Netflix, Inc. v. Blockbuster, Inc.
Filing
116
Attachment 2
NOTICE by Blockbuster, Inc.(a Delaware corporation), Blockbuster, Inc.(a Delaware corporation), Blockbuster, Inc.
Blockbuster's Amended Preliminary Invalidity Contentions On US Pat. No. 7024381 (Attachments: #
1 Exhibit Exhibit A#
2 Exhibit Exhibit B#
3 Exhibit Exhibit C#
4 Exhibit Exhibit D#
5 Exhibit Exhibit E#
6 Exhibit Exhibit F#
7 Exhibit Exhibit G#
8 Exhibit Exhibit H#
9 Exhibit Exhibit I#
10 Exhibit Exhibit J#
11 Exhibit Exhibit K)(Chen, Tony) (Filed on 12/20/2006)
Case 3:06-cv-02361-WHA
Document 116-3
Filed 12/20/2006
Page 1 of 11
BLOCKBUSTER'S AMENDED PRELIMINARY INVALIDITY CONTENTIONS
DECEMBER 20, 2006 U.S. PATENT NO. 7,024,381 B1
EXHIBIT B IDENTIFICATION OF PRIOR ART Prior Art Publications
Author
1. Wanger, et al.
Title
Automated Circulation System in Libraries Serving the Blind and Physically Handicapped: A Reference Guide for Planning Southern Retailer Says `Video Library' Makes Bookkeeping A Breeze Regional Reports: Central Regio n Pop*Card Franchise Purchased
Publication
Publisher
Cuadra Associates
Date
05/15/1981
Short Name
Reference Guide
Bates Numbers
BB00008174 8465
2.
Anguilla
Video Retailing
July 1982
Multi-Video Article Pop*Card Article No. 1 Pop*Card Article No. 2
BB00012975
3. 4.
Video Store The Oklahoman The Oklahoman
Jan. 1985 07/22/1984
BB00012976 BB00013058
Dockets.Justia.com
Case 3:06-cv-02361-WHA
Document 116-3
Filed 12/20/2006
Page 2 of 11
BLOCKBUSTER'S AMENDED PRELIMINARY INVALIDITY CONTENTIONS (U.S. PATENT NO. 7,024,381 B1)
Author
5. 6. 7.
Title
Finally, the No-Limit Video Tape Library! Get the Best Seat in the House Hurry! Free! Footloose Raiders of the Lost Ark Disney Go ld Your Choice When You Join Pop*Card! The NoLimit Videotape Library for 90 Days! Free! Cabbage Patch Doll
Publication
The Oklahoman The Oklahoman The Oklahoman
Publisher
The Oklahoman The Oklahoman The Oklahoman
Date
04/02/1982 12/24/1984 11/07/1984
Short Name
Pop*Card Ad No. 1 Pop*Card Ad No. 2 Pop*Card Ad No. 3
Bates Numbers
BB00013052 BB00013053 BB00013054
8. 9.
The Oklahoman
The Oklahoman The Oklahoman
05/25/1985 12/09/1983
Pop*Card Ad No. 4 Pop*Card Ad No. 5
BB00013056 BB00013057
Free! Raiders of the The Oklahoman Lost Ark! When You Join Pop*Card The NoLimit Videotape Library! Belly? Then You Need Pop*Card The NoLimit Videotape Library It-Had-To-Happen Department: Newest Ways to Rent Videos The Oklahoman
10.
The Oklahoman
05/20/1984
Pop*Card Ad No. 61
BB00013059
11.
Changing Times (pre-1986), p. 9, October 1985
Kiplinger
Oct. 1985
Video Hit Article
BB00004581
1
"Pop*Card Articles Nos. 1-2" and "Pop*Card Ads Nos. 1-6" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "Pop*Card publications." EXHIBIT B: IDENTIFICATION OF PRIOR ART (Prior Art Publications) Page 2 of 11
Case 3:06-cv-02361-WHA
Document 116-3
Filed 12/20/2006
Page 3 of 11
BLOCKBUSTER'S AMENDED PRELIMINARY INVALIDITY CONTENTIONS (U.S. PATENT NO. 7,024,381 B1)
Author
12. Dreyfuss 13.
Title
French Twist It-Had-To-Happen Department: Newest Ways to Rent Videos
Publication
Fortune Changing Times (pre-1986), p. 9, October 1985 PR Newswire
Publisher
Time Inc. Kiplinger
Date
05/13/1985 Oct. 1985
Short Name
Cine Club Article No. 1 Cine Club Article No. 2 Cine Club Article No. 3 Cine Club Article No. 4 Cine Club Newsletter Cine Club Article No. 5 Cine Club Ad No. 1 Cine Club Flyer Cine Club Ad No. 22
Bates Numbers
BB00012207, 13025-13027 BB00004581
14. 15. Pssst! Hey, You! Wanna Buy `Terminator' Cheap? The Cine Club Viewer
PR Newswire Association
09/10/1985 1985
BB00013047 13048 BB00013028
Daily News
16.
