The Facebook, Inc. v. Connectu, Inc et al

Filing 221

Declaration of Scott R. Mosko in Support of Defendants Winston Williams and Pacific Northwest Software, Inc.'s Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel Supplemental Responses to Interrogatory Nos. 3 and 4 filed by Pacific Northwest Software, Inc., Winston Williams. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1# 2 Exhibit 2# 3 Exhibit 3# 4 Exhibit 4-A# 5 Exhibit 4-B# 6 Exhibit 5# 7 Exhibit 6# 8 Exhibit 7# 9 Exhibit 8)(Mosko, Scott) (Filed on 11/7/2007) Text modified on 11/8/2007 (bw, COURT STAFF).

The Facebook, Inc. v. Connectu, LLC et al

Doc. 221 Att. 6

Case 5:07-cv-01389-RS

Document 221-7

Filed 11/07/2007

Page 1 of 8

EXHIBIT 5

Dockets.Justia.com

Case 5:07-cv-01389-RS

Document 221-7

Filed 11/07/2007

Page 2 of 8

1 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA SAN JOSE DIVISION FACEBOOK, INC., ZUCKERBERG, and MARK

Plaintiff, vs. CONNECTU, INC., (formerly known as CONNECTU, LLC), CAMERON WINKLEVOSS, TYLER WINKLEVOSS, DIVYA NARENDRA, PACIFIC NORTHWEST SOFTWARE, INC., WINSTON WILLIAMS, WAYNE CHANG, and DAVID GUCWA and DOES 1-25, Defendants. Case No. 5: 07--CV-01389--RS

/
---000--HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF WINSTON WILLIAMS Tuesday, June 19, 2007

---oQo--

SHEILA CHASE & ASSOCIATES REPORTING FOR: LiveNote World Service 21 Main Street, Suite 1250 2 San Francisco, California 94105 Phone: [phone] Fax: [phone]

Reported by: RACHEL FERRIER, CSR No. 6948

CSR

Case 5:07-cv-01389-RS

Document 221-7

Filed 11/07/2007

Williams, Winston HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

Page 3 of 8 6/19/2007
39

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

Q
A

Yes. Yes. All right. What company?

Q
A

I worked doing contract programming work I can't list

for various large number of companies. them all off the top of my head.

Q

When did you set up

--

or was this all

contract work? A Q Yes. All right. So you were not employees of

any of these companies? A Q No. All right. How long did you work for

Pacific Northwest Software? A Several years. All right. When did you cease to work for

Q

Pacific Northwest Software? A Q A I don't know the date. Was it in 2006? I believe so. Okay. Did you ever work as an employee of

Q
ConnectU? A

No. All right. Did you ever work as an

Q

employee of any company owned or bearing the named LiveNote World Service 800.548.3668 Ext. 1

tO H
U,

tO tO CD H O H CX) H H H O 0) 0
i

tO W H --J H tO H C) --J U ) tO H ø H

tO tO

tO H

H

t-l

H

Cl)

0 C)
-

P.'
ft
--

CD

i

0
C)
Hft

0 P.'
H-

ft

H

0 (1) H3

CD CD
CD
CD K)
I--a-

CD 0 (Q
CD
0 3 ft
I-

K)
K) K)
I I

P.' CD
CD
ft

K) ft
CD
ft

`

K) ft

H

CD CD
0

o
C) 0 CD
H

0

0 `1

H

H P.' CD
-OCD H

H

`-< CD 0 0 P.' ft
H

0 0 P.'
ft

H

0 CD
H
-

CD
I-

<
(Q
ft
CD HCD
-

Z
HC)

u
ft

p.'
ft ft H

Q CD
0 P.' P.'
ICD
t-

CD

P.'
ft

k<

tj CD
CD
ft
ft

H

P.' Q

Ii
0 ft CD
-

0
0

C)
Q

4 C
0 0

0
CD

Case 5:07-cv-01389-RS

tQ C) H(Q
C)

H CD CD H

H-

CD
0
CD C)) H

C)
ft

ft HP.'

H-

P.'

ft
1 CD C)
H-

CD CD
ft Cfl ft CD
CD CD
ft

ft

3

CD CD
C)

CD

C)

Co
CD
ft P.'
CD
-

0-i

Z 0

P.' C)

CD
ft

ft
ft H`-

0 C)

<
H
<

Hft

p.' tY CD
ft
ft
H

P.'

