complete

Sandoval, Ramon, Jr.

S115872

Briefing complete

Scott, Royce Lyn

S064858

Briefing complete

Silveria, Daniel Todd

S062417

Briefing complete

Simon, Richard Nathan

S102166

Briefing complete

Sivongxxay, Vaene

S078895

Briefing complete

Smith, Floyd Daniel

S065233

Briefing complete

Smith, Paul Gordon, Jr.

S112442

Briefing complete

Travis, John Raymond

S062417

Briefing complete

Vargas, Eduardo David

S101247

Briefing complete

Westerfield, David Alan

S112691

Briefing complete

Williams, Jack Emmit

S073205

Briefing complete

Winbush, Grayland

S117489

Briefing complete

Woodruff, Steve

S115378

Briefing complete

Zaragoza, Louis Rangel

S097886

Briefing complete

Alvarez, Francisco Jay

S089619

ARB pending

Armstrong, Craigen Lewis

S130659

ARB pending

Bankston, Anthony George

S044739

ARB pending

Barrera, Marco Esquivel

S103358

ARB pending

Camacho, Adrian George

S141080

ARB pending

Caro, Socorro Susan

S106274

ARB pending

Cordova, Joseph Seferino

S152737

ARB pending

Dixon, James Winslow

S163417

ARB pending

Espinoza, Johnny

S140795

ARB pending

Flinner, Michael William

S123813

ARB pending

Garton, Todd Jesse

S097558

ARB pending

Gomez, Ruben Perez

S087773

ARB pending

Hardy, Warren Justin

S113421

ARB pending

Hin, Mao

S141519

ARB pending

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 18

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 7
Name

Direct appeal case number

Direct appeal case status

Johnson, Jerrold Elwin

S093235

ARB pending

Leon, Jose Luis

S143531

ARB pending

Loot, Kendrick

S086578

ARB pending

Millsap, Bruce

S086578

ARB pending

Nadey, Giles Albert, Jr.

S087560

ARB pending

Penunuri, Richard

S095076

ARB pending

Poynton, Richard James

S096809

ARB pending

Ramirez, Juan Villa

S099844

ARB pending

Schultz, Michael Joseph

S114671

ARB pending

Scully, Robert Walter

S062259

ARB pending

Wright, William Lee

S107900

ARB pending

Young, Jeffrey Scott

S148462

ARB pending

Anderson, Eric Steve

S138474

RB pending

Argueta, Carlos Marvin

S150524

RB pending

Baker, Paul Wesley

S170280

RB pending

Barrett, Joseph Anthony

S124131

RB pending

Battle, Thomas

S119296

RB pending

Chhoun, Run Peter

S084996

RB pending

Drews, Martin Dexter

S154365

RB pending

Dworak, Douglas Edward

S135272

RB pending

Erskine, Scott Thomas

S127621

RB pending

Fayed, James Michael

S198132

RB pending

Gonzalez, Frank Christopher

S163643

RB pending

Helzer, Glen Taylor

S132256

RB pending

Johnson, Billy Joe

S178272

RB pending

Mataele, Tupoutoe

S138052

RB pending

Melendez, Angelo Michael

S118384

RB pending

Miles, Johnny Duane

S086234

RB pending

Miranda Guerrero, Victor M.

S118147

RB pending

Morales, Alfonso Ignacio

S136800

RB pending

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 19

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 7
Name

Direct appeal case number

Direct appeal case status

Morelos, Valdamir Fred

S051968

RB pending

Navarro, Anthony

S165195

RB pending

Orozco, Jose Luis

S152556

RB pending

Pan, Samreth Sam

S105403

RB pending

Williams, George

S131819

RB pending

Wilson, Javance Mickey

S118775

RB pending

Wilson, Lester Harland

S189373

RB pending

Abbott, Joe Henry

S141274

AOB pending

Acremant, Robert James

S110804

AOB pending

Becerrada, Ruben

S170957

AOB pending

Capers, Lee Samuel

S146939

AOB pending

Cardenas, Refugio Ruben

S151493

AOB pending

Chhoun, Run Peter

S105403

AOB pending

Crawford, Charles Edward

S107653

AOB pending

Demolle, Alex

S159120

AOB pending

Dent, Anthony

S176413

AOB pending

Dunlap, Dean Eric

S142857

AOB pending

Evans, Steve Carl

S169689

AOB pending

Flores, Ralph

S166737

AOB pending

Ford, Wayne Adam

S151172

AOB pending

Frazier, Robert Ward

S148863

AOB pending

Hamilton, Alexander Rashad

S158112

AOB pending

Kennedy, John Fitzgerald

S172750

AOB pending

Lamb, Michael Allan

S166168

AOB pending

Luther, Johnathan Ross

S152269

AOB pending

Madison, Ricky Rene

S174886

AOB pending

Magallon, Miguel Angel

S177281

AOB pending

McKnight, Anthony

S168441

AOB pending

Miracle, Joshua Martin

S140894

AOB pending

Mitchell, Louis, Jr.

S147335

AOB pending

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 20

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 7
Name

Direct appeal case number

Direct appeal case status

Mosley, Barry Wendell

S168204

AOB pending

Parker, Calvin Lamont

S113962

AOB pending

Pineda, Santiago

S150509

AOB pending

Poore, Christopher Eric

S104665

AOB pending

Rivera, Cuitlahuac Tahua

S153881

AOB pending

Sanchez, Vincent Henry

S120382

AOB pending

Silva, Mauricio Rodriguez

S155617

AOB pending

Steskal, Maurice Gerald

S122611

AOB pending

Thomas, Justin Heath

S161781

AOB pending

Turner, Chester Dwayne

S154499

AOB pending

Watta, Benjamin Wayne

S170001

AOB pending

Wesson, Marcus Delon

S136171

AOB pending

Aguirre, Jason Alejandro

S175660

Alcala, Rodney James

S181535

Aldana, Roman Gabriel

S185201

Alvarez, Alberto

S180174

Arias, Lorenzo Inez

S167010

Bertsch, John Anthony

S093944

Bracamontes, Manuel

S139702

Buettner, Jeffree J.

S182341

Cain, Anthony Deondrea

S179826

Chavez, Juan Jose

S162506

Choyce, William Jennings

S169090

Colbert, Tecumseh

S169152

Cook, Michael

S165649

Deleon, Skylar Julius

S171998

Dunn, Aaron Norman

S184521

Guerrero, Jose

S174227

Hernandez, George Anthony

S180217

Hill, Ivan J.

S152463

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 21

Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 7
Name

Direct appeal case number

Hronis, Jeffery Lee

S093944

Hughes, Mervin Ray

S134792

Jasso, Christopher Guy

S179454

Jones, Glen Joseph

S182341

Jones, Steven Anthony

S175663

Kemp, Darryl Thomas

S174232

Lewis, Travis Jeremy

S185221

Martin, Valerie Dee

S181555

Martinez, Carlos

S175720

Martinez, Santiago

S178464

McDaniel, Donte Lamont

S171393

McGhee, Timothy J.

S169750

Mejorado, Jose Sergio

S186162

Mendoza, Luis Alonso

S167010

Morales, Johnny

S137307

Oyler, Raymond Lee

S173784

Penuelas, Jesus Guadalupe Velazquez

S165894

Plata, Noel Jesse

S165998

Ramirez, Irving Alexander

S155160

Rhoades, Robert Boyd

S154053

Rices, Jean Pierre

S175851

Rivera, Samuel Ramon

S174455

Rottiers, Brooke Marie

S187726

Sarinana, Cathy Lynn

S174709

Sarinana, Raul Ricardo

S174709

Shermantine, Wesley Howard, Jr.

S097668

Shove, Theodore Churchill

S161909

Snyder, Janeen Marie

S146528

Stayner, Cary Anthony

S112146

Thornton, Michael Forrest

S146528

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 22

Direct appeal case status
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 7
Name

Direct appeal case number

Direct appeal case status
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction
Counsel appointed; Record
correction

Tran, Ronald Tri

S165998

Valles, Pedro Cortez

S188589

Varner, Scott Paul

S182059

Victorianne, Javier William

S162197

Volarvich, Brendt Anthony

S164370

Wycoff, Edward Matthew

S178669

Yonko, Tony Ricky

S176812

Young, Donald Ray

S142959

Young, Timothy James

S142959

Dennis, Calvin Jermaine

S170293

Ingram, Reyon Twain

S170293

Jennings, Glenn Wade

S188035

Aguilar, Jeffrey

S214388

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Avalos, Emilio Manuel

S209032

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Balcom, Jason Michael

S216466

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Barbar, Michael

S207510

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Bell, Cimarron Bernard

S195568

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Bernoudy, Kevin

S191346

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Brim, Ronald Earl

S213832

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Brown, Latece Megale

S203540

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Brown, Sherhaun Kerod

S203206

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Burris, Nathan

S208209

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Butler, Raymond Oscar

S202630

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Canales, Osman

S207945

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Castro, Robert Gonzales

S216791

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Cervantes, Daniel

S210054

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Contreras, Carlos

S210054

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Daniels, Jackson Chambers, Jr.

S180112

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Espinoza, Pedro

S206484

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Evans, Christopher

S182232

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 23

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 7
Name

Direct appeal case number

Direct appeal case status

Fajardo, Jonathan

S192662

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Fierros, Eusebio, Jr.

S202817

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Fletcher, Marcus

S198309

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Forte, Melvin Earl

S193769

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Fowler, Rickie Lee

S208429

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Frazier, Travis

S212477

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Galvan, Robert

S211060

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Graham, Jawaun Deion

S199667

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Green, Earl Ellis

S203655

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Halvorsen, Arthur Hans

S190636

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Hann, Jason Michael

S216750

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Heard, James Matthew

S185140

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Hirschfield , Richard Joseph

S208354

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Hughes, Michael

S203514

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Jackson, Earl Lloyd

S182161

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

John, Emrys Justin

S212376

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Johnson, Mila

S186271

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Kelley, Jimmy Dale

S185640

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Kling, Randolph Clifton

S180711

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Livingston, Waymon

S210386

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Macias, Armando

S196185

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Manzo, Jesse

S212699

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Marentes, Desi Angel

S208348

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Martinez, Alberto

S185364

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Mendoza, Angel

S215960

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Miller, Tyrone

S212376

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Mills, David

S206515

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Moore, Ryan T.

S201205

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Naso, Joseph

S214917

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Nelson, Tanya Jaime

S182278

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 24

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 7
Name

Direct appeal case number

Direct appeal case status

Nissensohn, Joseph Michael

S219152

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Nowlin, Kenneth Lee

S212477

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Paniagua, Rodrigo Ortiz, Jr.

S189296

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Perez, Christian

S211045

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Perez, John Michael

S212030

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Reed, David John

S197781

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Richardson, Jason Russell

S198378

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Rodriguez, Antonio

S186360

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Ronquillo, Gabriel Alexander

S200982

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Ruiz, Rudy Anthony

S212030

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Shorts, Donald

S189992

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Smith, Charles

S213242

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Thomson, John Wayne

S217774

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Threats, Derlyn Ray

S185810

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Topete, Marco Antonio

S200016

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Tucker, Jamar

S189992

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Vang, Ronnie

S218457

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Villa, Ricardo

S195828

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Wade, Anthony Darnell

S214649

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Walters, Michael J.

S212161

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Whiteside, Gregory C.

S188067

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Williams, Manling Tsang

S199741

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Zanon, David Charles

S188961

Awaiting direct appeal counsel

Inmates needing appellate or habeas counsel as of 6/6/2014
Inmates needing appellate counsel as of 6/6/2014
Source: Habeas Corpus Resource Center

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 25

352
71

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 8.1

Avila, Alejandro

7/22/2005

S135855

Time since
death
judgment
8.873374401

Avila, Joseph

4/29/1999

S078664

15.10472279

Bacon, Robert Allen

5/20/1999

S079179

15.04722793

Banks, Kelvyn Rondell

7/8/1999

S080477

14.91307324

Blacksher, Erven R.

2/9/1999

S076582

15.321013

Boyce, Kevin Dewayn

9/29/2000

S092240

13.68377823

Brady, Roger Hoan

3/16/1999

S078404

15.22518823

Brasure, Spencer Rawlins

8/24/1998

S072949

15.78370979

Capistrano, John Leo

1/6/1998

S067394

16.41341547

Castaneda, Gabriel

1/7/2000

S085348

14.41204654

10/24/2001

S101984

12.61601643

D'Arcy, Jonathan Daniel

4/11/1997

S060500

17.15263518

Debose, Donald Ray

7/21/1999

S080837

14.87748118

Duenas, Enrique Parra

1/22/1999

S077033

15.37029432

Enraca, Sonny

7/23/1999

S080947

14.87200548

9/5/1997

S064306

16.75017112

12/13/1996

S058025

17.47843943

4/2/1996

S052808

18.17659138

1/13/1998

S067353

16.39425051

Gonzales, John Anthony

12/18/1998

S075616

15.4661191

Gonzales, Veronica Utilia

7/20/1998

S072316

15.87953457

Grimes, Gary Lee

1/27/1999

S076339

15.35660507

Gutierrez, Alfred Anthony

8/10/1998

S073253

15.8220397

Hartsch, Cisco James

11/13/1998

S074804

15.56194387

Hensley, Paul Loyde

10/16/1995

S050102

18.63928816

Homick, Steven

1/13/1995

S044592

19.39493498

Jackson, Jonathan Keith

2/18/2000

S086269

14.29705681

Jackson, Michael Anthony

9/20/2002

S110206

11.70978782

Jennings, Martin Carl

7/22/1999

S081148

14.87474333

Jones, Albert

9/20/1996

S056364

17.70841889

Jones, Bryan Maurice

9/16/1994

S042346

19.72073922

Jones, William Alfred, Jr.

