Petroliam Nasional Berhad v. GoDaddy.com, Inc.

Filing 143

Declaration of Perry Clark in Support of 134 MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment re Liability for Contributory Cybersquatting as to PETRONASTOWERS.NET filed byPetroliam Nasional Berhad. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit 1, # 3 Exhibit 2, # 4 Exhibit 3, # 5 Exhibit 4, # 6 Exhibit 5, # 7 Exhibit 6, # 8 Exhibit 7, # 9 Exhibit 8, # 10 Exhibit 9, # 11 Exhibit 10, # 12 Exhibit 11, # 13 Exhibit 12, # 14 Exhibit 13, # 15 Exhibit 14, # 16 Exhibit 15, # 17 Exhibit 16, # 18 Exhibit 17, # 19 Exhibit 18, # 20 Exhibit 19, # 21 Exhibit 20, # 22 Exhibit 21, # 23 Exhibit 22, # 24 Exhibit 23, # 25 Exhibit 24, # 26 Exhibit 25, *** # 27 Exhibit 26 FILED IN ERROR. DOCUMENT LOCKED. DOCUMENT TO BE REFILED LATER. *** , # 28 Exhibit 27, # 29 Exhibit 28)(Related document(s) 134 ) (Clark, Perry) (Filed on 11/25/2011) Modified on 11/28/2011 (ewn, COURT STAFF).

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18

Ex. 11

19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
CLARK DECL. ISO REPLY ISO MTN. PART. SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Case No: 09-CV-5939 PJH

v?.r'f6

L s Y v

Oase4:09-cv-ff5$3$-PJf{
ilocume*t1
4

Filedl?122!AgPagel of 2

Bar
l'3
JffHN't $bAfSKY, State N+. 1955
F*.r
IlAVltr H IfftAhiF.R, State lttc, 16S452
n HOI"LIStlHTtI HItr{H,
lSar
$tnte N*. 30$65I
d;OOFltJCfrt ROS.ATI
&
WIL$ON ,$fiNn*[N-I
Prcfersi
onalCcrpnratinn
650FngehtultL{cad
4 PaloAlro,cA q4tfl4-Ifi5fl
'lielephune;
(S50)
4S3-S3fi0
l1
5 Facsiruile:
{dsfi)493-S$
[e-mail]
6 dk-rauler@tysgr,corr
hlrire@.wrgr,uonr
.?
I

L

I

I

A*orneysf,orDef*rrda:rt
Inc,
GoDaddv,corn.

I

DISTRIC:T
COURT
IINITED ST,{TE;$

l0
NOnTHERNDISTRICTOF CALTFO'RNIA
II
PIH
N$-: 09-CV-593s
CAI$E

Eerhn<t,
NasiCInal
1 2 Fetroliarn
Plnintif!

I3
t4

ITSCLAIL4,TIOI'{
OT
LJO]I'{N $LAF$I{Y

vs.

23,
DATE: B,eaember 2009
Tlh{E: 9:00a,nt.
JUDfiE: Hon"PhyllisJ. Hamilton

l 5 fintraddy.ccnn,
Inc.
t6
1"1
tff
l9

I, JohnL" $Iafs$'y,
declart ar follo'i.vs:

3i)

t,

I am an fllturn+y]icenr*ed practicelau' in th* Striteuf Califrrrria aud *m adnritted
to

7,1 to praeticcbeforethis Crrun" ] arn a ptrrffi#rwitlr the l'*urfinn of lVilsqrn$onsini Goodrich &
11

Rosati, counse[f+r De,fendant
fioD+cftly.Cftnr,Inc. ("Defendnrlfl-)in the *b+ve-cap{ionedilaffer.
2.

rtatahas*
that tr&ek$all damnin n&ffe
is
The Whois datrhase a $entrsl"seftrcllable

