Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al

Filing 112

DECLARATION of AUSTIN TARANGO IN SUPPORT OF #111 SAMSUNG'S OPPOSITION TO APPLE'S MOTION FOR EXPEDITED TRIAL ON ITS CLAIMS AND FOR EARLY CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE filed bySamsung Electronics America, Inc., Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd., Samsung Telecommunications America, LLC. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 1, #2 Exhibit 2, #3 Exhibit 3, #4 Exhibit 4, #5 Exhibit 5, #6 Exhibit 6, #7 Exhibit 7, #8 Exhibit 8, #9 Exhibit 9)(Maroulis, Victoria) (Filed on 7/15/2011) Modified on 7/20/2011 counsel failed to link entry to document #111 (dhm, COURT STAFF).

EXHIBIT 6

187

Table C-10.
U.S. District Courts—Median Time Intervals from Filing to Trial for Civil Cases in Which Trials Were Completed, by
District, During the 12-Month Period Ending September 30, 2010

Total Trials

Number

Circuit and District
of Trials

Median Time
Interval
in Months 1

Nonjury Trials

Number
of Trials

TOTAL

3,101

24.3

969

DC

23

40.1

8

1ST
ME
MA
NH
RI
PR

125
9
72
3
8
33

28.2
-
31.2
-
-
25.4

2ND
CT
NY,N
NY,E
NY,S
NY,W
VT

375
43
52
143
122
11
4

3RD
DE
NJ
PA,E
PA,M
PA,W
VI

4TH
MD
NC,E
NC,M
NC,W
SC
VA,E
VA,W
WV,N
WV,S

Median Time
Interval
in Months 1
21.4

Jury Trials
Median Time
Number
Interval
of Trials In Months 1
2,132

25.6

-

15

40.1

34
6
20
-
2
6

26.3
-
27.2
-
-
-

91
3
52
3
6
27

30.3
-
33.1
-
-
24.8

32.3
27.9
44.7
28.4
33.6
55.7
-

112
14
5
42
48
1
2

23.4
22.5
-
20.6
26.8
-
-

263
29
47
101
74
10
2

35.2
29.2
40.4
30.9
41.2
54.8
-

241
23
67
78
28
32
13

28.0
25.2
40.6
19.9
26.1
30.5
49.8

66
11
19
20
6
4
6

25.8
23.8
37.4
17.5
-
-
-

175
12
48
58
22
28
7

29.3
28.7
42.2
20.2
26.1
29.2
-

198
35
27
7
10
55
43
9
5
7

19.8
30.0
39.0
-
18.3
21.6
9.3
-
-
-

77
10
26
3
1
11
23
2
1
-

20.1
26.6
37.5
-
-
22.1
9.3
-
-
-

121
25
1
4
9
44
20
7
4
7

19.7
33.6
-
-
-
21.4
9.7
-
-
-

188

Table C-10. (September 30, 2010—Continued)