2/8/1999

S076721

15.32375086

Lewis, Michael Bernard

5/1/1998

S069959

16.09856263

12/12/1997

S066527

16.48186174

Name

Chism, Calvin Dion

Famalaro, John Joseph
Foster, Richard Don
Gamache, Richard Cameron
Gonzales, Ivan Joe

Lindberg, Gunner Jay

Date of death
judgment

Direct appeal
case number

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 26

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 8.1

Linton, Daniel Andrew

6/17/1999

S080054

Time since
death
judgment
14.9705681

Livingston, David James

7/20/2000

S090499

13.87816564

Lopez, Juan Manuel

9/18/1998

S073597

15.71526352

Loy, Eloy

1/14/1999

S076175

15.39219713

5/8/1998

S070536

16.07939767

Manibusan, Joseph Kekoa

1/24/2001

S094890

13.36344969

Martinez, Tommy Jesse

9/25/1998

S074624

15.69609856

McCurdy, Gene Estel

4/22/1997

S061026

17.12251882

McDowell, Charles Edward

1/26/2000

S085578

14.36002738

McKinnon, Crandell

3/5/1999

S077166

15.25530459

McKinzie, Kenneth

8/26/1999

S081918

14.77891855

Mendoza, Martin

12/23/1997

S067678

16.45174538

Mendoza, Ronald Bruce

10/24/1997

S065467

16.61601643

Montes, Joseph Manuel

3/18/1997

S059912

17.2183436

Moore, Charles Edward

12/7/1998

S075726

15.49623546

Moore, Ronald Wayne

8/16/1999

S081479

14.80629706

Morgan, Edward Patrick

7/19/1996

S055130

17.88090349

Myles, John

4/23/2001

S097189

13.11978097

Nunez, Daniel

9/14/2000

S091915

13.724846

Redd, Stephen Moreland

2/28/1997

S059531

17.26762491

Rogers, Glen

7/16/1999

S080840

14.89117043

Rogers, Ramon Jay

9/10/1997

S064337

16.73648186

Romero, Gerardo

5/22/1998

S070686

16.04106776

Rountree, Charles F.

8/11/1995

S048543

18.81998631

Satele, William

9/14/2000

S091915

13.724846

Sattiewhite, Christopher James

4/25/1994

S039894

20.11498973

Scott, David Lynn

3/19/1998

S068863

16.21629021

12/18/1998

S075616

15.4661191

Solomon, Morris, Jr.

9/16/1992

S029011

21.71937029

Souza, Matthew Aric

2/19/1999

S076999

15.2936345

Suff, William Lester

10/26/1995

S049741

18.61190965

Taylor, Brandon Arnae

6/27/1997

S062562

16.94182067

Taylor, Keith Desmond

6/5/1996

S054774

18.00136893

Thomas, Correll Lamont

10/7/1999

S082828

14.66392882

Thomas, Keith Tyson

1/16/1998

S067519

16.38603696

Name

Maciel, Luis Pelon

Soliz, Michael

Date of death
judgment

Direct appeal
case number

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 27

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 8.1

Thomas, Regis Deon

8/15/1995

S048337

Time since
death
judgment
18.80903491

Trinh, Dung Dinh Anh

4/14/2003

S115284

11.14579055

Valdez, Richard

6/11/1997

S062180

16.98562628

Vines, Sean Venyette

11/7/1997

S065720

16.57768652

Whisenhunt, Michael McCrea

10/21/1996

S056997

17.62354552

Williams, Corey Leigh

11/15/2000

S093756

13.55509925

Williams, Robert Lee
8/29/2003
S118629
Average time waiting for habeas counsel for inmates whose
direct appeals are concluded
Inmates needing habeas counsel whose direct appeals have
concluded
Source: Habeas Corpus Resource Center

10.770705

Name

Date of death
judgment

Direct appeal
case number

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 28

15.78
76

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 8.2

Solomon, Morris, Jr.

9/16/1992

S029011

Time since
death
judgment
21.71937029

Sattiewhite, Christopher James

4/25/1994

S039894

20.11498973

Jones, Bryan Maurice

9/16/1994

S042346

19.72073922

Homick, Steven

1/13/1995

S044592

19.39493498

Bankston, Anthony George

1/20/1995

S044739

19.37577002

Rountree, Charles F.

8/11/1995

S048543

18.81998631

Thomas, Regis Deon

8/15/1995

S048337

18.80903491

9/7/1995

S048763

18.74606434

Hensley, Paul Loyde

10/16/1995

S050102

18.63928816

Suff, William Lester

10/26/1995

S049741

18.61190965

2/21/1996

S051968

18.28884326

Gamache, Richard Cameron

4/2/1996

S052808

18.17659138

Taylor, Keith Desmond

6/5/1996

S054774

18.00136893

Morgan, Edward Patrick

7/19/1996

S055130

17.88090349

Jones, Albert

9/20/1996

S056364

17.70841889

Whisenhunt, Michael McCrea

10/21/1996

S056997

17.62354552

Case, Charles Edward

10/25/1996

S057156

17.61259411

Foster, Richard Don

12/13/1996

S058025

17.47843943

Holmes, Karl Darnell

1/21/1997

S058734

17.37166324

McClain, Herbert Charles

1/21/1997

S058734

17.37166324

Newborn, Lorenzo

1/21/1997

S058734

17.37166324

Redd, Stephen Moreland

2/28/1997

S059531

17.26762491

Montes, Joseph Manuel

3/18/1997

S059912

17.2183436

D'Arcy, Jonathan Daniel

4/11/1997

S060500

17.15263518

McCurdy, Gene Estel

4/22/1997

S061026

17.12251882

Valdez, Richard

6/11/1997

S062180

16.98562628

Silveria, Daniel Todd

6/13/1997

S062417

16.98015058

Travis, John Raymond

6/13/1997

S062417

16.98015058

Scully, Robert Walter

6/13/1997

S062259

16.98015058

Taylor, Brandon Arnae

6/27/1997

S062562

16.94182067

Famalaro, John Joseph

9/5/1997

S064306

16.75017112

Rogers, Ramon Jay

9/10/1997

S064337

16.73648186

Scott, Royce Lyn

9/17/1997

S064858

16.71731691

Smith, Floyd Daniel

10/16/1997

S065233

16.63791923

Mendoza, Ronald Bruce

10/24/1997

S065467

16.61601643

Name

Nelson, Sergio Dujuan

Morelos, Valdamir Fred

Date of death
judgment

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 29

Direct appeal
case number

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 8.2

Becerra, Frank Kalil

10/31/1997

S065573

Time since
death
judgment
16.59685147

Vines, Sean Venyette

11/7/1997

S065720

16.57768652

Lindberg, Gunner Jay

12/12/1997

S066527

16.48186174

Mendoza, Martin

12/23/1997

S067678

16.45174538

Clark, William Clinton

12/29/1997

S066940

16.43531828

Capistrano, John Leo

1/6/1998

S067394

16.41341547

Frederickson, Daniel Carl

1/9/1998

S067392

16.40520192

Gonzales, Ivan Joe

1/13/1998

S067353

16.39425051

Thomas, Keith Tyson

1/16/1998

S067519

16.38603696

Scott, David Lynn

3/19/1998

S068863

16.21629021

Lewis, Michael Bernard

5/1/1998

S069959

16.09856263

Maciel, Luis Pelon

5/8/1998

S070536

16.07939767

Romero, Gerardo

5/22/1998

S070686

16.04106776

Gonzales, Veronica Utilia

7/20/1998

S072316

15.87953457

Potts, Thomas

7/23/1998

S072161

15.87132101

Gutierrez, Alfred Anthony

8/10/1998

S073253

15.8220397

Brasure, Spencer Rawlins

8/24/1998

S072949

15.78370979

Williams, Jack Emmit

8/24/1998

S073205

15.78370979

Lopez, Juan Manuel

9/18/1998

S073597

15.71526352

Martinez, Tommy Jesse

9/25/1998

S074624

15.69609856

Buenrostro, Dora

10/2/1998

S073823

15.67693361

Covarrubias, Daniel Sanchez

10/27/1998

S075136

15.60848734

Hartsch, Cisco James

11/13/1998

S074804

15.56194387

Moore, Charles Edward

12/7/1998

S075726

15.49623546

Gonzales, John Anthony

12/18/1998

S075616

15.4661191

Soliz, Michael

12/18/1998

S075616

15.4661191

Johnson, Cedric Jerome

12/18/1998

S075727

15.4661191

Loy, Eloy

1/14/1999

S076175

15.39219713

Charles, Edward, III

1/15/1999

S076337

15.38945927

Duenas, Enrique Parra

1/22/1999

S077033

15.37029432

Grimes, Gary Lee

1/27/1999

S076339

15.35660507

Nguyen, Lam Thanh

1/28/1999

S076340

15.35386721

Jones, William Alfred, Jr.

2/8/1999

S076721

15.32375086

Blacksher, Erven R.

2/9/1999

S076582

15.321013

Souza, Matthew Aric

2/19/1999

S076999

15.2936345

McKinnon, Crandell

3/5/1999

S077166

15.25530459

Salazar, Magdaleno

3/12/1999

S077524

15.23613963

Name

Date of death
judgment

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 30

Direct appeal
case number

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 8.2

Brady, Roger Hoan

3/16/1999

S078404

Time since
death
judgment
15.22518823

Avila, Joseph

4/29/1999

S078664

15.10472279

Sivongxxay, Vaene

4/29/1999

S078895

15.10472279

Bacon, Robert Allen

5/20/1999

S079179

15.04722793

Mora, Joseph Adam

5/27/1999

S079925

15.02806297

Rangel, Ruben

5/27/1999

S079925

15.02806297

Linton, Daniel Andrew

6/17/1999

S080054

14.9705681

Ng, Charles Chitat

6/30/1999

S080276

14.93497604

7/8/1999

S080477

14.91307324

Rogers, Glen

7/16/1999

S080840

14.89117043

Debose, Donald Ray

7/21/1999

S080837

14.87748118

Jennings, Martin Carl

7/22/1999

S081148

14.87474333

Enraca, Sonny

7/23/1999

S080947

14.87200548

Moore, Ronald Wayne

8/16/1999

S081479

14.80629706

McKinzie, Kenneth

8/26/1999

S081918

14.77891855

Rhoades, Robert Boyd

9/10/1999

S082101

14.73785079

Reed, Ennis

9/29/1999

S082776

14.68583162

Thomas, Correll Lamont

10/7/1999

S082828

14.66392882

Chhoun, Run Peter

1/4/2000

S084996

14.4202601

Castaneda, Gabriel

1/7/2000

S085348

14.41204654

1/26/2000

S085578

14.36002738

2/8/2000

S086234

14.32443532

Jackson, Jonathan Keith

2/18/2000

S086269

14.29705681

Loot, Kendrick

2/23/2000

S086578

14.28336756

Millsap, Bruce

2/23/2000

S086578

14.28336756

Gomez, Ruben Perez

3/31/2000

S087773

14.18206708

Nadey, Giles Albert, Jr.

4/12/2000

S087560

14.14921287

Henriquez, Christopher

6/2/2000

S089311

14.00958248

Alvarez, Francisco Jay

6/28/2000

S089619

13.93839836

Livingston, David James

7/20/2000

S090499

13.87816564

Nunez, Daniel

9/14/2000

S091915

13.724846

Satele, William

9/14/2000

S091915

13.724846

Boyce, Kevin Dewayn

9/29/2000

S092240

13.68377823

Deen, Omar Richard

10/5/2000

S092615

13.66735113

Johnson, Jerrold Elwin

11/9/2000

S093235

13.57152635

Williams, Corey Leigh

11/15/2000

S093756

13.55509925

Bertsch, John Anthony

12/19/2000

S093944

13.46201232

Name

Banks, Kelvyn Rondell

McDowell, Charles Edward
Miles, Johnny Duane

Date of death
judgment

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 31

Direct appeal
case number

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 8.2

12/19/2000

S093944

Time since
death
judgment
13.46201232

Manibusan, Joseph Kekoa

1/24/2001

S094890

13.36344969

Penunuri, Richard

1/31/2001

S095076

13.34428474

Kopatz, Kim Raymond

3/21/2001

S097414

13.21013005

Poynton, Richard James

4/9/2001

S096809

13.15811088

Myles, John

4/23/2001

S097189

13.11978097

Garton, Todd Jesse

4/27/2001

S097558

13.10882957

Shermantine, Wesley Howard, Jr.

5/16/2001

S097668

13.0568104

Zaragoza, Louis Rangel

5/22/2001

S097886

13.0403833

Cooper, Leon Chauncey

5/25/2001

S099770

13.03216975

Brooks, Donald Lewis

7/16/2001

S099274

12.88980151

Krebs, Rex Allan

7/20/2001

S099439

12.8788501

Ramirez, Juan Villa

7/20/2001

S099844

12.8788501

Landry, Daniel Gary

9/11/2001

S100735

12.73374401

Vargas, Eduardo David

10/4/2001

S101247

12.67077344

10/24/2001

S101984

12.61601643

Simon, Richard Nathan

11/2/2001

S102166

12.59137577

Barrera, Marco Esquivel

12/13/2001

S103358

12.47912389

Poore, Christopher Eric

2/20/2002

S104665

12.29021218

Chhoun, Run Peter

3/12/2002

S105403

12.23545517

Pan, Samreth Sam

3/13/2002

S105403

12.23271732

Caro, Socorro Susan

4/5/2002

S106274

12.16974675

Crawford, Charles Edward

6/7/2002

S107653

11.99726215

Wright, William Lee

6/14/2002

S107900

11.97809719

Jackson, Michael Anthony

9/20/2002

S110206

11.70978782

Daveggio, James Anthony

9/25/2002

S110294

11.69609856

Michaud, Michelle Lyn

9/25/2002

S110294

11.69609856

Acremant, Robert James

10/4/2002

S110804

11.67145791

Smith, Paul Gordon, Jr.