Newsletter
Cine Club
July 1985
BB00013032 13033 BB00013029 BB00013031 BB00013034 13035 BB00013030
17. 18. 19. Morabito 20.
Fast Track Exclusive in New York
New York Daily News Letter with flyer Cine Club
10/07/1985 10/31/1985 11/25/1985 12/23/1985
Exclusive in New York
Daily News
2
"Cine Club Articles Nos. 1-5", "Cine Club Newsletter", "Cine Club Flyer" and "Cine Club Ads. 1-2" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "Cine Club publications." EXHIBIT B: IDENTIFICATION OF PRIOR ART (Prior Art Publications) Page 3 of 11
Case 3:06-cv-02361-WHA
Document 116-3
Filed 12/20/2006
Page 4 of 11
BLOCKBUSTER'S AMENDED PRELIMINARY INVALIDITY CONTENTIONS (U.S. PATENT NO. 7,024,381 B1)
Author
21. Rodriguez
Title
Funct ional Requirements
Publication
Access SelfStudy, Vol. 7
Publisher
Texas State Library Division for the Blind & Physically Handicapped Tape Rental Library Inc.
Date
12/15/1987
Short Name
Functional Requirements
Bates Numbers
BB00008466 8479
22.
Have You Heard The Best Idea for Maintaining Your Competitive Edge? Audio Cassettes Audio Cassettes Audio Cassettes Audio Cassettes Maxcess Makes It Easy: A Midrange Library System
Brochure
1997?
AudioQueue Brochure
BB00012226 12241
23. 24. 25. 26. 27. Hattery et al.
1988 Catalog 1997 Catalog 1995 Catalog 1998 Catalog Informat ion Retrieval & Library Automation
Tape Rental Library Inc. Tape Rental Library Inc. Tape Rental Library Inc. Tape Rental Library Inc. Lomond Publications, Inc.
1988 1997 1995 1998 April 1993
AudioQueue Catalog No. 1 AudioQueue Catalog No. 2 AudioQueue Catalog No. 3 AudioQueue Catalog No. 43 Maxcess
BB00012242 12310 BB00012311 12363 BB00012364 12426 BB00012427 12481 BB00003020 3024
3
"AudioQueue Brochure" and "AudioQueue Catalogs Nos.. 1-4" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "AudioQueue publications." EXHIBIT B: IDENTIFICATION OF PRIOR ART (Prior Art Publications) Page 4 of 11
Case 3:06-cv-02361-WHA
Document 116-3
Filed 12/20/2006
Page 5 of 11
BLOCKBUSTER'S AMENDED PRELIMINARY INVALIDITY CONTENTIONS (U.S. PATENT NO. 7,024,381 B1)
Author
28.
Title
Welco me to the Web! Avis Rent-A-Car
Publication
Internet for Business, Issue 1, p. 6
Publisher
Financial Times, Telecoms & Media Publishing Avis
Date
May/June 1996
Short Name
Avis Article
Bates Numbers
BB00003183 3184
29.
Avis Rent-A-Car web pages
avis.co m archive.org
1996
Avis 1996 Web Pages
BB00011978 11986; BB00011989 11990 BB00011937 11977; BB00011987 11988; BB00011991 12053 BB00011927 BB00011928 11930; BB00011933 11936; BB000112054
30.
Avis Rent-A-Car web pages
avis.co m archive.org
Avis
1997
Avis 1997 Web Pages
31. 32.
Avis Rent-A-Car web pages Avis Rent-A-Car web pages
avis.co m archive.org avis.co m archive.org
Avis Avis
1998 1999
Avis 1998 Web Pages Avis 1999 Web Pages4
4
"Avis Article" and "Avis 1996-1999 Web Pages" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "Avis publications." EXHIBIT B: IDENTIFICATION OF PRIOR ART (Prior Art Publications) Page 5 of 11
Case 3:06-cv-02361-WHA
Document 116-3
Filed 12/20/2006
Page 6 of 11
BLOCKBUSTER'S AMENDED PRELIMINARY INVALIDITY CONTENTIONS (U.S. PATENT NO. 7,024,381 B1)
Author
33.
