Elan Microelectronics Corporation v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 373

EXHIBITS re 358 Declaration in Support, /Exhibits F-G to the Declaration of Jane H. Bu in Support of Elan Microelectronics Corporation's Motion to Compel Discovery on Various Issues (Redacted) filed byElan Microelectronics Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit G)(Related document(s) 358 ) (Bu, Jane) (Filed on 8/3/2011)

Download PDF
EXHIBIT F #216*+2! &,33+. %21/" &+04" '1" $)" &5(-+)4" 7<J@AE<I<DM" 6<C<EA 6$ 9K?I><M" 3KCM (+" (&'' *,*& 64 ;<CJ?H" /?H?B 0C<E .GGC? 9?<D- .GGC? 0C<E ;24 8?HLA=? 70, 0C<E%.GGC?, .GGC?!I 7?IGFEI? JF 0C<E!I 716 5FI$ '&'#'&) 6KXKQ$ FU[ XKVKGZKJR_ SOYINGXGIZKXO`K U[X SKKZ GTJ IUTLKX& 3Y ; K^VRGOTKJ J[XOTM ZNK SKKZ GTJ IUTLKX$ ]K XKW[KYZ GRR XKRK\GTZ JUI[SKTZY VXUJ[IKJ H_ ZNK 3VVRK ZKYZOTM ZUURY& BNKYK JUI[SKTZY GXK XKRK\GTZ HKIG[YK 3VVRK NGY GXM[KJ GTJ IUTZOT[KY ZU GXM[K ZNGZ 7RGT NGY VXKYKTZKJ TU K\OJKTIK ZNGZ 3VVRK VKXLUXSY S[RZO%LOTMKX MKYZ[XKY& 3Y _U[ QTU]$ ZNK JUI[SKTZY XKW[KYZKJ H_ 7RGT YNU] 3VVRKaY [YK UL ZNK 3II[YKJ @XUJ[IZY OT GT OTLXOTMOTM SGTTKX& BN[Y$ ZU ZNK K^ZKTZ ZNGZ 3VVRK IUTZOT[KY ZU GXM[K ZNGZ 7RGT NGY TUZ VXKYKTZKJ K\OJKTIK ZNGZ 3VVRK KSVRU_KKY [YK ZNK 3II[YKJ @XUJ[IZY GY IRGOSKJ H_ 7RGT$ 7RGT XKW[KYZY ZNKYK JUI[SKTZY XKMGXJRKYY UL NU] ZNK JUI[SKTZ ]GY MKTKXGZKJ UX ]NU MKTKXGZKJ ZNK JUI[SKTZ& BNUYK JUI[SKTZ GXK \KX_ ROQKR_ ZU YNU] 3VVRKa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aY ZKYZOTM ZUURY GTJ ZU MGZNKX ZNK XKW[KYZKJ )%'%,"(+ JGZG MKTKXGZKJ H_ ZNUYK KTMOTKKXY& ;Z GVVKGXY LXUS U[X IUT\KXYGZOUT ZNGZ 3VVRK NGY LGORKJ ZU JU ZNK SUYZ #"*&$ XKYKGXIN ZU JKZKXSOTK ]NGZ OTLUXSGZOUT 3VVRK OZYKRL VUYYKYYKY& BNOY OY VGXZOI[RGXR_ ZX[K ]NKT _U[ YZGZKJ J[XOTM ZNK SKKZ GTJ IUTLKX ZNGZ 7RGT YUSKNU] QTU]Y ZNK IUTZKTZY UL 3VVRKaY JUI[SKTZY HKZZKX ZNGT 3VVRK JUKY& 8OTGRR_$ _U[X K%SGOR$ TUZ Y[XVXOYOTMR_$ USOZY ZNGZ 7RGT NGY VXU\OJKJ YOMTOLOIGTZ M[OJGTIK GY ZU OZY XKW[KYZ& 8OXYZ$ _U[ UXOMOTGRR_ ZUUQ ZNK VUYOZOUT ZNGZ 7RGTa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a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`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`XXM DQX[N\ BJ[T`Jb CNM`XXM DQX[N\% 75 2-)/.