?4 md +ontaetinftlrmatir:n t'*r the r*gistriurt +f eaehregist*red clou,rdnnam*. affiflng (]ther
2 5 infnnnation. Atmclredtrrereto Exhillit R is a tnre and conect copy ot''th* prrblic Whois recor'd
as
26 rvith registrutiCIn
infbnnatian tbr t$reInt€rnst domain ,nams{petrottastcurer.Il#t:}
{th* sud+ct of
27 this larrsuit), as prirrte,ctr Decerub+r 20fiP. Accordlrrgto this record,the registtairtfor this
on
21,
?8 domain r]flrrleis Heiko SeXruel+kess Lfindon, Un:itedKingdorn.
CIf
trECLARA"N+N J.L. SLAFSKY
OF
Cgse {rf{V-593t PIf{
No:

o
CO
o

I
o
@
6
o
o
o
(!t

z,
t!
o-

; 0 " t> - t t
,

APP055

4

|

Page 2
Oase4:S$-cv-05SSS-PJH
Documentl4. Fited'fityPzlfiSPage2of E

I

3,

to
Thelnterne-t
fuchive trtlayB**k
M*chineiu nn onllnetnnl sllovringIntmnetusers

+
A

at
of
a+ues,sible* givenwebsite,T'he
tool aanbe a*oeased
treokthehistoqy oontent
*t

J

{wrprrw.archive.orgts. farniliarwith {ht toal nndits use, Att*c.frerl
Eam
hcr:sto ExhibitF ls a tnre
ns

4 andoorrect*o1ry the seerch
f'or
nf
resultspegefrurm Intemetfuchive H$ayFack
the
fuIachine the
)

dwurw.Fetrunastower.nsLb
address, printedon Fecemhm?1,
as
3SCIP,

6
,!

Th.is
resultrpnge,*hows nurn,ber hyperilinked
dates,
suchasJuly 13,
search.
n
*f
*rnaBshot$" tirneot-thesfittsnt atths weh*ltein qu+stion.
200$"
refl+rtrng
in
Attnched
h#reto
as

s

ExhibitC is a finr+ osrrefit
end
copyof thoWebpege
underlying "Ip!g_l-]..
?flSI'- hyperlinknrr
tlle

I

resulHFagE.Thc U&L actdress t}risWehpage
therEarch
with thetsqt"ftmf,tflurrlhflt.net."'
on
e:rds

4,

I G Likewire,the $ugus.t ?0, Qnt*.bm ?Q03.
and
?^ -01,
?-5.
?-9.
F*.+ember ?fifr3" Jffie 7*?004hyptnlink*
tl

rerultspagr al** sirtrw
urith
onthi$ *earch
$imilarly,
URt nddresss$ thetsxt "flmatf,urch&t.nst.'o

l 1 theFsh$6rl'J, 3fi05hyperlinkon this search
Webpage
with
results
ts
connscts an archived
Ff,g+
*f
.
l 3 theheading
"Visit-X ffriginnl Video-Chat-Fla#ornr/10#S0s pi*s/t0$frs nm*teurE. . .'
uf free
t 4 All trrgether, infl*rmation
this
sugge*ts visitsrsto dgetrnilsstowe.r"net)
that
would lraveaceessed
*affiafeur
t 5 Forrographic
CIhats"
duringthetime periodfiprn 20S3
umtiltndny.
t6

5.

31,
at
On trecember 30fi9,Epointd my Wsbbrowser thc doffiaiflnflrae

l"l {FistrsnftEtLower"flet>.renulting
Webpage
the
The
highlighted hendiqg
"Visit-x.netamateurvideo
heretc*s Exhibittr ie a truea:rdcorreot
l s chst" nba-rressiea of porncgraphic
*
images.A.ttached
<visitl 9 copyof the public Whoisrecsrdwitil registr*tioninfomlationfor rthe
Internetdamainnftfir,s
for
domain
?fi x.netF,asprintedon Fecember ?il09. Aacordlng tilrisrecord. r*gistrnn{ tNds
2tr,
the
to
7.1 nalne Bnuno
is
Eehnder Sr,ritaerl*nd.
of
nn
AL

