Parrish et al v. National Football League Players Incorporated

Filing 593

OBJECTIONS to 583 Plaintiffs' Bill of Costs by National Football League Players Incorporated, National Football League Players Association. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A)(Padnos, Todd) (Filed on 12/11/2008) Modified on 12/12/2008 (sis, COURT STAFF).

EXHIBIT A

Case No. C 07 0943 WHA Parrish v. National Football League Players Association, et al.

Fees of the Clerk Payee State Bar of California Event Certificate of Good Standing for admission to USDC, Northern District for Noel S. Cohen, Manatt, Phelps & Phillips, LLP Admission to USDC, Northern District for Noel S. Cohen, Manatt, Phelps & Phillips, LLP Pro Hac Vice application for L. Peter Parcher, Manatt, Phelps & Phillips, LLP Pro Hac Vice application for Tom Graves, McKool Smith Fee $25.00 Page(s) Citation Rec. Doc. 583-2, Page(s) 2, 4-5

Clerk, U.S. District Court

$210.00

Rec. Doc. 583-2, Page(s) 2, 67

Clerk, U.S. District Court

$210.00

Rec. Doc. 583-2, Page(s) 2, 8- 9

Clerk, U.S. District Court Total

$210.00

Rec. Doc. 583-2, Page(s) 2, 11-12

$655.00

Fees for Hearing and Trial Transcripts Transcript Sanctions Hearing Transcript Case Management Conference Transcript Hearing on Plaintiffs' Discovery Dispute Hearing on Motion to Dismiss Second Amended Complaint Hearing on Discovery Dispute Class Certification Hearing Hearing on Discovery Dispute Summary Judgment Hearing Summary Judgment Hearing (deposit) Pretrial Hearing Trial Transcripts (deposit) Trial Transcripts Trial Transcripts Trial Transcripts Realtime Live Note Realtime Live Note Total Date 5/31/2007 6/14/2007 8/17/2007 8/30/2007 4/11/2008 4/24/2008 6/11/2008 7/24/2008± 7/24/2008 10/15/2008 10/17/2008 10/20/2008 11/03/2008 11/03/2008 10/20/2008 10/21/2008 ­ 11/10/2008 Fee $242.00 $46.00 $181.50 $217.80 $34.50± $132.00 $101.40± $20.34± $225.00 $997.02± $9,594.67 2,255.86± $16,977.06± $607.24± $671.00 $7,811.05 $19,728.26 Page(s) Citation Rec. Doc 583-4, Page(s) 3, 40 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 3, 41 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 3, 42 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 3, 43 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 3, 44-45 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 3, 46-47 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 3, 49-50 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 3, 51 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 3, 51-53 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 3, 54 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 3, 55 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 3, 57-58 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 3, 59-60 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 3, 62-63 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 58 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 63

± Plaintiffs also seek to tax the cost of multiple copies of these transcripts. Even if Plaintiffs are entitled to the costs of transcripts themselves, they still are not entitled to the costs of multiple copies.

Deponent Parrish Claims Bernard Parrish (transcript and video) Margaret Parrish (transcript and video) Adderley, Herbert; Parrish, Margaret; Parrish, Bernard Total

Date

Deposition Transcripts Fee $4,043.91 $1,493.71 Some portion of $796.00* $5,537.62 $359.66 $796.00 $1272.50 $2,532.10+ $2,487.92+ $3,032.03+ $300.00 $1,422.00 $247.68 $2,347.08+ $4.313.21+ $1,899.50

Page Citation(s) Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 2, 28-29 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 2, 30-31 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 2, 6

3/13/2008 3/5/2008 2/20/2008 3/5/2008 3/13/2008

Video Copies of Depositions Adderley, Herbert 2/20/2008 (video) Adderley, Herbert; 2/20/2008 Parrish, Margaret; 3/5/2008 Parrish, Bernard 3/13/2008 Allen, Doug (video) 9/7/2007 Allen, Pat (video) 2/28/2008

Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 2, 4 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 2, 6 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 2, 8 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 2, 9 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 2, 13 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 2, 14 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 2, 16 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 2, 18 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 2, 20 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 2, 21 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 2, 25 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 2, 27

Berthelsen, Richard 5/13/2008 (video) Eyrich, Glenn 2/12/2008 (video) Friss, Warren (video) 4/4/2008 Jizmagian, Stephen J. 7/8/2008 (video) Laird, Bruce (video) 9/24/2008 Linzner, Joel (video) Nahra, Joe (video) Noll, Roger (video) 2/8/2008 4/16/2008 7/9/2008

*Whatever portion of this total is attributable to the deposition videos of Margaret and Bernard Parrish should be deducted. + Whatever portion of this total is attributable to deposition videos should be deducted.