`-3 b CD
CD

P.'

ft
0

CD
ft

CD

QH

U,

0

-

CD

t'
H"3

CD
ht

P.'
P.'

ti 0
ft CD
I--i H-

ft

Cl)

t
P.'
H-

(0
·

CD CD P.' ft

ft
H

CD

H-

P.'
)-i

3

b CD 0
CD
t-h

<
0
J

d
0 H-

0
ft
H C)

H-CD

Document 221-7

P.'
CD CD

ft
p.'
0-i

3

co
M
CD
-

CD

H

ft

Ii

ft Z CD
I-

QCD

tn

ft

P.'
CD
C)
it

0

0 P.' CD P.' $1
P.'
-i

H

CD I-t

0-i
Q
C)
H-

ft
H-

Q-i P.'
3

H

C) CD

CD
CD CD

H 0
`

H CD

CD

ft

CD

P.' C) P.' 0-i P.'
h

`< CD CD

M

P.' < CD
0

C4 0 CD

CD

o
P.'
H

I--i --

H

H

p.'

H `ti 0
H-

p.

D P.' C)
0

ft

ft
-

P)
ft
0
CD

H CD
"3

i-3ft HO

CD

CD
ft

CD
)

`

ft
C) CD (0

Q.

`-< CD
ft
CD ft 0

0

CD

$1
ft
CD
·

CD
3 0
-

ft CD

P.'

P.'

t-

HCD

P.'

H

Q
ft CD
p
CD ft H-

P.'
CD

H C) P.'
t h

H-

C)

·

Filed 11/07/2007

CD

0

P.'

CD CD

CD <
HC) H-CD

P.' P.'
p.'

Z
ft CD
H<

P.'
0-i 0
Cl)

`<

P.'
C)

0
ft
H-

0

P.' C)

CD

CD CD P.' ft CD

CD
ft

Q < 0 Hft

C) CD
H-

CD

P.'

0

CD

P.' < CD
P.' P.'

CD
H
`0

Page 4 of 8
to 0 0 co

Case 5:07-cv-01389-RS

Document 221-7

Filed 11/07/2007

Page 5 of 8
6/19/2007

Williams, Winston HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

156 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 BY MR.

Q

Do you know who the lawyers are you are

referring to there? A I'm not sure. Do you recall the discussion that's

Q

referenced here? MR. MOSKO: answer. THE WITNESS: BY MR. COOPER: Q All right. Do you have an understanding No. Calls for a "yes" or "no"

here today if there is a methodology to identify the number of e--mails that were sent by ConnectU to students at California schools? MR. MOSKO:
THE WITNESS: COOPER: Is there any function that would permit

Lacks foundation.
Could you repeat?

Q

18 19
20 21

somebody reconstructing events to know how many e-mails were sent by ConnectU to students at
California schools? MR. MOSKO: Lacks foundation.

22 23 24 25

THE WITNESS:

It would be complicated to do and I don't know that it It's maybe

something of that nature,

has been done or is an existing function. possible, yeah. I mean,

I'm sure it's possible in

LiveNote World Service 800.548.3668 Ext. 1

t'J
U,

M
D
U,

tO W tO H

U,

t\J W

) tO

M H

H `D

)CO

H -J

lO

H

H

H W

H tO

H H

H C)

H Ct Cr Pi

CD Ct Cr

Qi

(T)
C) HICD

Cl CD 0 C
-

C) CU
H H tQ U)

o
CD CD CD Cr U)
t'

CD

tn

CD

Cr

Cr

0 Cl
CU
H-

CD CD
K)
C) H

CD
CD
K) K) ti

I

<

0
CD
-

CD

CD

CD

`Ti CU

K)
U) U)

C) CD CU CU 0
-

H-

O
U)
Cr
U,

i
HCt

H-

0

U)
CD
H"

CD
0
H
H

C -<
Cr U)

U)
`<

C)
H

CD
U) C) 0-

M H

CD

CD

Cl `-< `-<
H Ct

CD

<
C)
Cr
-

CD

`-<

< <
0 i
Ii
-

CD
CU
U) CD
Ct Cr
HF H-

0

d
Cl
CD M
H-

1
0 0 0 Cl CD tQ
Cr H
H

Cr h

H

C)

0 U)

(1)
Cr

CD

CD II

CU

d
CD
H-

Cr

H H

CD
U)

C)
0

U)
Cr

t1

`-<

Case 5:07-cv-01389-RS

<
Cr Cr

< CU
Cr
0 CD
j

0

<

CD

U)

CT)

C)

H

0
Cr Cr H Q Hti I-

CU

(Q CU
CD

CD CD Cr p
Cl) U)
CD
IHi

t3 Cr

U)

CD C)