Title
Publication
Publisher
Books On Tape
Date
02/14/1997
Short Name
Bates Numbers
Books On Tape On-line booksontape.com Order Form archive.org More About B-O-T & Frequently Asked Questions Sirsi Corporation booksontape.com archive.org Library Technology Reports: Vendors of Integrated Library Systems, p. 239 The Plain Dealer, p. 1B
Books On Tape BB00012211 12213 Web Pages No. 1 Books On Tape BB00013037 Web Pages 13046; 5 No. 2 BB00012214 Sirsi BB00003056
34.
05/08/1999
35.
American Library Association
MarchApril 1997
36. Kuehner
Serving Book Listeners Audio-Only Bookstore to Open in Solon User Manual Now Offering 30 Day Free Trial
The Plain Dealer, Cleveland, Ohio
11/11/1998
Talking Book World Article
BB00004576 4577
37. Magerman 38.
Video Vendor bizlibrary.com archive.org
Multipost No later Retail Systems than 1995 Business Training Library Oberlin News Tribune No later than April 1998 12/01/1998
Video Vendor User Manual Business Training Library Web Pages Campus Video Article
BB00012223 12225 BB00013049 13051
39.
Advert isement
Oberlin News Tribune
BB00013036
5
"Books On Tape Web Pages Nos. 1-2" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "Books On Tape publications." EXHIBIT B: IDENTIFICATION OF PRIOR ART (Prior Art Publications) Page 6 of 11
Case 3:06-cv-02361-WHA
Document 116-3
Filed 12/20/2006
Page 7 of 11
BLOCKBUSTER'S AMENDED PRELIMINARY INVALIDITY CONTENTIONS (U.S. PATENT NO. 7,024,381 B1)
Author
40.
Title
Auto Librarian
Publication
Library Technology Reports: Library System Software, p. 234 Annual Report 1998 The Times (London) USA Today Business Wire
Publisher
American Library Association
Date
MarchApril 1999
Short Name
Auto Librarian
Bates Numbers
BB00003025 3038
41. 42. Snoddy
Annual Report 1998 Coming soon: video recorder that picks the programmes BRIEFLY... DIRECTV Inc. Announces Equity Investment in TiVo Inc.; DIRECTV, TiVo Partner to Market Personal Television Service IQ News: Analysis Six Degrees of Television
TiVo Inc. Times Newspapers Ltd. Gannett Company, Inc. Business Wire, Inc.
03/31/1999 04.28.1999
TiVo Report TiVo Article No. 1 TiVo Article No. 2 TiVo Article No. 3
BB00012065 12163 BB00012164BB0012165 BB00012166 BB00012167BB00012168
43. 44.
04.28.1999 04.27.199
45. Kuchinskas
ADWEEK
A/S/M/ 04.26.1999 Communicatio ns, Inc.
TiVo Article No. 4
BB00012169BB00012170
EXHIBIT B: IDENTIFICATION OF PRIOR ART (Prior Art Publications) Page 7 of 11
Case 3:06-cv-02361-WHA
Document 116-3
Filed 12/20/2006
Page 8 of 11
BLOCKBUSTER'S AMENDED PRELIMINARY INVALIDITY CONTENTIONS (U.S. PATENT NO. 7,024,381 B1)
Author
46.
Title
TiVo Selects Atmel's Smart Card Crytpo Controller for Authentication and Security; AT90SC3232C Offers Highest Security REPLAY NETWORKS DEALS Why Digital Devices Will Proliferate; FORGET THE FREE PC INTERACTIVE VIDEO THE NEXT BATTLEGROUND DIGITAL DEVICES FUN, BUT PRICES SCARY INTERACTIVE SERVICES DEBATED
Publication
Business Wire
Publisher
Business Wire, Inc.
Date
04.26.1999
Short Name
TiVo Article No. 5
Bates Numbers
BB00012171BB00012172
47.
Consumer Electronics Fortune
Warren Publishing, Inc. Time Inc.
04.26.1999
TiVo Article No. 6 TiVo Article No. 7
BB00012173BB00012174 BB00012175BB00012176
48. Shaffer
04.26.199
49.
INSIDE MULTIMEDIA
Phillips Business Information, Inc. Sat Paul Pioneer Press Warren Publishing, Inc.
04.26.1999
TiVo Article No. 8
BB00012177BB00012178
50. Ojeda-Zapata
Saint Paul Pioneer Press (Minnesota) Televisio n Digest
04.26.1999
TiVo Article No. 9 TiVo Article No. 10
BB00012179BB00012180 BB00012181BB00012182
51.
