Oracle Corporation et al v. SAP AG et al

Filing 571

Declaration of Chad Russell in Support of 570 MOTION to Modify the Protective Order and to Compel Deposition Testimony and Further Responses to Requests For Admissions filed by Oracle EMEA Limited, Oracle International Corporation, Oracle USA Inc., Siebel Systems, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B, # 3 Exhibit C, # 4 Exhibit D, # 5 Exhibit E)(Related document(s) 570 ) (Russell, Chad) (Filed on 12/11/2009) Modified on 12/16/2009 (vlk, COURT STAFF).

Oracle Corporation et al v. SAP AG et al

Doc. 571 Att. 2

Case4:07-cv-01658-PJH Document571-3

Filed12/11/09 Page1 of 4

EXHIBIT C

Dockets.Justia.com

Case4:07-cv-01658-PJH Document571-3

Filed12/11/09 Page2 of 4

JONES DAY
717 TEXAS · SUITE 3300 · HOUSTON, TEXAS 77002-2712 TELEPHONE: [phone] · FACSIMILE: [phone]

Direct Number: [phone] [e-mail]

October 21, 2009 Via E-mail to [e-mail] Mr. Geoffrey M. Howard Bingham McCutchen, LLP Three Embarcadero Center San Francisco, CA 94111-4067 Re: Case No. 07-CV-1658; Oracle Corporation, et al., v. SAP AG et al. U. S. District Court, Northern District of California, Oakland Division

Dear Mr. Howard: Defendants have discovered the inadvertent production of twenty-two privileged documents from TN custodians. Defendants request, pursuant to paragraph 15 of the Stipulated Protective Order, that Plaintiffs promptly return or destroy all copies, electronic or otherwise, of the following documents, except the original production disk for disaster recovery purposes.1 The documents at issue are listed in the chart below. Beginning Bates Number TN-OR00657800 TN-OR00688048 TN-OR00688060 TN-OR00852363 TN-OR00852365 TN-OR00852376 TN-OR00852400 TN-OR01022329 TN-OR01022391 TN-OR01122770 TN-OR01122830 TN-OR01142754 TN-OR01570794 TN-OR01694688
1

Ending Bates Number TN-OR00657813 TN-OR00688057 TN-OR00688073 TN-OR00852364 TN-OR00852375 TN-OR00852386 TN-OR00852401 TN-OR01022338 TN-OR01022407 TN-OR01122782 TN-OR01122839 TN-OR01142766 TN-OR01570807 TN-OR01694689

Per Judge Laporte's August 29, 2008 Order ("[U]nder the existing protective order and the parties' agreement regarding disaster recovery, the party from whom documents are clawed back shall not retain a copy of the documents (except one for disaster recovery purposes) and shall not subsequently read or take notes about the clawed back documents.")
HUI-119648v1
AT L A N T A · BEIJING · BRUSSELS I RVI NE · LONDON · LOS ANGELES SAN DIEGO · SAN FRANCISCO · · CHICAGO · CLEVELAND · CO L U M B U S · · MA D R I D · MI L A N · MO S C O W · MU N I C H SHANGHAI · S I L I C O N VA L L E Y · SINGAPORE · DALLAS · FRANKFURT · NEW DELHI · N E W YO R K · SYDNEY · TA I P E I · HO N G K O N G · PA R I S · TO K Y O · · HO U S T O N PITTSBURGH W ASHI NGTO N

Case4:07-cv-01658-PJH Document571-3

Filed12/11/09 Page3 of 4

JONES DAY

Mr. Geoffrey M. Howard October 21, 2009 Page 2 Beginning Bates Number TN-OR01731470 TN-OR01778799 TN-OR02181823 TN-OR02181827 TN-OR02181835 TN-OR02185764 TN-OR02185767 TN-OR02185770 Ending Bates Number TN-OR01731480 TN-OR01778800 TN-OR02181826 TN-OR02181834 TN-OR02181839 TN-OR02185766 TN-OR02185769 TN-OR02185778

For your convenience, PDF copies of the redacted documents are being provided to you by e-mail. Defendants will promptly provide replacement .tif images and a load file for these documents. Please note that Defendants have redesignated some of these documents as "Confidential." Additionally, Defendants have discovered the inadvertent production of twelve privileged documents from SAP custodians. Defendants request, pursuant to paragraph 15 of the Stipulated Protective Order, that Plaintiffs promptly return or destroy all copies, electronic or otherwise, of the following documents, except the original production disk for disaster recovery purposes. The documents at issue are listed in the chart below. Beginning Bates Number SAP-OR00677484 SAP-OR00677580 SAP-OR00677719 SAP-OR00677727 SAP-OR00677804 SAP-OR00678067 SAP-OR00785742 SAP-OR00785762 SAP-OR00785771 SAP-OR00785778 SAP-OR00785784 SAP-OR00785820 Ending Bates Number SAP-OR00677490 SAP-OR00677588 SAP-OR00677725 SAP-OR00677735 SAP-OR00677813 SAP-OR00678075 SAP-OR00785750 SAP-OR00785770 SAP-OR00785777 SAP-OR00785780 SAP-OR00785792 SAP-OR00785829

For your convenience, PDF copies of the redacted documents are being provided to you by e-mail. Defendants will promptly provide replacement .tif images and a load file for these documents.
HUI-119648v1

Case4:07-cv-01658-PJH Document571-3

Filed12/11/09 Page4 of 4

JONES DAY

Mr. Geoffrey M. Howard October 21, 2009 Page 3 Please let us know if you have any questions. Regards, /s/ Courtney D. Scobie

cc:

Via E-mail Donn Pickett ­ Bingham McCutchen, LLP ­ [e-mail] Holly House ­ Bingham McCutchen, LLP ­ [e-mail] Zachary J. Alinder ­ Bingham McCutchen, LLP ­ [e-mail] Bree Hann ­ Bingham McCutchen, LLP ­ [e-mail] Chad Russell- Bingham McCutchen, LLP ­ [e-mail] Via E-mail Greg Lanier ­ Jones Day Silicon Valley ­ [e-mail] Scott W. Cowan ­ Jones Day Houston ­ [e-mail] Jason McDonell - Jones Day San Francisco ­ [e-mail] Elaine Wallace ­ Jones Day San Francisco ­ [e-mail] Jane Froyd ­ Jones Day Silicon Valley ­ [e-mail] Josh Fuchs ­ Jones Day Houston ­ [e-mail] Jacqueline K. S. Lee ­ Jones Day Silicon Valley ­ [e-mail]

HUI-119648v1