&**,WJ]QJW'P[NNWKUJ]]4`NRU'LXV $* /.) 1)+ ,+.* 8R[NL] $* /.) 1)+ ,*)) ;Ja #-,*! >DTJKODSDNX" =DMDOK =$ BNDKMTP/=DMDOK$>DTJKODSDNX3DMSTPO$FPNC $(+.! @JURSGDX" 9UMX ('" (&'' +/*) =; %,! ADMTHR" 5HRHL "'! 6MDO 4QQMH @HDN0 4QQMH 6MDO A8; ?HRVKFH0 ;DTTJHW$=PWHRS3THOSHIRKTXMDWIRPUQ$FPN $/&)('.! 6MDO%4QQMH/ 4QQMH!S >HSQPOSH TP 6MDO!S >7= <PS$ '&'#'&* 8NJ[ 8N[NT% = `[R]N [NPJ[MRWP 5YYUNe\ >^Ub *-]Q XKSNL]RXW\ ]X 9UJWe\ CNZ^N\] OX[ B[XM^L]RXW AX\' *)*&*)-' EQN\N [NZ^N\]\ [NZ^R[N ]QJ] 5YYUN Y[XM^LN MXL^VNW]\ PNWN[J]NM O[XV ]QN ]XXU MN\L[RKNM RW 5B9?)-20*)0 "C;B *)*#% 5YYUNe\ "C;B *)+#% 5YYUNe\ "C;B *),#% JWM 5YYUNe\ X[ JUPX[R]QV% \^LQ J\ ]QX\N \QX`W RW 5B9?)-20*)0% 5B9?).))0/,% 5B9?).))10.% JWM 5B9?).)*++)' 5YYUN QJ\ XKSNL]NM ]X Y[XM^LRWP ]QN\N [NUN_JW] MXL^VNW]\ J\ fX_N[K[XJM% ^WM^Ub K^[MNW\XVN JWM WX] [NJ\XWJKUb LJUL^UJ]NM ]X UNJM ]X ]QN MR\LX_N[b XO JMVR\\RKUN N_RMNWLN% RWLU^MRWP `R]QX^] URVR]J]RXW% ]X ]QN Na]NW] R] \NNT\ RWOX[VJ]RXW J_JRUJKUN ]X 9UJW ]Q[X^PQ X]QN[ \X^[LN\% RWLU^MRWP ]Q[X^PQ ]QN RW\YNL]RXW X[ ]N\]RWP XO ]QN JLL^\NM Y[XM^L]\ JWM(X[ H5YYUN ]XXUI VJMN J_JRUJKUN Kb 5YYUN% JWM ]X ]QN Na]NW] R] \NNT\ MXL^VNW]\ JWM ]QRWP\ WX] [NUJ]NM ]X ]QN JLL^\NM O^WL]RXWJUR]RN\ XO ]QN JLL^\NM Y[XM^L]\'g * GN MR\JP[NN ]QJ] ]QR\ R\ J _JURM KJ\R\ XW `QRLQ ]X `R]QQXUM ]QN\N YUJRWUb [NUN_JW] MXL^VNW]\' EQN\N MXL^VNW]\ J[N [NUN_JW] ]X X]QN[ R\\^N\% JWM `RUU Y[X_RMN RWOX[VJ]RXW WX] J_JRUJKUN ]X 9UJW ]Q[X^PQ X]QN[ \X^[LN\' ;X[ NaJVYUN% ]QR\ RWOX[VJ]RXW R\ [NUN_JW] JWM JMVR\\RKUN ]X \QX` ]QJ] 5YYUNe\ NVYUXbNN\ ^\N ]QN JLL^\NM Y[XM^L]\ RW ]QR\ LX^W][b RW JW RWO[RWPRWP VJWWN[' 5YYUNe\ [NURJWLN XW 9UJWe\ RW\YNL]RXW X[ ]N\]RWP XO ]QN JLL^\NM Y[XM^L]\ X[ 5YYUNe\ ]N\]RWP ]XXU\ R\ ^WJ_JRURWP KNLJ^\N% J\ bX^ TWX`% 9UJWe\ RW\YNL]RXW XO ]QN Y[XM^L] JWM ]N\]RWP ]XXU\ `X^UM UNJM ]X MJ]J PNWN[J]NM Kb 9UJW h WX] 5YYUN NVYUXbNN\' EQ^\% ]QN RWOX[VJ]RXW [NZ^N\]NM Kb 9UJW R\ KX]Q [NUN_JW] JWM JMVR\\RKUN JWM 9UJW [NZ^N\]\ ]QJ] 5YYUN RVVNMRJ]NUb Y[XM^LN \^LQ MXL^VNW]\' BUNJ\N UN] ^\ TWX` RO bX^ J[N J_JRUJKUN ]X VNN] JWM LXWON[ ]XVX[[X` J] *3)) B@ BDE [NPJ[MRWP ]QR\ R\\^N' 6N\] CNPJ[M\% BJUJWR BJUJWR B' CJ]QRWJ\JVb 5U\]XW $ 6R[M ??B +0. @RMMUNORNUM CXJM D^R]N *.) @NWUX BJ[T% 75 2-)+. ENU3 /.)