Total Trials

Number

Circuit and District
of Trials

Median Time
Interval
in Months 1

Nonjury Trials

Number
of Trials

Median Time
Interval
in Months 1

Jury Trials
Median Time
Number
Interval
of Trials In Months 1

5TH
LA,E
LA,M
LA,W
MS,N
MS,S
TX,N
TX,E
TX,S
TX,W

436
71
11
28
21
34
67
63
94
47

21.7
20.1
48.2
24.1
33.0
26.4
20.3
21.7
19.8
20.6

154
37
1
16
4
2
22
13
39
20

19.5
20.4
-
24.5
-
-
18.7
15.8
18.1
17.8

282
34
10
12
17
32
45
50
55
27

23.6
19.3
43.0
23.1
27.0
26.4
20.8
24.2
23.1
22.9

6TH
KY,E
KY,W
MI,E
MI,W
OH,N
OH,S
TN,E
TN,M
TN,W

7TH
IL,N
IL,C
IL,S
IN,N
IN,S
WI,E
WI,W

252
15
17
54
15
41
24
35
22
29

26.8
24.5
30.7
24.6
26.8
24.0
25.9
32.5
31.3
29.0

54
1
4
15
4
6
3
6
7
8

25.6
-
-
20.0
-
-
-
-
-
-

198
14
13
39
11
35
21
29
15
21

27.2
24.5
30.7
24.9
35.0
24.0
25.9
31.4
30.9
30.5

209
113
22
20
9
20
13
12

28.3
28.2
29.0
36.4
-
32.1
28.7
15.1

56
30
3
6
1
10
4
2

29.0
33.6
-
-
-
32.0
-
-

153
83
19
14
8
10
9
10

27.6
25.9
31.3
40.7
-
32.1
-
14.8

8TH
AR,E
AR,W
IA,N
IA,S
MN
MO,E
MO,W
NE
ND
SD

186
34
21
4
16
18
35
39
13
1
5

22.4
23.3
17.6
-
20.6
25.4
25.9
36.2
19.0
-
-

62
10
4
2
8
6
7
19
4
-
2

23.1
25.6
-
-
-
-
-
36.2
-
-
-

124
24
17
2
8
12
28
20
9
1
3

21.5
23.3
18.4
-
-
31.3
28.5
28.5
-
-
-

189

Table C-10. (September 30, 2010—Continued)

Total Trials

Number

Circuit and District
of Trials

Median Time
Interval
in Months 1

9TH
453
24.1

Nonjury Trials

Number
of Trials

Median Time
Interval
in Months 1

Jury Trials
Median Time
Number
Interval
of Trials In Months 1

AK
AZ
CA,N
CA,E
CA,C
CA,S
HI
ID
MT
NV
OR
WA,E
WA,W
GUAM
NMI

10TH
CO
KS
NM
OK,N
OK,E
OK,W
UT
WY

4
45
57
57
139
25
19
10
9
31
19
6
30
-
2

-
29.6
21.5
33.4
19.7
31.6
15.6
23.6
-
28.4
27.7
-
18.3
-
-

158
2
16
22
6
56
7
13
2
2
9
6
5
11
-
1

20.0
-
20.9
20.4
-
18.2
-
11.6
-
-
-
-
-
17.5
-
-

295
2
29
35
51
83
18
6
8
7
22
13
1
19
-
1

26.4
-
31.1
22.8
37.4
20.8
30.1
-
-
-
28.4
28.4
-
20.9
-
-

178
41
26
28
11
4
36
20
12

22.0
29.1
20.1
26.9
14.3
-
16.4
33.3
15.2

39
8
8
4
2
-
6
7
4

20.1
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-

139
33
18
24
9
4
30
13
8

22.5
29.1
21.7
26.9
-
-
16.4
35.6
-

11TH
AL,N
AL,M
AL,S
FL,N
FL,M
FL,S
GA,N
GA,M
GA,S

425
57
15
16
20
124
129
40
14
10

19.2
22.5
16.9
18.0
22.6
19.2
16.9
26.1
25.9
22.9

149
4
5
6
6
66
48
10
2
2

18.6
-
-
-
-
18.6
17.0
24.2
-
-

276
53
10
10
14
58
81
30
12
8

20.0
22.5
16.0
26.0
23.7
19.4
16.7
27.8
25.9
-

NOTE: Includes trials conducted by district and appellate judges only. All trials conducted by magistrate judges are excluded. Excludes the following trials: land condemnation; forfeitures and penalty cases; prisoner petitions (habeas corpus, motions
to vacate sentence under 28 U.S.C. 2255, hearings on evidentiary matters); bankruptcy petitions; and three-judge court cases. For civil cases resulting in completed trials, the median time is based on the original filing date and the date the trial was
completed. For reopened civil cases resulting in second completed trials, the median time remains based on the original filing date and the date the trial was completed.
1
Time intervals computed only for 10 or more trials.