12/6/2002

S112442

11.49897331

Stayner, Cary Anthony

12/12/2002

S112146

11.4825462

1/6/2003

S112691

11.41409993

Hardy, Warren Justin

1/23/2003

S113421

11.36755647

Parker, Calvin Lamont

2/24/2003

S113962

11.27994524

Schultz, Michael Joseph

3/26/2003

S114671

11.19780972

Trinh, Dung Dinh Anh

4/14/2003

S115284

11.14579055

Woodruff, Steve

4/17/2003

S115378

11.137577

5/9/2003

S115872

11.07734428

Name
Hronis, Jeffery Lee

Chism, Calvin Dion

Westerfield, David Alan

Sandoval, Ramon, Jr.

Date of death
judgment

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 32

Direct appeal
case number

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 8.2

Flores, Alfred, III

5/19/2003

S116307

Time since
death
judgment
11.04996578

Winbush, Grayland

7/11/2003

S117489

10.90485969

Adams, Marcus

7/30/2003

S118045

10.85284052

8/4/2003

S118147

10.83915127

Melendez, Angelo Michael

8/18/2003

S118384

10.80082136

Wilson, Javance Mickey

8/27/2003

S118775

10.7761807

Williams, Robert Lee

8/29/2003

S118629

10.770705

9/4/2003

S119296

10.75427789

11/4/2003

S120382

10.58726899

11/14/2003

S120583

10.55989049

Steskal, Maurice Gerald

2/6/2004

S122611

10.32991102

Flinner, Michael William

3/29/2004

S123813

10.18754278

S124131

10.16837782
159

Name

Miranda Guerrero, Victor M.

Battle, Thomas
Sanchez, Vincent Henry
Cage, Micky Ray

Date of death
judgment

Direct appeal
case number

Barrett, Joseph Anthony
4/5/2004
Inmates without habeas counsel for more than ten years
Source: Habeas Corpus Resource Center

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 33

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 9.1

Number of death
judgments
2009
30
2010
34
2011
11
2012
14
2013
25
Average death judgments 2009-2013
22.8
Source: California Appellate Project, California Supreme Court
Automatic Appeals Monitor, and Habeas Corpus Resource Center
Year

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 34

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 9.2

Number of
Year
habeas
appointments
2009
14
2010
14
2011
9
2012
6
2013
4
Average habeas appointments 2009-2013
9.4
Source: California Appellate Project, California Supreme Court
Automatic Appeals Monitor, and Habeas Corpus Resource Center

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 35

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 10

Number of cases with
replacement counsel

Years

Number of 1st petitions or
amended petitions filed
during these years

Note: Numbers include cases
Percentage of cases
where replacement occurred
for which
before case initiated or during
replacement counsel
informal briefing; numbers
was appointed
exclude cases where replacement
occurred after informal briefing
or after the 1st habeas case
closed

2003-2007
106
2008-2013
86
2003-2013
192
Source: Habeas Corpus Resource Center

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 36

19
21
40

17.93
24.42
21%

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 11.1

2005-2006 2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009 2009-2010 2010-2011 2011-2012 2012-2013
HCRC appointments: habeas
corpus only
Total habeas corpus
appointments per year
Percentage of habeas
appointments HCRC has
accepted

10

12

7

8

5

3

1

2

20

18

16

13

13

12

9

4

50%

67%

44%

62%

38%

25%

11%

50%

Average percentage of habeas
appointments HCRC has
accepted FY 2005-2006
through 2012-2013

43%

Source: California Appellate Project, California Supreme Court Automatic Appeals Monitor, and Habeas Corpus Resource Center

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 37

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 11.2

Number of HCRC 1st petitions from 2009-2014 (excluding initial
35
petitions not yet amended)
Number of non-HCRC 1st petitions from 2009-2014 (excluding
58
initial petitions not yet amended)
Average percentage of 1st petitions 2009-2014 filed by HCRC
38%
Source: California Appellate Project, California Supreme Court Automatic
Appeals Monitor, and Habeas Corpus Resource Center

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 38

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 12

State
habeas
case
number
S129612
S125670
S129603
S123149
S128874
S126032
S129510
S126085
S130263
S125276
S127630
S126851
S122460
S126781
S122097
S122545
S123962
S125755
S124998
S130314

Time to file
informal
response

Time to file
reply

Time to
decision

0.394250513

0.421629021

6.406570842

0.45174538

0.678986995

2.795345654

0.481861739

0.260095825

5.869952088

0.334017796

0.539356605

0.186173854

0.238193018

0.572210815

3.58384668

0.410677618

0.386036961

4.180698152

0.851471595

0.684462697

6.997946612

0.728268309

1.119780972

5.303216975

0.084873374

0.123203285

0.610540726

0.840520192

4.796714579

0.514715948

0.635181383

2.245037645

0.377823409

0.462696783

2.340862423

1.67008898

1.492128679

1.615331964

0.509240246

0.736481862

3.110198494

0.536618754

0.580424367

4.93908282

0.240930869

0.432580424

5.848049281

0.563997262

0.774811773

1.051334702

0.421629021

1.021218344

2.05065024

0.525667351

0.375085558

4.900752909

0.262833676

1.771389459

2.88843258

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 39

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 12
State
habeas
case
number
S122384

Time to file
informal
response

Time to file
reply

Time to
decision

0.889801506

0.777549624

1.021218344

0.711841205

0.413415469

4.210814511

0.45174538
0.673511294
Average
0.53
0.69
Source: Habeas Corpus Resource Center

6.746064339
3.78

S124851
S128008

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 40

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 13.1

Name

State habeas
case number

First full
petition filed

Years pending

Champion, Steve Allen

S065575

11/5/1997

16.56947296

Rogers, David Keith

S084292

12/14/1999

14.46406571

Carter, Tracey Lavell

S096438

4/2/2001

13.16358658

Welch, David Esco

S107782

6/24/2002

11.93702943

Ray, Clarence, Jr.

S110219

9/27/2002

11.67693361

Benavides, Vicente Figueroa

S111336

11/12/2002

11.55099247

Morrison, Jesse

S115559

5/2/2003

11.08281999

Stitely, Richard

S115894

5/15/2003

11.04722793

Davis, Stanley Bernard

S116750

6/16/2003

10.9596167

Holt, John Lee

S116794

6/18/2003

10.954141

Lewis, Robert, Jr.

S117235

7/2/2003

10.91581109

Griffin, Donald

S118650

9/2/2003

10.74606434

Tafoya, Ignacio Arriola

S120020

10/27/2003

10.59548255

Williams, David Earl

S121187

12/12/2003

10.46954141

Jackson, Noel

S129989

12/16/2004

9.456536619

Gay, Kenneth Earl

S130263

12/28/2004

9.423682409

Masters, Jarvis J.

S130495

1/7/2005

9.396303901

Hovarter, Jackie Ray

S133770

5/9/2005

9.062286105

Guerra, Jose Francisco

S134332

6/1/2005

8.999315537

Cook, Walter Joseph

S136687

8/24/2005

8.769336071

Wallace, Keone

S140077

1/4/2006

8.405201916

Hernandez, Jesus Cianez

S141716

3/7/2006

8.235455168

Riccardi, John Alexander

S143058

5/1/2006

8.084873374

Harris, Lanell Craig

S144756

7/3/2006

7.912388775

Richardson, Charles Keith

S148523

12/5/2006

7.488021903

Snow, Prentice Juan

S121365

12/18/2006

7.452429843

Welch, David Esco

S149222

1/4/2007

7.405886379

Friend, Jack Wayne

S150208

2/13/2007

7.296372348

Ray, Clarence, Jr.

S150974

3/14/2007

7.216974675

Letner, Richard Lacy

S151222

3/26/2007

7.184120465

Miranda, Adam

S151264

3/26/2007

7.184120465

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 41

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 13.1
Name

State habeas
case number

First full
petition filed

Years pending

Tobin, Christopher Allan

S151243

3/26/2007

7.184120465

Box, Christopher Clark

S153345

6/8/2007

6.981519507

Davenport, John Galen

S155689

8/23/2007

6.773442847

Williams, George Brett

S156682

9/27/2007

6.67761807

Bunyard, Jerry Thomas

S157098

10/9/2007

6.64476386

Whalen, Daniel Lee

S157184

10/15/2007

6.628336756

Robinson, James

S141320

10/23/2007

6.606433949

Cowan, Robert Wesley

S158073

11/9/2007

6.559890486

Lynch, Franklin

S158710

12/3/2007

6.494182067

Bennett, Eric Wayne

S159540

1/2/2008

6.412046543

Manriquez, Abelino

S141210

1/10/2008

6.390143737

Virgil, Lester Wayne

S160814

2/13/2008

6.29705681

Ervine, Dennis Newton

S162212

4/1/2008

6.165639973

Burton, Andre

S162260

4/2/2008

6.162902122

Farnam, Jack Gus

S162381

4/3/2008

6.160164271

Slaughter, Michael Corey

S167303

10/3/2008

5.659137577

Lenart, Thomas Howard

S167453

10/10/2008

5.639972621

Lucas, David Allen

S168103

11/6/2008

5.56605065

Smith, Gregory Scott

S138147

1/30/2009

5.333333333

Elliot, Michael Lee

S140140

2/23/2009

5.267624914

Ward, Carmen Lee

S142694

3/13/2009

5.2183436

Watkins, Paul Sodoa

S172438

4/28/2009

5.092402464

Bell, Steven M.

S151362

6/22/2009

4.941820671

Abel, John Clyde

S175275

8/4/2009

4.824093087

Gonzalez, Jesse Edward

S175344

8/7/2009

4.815879535

Pearson, Michael Nevail

S175920

8/31/2009

4.750171116

Lightsey, Christopher Charles

S176414

9/17/2009

4.703627652

Jenkins, Daniel Steven

S176494

9/21/2009

4.692676249

Dalton, Kerry Lyn

S178504

12/7/2009

4.481861739

Moon, Richard Russell

S178977

12/23/2009

4.438056126

Brown, John George

S179645

1/21/2010

4.358658453

Romero, Gerardo

S167166

1/21/2010

4.358658453

Barnwell, Lamar

S158842

1/22/2010

4.355920602

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 42

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 13.1
Name

State habeas
case number

First full
petition filed

Years pending

Adcox, Keith Edward

S180912

3/12/2010

4.221765914

Carey, Dewayne Michael

S157242

3/22/2010

4.194387406

Leonard, Eric Royce

S153974

3/22/2010

4.194387406

Riggs, Billy Ray

S173875

5/13/2010

4.052019165

Slaughter, Michael Corey

S183839

5/21/2010

4.030116359

Lancaster, Andrew

S154541

6/1/2010

4

Mungia, John

S166477

6/1/2010

4

Williams, Bob Russell, Jr.

S183405

6/9/2010

3.978097194

Lindberg, Gunner Jay

S173896

6/11/2010

3.972621492

Rangel, Pedro, Jr.

S183606

6/17/2010

3.956194387

Zamudio, Samuel Jimenez

S167100

6/28/2010

3.926078029

Roldan, Ricardo

S185447

8/16/2010

3.79192334

Raley, David Allen

S185736

8/25/2010

3.767282683

Thornton, Mark Scott

S158512

9/21/2010

3.693360712

Harris, Willie Leo

S187337

10/15/2010

3.627652293

Moon, Richard Russell

S189159

10/22/2010

3.608487337

O'Malley, James Francis

S187622

10/26/2010

3.597535934

Kelly, Douglas Oliver

S161036

12/7/2010

3.482546201

Ledesma, Fermin Rodriguez

S147702

12/10/2010

3.474332649

Webb, Dennis Duane

S190098

1/25/2011

3.348391513

Blair, James Nelson

S190217

1/31/2011

3.331964408

Eubanks, Susan Dianne

S190405

2/7/2011

3.312799452

Burney, Shaun Kareem

S190968

2/28/2011

3.255304586

Streeter, Howard Larcell

S191287

3/9/2011

3.230663929

Tully, Richard Christopher

S191449

3/16/2011

3.211498973

Carrasco, Robert

S191869

4/1/2011

3.167693361

Pearson, Kevin Darnell

S191872

4/1/2011

3.167693361

Watson, Paul Gregory

S167108

4/15/2011

3.12936345

Loker, Keith Thomas

S167792

4/29/2011

3.091033539

Elliott, Marchand

S192958

5/9/2011

3.063655031

Samuels, Mary Ellen

S193440

5/26/2011

3.017111567

Weaver, La Twon Regenial

S193534

5/31/2011

3.003422313

Geier, Christopher Adam

S193602

6/2/2011

2.997946612

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 43

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 13.1
Name

State habeas
case number

First full
petition filed

Years pending

Horning, Danny Ray

S194705

7/11/2011

2.891170431

Beames, John Michael

S195127

7/27/2011

2.847364819

Prince, Cleophus, Jr.

S155510

7/27/2011

2.847364819

Hinton, Eric Lamont

S195922

8/26/2011

2.765229295

Danks, Joseph Martin

S196398

9/13/2011

2.715947981

Turner, Richard Dean

S196910

10/3/2011

2.661190965

Geier, Christopher Adam

S198025

10/11/2011

2.639288159

Doolin, Keith Zon

S197391

10/24/2011

2.603696099

Wheeler, LeRoy

S197586

10/31/2011

2.584531143

Lomax, Darrell Lee

S197707

11/3/2011

2.576317591

Romero, Orlando Gene

S197824

11/9/2011

2.559890486

Thompson, Catherine

S192701

11/16/2011

2.54072553

Curl, Robert Zane

S180828

1/30/2012

2.335386721

Contreras, George Lopez

S199915

2/6/2012

2.316221766

DeHoyos, Richard Lucio

S199918

2/6/2012

2.316221766

Bryant, Stanley

S200323

2/23/2012

2.269678303

Brown, Steven Allen

S200366

2/27/2012

2.258726899

Self, Christopher

S200464

3/1/2012

2.250513347

Hamilton, Bernard Lee

S174549

3/19/2012

2.201232033

Alexander, Andre Stephen

S191587

4/13/2012

2.132785763

Howard, Demetrius Charles

S196958

4/30/2012

2.0862423

McWhorter, Richard

S180404

5/18/2012

2.036960986

Avila, Johnny, Jr.