04.26.1999
EXHIBIT B: IDENTIFICATION OF PRIOR ART (Prior Art Publications) Page 8 of 11
Case 3:06-cv-02361-WHA
Document 116-3
Filed 12/20/2006
Page 9 of 11
BLOCKBUSTER'S AMENDED PRELIMINARY INVALIDITY CONTENTIONS (U.S. PATENT NO. 7,024,381 B1)
Author
52. (In VIDEO NOTES) 53. Stern and Graser 54. Walker
Title
Publication
Video Week
Publisher
Warren Publishing, Inc. Reed Elsevier Inc. The Washington Post
Date
04.26.1999
Short Name
TiVo Article No. 11 TiVo Article No. 12 TiVo Article No. 13
Bates Numbers
BB00012183
Techies whip up biz at conflicted confab Getting Personal With Television; New Digital VCRs Tailor Program Select ion to Viewers' Tastes and Time STATE OF THE ART; Making Television Searchable ORACLE SEES VID ON DEMAND IN TV'S FUTURE Dishing up DishPlayer
Daily Variety The Washington Post
04.26.1999 04.24.1999
BB00012184BB00012185 BB00012186BB00012188
55. Lewis
The New York Times Daily Variety
The New York Times Company Reed Elsevier Inc. Reed Elsevier Inc. Star Tribune
04.22.1999
TiVo Article No. 14 TiVo Article No. 15 TiVo Article No. 16 TiVo Article No. 17
BB00012189BB00012191 BB00012192BB00012193 BB00012194 BB00012195BB00012197
56. Graser
04.21.1999
57. Graser 58. Alexander
Daily Variety
04.20.1999 04.20.1999
Tailor-made TV; The Star Tribune new "digital" VCRs are (Minneapolis, promising to remove MN) the stress of finding something you enjoy watching on TV.
EXHIBIT B: IDENTIFICATION OF PRIOR ART (Prior Art Publications) Page 9 of 11
Case 3:06-cv-02361-WHA
Document 116-3
Filed 12/20/2006
Page 10 of 11
BLOCKBUSTER'S AMENDED PRELIMINARY INVALIDITY CONTENTIONS (U.S. PATENT NO. 7,024,381 B1)
Author
59. Haley
Title
TAMING TV NEW HARD-DISK RECORDERS LET VIEWERS PAUSE LIVE TELECASTS AND TAPE SHOWS BY CATEGORY BRINGING TV UNDER CONTROL STATE OF THE ART; Making Television Searchable [?] TiVo Selects Atmel's Smart Cad Crytpo Controller for Authentication and Security; AT90SC3232C Offers Highest Security [?]
Publication
San Jose Mercury News (California)
Publisher
Date
Short Name
TiVo Article No. 18
Bates Numbers
BB00012198BB00012201
San Jose 04.18.1999 Mercury News
60. Lewis
The New York Times Business Wire Business Wire
The New York Times Company Business Wire, Inc. Business Wire, Inc.
04.22.1999
TiVo Article No. 19 TiVo Article No. 20 TiVo Article No. 21
BB00012202BB00012204 BB00012205 BB00012205
61. 62.
04.27.1999 04.26.1999
63.
The Washington Post
The Washington Post
04.24.1999
TiVo Article No. 226
BB00012206
6
"TiVo Report" and "TiVo Articles Nos. 1-22" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "TiVo publications." EXHIBIT B: IDENTIFICATION OF PRIOR ART (Prior Art Publications) Page 10 of 11
Case 3:06-cv-02361-WHA
Document 116-3
Filed 12/20/2006
Page 11 of 11
BLOCKBUSTER'S AMENDED PRELIMINARY INVALIDITY CONTENTIONS (U.S. PATENT NO. 7,024,381 B1)
Author
64.
Title
Netflix.co m Featured DVDs for Saturday, January 16, 1999 Netflix.co m Featured DVDs for Saturday, January 17, 1999 www.net flix.ht m Now with Over 3,200 DVDs to rent Tuesday, April 27, 1999 DVD Movie Rentals Come Online First Online DVD Rental Store Opens: Netflix Site Offers Unprecedented Title Selection, Availability and Convenience
Publication
net flix.co m archive.org
Publisher
Netflix, Inc.
Date
01/16/1999
Short Name
Netflix Web Pages No. 1
Bates Numbers
BB00013060 13063
65.
net flix.co m archive.org
Netflix, Inc.
01/17/1999
Netflix Web Pages No. 2
BB00013064 13067
66.
net flix.co m archive.org
Netflix, Inc.
04/27/1999
Netflix Web Pages No. 3
BB00013068 13070
67.
Newsweek Business Information Business Wire
Newsweek
04/15/1998
Netflix Article No. 1 Netflix Article No. 27
BB00008580 8581 BB00008582 8584
68.
04/14/1998
7
"Netflix Web Pages Nos. 1-3" and "Netflix Articles Nos. 1-2" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "Netflix publications." EXHIBIT B: IDENTIFICATION OF PRIOR ART (Prior Art Publications) Page 11 of 11
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?