I decl*reuaderpr,nalty perjuryunderthelaw.s theUnitedStates Ameriaa the
tllat
of
*f
of

is
?3 f"oregoing Eueandcorrect.
Exe*uted
Dec,emb€n 3fifi$in PaloAltn, C*lif+rnin,
?3,
24
25
_

?6
27

?s
trECLARA.TIflN T.L- SLAFSKY
OF
Cass E9{V-5939FJ}I
I'ls:

APP056

/s/ Jqtlnl*.,Flafsky
L.
Jnhm Slaf*kv

.,

Page 3
faae4:0$-sv-05939-pJH Dscumentl4-1 Filedt2/22/09 Fagel of t

EXHIBITA

GtrSol59S
APP057

Page
rffhplsSenruh
ffiflH#:09-cv-05$*9-PJHDoeurrentl4-1 Filedl2/22/S* Fagel of E

Tl..{ dr,r{ qfilhjnpd lp SsFsSf$.,sEEn,
t{p.! 'irlt}l#l$ &tlbpta
.*fdlt,bdiruud!y liicc,tidrprr$f bo ilftfuh, l*
lo
Fre/iitd'firh'
tdlh r}} gu.ssnlrF 0r rtfrEnlis rqgerdh.Eirs {cfi.crey, Tt&
lr{um*fftin h pvddod {rr thr *dc pu$$6 of isirtitrt, }Eu
.h 606r1'ingfocflnsfi':fl &bul dfirslrl {ltrm* rngE,ll.'thn rnrqrdr.
Any t*c of frii rlrlH lnirlrty,+dra Fvpala ir,sfipnEslh l6r$ikl€'t rr+$ol|t {rE jntarrf-rt60{1
SBr-rllr$iHls{ Cuf,*diff,csni tns, Ef iuknilljfl$ {il l[{iir.tnJ,
lqu HrnE F,lhss+ hnflE,S p$Sc lrd lirs*lthriq ldwrnMy.. In g$fiEl(lh..
tf,rtcil{i id ur€ tiis f€l$ harltw, €ftablo*+r 0lhe,erA* rfls$n f{€slble.
Wr.s
dh:$rnln$pn or mi${fofl cJthll dila ln Blri cr ln it* F'ltkrg, fGJfiny
ptifl(B+, I\dt EES1etrs.nlMi$r&xro+w€dkjtnd fldl,re{f,sirH
{fld
tolHtilFdi d sffI tini, inclmirq *peer.TqJ t'idftir sgiEe
fft lD ur{ hh dd$ lD tn#da hlf,ft r,i6*rm4,sldofirai{d {if fisslic slediir}rf*
Ffi$c[rEcEd0rlgirod,lo colhct c{ rs{R0l}cthir ddn lor sly FcrFs""r,
In{SJdi'q lnltrirr4thii 'trsh hr }r}ur '*}n Frrt,'-nJl cr cGftrff#ihtil purF*s{6,
Pl*qr,i4n#F. fiU rE![*hrnt +i {nF drrfabi n4ns b tpod8EgJ
ift $rs :r{ghbsili' frdd. lrl mg6t cit3r6i, G€Os,idy.cg& |rc"
ir ir6 rhi fiflii'lsdit df dq.rluiir ti*rfi!+ fs.]!d in ihit d{Erba96.
R[{,slr{flr:j
thllq+ $Eheffi#{86*
8pl[tF.s{C$
fildtdfr.s{
l*nd*q trnijm*ftlYgAill
tlt*H4l Klr4dtra
Rq?ictsffit S'Jloijohr
Gnfl 86rJi;0ffi ,.kE' :llslg:r'fiw*.gotHld/.c0er|
Il{dn0ln Hiflra: f ETEOf{,q87tlt1{rIIilET
ft€s&c,st; (t{"ht*f403
,fterlrE* ofl.:$f,^li*slLt0
tE#t UFdFbd ff: 0c.frtry{g,
ad$sfft tr'trllrBssreel;
htt&., drfri-lxir.stShD'rTra{,crrit
SchfrsneLrdt,
EFI\I I SS{Ffi
3tt Sld Sus+l
tsnd$1, L0ftkrn Ectv fl.tu
Li&rittpd
firhd#+n:t
rs4-igl6f3#806
TE#dft,4 g6nlad!
Bdrdsn#xsd, Hstlar do-Ajdss+81'stJBvl-c{Fn
Fr. tp5?t&
3?A{ld litss€t
tcflden' [sni{r.r EGIV $eu
Uilildd Kl$ttile
+{4Jgtr&5ltE0$
flcaruln rBmr:r h Il*tld ct"Jx:
+#gs.FfiEiA,0sqfi t{IHuLEQhl
t*sH, e#r14n4f $Htf{s r.f sel
ttssbiry Slrlrrg difriiB{{0tEFrE+1Blr{ll
fbsgF{ryStsUErctrEnlF,*rrrrrPmrdH
tor,
ft qihl* Stltur : rictrtTrsulsFtrhitJltd
Edf irlrf Sirius ; {fetfflt&SB*EFroHnitBd
$iffiUrdF#tusils#Ev#{de
RsE{rilftddi[fttair