S203288

6/14/2012

1.963039014

Farley, Richard Wade

S179795

6/14/2012

1.963039014

Johnson, Michael Raymond

S203329

6/15/2012

1.960301164

Seumanu, Ropati

S203852

7/9/2012

1.894592745

Lindberg, Gunner Jay

S204545

8/3/2012

1.826146475

Hajek, Stephen Edward

S204529

8/6/2012

1.817932923

Vo, Loi Tan

S204795

8/20/2012

1.779603012

Navarette, Martin Anthony

S204865

8/22/2012

1.77412731

Horning, Danny Ray

S206764

8/24/2012

1.768651608

Valencia, Alfredo

S167195

8/27/2012

1.760438056

George, Johnaton Sampson

S205750

10/2/2012

1.661875428

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 44

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 13.1
Name

State habeas
case number

First full
petition filed

Years pending

Lenart, Thomas Howard

S205999

10/15/2012

1.626283368

Parker, Gerald

S206006

10/15/2012

1.626283368

Beck, James David

S206945

11/28/2012

1.505817933

Cruz, Gerald Dean

S206963

11/28/2012

1.505817933

Lewis, Albert

S207075

12/4/2012

1.489390828

Mai, Hung Thanh

S208180

12/24/2012

1.434633812

Nieves, Sandi Dawn

S207902

1/9/2013

1.3908282

Powell, Carl Devon

S208154

1/22/2013

1.35523614

Gonzalez, Jesse Edward

S208922

2/27/2013

1.256673511

Johnson, Lumord

S209679

4/2/2013

1.163586585

Turner, Melvin

S210095

4/19/2013

1.117043121

Hawthorne, Carlos Anthony

S176951

4/22/2013

1.108829569

Mills, Jeffery Jon

S188459

4/22/2013

1.108829569

Butler, Raymond Oscar

S178123

6/10/2013

0.97467488

Martinez, Michael Matthew

S180670

6/17/2013

0.955509925

Merriman, Justin James

S212038

7/15/2013

0.878850103

Wilson, Andre Gerald

S166315

7/22/2013

0.859685147

Lopez, Michael Augustine

S212256

7/24/2013

0.854209446

Spencer, Christopher Alan

S212368

7/29/2013

0.840520192

Barnett, Lee Max

S212998

8/27/2013

0.761122519

Valdez, Alfredo Reyes

S213143

9/4/2013

0.739219713

Huggins, Michael James

S213717

10/1/2013

0.665297741

Hawthorne, Anderson, Jr.

S213911

10/10/2013

0.640657084

Clark, Royal

S214078

10/18/2013

0.618754278

Perry, Clifton

S214222

10/25/2013

0.599589322

Edwards, Robert Mark

S214543

11/12/2013

0.550308008

Weatherton, Fred Lewis

S214555

11/12/2013

0.550308008

Pollock, Milton Ray

S214789

11/21/2013

0.525667351

Salcido, Ramon Bojorquez

S214863

11/27/2013

0.509240246

Jablonski, Phillip Carl

S215450

12/24/2013

0.435318275

Leon, Richard

S215554

12/30/2013

0.41889117

Thompson, James Alvin

S188525

1/24/2014

0.350444901

Verdugo, Nathan James

S190666

1/27/2014

0.342231348

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 45

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 13.1
Name

State habeas
case number

First full
petition filed

Years pending

Bolden, Clifford Stanley

S216632

2/20/2014

0.27652293

Townsel, Anthony Letrice

S216626

2/20/2014

0.27652293

Cook, Joseph Lloyd

S217150

3/14/2014

0.216290212

Lee, Philian Eugene

S194609

3/19/2014

0.202600958

Chatman, Erik Sanford

S217244

3/20/2014

0.199863107

Hoyt, Ryan James

S217299

3/24/2014

0.188911704

Peoples, Louis James

S217369

3/26/2014

0.183436003

Bramit, Michael Lamar

S178113

4/25/2014

0.101300479

Sapp, John

S218046

4/25/2014

0.101300479

Ghobrial, John Samuel

S218292

5/5/2014

0.073921971

Jones, Kiongozi

S218551

5/15/2014

0.046543463

Booker, Richard Lonnie

S196994

5/19/2014

0.03559206

Smith, Robert Lee

S218736

5/19/2014

0.03559206

Average years all petitions have been pending (excludes initial petitions)

4.07

Source: Habeas Corpus Resource Center

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 46

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 13.2

Name

Abel, John Clyde
Adcox, Keith Edward
Avila, Johnny, Jr.
Barnwell, Lamar
Beames, John Michael
Bell, Steven M.
Benavides, Vicente Figueroa
Bennett, Eric Wayne
Blair, James Nelson
Box, Christopher Clark
Brown, John George
Brown, Steven Allen
Bunyard, Jerry Thomas
Burney, Shaun Kareem
Carey, Dewayne Michael
Carter, Tracey Lavell
Contreras, George Lopez
Cowan, Robert Wesley
Curl, Robert Zane

State
habeas
case
number

Date reply to
informal
response filed

Time waiting
for CSC
decision
(includes OSC
cases)

S175275

8/8/2011

2.828199863

S180912

11/4/2011

2.587268994

S203288

3/4/2014

0.257357974

S158842

7/5/2012

1.919233402

S195127

12/20/2012

1.45927447

S151362

9/28/2010

3.68788501

S111336

12/21/2012

1.456536619

S159540

5/28/2010

4.024640657

S190217

5/5/2011

3.088295688

S153345

9/24/2008

5.697467488

S179645 Not applicable

4.112251882

S200366

7/17/2013

0.887063655

S157098

10/7/2010

3.663244353

S190968

10/9/2012

1.656399726

S157242

9/28/2011

2.688569473

S096438

8/19/2002

11.79739904

S199915

1/8/2014

0.407939767

S158073

10/22/2008

5.620807666

S180828

5/9/2014

0.076659822

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 47

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 13.2

Name

Dalton, Kerry Lyn
Danks, Joseph Martin
Davenport, John Galen
Davis, Stanley Bernard
DeHoyos, Richard Lucio
Doolin, Keith Zon
Elliot, Michael Lee
Elliott, Marchand
Ervine, Dennis Newton
Eubanks, Susan Dianne
Farley, Richard Wade
Farnam, Jack Gus
Friend, Jack Wayne
Gay, Kenneth Earl
Geier, Christopher Adam
Geier, Christopher Adam
Gonzalez, Jesse Edward
Gonzalez, Jesse Edward
Hamilton, Bernard Lee
Harris, Lanell Craig
Harris, Willie Leo

State
habeas
case
number

Date reply to
informal
response filed

Time waiting
for CSC
decision
(includes OSC
cases)

S178504

6/2/2014

0.010951403

S196398

6/22/2012

1.954825462

S155689

5/15/2009

5.059548255

S116750

4/9/2004

10.15742642

S199918

12/2/2013

0.509240246

S197391

12/28/2012

1.437371663

S140140

2/14/2011

3.307323751

S192958

11/19/2012

1.544147844

S162212

3/15/2010

4.227241615

S190405

9/20/2012

1.708418891

S179795

10/7/2013

0.66255989

S162381

6/26/2009

4.944558522

S150208

5/28/2008

6.023271732

S130263

3/14/2005

9.229295003

S193602

2/4/2013

1.333333333

S198025

2/4/2013

1.333333333

S175344

8/2/2010

3.843942505

S208922

7/23/2013

0.87063655

S174549

10/30/2013

0.599589322

S144756

3/13/2009

5.232032854

S187337

6/19/2012

1.963039014

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 48

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 13.2

Name

Hinton, Eric Lamont
Horning, Danny Ray
Hovarter, Jackie Ray
Howard, Demetrius Charles
Huggins, Michael James
Jablonski, Phillip Carl
Jenkins, Daniel Steven
Kelly, Douglas Oliver
Lancaster, Andrew
Ledesma, Fermin Rodriguez
Lenart, Thomas Howard
Lenart, Thomas Howard
Leonard, Eric Royce
Letner, Richard Lacy
Lewis, Albert
Lewis, Robert, Jr.
Lightsey, Christopher Charles
Loker, Keith Thomas
Lucas, David Allen
Lynch, Franklin
Manriquez, Abelino

State
habeas
case
number

Date reply to
informal
response filed

Time waiting
for CSC
decision
(includes OSC
cases)

S195922

4/5/2012

2.168377823

S194705

1/15/2014

0.388774812

S133770

6/4/2007

7.006160164

S196958

3/17/2014

0.221765914

S213717

2/11/2014

0.314852841

S215450

5/8/2014

0.079397673

S176494

7/5/2011

2.92128679

S161036

3/4/2013

1.256673511

S154541

7/30/2013

0.851471595

S147702

10/31/2012

1.596167009

S167453

6/4/2010

4.005475702

S205999

1/25/2013

1.360711841

S153974

1/23/2012

2.368240931

S151222

3/18/2011

3.219712526

S207075

8/12/2013

0.815879535

S117235

4/16/2004

10.13826146

S176414

2/3/2011

3.33744011

S167792

6/25/2012

1.94661191

S168103

3/22/2010

4.20807666

S158710

4/1/2010

4.180698152

S141210

6/30/2009

4.933607118

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 49

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 13.2

Name

Masters, Jarvis J.
McWhorter, Richard
Miranda, Adam
Mungia, John
Navarette, Martin Anthony
Nieves, Sandi Dawn
O'Malley, James Francis
Pearson, Kevin Darnell
Pearson, Michael Nevail
Prince, Cleophus, Jr.
Rangel, Pedro, Jr.
Ray, Clarence, Jr.
Ray, Clarence, Jr.
Riccardi, John Alexander
Robinson, James
Rogers, David Keith
Roldan, Ricardo
Romero, Gerardo
Romero, Orlando Gene
Samuels, Mary Ellen
Seumanu, Ropati

State
habeas
case
number

Date reply to
informal
response filed

Time waiting
for CSC
decision
(includes OSC
cases)

S130495

9/19/2005

8.711841205

S180404

11/18/2013

0.547570157

S151264

2/6/2008

6.32991102

S166477

7/23/2012

1.869952088

S204865

3/4/2013

1.256673511

S207902

2/28/2014

0.268309377

S187622

3/5/2013

1.253935661

S191872

4/3/2012

2.173853525

S175920

1/18/2013

1.379876797

S155510

9/23/2013

0.700889802

S183606

3/8/2012

2.245037645

S110219

1/21/2003

11.37303217

S150974

2/15/2008

6.305270363

S143058

10/8/2009

4.65982204

S141320

3/24/2009

5.201916496

S084292

2/25/2002

12.27652293

S185447

5/30/2012

2.01779603

S167166

9/23/2013

0.700889802

S197824

10/30/2012

1.59890486

S193440 Not applicable

2.855578371

S203852

0.260095825

3/3/2014

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 50

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 13.2

Name

Slaughter, Michael Corey
Slaughter, Michael Corey
Smith, Gregory Scott
Snow, Prentice Juan
Streeter, Howard Larcell
Thompson, Catherine
Thornton, Mark Scott
Tobin, Christopher Allan
Tully, Richard Christopher
Turner, Melvin
Turner, Richard Dean
Valdez, Alfredo Reyes
Virgil, Lester Wayne
Ward, Carmen Lee
Watkins, Paul Sodoa
Watson, Paul Gregory
Weaver, La Twon Regenial
Webb, Dennis Duane
Welch, David Esco
Welch, David Esco
Whalen, Daniel Lee

State
habeas
case
number

Date reply to
informal
response filed

Time waiting
for CSC
decision
(includes OSC
cases)

S167303

5/21/2010

4.043805613

S183839

9/2/2010

3.759069131

S138147

3/22/2011

3.208761123

S121365

11/16/2009

4.553045859

S191287

2/8/2013

1.32238193

S192701

6/27/2013

0.941820671

S158512

7/25/2012

1.864476386

S151243

5/12/2011

3.069130732

S191449

7/3/2013

0.925393566

S210095

12/5/2013

0.501026694

S196910

1/30/2013

1.347022587

S213143

1/30/2014

0.34770705

S160814

3/6/2012

2.250513347

S142694

4/15/2011

3.143052704

S172438

11/3/2010

3.589322382

S167108

8/21/2013

0.791238877

S193534

6/4/2013

1.004791239

S190098

5/9/2011

3.077344285

S107782

10/15/2003

10.64202601

S149222

9/12/2007

6.732375086

S157184

10/8/2008

5.659137577

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 51

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 13.2

Name

Williams, Bob Russell, Jr.

State
habeas
case
number

Date reply to
informal
response filed

Time waiting
for CSC
decision
(includes OSC
cases)

S183405

12/14/2011

2.477754962

S121187

6/9/2005

8.991101985

S156682

5/10/2010

4.073921971

S167100
11/1/2012
Average time fully briefed cases have been waiting
(including OSC cases)

1.593429158

Williams, David Earl
Williams, George Brett
Zamudio, Samuel Jimenez

3.132

Source: Habeas Corpus Resource Center

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 52

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 14

Name

Time between
Date reply to
State
Date of CSC
reply and
informal
habeas case
disposition
CSC decision
number response filed

Allen, Michael Damone

S162508

12/8/2009

3/28/2012

2.302532512

Avila, Johnny, Jr.