<
CU

Cl

CU P)
( H

Cr CD
.0

Cr
H-

CD M

CD CU
U)
H

CD O

CU
CD CD CD
II U H-

0 0

CD

o
Hi

HH

H

0

-

CD CU i
I I

CU

Z
0
Cr

Cr
0 0

H0

<
CD 0

H QH

Cl
CU
H
H

pj
U) CD U) CD

U,

0
h

CU
0
-

CO

Cr :3

U)

CU Cl Cl

CU CU
r-r I`ti i Cr
l Cr

H

CD CD

< <
CD
CD
Ct H-

I-

Cr CD

3 Q

CD
CD (Q CD CD

`-<H Cl)

Document 221-7
0 U)

CD

Ct -

tj

< CD
CD
C,
H

U)
CU Ct

U) CD CD
Cr `< H

U) CD H0 U)
çt

CD

0 H-CD CD
U)
Cr

1

Cl
CD CU
HI-

Cr CU U) Cr
) Cr I I

xj

H

CO

CD C) C

Cl
F

CD
Cr
Cl) t3

CU Cr Q
H Cr

ij

X Cr
Hi

Cl C
-

CD H H-Hi CD
HH H HCr

0
CD C)

Cr Ct

CD

-

CU
H-

C) Cl)

Cl
H-

Cl
CD

Cl)

I-'

U) rt HO

H-

H

<
CD Cl) LQ

H-

C
-

P

CD
CD
H

C

Cr
Ct H

U)

Cr

CD
Cr H

H-C $i Hi

C
Ct

Hi Hi H-

(Q
CU
Cr HH H H i

0

C) 0

Cl
(Q
Cr

C CD
C)

CU U) (Q CD Cl

U) CD

CD ><
C
Hi

I-

i

C) CD Cl
Hi

CU 0

Ct

CD

Filed 11/07/2007

CD
Cl C
-o
Ct H-

H-

H

CU

CD Cl

Ct

C 3

CD C)

C LQ CD Cl

Ct

(I)

LQ

H

Cl 0

U)

0 C
-

H-

Cr

C (Q Q CD Cl CD
CD Cr
Cr
1<

Hi Ct

CD Cl
-0

H
IQ

O
I-Q

CU S

C)

C

·o

CD

H

i

C)

Cr

Cl

Cl CU
Ct

C `-Q (Q CD Cl
H-

0

Hi

Hi

Ct

Hi H-

HHi Hi H-

C
Hi

CD

CU
U)
-

O
H

C)

CU
CD
H
U,

I-

Page 6 of 8

CD Cr

U)

i

Cr

to --3 0 -3

bJ
-`

I-'
0%
`

fr-'
0 iD

tJ Ui
0 ¾0

bJ 0' J CD I
0%

h) W Ui 0
W 13 I-'

k) bJ

tJ I-'

I-' CD

IUi

I 0'

I-' W

I-' t.3

Pa.

P10
-

I-' 0

w000n I 0 n 0 fib
o

Pt

(0 0
,.
,.·

13

I-I

g
0 (0
Pa-

0
Ms

Pt I-'
Mi

I-'-

WI-'fl

0'

00 0' 0 0 I-'

On
H nn
o

0 Li
·

0'
pt
·
nc'

U)
I-'-`

i

0 m 0 fl 0

Pt

o

n

Pt

Pt
Pa·

Case 5:07-cv-01389-RS

0 0 Pt
·-

0 01-30 S 13 · 141114 0 E H H
p-'-n no no 0' 0 o

0 0' `Øct On Pt ç' ii `-a00 no Pt 0 ·

fr'-E
Pa-

b'1<

2:
fi
`

o 0
Oan

U) U) H etC
I-'H n I-bWO CD

n HO w Pan ·· 0 Ca C H UI 1 0 0' Pa0'
Ct H OPt

0 Pt 0 fi I-'0 C) *01<0 0 Pt 0'C I-' fr'sC 00 4 0 Pa-fl MiX 0' n no' 01-hO 0 0paPa-z 0 -` I-' `0 0 Pa0 fl Pa-CD 0 0 0 0 0 Pt FlOW 1-b
fr-" .
0 fr-' I

Pa0 C) Pt H I-'1-b 0
I-'fr's b' P-'Pt 0"
n no n 0'(0 o'n CO 0 n 00

HE

I.J

Fa
i4fr'e

Ut 0' CD

·

14

H

Document 221-7

··

0111111 I-'0 CD o

1< a a
Pt C
CD

0% 0%

0

i-'t

0
0 HG
00
nob

-P4
nO ct Pa·

S
I-'

*

0

·1<

a
--8
`4 CD Ott CD fr-'OO' Pt 0 Pt et etO

at fr-' rt 0 0'Pa-0'

HE

U'-'1<

·

·
0 CD
H CD 0 H Pa-fl 00
on

I
I--'nO 040 0
n

s1

0

00.0

Pa

1-h 1-b

n

Filed 11/07/2007

0'

0

PtHO (001<0 · I 0 O 5 PaI 0 I-'flOHO 0 Ui 0 0.100(0 0 0 ftfl Ct 5 Pa, 0 , fl

Pin , Pa0 1-by 0 at 01< P4 nfl
,-`

C H

it fr's

`-4 CD n 0 C H

00 C 10 (0

0

0 1-b

a:
H no nn 0
-.