flEn uf itr!.pcdial
fu:tdJnt #.Hb[dr
f,{y JE#J.JE
;*i&mr*utr
ity {iFpqdr:
F#tlttslt
,(ffi;nt
k'sr1ryn,fi htFfitidel
oldts i:r.X#ey
gi8$lFJl*gr-+

rHcr1fi

fnlsi

?'{{. tdrfi# fr:lgtn+

. f,lroptr50
*Slir,
$Bi-1$En*,'o
t*rrcn
fu:s*"
9icrJlrtfitjJtFBl
Ft€rtu*t 'ld,it,#
Gl4i *fcr
4f Dftrst ft*thrq
?gt'trd*rlllui

tl{l(r4rrtdoJ
'fihii{rls.rl
:r6,*fii{l
llidJlf
F.:*fifi f tirrltnlbt*d"
r{Rh!$i
Drird{!;l{ith
Ud
*f,dsFlritnogqh
git$ trirl

4t0$ltf:,i$41,tjr€*tf4,**i+'1cF&lri#'s!Edhsd,jiFtni0Bfilo'6{iJ?t+jlq{tr]H'.t{ET..*It{l..llf1j4,},3iEel.L€{trE++ltjE3t€trawli@hb
{a{flfi

ar 100+":#lrs

r:ifiniir{tft-edr.

+*

r'fi Flhlt r+$frul"

ht[p;#whn.godaddy,a*nu/Sirhcls*aspx?d+urainTsksn*$t'ftBrsr.n€t&prng;rel,=godaddy 1?/r$i3s09

GF-00fi
5S6
APP058

Page 5
Cese4:0S-cv-0593$-FJH
Focumentl4-e FiledlZ/2ffO$Fagel of?

EXHTFITB

Gtr0ill5S7
APP059

Page 6

I
trnHnetamftwgffiffif;Mff#ffi-pln Foeumentl4-2
Filedl2/2?f0$
Fage2 f F*se of I
0f

Enl*rtilbbAd#asa:
ry

t jl';HFtrffi

ffi:H

rromrure paser
Anrhiue
k"j rs'. ssarch
i.f Res{tl'b

9earthed furhffiJt!ffifler,aq]tffiffifi#ilgr"gpf
r dliild$€twhcnElt€'rfa6updtb€d"
HuilErt$l
h€r66 ffim$:s #uer cdlpegon,fisrf$g.
Wp|crlh bocglnm'ryrHabla