S116554

2/28/2005

6/15/2011

6.291581109

Beames, John Michael

S153603

9/17/2008

7/28/2010

1.859000684

Blair, James Nelson

S144759

12/13/2007

9/9/2009

1.741273101

Bonilla, Steven Wayne

S129612

9/26/2005

2/22/2012

6.406570842

Boyer, Richard Delmer

S101970

8/22/2002

6/17/2009

6.819986311

Brown, Andrew Lamont

S125670

8/4/2005

5/21/2008

2.795345654

Burgener, Michael Ray

S093551

9/4/2002

6/17/2009

6.784394251

Burney, Shaun Kareem

S133439

12/26/2006

12/17/2009

2.976043806

Carasi, Paul Joe

S129603

8/29/2005

7/13/2011

5.869952088

Carrington, Celeste Simone

S142464

8/3/2007

9/15/2010

3.118412047

Chatman, Erik Sanford

S114982

2/27/2004

12/10/2008

4.785763176

Clark, Royal

S142741

11/16/2007

1/11/2012

4.153319644

Cole, Stephen

S128874

8/24/2005

3/25/2009

3.58384668

Collins, Scott Forrest

S136461

9/5/2006

9/25/2013

7.055441478

Combs, Michael Stephen

S134705

2/14/2008

7/11/2012

4.405201916

Cook, Joseph Lloyd

S160915

3/17/2011

9/12/2012

1.492128679

Cornwell, Glen

S126032

4/19/2005

6/24/2009

4.180698152

Cruz, Tomas Verano

S129510

6/13/2006

6/12/2013

6.997946612

Danks, Joseph Martin

S121004

2/7/2005

9/15/2010

5.60164271

Davis, Richard Allen

S157917

7/31/2009

1/23/2013

3.482546201

Demetrulias, Gregory Spiros

S136487

6/18/2007

9/17/2008

1.25119781

DePriest, Timothy Lee

S136672

7/6/2009

5/1/2013

3.819301848

Doolin, Keith Zon

S137884

7/17/2006

6/24/2009

2.937713895

Dunkle, Jon Scott

S119946

10/25/2004

12/2/2009

5.103353867

Dykes, Ernest Edward

S126085

5/12/2006

8/31/2011

5.303216975

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 53

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 14

Name

Time between
Date reply to
State
Date of CSC
reply and
informal
habeas case
disposition
CSC decision
number response filed

Fuiava, Freddie

S161608

11/24/2009

4/30/2014

4.429842574

Geier, Christopher Adam

S147393

7/6/2009

6/9/2010

0.925393566

Halvorsen, Arthur Hans

S130342

12/21/2005

2/20/2013

7.167693361

Harris, Maurice Lydell

S139789

9/27/2011

5/15/2013

1.631759069

Harrison, Cedric Seth

S130762

1/17/2007

6/10/2009

2.395619439

Hinton, Eric Lamont

S125276

11/14/2005

9/1/2010

4.796714579

Horning, Danny Ray

S137676

3/16/2010

5/12/2010

0.156057495

Houston, Eric Christopher

S190730

11/5/2012

11/26/2013

1.056810404

Howard, Alphonso

S144008

5/31/2007

7/18/2012

5.133470226

Hoyos, Jaime Armando

S146472

7/11/2008

2/18/2009

0.607802875

Huggins, Michael James

S127630

11/1/2005

1/30/2008

2.245037645

Johnson, Cleamon

S180946

1/21/2011

3/28/2012

1.18275154

Jones, Ernest Dewayne

S110791

12/8/2003

3/11/2009

5.256673511

Jurado, Robert J.

S136327

7/9/2007

7/23/2008

1.040383299

Kennedy, Jerry Noble

S138625

6/1/2010

9/18/2013

3.299110198

Lewis, Albert

S120420

5/6/2004

8/18/2010

6.283367556

Lewis, John Irvin

S139017

6/11/2007

1/19/2011

3.608487337

Marlow, James Gregory

S101172

8/26/2002

10/22/2008

6.15742642

Marlow, James Gregory

S101171

8/26/2002

10/22/2008

6.15742642

Maury, Robert Edward

S122460

4/5/2010

11/16/2011

1.615331964

Monterroso, Christian Antonio

S120980

1/16/2008

6/20/2012

4.427104723

Moon, Richard Russell

S126781

10/31/2005

12/10/2008

3.110198494

Navarette, Martin Anthony

S122097

9/8/2006

8/17/2011

4.93908282

Oliver, Anthony Cedric

S122545

10/12/2004

8/18/2010

5.848049281

Perry, Clifton

S138225

1/24/2007

7/27/2011

4.503764545

Ramos, William James

S175417

4/29/2010

8/22/2012

2.316221766

Roldan, Ricardo

S115143

8/11/2003

8/12/2009

6.004106776

Roybal, Rudolph Jose

S156846

12/23/2008

1/3/2013

4.030116359

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 54

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 14

Name

Time between
Date reply to
State
Date of CSC
reply and
informal
habeas case
disposition
CSC decision
number response filed

Rundle, David Allen

S130722

6/16/2006

6/25/2008

2.026009582

Salcido, Ramon Bojorquez

S091159

7/3/2002

5/20/2009

6.880219028

Samuels, Mary Ellen

S124998

4/15/2005

3/10/2010

4.900752909

Sapp, John

S130314

1/12/2007

12/2/2009

2.88843258

Schmeck, Mark Lindsey

S131578

8/24/2006

11/13/2013

7.222450376

Smith, Robert Lee

S144019

4/16/2009

6/15/2011

2.162902122

Stanley, Darren Cornelius

S106165

11/25/2002

7/8/2009

6.617385352

Stevens, Charles

S119354

3/26/2004

8/26/2009

5.418206708

Turner, Richard Dean

S124851

7/2/2005

9/17/2009

4.210814511

Vieira, Richard John

S147688

12/10/2007

6/24/2009

1.538672142

Williams, Bob Russell, Jr.

S137389

11/13/2006

6/10/2009

2.57357974

Williams, Dexter Winfred

S128008

11/9/2005

8/8/2012

6.746064339

Wilson, Lester Harland

S152074

8/19/2009

6/30/2010

0.862422998

S116021
2/17/2004
8/12/2009
Average years between reply and decision for 1st petitions with
dispositions 2008-2014 (excluding OSC cases and cases dismissed due to
death)

5.483915127

Zambrano, Enrique

3.98

Source: Habeas Corpus Resource Center

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 55

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 15

Name

State habeas
case number

Date of death
judgment

Time between death
judgment and
decision for 1st
petition

Date of CSC
disposition

Avila, Johnny, Jr.

S116554

3/29/1995

6/15/2011

16.21355236

Beames, John Michael

S153603

10/11/1995

7/28/2010

14.79534565

Blair, James Nelson

S144759

8/9/1989

9/9/2009

20.08487337

Bolden, Clifford Stanley

S099231

7/19/1991

6/10/2009

17.89459274

Bonilla, Steven Wayne

S129612

1/20/1995

2/22/2012

17.08966461

Boyer, Richard Delmer

S101970

10/23/1992

6/17/2009

16.64887064

Boyette, Maurice

S092356

5/7/1993

8/28/2013

20.30937714

Brown, Andrew Lamont

S125670

5/14/1992

5/21/2008

16.01916496

Burgener, Michael Ray

S093551

1/3/1992

6/17/2009

17.45379877

Burney, Shaun Kareem

S133439

9/16/1994

12/17/2009

15.25256674

Carasi, Paul Joe

S129603

5/26/1998

7/13/2011

13.13073238

Carrington, Celeste Simone

S142464

11/23/1994

9/15/2010

15.8110883

Chatman, Erik Sanford

S114982

4/9/1993

12/10/2008

15.67145791

Clark, Royal

S142741

2/3/1995

1/11/2012

16.93634497

Cole, Stephen

S128874

7/16/1992

3/25/2009

16.6899384

Collins, Scott Forrest

S136461

12/19/1996

9/25/2013

16.76659822

Combs, Michael Stephen

S134705

6/21/1993

7/11/2012

19.05544148

Cook, Joseph Lloyd

S160915

9/16/1994

9/12/2012

17.99041752

Cornwell, Glen

S126032

4/21/1995

6/24/2009

14.17659138

Cruz, Tomas Verano

S129510

9/9/1994

6/12/2013

18.75701574

Danks, Joseph Martin

S121004

4/2/1993

9/15/2010

17.45379877

Davis, Richard Allen

S157917

9/26/1996

1/23/2013

16.32580424

Demetrulias, Gregory Spiros

S136487

5/19/1995

9/17/2008

13.33333333

DePriest, Timothy Lee

S136672

5/27/1994

5/1/2013

18.92950034

Doolin, Keith Zon

S137884

6/18/1996

6/24/2009

13.01574264

Dunkle, Jon Scott

S119946

2/7/1990

12/2/2009

19.816564

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 56

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 15

Name

State habeas
case number

Date of death
judgment

Time between death
judgment and
decision for 1st
petition

Date of CSC
disposition

Dykes, Ernest Edward

S126085

12/22/1995

8/31/2011

15.69062286

Fuiava, Freddie

S161608

8/19/1996

4/30/2014

17.69472964

Geier, Christopher Adam

S147393

7/21/1995

6/9/2010

14.88569473

Halvorsen, Arthur Hans

S130342

11/18/1988

2/20/2013

24.25735797

Harris, Maurice Lydell

S139789

12/20/1996

5/15/2013

16.39972621

Harrison, Cedric Seth

S130762

8/30/1993

6/10/2009

15.77823409

Hinton, Eric Lamont

S125276

12/10/1993

9/1/2010

16.72553046

Horning, Danny Ray

S137676

1/26/1995

5/12/2010

15.29089665

Houston, Eric Christopher

S190730

9/20/1993

11/26/2013

20.183436

Howard, Alphonso

S144008

10/20/1992

7/18/2012

19.74264203

Hoyos, Jaime Armando

S146472

7/11/1994

2/18/2009

14.6091718

Huggins, Michael James

S127630

12/17/1993

1/30/2008

14.11909651

Jones, Ernest Dewayne

S110791

4/7/1995

3/11/2009

13.92744695

Jurado, Robert J.

S136327

10/7/1994

7/23/2008

13.79329227

Kennedy, Jerry Noble

S138625

12/20/1993

9/18/2013

19.74537988

Lawley, Dennis Harold

S089463

2/26/1990

6/11/2008

18.28884326

Lewis, Albert

S120420

5/21/1993

8/18/2010

17.24298426

Lewis, John Irvin

S139017

3/3/1993

1/19/2011

17.88090349

Marlow, James Gregory

S101172

8/31/1989

10/22/2008

19.1430527

Marlow, James Gregory

S101171

5/8/1992

10/22/2008

16.45722108

Maury, Robert Edward

S122460

11/3/1989

11/16/2011

22.03422313

Monterroso, Christian Antonio

S120980

8/12/1993

6/20/2012

18.85557837

Moon, Richard Russell

S126781

5/9/1991

12/10/2008

17.59069131

Navarette, Martin Anthony

S122097

8/14/1991

8/17/2011

20.00821355

Oliver, Anthony Cedric

S122545

5/21/1993

8/18/2010

17.24298426

Perry, Clifton

S138225

7/24/1996

7/27/2011

15.00616016

Ramos, William James

S175417

1/8/1993

8/22/2012

19.61943874

Roldan, Ricardo

S115143

12/29/1992

8/12/2009

16.61875428

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 57

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 15

Date of death
judgment

Time between death
judgment and
decision for 1st
petition

Name

State habeas
case number

Date of CSC
disposition

Roybal, Rudolph Jose

S156846

10/20/1992

1/3/2013

20.20533881

Rundle, David Allen

S130722

9/21/1989

6/25/2008

18.75975359

Salcido, Ramon Bojorquez

S091159

12/17/1990

5/20/2009

18.42299795

Samuels, Mary Ellen

S124998

9/16/1994

3/10/2010

15.47980835

Sapp, John

S130314

10/16/1991

12/2/2009

18.13004791

Schmeck, Mark Lindsey

S131578

4/5/1990

11/13/2013

23.60848734

Smith, Robert Lee

S144019

9/30/1993

6/15/2011

17.70568104

Smithey, George Hatton

S070780

7/18/1989

9/10/2008

19.14852841

Stanley, Darren Cornelius

S106165

7/29/1991

7/8/2009

17.94387406

Stevens, Charles

S119354

7/30/1993

8/26/2009

16.07392197

Turner, Richard Dean

S124851

10/19/1988

9/17/2009

20.91170431

Valdez, Alfredo Reyes

S107508

5/22/1992

7/8/2010

18.12731006

Vieira, Richard John

S147688

3/30/1992

6/24/2009

17.2347707

Williams, Bob Russell, Jr.

