Oracle Corporation et al v. SAP AG et al

Filing 1056

Declaration of Tharan Gregory Lanier in Support of 1055 Opposition/Response to Motion, Defendants' Opposition to Oracle's Conditional Motion for New Trial filed bySAP AG, SAP America Inc, Tomorrownow Inc. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B, # 3 Exhibit C, # 4 Exhibit D, # 5 Exhibit E, # 6 Exhibit F)(Related document(s) 1055 ) (McDonell, Jason) (Filed on 4/8/2011)

Oracle Corporation et al v. SAP AG et al

Doc. 1056 Att. 1

Exhibit A
Dockets.Justia.com

UNITED NORTHERN BEFORE THE HONORABLE

STATES

DISTRICT

COURT

DISTRICT

OF CALIFORNIA JUDGE

PHYLLIS
ET

HAMILTON

ORACLE CORPORATION

AL NO
0701658
PJH

PLAINTIFFS

VS
SAP

Certified
ET

Copy

AG

AL
DEFENDANTS

PAGES

124

_____________________________

CALIFORNIA OAKLAND WEDNESDAY SEPTEMBER

30

2010

TRANSCRIPT

OF PROCEEDINGS

APPEARANCES
FOR

PLAINTIFFS

BOlES
1999

SCHILLER

OAKLAND

HARRISON CALIFORNIA

FLEXNER LLP STREET SUITE 900
94612 ATTORNEY LLP CENTER 94111-4607 AT LAW

BY

STEVEN

HOLTZMAN

BINGHAM MCCUTCHEN THREE EMBARCADERO

BY

SAN FRANCISCO CALIFORNIA ZACHARY ALINDER ANTHONY FALZONE HOLLY HOUSE GEOFFREY HOWARD DONN PICKETT ATTORNEYS

AT

LAW

FOR

DEFENDANTS

JONES

DAY

SILICON VALLEY OFFICE 1755 EMBARCADERO ROAD PALO ALTO CALIFORNIA

BY

THARAN

GREGORY

LANIER

94303 ATTORNEY

AT

LAW

APPEARANCES CONTINUED
REPORTED

NEXT CSR

PAGE

BY

RAYNEE

MERCADO

NO

8258

RA YNEE

MERCADO CSR RMR CRR FCRR CCRR 510

451-7530

55 -- LOOK TO

PEOPLESOFT
AND VALUE

AND

SIEBEL

BY

ANALOGY

AT

THAT

TOTAL

VALUE
WAS

EVERYTHING

THATS RELEVANT

THE

SOFTWARE

THAT

STOLEN

ITS
NOT

NOT
IT DO

ABOUT
IS

--

ITS
THE

NOT FAIR

ABOUT MARKET

LOST

PROFITS
OF

ITS
WHAT

ABOUT

THE

-TO

ABOUT

VALUE

USE
AT
THE

THEYRE
VERY

TRYING THEY
DOES

IS

EXPAND

THIS

PRIOR

ORDER

WHEN

TIME
IT

MADE NOT

THIS EXTEND

-- THEY TO

SOUGHT

THIS

ORDER

THEY

SAID

QUOTE THEORY
10

ORACLES HYPOTHETICAL

LICENSE

CLOSED NOW

QUOTE THEYRE
AND TRYING
IT DOES TO

TAKE

BACK WHAT
TO

THEY

SAID

TO

11

JUDGE LAPORTE LICENSE

SAY

EXTEND

ORACLES HYPOTHETICAL
MOTION
IS

12

THEORY
THE

THATS EXACTLY WHAT COURT
THE

THIS

ABOUT ASK
WAS
THE

13

CAN THAT
TO

JUST THIS
THE

ASK -- CAN PARTICULAR

JUST

14

ISSUE LOST

RAISED PROFITS

AT WAS

TIME

EVIDENCE

AS TO

15

RELEVANT

HYPOTHETICAL THEY VALUE SAID

LICENSE ANALYSIS
IT

16
17

MR PICKETT
DO

NO
FAIR HAD

BECAUSE MARKET EXPERT

HAD

NOTHING

TO

WITH

THE

HYPOTHETICAL THE

APPROACH
ALREADY BEEN

18

COURT

THE

REPORTS

19 20 21 22 23
24

PREPARED

--

MR
THE

PICKETT

NO
-- YOUR

COURT
PICKETT

EXPERT
WERE BUT
DONE TO DO

NO
PREPARED MONTHS

MR
THEY ARE

NO

THOSE

LATER
BOTH

-- STARTED

LAST

NOVEMBER
AND
IS

THATS AN ISSUE THAT
LOTS OF DISCOVERY
IS CUT

EXPERTS

HAVE
SO

LOOKED WHAT

AT
THIS

WEVE
TRYING

OVER
--

25

SIGNIFICANT

FAYNEE

MERCADO CSR RMR CRR FCRR CCRR 510

451-7530

124

CERTIFICATE RAYNEE STATES
THAT

OF REPORTER OFFICIAL
OF IN ET

MERCADO
DISTRICT

REPORTER

FOR

THE

UNITED

COURT

NORTHERN

CALIFORNIA C07-01658

HEREBY

CERTIFY

THE

FOREGOING
ET

PROCEEDINGS
SAP

PJH

ORACLE
BY

CORPORATION CERTIFIED UNDER
10

AL

AG

AL
WERE

WERE

REPORTED

ME

SHORTHAND DIRECTION AND
OF

REPORTER
INTO TRUE

AND

THEREAFTER
THE

TRANSCRIBED
IS

MY

TYPEWRITING RECORD
OF

THAT

FOREGOING
AS

FULL
ME AT

COMPLETE
THE TIME THE

SAID

PROCEEDINGS

BOUND

BY

11

FILING
OF THE

12

VALIDITY
BE

REPORTERS

CERTIFICATION AND/OR REMOVAL

OF

SAID THE

13

TRANSCRIPT COURT

MAY

VOID

UPON

DISASSEMBLY

FROM

14

FILE

15

16
17

RAYNEE

MERCADO MONDAY

CSR

RMR

CRR
2010

FCRR

CCRR

18

OCTOBER

19
20

21 22 23
24

25

RAYNEE

MERCADO CSR RMR CRR FCRR CCRR 510

451-7530