$eateh He*.1!tE Jan 0il, l$S,6- Jdn 24, 2s0S
fsr
g$05
rsso 1gs71qq8lgsF 2000aofi s0@ 2003
2000
2s04
ffi6
a00r 20CI8
o
n
0
0
0
G 0
0
0
0
"
4 pa$es
I
4__-^- 1

Fag€s
Fds€s
Ffiq€3
paies Fbgesrag€$
pflge€
pasesp'$es pag*s psgespages
p*g€s
{'
.fidls-ffru$ * il#rgIJiln{ F*b 04.2005* Fsb1"F"go[&
g,qqE
f.,e.!.J,P,
*
#,5,.4.0CI-S.
F"ell
*
llinf.ilS,.ffS.QS

HffEs lHsile
tq$fiffitdr.chh{s Isms-af-ttss t Ffi$asy€dlry
I

http//web.arehiv*.org/webf+ltrftp://wwlrir.Betrffi
sstorrrer.nd

ta?.lru009

Gtr0015$ff
APP060

Page 1
Case4:0Scv-05$3$-FJHFocumerrt14-3 Filedllf2ffflS Fagel of 2

EXHIBIT C

Gtr0015S9
APP061

Page B

h

GF-fl0X
Sfffl
APP062

Page 9
Gasa4:09-cv-0S939-PJH
Documentl,4*{ FiledtZf2?/09Faget of 3

EXHIBTTN

GEFSol6S1
APP063

P a g e 10
lVhois iafo of visit-x.n*t
Ca$e4:0Fsv-0593S-FJH ilocumentl4-4
,,

Page1 afZ
FifiedT?12?109
Fage? of 3

Whol* Behi*d
Whui* **rvice

il-plflfse.kutr

?

Sg:r-c.8ff$dgff.

ficntss*.

I x a s r g rI r o ; g o o p { o * c + r u

ss.tfsh*As-f,
$xE*csiLrseeijE--msd-R

S+*n*ln:

rri*it-x..net#

Itr !
T[-[t :
R*gieLrar

r

T*KFFI & toflHffp

r94.tr{i.1.50.}38
0CErT{Tsp tevel Domaln}
KEf-SYSTEtllS 6HBht fvislt)

m i l r y 1 , e a g r v e r $: , l { S t , V I S I T . H . l $ H T

{ t S 4 - t 1 6 . 1 5 S .t $ )

t { s ? . v t 5 . I T . xl" * T t 8 3 , 1 + t ,r 3 5 " 6 0 }
{
F t s S . v r S I T - X . l ' l E [T 2 . 1 8 9 . 1 3 3 . 8 8 ]
6

Grsntrd ; l5-H,qu-1999
UFd*t€d I ?6-l,l+v-IE0S
Expir',ec: l5-f'lou-201*

Gnft*{rty

RAtfif Wh*ir

l

rrvrr

Arl* litv ttf'.srln

Thls data Is provtded by clqrnaindlscountE4.ctm
for infermatioFr purp{$,es, and ts asslst perso,6s4ffilrring infolrriatiofl
about sr r€lat€d t0 dBmaln narfie ffiglfirfltkm rec+rds,
rantee: its afclxra€b',
dorfi al ndlscountfr4-csm dEes fi st g:un
tsy $ubilTtf;ttlffig WHOtrSflju€ryr trCIlir
$*Fee that yau will use Ehlsdstfi
a

yotl
a,nd
that, under no clre$Frst*n*es. wF[[
; only for lawful purposes
; usethls dst8 t0

ffi+ trsnFrfrrgsifln sf frfif,$s
; t ) atlavloenabl*, qr otfienfllse suppo,r-t
cr
; ufisollcit€d, edmffi€rEi#t adver.t+Fing r+lhltatlsns vna E-r-nalil