S137389

9/20/1996

6/10/2009

12.72005476

Williams, Dexter Winfred

S128008

2/28/1996

8/8/2012

16.44353183

Wilson, Lester Harland

S152074

6/29/2000

6/30/2010

10.00136893

Zambrano, Enrique

S116021

9/8/1993

8/12/2009

15.92607803

Average time between death judgment and decision for 1st petition dispositions 20082014, including OSCs, excluding dismissals

17.2

Source: Habeas Corpus Resource Center

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 58

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 16.1

Name
Adcox, Keith Edward
Alcala, Rodney James
Alcala, Rodney James
Alfaro, Maria del Rosio
Allen, Clarence Ray
Allison, Watson
Alvarez, Manuel Machado
Anderson, James Phillip
Andrews, Jesse James
Arias, Pedro
Avena, Carlos Jaime
Avila, Johnny, Jr.
Ayala, Hector Juan
Ayala, Ronaldo Medrano
Babbitt, Manuel Pina
Bacigalupo, Miguel Angel
Barnett, Lee Max
Beames, John Michael
Beardslee, Donald Jay
Beeler, Rodney Gene
Bell, Ronald Lee
Benson, Richard Allen
Berryman, Rodney, Sr.
Bittaker, Lawrence Sigmond
Blair, James Nelson
Bloom, Robert Maurice
Bloyd, Dale Michael
Bolden, Clifford Stanley
Bonin, William George
Bonin, William George
Box, Christopher Clark
Boyde, Richard
Boyer, Richard Delmer
Bradford, Bill
Bradford, Mark Alan
Breaux, David Anthony
Brown, Andrew Lamont
Brown, John George
Brown, John George
Burney, Shaun Kareem
Burton, Andre
Cain, Tracy Dearl
Caro, Fernando Eros

State habeas case numbers
S017293, S026779, S074000, S180912
CR21908, CR23258
S009129, S047409
S099569, S170966
S003571, S031165, S139857
S016415, S042478
S073670, S146501
S066574, S134525
S017657, S039576, S120348
S050843, S114347
S046608, S076118
S116554, S203288
S081267, S114371, S133446, S159584
S072059, S110094
S004455 ; CR24440, S009386, S029756, S078539
S032738, S079656
S059885, S096831, S120570, S212998
S153603, S195127
S004622, S052116
S033869, S065016, S127525
S015786, S044466, S105569
S030686, S063126, S094994, S116971
S034862, S068933, S077805
S010483, S052371
S144759, S190217
CR25325, S022735, S035229
Unknown, S000029/CR25554
S099231, S216632
S016301, S051633
S010087, S011262, S016344, S051634
S087643, S153345
S017352, S039855
S101970, S181948
S056604, S100542
S084903, S119155
S021609, S045944
S125670, S136785
S009797, S037992
S120253, S179645
S133439, S190968
S002936, S034725, S162260
S032447, S067172, S116805, S152288
S005083, S027045

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 59

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 16.1
Name
Carpenter, David Joseph
Carpenter, David Joseph
Carrera, Constantino
Carter, Dean Phillip
Carter, Dean Phillip
Catlin, Steven David
Chatman, Erik Sanford
Clair, Kenneth
Clark, Douglas Daniel
Clark, Richard Dean
Clark, Royal
Clark, William John
Cleveland, Dellano Leroy
Coddington, Herbert James
Cole, Stephen
Coleman, Calvin, Jr.
Coleman, Russell
Cook, Joseph Lloyd
Cooper, Kevin
Cornwell, Glen
Cox, Michael Anthony
Cox, Tiequon Aundray
Crew, Mark Christopher
Crittenden, Steven Edward
Cudjo, Armenia Levi, Jr.
Cummings, Raynard Paul
Danks, Joseph Martin
Davenport, John Galen
Davis, Larry David
Davis, Stanley Bernard
Deere, Ronald Lee
Demetrulias, Gregory Spiros
Dennis, William Michael
DePriest, Timothy Lee
DeSantis, Stephen
Diaz, Robert Rubane
Dickey, Colin Raker
Doolin, Keith Zon
Duncan, Henry Earl
Dyer, Alfred R.
Easley, Elbert Lee
Edwards, Thomas Francis
Espinoza, Antonio
Farnam, Jack Gus
Fauber, Curtis Lynn

State habeas case numbers
S058191, S083035
S083246, S110890
S003674, S049666, S062394, S141324
S090230, S153790
S096874, S153780, S180336
S090636, S173793
S114982, S217244
S024707, S045241, S052733, S169188
S115061, S120556
S031246, S060797, S116968
S142741, S214078
S020060, S022475
S123149, S143814
S085976, S107502
S128874, S142889
S023949, S117990, S133438
S013726, S025597, S041610
S160915, S217150
S052741, S064320, S075527, S077408, S116984, S122389, S122507
S126032, S152880
S004507, S033824, S038251, S135128
S044014, S082898
S084495, S107856
S034783, S060706
S029707, S090162, S128474, S134653
S044871, S071267
S121004, S196398
S049760, S089502, S155689
S045183, S062517
S116750, S130190
S019008, S036482
S136487, S160990
S055380, S099587, S201330
S136672, S171297
S020486, S051609
S016304, S033433
S115079, S165302
S137884, S197391
S016908, S047651
S008594, S022577, S023364, S032198
S004094, S032556
S030742, S092074
S023462, S062244, S116824
S081408, S122414, S162381
S030753, S065139, S134365

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 60

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 16.1
Name
Fields, Stevie Lamar
Fierro, David Rey
Frank, Theodore Francis
Freeman, Fred Harlan
Frierson, Lavell
Frye, Jerry Grant
Gates, Oscar
Gay, Kenneth Earl
Geier, Christopher Adam
Ghent, David Luther
Gonzalez, Jesse Edward
Gonzalez, Martin G.
Grant, Richard Edward
Gray, Mario Lewis
Green, Charles Alan
Gutierrez, Isaac, Jr.
Hamilton, Billy Ray
Hamilton, Michael Allen
Hardy, James Edward
Harris, Robert Alton
Hart, Joseph William
Hawkins, Jeffrey Jay
Hawthorne, Anderson, Jr.
Hayes, Blufford, Jr.
Hayes, Royal Kenneth
Heishman, Harvey Lee, III
Hernandez, Francis Gerard
Hernandez, Jesus Cianez
Hillhouse, Dannie Ray
Hines, Gary Dale
Hinton, Eric Lamont
Hitchings, Keith Sanford
Holloway, Duane
Holt, John Lee
Horning, Danny Ray
Horton, James Frank, II
Hovey, Richard Adams
Howard, Albert Cecil
Howard, Gary Lee, Sr.
Hoyos, Jaime Armando
Huggins, Michael James
Hughes, Kristin William
Jablonski, Phillip Carl
Jackson, Earl Lloyd
Jackson, Noel

State habeas case numbers
S009491, S037370
S022650, S031671, S057031, S116793
S013949, S042395
S041560, S065191, S122590, S142041, S156163
S018357, S044946, S050413, S051642
S062455, S087755
S020740, S060778
S130263, S130598
S147393, S193602, S198025
S005511, S031473
CR24021, S066882, S116359, S175344, S208922
S004572, S013761
CR22742/CR25209, S009417, S038643
S113159, S167924
CR21068, Unknown
S106745, S136926
S010053, S066192
S009360, S040799
S022153, S093694
CR22380, CR22612, S013598, S026177, S026235
S074569, S134962, S152912
S039950, S065450
S023285, S065934, S097160, S116670, S166498, S201319, S213911
CR25356, S039415
S073125, S117158
S008829, S022614, S031517, S033487
S013027, S029520, S153853
S107230, S117549, S141716
S102296, S126771, S201327
S044529, S077380
S125276, S195922
CR24213, S015706, S004189
S117268, S147749
S057078, S116794
S137676, S194705, S206764
S012531, S045771
CR23534, S008414, S013041, S144514
S016172, S060822
S013984, S042592, S046724
S146472, S190357
S127630, S213717
S089357, S126775
S136861, S215450
CR21285/CR22165, S009490, S055993
S053136, S070227, S129989, S201322

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 61

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 16.1
Name
Jenkins, Daniel Steven
Johnson, Laverne
Johnson, Willie Darnell
Jones, Earl Preston
Jones, Ernest Dewayne
Jones, Jeffrey Gerard
Jones, Michael Lamont
Jones, Ronald Anthony
Jones, Troy Lee
Jurado, Robert J.
Karis, James Leslie
Keenan, Maurice J.
Kelly, Horace Edwards
Kelly, Horace Edwards
Kimble, Eric B.
Kipp, Martin James
Kipp, Martin James
Kirkpatrick, William, Jr.
Koontz, Herbert Harris
Kraft, Randy Steven
Lang, Kenneth Burton, Jr.
Lawley, Dennis Harold
Lenart, Thomas Howard
Lewis, Albert
Lewis, Milton Otis
Lewis, Raymond Anthony
Lindberg, Gunner Jay
Lucky, Darnell
Majors, James David
Malone, Kelvin Shelby
Marks, Delaney Geral
Marlow, James Gregory
Marlow, James Gregory
Marshall, Ryan Michael
Martinez, Omar Fuentes
Mason, David Edwin
Massie, Robert Lee
Mattson, Michael Dee
Mayfield, Demetrie Ladon
Mayfield, Dennis
McDermott, Maureen
McDowell, Charles Edward
McLain, Robert Cruz
Medina, Teofilo, Jr.
Medina, Teofilo, Jr.

State habeas case numbers
S068655, S123618, S138757, S176494
S032285, S060758, S077521
S027758, S090040
S027729, S073227
S110791, S159235
S050483, S093647
S094239, S132646
S065479, S092494
S016628, S035140
S136327, S181061
CR25929, S022170, S023360
S016227, S053046
S017561, S026194, S115483, S143981
S069124, S115428, S143981
S008706, S025105
S057756, S087490
S093369, S129115
S005410, S075679
S104295, S128031
S094682, S172964
S001273, S011853, S036108
S089463, S163136, S177188
S126851, S167453, S205999
S120420, S207075
S074511, S114868
S083842, S131322, S154015
S173896, S204545
S002037, S011990, S080669
S062533, S101360, S117112
S010528, S024710, S073429
S110988, S145853
S101172, S108267, S135024, S178102
S101171, S178166
S009001, S023919, S062341, S117002
S112103, S141480, S198765
S012541, S026182, S034527
S055662, S060456
S021175, S023201, S043900, S084320, S116812
CR25916, S050116
S039866, S081000
S092813, S130708, S155331
S011634, S024033
S020204, S030456, S035594
S017627, S030938, S058051, S116476
S056590, S116444

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 62

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 16.1
Name
Michaels, Kurt
Mickey, Douglas Scott
Mickle, Denny
Miller, Donald
Millwee, Donald Ray
Mincey, Bryan Joseph
Miranda, Adam
Mitcham, Stephan Louis
Moon, Richard Russell
Morales, Michael Angelo
Morris, Bruce Wayne
Murtishaw, David Leslie
Musselwhite, Joseph Timothy
Navarette, Martin Anthony
Neely, Charles Frederick
Nicolaus, Robert Henry
Noguera, William Adolf
Ochoa, Lester Robert
Ochoa, Sergio
Odle, James Richard
Padilla, Alfredo Alvarado
Panah, Hooman Ashkan
Payton, William Charles
Pensinger, Brett Patrick
Perry, Clifton
Pinholster, Scott Lynn
Pollock, Milton Ray
Price, Curtis Floyd
Prieto, Alfredo R.
Proctor, William Arnold
Raley, David Allen
Ramirez, Richard Munoz
Ramos, Marcelino
Ray, Clarence, Jr.
Reilly, Mark Anthony
Reno (aka Memro, Harold Ray)
Rich, Darrell Keith
Riel, Charles Dell
Robbins, Malcolm Joseph
Rodriguez, Jose Arnaldo
Roldan, Ricardo
Ross, Craig Anthony
Rowland, Guy Kevin
Salcido, Ramon Bojorquez

State habeas case numbers
S071265, S147647
S054715, S058855
S017086, S025619, S066487
S057885, S115824
S072082, S120084
S025754, S056504, S132358
CR25350, S007965, S028518, S058528, S060781, S151264
S024600, S029219, S067887
S126781, S178977, S189159
S030276, S032386, S141074, S141245, S158610
S017372, S050354
S017727, S026455
S063433, S109288
S122097, S204865
S015623, S078822
S018483, S060675
S029779, S068360, S116529, S136826
S064794, S109935
S095304, S121184
S010456, S022451, S026511
S043733, S110741, S119666, S136121, S151385, S154838
S123962, S155942
CR25552, S056446, S209849
S009489, S047895, S087958, S089959
S138225, S214222
S034501, S063973, S113357, S193875
S117032, S214789
S018328, S023791, S069685, S139574
S114708, S156659
S043451, S063535, S201346
S025138, S053603, S185736
S125755, S171312
S034915, S109983
S057313, S110219, S150974
S031234, S058819, S107844
S044437, S124660
S027342, S054989
S084324, S105455
S011321, S048929
S043207, S068488, S113554
S115143, S185447
S043446, S025938, S076654
S038400, S061918
S091159, S214863

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 63

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 16.1
Name
Samayoa, Richard Gonzales
Samuels, Mary Ellen
San Nicolas, Rodney Jesse
Sanders, Ronald Lee
Sandoval, Alfred Arthur
Sapp, John
Scott, James Robert
Sheldon, Jeffrey Theodore
Silva, Benjamin Wai
Sims, Mitchell Carlton
Siripongs, Jaturun
Slaughter, Michael Corey
Smith, Gregory Calvin
Smith, Robert Lee
Stankewitz, Douglas Ray
Stanley, Gerald Frank
Stansbury, Robert Edward
Staten, Deondre Arthur
Steele, Raymond Edward
Taylor, Freddie Lee
Taylor, Robert Clarence
Thomas, Ralph International
Thompson, Thomas Martin
Tuilaepa, Paul Palalaua
Turner, Melvin
Turner, Richard Dean
Turner, Thaddaeus Louis
Valdez, Alfredo Reyes
Visciotti, John Louis
Wade, Melvin Meffery
Waidla, Tauno
Walker, Marvin Pete, Jr.
Weaver, Ward Francis, Jr.
Webb, Dennis Duane
Webster, Larry Junior
Welch, David Esco
Whitt, Charles Edward
Williams, Barry Glenn
Williams, Bob Russell, Jr.
Williams, Dexter Winfred
Williams, Keith Daniel
Williams, Kenneth Derrell
Williams, Michael Allen
Williams, Stanley

State habeas case numbers
S058851, S120249
S124998, S193440
S101300, S160027
S043131, S082022, S094849
S026386, S057548
S130314, S218046
S059739, S111112, S122167, S180692
S052024, S066498
S001959, S009772, S033635
S031117, S064968
S009164, S018140, S076216
S113371, S167303, S183839
S115818, S186093
S144019, S218736
S014015, S047659
CR25155, S081120
S016348, S066681
S107302, S121789, S141678
S114551, S147651
S011031, S062432, S137164
S102652, S166952
S013722, S063274
S008382, S018049, S029941, S062592
S027547, S065022
S037486, S069718, S114479, S120388, S146120, S210095
S124851, S196910
S034988, S116211
S107508, S213143
S031247, S074291
S001539, S009464, S015158
S076438, S102401
S017679, S070934
S073709, S115638
S031942, S054055, S080638, S190098
S007757, S053140
S107782, S149222
S023494, S051684
S050166, S100932
S137389, S183405
S128008, S163977, S219327
CR23904, S008968, S053130
CR24736, S006589, S006916
S012400, S024005
CR23806, S008526, S011868, S039285, S139526