S 0'
` 0 no.0 004t1s 0

0
0
·

Page 7 of 8

IL
I

o.&

n

a·
pa
Ui

pa
1%)
0 0

`4

)

H

H C C3i U]

t) UI

U)

tO tO

tO H

tO C

O

H OD

FJ

H C3

H UI

H U)

H tO

H H

tj

C)

Ij

CD

it

W
`-<

it CD

P)

`-<

(U

CD
-

CD

Pi C)

><
H

CD
it
t

it

P)
K) H K) C) i

Pi

CD
CD CD
CD

i-no
Q
i `-<

0
CD
P)

O
H

o
0
Ii

CD C) Q
0
t'i

H

P) `-3
--

P P)
H

H iO
C CD
C)

C)

C) 0 0
C) H

ii

C)

t'I til H-C
H-, iH U)

0 l3 Q CD )i Pi
CD

CD P) CD it
it it CD
HH

C)
H Cl)

Zi 0 it
0

CD

`-3
-

C')

0 P) CD
H-

H i-'

zl

`(I
it it

Xi
-.

Q C t'l -3
h l-- l-

CD
i-h

H Hit

0

t'I
H

Case 5:07-cv-01389-RS

-

it
0
h

H-

H it

i

0 ii
0 C]) C) 0 CD 0
H-

0 Pi i C) Pi H
H-

CD t5 CD Hit CD

P) C)
CD 0 i P.'
`<

it
CD
I-

Cl)

(Q `-3
til (I) H P.'

CD
it
H-,

CD P.'
H-

CD
Cl)
-.

H 0 CD P.'

CD
P.' t3
H-

HH
H

P) it H Cl.' CD H, 0 H H--

tj

t'i
H tO

H-

it

0

0
`-El

a) C) C

0
Cl)

0
0

it

it

C) t3 `-3 i
it it H CD it CD
ii

CD

Cl) C)

it CD

CD C) P.' H H

H 0 H-

U]

HCD 0 0
H

P.' it
0 H `-< M it I--I CD

C) 0 CD >< CD
1

H CD

C) P.'

a)
CD Cl) CD
Cli
i)

H]

Cl)

0

0

CD

P.'

it
P.' it

`-`I
HP.'

it `-<
it

b 0

C)

(a.'

<
CD
Cl) `3
`-tj

Document 221-7

o
P.'
tl it C) CD

P.'
CD C) it

CD i-h

X3

0 it 0
CD
) Cl)

CC!)

CX)

Ii CD C)

0-i P.' it

it
CD
I

CD P.'
it
P.'

CD

P.'
CD
C) 0

0
it

it

H

CD

H

tn

it HC)

0

P.'

0 P.'
Hit
H

C
CD

> it · CD P.' Cl)
Hi

i-I

Cli it Cl) 0 0 CD
it

1 P.' `.< 0 P.'
C) it H

P.' tY P.'

`-<

H-

Q
P.' i CD Q.
H H
Hi
h

0-i
CD it Cl)

0-i CD
it `-<
HH-,

P .'
CD
l-

Cl)

tY 0 0

I `-<

CD `t 0

CD

3i t
HO

H

H-

P.'

CD

it

`-< CD C) it 0
1 CD

0 CD it CD P.' it

CO

CD
P.'

H-

Cl)
H-

P.' tY P.'
CD CD

Cfl CD it CD b
Cl)

Cl)

Filed 11/07/2007

CD C) P.'
it

P.' C) C) 0 i Cl)

CD Cl)
it Hit

CD CD CD 0
HC) CD HI

C) O

II I

H H-

it CD

0
H 0
Cl)
··

CD
i-h I-

CD H

it 0

CD
P.' CD
CD
H H

P.'
$1

CD
0 it

P.'

CD
Cl) CD
CD H H

P.' C)
CD
CD 0

1

h

C) it

-`3

CD

-

H

0

P.'

Page 8 of 8

it

CD
H
U]

tO

C C