Deponent Parrish, Bernard (video) Parrish, Margaret (video) Skall, Howard (video) Upshaw, Gene (video) Zucker, Adam (video) Total

Date 3/13/2008 3/5/2008 2/14/2008 1/13/2008 4/4/2008

Fee $505.91 $274.51 $3,474.55+ $2,097.30+ $1,243.00 $24,486.74 $288.80 $136.50 $706.00 $1,051.00 $826.00 $281.60 $478.80 $353.40 $136.50 $238.40 $4,313.21++ $3, 474.55++ $12,284.76

Page Citation(s) Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 2, 29 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 2, 30 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 2, 36 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 3, 37 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 3, 39

Expedited Delivery of Transcripts Beach, Walter ­ 8/20/2008 "daily delivery" fee Friss, Warren ­ 4/4/2008 "immediate rough" transcript Jizmagian, Stephen ­ 7/8/2008 "80% Expedite Fee" Noll, Roger ­ "80% 7/9/2008 Expedite Fee" Parrish, Bernard ­ "2 3/13/2008 Day Delivery" Parrish, Margaret ­ 3/5/2008 "3 Day Expedited Delivery" Rascher, Daniel ­ 7/25/2008 "Daily Delivery" Rowley, Philip ­ 7/22/2008 "Daily Delivery" Zucker, Adam ­ 4/4/2008 "Immediate Rough" Transcript McNeil, Clifton ­ "3 10/3/2008 Day Expedited Delivery" Nahra, Joe ­ "4 Day 4/16/2008 Expedited Rate" Skall, Howard ­ "1 2/14/2008 Day Expedited Rate" Total

Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 11 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 16 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 17 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 26 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 28 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 31 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 32 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 33 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 39 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 61 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 25 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 36

+ Whatever portion of this total is attributable to deposition videos should be deducted. ++Whatever portion of this total is attributable to expedited delivery fees should be deducted.

Deponent Date Rough ASCII Copies Zucker, Adam 4/4/2008 Jizmagian, Stephen Laird, Bruce Beach, Walter Adderley, Herbert Parrish, Bernard Parrish, Margaret Rascher, Daniel Rowley, Daniel Zucker, Adam Total 7/8/2008 9/24/2008 8/20/2008 2/20/2008 3/13/2008 3/5/2008 7/25/2008 7/22/2008 4/4/2008

Fee $136.50 $706.00 $265.65 $222.75 $583.20 $747.25 $273.00 $364.65 $270.60 $136.50 $3,706.10

Page Citation(s) Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 16 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 17 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 19 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 11 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s)5 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 28 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 31 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 32 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 33 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 39

Condensed Transcripts, Word Indices, Video Capture & Synch and Invoice Processing Fees Adderley, Herbert 2/20/2008 $30.00 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 5 Beach, Walter 8/20/2008 $30.00 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 11 Laird, Bruce 9/24/2008 $30.00 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 19 Parrish, Bernard 3/13/2008 $30.00 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 28 Parrish, Margaret 3/5/2008 $35.00 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 31 Rascher, Daniel 7/25/2008 $30.00 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 32 Rowley, Philip 7/22/2008 $30.00 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 33 McNeil, Clifton 10/3/2008 $30.00 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 61 Allen, Doug 9/7/2007 $202.40 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 8 Adderley, Herbert ; 2/20/2008; $796.00+ Rec. Doc. 583-4, Parrish, Margaret ; 3/5/2008; Page(s) 6
+ Whatever portion of this total is attributable to "synch" should be deducted.

Parrish, Bernard Jizmagian, Stephen Noll, Roger Friss, Warren Zucker, Adam Total

3/13/2008 7/18/2008 7/9/2008 4/4/2008 4/4/2008

$420.00 $560.00 $91.42 $216.57 $2510.39

Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 18 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 26 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 39 Rec. Doc. 583-4, Page(s) 16

+ Whatever portion of this total is attributable to "synch" should be deducted.

Fees for Witnesses Witness Allen, Doug Allen, Doug Electronic Arts Electronic Arts Linzner, Joel Linzner, Joel NFLPA NFLPA c/o CT Corporation NFLPA Topps Total Date 9/7/2008 9/10/2008 2/8/2008 10/3/2008 2/8/2008 9/2/2008 8/22/2007 2/23/2007 2/29/2008 12/20/2007 Service of Subpoena Fee $394.75 $532.00 $242.50 $42.50 $80.00 $67.50 $110.00 $176.85 $170.00 $242.50 $2058,60 Page Citation(s) Rec. Doc. 583-3 Page(s) 2, 3 Rec. Doc. 583-3 Page(s) 2, 4 Rec. Doc. 583-3 Page(s) 2, 5 Rec. Doc. 583-3 Page(s) 2, 9 Rec. Doc. 583-3 Page(s) 2, 16 Rec. Doc. 583-3 Page(s) 2, 20 Rec. Doc. 583-3 Page(s) 2, 21 Rec. Doc. 583-3 Page(s) 2, 22 Rec. Doc. 583-3 Page(s) 2, 24 Rec. Doc. 583-3 Page(s) 2, 25

Fees for Exemplification and Copying Qty 4,954 8,756 293 1 14,003 Total Description "Images ­ Medium" "Images ­ Heavy" "Images ­ 11" Color" "DVDs" PDF Price $743.10 $1,313.40 $293.00 $50.00 $560.12 $3,203.79 Page Citation Rec. Doc. 583-5, Page 4 Rec. Doc. 583-5, Page 4 Rec. Doc. 583-5, Page 4 Rec. Doc. 583-5, Page 4 Rec. Doc. 583-5, Page 4