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 64

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 16.1
Name
Wilson, Robert Paul
Wright, Bronte Lamont

State habeas case numbers
S121061, S161435
S002964, S047131

Count of all inmates that have
filed exhaustion petitions 19782014 (includes inmates who
have both open and closed
cases; no inmates or cases are
excluded)
Source: Habeas Corpus Resource Center

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 65

268

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 16.2

Name

State habeas case
number

Date petition
filed

Date of CSC
disposition

Time per
inmate for
exhaustion
cases

Alcala, Rodney James

S047409

7/3/1995

3/20/1996

0.714579055

Alfaro, Maria del Rosio

S170966

3/2/2009

6/12/2013

4.27926078

Allen, Clarence Ray

S031165

2/10/1993

6/2/1993

Allen, Clarence Ray

S139857

12/23/2005

1/10/2006

0.355920602

Allison, Watson

S042478

9/30/1994

4/16/1997

2.543463381

Alvarez, Manuel Machado

S146501

9/11/2006

7/13/2011

4.83504449

Anderson, James Phillip

S134525

6/3/2005

5/15/2013

7.947980835

Andrews, Jesse James

S039576

5/2/1994

7/9/1997

Andrews, Jesse James

S120348

11/7/2003

10/26/2005

5.155373032

Arias, Pedro

S114347

3/17/2003

9/17/2008

5.505817933

Avena, Carlos Jaime

S076118

1/22/1999

1/12/2005

5.973990418

Ayala, Hector Juan

S114371

3/17/2003

9/1/2004

Ayala, Hector Juan

S133446

4/27/2005

11/30/2005

Ayala, Hector Juan

S159584

12/28/2007

9/9/2009

3.75633128

Ayala, Ronaldo Medrano

S110094

9/23/2002

9/10/2003

0.963723477

Babbitt, Manuel Pina

S009386

3/15/1989

6/1/1989

Babbitt, Manuel Pina

S029756

11/9/1992

4/12/1995

Babbitt, Manuel Pina

S078539

4/30/1999

5/3/1999

2.64202601

Bacigalupo, Miguel Angel

S079656

6/11/1999

9/11/2013

14.2532512

Beardslee, Donald Jay

S052116

3/4/1996

7/31/1996

0.407939767

Beeler, Rodney Gene

S065016

10/10/1997

11/10/2004

Beeler, Rodney Gene

S127525

12/8/2003

11/10/2004

Bell, Ronald Lee

S044466

1/20/1995

6/21/1995

Bell, Ronald Lee

S105569

4/2/2002

1/3/2008

Benson, Richard Allen

S063126

7/28/1997

8/20/1997

Benson, Richard Allen

S094994

2/5/2001

2/28/2001

Benson, Richard Allen

S116971

6/24/2003

5/17/2006

Berryman, Rodney, Sr.

S068933

3/20/1998

4/29/1998

Berryman, Rodney, Sr.

S077805

4/2/1999

4/21/1999

0.161533196

Bittaker, Lawrence Sigmond

S052371

3/15/1996

11/29/2000

4.709103354

Bloom, Robert Maurice

S022735

9/3/1991

2/19/1992

Bloom, Robert Maurice

S035229

9/28/1993

10/20/1993

0.5229295

S000029 and CR25554

7/7/1986

1/2/1987

0.490075291

Bonin, William George

S051633

2/6/1996

2/15/1996

0.024640657

Bonin, William George

S011262

7/24/1989

11/1/1989

Bonin, William George

S016344

7/2/1990

7/5/1990

Bonin, William George

S051634

2/6/1996

2/15/1996

0.306639288

Boyde, Richard

S039855

5/13/1994

4/24/1996

1.94934976

Bloyd, Dale Michael

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 66

8.010951403
6.171115674

3.022587269

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 16.2

Name

State habeas case
number

Date petition
filed

Date of CSC
disposition

Time per
inmate for
exhaustion
cases

Boyer, Richard Delmer

S181948

4/19/2010

6/20/2012

2.171115674

Bradford, Bill

S100542

9/12/2001

10/12/2005

4.082135524

Bradford, Mark Alan

S119155

9/19/2003

8/8/2007

3.885010267

Breaux, David Anthony

S045944

4/11/1995

9/24/1997

2.455852156

Brown, Andrew Lamont

S136785

8/26/2005

5/21/2008

2.735112936

Brown, John George

S037992

2/15/1994

4/2/1998

4.125941136

Cain, Tracy Dearl

S067172

1/12/1998

6/28/2000

Cain, Tracy Dearl

S116805

6/18/2003

9/21/2005

Cain, Tracy Dearl

S152288

4/30/2007

4/22/2009

6.699520876

Caro, Fernando Eros

S027045

6/8/1992

9/15/1993

1.270362765

Carpenter, David Joseph

S083035

10/22/1999

12/1/1999

0.109514031
0.150581793

Carpenter, David Joseph

S110890

10/24/2002

12/18/2002

Carrera, Constantino

S049666

10/27/1995

8/13/1998

Carrera, Constantino

S062394

6/26/1997

8/13/1998

Carrera, Constantino

S141324

2/23/2006

1/13/2010

7.813826146

Carter, Dean Phillip

S153790

6/22/2007

6/17/2010

2.986995209

Carter, Dean Phillip

S153780

6/22/2007

6/17/2010

Carter, Dean Phillip

S180336

2/16/2010

6/17/2010

3.318275154

Catlin, Steven David

S173793

6/15/2009

3/27/2013

3.780971937

Clair, Kenneth

S045241

3/6/1995

7/12/1995

Clair, Kenneth

S052733

4/3/1996

4/17/1996

Clair, Kenneth

S169188

12/19/2008

8/24/2011

3.066392882

Clark, Douglas Daniel

S120556

11/19/2003

11/25/2003

0.016427105

Clark, Richard Dean

S060797

4/23/1997

8/13/1998

Clark, Richard Dean

S116968

6/24/2003

6/24/2003

1.305954825

Clark, William John

S022475

8/16/1991

7/29/1993

1.952087611

Cleveland, Dellano Leroy

S143814

5/31/2006

6/21/2006

0.057494867

Coddington, Herbert James

S107502

6/11/2002

5/20/2010

7.939767283

Cole, Stephen

S142889

4/21/2006

3/25/2009

2.926762491

Coleman, Russell

S025597

3/12/1992

4/15/1992

Coleman, Russell

S041610

8/16/1994

12/21/1994

Cooper, Kevin

S064320

9/12/1997

10/15/1997

Cooper, Kevin

S075527

12/23/1998

4/14/1999

Cooper, Kevin

S077408

3/26/1999

4/14/1999

Cooper, Kevin

S116984

6/25/2003

10/22/2003

Cooper, Kevin

S122389

2/2/2004

2/5/2004

0.440793977

Cooper, Kevin

S122507

2/6/2004

2/9/2004

0.791238877

Cornwell, Glen

S152880

5/7/2007

2/10/2010

2.765229295

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 67

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 16.2

Name

State habeas case
number

Date petition
filed

Date of CSC
disposition

Time per
inmate for
exhaustion
cases

Cox, Michael Anthony

S033824

7/8/1993

8/11/1993

Cox, Michael Anthony

S038251

2/25/1994

8/20/1997

Cox, Michael Anthony

S135128

6/30/2005

6/9/2010

8.517453799

Cox, Tiequon Aundray

S082898

10/15/1999

2/13/2002

2.332648871

Crew, Mark Christopher

S107856

6/26/2002

8/8/2012

10.11909651

Crittenden, Steven Edward

S060706

4/21/1997

8/18/1999

2.324435318

Cudjo, Armenia Levi, Jr.

S090162

7/25/2000

11/25/2003

Cudjo, Armenia Levi, Jr.

S128474

10/13/2004

5/17/2006

Cudjo, Armenia Levi, Jr.

S134653

6/10/2005

3/14/2007

6.683093771

Cummings, Raynard Paul

S071267

6/22/1998

7/29/1998

0.101300479

Davis, Larry David

S062517

7/1/1997

1/14/1998

0.539356605

Davis, Stanley Bernard

S130190

10/21/2004

9/10/2008

3.887748118

Deere, Ronald Lee

S036482

12/2/1993

5/25/1994

0.476386037

Demetrulias, Gregory Spiros

S160990

2/19/2008

6/17/2010

2.324435318

Dennis, William Michael

S099587

8/2/2001

11/26/2002

Dennis, William Michael

S201330

4/3/2012

2/26/2014

3.216974675

DePriest, Timothy Lee

S171297

3/16/2009

5/1/2013

4.125941136

DeSantis, Stephen

S051609

2/5/1996

4/17/1996

0.197125257

Diaz, Robert Rubane

S033433

6/18/1993

8/11/1993

0.147843943

Dickey, Colin Raker

S165302

7/18/2008

5/23/2012

3.846680356
1.089664613

Duncan, Henry Earl

S047651

7/13/1995

8/14/1996

Dyer, Alfred R.

S022577

8/23/1991

10/16/1991

Dyer, Alfred R.

S023364

9/17/1991

10/31/1991

Dyer, Alfred R.

S032198

4/12/1993

4/28/1993

0.31211499

Easley, Elbert Lee

S032556

4/29/1993

5/12/1994

1.034907598

Edwards, Thomas Francis

S092074

10/5/2000

11/15/2000

0.112251882

Espinoza, Antonio

S062244

6/20/1997

2/17/1999

Espinoza, Antonio

S116824

6/19/2003

6/29/2005

Fauber, Curtis Lynn

S065139

10/17/1997

3/14/2001

Fauber, Curtis Lynn

S134365

6/1/2005

7/25/2012

10.55441478

Fields, Stevie Lamar

S037370

1/14/1994

10/14/1994

0.747433265

Frank, Theodore Francis

S042395

9/27/1994

6/21/1995

0.73100616

Frierson, Lavell

S044946

2/17/1995

10/25/1995

Frierson, Lavell

S050413

12/1/1995

12/20/1995

Frierson, Lavell

S051642

2/6/1996

2/21/1996

0.777549624

Frye, Jerry Grant

S087755

4/20/2000

1/24/2001

0.76386037

Gates, Oscar

S060778

4/23/1997

10/25/2000

3.507186858

Gay, Kenneth Earl

S130598

1/11/2005

5/11/2011

6.327173169

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 68

3.690622861

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 16.2

Name

State habeas case
number

Date petition
filed

Date of CSC
disposition

Time per
inmate for
exhaustion
cases

Ghent, David Luther

S031473

3/3/1993

2/23/1994

Grant, Richard Edward

S009417

3/20/1989

7/13/1989

Grant, Richard Edward

S038643

3/11/1994

12/15/1994

1.07871321

Hamilton, Billy Ray

S066192

12/1/1997

1/28/1998

0.158795346

Hamilton, Michael Allen

S040799

7/5/1994

5/6/1999

4.83504449

Hardy, James Edward

S093694

12/13/2000

7/26/2007

6.614647502

Hart, Joseph William

S134962

6/22/2005

3/28/2007

Hart, Joseph William

S152912

5/22/2007

9/28/2011

6.116358658

Hawkins, Jeffrey Jay

S065450

10/28/1997

3/9/1999

1.360711841

Hayes, Blufford, Jr.

S039415

4/22/1994

6/21/1995

1.163586585

Hayes, Royal Kenneth

S117158

7/1/2003

7/16/2003

0.041067762

Heishman, Harvey Lee, III

S022614

8/26/1991

4/29/1992

Heishman, Harvey Lee, III

S031517

3/5/1993

8/11/1993

Heishman, Harvey Lee, III

S033487

6/22/1993

8/11/1993

Hernandez, Francis Gerard

S029520

10/30/1992

1/27/1993

Hernandez, Francis Gerard

S153853

6/26/2007

6/11/2008

Hillhouse, Dannie Ray

S126771

8/2/2004

11/10/2004

Hillhouse, Dannie Ray

S201327

4/3/2012

2/26/2014

2.173853525

Hines, Gary Dale

S077380

3/17/1999

6/28/2000

1.284052019

Holloway, Duane

S147749

10/30/2006

8/19/2009

2.803559206

Horton, James Frank, II

S045771

4/3/1995

7/18/1996

1.292265572

Howard, Gary Lee, Sr.

S042592

10/7/1994

3/29/1995

Howard, Gary Lee, Sr.

S046724

5/23/1995

11/13/1996

1.952087611

0.977412731

1.248459959
1.204654346

Hoyos, Jaime Armando

S190357

2/3/2011

10/30/2013

2.737850787

Hughes, Kristin William

S126775

8/2/2004

6/21/2006

1.883641342

Jackson, Earl Lloyd

S009490

8/19/1981

8/31/1992

Jackson, Earl Lloyd

S055993

9/9/1996

2/23/2000

Johnson, Laverne

S060758

4/22/1997

11/25/1997

Johnson, Laverne

S077521

3/23/1999

4/14/1999

0.654346338

Johnson, Willie Darnell

S090040

7/20/2000

6/13/2001

0.898015058

Jones, Earl Preston

S073227

9/9/1998

2/23/2000

1.456536619

Jones, Ernest Dewayne

S159235

10/16/2007

3/11/2009

1.401779603

Jones, Jeffrey Gerard

S093647

12/5/2000

9/24/2003

2.800821355

Jones, Michael Lamont

S132646

3/30/2005

11/30/2011

6.669404517

Jones, Ronald Anthony

S092494

10/26/2000

3/28/2001

0.41889117

Jurado, Robert J.