&1,1&+)+0 d ;Ja3 /.)&1,1&+))* YJUJWR'[J]QRWJ\JVb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b OX[ ^\N XO ]QN RWMR_RM^JU X[ NW]R]b WJVNM JKX_N' =O ]QN [NJMN[ XO ]QR\ VN\\JPN R\ WX] ]QN RW]NWMNM [NLRYRNW]% X[ ]QN NVYUXbNN X[ JPNW] [N\YXW\RKUN ]X MNUR_N[ R] ]X ]QN RW]NWMNM [NLRYRNW]% bX^ J[N QN[NKb WX]RORNM ]QJ] JWb MR\\NVRWJ]RXW% MR\][RK^]RXW X[ LXYbRWP XO ]QR\ LXVV^WRLJ]RXW R\ \][RL]Ub Y[XQRKR]NM' =O bX^ QJ_N [NLNR_NM ]QR\ LXVV^WRLJ]RXW RW N[[X[% YUNJ\N RVVNMRJ]NUb WX]ROb ^\ Kb NVJRU "YX\]VJ\]N[4`NRU'LXV#% JWM MN\][Xb ]QN X[RPRWJU VN\\JPN' EQJWT b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b OX[ ^\N XO ]QN RWMR_RM^JU X[ NW]R]b WJVNM JKX_N' =O ]QN [NJMN[ XO ]QR\ VN\\JPN R\ WX] ]QN RW]NWMNM [NLRYRNW]% X[ ]QN NVYUXbNN X[ JPNW] [N\YXW\RKUN ]X MNUR_N[ R] ]X ]QN RW]NWMNM [NLRYRNW]% bX^ J[N QN[NKb WX]RORNM ]QJ] JWb MR\\NVRWJ]RXW% MR\][RK^]RXW X[ LXYbRWP XO ]QR\ LXVV^WRLJ]RXW R\ \][RL]Ub Y[XQRKR]NM' =O bX^ QJ_N [NLNR_NM ]QR\ LXVV^WRLJ]RXW RW N[[X[% YUNJ\N RVVNMRJ]NUb WX]ROb ^\ Kb NVJRU "YX\]VJ\]N[4`NRU'LXV#% JWM MN\][Xb ]QN X[RPRWJU VN\\JPN' EQJWT bX^' EQN RWOX[VJ]RXW LXW]JRWNM RW ]QR\ NVJRU VN\\JPN R\ RW]NWMNM XWUb OX[ ^\N XO ]QN RWMR_RM^JU X[ NW]R]b WJVNM JKX_N' =O ]QN [NJMN[ XO ]QR\ VN\\JPN R\ WX] ]QN RW]NWMNM [NLRYRNW]% X[ ]QN NVYUXbNN X[ JPNW] [N\YXW\RKUN ]X MNUR_N[ R] ]X ]QN RW]NWMNM [NLRYRNW]% bX^ J[N QN[NKb WX]RORNM ]QJ] JWb MR\\NVRWJ]RXW% MR\][RK^]RXW X[ LXYbRWP XO ]QR\ LXVV^WRLJ]RXW R\ \][RL]Ub Y[XQRKR]NM' =O bX^ QJ_N [NLNR_NM ]QR\ LXVV^WRLJ]RXW RW N[[X[% YUNJ\N RVVNMRJ]NUb WX]ROb ^\ Kb NVJRU "YX\]VJ\]N[4`NRU'LXV#% JWM MN\][Xb ]QN X[RPRWJU VN\\JPN' EQJWT bX^' EQN RWOX[VJ]RXW LXW]JRWNM RW ]QR\ NVJRU VN\\JPN R\ RW]NWMNM XWUb OX[ ^\N XO ]QN RWMR_RM^JU X[ NW]R]b WJVNM JKX_N' =O ]QN [NJMN[ XO ]QR\ VN\\JPN R\ WX] ]QN RW]NWMNM [NLRYRNW]% X[ ]QN NVYUXbNN X[ JPNW] [N\YXW\RKUN ]X MNUR_N[ R] ]X ]QN RW]NWMNM [NLRYRNW]% bX^ J[N QN[NKb WX]RORNM ]QJ] JWb MR\\NVRWJ]RXW% MR\][RK^]RXW X[ LXYbRWP XO ]QR\ LXVV^WRLJ]RXW R\ \][RL]Ub Y[XQRKR]NM' =O bX^ QJ_N [NLNR_NM ]QR\ LXVV^WRLJ]RXW RW N[[X[% YUNJ\N RVVNMRJ]NUb WX]ROb ^\ Kb NVJRU "YX\]VJ\]N[4`NRU'LXV#% JWM MN\][Xb ]QN X[RPRWJU VN\\JPN' EQJWT bX^' ,

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?