; (spsrnh 6r
tfiat
*lechunic FrssB$E*$ apptry
; l) enablehlgh v*lume, autornflted.'
WHSIS6€rxrer.
; ts thaF
wFth*utprlor ftBtirB,
; Thsset€rms rnsy hc {hangied
i By silbm'ltdr4thb tusry, ysu agre to flhlde bV ltriEFotlcy.
DornainHaffiel VISIT-X"NE-F

:
hfrpllwvrv* 3rufu csrn/lv/vi x..nst
*is.
sit-

r?ru1ffiOflF

Gn-fiill602
APP064

Page 11
ltrhois of visit*x"net
fnfr
Ca,se4:SFw-il5S3S-PJH
Documentl4-4 FiEed'{i3lE?l0S
Fag*Sof 3
*

fage? sf?

RSF donnalndls+ount34.corn
I
Reg{stra t }fr1-: :l/wuryu.dd?4.n*t
r
hltp
swfte{"*eo*1ta p-B.GE7r
d;
orrrttgr-orBanicatFgn Fqi AG
; cnrn nt
crrln*r-fnsrHesiruno
:
me:
orrrner-lna Eehnder
t
owrrer-gtrcet: afat€rutr, 40
own+r-atEyt
Afilirtelr
+wner-rlplSfi02
cr*riler-qoufiffy:
CFI
+41 {44} ,?S5 45
owner'Bhone:
?5
swntr-f'ax:+41 {*{} XfiS75 ?0
own+r.ernstl:he*hnderff samfg4n,tah
adrnin-auntattlF-EGf7r
edmin-ur$anieati+n
; mrnPcintAG
*Sr*ln*fname:Fruno
Zehnder
adr*in-lnanre:
l"avalter+F"
4S
+*milrr-*treet;
*drnrln*ctty: 1#
If, rlch
adrniirr-Eip:
800e
admjln-ceuntry;
flH
rdrnilnlphqn*t
+4[ (44] US575 45
+41
adrHin-fEx: {44} ?8S75 70
+drnl -ernalt k rnhndsr@eampdnt,cFt
n
;
terh-cfinta6t: P-EG??
!,
tech-orgareiuatlon
: camFuiritAG
t*ch-fnarne:Erums
t*rh-lname;Zehnder
tedt-sF€et: t-svaHrstn,,40
zfitrnr,ich
fech-c[hyl
te$-elpr 8$ff?
tech-coulrtry:CFI
+41 {4q) 38S75 4,5
tseF-ph+ne;
tccfi'f*x: +41 {44} eB,5 7#
TS
b.;rehnd:Er
Srannpuint,ch
tech-em.pih
bllllng"**ntact: F.SGZII
billing"
oryanirntion cnrnFsintAS
I
t
billinErfnarneBFHr:o
hllling-lnnme:
Eehnder
40
hillifiS-$trE6t:LavH,tsflstr"
blllimg*cltyl
UABrkh
bllllng-rlp:8.002
blllltrg-courrtry:
CH
+4I
h'llttog-phune: (44) 3SS75 45
hf;ltFng-ftx: {44} 385 75 7g
+41
peint#t
i1
bllfing-ema ; bx ehndr@car,n
ftlanl*Serv*rs:nstr,vlslt-x. t 9-+.I I 50,Ac
n+t
1S,
flatfie $eruem;n$2,risit-x.''ret 14?.115.6'*
t3.
illanne
S*ffers: rHsS,vlsit-x. 6?,1?9,tr33.AS
neh
; Flea* r€$lsterysur d*rnainsat
Het
; http;//wurw.dd34.
curren'tly handllng

tS gtld*. ar,sl 847 eeftdis -

dnrnfilns lnClFx

tt- ssarcfibFr.
ffi n# qg.{,,ru$g-1n**errlsp

ffi

wh+ i s $erT rGq - nE[Eiffs$ts*:dJJ4.hqi$.f;*&.

hftp:#rvww.vSwhois.eor#n'/visit-x"net

1?Y?1/?0SP

Gtr-fi0x
80f;
APP065