S181061

3/18/2010

1/16/2013

2.833675565

Karis, James Leslie

S022170

7/29/1991

10/16/1991

Karis, James Leslie

S023360

9/13/1991

2/19/1992

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 69

14.48870637

0.651608487

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 16.2

Name

State habeas case
number

Date petition
filed

Date of CSC
disposition

Time per
inmate for
exhaustion
cases

Keenan, Maurice J.

S053046

4/12/1996

2/18/1998

1.853524983

Kimble, Eric B.

S025105

2/10/1992

5/26/1993

1.289527721

Kipp, Martin James

S087490

4/12/2000

2/19/2003

2.855578371

Kipp, Martin James

S129115

11/5/2004

6/28/2006

1.642710472

Kraft, Randy Steven

S172964

5/14/2009

5/22/2013

4.021902806

Lang, Kenneth Burton, Jr.

S011853

9/1/1989

10/12/1989

Lang, Kenneth Burton, Jr.

S036108

11/15/1993

2/23/1994

0.386036961

Lewis, Milton Otis

S114868

4/1/2003

12/1/2004

1.67008898

Lewis, Raymond Anthony

S131322

2/4/2005

7/21/2010

Lewis, Raymond Anthony

S154015

6/29/2007

7/21/2010

Lucky, Darnell

S011990

9/11/1989

10/12/1989

8.517453799

Lucky, Darnell

S080669

7/19/1999

6/27/2007

Majors, James David

S101360

10/12/2001

10/31/2001

Majors, James David

S117112

6/27/2003

4/28/2010

6.88843258

Marks, Delaney Geral

S145853

8/14/2006

12/15/2010

4.336755647

Marlow, James Gregory

S108267

7/12/2002

10/22/2008

Marlow, James Gregory

S135024

6/27/2005

10/22/2008

Marlow, James Gregory

S178102

11/16/2009

5/22/2013

13.11430527

Marlow, James Gregory

S178166

11/16/2009

5/22/2013

3.51266256

Marshall, Ryan Michael

S023919

11/21/1991

2/13/1992

Marshall, Ryan Michael

S062341

6/23/1997

7/16/1997

Marshall, Ryan Michael

S117002

6/23/2003

9/22/2004

Martinez, Omar Fuentes

S141480

2/24/2006

6/29/2009

Martinez, Omar Fuentes

S198765

12/19/2011

2/15/2012

Mason, David Edwin

S026182

4/17/1992

4/23/1992

Mason, David Edwin

S034527

8/19/1993

8/20/1993

0.019164956

Massie, Robert Lee

S060456

4/11/1997

1/13/1999

1.757700205

Mattson, Michael Dee

S023201

10/3/1991

10/23/1991

Mattson, Michael Dee

S043900

12/16/1994

2/14/1996

Mattson, Michael Dee

S084320

12/14/1999

1/19/2000

Mattson, Michael Dee

S116812

6/19/2003

10/16/2008

6.64476386

Mayfield, Demetrie Ladon

S050116

11/20/1995

2/21/1996

0.254620123

Mayfield, Dennis

S081000

7/30/1999

3/5/2003

3.597535934

McDermott, Maureen

S130708

1/14/2005

1/3/2007

McDermott, Maureen

S155331

8/10/2007

5/21/2008

2.74880219

McDowell, Charles Edward

S024033

12/2/1991

7/9/1992

0.602327173

McLain, Robert Cruz

S030456

12/29/1992

1/13/1993

McLain, Robert Cruz

S035594

10/20/1993

10/27/1993

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 70

8.024640657

1.544147844
3.501711157

0.060232717

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 16.2

Name

State habeas case
number

Date petition
filed

Date of CSC
disposition

Time per
inmate for
exhaustion
cases

Medina, Teofilo, Jr.

S030938

1/27/1993

4/28/1993

Medina, Teofilo, Jr.

S058051

12/24/1996

9/3/1997

Medina, Teofilo, Jr.

S116476

6/5/2003

11/19/2003

1.399041752

Medina, Teofilo, Jr.

S116444

6/4/2003

11/19/2003

0.459958932

Michaels, Kurt

S147647

10/27/2006

8/19/2009

2.811772758

Mickey, Douglas Scott

S058855

1/31/1997

2/19/1997

0.052019165

Mickle, Denny

S025619

3/11/1992

7/15/1992

Mickle, Denny

S066487

12/12/1997

2/25/2003

5.549623546

Millwee, Donald Ray

S120084

11/22/2000

11/1/2006

5.941136208

Mitcham, Stephan Louis

S029219

10/14/1992

9/30/1993

0.960985626

Mitcham, Stephan Louis

S067887

2/9/1998

12/21/1999

1.861738535

Morales, Michael Angelo

S032386

4/21/1993

7/28/1993

Morales, Michael Angelo

S141074

2/10/2006

2/15/2006

Morales, Michael Angelo

S141245

2/21/2006

3/1/2006

Morales, Michael Angelo

S158610

11/30/2007

2/13/2008

0.509240246

Morris, Bruce Wayne

S050354

12/1/1995

12/6/1995

0.013689254

Murtishaw, David Leslie

S026455

5/5/1992

9/2/1992

0.328542094

Musselwhite, Joseph Timothy

S109288

8/19/2002

11/16/2005

3.244353183

Neely, Charles Frederick

S078822

5/10/1999

9/29/1999

0.388774812

Nicolaus, Robert Henry

S060675

4/18/1997

1/17/2001

3.750855578

Noguera, William Adolf

S068360

3/3/1998

10/17/2001

Noguera, William Adolf

S116529

6/9/2003

10/10/2007

Noguera, William Adolf

S136826

8/29/2005

10/10/2007

10.0752909

Ochoa, Lester Robert

S109935

9/17/2002

3/26/2003

0.52019165

Ochoa, Sergio

S121184

12/15/2003

12/21/2010

7.017111567

Odle, James Richard

S022451

8/14/1991

9/16/1992

Odle, James Richard

S026511

5/8/1992

10/28/1992

1.56605065

Panah, Hooman Ashkan

S155942

8/30/2007

3/16/2011

3.542778919

Payton, William Charles

S056446

10/1/1996

12/11/1997

Payton, William Charles

S209849

4/9/2013

5/1/2013

Pensinger, Brett Patrick

S047895

7/27/1995

7/26/2000

Pensinger, Brett Patrick

S087958

1/24/2000

7/26/2000

Pensinger, Brett Patrick

S089959

2/13/1998

7/26/2000

Pinholster, Scott Lynn

S063973

8/29/1997

10/1/1997

Pinholster, Scott Lynn

S113357

2/4/2003

4/20/2011

Pinholster, Scott Lynn

S193875

6/9/2011

10/31/2012

Price, Curtis Floyd

S023791

11/12/1991

2/19/1992

Price, Curtis Floyd

S069685

4/21/1998

4/13/2011

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 71

1.253935661

7.950718686

9.691991786

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 16.2

Name

State habeas case
number

Date petition
filed

Date of CSC
disposition

Time per
inmate for
exhaustion
cases

Price, Curtis Floyd

S139574

12/13/2005

6/24/2009

16.77754962

Prieto, Alfredo R.

S156659

9/21/2007

2/26/2014

6.43394935

Proctor, William Arnold

S063535

8/12/1997

2/13/2002

Proctor, William Arnold

S201346

4/3/2012

2/26/2014

Reilly, Mark Anthony

S058819

1/31/1997

7/26/2000

Reilly, Mark Anthony

S107844

6/26/2002

7/8/2009

10.51608487

Reno (aka Memro, Harold Ray)

S124660

5/10/2004

8/30/2012

8.306639288

Rich, Darrell Keith

S054989

7/19/1996

1/16/1997

0.495550992

Riel, Charles Dell

S105455

3/22/2002

5/15/2002

0.147843943

Robbins, Malcolm Joseph

S048929

9/18/1995

8/3/1998

2.874743326

Ross, Craig Anthony

S025938

4/1/1992

5/31/1995

Ross, Craig Anthony

S076654

2/19/1999

10/30/2002

6.855578371

Rowland, Guy Kevin

S061918

6/5/1997

7/9/1997

0.093086927

Samayoa, Richard Gonzales

S120249

11/4/2003

3/16/2005

1.363449692

San Nicolas, Rodney Jesse

S160027

1/16/2008

2/11/2014

6.072553046

Sanders, Ronald Lee

S082022

9/10/1999

9/22/1999

Sanders, Ronald Lee

S094849

1/29/2001

6/13/2001

0.402464066

Sandoval, Alfred Arthur

S057548

11/27/1996

10/21/1998

1.897330595

Scott, James Robert

S111112

11/1/2002

1/27/2003

Scott, James Robert

S122167

1/23/2004

6/9/2004

Scott, James Robert

S180692

3/3/2010

8/11/2010

1.056810404

Sheldon, Jeffrey Theodore

S066498

12/12/1997

6/11/1998

0.495550992

Silva, Benjamin Wai

S009772

4/14/1989

7/26/1989

6.406570842

Silva, Benjamin Wai

S033635

7/1/1993

7/28/1993

0.355920602

Sims, Mitchell Carlton

S064968

10/9/1997

4/29/1998

0.553045859

Siripongs, Jaturun

S018140

10/31/1990

1/17/1991

Siripongs, Jaturun

S076216

1/27/1999

2/4/1999

0.235455168

Smith, Gregory Calvin

S186093

9/7/2010

1/12/2011

0.34770705

Stankewitz, Douglas Ray

S047659

7/14/1995

3/14/1996

0.668035592

Stanley, Gerald Frank

S081120

8/2/1999

7/17/2002

2.95687885

Stansbury, Robert Edward

S066681

12/22/1997

1/30/2001

3.107460643

Staten, Deondre Arthur

S121789

1/8/2004

7/13/2005

Staten, Deondre Arthur

S141678

3/8/2006

12/20/2006

2.29705681

Steele, Raymond Edward

S147651

10/30/2006

1/24/2007

0.235455168

Taylor, Freddie Lee

S062432

6/27/1997

7/16/2003

Taylor, Freddie Lee

S137164

9/12/2005

9/11/2013

14.04791239

Taylor, Robert Clarence

S166952

12/5/2008

9/1/2010

1.73853525

Thomas, Ralph International

S063274

8/1/1997

4/12/2006

8.6954141

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 72

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 16.2

Name

State habeas case
number

Date petition
filed

Date of CSC
disposition

Time per
inmate for
exhaustion
cases

Thompson, Thomas Martin

S018049

10/25/1990

1/23/1991

Thompson, Thomas Martin

S029941

11/25/1992

2/10/1993

Thompson, Thomas Martin

S062592

7/3/1997

7/16/1997

0.492813142

Tuilaepa, Paul Palalaua

S065022

10/10/1997

11/29/2006

9.136208077

Turner, Thaddaeus Louis

S116211

5/22/2003

10/22/2008

5.420944559

Visciotti, John Louis

S074291

10/26/1998

2/24/1999

0.331279945

Wade, Melvin Meffery

S009464

3/22/1989

6/21/1989

Wade, Melvin Meffery

S015158

4/19/1990

5/30/1990

0.361396304

Waidla, Tauno

S102401

11/27/2001

4/5/2005

3.353867214

Walker, Marvin Pete, Jr.

S070934

6/5/1998

12/22/2004

6.548939083

Weaver, Ward Francis, Jr.

S115638

5/6/2003

8/26/2009

6.308008214

Webster, Larry Junior

S053140

4/23/1996

4/26/1996

0.008213552

Whitt, Charles Edward

S051684

2/8/1996

11/12/2003

7.759069131

Williams, Barry Glenn

S100932

9/24/2001

12/10/2003

2.209445585

Williams, Dexter Winfred

S163977

5/30/2008

8/8/2012

4.191649555

Williams, Keith Daniel

S008968

2/14/1989

2/17/1989

Williams, Keith Daniel

S053130

4/22/1996

4/26/1996

Williams, Kenneth Derrell

S006589

7/26/1988

3/2/1989

Williams, Kenneth Derrell

S006916

8/19/1988

3/2/1989

1.133470226

Williams, Michael Allen

S024005

11/27/1991

2/11/1992

0.20807666

Williams, Stanley

S008526

1/9/1989

1/18/1989

Williams, Stanley

S011868

9/1/1989

4/11/1994

Williams, Stanley

S039285

4/15/1994

6/21/1995

Williams, Stanley

S139526

12/10/2005

12/11/2005

5.817932923

Wilson, Robert Paul

S161435

3/3/2008

12/11/2013

5.77412731

Average time each inmate spent in state court

0.019164956

3.18

Source: Habeas Corpus Resource Center

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 73

CV-09-2158-CJC

PARAGRAPH 17

Count of all state petitions filed since 1978 (includes cases
dismissed due to inmate death and initial petitions with
Overall
pending amended petitions)
(Closed
and Open
Count of OSCs issued
Cases)

Closed
Cases
Only

Open
Cases
Only

Count of reference hearings ordered
Count of closed state habeas cases since 1978 (excludes
cases dismissed due to inmate death)
Count of OSCs issued in closed cases (excludes cases
dismissed due to inmate death)
Count of reference hearing ordered in closed cases
Count of open state habeas cases since 1978 (excludes 64
initial petitions that have not had an amended petition
filed)
Count of OSCs issued in open cases

Count of reference hearing ordered in open cases
Updated as of 6/1/2014
Source: Habeas Corpus Resource Center

Data Used in Declaration of Michael Laurence 74

1003
129
57
729
99 OSCs issued 13.58% in closed cases
45 Reference hearings ordered 6.17% in closed cases

176
27 OSCs have been issued 15.34% in open/pending cases
Reference hearings have been ordered 5.68% in
10 open/pending cases

CV-09-2158-CJC